News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How Airlines don’t care about privacy: Case Study Emirate... by ggm on Sunday March 04, 2018 @06:21PM (#16517435)
I oftentimes reach for my 'call the regulator' button when I read these articles. Whats odd is how many people say "god no..." as if there was some consequential downside to using the very government entity we created (in law) to make corporate entities "do the right thing" when they don't appear to want to do it voluntarily.

So.. here we go. Explain to me, why we don't want to enact law to require (through regulation) this practice to cease.

Re:How Airlines don’t care about privacy: Case Study Emirate... by hermitdev on Sunday March 04, 2018 @06:28PM (#16517460)
I'm waiting for someone to state "when you're not paying for something, you are the product", except in this case, you are paying for something, yet you're still the product.

This is just...disgusting.

Re:How Airlines don’t care about privacy: Case Study Emirate... by on_and_off on Sunday March 04, 2018 @08:37PM (#16518053)
This is why we should stop quoting that all the time.

Just because you are paying for a product does not prevent your data from being sold or used in unethical ways.

Re:How Airlines don’t care about privacy: Case Study Emirate... by hyperdimension on Sunday March 04, 2018 @08:49PM (#16518107)
As much as I agree with you that we seriously have got to stop trotting out that quote all the time, the quote doesn't necessarily preclude what you point out.

According to the quote, if you don't pay for it, you're definitely the product, but clearly, as you mention, just because you pay for it doesn't mean you're still not the product.

Unfortunately.

Re:How Airlines don’t care about privacy: Case Study Emirate... by virgilp on Monday March 05, 2018 @03:25AM (#16519600)
That quote is a lazy-soudbite-argument that "you shouldn't use free services" (because "you're the product" and that's "obviously" bad). However, if you stop to think about it for a second, you'll realize that it's dead wrong. It sounds nice & all, but it is in fact meaningless, and probably misguiding.
Re:How Airlines don’t care about privacy: Case Study Emirate... by unethical_ban on Monday March 05, 2018 @09:53AM (#16521384)
I've thought about it for several seconds and don't see what is wrong with the quote.

It is a cheap and easy way to explain to non-technical people that when something is "free" the provider is getting something back. Payment for advertising to you, collected data from you, and so on. If you(general) understand that, and are OK with that, then continue. But don't be naive.

Re:How Airlines don’t care about privacy: Case Study Emirate... by virgilp on Monday March 05, 2018 @10:06AM (#16521485)
What does Linus (& the rest of the Linux developers) get from YOU?
Re:How Airlines don’t care about privacy: Case Study Emirate... by unethical_ban on Thursday March 08, 2018 @11:41AM (#16545498)
Well, Linus and other groups make such good software that companies pay them to make it directly or otherwise; other people release code for showing their own portfolio like an artist, to prove their skills; others do it so people on the Internet can help improve the code. And finally, none of this matters, because that rule applies to organizations making money (or trying to). Jane Hobbyist writing device drivers for the love of the job isn't a part of the saying.
Re:How Airlines don’t care about privacy: Case Study Emirate... by fvdessen on Monday March 05, 2018 @10:30AM (#16521631)
Reputation ? (and other network effects that comes with having a large audience)
Re:How Airlines don’t care about privacy: Case Study Emirate... by virgilp on Monday March 05, 2018 @11:19AM (#16522029)
You are the product that gives them reputation?

Note - I'm not saying people don't have a reason to provide free stuff. I'm saying that the soundbite "you're the product!" is lazy, and sometimes misleading.

Re:How Airlines don’t care about privacy: Case Study Emirate... by craftyguy on Monday March 05, 2018 @12:13AM (#16518901)
The quote is not wrong. If you aren't paying for something, then 100% of the time you are the product. If you are paying for something, then <100% of the time you are also the product.
Re:How Airlines don’t care about privacy: Case Study Emirate... by on_and_off on Monday March 05, 2018 @01:07AM (#16519100)
I don't pay for wikipedia (actually I do via donations and edits but that's not the point) but I don't see anything bad about their BM.
Re:How Airlines don’t care about privacy: Case Study Emirate... by tedeh on Monday March 05, 2018 @05:10AM (#16520001)
But Wikipedia is run by a non-profit organization...
Re:How Airlines don’t care about privacy: Case Study Emirate... by orblivion on Monday March 05, 2018 @07:04AM (#16520444)
I'd say the more direct response is that with Wikipedia there is no product, in that sense of the word.
Re:How Airlines don’t care about privacy: Case Study Emirate... by mcherm on Monday March 05, 2018 @09:45AM (#16521333)
There most certainly IS a product! The only way I can imagine that you came to believe there wasn't is that you were confused by the fact that they give their product away.

Does Encyclopedia Britannica's website "britannica.com" have a product? Is Encarta a product? Of course they are, and so is Wikipedia, unless BY DEFINITION you exclude any "product" not exchanged for money from the definition of "product". And by that definition, the second can of beans I got at the grocery store on a buy-one-get-one-free sale wasn't a product -- which I feel demolishes the usefulness of the term.

Re:How Airlines don’t care about privacy: Case Study Emirate... by orblivion on Monday March 05, 2018 @03:11PM (#16523953)
It's something that's produced, but not something sold (like Encarta). Accordingly you're right that it is a product.

In the informal sense in which we talk about users "being the product" I'd call it not quite right, since there's nothing sold. The user doesn't have to worry as much about ulterior motives.

Re:How Airlines don’t care about privacy: Case Study Emirate... by vezycash on Monday March 05, 2018 @09:26AM (#16521219)
What of Linux?
Re:How Airlines don’t care about privacy: Case Study Emirate... by sorokod on Monday March 05, 2018 @03:36AM (#16519631)
=< 100
Re:How Airlines don’t care about privacy: Case Study Emirate... by kkm on Sunday March 04, 2018 @06:32PM (#16517473)
This comment is spot on. Do you mind if I use it as a caption on the artice aswell(with due credits)
Re:How Airlines don’t care about privacy: Case Study Emirate... by ggm on Sunday March 04, 2018 @09:56PM (#16518392)
If you don't pay for it, you are the product. If you pay for it, you may still be productized. Odd that an EULA actually binds both parties, but somehow unequally? I don't think so!
Re:How Airlines don’t care about privacy: Case Study Emirate... by propogandist on Sunday March 04, 2018 @08:24PM (#16518009)
not at all; I don't mind
Re:How Airlines don’t care about privacy: Case Study Emirate... by Aissen on Tuesday March 06, 2018 @10:31AM (#16529399)
This quote also completely forgets open source and non profits exist and provide things.
Re:How Airlines don’t care about privacy: Case Study Emirate... by jakobegger on Monday March 05, 2018 @03:03AM (#16519514)
Well, the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) will become enforceable in May (for all people in the EU).

As far as I understand, Emirates is risking big fines if they they don't fix this by May 25.

Re:How Airlines don’t care about privacy: Case Study Emirate... by kkm on Monday March 05, 2018 @04:14AM (#16519751)
Even though they are not based out of EU and only operate in EU?
Re:How Airlines don’t care about privacy: Case Study Emirate... by jakobegger on Monday March 05, 2018 @04:24AM (#16519803)
Yes, the GDPR affects everyone who processes data of people in the EU, regardless of where they are based.
Re:How Airlines don’t care about privacy: Case Study Emirate... by hooeezit on Monday March 05, 2018 @04:49AM (#16519920)
Where they are based doesn't matter. If they are collecting revenues (taking payments) from EU clients, it applies. That includes generating ad revenues from EU based eyeballs. When it comes to on-ad-generating, free websites, it remains to be seen how bold EU regulators get. It'll be hard to penalize or prosecute such websites, and there are enough violations in the fat cats anyway, so I'm guessing those free websites will get a free pass for now (pun intended).
Re:How Airlines don’t care about privacy: Case Study Emirate... by Zak on Monday March 05, 2018 @08:52AM (#16521000)
> That includes generating ad revenues from EU based eyeballs.

That would be fairly hard to enforce against a company that doesn't have a physical or legal presence in the EU.

In general, I'm disturbed by governments trying to enforce laws beyond their border just because their citizens are somehow involved by sending information over the internet. In some fields, it's a legal minefield just to comply with the rules of one country, much less several. This won't be a major difficulty for big players with high-paid lawyers and compliance departments, but it could easily kill startups, some before they're even launched.

Re:How Airlines don’t care about privacy: Case Study Emirate... by distances on Monday March 05, 2018 @06:34PM (#16525587)
> In general, I'm disturbed by governments trying to enforce laws beyond their border just because their citizens are somehow involved by sending information over the internet.

Isn't it simple enough to geoblock areas if European customers are somehow too hard to serve?

> In some fields, it's a legal minefield just to comply with the rules of one country, much less several. This won't be a major difficulty for big players with high-paid lawyers and compliance departments, but it could easily kill startups, some before they're even launched.

As the topic is GDPR: a privacy first approach is not rocket science. I'm sure any startup with even the remotest chance of success can follow the basic principles without undue complications.

Re:How Airlines don’t care about privacy: Case Study Emirate... by Zak on Wednesday March 07, 2018 @04:23PM (#16540029)
Geoblocking is breaking the internet.

While I agree that startups should be respectful of privacy, that doesn't change the principle at work here. Allowing countries to enforce laws against companies that don't have a physical or legal presence within their borders is a dangerous mechanism. Introducing a dangerous mechanism to enforce a good policy will result in that mechanism being used for a bad policy later on.

Re:How Airlines don’t care about privacy: Case Study Emirate... by rostigerpudel on Monday March 05, 2018 @04:33AM (#16519845)
When you operate a business somewhere, you have to observe the laws of the place you do business in. It does not matter where you are based.

How someone gets a hold of you to enforce any action against you is a different matter. But Emirates kind of needs to come to the EU sometimes to do its business there.

Re:How Airlines don’t care about privacy: Case Study Emirate... by nolok on Monday March 05, 2018 @05:01AM (#16519963)
They're taking money from EU customers, so yes the EU will enforce.

They have assets (and even more, they want to land in EU airports) in the EU so yes the EU can force them to comply even if they don't want to.

Re:How Airlines don’t care about privacy: Case Study Emirate... by gambiting on Monday March 05, 2018 @04:40AM (#16519881)
If they sell to EU customers, then yes, they have to abide by the EU privacy regulations. Alternatively, they can set up a website just for EU customers or stop serving them altogether.
Re:How Airlines don’t care about privacy: Case Study Emirate... by asclepi on Monday March 05, 2018 @07:46AM (#16520641)
I can only hope for the EU that their economic incentive remains strong enough to prevent foreign companies from totally pulling out, resulting in the EU market becoming bleaker and bleaker. And it's not even the current companies that I worry most about - they often have already invested too much to withdraw because of this - it's the new companies that may flat out refuse to enter the EU market.

The GDPR is yet another regulation that adds a lot of liability with the risk of huge fines for a foreign company. And while no regulation in itself is ever going to be enough of reason, it's the plethora of regulations that is, and the more it grows, the more companies will feel it reached the tipping point for them, which may result in either withdrawal or refusal to serve the EU market. If this proves true, EU citizens should expect to see a lot more of "We're sorry, this service is not available in your country" messages. And it's already pretty bad from what I've heard.

Note: I'm not saying Emirates will pull out because of this, they won't. I'm also NOT against the GDPR and I totally understand the need, I just wish it would be regulated on a more universal level. Same with copyright regulations.

Re:How Airlines don’t care about privacy: Case Study Emirate... by distances on Monday March 05, 2018 @06:42PM (#16525630)
> Note: I'm not saying Emirates will pull out because of this, they won't. I'm also NOT against the GDPR and I totally understand the need, I just wish it would be regulated on a more universal level. Same with copyright regulations.

What could be a more universal level than EU that could actually enforce something like GDPR? US is rather anti-privacy these days, which I found interesting as they are extremely individualistic at the same time. The only even remotely suitable body is WTO, and that won't happen.

Re:How Airlines don’t care about privacy: Case Study Emirate... by asclepi on Tuesday March 06, 2018 @03:20AM (#16527619)
Right, it's a universal regulation that applies to about 6% of the world population. But you make a good point, it is very hard to regulate this on a higher level. I'm just saying that the EU shouldn't expect every foreign company to accept and play by their rules, especially if it's only relevant to a fraction of their customers. What this may lead to is companies refusing to serve the EU and EU residents forced to resort to shady VPN companies to access their services - as they already do to circumvent copyright regulations - eventually resulting in less privacy and loss of VAT and other revenue for the EU.

Again, I do not want to paint an overly bleak picture - and I do support regulations like this one - but my feeling is that, due to the lack of a universal solution, this GDPR won't have a better fate than the current copyright regulations: beneficial for some, but at the cost of more internet fragmentation and discrimination. It's almost like lawmakers consistently forget that the internet doesn't stop at borders.

Re:How Airlines don’t care about privacy: Case Study Emirate... by smartbit on Tuesday March 06, 2018 @01:33AM (#16527277)
GDPR concerns a human right (civil rights in USA-parlance). Are you stating that human rights are a nuisance?
Re:How Airlines don’t care about privacy: Case Study Emirate... by asclepi on Tuesday March 06, 2018 @02:37AM (#16527468)
The preamble of the GDPR states that it regulates the fundamental right to privacy, not the human right to privacy. The human right to privacy is much lower level than the fundamental right to privacy.

To repeat myself: I'm [also] NOT against the GDPR and I totally understand the need, I just wish it would be regulated on a more universal level.

Re:How Airlines don’t care about privacy: Case Study Emirate... by PhantomGremlin on Sunday March 04, 2018 @09:58PM (#16518403)
I oftentimes reach for my 'call the regulator' button when I read these articles.

And what regulator is that? Does Dubai even have a "regulator" overseeing stuff like this?

Emirates is wholly owned by the government of Dubai. So basically you would be complaining about one Dubai government agency to another Dubai government agency.

Perhaps you could complain about this to some US or EU regulator? Would they care enough to get involved?

Re:How Airlines don’t care about privacy: Case Study Emirate... by icebraining on Monday March 05, 2018 @01:52AM (#16519247)
I live in Portugal, an EU country. After a complaint, our National Data Protection Commission fined one of my neighbors for having posted certain personal data of other tenants on our building hall.

They care.

Re:How Airlines don’t care about privacy: Case Study Emirate... by hooeezit on Monday March 05, 2018 @04:52AM (#16519937)
Emirates gets a big chunk of their revenues from EU customers. They definitely don't want to piss of EU regulators. As for US regulators, they've been at odds with them for some time, so Emirates will probably try to fight them before giving in. But this particular privacy hole is the size of a crater - it will be hard to fight the regulators. In fact, as a software architect, I feel that the solution is far cheaper than fighting regulators.
Re:How Airlines don’t care about privacy: Case Study Emirate... by Zak on Monday March 05, 2018 @08:57AM (#16521028)
Emirates has a physical presence in the EU and would definitely be subject to EU regulations when a flight to, from or purchased in the EU is involved.