News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Stride, Atlassian’s Slack competitor, opens its API to al... by tootie on Tuesday February 20, 2018 @03:13PM (#16423754)
What happened to HipChat? It was already the same thing as Slack for less money.
Re:Stride, Atlassian’s Slack competitor, opens its API to al... by ljm on Tuesday February 20, 2018 @03:47PM (#16424040)
It seems it stagnated. There wasn’t a real competitor to it until Slack turned up and developed a fantastic integration ecosystem (I don’t think there would be such a focus on conversational UI were it not for Slack, whether or not they intended that). By that time it was already too late, HipChat is old school, Slack is the new hotness.

Anecdotally, anyone working in a startup with an opinion on design will know how shallow a judgment has to be to switch to a competitor. App is functional but has 2008 design? The less functional equivalent with 2017 design is better because it looks up to date

Re:Stride, Atlassian’s Slack competitor, opens its API to al... by rozenmd on Tuesday February 20, 2018 @04:38PM (#16424450)
There were also performance issues with HipChat, that Slack didn't have: messages went undelivered, load times unbearable etc. (at least in Sydney where we only just got speeds faster than broadband)
Re:Stride, Atlassian’s Slack competitor, opens its API to al... by madeofpalk on Tuesday February 20, 2018 @08:23PM (#16426036)
FWIW, I observed that 'conversational UI' and chatbots came from the western tech industry trying to 'learn' from the successes of Asian platforms like WeChat.
Re:Stride, Atlassian’s Slack competitor, opens its API to al... by itomato on Wednesday February 21, 2018 @08:48PM (#16434563)
I observed chatbots in IRC probably before you were born.
Re:Stride, Atlassian’s Slack competitor, opens its API to al... by madeofpalk on Thursday February 22, 2018 @03:21AM (#16436087)
I'm sure you did.

That's completely irrelevant though.

Re:Stride, Atlassian’s Slack competitor, opens its API to al... by itomato on Saturday March 03, 2018 @11:17AM (#16509918)
There's nothing new here but the packaging.
Re:Stride, Atlassian’s Slack competitor, opens its API to al... by tootie on Tuesday February 20, 2018 @07:22PM (#16425665)
Yeah, no kidding. My last company was up in arms to replace HipChat with Slack even though they were 99% identical. There hasn't been a significant innovation in chat technology in like 30 years yet the business sector is more frothy than ever.
Re:Stride, Atlassian’s Slack competitor, opens its API to al... by lev99 on Tuesday February 20, 2018 @09:56PM (#16426472)
The core tech hasn't changed a ton, but slack is a good chat program for how people use computers in the modern age. If it encourages communication among your organization it's probably worth adopting, even at the higher price. I don't have numbers, but I was in an organization the switched and mobile use of slack was higher than hipchat.
Re:Stride, Atlassian’s Slack competitor, opens its API to al... by azinman2 on Tuesday February 20, 2018 @11:00PM (#16426738)
Having extensively used both, Slack really is much better. Hipchat has a ton of reliability/usability issues and it’s clear _consumer-like_ product design is not Atlassian’s forte.
Re:Stride, Atlassian’s Slack competitor, opens its API to al... by x0x0 on Wednesday February 21, 2018 @02:38AM (#16427644)
Also, HipChat circa 2016 was forced on my acquired company that had previously used slack. What a piece of shit that app is. HipChat just nuked the battery life on my stock nexus phone.

I had never before gotten in an argument about a chat app, but HipChat made me passionate about using anything else.

Re:Stride, Atlassian’s Slack competitor, opens its API to al... by SOLAR_FIELDS on Wednesday February 21, 2018 @03:15PM (#16432566)
I use it at my work and it works reliably ok on the desktop, but yes I agree the mobile app (at least the iPhone one) is absolutely garbage.

That said from everyday desktop use it’s not bad. It’s nowhere near as unreliable for me as other posters are commenting about.

Re:Stride, Atlassian’s Slack competitor, opens its API to al... by pavel_lishin on Tuesday February 20, 2018 @04:29PM (#16424367)
To be fair, Hipchat is missing a lot of features that Slack has.
Re:Stride, Atlassian’s Slack competitor, opens its API to al... by ljm on Tuesday February 20, 2018 @05:15PM (#16424749)
That’s exactly the point, right? Slack turned up and offered more and HipChat didn’t respond in a meaningful way except to rewrite all their clients in JS. At that point they had a buggy client and fewer features, while Slack had an inefficient client with lots of features.
Re:Stride, Atlassian’s Slack competitor, opens its API to al... by pavel_lishin on Tuesday February 20, 2018 @07:34PM (#16425735)
I was referring to the (weirdly opposed) example they mentioned with the better-looking-fewer-features.
Re:Stride, Atlassian’s Slack competitor, opens its API to al... by tootie on Tuesday February 20, 2018 @11:44PM (#16426910)
Like what? 99% of usage is just chat rooms. I could hook in build notifications and post gifs. HipChat had voice and video years before Slack.
Re:Stride, Atlassian’s Slack competitor, opens its API to al... by pavel_lishin on Wednesday February 21, 2018 @11:07AM (#16430429)
Before I list everything: posting gifs is garbage. Things like giphy integration degrade the signal-to-noise ratio, and I rage against it in every chat app I use. Even in off-topic rooms it'll random make following a conversation annoying at best.

Anyway, hipchat's faults:

Search is garbage.

Editing a message is garbage.

Joining a room/messaging a specific person on mobile is annoying.

I'm not sure about how Slack handles it, but when a person leaves our company, our Hipchat chat history completely disappears. All those decisions we made with our old Product Manager via private message? Into the ether.

Want to delete a file you uploaded? Too bad. Maybe you can do it via the web interface?

Want to delete a message? Same deal.

Re:Stride, Atlassian’s Slack competitor, opens its API to al... by hrktb on Wednesday February 21, 2018 @01:53AM (#16427432)
Hipchat is not very good at notifications and chat though.

3 years in, and still randomly missing messages for a while until it’s somewhat synched.

Whole ongoing conversations don’t appear on other devices if I don’t manually open them.

Getting notified on my phone while I’m on my laptop.

Lack of integrations is the most sailant thing to point st, but I think at its core Hipchap is also a very meh service.

Re:Stride, Atlassian’s Slack competitor, opens its API to al... by stevejohnson on Wednesday February 21, 2018 @02:10AM (#16427506)
We switched to Slack the day Hipchat went down for several hours.
Re:Stride, Atlassian’s Slack competitor, opens its API to al... by rlopezcc on Tuesday February 20, 2018 @05:09PM (#16424702)
I was really disappointed when noticed they didn't have a way to report bugs. They had some kind of "Suggestions box", so I used that to report mine: Images wouldn't upload correctly when the chat room name started wih a slash (/dev/null in my case). They deleted the ticket and a few days later it was magically fixed.

You will find pretty annoyed people if you search for "report hipchat bug".

Re:Stride, Atlassian’s Slack competitor, opens its API to al... by ec109685 on Wednesday February 21, 2018 @11:53PM (#16435230)
Slack’s /feedback is stupendous. You get a human response in minutes. And they have live chat too.

Google for example makes it 1000x harder to give feedback and report bugs, which greatly limits the amount of quality feedback they get.

Anecdote: hangouts didn’t let us accept external users into a hangout today. Google will never know that because I have no easy way to tel them that.

Re:Stride, Atlassian’s Slack competitor, opens its API to al... by wwalser on Tuesday February 20, 2018 @06:11PM (#16425182)
> "I'm annoyed they didn't use my wording. They did fix my bug but I'm still annoyed."

In what world would one imagine that a suggestions box was in any way different from reporting a bug? "Suggestions box" is a bug report but renamed to be understood by Joan from accounting.

Re:Stride, Atlassian’s Slack competitor, opens its API to al... by rspeer on Tuesday February 20, 2018 @09:21PM (#16426333)
The thing about the HipChat suggestions box is that you had to collect "votes" for your "suggestion" to be considered.

So you could try to get their attention to the bug of "when you paste XML into a code block, it replaces it with subtly different, broken XML, my suggestion is to stop doing that", but it's going to be sitting several pages beyond "please add a left shark emoji!!!"

You can try to get your whole office to stack the vote, but why? I only have to be one person to report a bug to Slack.

Re:Stride, Atlassian’s Slack competitor, opens its API to al... by encoderer on Tuesday February 20, 2018 @04:27PM (#16424352)
Anecdata: The SaaS service I run has integrations with both -- Slack has literally 10x the number of integrated channels.
Re:Stride, Atlassian’s Slack competitor, opens its API to al... by rekoros on Wednesday February 21, 2018 @01:52AM (#16427425)
Re:Stride, Atlassian’s Slack competitor, opens its API to al... by asda22sdasd on Tuesday February 20, 2018 @08:04PM (#16425902)
You integrated slack 10x more in your SaaS?
Re:Stride, Atlassian’s Slack competitor, opens its API to al... by lev99 on Tuesday February 20, 2018 @09:57PM (#16426475)
My understanding was 10x more of his users integrate with slack than hipchat.
Re:Stride, Atlassian’s Slack competitor, opens its API to al... by salmonfamine on Tuesday February 20, 2018 @03:19PM (#16423807)
I believe they are in the process of sunsetting HipChat. It was not successful.
Re:Stride, Atlassian’s Slack competitor, opens its API to al... by 7ewis on Tuesday February 20, 2018 @04:41PM (#16424471)
They gave us a deadline to move (~2000 users). So we're just getting the Slack business case ready.

If we have to move AND pay more money anyway, then why not just go to Slack?

Re:Stride, Atlassian’s Slack competitor, opens its API to al... by taoistextremist on Tuesday February 20, 2018 @04:56PM (#16424599)
A quick look at the prices, Stride is under half the price of Slack. No idea if quality correlates with price here since I've never touched Stride.
Re:Stride, Atlassian’s Slack competitor, opens its API to al... by eridius on Tuesday February 20, 2018 @08:45PM (#16426137)
I don't know about Stride, but the quality of Slack has really been declining lately. Especially the quality of the desktop client.

If I was in charge of the decision for what communication tool to use at my company, I would take a long hard look at every single alternative to Slack.

Re:Stride, Atlassian’s Slack competitor, opens its API to al... by cjalmeida on Tuesday February 20, 2018 @04:51PM (#16424556)
I believe it's cheaper, isn't it?
Re:Stride, Atlassian’s Slack competitor, opens its API to al... by zie on Tuesday February 20, 2018 @05:13PM (#16424739)
You might also look at mattermost, if you are OK with hosting yourself (it's not hard, and upgrades are easy).
Re:Stride, Atlassian’s Slack competitor, opens its API to al... by notwhereyouare on Tuesday February 20, 2018 @05:04PM (#16424666)
have you considered rocket chat? It's a slack you can either have hosted for you, or host in house.
Re:Stride, Atlassian’s Slack competitor, opens its API to al... by ckorhonen on Tuesday February 20, 2018 @04:48PM (#16424523)
I thought Stride was the same price as Hipchat?
Re:Stride, Atlassian’s Slack competitor, opens its API to al... by briffle on Tuesday February 20, 2018 @03:35PM (#16423940)
They say they are working to improve hipchat, but only for datacenter, no more hosted.
Re:Stride, Atlassian’s Slack competitor, opens its API to al... by hartator on Tuesday February 20, 2018 @03:23PM (#16423845)
Stride is just re-branded HipChat.
Re:Stride, Atlassian’s Slack competitor, opens its API to al... by mansilladev on Tuesday February 20, 2018 @05:59PM (#16425084)
Stride was designed and built from ground up (not just a rebrand). I work at Atlassian, and have been using to since alpha.
Re:Stride, Atlassian’s Slack competitor, opens its API to al... by patrickaljord on Tuesday February 20, 2018 @03:26PM (#16423863)
I know it sounds silly but I believe the main reason for HipChat failing is mostly because the name was so uncool.
Re:Stride, Atlassian’s Slack competitor, opens its API to al... by bpicolo on Tuesday February 20, 2018 @04:20PM (#16424295)
More likely it's just that HipChat isn't a great product experience.

As an example, the only way to edit a message is to use a sed-style "s/foo/bar", which is absurd. Because of this, you can't edit messages other than the most recent one, and if you want to edit one instance of "foo" but not another instance of "foo" you're out of luck. That's a terrible piece of UX even if you're in the only subset of users (software devs familiar with sed-style search and replace) where it makes any sense whatsoever

Re:Stride, Atlassian’s Slack competitor, opens its API to al... by Fishkins on Tuesday February 20, 2018 @09:37PM (#16426411)
One time I was trying to correct and "its" that should've been an "it's", but I didn't realized there was a preceding, correct "its" in the post. I ended up changing that "its" to an incorrect "it's", while also leaving the following incorrect "its". It was inconsequential, but very frustrating.

As a sibling comment said, the main reason my team abandoned Hipchat for Slack was Hipchat was hopelessly buggy and unreliable at the time we tried to use it.

Re:Stride, Atlassian’s Slack competitor, opens its API to al... by ec109685 on Wednesday February 21, 2018 @11:55PM (#16435235)
Um, you should have sed’d the whole sentence! J/K: totally absurd.
Re:Stride, Atlassian’s Slack competitor, opens its API to al... by xfour on Tuesday February 20, 2018 @03:36PM (#16423949)
Uptime wasn't the greatest at a critical moment when Slack was gaining market share as well.
Re:Stride, Atlassian’s Slack competitor, opens its API to al... by el_duderino on Tuesday February 20, 2018 @05:31PM (#16424863)
Yeah. HipChat's stability was absolutely abysmal for quite some time. They seem to have finally gotten it under control. That or a majority of their user base went elsewhere.
Re:Stride, Atlassian’s Slack competitor, opens its API to al... by sjellis on Wednesday February 21, 2018 @02:34AM (#16427625)
Barry Warsaw's law of names: "All names are stupid until you become rich and famous with it."

HipChat is a terrible name for a work-related collaboration tool, but "Slack" isn't great either....

Re:Stride, Atlassian’s Slack competitor, opens its API to al... by cortesoft on Tuesday February 20, 2018 @05:32PM (#16424868)
But slack is?
Re:Stride, Atlassian’s Slack competitor, opens its API to al... by blang on Tuesday February 20, 2018 @04:57PM (#16424611)
We were on HipChat but went to Slack because Stride was lacking compared to HipChat.
Re:Stride, Atlassian’s Slack competitor, opens its API to al... by GFischer on Tuesday February 20, 2018 @03:47PM (#16424039)
They're trying to say it's not while also saying it's an "upgrade".

I guess it is a new major release of HipChat (with re-architecting) and re-branding. Same lead (Steve Goldsmith).

Unless an insider tells, we won't know I guess :)

Re:Stride, Atlassian’s Slack competitor, opens its API to al... by GFischer on Tuesday February 20, 2018 @08:35PM (#16426089)
An insider did tell, trust Hacker News :) - Steve Goldsmith himself.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16424942

Re:Stride, Atlassian’s Slack competitor, opens its API to al... by theli0nheart on Tuesday February 20, 2018 @03:44PM (#16424011)
Not at all--unless you consider building an entirely new product from the ground up a re-brand.
Re:Stride, Atlassian’s Slack competitor, opens its API to al... by spelunker on Tuesday February 20, 2018 @04:23PM (#16424329)
Joke's on them, we're still using Stash at my employer!
Re:Stride, Atlassian’s Slack competitor, opens its API to al... by indigodaddy on Tuesday February 20, 2018 @07:59PM (#16425876)
I rather like Stash. It has nice integration with Jira, and works fine.
Re:Stride, Atlassian’s Slack competitor, opens its API to al... by Rychard on Wednesday February 21, 2018 @01:21AM (#16427302)
Stash works fine in precisely the same sense that lynx is a perfectly capable web browser. It's not wrong, but you have to admit that it's missing a number of 'modern' features that many users have grown accustomed to.

The more recent offering (Bitbucket Server) falls behind the curve as well, even when compared to their own Bitbucket Cloud service.

Re:Stride, Atlassian’s Slack competitor, opens its API to al... by cowmix on Tuesday February 20, 2018 @03:52PM (#16424090)
Stride is a complete rewrite.
Re:Stride, Atlassian’s Slack competitor, opens its API to al... by snowsquirrel on Tuesday March 06, 2018 @09:35AM (#16529068)
We are considering this for the solely because it is has screen sharing built in at the free level. In Slack, we would have to bump up to the paid level, and for our small team, the price jumps from free to $600+. The "decisions" and "tasks" features look like they might be nice (in theory). The largest thing holding us back is that many of us use Slack for other groups, which means Stride would be one more thing to run. A killer feature would be the ability to participate in Slack workspaces.
Re:Stride, Atlassian’s Slack competitor, opens its API to al... by GFischer on Tuesday February 20, 2018 @04:20PM (#16424300)
Any sources on that? I'm pretty sure it's a heavy re-architecting at the very least, but if it's the same team and lead, have they gone entirely from scratch or repurposed some of Hipchat's code? (just questioning)

Not curious enough to do the kind of blackbox exploration folks at https://webrtchacks.com or other sites do :)

Re:Stride, Atlassian’s Slack competitor, opens its API to al... by goldsmithsteve on Tuesday February 20, 2018 @05:40PM (#16424942)
I believe I am a pretty good source. :)

Stride is a brand new product (not a rebrand of Hipchat), we did not repurpose Hipchat's code. It's built from ground up on Atlassian platform - new protocol, clients, platform, etc. One exception is the video bridge technology which remains powered by the Jitsi.org open source product (which we acquired in 2015). I do look after both products (Hipchat Cloud and Stride) for Atlassian, happy to answer questions.

Re:Stride, Atlassian’s Slack competitor, opens its API to al... by GFischer on Tuesday February 20, 2018 @08:34PM (#16426082)
Thank you, indeed you are :) . Good luck ! Maybe you can convince the higher ups at my office that Microsoft Teams is an inferior product :) (we're already invested with Jira and Confluence so it's not a stretch...)

Would have been a shame not to use the Jitsi technology for sure, I deeply respect Emil Ivov and team.

Re:Stride, Atlassian’s Slack competitor, opens its API to al... by holychiz on Tuesday February 20, 2018 @06:51PM (#16425467)
Stride looks first-rate. Hopefully opening up APIs will bring integration on-par with Slack. What's the plan for bringing Stride to self-hosted options?
Re:Stride, Atlassian’s Slack competitor, opens its API to al... by paulydavis on Tuesday February 20, 2018 @09:08PM (#16426268)
So I was told at your last conference that your going to be going to a RHEL instead of the current Ubuntu. I can’t seem to get an answer on what the timeline is for that. My director is signaling to look at other options and I really don’t want to do that. I mean will it be in next 6 months? We are looking at a huge commitment.
Re:Stride, Atlassian’s Slack competitor, opens its API to al... by danielvf on Tuesday February 20, 2018 @06:22PM (#16425260)
I love the decisions and actions features. I was wishing for those today in our project chat setup!
Re:Stride, Atlassian’s Slack competitor, opens its API to al... by gaahrdner on Wednesday February 21, 2018 @12:19AM (#16427046)
hi steve
Re:Stride, Atlassian’s Slack competitor, opens its API to al... by pavel_lishin on Tuesday February 20, 2018 @04:29PM (#16424373)
We're still running Hipchat at work, and haven't gotten any "switch now, peasants" emails.
Re:Stride, Atlassian’s Slack competitor, opens its API to al... by walterbell on Tuesday February 20, 2018 @04:55PM (#16424588)
The industry needs a meme/graphic for this frequently broadcast communication.