Anyway, hipchat's faults:
Search is garbage.
Editing a message is garbage.
Joining a room/messaging a specific person on mobile is annoying.
I'm not sure about how Slack handles it, but when a person leaves our company, our Hipchat chat history completely disappears. All those decisions we made with our old Product Manager via private message? Into the ether.
Want to delete a file you uploaded? Too bad. Maybe you can do it via the web interface?
Want to delete a message? Same deal.
3 years in, and still randomly missing messages for a while until it’s somewhat synched.
Whole ongoing conversations don’t appear on other devices if I don’t manually open them.
Getting notified on my phone while I’m on my laptop.
Lack of integrations is the most sailant thing to point st, but I think at its core Hipchap is also a very meh service.