News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:iMac Pro 18-core Follow Up Review by plg on Saturday February 03, 2018 @08:08PM (#16300652)
A lot of the negative comments wrt cost are versions of this: what a ripoff, you can get better components for way less money in some other PC and/or if you build your own.

That's nice but it's not Apple's market. Apple's market is not other PCs, and it's not build your own.

This criticism of Apple has been around ever since Apple has been around (1970s). While the criticism has basically stayed the same since then, Apple has not stayed the same, they have grown. Their products have improved. Their market share has grown and it continues to grow.

Some people pay more money for a Benz, and other people say Hey that's a ripoff, I can buy a Toyota that gets me to work and back, just like your expensive Benz, for half the price! What a ripoff!

Apple is not in the business of making inexpensive PCs (and accepting all of the tradeoffs therein). The trends show that more and more people are willing to spend their money on Apple products.

They are clearly doing something right.

If you are enraged by their success, perhaps you are not their target market. And that is ok.

Re:iMac Pro 18-core Follow Up Review by ghostcluster on Saturday February 03, 2018 @08:20PM (#16300696)
Some of the harshest criticisms of Apple have been coming from diehard fans in Apple's market niche, such as Marco Arment. See: the Touch Bar, the keyboards: https://marco.org/2017/11/24/fixing-the-macbook-pro

> They are clearly doing something right.

Mac sales are down 5%.

Re:iMac Pro 18-core Follow Up Review by pentae on Sunday February 04, 2018 @01:09AM (#16301608)
The worst part about this, is Apple will throw their hands up in the air and say "See? The PC Business is dying. We need to double down on making Macbooks more like iPads and focus on the iPhone business" Rather than realising it's because their new Macbook computer lineup is a burning dumpster fire that is almost universally reviled.
Re:iMac Pro 18-core Follow Up Review by sethherr on Sunday February 04, 2018 @01:34AM (#16301663)
This. Diehard fan - at least previously, but times are a changing.

Let alone the OS feeling less polished, the removal of time remaining on battery and other user hostile changes, the touch bar being poorly thought out net loss (e.g. the fact that you can’t adjust the brightness so in low light typing, it messes with your eyes), I’ve had to warranty 3 MacBook pros in the past year. I’d never had to warranty an apple product before.

I don’t want another iPad or iPhone. I want a laptop that just works and I’m willing to pay for it. Please somebody deliver that, since apple isn’t chasing it anymore.

Re:iMac Pro 18-core Follow Up Review by abritinthebay on Sunday February 04, 2018 @02:14AM (#16301766)
You need to get out if your bubble. The only complaint I’ve geard from literally hundreds of actual users about the new MBPs is they don’t like the shallow key travel on the new keyboards.

I do, but I’ve always preferred less travel.

Outside of the moaning online bubble (like HN) the MBP is a raging success.

Re:iMac Pro 18-core Follow Up Review by fit2rule on Sunday February 04, 2018 @07:31AM (#16302484)
Mac ex-fanboix reporting in, had everything since the tiBook, an Apple II, and between.

I don't wanna play no more. Because of the atrocious nature of things vis a vis MBP2017, and onwards, I'm leaving for something else.

I say this, typing uncomfortably on a MBP2017 with a touchbar I never use, making constant typos, and feeling just plain ripped off.

Re:iMac Pro 18-core Follow Up Review by itbeho on Sunday February 04, 2018 @12:29PM (#16303673)
Leaving for what though? I have mostly the same sentiment as you, but find just about everything else on the market has some level of design insanity that provokes frustration with use. It's literally out of the pot, into the fire....
Re:iMac Pro 18-core Follow Up Review by abritinthebay on Sunday February 04, 2018 @12:47PM (#16303774)
If you don’t use the touchbar I wonder what you ever do on the MBP. I use it regularly, many times a day for development & other tasks.
Re:iMac Pro 18-core Follow Up Review by mmjaa on Monday February 05, 2018 @04:22AM (#16307647)
Also a pro developer here, also a non Touch Bar-user - in my point of view its a piece of junk and not worth the effort.

So I'm curious how you find it so useful?

Re:iMac Pro 18-core Follow Up Review by sgarman on Sunday February 04, 2018 @03:35AM (#16301933)
I have owned every single 15" MBP since they started using intel. Each one was better then the last - they were great - best laptops you can buy. This most recent one is the first one that is worse then the previous one.
Re:iMac Pro 18-core Follow Up Review by 5_minutes on Sunday February 04, 2018 @03:42AM (#16301951)
I thought I got used to the horrible keyboard, but after working on a old MBP I realise how bad the current one really is.

I have no feeling with it.

So yeah, for the first time in years, I'm looking around at other brands.

I'm just locked in with iPhoto.

Re:iMac Pro 18-core Follow Up Review by abritinthebay on Sunday February 04, 2018 @12:46PM (#16303764)
No feeling? Do you have nerve issues or something? Help me understand this complaint, I don’t get it.

Large key travel is only good for those hitting they keys way too hard imo

Re:iMac Pro 18-core Follow Up Review by jacobolus on Sunday February 04, 2018 @07:05PM (#16305680)
Longer key travel is helpful for almost everyone (for accuracy, speed, comfort, and avoiding injury). Ideal is probably at least 1.5mm before actuation, and at least 1mm after actuation. Maybe more. No recent laptop keyboard comes anywhere close to a truly fast and accurate keyboard, because the space constraints are simply too tight to fit in a mechanism optimized for ergonomics. All the best keyswitches are from <1990. They had many small moving parts and were very expensive to produce relative to cheaper alternatives like rubber domes.

(Laptop keyboards also don’t have the space to properly raise the keycap tops on keys in further rows, because they don’t have space for it; this makes reaching for the top 2 rows of the keyboard noticeably slower and less comfortable)

The best keyswitches actuate about halfway through the stroke, have a distinct drop in force at the actuation point, and have a significant mechanical bounce to them on the upstroke, launching your fingers up toward the next keypress. My all-time favorites are Alps “plate spring” switches used on certain Japanese IBM computers and some IBM luggables in the late 1980s (I can type about 20–30 wpm faster on these than on any laptop keyboard). You can also get this effect (with a very different overall feel) from Topre switches (still produced), or from IBM beam spring keyboards (from the 1970s). Some other keyboard enthusiasts have different preferences, e.g. for simple springs with no additional tactile mechanism (“linear switches”) optionally with a clicker or buzzer to give audio feedback of key actuation. Such switches are slower to type on than a snappier alternative, but some people prefer the feeling.

Nobody should be hitting any type of keys “way too hard”. You want to use just enough force to actuate the key and not push the key hard all the way through the bottom of the stroke. This is much easier to judge when the switch has relatively dramatic tactile feedback and a lot of post-actuation travel which ramps up in resistance toward the bottom.

Re:iMac Pro 18-core Follow Up Review by abritinthebay on Monday February 05, 2018 @02:40AM (#16307239)
What you’re describing are literally the most horrible keyboards I have the displeasure to use.

For example: the IBM Model M is one of the single worst typing experiences imo. The only way to type on that thing is use about 5x the force I normally do.

No wonder our industry is plagued by RSI - it lionizes horrible things like this due to misguided nostalgia.

Re:iMac Pro 18-core Follow Up Review by jacobolus on Monday February 05, 2018 @06:53AM (#16308232)
The IBM Model M is a great typing keyboard after you get used to it, but you are right that it is on the stiffer side. The previous Model F keyboards took about 10 grams less to actuate, and are widely preferred. I find even those a bit stiffer than my taste. Neither of those keyboards has my preferred feedback or force curve, though I don't mind typing on them. The biggest objection I've ever heard to either is the noise.

In any event, actuation force is an orthogonal concern to travel distance, tactile feedback, post-actuation force curve, upstroke bounce, keycap shape, etc.

Relatively fewer people typing on a such IBM keyboards got RSI compared to other keyboards, because the extreme tactile snap makes it very obviously unnecessary to type with much force more than barely required to actuate them.

But the cause of RSI is largely down to posture and typing style more than keyswitch design, though the latter can contribute (the worst are cheap rubber dome boards from the 90s-2000s, which often force a hard smashing typing style). We would have much less RSI if computer users kept their wrists straighter, pulled the keyboard closer, tilted it parallel to their forearms, and stopped slouching as much.

Re:iMac Pro 18-core Follow Up Review by 5_minutes on Monday February 05, 2018 @02:58PM (#16311537)
I’m not the only one that has more difficulties typing blindy on it because there’s so little travel.

“Nerve issues”, hah, what a trolly answer.

Re:iMac Pro 18-core Follow Up Review by abritinthebay on Sunday February 04, 2018 @12:45PM (#16303755)
Could not disagree more. The touchbar & Touch ID alone make it better (and I prefer they keyboard too, which imo is the best laptop keyboard I’ve used in my 26 years of using them).

Could it have a slightly better power/price ratio? Yes. But it’s so much better than my pervious model MBP it’s rediculous (previous was two releases behind but one physical revision).

Re:iMac Pro 18-core Follow Up Review by pentae on Sunday February 04, 2018 @02:34AM (#16301817)
May I ask what kind of work you do where you're meeting hundreds of actual MBP users? I am part of a big digital nomad community and the new MBP has received tons of criticism, and I believe rightfully so.
Re:iMac Pro 18-core Follow Up Review by coldtea on Sunday February 04, 2018 @09:55AM (#16302936)
Well, I'm part of the "digital nomad community" as well, and don't have many complaints, nor have heard tens of other people I know with one complaining, except for: the lack of convenience with the reduced port types.
Re:iMac Pro 18-core Follow Up Review by abritinthebay on Sunday February 04, 2018 @12:43PM (#16303740)
I’m a developer in SF where the official work & home computer is basically a MBP.
Re:iMac Pro 18-core Follow Up Review by Veen on Sunday February 04, 2018 @05:18AM (#16302195)
I don't mind the shallow key travel, but the unreliability annoys me no end. In 2018, we shouldn't have to deal with keys that stick because a minute quantum of dust worked its way into the mechanism.
Re:iMac Pro 18-core Follow Up Review by abritinthebay on Sunday February 04, 2018 @12:49PM (#16303786)
Hmm, personally I’ve never had that issue, and I’m not exactly the poster child for a clean & pristine laptop.

Neither has any developer I know at my work. Are you somewhere with a lot of dust or something?

Re:iMac Pro 18-core Follow Up Review by jacobolus on Sunday February 04, 2018 @06:54PM (#16305640)
These problems are quite common, to the point that if you go to an Apple Store and tell one of the “geniuses” that you have missing (or doubled) key actuations, they’ll knowingly sigh and start filling out the paperwork to send your laptop off for a keyboard replacement. Obviously “quite common” is not the same as “at least one person in every office will run into this”.

The problem is not whether your environment is pristine. The mechanism is just unreliable. Some people end up with keys not working after a few weeks of limited and careful use. My guess is that the tiny parts relatively easily get into some kind of subtle misalignment.

The basic design is sound enough. I think with another few generations of engineering tweaks they can get these keyboards working as expected. In the mean time it’s pretty frustrating though.

Re:iMac Pro 18-core Follow Up Review by akvadrako on Sunday February 04, 2018 @01:20PM (#16303984)
I had two sticky keys after about a year, and I'm not particularly dirty. They do even officially recommended you buy compressed air for cleaning, which I've never heard of before this keyboard.
Re:iMac Pro 18-core Follow Up Review by abritinthebay on Monday February 05, 2018 @02:36AM (#16307228)
Oh, well, that makes sense. I thought you meant something more serious.

I’ve seen issues like that with literally every laptop or regular pc keyboard since the 80s. Regular maintenance of a computer (any one) includes gentle cleaning of debris like that.

Re:iMac Pro 18-core Follow Up Review by ksec on Sunday February 04, 2018 @01:38PM (#16304077)
You see, the problem is most of those who complain are the old time Mac users. Old as in when Apple was dying, and we were still buying Apple, until Steve Jobs came back and until Apple made iPod and later iPhone.

Most of these MBP users are what I call new users, they are new to the Apple ecosystem. Mainly pulled in by the iPhone hollow effect. That is why Mac as a segment is still doing so well, there are lot of new users coming in, especially from China.

The sales data doesn't tell how angry some of these old Apple users are. If it wasn't a friend of someone within the Apple executive circle told them how they were planning to leave the Mac ecosystem because the current Mac Pro didn't work, they will never have known they had a problem.

It took 2 years for Apple to release a new product after they knew its has problem. Once Steve Jobs knew how many people hated the Apple Mouse, they had news and Interview saying they knew people didn't like it, and they are working on it.

The new Apple now, it is coming up to 5 years and Mac Pro hasn't seen a update.

Re:iMac Pro 18-core Follow Up Review by rsynnott on Sunday February 04, 2018 @06:17PM (#16305516)
While the PC business isn’t dying, sales are certainly in decline, and have been since 2012 or so. A 5% decline for Apple isn’t astonishing in context.
Re:iMac Pro 18-core Follow Up Review by scarface74 on Saturday February 03, 2018 @09:35PM (#16300964)
This isn't about the MacBook Pro. Marco bought a 10 core iMac Pro and raves about it on both ATP and Under the Radar.
Re:iMac Pro 18-core Follow Up Review by ghostcluster on Saturday February 03, 2018 @10:19PM (#16301118)
Plenty of Apple diehards have complaints about the iMac Pro, and Apple's market share has not 'continued to grow' as the original poster claimed. It's hovered between 3-8% of the PC market for many years.
Re:iMac Pro 18-core Follow Up Review by scarface74 on Saturday February 03, 2018 @10:29PM (#16301150)
So where are these "plenty of Mac die hards"? All of the reviews I've seen from the well known Apple bloggers and podcasters have been quite positive about it. It's not like any of them hold back criticizing Apple or Macs in general.
Re:iMac Pro 18-core Follow Up Review by coldtea on Sunday February 04, 2018 @09:57AM (#16302945)
That's a single company, having a 3-8% of a huge market with hundreds of players and built-it-yourself options.

And that 3-8% market is an 70-90% of the high end expensive market, and commands 90% of the profits -- more profits than the next 3-4 players combined.

Re:iMac Pro 18-core Follow Up Review by oceanswave on Sunday February 04, 2018 @09:45AM (#16302895)
IDC and Gartner reported in Jan of marginal increase in market share, perhaps this is what the OP was referring to.
Re:iMac Pro 18-core Follow Up Review by glhaynes on Saturday February 03, 2018 @08:34PM (#16300745)
"Apple outperformed nearly every PC maker in 2017 as Mac sales remain steady" (The MBP redesign that's been so controversial was introduced mid-2016.) http://bgr.com/2018/01/14/mac-sales-2017-marketshare-pc-decl...

Which isn't to say that the Mac business is as good as it could be—surely it isn't, and they have several models they need to address with updates. I don't really like the Touch Bar. But the Mac is doing fine.

Re:iMac Pro 18-core Follow Up Review by ghostcluster on Saturday February 03, 2018 @08:39PM (#16300765)
You just quoted an article of IDC predictions. Apple released its actual results on Thursday:

Mac sales and revenue were both down 5% from last year.

Mac sales down ~200,000 units.

Q1-2018 numbers, reported 02 Feb 18: https://www.macworld.co.uk/news/apple/apple-financial-result...

Re:iMac Pro 18-core Follow Up Review by sib on Sunday February 04, 2018 @01:00AM (#16301583)
It's important to note that Apple had 13 weeks in the quarter that they just reported on, while, in the year-before quarter, they had 14 weeks. This is a difference of just over 7%. That means that Apple sold more Macs per day (and generated more revenue per day) this year than in the year-ago quarter.
Re:iMac Pro 18-core Follow Up Review by rzzzt on Sunday February 04, 2018 @06:15AM (#16302331)
I was puzzled by your comment, then did some searching: http://www.slate.com/blogs/moneybox/2014/02/06/_14_week_quar...
Re:iMac Pro 18-core Follow Up Review by ntsplnkv2 on Saturday February 03, 2018 @09:34PM (#16300960)
Can you compare that to other PC manufacturers? Otherwise it's a meaningless number-we know desktop sales, esp at the super high end, are down overall.
Re:iMac Pro 18-core Follow Up Review by glhaynes on Saturday February 03, 2018 @08:51PM (#16300807)
I was just trying to give some context beyond a single quarter. The highly-criticized devices have been out for a long time and have been good sellers. They've clearly got some work to do overall, though. I just don't think the Mac is in some historically-unique bad spot (not saying you said that), which one would surely think if they just went by blog posts.
Re:iMac Pro 18-core Follow Up Review by CleanSlate_III on Saturday February 03, 2018 @08:27PM (#16300722)
I agree, they're in a bit of a drought with respect to what their core consumers wants.

I'm still using my 2010 15" MPB (i5 duo core). When I was browsing for a computer at the time it was a product I could see myself using for a decade. I hope that turns out to be true--it works great for what I need to do. Their recent updates have made me shrug and think, "meh, I can wait." If I'm going to shell out $2k+ for a new computer it better be damn near perfect.

Re:iMac Pro 18-core Follow Up Review by lindig on Sunday February 04, 2018 @06:39AM (#16302375)
> Mac sales are down 5%.

Not true. Apple sold 5.112M Macs units in 13 weeks recently and 5.374M Macs in 14 weeks a year ago. That is 0.393M/week recently vs. 0.384M/week a year ago.

https://www.apple.com/newsroom/pdfs/Q1_FY18_Data_Summary.pdf

Re:iMac Pro 18-core Follow Up Review by seanmcdirmid on Monday February 05, 2018 @04:52PM (#16312567)
> Mac sales are down 5%.

Mac sales are down 5% in Q1 2018, after being up 25% in Q4 2017. Its hardly a convinceable narrative that market share is steadily decreasing, because it isn't (incidentally, Apple moved up the ranks to #4 PC maker because the whole PC market took a dive).

Re:iMac Pro 18-core Follow Up Review by coldtea on Sunday February 04, 2018 @09:53AM (#16302929)
Which means nothing much -- 5% is peanuts, and the previous quarter was a record one.

Besides, without checking how did the overall industry go, it can't tell much.

Re:iMac Pro 18-core Follow Up Review by oceanswave on Sunday February 04, 2018 @09:46AM (#16302899)
Latest earnings report didn’t include iMac Pro Sales.
Re:iMac Pro 18-core Follow Up Review by rimliu on Sunday February 04, 2018 @03:58AM (#16301984)
How about non-Mac sales?
Re:iMac Pro 18-core Follow Up Review by rorykoehler on Sunday February 04, 2018 @12:00AM (#16301436)
The touchbar is why I decided to buy a maxed out 4 year old mbp instead of a new one to replace my 7 year old mbp.
Re:iMac Pro 18-core Follow Up Review by gaius on Sunday February 04, 2018 @04:45AM (#16302086)
Some of the harshest criticisms of Apple have been coming from diehard fans in Apple's market niche

My first Mac was an LC475 upgraded with a real '040 to run MATLAB, back in oh, '94 I think. Also had a second-hand SE30 to run Word 5.1 (still the best version). Next up was a Power Mac 7600 when I needed more grunt to run FORTRAN code. Amazing machine, the price/performance was incredible. It was faster than a DEC Alpha 3000 at a fraction of the price! A few more both desktop and laptop between then and now. So I think I count as a long-term Mac user and loyal customer.

My current machines are a 2008 MBP and a 2014 Mac Mini. Apple simply haven't given me any compelling reason to upgrade, in fact have pushed me to offload my compute needs to Azure. Now that I have made that leap, I'm actually not particularly interested in a real Mac Pro anymore, I just don't need it. I can't be alone, and this will bite Apple in the ass at some point.

Who's buying the current MBP then? Not professional users, just people looking to flash the brand. Which is fine, but the fashion crowd is fickle. Apple has chosen to court them rather than 20+ year customers. And that's OK too, it's their business to run as they see fit. But a third thing that is fine is for people to post their opinions of it...

Re:iMac Pro 18-core Follow Up Review by Veen on Sunday February 04, 2018 @05:14AM (#16302184)
Perhaps your definition of professional is too narrow. I'm a professional writer (and hobbyist coder). I used a MacBook Air for four years before upgrading to a MacBook Pro.

My reasons for upgrading to a MacBook Pro were: (i) the better screen (which matters when you're looking at it eight hours a day), (ii) improved performance compared to the Air or the MacBook, (iii) the ability to drive a couple of high-definition external screens, and (iv) all the above on on a portable device that runs MacOS. Number iv is probably the most important reason: I prefer MacOS.

If you construe "professional" as someone with high CPU and GPU processing demands, then perhaps I don't count. But that's a tiny market: most professionals who choose a MacBook choose it for the same reasons I did.

Re:iMac Pro 18-core Follow Up Review by gaius on Sunday February 04, 2018 @05:23AM (#16302207)
Number iv is probably the most important reason: I prefer MacOS.

Yes, me too, so I find myself in a weird no-mans-land - I don't want to switch to another platform, and I don't want to buy anything in the recent line-up. I will be forced to when my Mini becomes unsupported for OS updates, then I will spend as little as I can to get back in the game, because they have already pushed me into the mindset and workflow of offloading the heavy lifting. But offer me a machine as radical my old 7600 was relative to what I had previously and relative to the rest of the market, and I'll jump at it.

Re:iMac Pro 18-core Follow Up Review by akvadrako on Sunday February 04, 2018 @05:49AM (#16302268)
Nobody cares if you are happy with your old model; maybe there just isn't any reason for you to upgrade at all.

But for people that want a new laptop, the MBP is the best machine available by many metrics, especially the screen - it's finally bright enough I can work outside on a sunny day.

Re:iMac Pro 18-core Follow Up Review by gaius on Sunday February 04, 2018 @07:20AM (#16302457)
Nobody cares if you are happy with your old model; maybe there just isn't any reason for you to upgrade at all

A manufacturer that in 10 years hadn’t produced a compelling reason to upgrade doesn’t strike you as a little odd?

Nevertheless the point stands; its not “haters” criticising Apple here, but long term fans and customers

Re:iMac Pro 18-core Follow Up Review by akvadrako on Sunday February 04, 2018 @08:04AM (#16302585)
I don't see how former fans can't be haters and in either case it's unreasonable. PC's became good enough for most common tasks years ago and a lot of the low-hanging fruit has been picked. The technology is not quite ready to go the next step, like for example worthwhile VR.

You didn't even explain what you want from Apple. Is it about performance or some groundbreaking new feature?

Re:iMac Pro 18-core Follow Up Review by gaius on Sunday February 04, 2018 @10:47AM (#16303179)
You didn't even explain what you want from Apple. Is it about performance or some groundbreaking new feature?

I think most professional MBP users would happily trade 5mm thickness for 32 or even 64G RAM, and a better CPU/GPU.

Re:iMac Pro 18-core Follow Up Review by biztos on Sunday February 04, 2018 @04:58AM (#16302129)
"Flash the brand?" Really?

I bought an MBP last year, because I needed a new computer and I still think the Macs are the best for my needs, in both software and hardware. And I am most definitely a professional user.

Do I wish it had a few more ports and a quieter keyboard? Yes!

Did that ever seriously threaten my purchase? No!

I don't think anybody who wants to just show off the logo is going to buy an MBP over a straight MB, which is lighter and (IMO) better looking.

But is that even "a thing" with computers in 2018?

Re:iMac Pro 18-core Follow Up Review by gaius on Sunday February 04, 2018 @05:04AM (#16302151)
"Flash the brand?" Really?

I don't know where you are but in the UK there is a TV ad suggesting a MBP is the ideal machine for parent to buy a first-year undergrad.

The prioritization of thinness above everything else - when there is already the Macbook Air for that market segment - is a further example. I'll buy a brand new MBP as soon as there is a compelling reason to replace my 10 year old one. That just hasn't happened yet.

Re:iMac Pro 18-core Follow Up Review by wtallis on Sunday February 04, 2018 @08:21PM (#16305972)
> I'll buy a brand new MBP as soon as there is a compelling reason to replace my 10 year old one. That just hasn't happened yet.

If you're satisfied with the performance of a Core 2 Duo, still able to get fresh batteries, too old for your eyes to benefit from a Retina display, and don't want to shave off 25-40% of the weight, then why do you expect that there ever could be a compelling reason to replace your current MBP? If you don't want anything more from your computer, then how is anyone supposed to entice you with a computer that does more?

Re:iMac Pro 18-core Follow Up Review by rsynnott on Sunday February 04, 2018 @06:22PM (#16305543)
My work machine is a 2017 MBP; previously a 2013 one, and before that 2008 or so. For my usecase (programmer), it’s so much better than the 2008 one it’s not even funny, and also substantially better than the 2013 one (in particular, the SSD is much faster, and the battery holds up better for me). I’m a professional user. I’m not really seeing the problem (for my usecase).

Edit: Also, I know people love to complain about how thin it’s gotten, but as someone who has to drag it to meetings a lot, I kind of appreciate the thinness (along with the one-port connection when I get it back to the desk).

Re:iMac Pro 18-core Follow Up Review by sneak on Sunday February 04, 2018 @07:22AM (#16302464)
As someone who just did a PC build along these lines, and has an 18-core iMac Pro arriving this week, I can also say that this simply isn’t true. It’s more expensive than a hand build, but the Apple Tax is the lowest it has ever been. $14k for a 4tb hardware raid0, hardware crypto pci flash, 128GB ECC ram, 18 core Xeon, 5k wide gamut display, and 64gb Vega is not bad when the equivalent hand build is well over $10k (and it comes in an ugly box, even if you get the nicest ugly box available on the market).

The Apple Tax used to be pushing 100%. Now it’s somewhere around 15-20%. It’s amazing. It’s the reason I got the iMac Pro, despite having a booting Hackintosh OS on very close to the same hardware. It’s just not that much of a premium anymore.

PS: anyone want to buy a PC? it’s in a really nice case and has lots of ram.

Re:iMac Pro 18-core Follow Up Review by mrits on Saturday February 03, 2018 @08:36PM (#16300753)
I don't think very many people think their products have improved. I still buy Apple but am increasingly frustrated by their design choices in the last few years.
Re:iMac Pro 18-core Follow Up Review by bane on Saturday February 03, 2018 @10:24PM (#16301130)
I think both you and the home-builders are correct. One interesting question for home-builders to answer then is this one, why haven't mainstream PC makers build competitive systems for a much smaller price to consumers?
Re:iMac Pro 18-core Follow Up Review by hungerstrike on Sunday February 04, 2018 @01:45AM (#16301684)
Pffft. Why would I want to drive a Benz when I can build my own Ferrari?
Re:iMac Pro 18-core Follow Up Review by abritinthebay on Sunday February 04, 2018 @02:17AM (#16301779)
The trouble is that a lot of home builders end up putting a Ferrari engine in a Volvo body with a Yugo drivetrain & wheels from a Reliant Robin.

Yet they’ll think they have a better car, because it’s got a Ferrari under the hood.

Re:iMac Pro 18-core Follow Up Review by hungerstrike on Sunday February 04, 2018 @01:16PM (#16303962)
Yeah, but I can build an actual Ferrari.

However I do consider the Mac OS to be very Benz-like, which is why I think it’s terrible.