News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:iMac Pro 18-core Follow Up Review by abritinthebay on Sunday February 04, 2018 @02:14AM (#16301766)
You need to get out if your bubble. The only complaint I’ve geard from literally hundreds of actual users about the new MBPs is they don’t like the shallow key travel on the new keyboards.

I do, but I’ve always preferred less travel.

Outside of the moaning online bubble (like HN) the MBP is a raging success.

Re:iMac Pro 18-core Follow Up Review by fit2rule on Sunday February 04, 2018 @07:31AM (#16302484)
Mac ex-fanboix reporting in, had everything since the tiBook, an Apple II, and between.

I don't wanna play no more. Because of the atrocious nature of things vis a vis MBP2017, and onwards, I'm leaving for something else.

I say this, typing uncomfortably on a MBP2017 with a touchbar I never use, making constant typos, and feeling just plain ripped off.

Re:iMac Pro 18-core Follow Up Review by itbeho on Sunday February 04, 2018 @12:29PM (#16303673)
Leaving for what though? I have mostly the same sentiment as you, but find just about everything else on the market has some level of design insanity that provokes frustration with use. It's literally out of the pot, into the fire....
Re:iMac Pro 18-core Follow Up Review by abritinthebay on Sunday February 04, 2018 @12:47PM (#16303774)
If you don’t use the touchbar I wonder what you ever do on the MBP. I use it regularly, many times a day for development & other tasks.
Re:iMac Pro 18-core Follow Up Review by mmjaa on Monday February 05, 2018 @04:22AM (#16307647)
Also a pro developer here, also a non Touch Bar-user - in my point of view its a piece of junk and not worth the effort.

So I'm curious how you find it so useful?

Re:iMac Pro 18-core Follow Up Review by sgarman on Sunday February 04, 2018 @03:35AM (#16301933)
I have owned every single 15" MBP since they started using intel. Each one was better then the last - they were great - best laptops you can buy. This most recent one is the first one that is worse then the previous one.
Re:iMac Pro 18-core Follow Up Review by 5_minutes on Sunday February 04, 2018 @03:42AM (#16301951)
I thought I got used to the horrible keyboard, but after working on a old MBP I realise how bad the current one really is.

I have no feeling with it.

So yeah, for the first time in years, I'm looking around at other brands.

I'm just locked in with iPhoto.

Re:iMac Pro 18-core Follow Up Review by abritinthebay on Sunday February 04, 2018 @12:46PM (#16303764)
No feeling? Do you have nerve issues or something? Help me understand this complaint, I don’t get it.

Large key travel is only good for those hitting they keys way too hard imo

Re:iMac Pro 18-core Follow Up Review by jacobolus on Sunday February 04, 2018 @07:05PM (#16305680)
Longer key travel is helpful for almost everyone (for accuracy, speed, comfort, and avoiding injury). Ideal is probably at least 1.5mm before actuation, and at least 1mm after actuation. Maybe more. No recent laptop keyboard comes anywhere close to a truly fast and accurate keyboard, because the space constraints are simply too tight to fit in a mechanism optimized for ergonomics. All the best keyswitches are from <1990. They had many small moving parts and were very expensive to produce relative to cheaper alternatives like rubber domes.

(Laptop keyboards also don’t have the space to properly raise the keycap tops on keys in further rows, because they don’t have space for it; this makes reaching for the top 2 rows of the keyboard noticeably slower and less comfortable)

The best keyswitches actuate about halfway through the stroke, have a distinct drop in force at the actuation point, and have a significant mechanical bounce to them on the upstroke, launching your fingers up toward the next keypress. My all-time favorites are Alps “plate spring” switches used on certain Japanese IBM computers and some IBM luggables in the late 1980s (I can type about 20–30 wpm faster on these than on any laptop keyboard). You can also get this effect (with a very different overall feel) from Topre switches (still produced), or from IBM beam spring keyboards (from the 1970s). Some other keyboard enthusiasts have different preferences, e.g. for simple springs with no additional tactile mechanism (“linear switches”) optionally with a clicker or buzzer to give audio feedback of key actuation. Such switches are slower to type on than a snappier alternative, but some people prefer the feeling.

Nobody should be hitting any type of keys “way too hard”. You want to use just enough force to actuate the key and not push the key hard all the way through the bottom of the stroke. This is much easier to judge when the switch has relatively dramatic tactile feedback and a lot of post-actuation travel which ramps up in resistance toward the bottom.

Re:iMac Pro 18-core Follow Up Review by abritinthebay on Monday February 05, 2018 @02:40AM (#16307239)
What you’re describing are literally the most horrible keyboards I have the displeasure to use.

For example: the IBM Model M is one of the single worst typing experiences imo. The only way to type on that thing is use about 5x the force I normally do.

No wonder our industry is plagued by RSI - it lionizes horrible things like this due to misguided nostalgia.

Re:iMac Pro 18-core Follow Up Review by jacobolus on Monday February 05, 2018 @06:53AM (#16308232)
The IBM Model M is a great typing keyboard after you get used to it, but you are right that it is on the stiffer side. The previous Model F keyboards took about 10 grams less to actuate, and are widely preferred. I find even those a bit stiffer than my taste. Neither of those keyboards has my preferred feedback or force curve, though I don't mind typing on them. The biggest objection I've ever heard to either is the noise.

In any event, actuation force is an orthogonal concern to travel distance, tactile feedback, post-actuation force curve, upstroke bounce, keycap shape, etc.

Relatively fewer people typing on a such IBM keyboards got RSI compared to other keyboards, because the extreme tactile snap makes it very obviously unnecessary to type with much force more than barely required to actuate them.

But the cause of RSI is largely down to posture and typing style more than keyswitch design, though the latter can contribute (the worst are cheap rubber dome boards from the 90s-2000s, which often force a hard smashing typing style). We would have much less RSI if computer users kept their wrists straighter, pulled the keyboard closer, tilted it parallel to their forearms, and stopped slouching as much.

Re:iMac Pro 18-core Follow Up Review by 5_minutes on Monday February 05, 2018 @02:58PM (#16311537)
I’m not the only one that has more difficulties typing blindy on it because there’s so little travel.

“Nerve issues”, hah, what a trolly answer.

Re:iMac Pro 18-core Follow Up Review by abritinthebay on Sunday February 04, 2018 @12:45PM (#16303755)
Could not disagree more. The touchbar & Touch ID alone make it better (and I prefer they keyboard too, which imo is the best laptop keyboard I’ve used in my 26 years of using them).

Could it have a slightly better power/price ratio? Yes. But it’s so much better than my pervious model MBP it’s rediculous (previous was two releases behind but one physical revision).

Re:iMac Pro 18-core Follow Up Review by pentae on Sunday February 04, 2018 @02:34AM (#16301817)
May I ask what kind of work you do where you're meeting hundreds of actual MBP users? I am part of a big digital nomad community and the new MBP has received tons of criticism, and I believe rightfully so.
Re:iMac Pro 18-core Follow Up Review by coldtea on Sunday February 04, 2018 @09:55AM (#16302936)
Well, I'm part of the "digital nomad community" as well, and don't have many complaints, nor have heard tens of other people I know with one complaining, except for: the lack of convenience with the reduced port types.
Re:iMac Pro 18-core Follow Up Review by abritinthebay on Sunday February 04, 2018 @12:43PM (#16303740)
I’m a developer in SF where the official work & home computer is basically a MBP.
Re:iMac Pro 18-core Follow Up Review by Veen on Sunday February 04, 2018 @05:18AM (#16302195)
I don't mind the shallow key travel, but the unreliability annoys me no end. In 2018, we shouldn't have to deal with keys that stick because a minute quantum of dust worked its way into the mechanism.
Re:iMac Pro 18-core Follow Up Review by abritinthebay on Sunday February 04, 2018 @12:49PM (#16303786)
Hmm, personally I’ve never had that issue, and I’m not exactly the poster child for a clean & pristine laptop.

Neither has any developer I know at my work. Are you somewhere with a lot of dust or something?

Re:iMac Pro 18-core Follow Up Review by jacobolus on Sunday February 04, 2018 @06:54PM (#16305640)
These problems are quite common, to the point that if you go to an Apple Store and tell one of the “geniuses” that you have missing (or doubled) key actuations, they’ll knowingly sigh and start filling out the paperwork to send your laptop off for a keyboard replacement. Obviously “quite common” is not the same as “at least one person in every office will run into this”.

The problem is not whether your environment is pristine. The mechanism is just unreliable. Some people end up with keys not working after a few weeks of limited and careful use. My guess is that the tiny parts relatively easily get into some kind of subtle misalignment.

The basic design is sound enough. I think with another few generations of engineering tweaks they can get these keyboards working as expected. In the mean time it’s pretty frustrating though.

Re:iMac Pro 18-core Follow Up Review by akvadrako on Sunday February 04, 2018 @01:20PM (#16303984)
I had two sticky keys after about a year, and I'm not particularly dirty. They do even officially recommended you buy compressed air for cleaning, which I've never heard of before this keyboard.
Re:iMac Pro 18-core Follow Up Review by abritinthebay on Monday February 05, 2018 @02:36AM (#16307228)
Oh, well, that makes sense. I thought you meant something more serious.

I’ve seen issues like that with literally every laptop or regular pc keyboard since the 80s. Regular maintenance of a computer (any one) includes gentle cleaning of debris like that.

Re:iMac Pro 18-core Follow Up Review by ksec on Sunday February 04, 2018 @01:38PM (#16304077)
You see, the problem is most of those who complain are the old time Mac users. Old as in when Apple was dying, and we were still buying Apple, until Steve Jobs came back and until Apple made iPod and later iPhone.

Most of these MBP users are what I call new users, they are new to the Apple ecosystem. Mainly pulled in by the iPhone hollow effect. That is why Mac as a segment is still doing so well, there are lot of new users coming in, especially from China.

The sales data doesn't tell how angry some of these old Apple users are. If it wasn't a friend of someone within the Apple executive circle told them how they were planning to leave the Mac ecosystem because the current Mac Pro didn't work, they will never have known they had a problem.

It took 2 years for Apple to release a new product after they knew its has problem. Once Steve Jobs knew how many people hated the Apple Mouse, they had news and Interview saying they knew people didn't like it, and they are working on it.

The new Apple now, it is coming up to 5 years and Mac Pro hasn't seen a update.