News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Airbus A380, Once the Future of Aviation, May Cease Produ... by double0jimb0 on Monday January 15, 2018 @03:17PM (#16153057)
Interning at Boeing in 2005, when the Dreamliner was still 2-3 years away from production, I asked a BD manager if Boeing was worried about A380 (the burning question at the time was "Who is going to win, A380/Airbus or Dreamliner/Boeing").

Without pause, he said "Not worried at all, A380 serves the hub and spoke model, which is dying. People hate layovers, they want more direct flights."

Not a hard insight to grasp, and one which seems to have doomed A380 from the start.

Re:Airbus A380, Once the Future of Aviation, May Cease Produ... by pkaye on Monday January 15, 2018 @03:25PM (#16153118)
It is not a obvious insight to grasp since airlines take a strategy that makes them the most money and passengers are cost sensitive. Wasn't this the driving force behind the hum and spoke model?
Re:Airbus A380, Once the Future of Aviation, May Cease Produ... by JumpCrisscross on Monday January 15, 2018 @03:47PM (#16153296)
> Wasn't this the driving force behind the hum and spoke model?

No, the range of small jets (which were constrained by relatively unreliable, inefficient engines) was. Small jets can safely go further today than they could before. Boeing saw this. To be fair, Airbus also saw this. Political factors, similar to those behind NASA’s Space Shuttle debacle, constrained them to making a giant ass plane.

Re:Airbus A380, Once the Future of Aviation, May Cease Produ... by InTheArena on Monday January 15, 2018 @05:18PM (#16153955)
This.

To be fair, Airbus actually owned the big twin market until the 767 and 757 came out. Then those planes (as well as Airbus's own planes) fragmented transatlantic flying. Then they lost their way when they focused on the A380 - but the engines that enabled the 787 were not yet out.

Re:Airbus A380, Once the Future of Aviation, May Cease Produ... by mthomasb on Monday January 15, 2018 @06:28PM (#16154412)
This is a great video on the economics of the hub and spoke vs. direct model embodied by the A380 vs 787: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NlIdzF1_b5M

That channel also has alot of very interesting content on the economics of air travel (e.g., seating classes, how tickets are priced, etc).

Re:Airbus A380, Once the Future of Aviation, May Cease Produ... by double0jimb0 on Monday January 15, 2018 @03:38PM (#16153222)
Passengers are cost AND travel-time/hassle sensitive. It appears Airbus didn't place enough value into the "travel-time/hassle" part.

More detail: the Dreamliner is 20% more efficient than previous generation planes. This allowed airlines to "break" the major hubs into many quicker/easier direct flights at a price that passengers are willing to pay. Boeing bet increasing value in this manner was superior than Airbus's bet to simply make hubs cheaper to operate.

Re:Airbus A380, Once the Future of Aviation, May Cease Produ... by geezerjay on Monday January 15, 2018 @04:43PM (#16153714)
Passangers are sensitive to travel time but the constraint is placed firmly on cost, particular on major tourism destinations where airports are already saturated.

Furthermore, some international and national air travel networks are in fact organized in a hub and spoke pattern, particularly trans-oceanic flights where demand is high and cost is the main competitive advantage, including business travel.

It's easy to claim now that the choice that was made a couple of decades ago was the right or wrong one, just like it's very easy to pick yesterday's lottery numbers, but if the world economy didn't tanked and if Airbus's projects weren't with so many delays then I really doubt Boeing's bet would be so right.

Re:Airbus A380, Once the Future of Aviation, May Cease Produ... by thaumasiotes on Tuesday January 16, 2018 @02:12AM (#16156379)
> just like it's very easy to pick yesterday's lottery numbers

It can be harder than it appears. Never forget the poor Chinese guy who noticed that the winning lottery numbers were announced before the close of ticket sales, and got thrown in jail for his pains.

Re:Airbus A380, Once the Future of Aviation, May Cease Produ... by hinkley on Monday January 15, 2018 @05:19PM (#16153961)
The Dreamliner can also fly about 2x as many miles between servicing (due to more careful logging of wear and tear), which means not only lower costs but also fewer logistical problems about getting the plane back to a maintenance facility before the FAA is breathing down your neck for noncompliance.
Re:Airbus A380, Once the Future of Aviation, May Cease Produ... by InTheArena on Monday January 15, 2018 @05:32PM (#16154048)
And in general, Twins are just lower maintenance.
Re:Airbus A380, Once the Future of Aviation, May Cease Produ... by ghaff on Monday January 15, 2018 @03:52PM (#16153339)
>Passengers are cost AND travel-time/hassle sensitive.

Especially among business travelers. Many business travelers may still shop on price up to a point but they'll tend to do so given that the flights have the same number of stops.

Re:Airbus A380, Once the Future of Aviation, May Cease Produ... by bunderbunder on Monday January 15, 2018 @05:39PM (#16154103)
For me, the price needs to be quite a bit lower to justify a layover even on pure financial grounds. I can't back this up with any hard math, but my sense is that time in transit curtails my productivity severely enough that there'd have to be a pretty enormous savings in ticket price to offset the cost of having me spend (say) twice as much time camping out in airport waiting areas and being subject to takeoff/landing laptop embargos.
Re:Airbus A380, Once the Future of Aviation, May Cease Produ... by ghaff on Monday January 15, 2018 @05:46PM (#16154145)
I can't really point to a whole lot of productivity when traveling anyway. And, if I'm being honest, I will sometimes take connections to fly preferred (because of programs) airlines on longer flights. But, yeah, it's more time and that many more opportunities to have blown up travel plans that do lose significant chunks of time.
Re:Airbus A380, Once the Future of Aviation, May Cease Produ... by cwyers on Monday January 15, 2018 @04:55PM (#16153782)
Others have mentioned the improvements in range in more fuel-efficient aircraft. But there's also other incentives at play. Remember when United had a passenger dragged off the plan on a commuter flight? Turns out that wasn't United, but one of many regional airlines that contracts with United. United's union contract constrains the size of these flights, but the pilots at these airlines make less than members of the union. So there's other incentives for airlines to abandon hub-and-spoke in favor of more commuter flights.
Re:Airbus A380, Once the Future of Aviation, May Cease Produ... by forkandwait on Monday January 15, 2018 @05:43PM (#16154125)
If I were building a model, I would estimate my customers average hourly income and figure that is how to calculate break even in a time vs money calculation for a flight. I make 60 an hour (low for regular flyers I bet), a flight change adds 4 hours, so a $240 cost difference for each direct flight is realistic. That might turn into real money if you scale it.
Re:Airbus A380, Once the Future of Aviation, May Cease Produ... by kelnos on Tuesday January 16, 2018 @04:45AM (#16156919)
People don't actually value things that way, because people don't work for a wage every hour they aren't doing something else. This kind of calculation comes up all the time when people are trying to "value their time", but the reality is quite different.
Re:Airbus A380, Once the Future of Aviation, May Cease Produ... by Gibbon1 on Monday January 15, 2018 @09:35PM (#16155348)
I have a suspicion which is you are right, ticket prices don't capture full cost. Especially for business passengers.

Problem with the spoke and hub model is passengers not only decide on whether to fly based on price but on psychological stress[1]. When that gets too high they won't fly no matter what the price is. Airlines probably make more money if they _all_ charge more for lower stress flights.

[1] More stress means business travelers need more down time after flights, which lowers productivity and moral. Long stressful flights impacts the quality of vacation travel.

Re:Airbus A380, Once the Future of Aviation, May Cease Produ... by eloisant on Tuesday January 16, 2018 @06:19AM (#16157380)
It might be true for US domestic flights, but for international flights you'll always have many people flying from one population hub to an other.

Think Paris-Tokyo, London-New York, etc. You'll never have a direct flight from Edinburg to Osaka anyway.

Re:Airbus A380, Once the Future of Aviation, May Cease Produ... by bluGill on Tuesday January 16, 2018 @11:37AM (#16159441)
While we may never have the Edinburg to Osaka direct flight, the 5 people/month (number made up, it seems reasonable) who make that trip want it. The smaller the plane the can profitably make those long trips the more small airports get direct flights and the happier customers will be.

I know if I could get a direct flight to my in-laws only once a week I'd plan my vacation around when the plane runs over taking a layover someplace I don't want to be.

Re:Airbus A380, Once the Future of Aviation, May Cease Produ... by Havoc on Monday January 15, 2018 @04:41PM (#16153704)
As long as hub & spoke works out cheaper (which it will thanks to centralisation & economies of scale) it'll have a place in the budget market
Re:Airbus A380, Once the Future of Aviation, May Cease Produ... by InTheArena on Monday January 15, 2018 @05:30PM (#16154034)
As far as I am aware, there are no A380s in the charter market yet (which is a lot of budget market) and very very few in the discount carrier world (EasyJet, RyanAir, Sprit, Norwegian, Iceland Air, etc). The charter carriers and discount carriers typically don't have the traffic to sustain these flights, and really don't have first or business class traffic to sustain the flight.

The a380 was made for large traffic to and from Asian cities. If there is going to be a savior for the program, that's where it will come from.

There are rumors that Airbus has approached China to talk about taking over a large portion of the project, in exchange for Chinese orders. That's something to keep a eye on.

Re:Airbus A380, Once the Future of Aviation, May Cease Produ... by kalleboo on Tuesday January 16, 2018 @02:15AM (#16156387)
It looks like the problem with the hub & spoke model right now is that the big hub airports are all slot-restricted. LCCs like to use smaller airports out of town that have cheaper open slots, and this makes it harder to implement hubs. But I predict as they build out intercontinental travel (like Norwegian are doing now), hubs will emerge for the intra-continental legs.
Re:Airbus A380, Once the Future of Aviation, May Cease Produ... by Havoc on Tuesday January 16, 2018 @08:57AM (#16158151)
>right now is that the big hub airports are all slot-restricted

Dubai too? Looked to me like they had loads of capacity left last few times I went through

Re:Airbus A380, Once the Future of Aviation, May Cease Produ... by raz32dust on Monday January 15, 2018 @03:54PM (#16153358)
Isn't A350 the competitor to Dreamliner? I think A380 was aimed at replacing B747, which it did. Also I feel (no data) that hub and spoke is alive and well. It's just that it is using more efficient, lower capacity flights (B787, A350) which are easier to fill up and maintain.
Re:Airbus A380, Once the Future of Aviation, May Cease Produ... by seanmcdirmid on Monday January 15, 2018 @04:01PM (#16153410)
The 787 replaced the 767 in Boeing's lineup, which in turn was competitor of the 350. The 747 is still incredibly successful for cargo, so the 380 didn't replace it; it is absolutely nuts that AirBus didn't come up with a cargo version of the 380 yet.

Next up is the 777, which has higher capacity than the 787/350. However, it is modern enough that it can probably just be upgraded, no new plane is needed.

Re:Airbus A380, Once the Future of Aviation, May Cease Produ... by exidy on Monday January 15, 2018 @07:30PM (#16154784)
The Airbus competitor to the 767 is the not the A350, it is the A330, which is ubiquitous outside of NA in the medium haul market. It has been an extremely successful plane for Airbus and will likely continue to be so with the A330neo.

While each company's offerings overlap somewhat, the A350 is a substantially larger plane and competes with the 777.

Widebody twin 2-class capacity (variants):

  767  | 216 / 261 / 296
  A330 |       246 / 300
  787  |       242 / 290 / 330
  A350 |                   325 / 366
  777  |                   313 /     / 396
  777X |                         365 / 414
Re:Airbus A380, Once the Future of Aviation, May Cease Produ... by seanmcdirmid on Tuesday January 16, 2018 @12:00AM (#16155953)
I stand corrected, thanks! The 767 is replaced by the 787 still (well, the 767 is still in production for non passenger uses), which exists in the space as a smaller wide body.
Re:Airbus A380, Once the Future of Aviation, May Cease Produ... by altstar on Monday January 15, 2018 @04:19PM (#16153548)
There was a 380 cargo version. It was not economical for operators to fly and all the initial orders were cancelled. It was called the 380F.
Re:Airbus A380, Once the Future of Aviation, May Cease Produ... by erispoe on Tuesday January 16, 2018 @03:41AM (#16156675)
The A380 doesn't make sense for cargo. Too much volume for the weight it can lift. At the average plane cargo density, an A380 cargo would be at weight capacity way before it gets to volume capacity.[1]

The A380 cannot lift much more than a B747. But it has more volume, which comes in handy for passengers, not for cargo.

[1]: https://www.flexport.com/blog/airbus-a380-no-cargo-equivalen...

edit: 747 n° mistake

Re:Airbus A380, Once the Future of Aviation, May Cease Produ... by ubernostrum on Tuesday January 16, 2018 @06:12AM (#16157348)
The A380's useful payload is actually less then a 747 freighter. The added weight of the aircraft itself, plus the extra fuel necessary to get and keep it airborne, eats up all the extra takeoff weight capacity and then some.
Re:Airbus A380, Once the Future of Aviation, May Cease Produ... by filereaper on Monday January 15, 2018 @04:08PM (#16153458)
777 has incredible range, the current 777-LR (worldliner) still flies further than the 787. I think Boeing will upgrade the 777 with better composites and engines, but I doubt 777 will be die anytime soon.
Re:Airbus A380, Once the Future of Aviation, May Cease Produ... by timb07 on Monday January 15, 2018 @05:36PM (#16154080)
The 777X program is already well advanced, with first flight expected sometime next year.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boeing_777X

Re:Airbus A380, Once the Future of Aviation, May Cease Produ... by rwmj on Monday January 15, 2018 @04:04PM (#16153428)
You can't just take the seats out and fill it with boxes? What else is needed for a cargo plane?
Re:Airbus A380, Once the Future of Aviation, May Cease Produ... by txcwpalpha on Monday January 15, 2018 @04:24PM (#16153577)
You need a good way to get the boxes on and off the plane, such as the 747 freighter's nose door [1]. The A380 can't be fitted with one of these due to its cockpit placement.

The 2nd floor of the A380 also can't be removed because it's required structurally, and that really limits the size of the cargo you could potentially put in it.

1: http://www.aerospace-technology.com/wp-content/uploads/sites...

Re:Airbus A380, Once the Future of Aviation, May Cease Produ... by Alupis on Monday January 15, 2018 @04:10PM (#16153477)
Usually you need special flooring with tie-downs and rollers to facilitate moving the load around, which helps maintain an appropriate CG (Center of Gravity).

Purpose-built freighter models also remove things that aren't necessary and just add weight - such as windows (packages don't need a view). This allows the carrier to transport more cargo in the same flight.

Re:Airbus A380, Once the Future of Aviation, May Cease Produ... by tuna-piano on Monday January 15, 2018 @04:31PM (#16153629)
Supposedly the A380 also has a max weight that would not use all the available volume for cargo.

"The A380-F would be able to carry 60% more volume than the 747, but only 28% more weight."

https://www.flexport.com/blog/airbus-a380-no-cargo-equivalen...

Re:Airbus A380, Once the Future of Aviation, May Cease Produ... by dx034 on Tuesday January 16, 2018 @05:22AM (#16157106)
Is that a restriction? Are cargo planes typically flying at weight capacity? I thought with ecommerce, more lower-weight items are now flown.
Re:Airbus A380, Once the Future of Aviation, May Cease Produ... by ubernostrum on Tuesday January 16, 2018 @06:17AM (#16157367)
The A380's maximum takeoff weight is 575,000kg, compared to 447,700kg for a 747-8 freighter. However, the A380 -- sitting empty on the ground -- weighs 80,000kg more to begin with, and also requires more fuel (because of its greater mass).

The result is that the useful payload of an A380 is lower than a 747-8F (about 84,000kg versus 132,000kg).

And that's without getting into the other issues, like the A380's structural middle-deck (which can't be removed to turn the interior into a giant cargo hold) or inability to have its nose turned into a large cargo door like a 747 (the A380's flight deck is too low to the ground, in order to maintain training compatibility with the A330 and A340).

Re:Airbus A380, Once the Future of Aviation, May Cease Produ... by ubernostrum on Tuesday January 16, 2018 @06:11AM (#16157342)
Isn't A350 the competitor to Dreamliner?

No. The A350 and 787 both use composite materials, and that's the end of the similarities; they're planes of different size classes, designed for different market niches.

The A350 is a competitor for the 777; both planes are designed for high-demand long-haul routes.

Airbus currently does not have a competitor for the 787, which is designed for medium-demand long- to ultra-long-haul routes.

Or in other words: an A350 or 777 is what you fly between two major top-tier cities with lots of passenger demand. Think of routes like Hong Kong to San Francisco (which is routinely flown by... A350s and 777s). A 787 is what you fly between places that are far apart, but don't have quite so much demand.

This is important because the 787 has opened up the possibility of flying routes airlines wouldn't have considered before, while the A350 just plops into existing routes easily. The 787 was basically single-handedly responsible for the return of trans-Pacific flights to San Jose, for example, and Qantas is about to launch nonstop(!) service from Perth to London on a 787.

Re:Airbus A380, Once the Future of Aviation, May Cease Produ... by mulmen on Monday January 15, 2018 @04:54PM (#16153778)
The 380 and the 747 really aren't comparable and the 380 didn't replace the 747. 747 is widely used for cargo routes for example. The 380 was Airbus saying they think there is a market for a jet significantly larger than the 747. Boeing didn't think there was enough market for two superjumbos so they just added a bit to the 747 instead of designing a whole new 380 competitor.
Re:Airbus A380, Once the Future of Aviation, May Cease Produ... by InTheArena on Monday January 15, 2018 @05:59PM (#16154215)
The A350 is more of a competitor to the 777 (it's base configuration is larger then the base configuration then the 787). It basically is in the space between the 777 and the 787.

However, it does compete with the a380. Every time you see a seat on a flight between Denver and Narita, realize that it's a seat that isn't on a A380 flying between San Fransisco or LAX and Japan.

Re:Airbus A380, Once the Future of Aviation, May Cease Produ... by aceinaday on Monday January 15, 2018 @03:48PM (#16153301)
Listened to the American Airlines CEO talk about the hub and spoke a couple months ago and they seem pretty committed to it. He was saying that if there was an obvious market for a direct flight, they would break the hub and spoke, but otherwise, it was there to say.
Re:Airbus A380, Once the Future of Aviation, May Cease Produ... by ghaff on Monday January 15, 2018 @03:59PM (#16153397)
It's probably more accurate to say that airlines have tended to move toward more and often smaller hubs augmented by some point to point flights than that they're abandoning hub and spoke entirely.
Re:Airbus A380, Once the Future of Aviation, May Cease Produ... by jrs235 on Monday January 15, 2018 @04:04PM (#16153429)
Hub and spoke allows the airlines to keep costs down by using smaller airplanes for the spoke routes which can be contracted out to smaller regional airlines that pay their pilots peanuts.
Re:Airbus A380, Once the Future of Aviation, May Cease Produ... by rurban on Monday January 15, 2018 @05:33PM (#16154054)
But this is also the Dubai business model. Nobody wants to stay there, it's just a convenient stop. With more direct flights Dubai will also die.

Also the EU is strongly behind this project. This is more than just Airbus or Emirates.

So I see no death of the A380, even if the market moved on since.

Re:Airbus A380, Once the Future of Aviation, May Cease Produ... by dx034 on Tuesday January 16, 2018 @05:23AM (#16157109)
Dubai won't die but the region won't need 3 super-hubs anymore (DOH, DXB, AUH).
Re:Airbus A380, Once the Future of Aviation, May Cease Produ... by thaumasiotes on Tuesday January 16, 2018 @02:07AM (#16156360)
> People hate layovers, they want more direct flights.

But the fact that people hate layovers is a tool that airlines use for price discrimination. I just searched priceline.com for one-way flights to PVG on February 20. SFO to PVG nonstop is $640 and up. LAX to PVG with a layover in SFO is $594.

Re:Airbus A380, Once the Future of Aviation, May Cease Produ... by princeb on Monday January 15, 2018 @11:15PM (#16155778)
>People hate layovers, they want more direct flights.

still waiting for direct sin-jfk or syd-lhr.

none exist.

SIN-EWR used to exist, but it was too costly to run.

edit: the new a350-900 ULR delivering this year is capable of flying long distance, so we'll see some of these flights reappear, esp now that fuel is cheap again.

Re:Airbus A380, Once the Future of Aviation, May Cease Produ... by dx034 on Tuesday January 16, 2018 @05:19AM (#16157095)
SYD-LHR will come as soon as technically possible. It'll be a 20h flight but can probably mostly be filled with business and premium eco. The yield on that route would be high enough to justify it (SIN-EWR was only so costly because the plane wasn't built for the distance).
Re:Airbus A380, Once the Future of Aviation, May Cease Produ... by stephen_g on Tuesday January 16, 2018 @03:33AM (#16156636)
Qantas announced last year that they're interested in flying direct to London and some other European cities from the eastern states of Australia. They're still waiting for a plane that can economically I think. A variant of the 777X might be an option.

https://www.sbs.com.au/news/qantas-eyes-sydney-to-london-dir...

Re:Airbus A380, Once the Future of Aviation, May Cease Produ... by dmead on Monday January 15, 2018 @04:56PM (#16153789)
Can you clarify why it serves the hub and spoke model?
Re:Airbus A380, Once the Future of Aviation, May Cease Produ... by wlesieutre on Monday January 15, 2018 @05:03PM (#16153832)
The only routes with enough people to fill an A380 are from one hub to another.

If you flew Buffalo to Chicago to Denver to Colorado Springs, the Chicago to Denver leg could be on an A380 combined with people on tons of other itineraries that use the same hub-to-hub connection.

But airlines are moving toward more small flights that just get you from one place to another without routing through the same central points. Maybe you'd fly direct, or maybe you'd fly to Chicago and then straight to Colorado Springs without going through Denver. Without the hub/spoke model there's no individual flight with so many people on it.

Re:Airbus A380, Once the Future of Aviation, May Cease Produ... by bluGill on Tuesday January 16, 2018 @12:00PM (#16159701)
Even when a hub->hub flight is that full it might make sense to run two smaller planes. People who arrive a little earlier get the earlier flight and get there sooner. If there is mechanical problems at least half the customers get there (probably more than half as you can fill empty seats) and are happy. If not enough people buy tickets one day you park a plane and fly a full plane instead of a half full one.
Re:Airbus A380, Once the Future of Aviation, May Cease Produ... by jsjohnst on Tuesday January 16, 2018 @11:23AM (#16159305)
Chicago - Denver is too short a flight to justify an A380 even if it’s full. Nothing short of NYC to SF or NYC to LAX would likely be justified.
Re:Airbus A380, Once the Future of Aviation, May Cease Produ... by chrisper on Monday January 15, 2018 @03:55PM (#16153362)
You have to admit that it was a gamble though.