News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Mickey Mouse’s 1998 copyright extension probably won’... by shirian on Tuesday January 09, 2018 @07:14AM (#16105565)
To be fair, the life expectancy of people keeps increasing.
Re:Why Mickey Mouse’s 1998 copyright extension probably won’... by kenny_r on Tuesday January 09, 2018 @07:16AM (#16105578)
I don't think anyone will ever live for another 70 years after their death.
Re:Why Mickey Mouse’s 1998 copyright extension probably won’... by shirian on Tuesday January 09, 2018 @02:11PM (#16108823)
You are quite right. I apologize for misremembering the copyright laws.
Re:Why Mickey Mouse’s 1998 copyright extension probably won’... by Joeboy on Tuesday January 09, 2018 @07:25AM (#16105630)
Sure, and nobody will ever need more than 640k of RAM either.
Re:Why Mickey Mouse’s 1998 copyright extension probably won’... by loup-vaillant on Tuesday January 09, 2018 @08:00AM (#16105819)
Current copyright duration in the US is "life + 70 years".

Nobody is alive after their death, because, well… they're dead.

Re:Why Mickey Mouse’s 1998 copyright extension probably won’... by Joeboy on Tuesday January 09, 2018 @08:12AM (#16105878)
In my head, I was making a clever remark that succinctly poked fun at HN discussions, Bill Gates, transhumanism and the difficulties of futurology. I may have been overly-optimistic.
Re:Why Mickey Mouse’s 1998 copyright extension probably won’... by loup-vaillant on Tuesday January 09, 2018 @08:34AM (#16105984)
Ah. Ok. Sorry. This may have worked with behavioural cues such as voice inflexion and body language.
Re:Why Mickey Mouse’s 1998 copyright extension probably won’... by joelthelion on Tuesday January 09, 2018 @08:44AM (#16106053)
If that makes you feel any better, I wanted to make the same joke as you :)
Re:Why Mickey Mouse’s 1998 copyright extension probably won’... by Joeboy on Tuesday January 09, 2018 @10:00AM (#16106583)
It was actually a great joke, the world just wasn't ready for it :-(
Re:Why Mickey Mouse’s 1998 copyright extension probably won’... by bmm6o on Tuesday January 09, 2018 @12:58PM (#16108154)
You can profit from it for up to 70 years after your death. The world will be ready by then.
Re:Why Mickey Mouse’s 1998 copyright extension probably won’... by thinkMOAR on Tuesday January 09, 2018 @08:06AM (#16105841)
I don't know, after seeing "Be Right Back" episode of Black Mirror (episode 1 season 2), get really close to living after your death.
Re:Why Mickey Mouse’s 1998 copyright extension probably won’... by loup-vaillant on Tuesday January 09, 2018 @08:35AM (#16105993)
Watch "San Junipero" (season 3). (Also, please don't spoil it, everyone.)
Re:Why Mickey Mouse’s 1998 copyright extension probably won’... by thinkMOAR on Tuesday January 09, 2018 @08:43AM (#16106046)
Oh that's why i get all these down votes i apparently spoiled it. Sorry about that, kind of assumed everybody saw it already lol

All seasons watched here, great series.

Re:Why Mickey Mouse’s 1998 copyright extension probably won’... by PurpleRamen on Tuesday January 09, 2018 @08:00AM (#16105816)
No, but children and grandchildren might live on after their dead. Copyright after death is mainly for heritage-reasons, to close the gap to families who inherit valuable physical objects or land owning-rights.
Re:Why Mickey Mouse’s 1998 copyright extension probably won’... by josteink on Tuesday January 09, 2018 @08:24AM (#16105939)
So your parents made stuff which due to a legal monopoly they were able to earn money and property from.

Not only are you to inherit the money and property they earned. You are also to inherit the right to further make new money from this legal monopoly on something you have done nothing for at all.

Sounds reasonable to me.

Re:Why Mickey Mouse’s 1998 copyright extension probably won’... by dalbasal on Tuesday January 09, 2018 @09:58AM (#16106570)
Well.... the whole premise is that copyright is a type of property, or that it should be. You could replace "legal monopoly" with "property rights" and it works equally well for both songs and buildings. You are only able to collect rent for a building because exclusive property rights give you the .. erm.. right to allow or deny(exclude) use of the property . This could also be called "legal monopoly" though not in the more modern antitrust influenced sense of the term.

I don't really have a problem with copyright being a "made up" legal fiction. A lot of things are fictions made "real" by laws, customs and such.

The questions (IMO) shouldn't be around what is real or not, based on some abstract reasoning. It should be about what is beneficial, practically, in our time.

Anyway, I think we need to rethink patents and copyright entirely. For patents, it isn't entirely clear they work as intended (incentivising innovation). The downsides, at least, seem more visible now than before.

Copyrights in the digital age.... It's just a completely different thing. A book or song or whatnot needed to be published regardless of copyright. Print costs, retail, etc. The only difference was royalties. The difference between a public domain and copyrighted work now is much bigger. Free means flexible, accessible, obscurity tolerant... For a lot of works, copyright by default is like burning the only copy.

Combining and reworking is also different in this age.

Re:Why Mickey Mouse’s 1998 copyright extension probably won’... by marcosdumay on Tuesday January 09, 2018 @10:15AM (#16106686)
You know, I have no problem with treating copyrights as a type of property. That means it must be registered and taxed in proportion to its value. It may be a better situation than both always short lived duration and the taxed by increased amounts options.
Re:Why Mickey Mouse’s 1998 copyright extension probably won’... by dalbasal on Tuesday January 09, 2018 @10:33AM (#16106861)
Most property isn't taxed, in most places. The big exception is land/real estate, which is sometimes taxed.

For copyright, part of the problem is that most copyright is valueless in many senses (including financial). No one is making money off it. No one is reading/watching it. It's like art in a vault. Freeing the works would allow people to access them. Free as in liberty, as well as beer. The two are related, often.

Re:Why Mickey Mouse’s 1998 copyright extension probably won’... by rayiner on Tuesday January 09, 2018 @09:34AM (#16106393)
Your description applies precisely to a farm or vacation property too. And at least a copyrighted work is something that exists in the universe due to your parent’s effort. That farm is just some land that your parent’s predecessor stole from the Indians. The government helped someone enclose land that had not existed as private property before, helped defend it by driving out the Indians, and then gave legal protection to the chain of transactions that led to you inheriting it. That’s a government monopoly as much as any copyright.
Re:Why Mickey Mouse’s 1998 copyright extension probably won’... by throwaway2048 on Tuesday January 09, 2018 @09:37AM (#16106413)
I think thats too general of a statement, plenty of people take issue with inherited wealth. The USA for a long time had extremely steep inheritance taxes for instance.
Re:Why Mickey Mouse’s 1998 copyright extension probably won’... by simonh on Tuesday January 09, 2018 @08:33AM (#16105980)
So if I create a work and die the day it’s published, my heirs should get nothing. How reasonable does that sound?
Re:Why Mickey Mouse’s 1998 copyright extension probably won’... by bonesss on Tuesday January 09, 2018 @08:59AM (#16106148)
It sounds unreasonable.

That said, the idea that your "life" has any role in this whatsoever is also unreasonable.

Copyright should last X years. If the author dies, X is still X, and if the author lives then X is still X.

This maintains the incentives, despite terminal illnesses, while also preserving the rights of the greater society to reflect on its own culture and encourage new artistic works. It's also how copyright originally worked (IIRC).

Re:Why Mickey Mouse’s 1998 copyright extension probably won’... by logfromblammo on Tuesday January 09, 2018 @11:29AM (#16107322)
My own perception of fair would be that copyright expires 25 years after creation, or 20 years after publication, whichever comes first. If any of the creators are alive at that time and still own the copyright, they may extend by 10 years if no other creator objects.

If you create a copyrightable work and die the next day, and your executor manages to get it published the next year, your estate owns the copyrights for the next 20. That is enough time for any child sired by a male author on the day he died to be supported by his estate until it becomes an adult. It also provides a reasonable 5 year window to get something published before later publication is punished by a shortened copyright term. Still-living creators will, of course, be able to deny that a work was actually finished--and therefore started the 25-year clock--until just before the day the first copy is made available for sale--which starts the 20-year clock--so that would pretty much just be enforceable on posthumous publications and on bizarre edicts from eccentric or reclusive creators who try to exert too much control over how other people may enjoy their work.

And it allows for a work still profitable after 20 years to squeeze a little more out. I think the extension may encourage corporations that commission works for hire to support their successful creators for 20 years so that they will not object to the extension.

Works-for-hire, by the way, would have all the individual humans and the corporation as the creators, and the default would be tenancy-in-common, with the humans temporarily assigning their interest to the corporation in exchange for a regular salary. (I think the current works-for-hire system encourages immortal corporations to use up and throw away their human talent.) So if the corporation stops making the payments, the creators regain their full interest in the work, according to the size of their contribution defined by the work-for-hire agreement, if one exists, or an equal share if not. So the only reason to fire a creator would be if the profits from the works they create aren't sufficient to pay their salary, at which time they get their (lesser) share of the profits instead.

A session musician, for instance, might be hired by a record label to get a 4% share of every recorded music track, and assign that interest to the company in exchange for salary of $1200 every week working in the home studio and $1800 every week spent touring. If the tracks that musician played on bring in more than $2.34M, the company should keep them as salaried employees indefinitely. Otherwise, they could fire them as an employee and just pay out their 4% until the copyright term runs out.

Re:Why Mickey Mouse’s 1998 copyright extension probably won’... by consp on Tuesday January 09, 2018 @09:12AM (#16106243)
Pretty reasonable but inaccurate:

You sign a publishing contract with a publisher, you (and your estate so your kids) collect money from that. After the contract ends it's done. Which is reasonable in my opinion. If I die, my kids don't get my monthly payment anyway.

Since other publishers do not have the manuscript, they can take the book and write it over completely to their own publishing house but due to market lag they it's too little, to late. And if you are wondering, digital reproductions usually fall under the same rights as reproductions (e.g. playing Beethoven, you cannot reproduce that specific work while the author has been dead for years).

Re:Why Mickey Mouse’s 1998 copyright extension probably won’... by jrimbault on Tuesday January 09, 2018 @08:41AM (#16106032)
On the other hand, if I kill someone right before I die myself (from "natural causes"), will my heirs be criminals ?

Sounds reasonnable ?

Re:Why Mickey Mouse’s 1998 copyright extension probably won’... by yathern on Tuesday January 09, 2018 @09:02AM (#16106174)
There's no reason that inheriting wealth means you must also inherit crimes. Just because they are related concepts doesn't make them have to both be reasonable or unreasonable together.

Inheriting wealth is reasonable because gives people a(nother) reason to contribute to the world - to secure a place for their children in a potentially uncertain future. Parents who have spent a large portion of their life caring and provisioning for there children want to see that they have a level of security when gone.

Inheriting crime is unreasonable for, hopefully, obvious reasons.

Luckily, we don't have to throw the baby out with the bathwater.

Re:Why Mickey Mouse’s 1998 copyright extension probably won’... by sleepychu on Tuesday January 09, 2018 @09:00AM (#16106163)
Right but if you kill someone and stay living your heirs are not criminals either.

If you create the next billion dollar game and survive your heirs (or those you specify in your will) will surely be enriched, perhaps it should be 70 years alive or dead that copyright persists for.

Re:Why Mickey Mouse’s 1998 copyright extension probably won’... by jrimbault on Tuesday January 09, 2018 @09:13AM (#16106250)
> perhaps it should be 70 years alive or dead

I agree

Re:Why Mickey Mouse’s 1998 copyright extension probably won’... by jackvalentine on Tuesday January 09, 2018 @08:40AM (#16106027)
Sounds reasonable to me.

But I sense you and I won’t agree there so why don’t we compromise with 1 year exclusive rights for heirs after the author’s death?

Re:Why Mickey Mouse’s 1998 copyright extension probably won’... by matte_black on Tuesday January 09, 2018 @08:51AM (#16106100)
How about if the work is never published while you’re alive, but then your heirs publish it. They get lifetime rights now?
Re:Why Mickey Mouse’s 1998 copyright extension probably won’... by jcranmer on Tuesday January 09, 2018 @09:05AM (#16106194)
Nope. They get 70 years from your death. Since 1976, copyright ticks from the date the work was created, not the date it was published. That's also why it changed from a fixed period (X years after publication) to life + so many years (X years after death of the author).
Re:Why Mickey Mouse’s 1998 copyright extension probably won’... by bringtheaction on Tuesday January 09, 2018 @09:20AM (#16106300)
It would be 70 years after the author died. Here, read this:

> Often when and how a copyright owner registers a copyrighted work will depend on whether that work is published or unpublished because the requirements for registration differ slightly depending on whether the work is considered to be published or unpublished under the law. The “under the law” phrase is important here because what the normal person might consider to be published does not necessarily correspond to the Copyright Office’s definition of the term. Moreover, sometimes even knowing these definitions doesn’t help because there is some ambiguity in the term and how it applies to new digital environments. So this is one area to proceed with caution.

> The Copyright Office’s definition of published includes: the distribution of copies of a work to “the public by sale or other transfer of ownership, or by rental, lease, or lending” or offering to distribute copies … “to a group of persons for purposes of further distribution, public performance, or public display, constitutes publication.” A public performance or display of a work does not by itself constitute publication.

> In the online environment this gets confusing. For example, a blog post or a photo posted on a website might be considered to be a “distribution of copies,” which would mean it’s a published work under the definition or it could be a “public display,” which would mean it’s unpublished.

http://copyrightalliance.org/education/copyright-law-explain...

Re:Why Mickey Mouse’s 1998 copyright extension probably won’... by jackvalentine on Tuesday January 09, 2018 @05:57PM (#16110986)
No why would they? They're not the author in my scenario.
Re:Why Mickey Mouse’s 1998 copyright extension probably won’... by perfmode on Tuesday January 09, 2018 @08:45AM (#16106063)
The purpose of the regulation is to promote creation. People will create regardless of whether their children can inherit it.
Re:Why Mickey Mouse’s 1998 copyright extension probably won’... by remedan on Tuesday January 09, 2018 @09:00AM (#16106158)
I think a fair system would be X years after publication.

* If you die X+1 years after, your kids get nothing.

* If you die the day it's published, your kids get X-1 day.

* If your kids discover it after your death and publish it, they get the whole X years.

Around 40 years seems like a reasonable value for X, in my opinion.

Re:Why Mickey Mouse’s 1998 copyright extension probably won’... by onion2k on Tuesday January 09, 2018 @09:14AM (#16106263)
It sounds completely reasonable. The work should move in to the public domain. Then everyone benefits, including your heirs.
Re:Why Mickey Mouse’s 1998 copyright extension probably won’... by kohanz on Tuesday January 09, 2018 @08:57AM (#16106132)
It's there to incentivize. If you acknowledge that copyright exists to incentivize a 20-year old with possible monetary gains, then what incentivizes a 60 or 70 year old to create? Why should they be incentivized less?
Re:Why Mickey Mouse’s 1998 copyright extension probably won’... by macintux on Tuesday January 09, 2018 @08:59AM (#16106149)
When you're 60+, you either still need to make money (life is expensive) or you're creating because you want to. Creating so that your grandchildren can keep making money 50 years from now doesn't seem like a strong motivation.
Re:Why Mickey Mouse’s 1998 copyright extension probably won’... by kohanz on Tuesday January 09, 2018 @09:03AM (#16106176)
Legacy and providing for your offspring is a huge motivation for many people. It's interwoven through all aspects of our society. Why should it be ignored here? To say it's not a "strong" motivation for older people misses the mark, IMHO. It may not be a motivation for you (at this point in your life, or forever), but that doesn't mean it's not a significant factor.

Again, you're essentially saying that older people don't need as much incentive as younger people to create, which I don't necessarily agree with.

Re:Why Mickey Mouse’s 1998 copyright extension probably won’... by soundwave106 on Tuesday January 09, 2018 @10:31AM (#16106837)
Plenty of economists have negative views about inherited wealth, and the negative sociological and economic effects of inheritance inequality that result. Copyright goes beyond wealth -- it is a defacto monopoly on creative work that the public cannot benefit from without paying someone for the privilege of usage.

Although you are taking the "family" viewpoint, the reality is that copyright more atypically tends to be shuffled around and bought up by large rent-seekers corporations. Many times, the original artist's descendants don't even make a penny. Example: Before invalidated in 2015, who benefited from the strange copyright on "Happy Birthday"? Was it the ancestors of the originators (Mildred J. Hill at the most direct, but probably with several other hands involved before it morphed into its familiar form)? No, it was Warner/Chappell Music.

To me, it would be very hard to argue that the benefits of extended copyright at this point. It's a form of rent-seeking, an activity many economists have problems with. (It was actually pretty easy to find an economist -- a Nobel winner -- blasting rent-seeking. Nobel winner Angus Daton did so here for instance around the 30 minute mark -- https://www.c-span.org/video/?424924-5/national-association-.... It was more in the context of our broken health care system, but similar issues apply with government-sanctioned monopolies of creative works.)

Re:Why Mickey Mouse’s 1998 copyright extension probably won’... by namarie on Tuesday January 09, 2018 @10:12AM (#16106674)
Then people should save money they made from their works and pass it to their children. I've never heard of someone continuing to work after their death to provide for their children, which is what the current copyright system basically amounts to.
Re:Why Mickey Mouse’s 1998 copyright extension probably won’... by kohanz on Wednesday January 10, 2018 @03:05PM (#16118507)
What about passing on an income generating asset (real estate, dividend portfolio) to children?
Re:Why Mickey Mouse’s 1998 copyright extension probably won’... by namarie on Saturday January 13, 2018 @02:53PM (#16140995)
I think it should be at least heavily taxed and wouldn't be very much opposed to it not actually passing down.
Re:Why Mickey Mouse’s 1998 copyright extension probably won’... by davidgh on Tuesday January 09, 2018 @09:44AM (#16106453)
The argument against copyright sounds too simplistic to me.

A lot of things that are subject to copyright are not as simple as scratching out a poem on a rainy afternoon.

If I was to spend my resources to design and build a building, most reasonable people would not argue that my estate should be forced to give up its rights to the building when I die. There may be an estate tax, but the estate can choose to keep the building and its income, decide to sell it, or whatever. Seems logical. In fact, the very reason I may have deployed my resources into a building was because it would outlast me and provide economic benefits to those I love after I die.

Are not many (if not most) works subject to copyright just another type of developed asset, like a building? Sure, there are no sticks and bricks, but valuable time, resources and money went into developing the asset. Is that irrelevant because the developed asset is intellectual rather than tangible? Should my estate be denied of benefits based on the type of asset I spent my time and resources creating?

As a society, we have decided to limit the scope in which certain works are protected, for the greater good. I support this. But to abolish copyright or to truncate benefits based on death of the creator doesn’t seem to make economic sense to me.

Re:Why Mickey Mouse’s 1998 copyright extension probably won’... by jack9 on Tuesday January 09, 2018 @10:11AM (#16106664)
> Is that irrelevant because the developed asset is intellectual rather than tangible?

Copyright has a sort of enthalpy (an appreciation) that grows into new forms of protections with socio-techno changes increasing the value, as opposed to a depreciation. The value is also appreciated by how much it's already been used to make! (e.g. Star Wars) Without physical entropy, like a building, you have a very different economic mechanism. The benefit to the originator's estate is not the single determining factor. Copyright is bad, in the current form. A simple depreciation factor would be far superior to the copyright expiry.

Re:Why Mickey Mouse’s 1998 copyright extension probably won’... by brianwawok on Tuesday January 09, 2018 @09:03AM (#16106183)
"I was gonna write this world changing poem, but then I realized my kids wouldn't get payments for 70 years after I died so I just took a nap instead"
Re:Why Mickey Mouse’s 1998 copyright extension probably won’... by kohanz on Tuesday January 09, 2018 @09:23AM (#16106318)
"I was gonna write a world changing poem, and thank goodness I'm young and will make $ off of it for decades"

That's a perfectly fine motivation, from my point of view, but I'm contrasting it against yours, because why are we expecting older people to have more altruistic motivations than young people?

(poetry is a poor example because it's not very lucrative in general)

Re:Why Mickey Mouse’s 1998 copyright extension probably won’... by icebraining on Tuesday January 09, 2018 @09:05AM (#16106192)
They're still being incentivized less, since they'll live fewer years and copyright is tied to their life. You'd need a fixed term - like the US had originally - to incentivize both equally.
Re:Why Mickey Mouse’s 1998 copyright extension probably won’... by kohanz on Tuesday January 09, 2018 @09:21AM (#16106307)
True, but the difference would be significantly smaller than the proposal to have copyright end with death of the creator.
Re:Why Mickey Mouse’s 1998 copyright extension probably won’... by guelo on Tuesday January 09, 2018 @08:11AM (#16105867)
And incentivize other children to have dead parents who created financially successful copyrighted works.
Re:Why Mickey Mouse’s 1998 copyright extension probably won’... by contras1970 on Tuesday January 09, 2018 @08:46AM (#16106076)
won't somebody think of plumbers' children? they should be entitled to some money every time we flush! they won't plumb any more toilets otherwise!

and what about carpenters? they won't do squat if we don't grant them perpetual payments for the houses they once built.

same with tailors. they're entitled to fees every time we wear our clothes...

i mean, the incentive argument is so transparently bogus my mind boggles.

Re:Why Mickey Mouse’s 1998 copyright extension probably won’... by oblio on Tuesday January 09, 2018 @08:32AM (#16105976)
I'd agree with guelo. Kids, maybe OK. But grand kids? And especially 70 years after the death? At that point in most common scenarios we're talking about the 3rd or 4th generation of descendants.

My grand-grand children should just get off their lazy bums and go work :p

Re:Why Mickey Mouse’s 1998 copyright extension probably won’... by JohnTHaller on Tuesday January 09, 2018 @09:55AM (#16106540)
Copyright at its current length is for corporate reasons.
Re:Why Mickey Mouse’s 1998 copyright extension probably won’... by Xylakant on Tuesday January 09, 2018 @07:16AM (#16105580)
And the death expectancy keeps dropping. How can you make a fortune if you have less and less time to be dead until the ein of the universe?
Re:Why Mickey Mouse’s 1998 copyright extension probably won’... by raverbashing on Tuesday January 09, 2018 @07:24AM (#16105621)
Still 100% I'm afraid
Re:Why Mickey Mouse’s 1998 copyright extension probably won’... by UncleEntity on Tuesday January 09, 2018 @07:17AM (#16105589)
> To be fair, the life expectancy of people keeps increasing.

Oh, that's why it's "life plus" so many years...

Re:Why Mickey Mouse’s 1998 copyright extension probably won’... by crankylinuxuser on Tuesday January 09, 2018 @07:20AM (#16105603)
The reason why it was "life plus X years" was to provide a means for the family if the creator had an untimely death. After all the logic is that the world has their creation, and compensation shouldn't be snuffed out simply cause (s)he died early.
Re:Why Mickey Mouse’s 1998 copyright extension probably won’... by grey-area on Tuesday January 09, 2018 @07:24AM (#16105617)
The reason why it was "life plus X years" was to provide a means for the family if the creator had an untimely death.

While that was the ostensible reason, corporations who have had rights assigned to them want to milk those rights after the author's death, indeed often the creator's death is a catalyst for higher sales, which will usually go mostly to the publisher/media conglomerate, not their family.

Re:Why Mickey Mouse’s 1998 copyright extension probably won’... by noxToken on Tuesday January 09, 2018 @08:35AM (#16105986)
I always wonder how low the IP for Mickey will sink when that copyright expires. Disney can usually produce good enough content with Mickey including some games (Kingdom Hearts series) and animation for kids. It might not hit the mark for everyone, but I think Disney prides itself on never producing shovelware - even if the content is bland.

Imagine the App/Play Store (or whatever exists then) once it expires though. If you thought the Flappy Bird spam was bad...

Re:Why Mickey Mouse’s 1998 copyright extension probably won’... by berbec on Tuesday January 09, 2018 @08:56AM (#16106124)
IANAL - but Mickey Mouse will continue to be protected as a trademark of the Disney company even after Steamboat Willie expires.
Re:Why Mickey Mouse’s 1998 copyright extension probably won’... by dragonwriter on Tuesday January 09, 2018 @09:21AM (#16106302)
> The reason why it was "life plus X years" was to provide a means for the family if the creator had an untimely death.

Doesn't make any sense; a fixed term copyright as is used for corporate-author works (currently 90 years) does that just as well.

All a “Life plus X” term for, in terms of expected to benefit, is give decreasing expected copyright term as your age increases (well, as remaining life expectancy given known facts decreases, more precisely.)

I suspect “Life plus” was more about eliminating disputes about creation date for individually-authored works that aren't immediately published, not about what it provides to author’s families. With a “Life plus” term, creation dates become immaterial in computing the end of the copyright term, if you know who the author is then, once their death date is known, expiration of all copyrights is known even if the exact creation date of some works is not known.

Re:Why Mickey Mouse’s 1998 copyright extension probably won’... by Joeboy on Tuesday January 09, 2018 @07:42AM (#16105727)
I get that if somebody's partner dies an untimely death it's unkind to simultaneously remove their family income, but 70 years seems like a ridiculously long buffer.
Re:Why Mickey Mouse’s 1998 copyright extension probably won’... by tialaramex on Tuesday January 09, 2018 @08:18AM (#16105914)
When these rules were invented, the ostensible concern really was about destitute artist families.

Today it's just an excuse, wheel out Jimmy and have him say about how his grandfather just wanted to do right by the kids and imply that people using Jim's granddad's story idea now it's entering the public domain are "stealing" from him and this is an outrage.

Copyright is by its nature rent-seeking, you get income from owning something, and not by actually contributing anything of value. Even in the rare cases where it really _does_ keep some artist's recently bereaved family out of poverty we ought to be asking why aren't we keeping _everybody_ out of poverty?

The original argument tried to justify this rent-seeking by saying we are getting something from it, these brilliant ideas might never get published if Copyright doesn't ensure there's a reward. And if they're not published we'd never know about them, you can't riff on Mickey if nobody has ever seen a Mickey Mouse cartoon. And you know what, I don't agree but if the bargain had stuck at 28 years I'd hold my nose. But of course it didn't. We managed to get _Big Pharma_ to put up with a genuinely limited exclusivity period for their drugs, and a world where generic medicines not only exist but thrive - yet somehow Big Content got extension after extension for some guy's idea for a cartoon mouse (among many other things).

Re:Why Mickey Mouse’s 1998 copyright extension probably won’... by crankylinuxuser on Tuesday January 09, 2018 @08:26AM (#16105947)
That is true, initially with extensions past the creator's death. But as you also point out, it is very much rent seeking behavior by companies.

However to understand why we even have copyright, you have to know your renaissance European history. Prior to copyright/patents, you had the guild system. Knowledge was hidden, obfuscated, and destroyed. Those whom wanted to share the secrets of the guild were imprisoned and/or killed.

Fast-forward to the creation of the USA - most of the people here were second sons whom had little to no claims on European riches. They also knew of the guilds, and the danger they have. So, they posited copyright, trademark, and patent. It wasn't cause they were the best tools, but they were better than the guilds that preceded them.

It's about time we revisit the idea of copyright, patent, and trademark and how they apply in the 21'st century.

Re:Why Mickey Mouse’s 1998 copyright extension probably won’... by angus-prune on Tuesday January 09, 2018 @09:10AM (#16106234)
Your IP history is wrong.

Patents originated in 15th Century Venice and Copyright in 17th Century Britain and trademarks in France in the (iirc) 19th Century.

Patents were, indeed, a way to encourage people to share their inventions rather than keep them as trade secrets, but this doesn't apply to copyright (rampant book piracy after the invention of the printing press) or trademark (consumer protection and counterfitting).

I have never heard of any link the the USA or second sons etc, and the way these laws developed doesn't support your hypothesis.

Absolutely with you that these things need modernising though (and not in a Digital Millenium way)

Re:Why Mickey Mouse’s 1998 copyright extension probably won’... by tialaramex on Tuesday January 09, 2018 @11:12AM (#16107170)
Yup, Trademarks are fine, the insistence on muddling Trademark, Patent and Copyright together is bad mojo and people (even lawyers!) need to cut it out.

The same principle as Trademarks even pre-date the formal existence of registrable trademarks, because everybody can see that if "Jameson Beans" are considered to be good quality beans then buying some crap beans and selling them on as "Jameson Beans" is clearly not OK. English law has a tort of "passing off" which is committed when you trick customers in this way, and you can still use it for unregistered marks today, it's just harder than the Registered Trademark law.

Re:Why Mickey Mouse’s 1998 copyright extension probably won’... by contras1970 on Tuesday January 09, 2018 @08:57AM (#16106138)
copyright was a british invention to limit proliferation of "uncomfortable" works.
Re:Why Mickey Mouse’s 1998 copyright extension probably won’... by guelo on Tuesday January 09, 2018 @08:15AM (#16105888)
If I die my family doesn't keep getting my paycheck. The living are expected to work. Financially comfortable "heirs" are not a good that society needs to protect.
Re:Why Mickey Mouse’s 1998 copyright extension probably won’... by Joeboy on Tuesday January 09, 2018 @08:22AM (#16105929)
The reasons your family wouldn't keep getting your paycheck are practical though (you'd stop doing the work that earns your employer an income). Those reasons don't really exist in the case of "Intellectual Property", and it seems unnecessarily mean to make their loss harsh just because other people's losses are harsh. Although I think it should be more like a few years' buffer rather than a lifetime income.
Re:Why Mickey Mouse’s 1998 copyright extension probably won’... by mcny on Tuesday January 09, 2018 @08:07AM (#16105848)
> I get that if somebody's partner dies an untimely death it's unkind to simultaneously remove their family income, but 70 years seems like a ridiculously long buffer.

at the risk of sounding like a broken record, I think we can eliminate a lot of this "friction" if we have an effective basic income. I get that eliminating things like copyright could lead us back to an age where only art that people make is basically with some wealthy feudal lord's patronage but it doesn't necessarily have to be that way.

Re:Why Mickey Mouse’s 1998 copyright extension probably won’... by pimmen on Tuesday January 09, 2018 @07:17AM (#16105588)
Yeah, but post-mortem activity hasn't seen a lot of progress lately. If anything, the dead do less useful stuff beyond their life now than ever what with all these pesky laws against violating corpses.

Yes, it's sarcasm