News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Volkswagen Official Gets 7-Year Term in Diesel-Emissions ... by cies on Wednesday December 06, 2017 @07:21PM (#15866440)
Even higher-ups are replaceable. Gov'ts need to really catch the shareholders, they own the misbehaving company, and they push them so hard for profits that the workers/managers are lured into cheating the system.
Re:Volkswagen Official Gets 7-Year Term in Diesel-Emissions ... by gregw134 on Wednesday December 06, 2017 @07:58PM (#15866656)
The United States used to hold stockholders accountable back in the late 19th century, when there were many more fraudulent and poorly run industrial and railroad companies. As a result, shareholders were so afraid of liability they gave their voting power to "voting trusts" run by bankers, notably JP Morgan. The banks ended up having seats on the boards of the majority of companies in an industry and would use their position to stop companies from competing with each other (after all, competition lowers the profits of all companies in an industry, which makes it less likely they will be able to repay the debt they owe to banks). The result was we ended up with monopolies in nearly everything, from meatpacking to barbed wire to railroads...

In other words, not only would punishing shareholders be unfair and stifle investment, it might have other unintended consequences that would hurt the economy.

Re:Volkswagen Official Gets 7-Year Term in Diesel-Emissions ... by Retric on Wednesday December 06, 2017 @10:35PM (#15867436)
It still does via Fines which directly hurt shareholders. The real problem is the fines rarely add up to a significant percent of a companies liquid assets let alone value. Thus, when the penalty is vastly lower than the direct gains, it just promotes bad behavior.

Really, you need to spread the pain across every level from grunt to CEO to shareholder. With relative culpability based on influence on and benefit from such behaviors.

Re:Volkswagen Official Gets 7-Year Term in Diesel-Emissions ... by mjevans on Thursday December 07, 2017 @01:03AM (#15867963)
The limit to shareholders should be monetary (civil liability?)

It should be limited to the most recent (five?) years of profit at a maximum; but determined by the valued magnitude of the profits obtained by the infringement (multiplied by something, maybe 3-5?, for punitive effect).

Each stock should have that share of debt added to it; zero interest over time, full remainder due upon sale, and reduced by future dividends. The actual debt needn't be tracked per stock; it is sufficient to differentiate between affected and not.

Criminal liability belongs with those actively participating or criminally negligent in their oversight.

Re:Volkswagen Official Gets 7-Year Term in Diesel-Emissions ... by mcny on Wednesday December 06, 2017 @09:29PM (#15867135)
What about the CEO and the board?
Re:Volkswagen Official Gets 7-Year Term in Diesel-Emissions ... by sah2ed on Thursday December 07, 2017 @02:33AM (#15868360)
Any book(s) you could recommend to read more about this bit of history and the resulting monopolies?

Thanks.

Re:Volkswagen Official Gets 7-Year Term in Diesel-Emissions ... by gregw134 on Thursday December 07, 2017 @03:55AM (#15868635)
Yeah definitely read The Robber Barons. It covers all the major tycoons of the 19th century and their financial shenanigans. A surprisingly exciting read, full of wicked deeds. To tell one story from the book, there was a battle over a railroad where thugs hired by opposing companies got on trains at different stains and advanced towards each other. The trains collided and the soldiers jumped off and fought with clubs.

The only other book I've read about the era is The House of Morgan, which covers the history of JP Morgan bank. It's highly recommended as well. It tells a convincing tale as bankers as the good guys (gentlemen bankers), who funded Thomas Edison, the transatlantic cable, Charles Lindbergh's transatlantic flight, and who raised the funds and managed the purchases necessary to win WWI.

If anyone else has finance books to recommend I'd love to hear them.

Re:Volkswagen Official Gets 7-Year Term in Diesel-Emissions ... by GrumpyNl on Thursday December 07, 2017 @05:21AM (#15868929)
If you partially own a company you are responsible for that part.
Re:Volkswagen Official Gets 7-Year Term in Diesel-Emissions ... by throwaway613834 on Wednesday December 06, 2017 @07:26PM (#15866476)
> Even higher-ups are replaceable. Gov'ts need to really catch the shareholders, they own the misbehaving company, and they push them so hard for profits that the workers/managers are lured into cheating the system.

OK, I was with everyone saying higher-ups need to be held accountable, but now you're spewing utter nonsense. It's not like the shareholders knew what was going on. What are they going to be "held accountable" for? For being lied to by a cheating company? It's almost like going after taxpayers because they subsidized a criminal's public transportation.

Re:Volkswagen Official Gets 7-Year Term in Diesel-Emissions ... by throwawayjava on Wednesday December 06, 2017 @07:37PM (#15866534)
Also, lots of shareholders did lose big? Take a look at VOW 2014 - 2018. The price is basically just now recovering.
Re:Volkswagen Official Gets 7-Year Term in Diesel-Emissions ... by empthought on Wednesday December 06, 2017 @08:39PM (#15866877)
Not really a loss unless they had to sell in that timeframe. Earnings and dividends are a more appropriate metric for impact to shareholders.
Re:Volkswagen Official Gets 7-Year Term in Diesel-Emissions ... by beagle3 on Thursday December 07, 2017 @02:02AM (#15868248)
No, that's not really how that works.

They have had a loss, which they may or may not have felt (e.g. if they had to sell, they most certainly did; If those shares were collateral, which is extremely common, they most certainly did). And then there was a gain, which they only had if they did not have to sell.

There's also the issue of opportunity cost.

Really, the only way economics make sense is if you assume that everything is valued at its real value at any time -- not just when it changes hands.

Re:Volkswagen Official Gets 7-Year Term in Diesel-Emissions ... by empthought on Thursday December 07, 2017 @05:26PM (#15874950)
> Really, the only way economics make sense is if you assume that everything is valued at its real value at any time -- not just when it changes hands.

“When the price of a stock can be influenced by a "herd" on Wall Street with prices set at the margin by the most emotional person, or the greediest person, or the most depressed person, it is hard to argue that the market always prices rationally. In fact, market prices are frequently nonsensical.”

“Ships will sail around the world but the Flat Earth Society will flourish. There will continue to be wide discrepancies between price and value in the marketplace, and those who read their Graham & Dodd will continue to prosper.” — Warren Buffett

Re:Volkswagen Official Gets 7-Year Term in Diesel-Emissions ... by beagle3 on Friday December 08, 2017 @02:54AM (#15877358)
It would be great to recite that as response when you get a margin call. But your broker is still going to seize your collateral based on its price, not value.
Re:Volkswagen Official Gets 7-Year Term in Diesel-Emissions ... by empthought on Friday December 08, 2017 @06:18AM (#15878021)
I thought we were talking about shareholders, not speculators.

Your premise of "the only way economics make sense is if you assume that everything is valued at its real value at any time -- not just when it changes hands" is absurd on its face; one only need look back nine or ten years for confirmation of this. If what you say were true, Bear Stearns would still exist, and you would have to claim that those real estate hedge funds were at their "real value" both in 2006 and in 2007 even though the latter was pennies on the dollar. Is it any comfort to say, "well, that stock collapsed but I at least I bought it at its 'real value' that it had up until yesterday?"

Unless your point is that economics cannot possibly make any sense, I suppose.

Re:Volkswagen Official Gets 7-Year Term in Diesel-Emissions ... by beagle3 on Saturday December 09, 2017 @03:24AM (#15884872)
Speculators are shareholders.

Bear stearns had pledged 104% of their capital. They weren’t the only one in such a condition, and in this sense it is unfair, but the closing down was justified.

The law was changed from “mark to market” (the standard evaluation for decades) to “Mark to fantasy” specifically so that many bankruptcies would not need to be declared - but without a $700B injection at the time, many more would have happened.

You cannot have consistent book keeping if two entities can book the same item at the same time for materially different values at the same time. It is as simple as that.

Re:Volkswagen Official Gets 7-Year Term in Diesel-Emissions ... by throwaway613834 on Thursday December 07, 2017 @04:57AM (#15868845)
> Really, the only way economics make sense is if you assume that everything is valued at its real value at any time -- not just when it changes hands.

Why? The other way seems to make sense to me.

Re:Volkswagen Official Gets 7-Year Term in Diesel-Emissions ... by beagle3 on Thursday December 07, 2017 @07:16AM (#15869400)
It only makes sense if you have complete information about every market participant, their plans, liabilities, obligation, etc.

If I had VW stock that I had to sell in between to pay my down payment, i most definitely have lost, regardless of it going up later. If I used my VW stock as collateral for something else, I would have had much less collateral to pledge.

Assuming a “buy and hold” universal is not a reasonable assumption.

Assuming anyone might need to liquidate at any minute is not necessarily more reasonable, but it is more consistent with reality

Re:Volkswagen Official Gets 7-Year Term in Diesel-Emissions ... by jimnotgym on Thursday December 07, 2017 @02:16AM (#15868309)
The more excepted model is that capital gains (and losses) are equivalent to dividends[0]. So yes it was a loss. [0]https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Modigliani%E2%80%93Miller_th...
Re:Volkswagen Official Gets 7-Year Term in Diesel-Emissions ... by empthought on Thursday December 07, 2017 @04:16PM (#15874323)
If they didn’t sell any stock, there was no capital gain or loss.
Re:Volkswagen Official Gets 7-Year Term in Diesel-Emissions ... by psergeant on Wednesday December 06, 2017 @10:42PM (#15867457)
The board are responsible to shareholders; most shareholders are simply too small to have any effect though. I wonder if diluting the shares is in any way a reasonable or feasible solution. You could put the newly created shares in Trust for the country’s pension system or something.
Re:Volkswagen Official Gets 7-Year Term in Diesel-Emissions ... by rubyn00bie on Wednesday December 06, 2017 @07:31PM (#15866498)
WAT?!

And how would that work?

Most shareholders with enough voting rights to matter are organizations themselves. This would essentially cease any attempt due to the absurd and never-ending complexity holding people accountable.

--- "Corp X needs to be accountable!" "It's shareholders must pay!" [looks up shareholders] "Corp Y is a shareholder of X" ... "Corp Y needs to be accountable!" "It's shareholders must pay" [looks up shareholders] "Corp Z is a shareholder of Y" ... "Corp Z needs to be accountable!" --

The separation of ownership and management is what got us in this problem to begin with. Pointing the finger back at ownership when it's a corporation with thousands, or maybe even millions, of shareholders is stepping backwards in time and approach.

Owners don't make the decisions, managers who effectively have no boss make decisions and they're the ones who should pay.

Re:Volkswagen Official Gets 7-Year Term in Diesel-Emissions ... by seanmcdirmid on Wednesday December 06, 2017 @09:28PM (#15867126)
Also, isn’t the biggest VW shareholder Bavaria?
Re:Volkswagen Official Gets 7-Year Term in Diesel-Emissions ... by pacificmint on Wednesday December 06, 2017 @11:02PM (#15867535)
Its the state of Niedersachen (Lower Saxony), not Bavaria.

And they are not the largest shareholder, they hold about 20%. Qatar holds 17% and Porsche a tad over 50%.

Re:Volkswagen Official Gets 7-Year Term in Diesel-Emissions ... by sitkack on Wednesday December 06, 2017 @07:55PM (#15866640)
I really enjoy the string of responses your comment has elicited. People really like only being liable for the amount of money they put into something. Regardless if the downsides of their actions end up costing more than the inputs.
Re:Volkswagen Official Gets 7-Year Term in Diesel-Emissions ... by jacquesm on Wednesday December 06, 2017 @11:05PM (#15867550)
Individual shareholders are not capable of meaningfully directing company action unless they act in aggregate and even then it would be very hard for individual stockholders to make this happen because of the low frequency with which shareholder meetings are held.

Stockholders - especially those that originally bought company stock when it was issued - assume liability already, if the company goes under their stock is worthless, if the company is fined their dividends drop.

To make them liable beyond that for something they themselves do not control in a way that would enable you to assign blame is excessive.

Re:Volkswagen Official Gets 7-Year Term in Diesel-Emissions ... by sitkack on Thursday December 07, 2017 @12:46AM (#15867903)
People would make more responsible choices if they were liable for the effect of their actions and not just what the corp could get away with.

> their dividends drop

Corporations are rarely fined even 100% of their profits from illegal actions.

If the punishment is simply going to be temporary drop in returns, and that maximum damage inflicted upon a corporation and investor is dissolution, that dissolution should be wielded with a casual frequency. Corporations are benefiting from breaking the law. They get caught, and they still benefit.

Many of these arguments center around 1) a drop in returns is punishment enough 2) it would be difficult. Both are simplistic pat answers that defend the corporation as a one-way valve for wealth that disintermediates the criminal from the crime. How is it that I am responsible for all of my actions, except when my action is a pooled investment?

The ultimate question is can money only harm up to its denominal value?

Re:Volkswagen Official Gets 7-Year Term in Diesel-Emissions ... by flexie on Wednesday December 06, 2017 @10:10PM (#15867327)
Apart from the Porsche family that would be all 8 million citizens in the state of Lower Saxony and the 2.5 million in Qatar? Why stop at the shareholders? Some shares are owned by pension funds. Surely those greedy savers would fit in your giant prison too.
Re:Volkswagen Official Gets 7-Year Term in Diesel-Emissions ... by fma on Wednesday December 06, 2017 @07:32PM (#15866503)
If you have mutual funds, index funds... You are likely a shareholders of a misbehaving company. So... Are you ready for jail time?
Re:Volkswagen Official Gets 7-Year Term in Diesel-Emissions ... by mikestew on Wednesday December 06, 2017 @07:44PM (#15866580)
Yeah, when Tesla hypothetically defrauds customers and governments, my 1000 shares is going to carry a lot of weight at that shareholders meeting. Oh, did you mean mutual funds and the like? Like the one your 401K might hold? How hard did you think about this before posting?
Re:Volkswagen Official Gets 7-Year Term in Diesel-Emissions ... by jimnotgym on Thursday December 07, 2017 @02:19AM (#15868322)
Well at least your Tesla shares are safe from this particular scandal!
Re:Volkswagen Official Gets 7-Year Term in Diesel-Emissions ... by paxy on Wednesday December 06, 2017 @07:55PM (#15866643)
So if I have a 401k with some money in a broad index fund which includes VW, I should be in jail?
Re:Volkswagen Official Gets 7-Year Term in Diesel-Emissions ... by jjeaff on Wednesday December 06, 2017 @07:43PM (#15866576)
That's what the fines are for. That is essentially money out of shareholders pockets.
Re:Volkswagen Official Gets 7-Year Term in Diesel-Emissions ... by adambyrtek on Thursday December 07, 2017 @07:34AM (#15869482)
Like pension funds and passive ETFs that are shareholders of most if not all public companies?
Re:Volkswagen Official Gets 7-Year Term in Diesel-Emissions ... by lostapathy on Wednesday December 06, 2017 @07:33PM (#15866515)
Sharehlders get punished when the stock drops.

Or are you suggesting we lock up anybody who owns a few shares?

Re:Volkswagen Official Gets 7-Year Term in Diesel-Emissions ... by seanmcdirmid on Wednesday December 06, 2017 @09:26PM (#15867115)
So I could go to jail for holding an index fund?