News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Aetna CEO Set to Reap About $500M If CVS Deal Closes by ryanwaggoner on Tuesday December 05, 2017 @12:41PM (#15853612)
Well, he led the company while its value went from $10 billion to $69 billion in 7 years. Doesn't seem ridiculous.
Re:Aetna CEO Set to Reap About $500M If CVS Deal Closes by chasing on Tuesday December 05, 2017 @12:45PM (#15853665)
Yes it does.

Aetna employees almost 50,000 people.

Aetna owes some success to their CEO. They owe most of their success to their employees.

Re:Aetna CEO Set to Reap About $500M If CVS Deal Closes by lefstathiou on Tuesday December 05, 2017 @01:01PM (#15853883)
I respectfully disagree with the way you are positioning this.

The relative impact of a CEO, whose job is to set strategic direction and direct human (tens of thousands of employees) and financial capital (billions of dollars) at scale, dwarfs that of any of its individual employees and the vast swath of them combined.

Most relevant to you, the majority of the benefit of this 7x increase in value in 7 years is actually accruing to the the shareholders, not the CEO. And guess who are the top shareholders of Aetna?

#1 Blackrock #2 Capital World Investors #3 Vanguard #4 T Rowe #5 State Street Source: https://whalewisdom.com/stock/aet

All of these above are money managers of "the people's" 401k's and retirements funds. So you can rest assured that the majority of the benefit is going to the people for whom Aetna owes its success.

Re:Aetna CEO Set to Reap About $500M If CVS Deal Closes by eecc on Tuesday December 05, 2017 @01:23PM (#15854147)
> The relative impact of a CEO, whose job is to set strategic direction and direct human (tens of thousands of employees) and financial capital (billions of dollars) at scale

Or - according to my anecdotal experience - get out of the way and stop interfering with employees that know what they’re doing? I can think of several asinine “big plans” that just ended up burning huge stashes of capital and costing even more in opportunities that were heralded as the new Advent of Christ, “and don’t you dare be the naysayer!”

Re:Aetna CEO Set to Reap About $500M If CVS Deal Closes by nugget on Tuesday December 05, 2017 @04:09PM (#15856011)
Are you advocating for a flat org structure and if so have you seen any examples of that succeeding at scale?

I think many people who argue against the value of great management have just never worked at a company with great management. Great managers are as awesome and empowering as bad managers are terrible and soul-destroying.

Re:Aetna CEO Set to Reap About $500M If CVS Deal Closes by sverhagen on Tuesday December 05, 2017 @01:06PM (#15853955)
I don't think anyone is arguing that he has a more than average impact on the direction of the company. But, like any humble CEO would say, it's all about the people, the people below them, the people throughout the organization. So, while he deserves a decent bonus, fine, why does it need to be roughly thirty-three thousand times minimum wage. And this is just the bonus, he probably still has a very happy salary as well.
Re:Aetna CEO Set to Reap About $500M If CVS Deal Closes by cabaalis on Tuesday December 05, 2017 @01:25PM (#15854160)
> why does it need to be roughly thirty-three thousand times minimum wage

Because that's what he negotiated with his employers.

Re:Aetna CEO Set to Reap About $500M If CVS Deal Closes by state_less on Tuesday December 05, 2017 @01:55PM (#15854543)
> All of these above are money managers of "the people's" 401k's and retirements funds.

Numbers matter though. Most people don't own much capital and it's getting worse year by year. In other words, if I have a small 401k, I'd prefer the cheaper healthcare to a small bump in my meager savings (many don't have a 401k at all).

Re:Aetna CEO Set to Reap About $500M If CVS Deal Closes by btrautsc on Tuesday December 05, 2017 @01:26PM (#15854188)
this is a great comment.
Re:Aetna CEO Set to Reap About $500M If CVS Deal Closes by refurb on Tuesday December 05, 2017 @01:01PM (#15853896)
And if the company had done poorly, would be game for the employees taking a pay cut? It works both ways.
Re:Aetna CEO Set to Reap About $500M If CVS Deal Closes by iterati on Tuesday December 05, 2017 @01:03PM (#15853912)
They'd be fired.
Re:Aetna CEO Set to Reap About $500M If CVS Deal Closes by wmeredith on Tuesday December 05, 2017 @01:26PM (#15854196)
No it doesn't. If the company was tanking, the employees would get laid off whereas the CEO would be launched with a golden parachute, often one that's worth more than any employee will make in their entire life.
Re:Aetna CEO Set to Reap About $500M If CVS Deal Closes by zentiggr on Tuesday December 05, 2017 @01:21PM (#15854126)
That usually works out as 100% for some, 0% for the rest.
Re:Aetna CEO Set to Reap About $500M If CVS Deal Closes by jimbokun on Tuesday December 05, 2017 @07:01PM (#15857374)
Uh, yeah, that's probably much more likely than management taking a pay cut at almost any US company.

Or getting laid off.

Re:Aetna CEO Set to Reap About $500M If CVS Deal Closes by dymk on Tuesday December 05, 2017 @12:50PM (#15853735)
Right, because those 50,000 employees were making the major directional decisions for the company, not the C level execs
Re:Aetna CEO Set to Reap About $500M If CVS Deal Closes by chasing on Tuesday December 05, 2017 @12:51PM (#15853749)
Directional decisions aren't the only important decisions.

And, yes: Non-C-level execs make directional decisions all the time. Especially in a company the size of Aetna.

Re:Aetna CEO Set to Reap About $500M If CVS Deal Closes by new-account-9 on Tuesday December 05, 2017 @01:13PM (#15854039)
If you get the big decisions correct, then your company can survive many incorrect small decisions.

If you get the big decisions incorrect, then your company will not survive even if all the small decisions are correct.

Re:Aetna CEO Set to Reap About $500M If CVS Deal Closes by pc86 on Tuesday December 05, 2017 @02:18PM (#15854805)

    [citation needed]
Re:Aetna CEO Set to Reap About $500M If CVS Deal Closes by illvm on Tuesday December 05, 2017 @12:54PM (#15853795)
The only reason those people are able to contemplate such decisions is because of the thousands of workers supporting the enterprise.
Re:Aetna CEO Set to Reap About $500M If CVS Deal Closes by Sargos on Tuesday December 05, 2017 @01:16PM (#15854066)
And the only reason those thousands of people are able to support the enterprise is because of the top level executives making sure the business stays on track
Re:Aetna CEO Set to Reap About $500M If CVS Deal Closes by justicezyx on Tuesday December 05, 2017 @12:53PM (#15853773)
Can you quantify the ratio of payment vs. the ratio of contribution? And the amount of supply vs demand for 2 groups?
Re:Aetna CEO Set to Reap About $500M If CVS Deal Closes by psyc on Tuesday December 05, 2017 @12:54PM (#15853790)
No rationalization about value can ever hide the obvious and deep-rooted lord / serf dynamic.
Re:Aetna CEO Set to Reap About $500M If CVS Deal Closes by new-account-9 on Tuesday December 05, 2017 @01:17PM (#15854073)
You claim there is a lord/serf dynamic. Let's take that a step further. Let's free the "serfs" by removing every lord from power today. Now, we have just lost all of our experts in managing large companies, and global competitors come in and take over the markets our own companies used to control. Now you work for them, instead of for our own companies, because you still have to make money. Do you think that your Chinese or Israeli lords are better than the American ones?
Re:Aetna CEO Set to Reap About $500M If CVS Deal Closes by bkanber on Tuesday December 05, 2017 @12:55PM (#15853819)
I'm all for taxing the rich and compensating workers fairly.

But:

- Had the company declined, the CEO would have gotten all the blame and been crucified. Can't give blame if you can't also give credit.

- The CEO negotiated this deal, the employees did not.

- A good portion of this $500M is from the value of his stock, which is part of his compensation. I don't know the percentage of this payout that comes from stock (WSJ paywall...), but we certainly can't take stock AWAY from him to reduce his payout.

- Employees who have cashed in their options will also make money from this deal. Other stockholders will make money too.

Again -- I am NOT condoning our American trend of over-paid CEOs. More money in the working class is good for the economy. But this event specifically is not ridiculous.

Re:Aetna CEO Set to Reap About $500M If CVS Deal Closes by Nrsolis on Tuesday December 05, 2017 @01:04PM (#15853918)
Something I find curious is the degree to which HN seems to want to break out the torches and pitchforks when a CEO profits handsomely by increasing shareholder value. There doesn't seem to be the same animus towards ordinary developers becoming millionaires in a few short years by getting lucky and landing at the right unicorn startup pre-IPO.

CEOs interests are aligned perfectly in this situation: increase shareholder value. The vast bulk of CEO pay is derived from the stock that's granted to them and vested over time just like it would be for any employee that received RSUs or stock options.

I don't quite grok the idea that employees with no ownership stake in the company are somehow owed a share of the capital gain when they've got no capital of their own at risk.

A big part of my compensation is commission and another big part is RSUs. If I don't deliver results and if I don't align my goals with that of the major shareholders and the market, I don't make as much money. I don't see how this contravenes the startup/get-rich zeitgeist here in HN.

Capitalism for me but not for thee?

Re:Aetna CEO Set to Reap About $500M If CVS Deal Closes by pg314 on Tuesday December 05, 2017 @01:13PM (#15854037)
> CEOs interests are aligned perfectly in this situation: increase shareholder value.

That is wrong. The CEO's risk is asymmetric. Huge upside with limited downside, which encourages reckless risk taking. It is also shorter term (until his grants vest), encouraging short term profit over long term value.

> I don't quite grok the idea that employees with no ownership stake in the company are somehow owed a share of the capital gain when they've got no capital of their own at risk.

Is the CEO not an employee? Why would he be owed a share of the capital gain, and other workers not?

Re:Aetna CEO Set to Reap About $500M If CVS Deal Closes by Nrsolis on Tuesday December 05, 2017 @01:22PM (#15854142)
His risk isn't asymmetric. He (or she) has got to justify their job each and every quarter to the investors. A couple of bad quarters and you can expect the shareholders to be looking for a scalp and it's usually the CEO.

I think you maybe underestimate the job market for senior executives. It's not like a CEO of a S&P500 company can find another job on LinkedIn. Sometimes they land a new gig. A lot of the times they don't.

I'd also suggest you try the job of leading people and groups of that size. There are very few who can do this sort of work effectively.

Also consider that a CEO has to consider the types of challenges he or she would like to tackle. A Board of Directors is shopping for talent and trying to get the right fit. Why does a CEO not get the same opportunity to negotiate a pay package?

Re:Aetna CEO Set to Reap About $500M If CVS Deal Closes by s73ver_ on Tuesday December 05, 2017 @04:06PM (#15855976)
"His risk isn't asymmetric. He (or she) has got to justify their job each and every quarter to the investors. A couple of bad quarters and you can expect the shareholders to be looking for a scalp and it's usually the CEO."

But what actual risk is the CEO taking? Sure, the board might decide to let them go. But that usually comes with a multi-million dollar severance package. They're not hurting. There is no practical downside. On the other hand, someone who gets laid off because of the company tanking does get hurt, through no fault of their own.

"I think you maybe underestimate the job market for senior executives. It's not like a CEO of a S&P500 company can find another job on LinkedIn. Sometimes they land a new gig. A lot of the times they don't."

They land on their feet more often than not. And, again, they're not hurting for money. If they don't find another job, their children are not going to go hungry.

Re:Aetna CEO Set to Reap About $500M If CVS Deal Closes by Nrsolis on Tuesday December 05, 2017 @04:20PM (#15856102)
If you got fired from a job that had a potential $500M payday attached to it and only got a $25M severance package at the end of it, trust me, you'd be pretty bummed about it. Go looking for CEOs that got fired and see where they landed. it's one and done for a lot of them.

Again, there is no room for socialist populism here. He negotiated a package and he delivered results. His interests as a CEO are aligned with the shareholders who risk their capital with ownership of the company. They trust the board and the CEO to increase the value of their investment.

Why is this controversial? Why does it matter if he's rich before or after he does the job? All of these guys are already wealthy before they even sign up. They don't need to do this work to survive.

Somehow the notion seems to go around that anyone who makes a boatload of money suddenly has to kowtow to the public on whether or not they deserve that money. That's not how this works.

Re:Aetna CEO Set to Reap About $500M If CVS Deal Closes by pg314 on Tuesday December 05, 2017 @05:42PM (#15856761)
> If you got fired from a job that had a potential $500M payday attached to it and only got a $25M severance package at the end of it, trust me, you'd be pretty bummed about it.

Trust me, I wouldn't be. I pity the person who is bummed to have only $25M.

> He negotiated a package and he delivered results. His interests as a CEO are aligned with the shareholders who risk their capital with ownership of the company. They trust the board and the CEO to increase the value of their investment.

Ever tried getting a CEO's compensation reduced as a shareholder? Warren Buffett describes it as follows: "the deck is stacked against investors when it comes to the CEO’s pay" [1].

[1] http://www.berkshirehathaway.com/letters/2005ltr.pdf

Re:Aetna CEO Set to Reap About $500M If CVS Deal Closes by jimbokun on Tuesday December 05, 2017 @07:12PM (#15857427)
That is outstanding reading. Like the closing quote of that section:

"Though I have served as a director of twenty public companies, only one CEO has put me on his comp committee. Hmmmm . . ."

Everyone in this thread claiming CEOs usually "earn" their compensation needs to read this and explain why Buffet's arguments are wrong.

(Not because it's Buffett, because his arguments are well thought out and reflect a lot of personal experience with the topic.)

Re:Aetna CEO Set to Reap About $500M If CVS Deal Closes by s73ver_ on Tuesday December 05, 2017 @05:21PM (#15856596)
"If you got fired from a job that had a potential $500M payday attached to it and only got a $25M severance package at the end of it, trust me, you'd be pretty bummed about it."

I'd be bummed. That's it. I wouldn't be wondering if I was going to lose my house, or if I'd still be able to eat.

" His interests as a CEO are aligned with the shareholders who risk their capital with ownership of the company. "

But not with the interests of the employees who risk their human capital.

"Why is this controversial?"

Because those who do the majority of the work making the company successful are not rewarded for it.

Re:Aetna CEO Set to Reap About $500M If CVS Deal Closes by Nrsolis on Tuesday December 05, 2017 @05:45PM (#15856781)
Well, in this great country, you're perfectly welcome to start your own company and distribute 95% of the shares to your first 1000 employees.

Tell them they need to work for free for 4 years (or for far below market wages) in order to account for the capital contribution of their labor, comrade, and see how far that gets you.

Ben and Jerry's tried to cap CEO pay at 7x their lowest paid worker and soon realized that nobody wanted the job (or at least nobody that was qualified). Now their current CEO is taking home a whole lot more than that and he's not being paid in Chubby Hubby.

http://abcnews.go.com/Business/companies-follow-ben-jerrys-l...

"I'm talking about Ben Cohen and Jerry Greenfield and their iconoclastic Ben & Jerry's ice cream company.

But it's neither Cherry Garcia nor Phish Food that's on my mind right now—well, maybe just a little—as much as it is the social pact that Messrs. Cohen and Greenfield made with their employees at the start of their venture: From top to bottom, the pay ratio between the highest salaried executive and lowest-earning-worker would be no greater than 5 to 1.

To their credit, the ice cream kings kept to their pay scale deal for 16 years. At that point, Cohen was set to retire and no successor who was willing to accept B&J's compensation compact could be found.

End of an Era

So the bar was raised to 7 to 1 to attract new talent, and ultimately to 17 to 1 over the course of a half dozen years more. The company was then acquired by Unilever USA in 2000, after which the corporate cone of silence descended on what was once a very transparent practice."

Re:Aetna CEO Set to Reap About $500M If CVS Deal Closes by s73ver_ on Tuesday December 05, 2017 @05:48PM (#15856814)
"Well, in this great country, you're perfectly welcome to start your own company and distribute 95% of the shares to your first 1000 employees."

That is a cop-out answer that shows that you're not interested in discussing the issue. If you don't see an issue with corporate greed in the world today, that's your prerogative, but don't make it to seem like those who do are the ones who don't know what they're talking about.

Re:Aetna CEO Set to Reap About $500M If CVS Deal Closes by ryanwaggoner on Tuesday December 05, 2017 @06:10PM (#15856995)
That's not how I read their answer. In fact, they spent a lot of time explaining what they meant, while you seem to be the one trying to shut down discussion.
Re:Aetna CEO Set to Reap About $500M If CVS Deal Closes by bkanber on Tuesday December 05, 2017 @06:45PM (#15857281)
> But what actual risk is the CEO taking?

Not much financial risk, no. But they are accountable in many other ways. Personally, I'd never want to be the CEO of a Fortune 500 company, even with a $10M salary.

> usually comes with a multi-million dollar severance package

Only at the top of the game at the largest companies.

> On the other hand, someone who gets laid off because of the company tanking does get hurt, through no fault of their own.

This is of course true, but you're only looking at financial hurt.

> If they don't find another job, their children are not going to go hungry.

For many CEOs, this _was also true_ at some point earlier in their careers.

Re:Aetna CEO Set to Reap About $500M If CVS Deal Closes by bkanber on Tuesday December 05, 2017 @06:35PM (#15857219)
> Huge upside with limited downside

From your perspective, sure, especially if you're only considering financial downside. There are huge non-financial downside risks, like staking your personal reputation on the performance of the 50,000 person company that you're running. Maybe you don't personally care about those other risks, but CEOs in that position do.

> encourages reckless risk taking

Not all CEOs take reckless risks.

> encouraging short term profit over long term value

This is a function of shareholders, not of CEOs.

> Is the CEO not an employee?

No, the CEO is an Officer of the Corporation and is literally held accountable for the performance of the company. An employee is not. The CEO and CFO of public companies can go to jail for misleading investors, insider trading, falsifying financial reports, etc. There is no such law that holds employees accountable for those things.

> Why would he be owed a share of the capital gain, and other workers not?

Because he owns stock. Anyone is free to buy shares of a public company. Any employee can buy stock and therefore take a share of the capital gain. There are lots of companies that give workers options and even stock grants. CEO compensation packages are designed to be heavy on stock so that the incentive to increase shareholder value becomes personal.

Re:Aetna CEO Set to Reap About $500M If CVS Deal Closes by jimbokun on Tuesday December 05, 2017 @07:04PM (#15857396)
"There are huge non-financial downside risks, like staking your personal reputation on the performance of the 50,000 person company that you're running."

That doesn't actually happen. CEOs get golden parachutes and move on to high paid jobs somewhere else when their company does poorly.

Re:Aetna CEO Set to Reap About $500M If CVS Deal Closes by bkanber on Tuesday December 05, 2017 @11:36PM (#15858559)
What about my other points?
Re:Aetna CEO Set to Reap About $500M If CVS Deal Closes by maxerickson on Tuesday December 05, 2017 @01:08PM (#15853986)
I'm not particularly animated by the issue but I'm also not convinced the compensation has much to do with relative ability and performance. It's based on lucky positioning and risk averse ass covering (the board thinks it is more defensible to pay lots for a star than take a risk paying less).
Re:Aetna CEO Set to Reap About $500M If CVS Deal Closes by bkanber on Tuesday December 05, 2017 @06:27PM (#15857148)
You're right, partially. The thing about free markets is that the average value across all data points will converge to the free market value, and there are outliers on both sides. There are lots of CEOs that are under-paid for their abilities as well as lots of CEOs that are over-paid for their abilities. If you were to look at all CEO salaries averaged over all companies in an industry, you probably would get a pretty fair view of what the average CEO is worth, but of course an N=1 can deviate greatly from the average.

A company's performance may be strongly correlated to a CEO's ability and performance, or not. These salaries aren't set algorithmically and there's no way to predict ahead of time exactly what the impact of a given person on an organization will be. Past performance is not a guarantee of future returns, but there's really nothing else to determine CEO salary by except for experience, fit, and past performance. The salaries are set by whatever the board and shareholders are willing to pay, which is influenced by all the data (objective and subjective alike) -- a central tenet of free markets.

The truth is there's really no other way to do it.

Re:Aetna CEO Set to Reap About $500M If CVS Deal Closes by jimbokun on Tuesday December 05, 2017 @07:14PM (#15857435)
That, and CEOs benefit from raising other CEOs compensation packages from sitting on each other's boards.
Re:Aetna CEO Set to Reap About $500M If CVS Deal Closes by maxerickson on Tuesday December 05, 2017 @07:02PM (#15857382)
You are begging the question.

First you have to prove that the CEO market is efficient. Then you can praise the free hand.

Re:Aetna CEO Set to Reap About $500M If CVS Deal Closes by bkanber on Tuesday December 05, 2017 @07:24PM (#15857493)
All free and competitive markets are taken to be efficient. In a market where a million wannabe-CEOs are vying for one of the top 500 spots, you get tough competition and the compensation is commensurate with the level of competition.
Re:Aetna CEO Set to Reap About $500M If CVS Deal Closes by maxerickson on Tuesday December 05, 2017 @07:37PM (#15857560)
Lots of people willing to do the job should drive down the compensation.

High compensation is partly a result of businesses choosing from a small pool of candidates...

Re:Aetna CEO Set to Reap About $500M If CVS Deal Closes by bkanber on Tuesday December 05, 2017 @10:03PM (#15858149)
Willing, but not able. There are lots of people willing to be astronauts and NFL players too. The small pool represents the top performers, and that's where the competition is.
Re:Aetna CEO Set to Reap About $500M If CVS Deal Closes by Nrsolis on Tuesday December 05, 2017 @01:35PM (#15854302)
Who gets to decide this? As I understand it, it's the board of directors that put together a compensation committee. It's not like they are spending your money. They're spending the shareholder's money.

If only you owned stock in CVS or Aetna you'd be able to make your voice heard.

Re:Aetna CEO Set to Reap About $500M If CVS Deal Closes by maxerickson on Tuesday December 05, 2017 @01:36PM (#15854325)
What's your point?

You think I should keep my opinion to myself or something?

Re:Aetna CEO Set to Reap About $500M If CVS Deal Closes by Nrsolis on Tuesday December 05, 2017 @01:48PM (#15854466)
I don't understand the animus towards CEO pay. It can easily be applied to any major celebrity or athlete.

If anyone could do what they do, they'd be paid accordingly.

The market (via the shareholders) sets the rate of pay. Why the general public cares about one and not the other is beyond me.

Re:Aetna CEO Set to Reap About $500M If CVS Deal Closes by jimbokun on Tuesday December 05, 2017 @07:17PM (#15857450)
"If anyone could do what they do, they'd be paid accordingly."

This is not at all self evident. There is a lot of reporting suggesting CEO compensation is not really tied to the best interests of share holders.

As cited elsewhere in this thread:

http://www.berkshirehathaway.com/letters/2005ltr.pdf

Re:Aetna CEO Set to Reap About $500M If CVS Deal Closes by maxerickson on Tuesday December 05, 2017 @02:22PM (#15854842)
My post questions the ability of the market to price CEO value a lot more than it expresses outrage.

Athletes and celebrities are different, their pay is a natural consequence of gathering lots of attention. A more rational species would substitute cheaper entertainment.

Re:Aetna CEO Set to Reap About $500M If CVS Deal Closes by bkanber on Tuesday December 05, 2017 @06:47PM (#15857291)
> Athletes and celebrities are different, their pay is a natural consequence of gathering lots of attention.

And a Fortune 500 CEO's pay is a natural consequence of being a Fortune 500 CEO. There are only 500 of them. This is the top of the game, just like pro athletes.

> A more rational species would substitute cheaper entertainment.

But we aren't, and we don't.

Re:Aetna CEO Set to Reap About $500M If CVS Deal Closes by ilyanep on Tuesday December 05, 2017 @01:04PM (#15853923)
It's like 80% according to the article:

- $230m from "already-vested stock-appreciation rights"

- $190m from "Aetna common stock he currently owns"

- "Between $60 million and $85 million" as part of a "change-in-control package" which is paid out if he's terminated as a result of the sale.

One of my biggest pet peeves regarding reporting of executive compensation is when the headlines pretend that CEOs are being paid hundreds of millions of dollars in cash, when it's mostly coming from stock-based compensation, which is arguably the most fair way to pay a CEO (if they do poorly leading the company, they make much less money).

Re:Aetna CEO Set to Reap About $500M If CVS Deal Closes by pg314 on Tuesday December 05, 2017 @01:07PM (#15853971)
> - Had the company declined, the CEO would have gotten all the blame and been crucified. Can't give blame if you can't also give credit.

He was making 10+ million dollars a year already [1], which he would have been able to keep. The worst that could have happened to him if he was underperforming was being fired. Calling it being crucified is ridiculous hyperbole.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mark_Bertolini

Re:Aetna CEO Set to Reap About $500M If CVS Deal Closes by jimbokun on Tuesday December 05, 2017 @07:02PM (#15857380)
"Had the company declined, the CEO would have gotten all the blame and been crucified."

Hahaha, that's a good one.

The CEO would get a golden parachute payout and move onto another highly paid position.

Re:Aetna CEO Set to Reap About $500M If CVS Deal Closes by bkanber on Tuesday December 05, 2017 @07:20PM (#15857470)
If you want a golden parachute like that, then you also need to be one of the top 500 or 1000 sought-after CEOs in the country. Just like if you want a pro footballer's (NFL) salary, you need to be one of the top 1500 players. Software engineers like me and (probably) you don't get golden parachutes because we're not one in 500, we're one in a million.
Re:Aetna CEO Set to Reap About $500M If CVS Deal Closes by jimbokun on Tuesday December 05, 2017 @07:34PM (#15857544)
Football players are good comparison. If they don't play well, they are just cut and not paid anything. No "golden parachutes" for poor performance.
Re:Aetna CEO Set to Reap About $500M If CVS Deal Closes by bkanber on Tuesday December 05, 2017 @10:06PM (#15858161)
They do get golden parachutes. If you're a pro football player and you get benched in game 1 with a season-ending injury, you still get paid. If you get cut for poor performance before your contract's guaranteed payout is paid, you still get that money. That is the golden parachute.
Re:Aetna CEO Set to Reap About $500M If CVS Deal Closes by s73ver_ on Tuesday December 05, 2017 @01:39PM (#15854358)
"- Had the company declined, the CEO would have gotten all the blame and been crucified. Can't give blame if you can't also give credit."

And he would have been given a golden parachute worth far more than most of us will see in our lifetimes. His family wouldn't go hungry or homeless. At the same time, many employees will get laid off, and their families will have a very real chance of going hungry or homeless.

Re:Aetna CEO Set to Reap About $500M If CVS Deal Closes by bkanber on Tuesday December 05, 2017 @06:53PM (#15857334)
Yes, that's true. When a pro NFL player gets injured in game 1 and has to sit out the rest of the season, they still get paid. If I get injured and can't code, I'm screwed. If we're talking about Fortune 500 CEOs, we're talking about pros at the top of the game where the economics are totally different. If you want a golden parachute like the Fortune 500 CEOs get, you also have to be one of the 500 -- just like I'd have to be a pro NFL player in order to get paid millions of dollars while sitting on an injury.
Re:Aetna CEO Set to Reap About $500M If CVS Deal Closes by pkaye on Tuesday December 05, 2017 @01:02PM (#15853903)
Then why not get rid of the rest of the employees and just hire a dozen like him since he is bringing all the value.
Re:Aetna CEO Set to Reap About $500M If CVS Deal Closes by chrisdbaldwin on Tuesday December 05, 2017 @01:41PM (#15854383)
You need exactly 1 in the organization. No more, no less. Can you deduce why a collective or cluster hasn't replaced the role? I'd imagine the answer is blame, but I'd like to know what you think.
Re:Aetna CEO Set to Reap About $500M If CVS Deal Closes by thevardanian on Tuesday December 05, 2017 @12:53PM (#15853776)
Say I start building a house. I realize I can't do it all by myself, so I get other people to do all the labor involved in building it. All the while providing all the details, instructions, and architectural guidelines to get a good finished product. Not to mention sourcing the materials required, getting the plans approved by the city, and making sure that on-sight construction passes inspection by the city.

Who "owes" most of the success in building the house? The labor, or the person employing the labor productively?

Edit: Just to clarify. I genuinely don't know who should get credit for the success of building a house. Both are almost equally as important. However I can say that it seems, maybe, possibly that labor collectively is as important as the single person making all the decision. That is no single laborer is as important as the person trying to get the building made.

Re:Aetna CEO Set to Reap About $500M If CVS Deal Closes by Cshelton on Tuesday December 05, 2017 @12:58PM (#15853846)
To add to that: Would the house ever be built at all if not for the person employing the labor to build it?

Great analogy for a company too. Whether it's a start up or growing a large company to be even larger. There is no automatic force that just makes a company grow, innovate, grab market share. Things don't just happen without the leadership and direction from the top.

Re:Aetna CEO Set to Reap About $500M If CVS Deal Closes by chasing on Tuesday December 05, 2017 @12:57PM (#15853832)
Aetna's CEO is an employee of Aetna. So in your tale he's part of the labor, not the person who wants a house built.
Re:Aetna CEO Set to Reap About $500M If CVS Deal Closes by Cshelton on Tuesday December 05, 2017 @01:00PM (#15853876)
Typically high level executives are required to buy a certain number of shares in the company. That's not including the options earned, but actual shares they have to buy. Now yes, much of the time, the shares they have to buy are options they have to exercise, but in the end, the stakeholders always want to see the decision makers have skin in the game.

So yes, the CEO is an owner as well.

Re:Aetna CEO Set to Reap About $500M If CVS Deal Closes by bkanber on Tuesday December 05, 2017 @07:32PM (#15857533)
Aetna's CEO is not an employee of Aetna, he is an Officer of the corporation.
Re:Aetna CEO Set to Reap About $500M If CVS Deal Closes by untog on Tuesday December 05, 2017 @12:59PM (#15853865)
Comparisons like this inevitably break down at some point. I'm not at all convinced that the Aetna CEO does whatever the equivalent of sourcing materials does in their business. Architectural guidelines? Sure. "All details"? Almost definitely not.

Even taking your example at face value, I don't agree with it. The house wouldn't exist without either labourers or the planner. They are both vital. But in the Aetna situation, only one is rewarded.

Re:Aetna CEO Set to Reap About $500M If CVS Deal Closes by thevardanian on Tuesday December 05, 2017 @01:05PM (#15853928)
A CEO is responsible for the products that they make. In the case of any company really you have to deal with various professionals, the City, and laborers to make a product.

I think it's fair to say that no single laborer, it seems, is as important in the process of production than the person making all the decisions to employ labor to some final product.

Re:Aetna CEO Set to Reap About $500M If CVS Deal Closes by untog on Tuesday December 05, 2017 @01:15PM (#15854064)
But the CEO doesn't make all the decisions. Like I said, the comparison doesn't really work. Aetna isn't one CEO and 50,000 labourers, it has an entire corporate chain of command.
Re:Aetna CEO Set to Reap About $500M If CVS Deal Closes by thevardanian on Tuesday December 05, 2017 @01:29PM (#15854232)
Building a house isn't just one person ordeal either. It's a simplistic model in either case. A CEO for all intents and purposes does make all the decision in the same sense that any leader in most any circumstance makes "all the decisions". Even a company Commander in the military doesn't "make all the decisions", however they are most definitely responsible for all the decision they make for themselves and for their company.

Hell even at the very top the Commander in Chief doesn't make "all the decision".

Re:Aetna CEO Set to Reap About $500M If CVS Deal Closes by dangerlibrary on Tuesday December 05, 2017 @12:55PM (#15853804)
That's not really a good analogy for a CEO's job, though.

A CEO's job would be someone who makes a small number of very broad, directional choices (should the home be Victorian, or Brutalist?) then hires and manages a team of people to hire and manage teams of people to hire and manage teams of people to build a house.

Given that the only decision they made was "Victorian vs Brutalist" and then hiring some decent managers, should they still receive that much compensation just for (in this case!) happening to have made the right choice?

Re:Aetna CEO Set to Reap About $500M If CVS Deal Closes by bfuller on Tuesday December 05, 2017 @01:07PM (#15853967)
I am just curious how the system should work then?
Re:Aetna CEO Set to Reap About $500M If CVS Deal Closes by itchyjunk on Tuesday December 05, 2017 @12:59PM (#15853866)
Wow, $500 million bonus sounded ridiculous. But under the context that the company valuation went up by ~$59 billion, it doesn't sound too crazy at all.$500k bonus for increasing the value of company by ~50mil is stuff I've heard of before. But brain refused to compute it in terms of millions.

Can't say if he deserves it or not the the initial shock is definitely blunted in the context.

Re:Aetna CEO Set to Reap About $500M If CVS Deal Closes by FreeRadical on Tuesday December 05, 2017 @12:46PM (#15853686)
During a major bull market
Re:Aetna CEO Set to Reap About $500M If CVS Deal Closes by dangerlibrary on Tuesday December 05, 2017 @12:54PM (#15853788)
He's received eight-figure compensation packages every year since 2010, were those not sufficient?