News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:VLC maintainer has refused “several tens of millions of E... by jbk on Saturday September 30, 2017 @07:21AM (#15372318)
That's me.

However, I am not the VLC creator, just the one working on it since 10+ years. And I created the non-profit organization.

See the AMA for more details ;)

Re:VLC maintainer has refused “several tens of millions of E... by KGIII on Saturday September 30, 2017 @10:54AM (#15373100)
Just the other day, I was commenting about how VLC is pretty much the embodiment of perfect settings/preferences/options. While many folks have reduced settings to just selecting a theme, VLC has settings for preferences that I don't even understand.

And that is perfect.

You've now been added to my regular donation cycle. I'd rather provide for longevity than a lump sum where I forget to keep contributing.

VLC should be the goal for most every application's settings menu. It is not just a menu to change settings, it's a menu that leads to discovery and learning. It's pretty much perfection.

Re:VLC maintainer has refused “several tens of millions of E... by sagichmal on Saturday September 30, 2017 @01:31PM (#15373951)
Bizarre. I have completely the opposite reaction. VLC settings is UX nightmare, I have actual negative emotional response when I have to go in there.
Re:VLC maintainer has refused “several tens of millions of E... by KGIII on Saturday September 30, 2017 @02:38PM (#15374327)
I don't even know what half of them do. It's great!

I can just use the regular settings, or I can click advanced. If I do, I can look around and find new things. I can then take a little while to learn about what those new things are, what they do, and how they impact me.

It is pretty much perfect. I still haven't learned all there is to know about it. I still haven't tried every setting. It's just a video player - yet it has that many options.

I like complex, it gives me something to learn. I love it when I find something I don't already know.

Re:VLC maintainer has refused “several tens of millions of E... by Zandikar on Sunday October 01, 2017 @01:00PM (#15378678)
> I don't even know what half of them do. It's great!

Believe it or not, this is stresses a lot of people out, especially considering to the average user a lot more than half of the settings aren't going to be intuitively or immediately apparent.

I'm with you, I enjoy this aspect of things - I like to pick and pull things apart to figure out how they work, to mod them and make them mine and if I'm luckily/diligent, sometimes even make them better lol; be it by way of themeing or breaking out the code editor. but not everyone is like that.

Re:VLC maintainer has refused “several tens of millions of E... by gsich on Sunday October 01, 2017 @03:15PM (#15379313)
That's why there are two menus. "Simple" and "All". So you have the option, which is great. There is also a reset button in case you misconfigured something.
Re:VLC maintainer has refused “several tens of millions of E... by jbk on Saturday September 30, 2017 @02:07PM (#15374137)
Why? Simple preferences is close to Firefox or other software.

Advanced preferences are complex, so it's like about:config

Re:VLC maintainer has refused “several tens of millions of E... by KGIII on Saturday September 30, 2017 @07:40PM (#15375562)
In the conversation where I brought up VLC as having the perfect preferences aspect, it started off with a poster saying, "the customer should be able to use the product fully without having to read any documentation."

I used that to segue into quite a rant about how I lamented the lack of complexity in software. I extended it quite broadly into things like it being a sign of declining intellectual curiosity, about how aiming for the lowest common denominator was bad for those who understand computers, and even extended it to my dismay at the lack of decent help files.

It was long and rambling, touching on many subjects, and I think I should turn it into a more formal essay.

Anyhow, VLC gets the preferences options perfect. The UI can use a bit of work and the UX is a bit rough, but the multitude of options makes up for any shortcomings it may otherwise have. I haven't even really bothered to learn the command line options, which is actually a little strange for me. I spend quite a bit of time in the terminal.

And no, no... I made it a point to inform people that I wasn't wanting computing to revert to the older days. No, software wasn't better back twenty years ago. The Internet wasn't better and computers weren't better.

What was better was that programs actually had options. They had preferences. They had multiple ways that they could be configured. They could output and process work differently.

I guess my final message was a plaintive request that developers bring back my buttons. I miss those buttons. I get a hamburger icon that expands and the entire options, if it exists at all, is actually just a theme picker. Some software doesn't even have exit as a menu option. If I want to close an app on a mobile, it may actually mean finding a task manager just to close it. It gets even worse if there is no back option and I want to begin anew at the application's start screen.

So, I just wanted to take an extra minute and explain a bit more and to thank you. I already set up a donation and the project should get a donation every month, assuming I did it properly. VLC doesn't just do what it says on the box, it inspires me to learn, to discover, and to keep being curious.

I think all of those things are much more valuable than a video player. Anyone can write a video player. It takes someone special to write one that plays videos and encourages curiosity, growth, and learning.

Which is rather a long way to say, "Thanks, again!"

Re:VLC maintainer has refused “several tens of millions of E... by Merovius on Sunday October 01, 2017 @02:01AM (#15376624)
> I used that to segue into quite a rant about how I lamented the lack of complexity in software.

A software that does the right thing for everyone without any settings is several orders of magnitude more complex than a software that just lazily requires its users to configure it.

Re:VLC maintainer has refused “several tens of millions of E... by throwaway613834 on Monday October 09, 2017 @04:59PM (#15437413)
> "the customer should be able to use the product fully without having to read any documentation."

I agree with this. Even if the customer is a world-class developer.

> Anyhow, VLC gets the preferences options perfect. The UI can use a bit of work and the UX is a bit rough, but the multitude of options makes up for any shortcomings it may otherwise have.

I don't see how they're even close to "perfect". Yes, there are a lot of options, but when the average user doesn't know what options he might actually want or need to enable, that's not exactly, well, helpful. Here are a bunch of issues I have with the current set of options on the Simple page:

1. Interface: "Resize interface to video size". What in the world does this mean? If I play 1080p video on my 1600x900 monitor will the video suddenly expand beyond the monitor size and I won't be able to close it? Why would I want that?

2. Audio: "Enable audio"... er, you can already mute or set the volume to zero on your computer whether globally or for VLC itself, and you can set the volume near zero within VLC just for playback too, and you can mute the volume within VLC. Why in the world is there another option in Preferences? What's the difference? Is this supposed to be intuitive?

3. Audio: "Replay gain mode: None/Track/Album" in the "simple" options... you expect a non-"advanced" user to know what this means? And the tooltip is ever so helpful: "Select the replay gain mode"!

4. Video: "Use hardware YUV->RGB conversions"... this is a Simple setting? How/why is an average user (or even a power user) supposed to care about this? Do you ever worry about it?

5. Video: "Enable video"... er, why not just let users hide the video from the video playback (e.g. drag & collapse, or with a button)? Why in the world is this a global setting for the entire player?

6. Codecs: "x264 preset and tuning selection"... even as a developer I have literally no idea what "ultrafast" and "slower" and "placebo" as well as what "film" or "psnr" or "grain" imply, or why I would ever need to change them. Isn't this a clearly advanced setting? These are the kinds of drop-down options you expect to a hastily-written GUI front-end of a command-line tool that just expects the user to "know" the right thing to do somehow.

etc.

Putting all possible options there is half the battle. The harder part is making it so the user would actually use them. VLC still has a long ways to go for the latter, unless its target audience is multimedia experts.

Re:VLC maintainer has refused “several tens of millions of E... by bigbugbag on Saturday September 30, 2017 @04:19PM (#15374814)
Same here. VLC UX/UI has been a nightmare from the start, in the early days when it was the counterpart to IIRC VLS we eventually gave up on VLC to use mplayer instead.

Don't get me wrong VLC is an incredibly useful and great software available on many platforms, both UI and UX have improved a lot since the early days but still confusing. This arguably bad UX is the reason VLC is a second class citizen to MPC-HC / smplayer on all the computers I maintain.

Re:VLC maintainer has refused “several tens of millions of E... by jbk on Sunday October 01, 2017 @10:30AM (#15378001)
Sorry, but I hate those kind of posts. They are just vague and don't say anything useful...

What part is confusing? What is confusing in VLC that is not in the other ones? The main UI has max 10 buttons.

Especially when comparing with MPC-HC and smplayer and mplayer, which are 3 different look, UI and UX...

Sorry, you just sound like the usual hater...

Re:VLC maintainer has refused “several tens of millions of E... by jbergstroem on Saturday September 30, 2017 @06:38PM (#15375341)
You might find IINA on macOS refreshing: https://github.com/lhc70000/iina

(note: I understand that linking to other software might come off as offensive, but I truly feel there is a place for both. VLC is pretty much irreplaceable for many, many things)

Re:VLC maintainer has refused “several tens of millions of E... by NicoJuicy on Saturday September 30, 2017 @08:08AM (#15372489)
Time to donate https://www.videolan.org/contribute.html#money

Thanks VLC team for all the good years !

Re:VLC maintainer has refused “several tens of millions of E... by VMG on Saturday September 30, 2017 @08:15AM (#15372513)
I love it when the Bitcoin QR code is just right there. Donated 10mbtc
Re:VLC maintainer has refused “several tens of millions of E... by mrb on Saturday September 30, 2017 @10:55AM (#15373103)
Ditto, I donated 5 mbtc. I love the zero-friction experience of paying in bitcoins. Click the link, instantly opens my wallet, type amount and hit send. Done.

No need to wait for a slow site to load and having to click through multiple confirmation screens (Paypal)...

Re:VLC maintainer has refused “several tens of millions of E... by KekDemaga on Saturday September 30, 2017 @11:07AM (#15373166)
Paypal is two clicks now. Click buy on the site you are buying from, PayPal loads and logs you in automatically, confirm the amount and click pay.
Re:VLC maintainer has refused “several tens of millions of E... by hujokilom on Saturday September 30, 2017 @11:29AM (#15373291)
God forbid you attempt a donation to a party PayPal doesn't like, they will just seize your assets.
Re:VLC maintainer has refused “several tens of millions of E... by KekDemaga on Saturday September 30, 2017 @11:53AM (#15373440)
I can only talk about Paypal from the payer side it's virtually frictionless in my experience and transactions can be disputed via Paypal or my bank. Buying and using bitcoin adds a number of extra steps as well as transaction costs in moving dollars into bitcoin as well as giving me no dispute mechanism.
Re:VLC maintainer has refused “several tens of millions of E... by mrb on Saturday September 30, 2017 @03:14PM (#15374555)
Paypal is pretty frictionless, but it still takes ~15-20 sec to do the 3 clicks through 3 slow-to-load Paypal pages (1: paypal button, 2: page to specify amount, 3: confirmation page). By contrast, a click on the Bitcoin address opens my local Bitcoin wallet which opens up instantaneously, and clicking send is also instantaneous. Total ~3 sec. The difference between ~15-20 and ~3 sec is enough to make me prefer BTC over Paypal.

I don't need the ability to dispute: I am not going to change my mind later about this donation.

I don't need to buy BTC: like many bitcoin users I already have some in my possession, ready to be spent at any time.

Re:VLC maintainer has refused “several tens of millions of E... by moonchrome on Saturday September 30, 2017 @08:17PM (#15375715)
How long does it take for the payment to go through ? What's the fee ?

For a donation transfer speed doesn't matter, but for actual purchase it's a lot more than 30 s last I've tried

Re:VLC maintainer has refused “several tens of millions of E... by mrb on Sunday October 01, 2017 @01:55PM (#15378927)
The payment is broadcasted instantly (1-2 seconds). Fee can be as low as $0.10-0.30 (eg. these donations to the VLC address https://blockchain.info/tx/99ee82b2b8f33ee22c6c51ff4ba198141... https://blockchain.info/tx/d056b36bdb81f70cf344d4489ba337ad1... https://blockchain.info/tx/445ba8e7559a4f83bcd7fd7adac30cf9f...).

It's important to understand the difference between a broadcasted transaction (tx received by most Bitcoin nodes, "0-confirmation", 1-2 seconds) versus the transaction being included in at least 1 block ("1 confirmation", ~10 minutes). Some merchants accept 0-confirmation tx, while others require 1 confirmation. But in almost all cases it's fine to accept 0-confirmation transactions:

• ordering physical goods online (an order takes more than ~10 minutes to be shipped & delivered anyway)

• ordering virtual goods/services (eg. paying for VPN: the vendor can simply cancel the service if the tx is never confirmed)

• any low-value real-world transaction (eg. paying for groceries... no one will bother with a double-spend attack to steal groceries)

• etc

Re:VLC maintainer has refused “several tens of millions of E... by michaelmrose on Saturday September 30, 2017 @02:14PM (#15374180)
PayPal also collects money in the name of charitable organizations not affiliated with PayPal who didn't ask PayPal to do so.

If they don't check with PayPal to discover this the money is given to a different organization.

Re:VLC maintainer has refused “several tens of millions of E... by exikyut on Tuesday October 03, 2017 @01:33AM (#15390400)
Wait, what? How is that legal?!
Re:VLC maintainer has refused “several tens of millions of E... by wyager on Saturday September 30, 2017 @11:39AM (#15373346)
Until they freeze your account or ban you for some silly reason.
Re:VLC maintainer has refused “several tens of millions of E... by jbk on Saturday September 30, 2017 @08:25AM (#15372544)
Thanks a lot. Really cool.
Re:VLC maintainer has refused “several tens of millions of E... by fmx on Saturday September 30, 2017 @08:56AM (#15372651)
I couldn't decide how much to donate, so I decided to donate RANDBETWEEN(1, 50) euros.
Re:VLC maintainer has refused “several tens of millions of E... by vintageseltzer on Saturday September 30, 2017 @11:54AM (#15373448)
Thank you. VLC is a near-perfect product. I love the focus on utility, speed, and simplicity and nothing else. It is the WinAmp of video. It seems like you know what you're doing, but please resist pressure to iTunes-ify what you've built.
Re:VLC maintainer has refused “several tens of millions of E... by jbk on Saturday September 30, 2017 @12:59PM (#15373778)
> but please resist pressure to iTunes-ify what you've built.

What would be iTunes-ifying it?

Re:VLC maintainer has refused “several tens of millions of E... by vintageseltzer on Saturday September 30, 2017 @04:00PM (#15374732)
Early iTunes was pretty nice — a lightweight, focused music player and not much else. Over time it became slow, unusable bloatware — an iPhone/iPad backup / sync manager, an e-commerce / ad platform (iTunes store), a social media platform (Ping), a way for Apple to automatically tag/categorize/mess up your library, among others. I'm not sure if it's better now, I abandoned it years ago.
Re:VLC maintainer has refused “several tens of millions of E... by sdenton4 on Saturday September 30, 2017 @03:23PM (#15374592)
I imagine they mean adding a pile of content management bloat...
Re:VLC maintainer has refused “several tens of millions of E... by jbk on Sunday October 01, 2017 @10:31AM (#15378010)
OK, but a media library can be lean, can it not?
Re:VLC maintainer has refused “several tens of millions of E... by Can_Not on Saturday September 30, 2017 @10:19PM (#15376049)
I associate iTunes with useless bloat and loss of user control. My experience has exclusively been with windows and I've never purchased a device that requires iTunes to sync. Before iTunes came out, applications like foobar/winamp/Windows Media player were already loaded fast, used low resources, stable, and performant. iTunes was not. Before iTunes, you would copy your mp3s to your device. With iTunes you had a mysterious syncing process. Stories about requiring a 3 hour sync to add one new song or your entire collection being deleted were not uncommon. There was DRM in the early days. I surely wasn't going to switch from my pre-iTunes system to a system with DRM for literally no other additional value. If I knew that advanced options were missing, I'd include that in my complaints, too.
Re:VLC maintainer has refused “several tens of millions of E... by johnhenry on Saturday September 30, 2017 @08:56AM (#15372649)
Re:VLC maintainer has refused “several tens of millions of E... by Iv on Saturday September 30, 2017 @07:56AM (#15372444)
On te le redit ici, t'es un putain de héros mec.
Re:VLC maintainer has refused “several tens of millions of E... by jbk on Saturday September 30, 2017 @08:04AM (#15372474)
Ahah. No.

Les héros de l'Internet, c'est Aaron Swartz, Jimmy Wales et Sam Hocevar. Pas moi :)

Re:VLC maintainer has refused “several tens of millions of E... by bigbugbag on Saturday September 30, 2017 @04:20PM (#15374818)
Jimmy wales is not an internet hero, not even close.
[dead]
Re:VLC maintainer has refused “several tens of millions of E... by jbk on Saturday September 30, 2017 @08:25AM (#15372543)
You say that some people are heroes without believing that everything they are doing is amazing. Life is not black-and-white.
[dead]
Re:VLC maintainer has refused “several tens of millions of E... by jbk on Saturday September 30, 2017 @08:38AM (#15372592)
I believe this is very off-topic, and I have no idea what you are talking about. And I doubt it is the right place for that.
Re:VLC maintainer has refused “several tens of millions of E... by aptwebapps on Saturday September 30, 2017 @08:43AM (#15372605)
I'm not very well informed about this stuff, but you aren't confusing Hocevar with Weev, are you? I thought he was the one accused wrt Kathy Sierra.
Re:VLC maintainer has refused “several tens of millions of E... by throwawayknecht on Saturday September 30, 2017 @11:53AM (#15373442)
Hocevar was a member of Auernheimer's trolling organization, the GNAA, during that time and after.
Re:VLC maintainer has refused “several tens of millions of E... by Spare_account on Saturday September 30, 2017 @08:14AM (#15372508)
Forgive my naivety, but which one?
Re:VLC maintainer has refused “several tens of millions of E... by sametmax on Saturday September 30, 2017 @08:02AM (#15372467)
+1

And all the VLC people are.

I made a donation to VLC and encourage every people to do so.

You rock.

Re:VLC maintainer has refused “several tens of millions of E... by makapuf on Saturday September 30, 2017 @04:44PM (#15374900)
hey, nice seeing some of the usual suspects of the french internet here (aka the real french tech ;)
Re:VLC maintainer has refused “several tens of millions of E... by sametmax on Saturday September 30, 2017 @06:01PM (#15375206)
We are everywhere, there are dozens of us. Dozens !
Re:VLC maintainer has refused “several tens of millions of E... by Iv on Sunday October 01, 2017 @09:53AM (#15377801)
Heard in Tokyo a few week ago from a US CEO: "Why the hell are there so many french guys doing AI in Tokyo ?!?"
Re:VLC maintainer has refused “several tens of millions of E... by sharpercoder on Saturday September 30, 2017 @10:14AM (#15372922)
Have you considered accepting money on certain terms and subsequently using that money to do improvements? A couple millions can get quite far in improving certain aspects of the software, like UX, documentation etc.

It seems to me that your response was seemingly the right moral thing to do. However, I can also see a lot of practical benefits of having a pile of cash to improve open software.

Re:VLC maintainer has refused “several tens of millions of E... by jbk on Saturday September 30, 2017 @01:00PM (#15373780)
> Have you considered accepting money on certain terms and subsequently using that money to do improvements? A couple millions can get quite far in improving certain aspects of the software, like UX, documentation etc.

Yes, I did. But only if the terms are fine and moral. That never happened.

Re:VLC maintainer has refused “several tens of millions of E... by AsyncAwait on Saturday September 30, 2017 @04:30PM (#15374847)
Thanks for taking the moral stance, even in the face of loosing access to millions of euros, much appreciated!
Re:VLC maintainer has refused “several tens of millions of E... by cgb223 on Saturday September 30, 2017 @03:42PM (#15374677)
Thanks so much for doing this

I’ve been using VLC for 6 years and nothing has compared.

When do you expect the cast to chromecast feature to make it into the stable build for Mac?

Re:VLC maintainer has refused “several tens of millions of E... by hmate9 on Saturday September 30, 2017 @02:31PM (#15374287)
I will appreciate VLC 100x as much from now on.
Re:VLC maintainer has refused “several tens of millions of E... by camus2 on Saturday September 30, 2017 @11:05AM (#15373153)
Merci pour le taff! fallait prendre la thune ;)

Thanks for your work, you should have taken the money ;)

Seriously it just means that your work is that valuable.

Re:VLC maintainer has refused “several tens of millions of E... by punnerud on Saturday September 30, 2017 @02:30PM (#15374284)
Actually reinstalled VLC two days ago, after two years without it. Still freel I use Google a lot to find settings/features I know VLC have (also one of the reasons back).

jbk, you have a lot of good submissions. To bad I haven’t seen more of them up on the HN-board.

Added to my donation list too.

Re:VLC maintainer has refused “several tens of millions of E... by jbk on Sunday October 01, 2017 @10:33AM (#15378021)
> jbk, you have a lot of good submissions. To bad I haven’t seen more of them up on the HN-board.

Well, I'm not pushing a lot...

Re:VLC maintainer has refused “several tens of millions of E... by trapperkeeper74 on Saturday September 30, 2017 @11:07AM (#15373169)
VLC is awesome! :D I use the iOS and macOS versions often. Thank you^10.
Re:VLC maintainer has refused “several tens of millions of E... by productboy on Saturday September 30, 2017 @05:41PM (#15375123)
In awe of your fine work, gracias. BTW: The settings UX is my favorite aspect of VLC. It's like if NASA designed a video player.

I only have ETH in my wallet... will try to donate later.

Re:VLC maintainer has refused “several tens of millions of E... by ericd on Saturday September 30, 2017 @07:50PM (#15375609)
Thanks for ending what used to be a bimonthly cycle of trying to find codecs while trying to avoid malware. VLC is now one of my first downloads on any fresh OS install.
Re:VLC maintainer has refused “several tens of millions of E... by senectus1 on Saturday September 30, 2017 @08:58AM (#15372657)
you, sir are a legend
Re:VLC maintainer has refused “several tens of millions of E... by gpvos on Saturday September 30, 2017 @12:28PM (#15373611)
So, how about the several offers to have your babies, did you accept any?
Re:VLC maintainer has refused “several tens of millions of E... by jbk on Saturday September 30, 2017 @01:01PM (#15373784)
Haha, no. Those people were phonies! Do you believe that?
Re:VLC maintainer has refused “several tens of millions of E... by gpvos on Saturday September 30, 2017 @02:31PM (#15374286)
Nah, not really. :)
Re:VLC maintainer has refused “several tens of millions of E... by amigoingtodie on Saturday September 30, 2017 @08:28AM (#15372559)
Can you fix uPNP browsing?
Re:VLC maintainer has refused “several tens of millions of E... by jbk on Saturday September 30, 2017 @08:30AM (#15372564)
Yep. Fixed in 3.0. Along with FTP, SFTP, SMB and NFS browsing.
Re:VLC maintainer has refused “several tens of millions of E... by trapperkeeper74 on Saturday September 30, 2017 @11:09AM (#15373176)
Cool! Google Drive integration on iOS stopped working. Other than that, works awesome.
Re:VLC maintainer has refused “several tens of millions of E... by jbk on Saturday September 30, 2017 @01:00PM (#15373781)
No, it is fixed for 2.8.4
Re:VLC maintainer has refused “several tens of millions of E... by amigoingtodie on Sunday October 01, 2017 @07:06PM (#15380429)
Awesome work, sir.
Re:VLC maintainer has refused “several tens of millions of E... by agumonkey on Saturday September 30, 2017 @07:27AM (#15372339)
Any new funding attempts btw ?
Re:VLC maintainer has refused “several tens of millions of E... by jbk on Saturday September 30, 2017 @08:03AM (#15372470)
Serious people offering money? A couple. Clean business models? none.

Spyware and hacking is not a clean business model, as far as I am concerned.

But, you know, you can invest in my startup, if you prefer :)

Re:VLC maintainer has refused “several tens of millions of E... by agumonkey on Saturday September 30, 2017 @08:23AM (#15372540)
Oh no I meant like kickstarter, or any other similar platform.

Emacs Magit author just finished one. People gave enough for him to work for about a year.

Re:VLC maintainer has refused “several tens of millions of E... by ekimekim on Saturday September 30, 2017 @08:53AM (#15372643)
I feel like Patreon would be a good fit here.
Re:VLC maintainer has refused “several tens of millions of E... by agumonkey on Saturday September 30, 2017 @09:07AM (#15372680)
It's the most cited in the recent months.
Re:VLC maintainer has refused “several tens of millions of E... by tiernano on Saturday September 30, 2017 @09:28AM (#15372767)
I’d back it!
Re:VLC maintainer has refused “several tens of millions of E... by foepys on Saturday September 30, 2017 @01:58PM (#15374095)
Why? Just setup a recurring donation via Paypal or something else. Giving Patreon 30% (or whatever they take) is completely unnecessary.

Patreon also requires creators to regularly post updates and provide goodies to their subscribers. What could the VLC developers even give to their subscribers except publicly available changelogs? The devs should - and I believe also want to - rather develop the player instead of thinking about what to give to maybe 50 people on Patreon every other week.

Re:VLC maintainer has refused “several tens of millions of E... by michaelmrose on Saturday September 30, 2017 @02:17PM (#15374203)
It's aprox 5%. Are you a PayPal employee or just making stuff up for no good reason.
Re:VLC maintainer has refused “several tens of millions of E... by foepys on Saturday September 30, 2017 @04:31PM (#15374852)
No, I am not, I don't even have a Paypal account because I personally don't trust them. But even 5% is too much, Paypal takes about 2% without the _mandatory_ goodie stuff for subscribers. Furthermore, Patreon actually takes 10% because of "5% transaction fees" plus their 5% share - following your logic, you must be a Patreon employee...

It's better to send donations via SWIFT anyway but most Americans here can use Paypal a lot easier right now instead of waiting for a never coming Patreon campaign or complicated wire transfers with high fees.

Re:VLC maintainer has refused “several tens of millions of E... by DonbunEf7 on Saturday September 30, 2017 @05:22PM (#15375051)
In the USA, people are used to 5% off the top. Relax already.
Re:VLC maintainer has refused “several tens of millions of E... by ekimekim on Saturday September 30, 2017 @10:46PM (#15376102)
Source on 'mandatory goodies'? I know of plenty of patreon pages where the only tier is "Reward ($1.00): My thanks for your support"
Re:VLC maintainer has refused “several tens of millions of E... by hackbinary on Saturday September 30, 2017 @02:46PM (#15374386)
Andrew Godwin who wrote South, then the built-in Django migrations library did a very successful kickstarter.

https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/andrewgodwin/schema-mig...

Re:VLC maintainer has refused “several tens of millions of E... by slipstream- on Saturday September 30, 2017 @10:24AM (#15372958)
I'd actually be interested to see the pitches made by these kinds of people...
[dead]
Re:VLC maintainer has refused “several tens of millions of E... by make3 on Saturday September 30, 2017 @04:15PM (#15374799)
you mean she decided to leave you for him. girlfriends are people who make their own decisions, not things, and as such can't be stolen.
Re:VLC maintainer has refused “several tens of millions of E... by bigbugbag on Saturday September 30, 2017 @04:27PM (#15374840)
Of course people are not things, this is an expression.

Allow me to rephrase that: When you fuck an other guy girlfriend behind his back, you're an ass. Specially when you fuck the girl at her boyfriend place and later get her to leave him for you. VLC creator did exactly that.

Re:VLC maintainer has refused “several tens of millions of E... by make3 on Saturday September 30, 2017 @04:38PM (#15374880)
He didn't get her to leave for you is what I'm saying. She would be the ass for deciding to have sex with someone else behind your back. He his surely not responsible for her decisions, as she is a human being with full decision making capabilities. And he didn't get her to leave. She chose to leave. All of this is her responsibility, not his.
Re:VLC maintainer has refused “several tens of millions of E... by bigbugbag on Saturday September 30, 2017 @05:02PM (#15374971)
I understand your point and it would make sense about a general hypothetical case, but it start to unravel quickly when you get into the real world, for example would you still consider a drunk human being as having full decision making capabilities ? Would you consider fucking a drunk girl to be some kind of abuse or that she used her full decision making capabilities and the responsibility lies with her exclusively ?

I'm pretty sure you're talking about something you don't even know the beginning of. I won't get into details, let's just say I know what happened and how it happened and that I know what I'm saying when I say what I say.

Re:VLC maintainer has refused “several tens of millions of E... by malmsteen on Saturday September 30, 2017 @10:18AM (#15372933)
Et euh, pourquoi ne pas accepter et ten foutre car c'est open source donc qqun le forke ou tu le fais toi même ?

translate: why not accept and not care because opensource so someone fork or even yourself on the long term