I really can't trust any closed-source OS, and very few closed-source applications.
But at its logical conclusion, this idea puts up some serious practical barriers. Even if you only use an OS that you’ve personally audited, and even if you’ve gotten past the potential Thompsonian compiler issues, you’re still left with a minefield of possibly-adversarial pieces of software that might interfere with your computing experience.
Have you audited your BIOS/UEFI firmware [0]? Your CPU’s microcode [1]? Your WiFi/Bluetooth adapter’s firmware [2]? Your HDD controller’s firmware [3]?
I acknowledge that I’m advancing something of a “slippery slope” argument here, but I still care about the question. Where do you draw the line? Obviously being able to audit all of it yourself perfectly would be awesome. But to me that just seems impossible. So how much is enough?
EDIT: beaten by astrodust!
[0] https://www.pcworld.com/article/2948092/security/hacking-tea...
[1] https://www.dcddcc.com/docs/2014_paper_microcode.pdf
You can't win. Make compromises that are reasonable.
When it's so easy to use a community-vetted Linux distribution, I think "reasonable" gets shunted down a layer.
It's not all or nothing. Every reasonable step counts.
i wonder if this sort of confidence makes you less-safe. something like this should've prevented heartbleed, in theory, right?
You and your friend down there seemingly have more faith that a closed source process, what, would have identified this bug before it was deployed? Why? That it would have been found by good actors first? Why? That it would have been fixed promptly? Why? Announced with disclosure of its existence and ramifications? Why?
It's not a money question for this stuff either. There are hundreds if not thousands of paid engineers for known good-actors all working to break and responsibly disclose security issues in the same software stack I use.
The only thing you know about the comings and goings of closed source software is when public disclosure happens (and it's later fixed). Why would I be more confident in that process? It's not good enough.
Open-source is not inherently better or worse, it's all a matter of motivation on the part of the developers.
Recompile on compilers B and C and compare results. Or on CPUs Y and Z.
In reality, there will almost certainly be differences (different compiling algos, different CPU instruction sets), but if you can pinpoint behavioural distinctions or encoding distinctions which are not explained by known compile or instruction-set distinctions, well, you've got something interesting to explore.
The point being that you don't have to descend the entire stack of turtles. Just compare different stacks of turtles.
As much as I appriciate the sentiment, I have to admit I personally gave up trusting OSS for the soul reason that I / someone might be able to read and understand it.
Your concern seems like a security negative.
Also, Apple has demonstrated a great deal of care in the statistics we know they collect, eg by making it impossible to determine your actual input while collecting aggregate statistics.
So it is a theoretical concern, but in any practical threat model, it's also a better concern to have than the alternatives.
Who? Who do you think I accept abuse from?
Or the terribleness of Android (-- I certainly wouldn't pick it over iOS for security reasons).
Apple could care less about the privacy of its users. https://www.cultofmac.com/230358/everything-you-need-to-know...
Is everyone going to pay 3$ / month every website? Apple should have fixed that first, but is now blocking everyone because their own iAd failed. I think a lot is going to blow up, eg. Apple users requiring membership for websites + a subscription.
What if those companies suddenly require an email to read more content, then their backend syncs all the required data. ( yes, we will submit a fake email, but a lot of people won't)
Also, i see >1/2 of the frontpage from these "ad supported companies" that "everyone" hates, i don't want more paywalled articles appearing here...
I can understand blocking the ever cookie. But this is probably a bridge too far, i don't want to see more paywalled articles on HN.
And yeah, this will not be a popular opinion here... I'd appreciate responding with arguments instead of down voting :)
Edit: Failed, downvoting begins as expected
People aren't unhappy that ads exist, they are unhappy that ads (and ad networks in general) run rough trod over their privacy, and track them everywhere that they go.
Unless you believe that ads /only/ work if the advertiser knows your age, sex, religion, political affiliation, your living arrangements, your relationship with your family, ....
I would argue that the current obsession with tracking users has not only violate our privacy but also made the ads worse. e.g.
I once bought a washing machine over the internet. For about 6 months I continued to get ads offering me deals to apparently help me expand my new washing machine collection. It didn't matter what I was looking at, the sum total of what they got from all of the information they collected is that while looking at books I was secretly yearning for more washing machines.
None the less, i think it's usefull to know the age, sex and interests of readers ( small client websites with some blogs).
Religion, political affiliation, your living arrangements, your relationship with your family, ... are none of the concern.
But i'm not sure that people are unhappy that ads are there. They just don't want to see them, without knowing why they are there or that it's privacy related ... ( subjective opinion of working with a lot of consumers)
I've even worked literally trafficking ads.
Targeting any more specific than a good contextual match is usually a waste and not any more effective. Advertisers do not need this information and should not be given it. The agreement is that they show an ad in return for you seeing the page, that does not (and should not) mean that they get access to any more information than is absolutely necessary to display said ad.
If I go onto a site about bikes, I expect to see bike ads. If I go on a tech/programming site, I expect to see tech/programming ads. I don't like going somewhere and seeing random ads for something unrelated to where I am because some advertiser thought I might like Caribbean holidays or something. The solution is not to give them more of your information just so they can "serve you a better ad" (a trade that they benefit off far more than you do), the solution is for them to advertise contextually.
I'd like to believe this. But why then does user tracking adtech exist? Why is the advertising industry opposed to this move to limit user tracking? Advertisers (the ones paying $ for adtech) are conned? Can you point at evidence for your claim?
+1 from me for admitting it. That's the first step. Good luck!
A user doesn't want site A knowing that they went to site B, and that is what tracking based ads appear to be to the user. In reality it's even worse because while sites A & B, which the user does trust, don't know it is in fact a separate business they've never seen or heard of that know about you visiting A and B. and also C, D, E....
Yes, we ( HN readers), don't want them tracking us. So that is what you think it is. But we are only a "small" percentage.
Non-HN readers ( mostly non-technical readers), just don't want to see ads and don't want to pay. They also don't know how the tracking works and mostly don't care ( in my experience)
See:
Jonathan Albright: "Who Hacked the Election? Ad Tech did. Through “Fake News,” Identity Resolution and Hyper-Personalization" https://medium.com/@d1gi/who-hacked-the-election-43d4019f705...
Robert McChesney, Communication Revolution (an excellent history of media failures): http://www.worldcat.org/title/communication-revolution-criti...
And, one of my personal favourites, a brief, very readable, and information-packed 1909 account, Hamilton Holt's Commercialism and Journalism: https://archive.org/details/commercialismjou00holtuoft'
As to what to replace this with: treat information as the public good it is:
https://www.reddit.com/r/dredmorbius/comments/1uotb3/a_modes...
The last ad I clicked was an image, organically hosted and relevant to the web site.
It seems this is not about commerce - selling goods and services - but about malware, scams and PR by giant corporations for "low information" people.
Cue the ad industry apologists: how would I know about their great products? I would research something I NEED (not WANT) WHEN I need it.
The Deck was a great option while it lasted.
So, in summary, I'll repeat the ad blocker discussion: I don't care if a lot of sites that depend on ad revenue go under. I've done just fine without network TV and cable for the last ten years, I'll do alright if I don't get the latest from OutBrain.
Yet they still serve me ads and 3rd-party tracking scripts when I'm logged in.
Increasingly, I'm becoming unhappy with this and I will soon write to NYTimes.com to complain about this.
If I'm paying for access to your website I don't want to see ads. Ever.
At the very least, make ads opt-outable for subscribers.
I don't have cable also and OutBrain / Taboola really suck. Don't visit buzzfeed and don't pay currently for articles. Because i pay them with ads.
I'd like to see numbers of how much people actually pay for content, before i believe that "the old way" works on the web 15 years later and with a lot more competition... I already hate the paywalled gardens that sometimes show up on HN. The problem will only get worse
One argument is that they're using the dreck to subsidise this. I don't know if that's long-term sustainable, but it's an interesting approach.
There's a long (nearly 200 year) history of this in journalism, dating to the Penny Press of ~1830. See Tim Wu's Attention Merchants.
There's so much good content that I just don't care if the ad-supported stuff dies. In its absence, free community-driven sites will have a reason to exist and paid options will stand a fighting chance. Maybe magazine-style non-tracking ads will be viable again. Anything that doesn't make the transition to one of those models doesn't matter to me—I don't have anywhere near enough time for it all as it is.
All of these are ad-supported for the content. I think most people don't have a correct interpretation of what it is to have money to pay journalists for articles and then get paid for content through ads, because 99,9% of the people won't pay a subscription.
Fyi, the public content is paid by ads right now and most of them have a digital-subscription on the side.
The change, cookies can't track users. Will probably be a loss of ad revenue per user, more companies that will have paid subscriptions and a lot of knowledge / news / interesting stories will be behind a paywall --> Personal opinion.
If you only need a encyclopedia, then you don't need to pay anywhere or "free payment through ads". If you sometimes scroll HN and read content for free, then i'm not sure if the content, that you want to read, is only available on Wikipedia.
I think a lot of that content is actually produced by paid journalists, that work for big media companies.
It was one example, not every single free thing on the Internet that I find highly valuable. Open source would be another, which is mostly supported by volunteers and straight-up paying customers.
> If you only need a encyclopedia, then you don't need to pay anywhere or "free payment through ads". If you sometimes scroll HN and read content for free, then i'm not sure if the content, that you want to read, is only available on Wikipedia.
HN is mostly a replacement for playing Minesweeper or is displacing doing something actually valuable. Or hanging out on IRC. If I actually need news I'd be fine with paying for it (I mostly don't, though).
> I think a lot of that content is actually produced by paid journalists, that work for big media companies.
We had those (journalists, big media companies) before spying ads were a thing. We'd have them after. You think that, for some reason, if no one can use spying ads anymore, that'll mean the end of online media? Or even just online news? Or that Internet advertising would even do more than hiccup for a moment and keep going? Think about it: you're responsible for advertising at Coca Cola. Tracking ads go away, everywhere, for everyone. Do you stop spending ad dollars online? No, obviously not.
My guess is the result would be a concentration of ad dollars on bigger sites, with little or no reduction in total spending. Probably more shitty "native advertising" too, especially for smaller players, which sucks, but we already have tons of that so oh well. Point is, we've all been pining for the days when news orgs had actual money to spend on reporters, and I'd not be a bit surprised if eliminating tracking gave bigger players enough of an advantage that those days came back.
Paying customers receive more value in most cases, it's not the same content. A good reference is a paywall in this case. I love open source, but how many people get a wage out of it? You only see success stories here and not that much I'm afraid.
+ I don't know any newspaper online that earns money without ads or subscriptions. For now, there are only 2 business models and currently subscriptions gain importance -> paywalls
>if no one can use spying ads anymore, that'll mean the end of online media? Or even just online news?
My guess is more paywall. Interesting articles will be found less on HN
>I'd not be a bit surprised if eliminating tracking gave bigger players enough of an advantage that those days came back.
Not sure if I agree. You mean that, people will have to choose for paying for subscriptions, so the best quality articles after a paywall will get the money by creating better articles. But it leaves less space for everyone else. I'm not sure if that is a good thing, but I understand the reasoning
No. Again, paying for subscriptions would not be the only option. Internet advertising would still exist without tracking. It'd just be harder to sell as a small-time operator. Winners in a no-tracking world: large, trustworthy sites. Losers: ad networks/spying companies, small ad-supported sites.
What's more, the claim that Apple is doing this for the sake of user trust is a lie. The real reason they're breaking the functionality of cookies is the same reason they refuse to implement progressive web apps, and the same reason they've become the slowest browser to adopt new standards, and the same reason you see "Safari is the new IE" all over the place. They're deliberately trying to hold back web technology so that people will be forced to create and use native apps instead. They're desperately trying to cling to the annual developer license fees and app commissions.
I say this as a die-hard MacBook user. I prefer Apple to Microsoft, but I hope Google wins in the web-vs-native holy war.
> Not all cookies are used for tracking.
No, but third-party cookies are basically used for tracking. A legitimate site does not depend on a third-party cookie to handle features or login. At all, full stop no ifs, ands, or buts.
> Be prepared to start losing your settings in web apps or being logged out after 24 hours if you use Safari.
Again, not going to happen because those are not associated with third-party cookies.
> They're deliberately trying to hold back web technology so that people will be forced to create and use native apps instead.
God no, or there would be no icloud.com, online shopping app, or their other web offerings. There is no conspiracy or holding back, this is purely to protect the user.
> I say this as a die-hard MacBook user.
Then you should be prepared with more research and have your homework done ahead of time on this matter. This is all nonsense and just false.
Sites which use Disqus, or similar, for comments.
I hate Disqus with a passion and wish horrible flaming death upon it, and am actually quite pleased that this will break it. But nonetheless it's a "legit" use of third-party cookies to provide a feature (remembering login on an embedded commenting engine).
http://benalman.com/code/projects/jquery-postmessage/example...
I mostly just ignore it, why do you hate it with such intensity? hahah
I'd point out that in the case of DocuSign signing sessions powered by iframes that without being able to set this third party cookie prevents the session from loading. Probably the only use case of a third party cookie being useful that I can think of.
After reading the webkit blog post on ITP I had no idea they changed this, but yeah, they are probably going to anyway if haven't yet. Otherwise it'd be too easy game this.
Apple wasn’t the one that broke the “functionality” of cookies. Though I’ll allow that one could think that third-party tracking cookies were part of the original intent.
Be prepared to start losing your settings in web apps or being logged out after 24 hours if you use Safari.
Be prepared to start reading articles on how this actually works before sharpening the pitchfork. I’ll give you a hint: none of what you describe will come to pass.
If that was the intent they wouldn't have already killed the native APIs for device identifiers ages ago.
This!
I switched from Windows+Android to the Apple ecosystem in 2015. Because I love so many things about Apple products. But this alone (Apple taking measures to protect its customers' privacy concerns) is a huge huuuge selling point and a competitive advantage for them.