News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Every Major Advertising Group Is Blasting Apple for Block... by msla on Thursday September 14, 2017 @04:58PM (#15252462)
Unless I can build and install a completely custom version, it isn't open enough to be safe.
Re:Every Major Advertising Group Is Blasting Apple for Block... by egwynn on Thursday September 14, 2017 @05:43PM (#15252773)
You get my upvote, because I respect your perspective and I agree in principle.

But at its logical conclusion, this idea puts up some serious practical barriers. Even if you only use an OS that you’ve personally audited, and even if you’ve gotten past the potential Thompsonian compiler issues, you’re still left with a minefield of possibly-adversarial pieces of software that might interfere with your computing experience.

Have you audited your BIOS/UEFI firmware [0]? Your CPU’s microcode [1]? Your WiFi/Bluetooth adapter’s firmware [2]? Your HDD controller’s firmware [3]?

I acknowledge that I’m advancing something of a “slippery slope” argument here, but I still care about the question. Where do you draw the line? Obviously being able to audit all of it yourself perfectly would be awesome. But to me that just seems impossible. So how much is enough?

EDIT: beaten by astrodust!

[0] https://www.pcworld.com/article/2948092/security/hacking-tea...

[1] https://www.dcddcc.com/docs/2014_paper_microcode.pdf

[2] https://blog.exodusintel.com/2017/07/26/broadpwn/

[3] http://spritesmods.com/?art=hddhack&page=1

Re:Every Major Advertising Group Is Blasting Apple for Block... by astrodust on Thursday September 14, 2017 @05:31PM (#15252686)
Can't trust the OS without all the code. Can't trust the code if you can't trust the compiler. Can't trust the compiler if you can't trust the CPU. Can't trust the CPU if you can't trust the microcode. Can't trust the microcode unless you've visually inspected the die.

You can't win. Make compromises that are reasonable.

Re:Every Major Advertising Group Is Blasting Apple for Block... by oliwarner on Thursday September 14, 2017 @05:39PM (#15252741)
> Make compromises that are reasonable.

When it's so easy to use a community-vetted Linux distribution, I think "reasonable" gets shunted down a layer.

It's not all or nothing. Every reasonable step counts.

Re:Every Major Advertising Group Is Blasting Apple for Block... by abiox on Thursday September 14, 2017 @09:37PM (#15253921)
> community-vetted

i wonder if this sort of confidence makes you less-safe. something like this should've prevented heartbleed, in theory, right?

Re:Every Major Advertising Group Is Blasting Apple for Block... by oliwarner on Friday September 15, 2017 @03:16AM (#15255272)
It's not confidence that I'm secure, it's a belief that this software development process makes me more secure.

You and your friend down there seemingly have more faith that a closed source process, what, would have identified this bug before it was deployed? Why? That it would have been found by good actors first? Why? That it would have been fixed promptly? Why? Announced with disclosure of its existence and ramifications? Why?

It's not a money question for this stuff either. There are hundreds if not thousands of paid engineers for known good-actors all working to break and responsibly disclose security issues in the same software stack I use.

The only thing you know about the comings and goings of closed source software is when public disclosure happens (and it's later fixed). Why would I be more confident in that process? It's not good enough.

Re:Every Major Advertising Group Is Blasting Apple for Block... by scarface74 on Thursday September 14, 2017 @10:01PM (#15254020)
"Community-vetting" didn't stop the HeartBleed bug to linger for over a year.
Re:Every Major Advertising Group Is Blasting Apple for Block... by msla on Friday September 15, 2017 @11:02AM (#15257695)
And we have no idea how many bugs worse than HeartBleed haven't been found yet in closed-source software.
Re:Every Major Advertising Group Is Blasting Apple for Block... by astrodust on Friday September 15, 2017 @11:41AM (#15258043)
It depends on the development process. Some companies aggressively re-visit older code, others never look at it.

Open-source is not inherently better or worse, it's all a matter of motivation on the part of the developers.

Re:Every Major Advertising Group Is Blasting Apple for Block... by dredmorbius on Thursday September 14, 2017 @08:19PM (#15253579)
Cross-compiling and multi-device compiles are a thing.
Re:Every Major Advertising Group Is Blasting Apple for Block... by abiox on Thursday September 14, 2017 @09:39PM (#15253929)
i feel like this is just shuffling concerns rather than addressing them, but i'm open to being shown otherwise.
Re:Every Major Advertising Group Is Blasting Apple for Block... by dredmorbius on Thursday September 14, 2017 @10:20PM (#15254091)
Suppose you suspect compiler A or CPU X.

Recompile on compilers B and C and compare results. Or on CPUs Y and Z.

In reality, there will almost certainly be differences (different compiling algos, different CPU instruction sets), but if you can pinpoint behavioural distinctions or encoding distinctions which are not explained by known compile or instruction-set distinctions, well, you've got something interesting to explore.

The point being that you don't have to descend the entire stack of turtles. Just compare different stacks of turtles.

Re:Every Major Advertising Group Is Blasting Apple for Block... by astrodust on Friday September 15, 2017 @11:39AM (#15258026)
It's going to be really hard to compare binary A vs. binary B and determine functional differences. clang and gcc emit entirely different machine code, but they do their best to be functionally identical, at least as far as their respective specs are concerned.
Re:Every Major Advertising Group Is Blasting Apple for Block... by YouKnowBetter on Tuesday September 19, 2017 @03:59AM (#15282602)
You compile (After reading and understanding the source) of the firmware used on your machine? You take your time to read & understand the millions lines of code of all libraries needed? You know & trust your compiler?

As much as I appriciate the sentiment, I have to admit I personally gave up trusting OSS for the soul reason that I / someone might be able to read and understand it.