News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:KIA Dealership in Canada remotely disables car over $200 fee by sandworm101 on Tuesday August 29, 2017 @12:02PM (#15125189)
Note that every canadian pundit is rightly calling this illegal. Disabling a car they no longer had any title over was a mistake and everyone knows it. That said, cars are disabled every day for non-payment of even smaller amounts. These lockouts are vicious tools.
Re:KIA Dealership in Canada remotely disables car over $200 fee by pkulak on Tuesday August 29, 2017 @01:09PM (#15125799)
It's part of an entire industry that re-labels auto "rentals" as "sales":

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4U2eDJnwz_s

Re:KIA Dealership in Canada remotely disables car over $200 fee by lordlimecat on Tuesday August 29, 2017 @06:17PM (#15128109)
At some point, you have to assign at least some of the responsibility to the folks getting loans they cannot afford. It doesn't make predatory lending right, but lets not dehumanize or patronize the victims by implying they lack agency or responsibility.

Stinks that the woman's commute is an hour and a half, but come on there are a LOT of people who do that commute. Reducing the commute to 10 minutes is not necessity, and does not excuse throwing judgement out of the window.

Re:KIA Dealership in Canada remotely disables car over $200 fee by fish_fan on Tuesday August 29, 2017 @01:42PM (#15126097)
Any non video link?
Re:KIA Dealership in Canada remotely disables car over $200 fee by SilasX on Tuesday August 29, 2017 @01:57PM (#15126226)
Yes, in this case it was wrong, but how are you equating it with the general case?

The loan was only extended in the first case on the understanding that you would lose access in case of non-payment. Had they not been able to revoke access, they would not have given the loan, or would have given it at a higher rate.

Are you saying you should be able to just walk away with a car and forget your obligation to give it back?

Re:KIA Dealership in Canada remotely disables car over $200 fee by djmobley on Tuesday August 29, 2017 @12:42PM (#15125555)
I'm no expert on Canadian law, but if I were the dealership I would have had a clause in the contract requiring return of the GPS tracker as a condition of title being transferred (in addition to payment of any outstanding amounts on the loan)

How else are you going to get the tracker back?

Re:KIA Dealership in Canada remotely disables car over $200 fee by maxerickson on Tuesday August 29, 2017 @12:45PM (#15125578)
They additionally wanted to charge for removing the device.

The way I read it, the vehicle owner didn't object to providing them access to remove the device, he objected to paying them to remove their device.

Re:KIA Dealership in Canada remotely disables car over $200 fee by djmobley on Tuesday August 29, 2017 @12:54PM (#15125667)
Ultimately it's a question of whether the contract allowed them to demand the fee, and disable the vehicle for non payment.

Nobody involved in writing this article seems to have consulted this particular contract, but I wouldn't find the existence of such a contract unbelievable, nor the terms particularly unreasonable.

Re:KIA Dealership in Canada remotely disables car over $200 fee by icebraining on Tuesday August 29, 2017 @01:12PM (#15125826)
Nope, if the law says they can't disable the car for such a debt - as the article states - then the contract is irrelevant.
Re:KIA Dealership in Canada remotely disables car over $200 fee by djmobley on Tuesday August 29, 2017 @01:29PM (#15125977)
That's not what the article states.
Re:KIA Dealership in Canada remotely disables car over $200 fee by icebraining on Tuesday August 29, 2017 @01:37PM (#15126054)
George Iny, president of the Automobile Protection Association, said Quebec has strict rules on how GPS immobilizers can be used. In this case, he said, the dealership's actions were against the law because it no longer owned the car.

Seems clear to me. What am I missing?

Re:KIA Dealership in Canada remotely disables car over $200 fee by djmobley on Tuesday August 29, 2017 @01:50PM (#15126163)
One of the points requiring clarification here is whether the dealer did in fact cede title of the car before the disagreement over the GPS tracker.

If they retained ownership (which is quite plausible, given the disagreement over the fees), Iny's interpretation of the law is irrelevant.

Re:KIA Dealership in Canada remotely disables car over $200 fee by icebraining on Tuesday August 29, 2017 @01:55PM (#15126197)
Why are you assuming that the law lets them decide at all whether to cede the title? His statement is unambiguous: "To turn off somebody's vehicle after he had already paid off the loan is clearly illegal."
Re:KIA Dealership in Canada remotely disables car over $200 fee by djmobley on Tuesday August 29, 2017 @02:05PM (#15126295)
You can't just throw money at a lease provider and automatically gain ownership of an asset.

Lease providers can and will impose conditions. Like early repayment fees. Or fees for the return of GPS trackers...

Re:KIA Dealership in Canada remotely disables car over $200 fee by icebraining on Tuesday August 29, 2017 @02:13PM (#15126368)
How long have you been versed in Québécois law?
Re:KIA Dealership in Canada remotely disables car over $200 fee by maxerickson on Tuesday August 29, 2017 @02:17PM (#15126405)
This back and forth isn't accomplishing anything.

More info needed to decide who has a better hand wavy interpretation of the information that is available.

Re:KIA Dealership in Canada remotely disables car over $200 fee by kobeya on Tuesday August 29, 2017 @02:01PM (#15126260)
The question is whether the fee is considered part of the loan.
Re:KIA Dealership in Canada remotely disables car over $200 fee by icebraining on Tuesday August 29, 2017 @02:10PM (#15126337)
Well, the guy said in this case it's illegal. We can suppose the president of the Automobile Protection Association hasn't thought about an obvious question that occurs to any of us, of course, but still, right or not the article answers the question.
Re:KIA Dealership in Canada remotely disables car over $200 fee by moioci on Tuesday August 29, 2017 @01:00PM (#15125718)
He said there was no mention of it in the contract, and no one from the dealership has disputed that.
Re:KIA Dealership in Canada remotely disables car over $200 fee by djmobley on Tuesday August 29, 2017 @01:04PM (#15125764)
The borrower claims the contract made no mention of the fee, and the dealer did not provide any comment for the article.

The dealer backed down quickly over the fee, but that doesn't mean they didn't have a right to request the sum.

Re:KIA Dealership in Canada remotely disables car over $200 fee by admax88q on Tuesday August 29, 2017 @01:43PM (#15126107)
> they didn't have a right to request the sum.

Why do all discussions like this on hacker news come down to debating what they legally do and do not have the right to do.

Wouldn't it be more productive to talk about whether they _should_ or _shouldn't_ have the right to do something?

Re:KIA Dealership in Canada remotely disables car over $200 fee by tene on Tuesday August 29, 2017 @02:38PM (#15126585)
Moral and ethical questions can be rather contentious and people often come to different conclusions, and there's nontrivial moral weight to due process and the rule of law. Many people are better off operating in a consistent and predictable legal framework, so if someone is violating current law, that's relevant to a moral evaluation of a situation.

Further, establishing what current law has to say about a situation, and what actually happened in the situation, is a required prerequisite to a discussion about proposed policy changes. Trying to propose changes to the law to change people's rights in situations like this without knowing what the actual details are or whether those details are already in violation or compliance with current law isn't exactly productive, especially given the base rate of inaccurate and incomplete reporting.

Phrased a bit differently, "should" and "shouldn't" aren't completely independent from a given regulatory environment, in that there's nontrivial societal benefit from people knowing what to expect. In cases where some people have decided that certain clauses in a contract are unacceptable (noncompete employment agreements in some states, for example) we've explicitly documented that. If you have opinions on regulation of contracts for auto purchases relevant to this situation, it's absolutely worth first establishing when the contract specified transfer of title, whether or not the contract mentioned the $200 removal fee, and what current law has to say about that.

Re:KIA Dealership in Canada remotely disables car over $200 fee by ThrustVectoring on Tuesday August 29, 2017 @03:49PM (#15127078)
Increase the total value of the loan contract to cover the value of the lockout device. Add a clause saying that you'll pay for the return of the lockout device. If they don't return the vehicle for removal of the lockout device, you keep the extra $200 or whatever and it makes little difference to you.
Re:KIA Dealership in Canada remotely disables car over $200 fee by yock on Tuesday August 29, 2017 @12:47PM (#15125602)
> they no longer had any title over

In the US an auto lender is granted a lien on the vehicle's title until the lien is released, usually after the loan is fully paid. It's likely similar in Canada, but I don't know for sure.

Re:KIA Dealership in Canada remotely disables car over $200 fee by djrogers on Tuesday August 29, 2017 @12:52PM (#15125654)
If you read the article, the loan was paid off. They disabled it because the buyer refused to pay an undocumented $200 charge for removing the kill switch after the transaction.
Re:KIA Dealership in Canada remotely disables car over $200 fee by larvaetron on Tuesday August 29, 2017 @12:59PM (#15125710)
It probably varies by state in the US, I know that where I live, the primary lienholder is in possession of the title and releases it when the loan is paid in full. I can't think of a scenario where I could own a vehicle and physically hold the title, yet have an auto lender's lien on it.
Re:KIA Dealership in Canada remotely disables car over $200 fee by mjcl on Tuesday August 29, 2017 @01:41PM (#15126086)
I had something like that happen when I refinanced a car loan. The old lender released the title and sent it to me. About a year later the new lender finally noticed they didn't have the title and asked for it.
Re:KIA Dealership in Canada remotely disables car over $200 fee by whipoodle on Tuesday August 29, 2017 @12:05PM (#15125218)
I bet it's also illegal to "tamper" with your own car in such a way as to stop this from happening, but clearly it's been decided the law is not important here.
Re:KIA Dealership in Canada remotely disables car over $200 fee by RijilV on Tuesday August 29, 2017 @12:19PM (#15125334)
While I'm no legal expert, I believe the crux of the issue is in this case the dealership had already signed over the title, meaning the had no legal right over the car. Bad on them for demanding a $200 fee to remove it which wasn't clear upfront (though the dealership never responded to the reporters so all we have is the one sided story)

That being said, I think you're referencing the more common cases where these devices are used to disable vehicles on lease to customers. In that case the lease holder is not the owner, so yeah tampering with someone else's car is probably not legal. atleast on the surface that seems reasonable, I wouldn't want someone messing with my vehicle.

I'll agree that leasing agreements are often predatory and there is confusion over who's vehicle it is, but if you want ownership you really need to have purchased the title.

Re:KIA Dealership in Canada remotely disables car over $200 fee by gozur88 on Tuesday August 29, 2017 @12:29PM (#15125435)
I'd be very surprised if the buyer didn't sign something upon purchase that gives the dealer the right to disable the car on lack of payment.
Re:KIA Dealership in Canada remotely disables car over $200 fee by adekok on Tuesday August 29, 2017 @12:30PM (#15125450)
Sure.. but that didn't happen here. He paid off the car. And they still disabled it.
Re:KIA Dealership in Canada remotely disables car over $200 fee by djmobley on Tuesday August 29, 2017 @12:44PM (#15125574)
But he didn't pay all the fees they requested of him.

Whether they had a contractual right to request the fee for removal of the tracker is a different matter.

Re:KIA Dealership in Canada remotely disables car over $200 fee by icebraining on Tuesday August 29, 2017 @01:15PM (#15125851)
The article clearly states that the law prohibits that. The contractual rights don't supersede the law.
Re:KIA Dealership in Canada remotely disables car over $200 fee by EpicEng on Tuesday August 29, 2017 @12:57PM (#15125692)
Which is completely irrelevant if the buyer owns the car outright? Want your fees? Take it up in small claims. They have no rights over your property.
Re:KIA Dealership in Canada remotely disables car over $200 fee by djmobley on Tuesday August 29, 2017 @01:07PM (#15125778)
It's quite plausible that payment of this fee was a condition of title being transferred.

Also, even once the title for the car is transferred, the tracker remains the property of the dealer and they will have some rights to recover it.

Re:KIA Dealership in Canada remotely disables car over $200 fee by rayiner on Tuesday August 29, 2017 @01:35PM (#15126033)
There are two different legal regimes at play: property law and contract law. You can put whatever you want in a contract, and if the buyer breaches the contract you can sue them for breach. But as a general matter, there are no "self help" remedies for breach of contract. Remedies like repossession are the domain of property law. You can leverage property-law interests in a contract (e.g. providing in a contract that buyer retains title property until payment for goods), but as a general matter you can't mess with peoples' property to enforce a contract.

I'm not sure how Canadian law works, but in most U.S. states, an auto lender holds a lien, which is an encumbrance on your car title. Liens cease to exist when the debt obligation they are tied to is repaid. (Your lender will send you a letter or notice of satisfaction, but that is merely evidence of the fact that the lien has been extinguished.)

Because property law has its own mechanics, you can't just assume that the dealership can give itself arbitrary self-help rights in the contract. It's possible that the dealership has clever lawyers and set things up to allow it to lock out the car even after repayment. But it seems more likely that the dealership simply fucked up, and tried to collect a fee using a self-help remedy it was no longer entitled to use after repayment of the loan.

Re:KIA Dealership in Canada remotely disables car over $200 fee by gozur88 on Tuesday August 29, 2017 @03:05PM (#15126775)
>There are two different legal regimes at play: property law and contract law. You can put whatever you want in a contract, and if the buyer breaches the contract you can sue them for breach.

Are you saying if you signed a contract with a clause that read something like "If you owe us money we can shut off your car after 90 days" it would be illegal for them to actually do it? That seems odd to me.

Re:KIA Dealership in Canada remotely disables car over $200 fee by adekok on Tuesday August 29, 2017 @04:20PM (#15127299)
No, the contract would say "if you don't pay for OUR car, we can shut off OUR car after 90 days".

If you're making rental payments on a car like he was, the title is still with the dealer. And the dealer can do what they want with their car. You have to follow their rental agreement in full, or else.

If he had bought a car with a bank loan, title would be with him. But the bank would have a lien on the car. And the bank (not being stupid) would get a court order before repossessing the car after missed loan payments.

Re:KIA Dealership in Canada remotely disables car over $200 fee by gozur88 on Tuesday August 29, 2017 @04:51PM (#15127503)
Contracts say whatever they say. What I was asking is if the wording I specified would make shutting off the car legal.
Re:KIA Dealership in Canada remotely disables car over $200 fee by adekok on Tuesday August 29, 2017 @10:07PM (#15129192)
Again, read what I wrote, and read the article.

They can shut off THEIR car, if THEY own it, and if THEY have title.

If he owns the car, Quebec law is clear that it is ILLEGAL for them to shut off the car, NO MATTER WHAT THE CONTRACT SAYS.

And yes, ALL CAPS is necessary here, because the information you're asking for has already been explained repeatedly.

Re:KIA Dealership in Canada remotely disables car over $200 fee by gozur88 on Wednesday August 30, 2017 @01:17PM (#15133975)
If you find yourself shouting at people, it probably means you haven't been listening. My question was more general than this specific case.
Re:KIA Dealership in Canada remotely disables car over $200 fee by adekok on Thursday August 31, 2017 @02:13PM (#15142448)
My answer was general. What part of that was unclear? Or do you think that this guy has a law which applies only to him, and no one else?

If you find yourself unable to understand simple English, it probably means you haven't been listening.

Re:KIA Dealership in Canada remotely disables car over $200 fee by djmobley on Tuesday August 29, 2017 @01:44PM (#15126119)
Not an expert on Canadian law, but common sense suggests it's more complex than that.

You cannot simply throw money at a lease provider and gain title of a vehicle.

The lease provider can impose other conditions on title transfer (e.g. early repayment fees)

If you're throwing large sums of money at them, they should probably perform some anti-money laundering checks before accepting the money.

If you're paying cash, they may justifiably not want to handle large amounts of cash.

It doesn't seem unreasonable to me that return of the dealer's GPS tracker (and possible payment for removal) could also be conditions on them transferring the title.

The article is unclear on whether the title was actually transferred before the disagreement over return of the tracker.

Re:KIA Dealership in Canada remotely disables car over $200 fee by adekok on Tuesday August 29, 2017 @04:24PM (#15127321)
> The article is unclear on whether the title was actually transferred before the disagreement over return of the tracker.

Yes, the article is abundantly clear. You're getting downvoted because your position is counter to available facts, and your logic is faulty.

He owned the car. They had no legal right to disable it. As the article says:

Quebec's Consumer Protection Bureau said it is illegal to charge fees not included in a signed contract.

The office also said a lender has to furnish a borrower with notice of 30 days before acting in such a way. Immobilizing a car could amount to a form of intimidation, which is also prohibited under consumer protection laws, they said.

Your position is essentially that illegal behavior is fine, because, well, it's not "clear" that the behavior is illegal. Despite oodles of evidence that it is.

Re:KIA Dealership in Canada remotely disables car over $200 fee by djmobley on Tuesday August 29, 2017 @06:10PM (#15128052)
Where in the article does it say he owned the car at the time of the disagreement over the GPS tracker?
Re:KIA Dealership in Canada remotely disables car over $200 fee by jungletek on Thursday August 31, 2017 @01:40AM (#15138369)
It's literally the third paragraph.
Re:KIA Dealership in Canada remotely disables car over $200 fee by theandrewbailey on Tuesday August 29, 2017 @01:30PM (#15125991)
It was mentioned that the fee was not part of the contract.

I'm inclined say the tracker is part of the car, and the dealer has no rights over it (unless mentioned in the contract), similar to how a furnace, thermostat, or water heater is part of a house (because its nailed/bolted to the house).

(IANAL)

Re:KIA Dealership in Canada remotely disables car over $200 fee by djmobley on Tuesday August 29, 2017 @01:34PM (#15126023)
Nonsense. The tracker is removable and remains the property of the dealer.
Re:KIA Dealership in Canada remotely disables car over $200 fee by logfromblammo on Tuesday August 29, 2017 @02:18PM (#15126425)
Removability is not the applicable criterion. It is whether the device is permanently affixed or not.

If the dealer left a ballpoint pen in the glove box, sure, you could make an argument that they retain ownership of it. But the lockout device is exactly as removable and as permanently affixed as the car stereo, or the headlights, or the transmission.

If you replaced the original manufacturer's car stereo with an aftermarket model, and wanted to keep it and swap it back out for the original stereo, you would have to mention that in the purchase agreement. The same goes for any other fixture or appurtenance on the vehicle. If it isn't removed before the papers are signed, or mentioned in those papers, ownership goes with the title to the vehicle.

Re:KIA Dealership in Canada remotely disables car over $200 fee by djmobley on Tuesday August 29, 2017 @06:11PM (#15128056)
It's not permanently affixed. It's removable.
Re:KIA Dealership in Canada remotely disables car over $200 fee by EpicEng on Tuesday August 29, 2017 @07:03PM (#15128333)
So are the bricks which hold up my home. Don't pretend you're a legal expert.
Re:KIA Dealership in Canada remotely disables car over $200 fee by theandrewbailey on Tuesday August 29, 2017 @07:04PM (#15128340)
Everything is removable with a sledgehammer. Many things are made of constituent parts that can be removed, but that doesn't mean that the original owner has rights to it.
Re:KIA Dealership in Canada remotely disables car over $200 fee by logfromblammo on Wednesday August 30, 2017 @10:11AM (#15132258)
But it wasn't removed. Nor were arrangements made for it to be removed. So all parties involved should have been able to expect that it would remain affixed to the car for the foreseeable future--the future in which the entire car, and everything in it, changes ownership.
Re:KIA Dealership in Canada remotely disables car over $200 fee by houseofzeus on Tuesday August 29, 2017 @12:45PM (#15125581)
Yeah, but he paid off the car and now they want their immobilizer back and to charge him for them to remove it.
Re:KIA Dealership in Canada remotely disables car over $200 fee by gozur88 on Wednesday August 30, 2017 @05:10PM (#15136065)
$200 to remove a tracker seems a bit steep, and were I him I'd be inclined to either remove it myself or tell them they were welcome to remove it on their dime. Assuming, of course, he's correct in his assertion the fee wasn't in the contract.
Re:KIA Dealership in Canada remotely disables car over $200 fee by ajross on Tuesday August 29, 2017 @12:28PM (#15125431)
It is in this case (originally), because it's a leased vehicle. It's not "your own car" in any meaningful way. You aren't allowed to do maintenance on a Hertz rental either. Legally there's nothing wrong with this device being on the car.

But in this particular case, they had already sold the car to the guy's family and didn't own the title any more. Yet the kill switch was still in place and they decided to use it over some random fee (which seems to have been for the kill switch itself, per the article). That's pretty obviously illegal.

Re:KIA Dealership in Canada remotely disables car over $200 fee by logfromblammo on Tuesday August 29, 2017 @01:03PM (#15125753)
Also, being affixed to the car at the time the title was transferred, unless there was a specific mention of it in the purchase agreement, the immobilizer was transferred with the car. If the new owner had the expertise, he could have removed the device himself and destroyed it.

The dealer, by remotely accessing the device for which they no longer had authorization, is also technically guilty of criminal hacking.

Re:KIA Dealership in Canada remotely disables car over $200 fee by belovedeagle on Tuesday August 29, 2017 @01:19PM (#15125893)
And to top it all off, they demanded a protection fee in cash and goods (the device) in order to stop the illegal hacking.