The way I read it, the vehicle owner didn't object to providing them access to remove the device, he objected to paying them to remove their device.
Nobody involved in writing this article seems to have consulted this particular contract, but I wouldn't find the existence of such a contract unbelievable, nor the terms particularly unreasonable.
Seems clear to me. What am I missing?
If they retained ownership (which is quite plausible, given the disagreement over the fees), Iny's interpretation of the law is irrelevant.
Lease providers can and will impose conditions. Like early repayment fees. Or fees for the return of GPS trackers...
More info needed to decide who has a better hand wavy interpretation of the information that is available.
The dealer backed down quickly over the fee, but that doesn't mean they didn't have a right to request the sum.
Why do all discussions like this on hacker news come down to debating what they legally do and do not have the right to do.
Wouldn't it be more productive to talk about whether they _should_ or _shouldn't_ have the right to do something?
Further, establishing what current law has to say about a situation, and what actually happened in the situation, is a required prerequisite to a discussion about proposed policy changes. Trying to propose changes to the law to change people's rights in situations like this without knowing what the actual details are or whether those details are already in violation or compliance with current law isn't exactly productive, especially given the base rate of inaccurate and incomplete reporting.
Phrased a bit differently, "should" and "shouldn't" aren't completely independent from a given regulatory environment, in that there's nontrivial societal benefit from people knowing what to expect. In cases where some people have decided that certain clauses in a contract are unacceptable (noncompete employment agreements in some states, for example) we've explicitly documented that. If you have opinions on regulation of contracts for auto purchases relevant to this situation, it's absolutely worth first establishing when the contract specified transfer of title, whether or not the contract mentioned the $200 removal fee, and what current law has to say about that.
How else are you going to get the tracker back?