News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google Issuing Refunds to Advertisers Over Fake Traffic, ... by madars on Sunday August 27, 2017 @12:51AM (#15109179)
In related news, certain subreddits have been promoting the use of https://adnauseam.io/, a fork of uBlock origin that automatically clicks all the ads encountered. The same redditors also encourage searching for high-CPC terms (e.g. insurance or rare medical conditions) to maximize the impact.
Re:Google Issuing Refunds to Advertisers Over Fake Traffic, ... by shubhamjain on Sunday August 27, 2017 @04:23AM (#15109712)
It's hard to understand the level of _schadenfreude_ that warrants use of AdNauseam. Ads can be hated. That's all right. But, why would anyone be so hell bent on depleting advertisers budget. What if the advertiser is not a rich company but a small business. How acceptable it's to destroy the potential value of her budget?

Of course, Google might already be detecting it, but the intent of AdNeuseam seems nothing but despicable.

Re:Google Issuing Refunds to Advertisers Over Fake Traffic, ... by pdkl95 on Sunday August 27, 2017 @05:38AM (#15109963)
This isn't shadenfreude; it's a type of direct action against advertising and indirectly the type of hyper-capitalism that allowed advertising to become malignant.

When profit is the only metric that counts, the only way to send a message is to disrupt the flow of revenue.

> seems nothing but despicable

I'd suggest viewing it from the other side, but I suspect Upton Sinclair's caution may apply: "It is difficult to get a man to understand something, when his salary depends upon his not understanding it!"

Re:Google Issuing Refunds to Advertisers Over Fake Traffic, ... by _ak on Sunday August 27, 2017 @08:20AM (#15110451)
You overestimate the amount of impact adnauseam makes. Users that click on many ads on one page within a short time window, but never convert? Obviously fraud that's being filtered, the user will be blacklisted on both the supply and the demand side, and you very quickly make no impact at all, and will most certainly not disrupt the flow of revenue for anybody involved here. That's not some outlandish futuristic technology, that's standard practice for any half-decent player in online advertising.
Re:Google Issuing Refunds to Advertisers Over Fake Traffic, ... by pdkl95 on Sunday August 27, 2017 @08:45AM (#15110544)
> You overestimate the amount of impact

I never discussed the level of impact for this type of direct action.

edit: Also, if the impact is negligible, I assume you're fine with more people installing adnauseam.

> Obviously fraud

Good luck making that decision. Are you willing to defraud the people hosting your ads with an overly-sensitive detector? Unlike the user that installs adnauseam that doesn't have any contractual relationship with the advertiser or ad-hosting website, the advertiser would be committing fraud if their false positive is too high.

Re:Google Issuing Refunds to Advertisers Over Fake Traffic, ... by taneq on Sunday August 27, 2017 @09:11AM (#15110644)
> the user will be blacklisted on both the supply and the demand side

Isn't that a win, for a user who already runs an adblocker?

Re:Google Issuing Refunds to Advertisers Over Fake Traffic, ... by jdavis703 on Sunday August 27, 2017 @10:53AM (#15111016)
No it just means that you start seeing really crappy ads, i.e. Russian bride ads and malware ads with big "download' buttons.
Re:Google Issuing Refunds to Advertisers Over Fake Traffic, ... by taneq on Monday August 28, 2017 @04:55AM (#15115296)
Except you don't, because you run an adblocker.

Also, receiving untarged ads may mean you're no longer being tracked, which is a bonus if you're concerned about privacy.

Re:Google Issuing Refunds to Advertisers Over Fake Traffic, ... by wongarsu on Sunday August 27, 2017 @09:21AM (#15110667)
Maybe the actual impact is low, but GP was discussing intent, which is completely unrelated to achieved impact.
Re:Google Issuing Refunds to Advertisers Over Fake Traffic, ... by nurettin on Sunday August 27, 2017 @10:18AM (#15110885)
>> Users that click on many ads on one page within a short time window, but never convert?

I think this is why companies are paying real software engineers top $ to come up with real solutions to this non-trivial problem.

Re:Google Issuing Refunds to Advertisers Over Fake Traffic, ... by amelius on Sunday August 27, 2017 @05:37AM (#15109955)
Arguments against ads:

- They provide unsollicited information, which distracts and irritates users.

- They use screen real estate.

- They use bandwidth.

- They use energy.

- They make websites slower.

- They introduce security problems.

- They track users, collect their data.

- They incentivize companies to disrespect our privacy.

- They put users in an information bubble.

- Market failure: not the "best" product wins, but the one with the biggest advertisement budget behind it.

- They make people feel inconfident (see photoshopped fashion ads)

- They play with our minds.

- They are often targeted at children.

Re:Google Issuing Refunds to Advertisers Over Fake Traffic, ... by srean on Sunday August 27, 2017 @06:09AM (#15110059)
I think those descriptions are a little too subtle and too nuanced. Broader generalizations that make more sweeping claims would work better to make the point.
Re:Google Issuing Refunds to Advertisers Over Fake Traffic, ... by tyfon on Sunday August 27, 2017 @07:25AM (#15110268)
I think each of those are broad and sweeping and show just how bad the advertisement has become.
Re:Google Issuing Refunds to Advertisers Over Fake Traffic, ... by zaptheimpaler on Sunday August 27, 2017 @10:03AM (#15110838)
Absolutely. Broad, biased statements are indisputably the best way to gain deep insight into an issue. Details and worries about correctness often muddy the waters.
Re:Google Issuing Refunds to Advertisers Over Fake Traffic, ... by srean on Sunday August 27, 2017 @11:52AM (#15111244)
Indeed sir, glad that you concur. My downvoters dont seem to agree. Poe it is.
Re:Google Issuing Refunds to Advertisers Over Fake Traffic, ... by philipodonnell on Sunday August 27, 2017 @12:31PM (#15111426)
I'm pretty sure one of you is being sarcastic, but I can't tell which one. :-)
Re:Google Issuing Refunds to Advertisers Over Fake Traffic, ... by srean on Monday August 28, 2017 @04:22AM (#15115189)
Why chose when you can have it all.

May be this will help https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15115082

Re:Google Issuing Refunds to Advertisers Over Fake Traffic, ... by clarry on Sunday August 27, 2017 @04:59AM (#15109822)
> Ads can be hated. That's all right. But, why would anyone be so hell bent on depleting advertisers budget.

Why not? Many of us are so hell bent on not wanting to see ads that we actually run adblockers. Then ad companies want to dmca or prosecute adblockers and advertisers call us thieves for using one (however, none of them would reimburse the ram, electricity, internet bandwidth, and time wasted with all that unsolicited spam). I don't care if they go bankrupt.

> What if the advertiser is not a rich company but a small business. How acceptable it's to destroy the potential value of her budget?

When they pay for clicks, they're gambling. No sympathy. It might be a good idea to cap that gambling budget and consider less risky ways to reach people if the yield isn't high enough.

Re:Google Issuing Refunds to Advertisers Over Fake Traffic, ... by belorn on Sunday August 27, 2017 @06:23AM (#15110090)
Several reasons why adnetworks is hated to the point where people want to take action:

Adnetworks don't take responsibility for what they publish. Malware, scams, illegal ads (such as targeting children), and resource depleting software are all ire-causing problems where it's the victim that have to shoulder it.

Then we have the ethical question about tracking and creating registers over people who search for medical conditions. To target the sick and vulnerable is very ire-inducing. Doctor-patient confidentiality exist for good reasons and many ad networks have no problems in ignoring that.

If adnetworks played by the common rules (ie laws) that we all have to abide to, then I would generally agree that citizen action like this is bad. But thats not the current situation, so its either activism like this or put our hope that global treaties is going to be signed that limit what companies can do and what legal responsibility they have.

Re:Google Issuing Refunds to Advertisers Over Fake Traffic, ... by new299 on Sunday August 27, 2017 @04:38AM (#15109758)
I don't use AdNauseam.

However, it doesn't seem that hard for me to understand. If you see advertising as a social ill, that seeks to manipulate people into making purchases that they neither need nor will make their lives better. If that's what you believe it doesn't seem inconsistent to want to do everything you can to make advertising nonviable.

Re:Google Issuing Refunds to Advertisers Over Fake Traffic, ... by closeparen on Sunday August 27, 2017 @04:46AM (#15109787)
> the intent of AdNeuseam seems nothing but despicable.

To some, the intent to operate a business, particularly one that depends on advertising, is despicable. They consider the act of making money (i.e. revenues > costs) to be evil exploitation of workers, and the act of getting people to buy something they can survive without (i.e. advertising influences whether and how much consumers buy) to be evil consumerist waste, part of a culture of buying shit you don't need, which they see as a cancer on human civilization.

Running a DoS attack against advertising has a decently advantageous risk:effectiveness ratio as a technique to fight capitalism, if that's your intention, and for some people it is.

Re:Google Issuing Refunds to Advertisers Over Fake Traffic, ... by pasta on Sunday August 27, 2017 @05:14AM (#15109879)
I think there are two major point why people hate ads: no privacy and a potential source of malware and what not.

Yesterday I was looking for a nice Android game and stumbled upon Mekorama. Not only is it a great game but the developer is asking very politely for some money without the use of ads. In the reviews you can see this is an absolute bonus. And because of this the game doesn't need ads for exposure. See, I just promoted the game on HN.

People just hate ads.

Re:Google Issuing Refunds to Advertisers Over Fake Traffic, ... by keldaris on Sunday August 27, 2017 @07:16AM (#15110241)
> It's hard to understand the level of _schadenfreude_ that warrants use of AdNauseam.

Have you seen modern ads? They're a direct security threat, a threat against privacy and, many would argue, a considerable social ill. AdNauseam represents one of the few available means of direct action against the ad industry. Personally, I think it's a great idea.

In fact, I would argue that until the ad networks take responsibility over the security implications of their actions, using AdNauseam is the ethical thing to do.

Re:Google Issuing Refunds to Advertisers Over Fake Traffic, ... by throwaway7312 on Sunday August 27, 2017 @06:35AM (#15110126)
If enough users adopt this, the effect will be advertisers flee whatever websites those users frequent.

The end result being those websites (due to declines in revenue) cut their staffs, reducing the quantity and quality of their content. And then AdNauseum users complain on certain subreddits about the declining quality of the target sites.

AdNauseum seems to be a case of "you destroy what you love."

Re:Google Issuing Refunds to Advertisers Over Fake Traffic, ... by kaffeemitsahne on Sunday August 27, 2017 @08:41AM (#15110527)
Something that can only support itself with ads has no right to exist at all in my view.
Re:Google Issuing Refunds to Advertisers Over Fake Traffic, ... by colejohnson66 on Sunday August 27, 2017 @01:30PM (#15111688)
How exactly do truely free to use websites run if not with advertisements? Where does StackExchange get its money?
Re:Google Issuing Refunds to Advertisers Over Fake Traffic, ... by CaptSpify on Monday August 28, 2017 @11:22AM (#15117133)
> How exactly do truely free to use websites run if not with advertisements?

They don't. And I consider this a feature, not a bug. The www existed just fine before advertisers came onto the scene, and it can function even better when they leave.

Re:Google Issuing Refunds to Advertisers Over Fake Traffic, ... by colejohnson66 on Monday August 28, 2017 @12:40PM (#15117931)
Are you saying the internet would be a better place without StackExchange?
Re:Google Issuing Refunds to Advertisers Over Fake Traffic, ... by CaptSpify on Monday August 28, 2017 @03:51PM (#15119520)
I think SE would indeed be a loss, but I do strongly believe that the loss would be well worth it to push out internet advertising. Additionally, I don't believe that SE's only viable financial model is advertisement.
Re:Google Issuing Refunds to Advertisers Over Fake Traffic, ... by neotek on Sunday August 27, 2017 @10:21AM (#15110899)
What a ridiculous way to think.
Re:Google Issuing Refunds to Advertisers Over Fake Traffic, ... by squarefoot on Sunday August 27, 2017 @10:52AM (#15111008)
Badly exposed, maybe, but surely not ridiculous. We are so used to wasting hours alone in front of a screen while being bombarded by advertising that we are totally forgetting what it looks like to get out and speak with other people. Word of mouth, baby. When a product is good it makes a good subject for conversation with friends and relatives, and they surely don't cover my mouth with duct tape as a form of ad-blocking.
Re:Google Issuing Refunds to Advertisers Over Fake Traffic, ... by hanetzer on Sunday August 27, 2017 @03:48PM (#15112343)
Off topic, but are you still interested in those ActiveX h264 dvrs? I've got sdks for a few variants of a chip family commonly used in them and am working on reverse engineering their binary kernel modules, and was hoping to start gathering helpers.
Re:Google Issuing Refunds to Advertisers Over Fake Traffic, ... by squarefoot on Monday August 28, 2017 @04:29AM (#15115209)
Hi, thanks. I have only one of the old 4 inputs models left, but should get one of the new AHD ones and be able to do some tests in a while. I'm not expert in reverse engineering but if I can help I'll be glad to.

I'm almost new here, if there is a way to send PMs to other people I didn't find it.

Re:Google Issuing Refunds to Advertisers Over Fake Traffic, ... by hanetzer on Monday August 28, 2017 @07:54PM (#15121125)
Also, I'm still recovering from hurricane Harvey, so I may not be online as much as usual, but you can memoserv me and I'll get it once I'm back online.
Re:Google Issuing Refunds to Advertisers Over Fake Traffic, ... by squarefoot on Tuesday August 29, 2017 @02:03PM (#15126271)
Got it, will contact you asap. I'm very sorry about the hurricane, best luck to all of you people over there.
Re:Google Issuing Refunds to Advertisers Over Fake Traffic, ... by hanetzer on Monday August 28, 2017 @07:52PM (#15121115)
None that I know of, but you can find me on freenode in gentoo channels, other places, and #exploiteers. Gathering hardware data would be a good place to start.
Re:Google Issuing Refunds to Advertisers Over Fake Traffic, ... by CaptSpify on Sunday August 27, 2017 @11:58AM (#15111271)
Why?

I can't think of any quality product that relies solely on advertisement, and I can't think of any product that has become better once advertisements became a part of its funding.

Re:Google Issuing Refunds to Advertisers Over Fake Traffic, ... by yjftsjthsd-h on Sunday August 27, 2017 @12:34PM (#15111447)
> reducing the quantity and quality of their content

For many ad-based sites, the loss will be minimal.

Re:Google Issuing Refunds to Advertisers Over Fake Traffic, ... by omginternets on Sunday August 27, 2017 @05:54AM (#15110025)
>But, why would anyone be so hell bent on depleting advertisers budget.

Literally nothing else seems to be working, so poisoning the advertising well strikes me like a fair tactic.

Re:Google Issuing Refunds to Advertisers Over Fake Traffic, ... by zo1 on Sunday August 27, 2017 @09:08AM (#15110638)
Have you tried regulating? Seems to work pretty well for places like China.
Re:Google Issuing Refunds to Advertisers Over Fake Traffic, ... by feelin_googley on Sunday August 27, 2017 @11:29AM (#15111148)
This is one way to look at it.

The type of business Doubleclick engages in is neither efficient nor effective on most web users but it causes a pervasive wide scale annoyance to all who enounter Doublclick's tentacles. One could argue that Doubleclick (now Google) must retain a certain level of schadenfreude to pollute the web with their garbage for so long knowing that, in the main, they are only creating a nuisance for web users, not generating revenue for their customers. If a salesman has to knock on thousands of doors to find only a single buyer, there is always the chance communities close their gates to keep the salesman out. Clearly, most people living in the community are not interested in what he is selling. Is it reasonable to annoy thousands of people to find one person who will buy? Who knows? But certainly, one can expect that there will be thousands of annoyed people.

Another way to look at this, especially after Google acquired Doubleclick, is that it could be the customers purchasing ads who are being deceived. It is hard to imagine that web users are deceiving Doubleclick and Google by clicking on ads and not purchasing products. Doubleclick knows most users do not click and do not purchase products/services in response to these ads. But those purchasing ads may not know this. The information asymmetry is in Google's favor.

These "adnauseum" users appear to be acting out of frustration in response to the promulgation of advertising that Google knows most users are not interested in. They are not achieving any financial gain, and certainly not by deceiving others.

It is easier to imagine a situation where those parties buying ads are being deceived by Doubleclick to believe that certain web advertising is more efficient, effective and reliable than it truly is. Hence the refunds.

Users are entitled to click on whatever they so choose. If they become frustrated and start clicking on everything, it is hard to argue this is "fraudulent" or deceptive. They are expressing themselves honestly: they are frustrated. The possibility that users can click on anything and everything in a page presented to them has always been there; buyers of web advertising should be aware of this when engaging a web ad sales company. Leading them to believe otherwise might be deceptive or even "fraudulent".

Re:Google Issuing Refunds to Advertisers Over Fake Traffic, ... by amelius on Sunday August 27, 2017 @04:32AM (#15109742)
The problem with ads is much bigger than most people realize.

To put it simply: ads work against the free market; instead of the "best" product, the one with the largest advertisement budget wins.

Re:Google Issuing Refunds to Advertisers Over Fake Traffic, ... by srean on Sunday August 27, 2017 @04:37AM (#15109756)
Free market cannot work without propagation of information. Curious what kind of mechanism you envision to solve that problem: public service anouncements in place of ads ?
Re:Google Issuing Refunds to Advertisers Over Fake Traffic, ... by psyc on Sunday August 27, 2017 @09:02AM (#15110620)
I can't recall a time when ads ever provided useful information about products, as opposed to psychologically conditioned brand awareness.
Re:Google Issuing Refunds to Advertisers Over Fake Traffic, ... by neotek on Sunday August 27, 2017 @10:57AM (#15111035)
How about providing knowledge of the mere existence of the product? How is that not useful?
Re:Google Issuing Refunds to Advertisers Over Fake Traffic, ... by clarry on Sunday August 27, 2017 @11:15AM (#15111108)
If it really did that. In practice, it doesn't. Not for me anyway. It's like firing an assault rifle at the sky and hoping there's someone to catch the bullet, where ever it might land. It's just spam about products I'm never going to buy and don't need to know about.

By all means, give me all the ads when I'm actually looking for a product to buy. The sad thing is that when I do that, all the ads tend to be irrelevant. Even on sites like amazon, which should know what I'm looking for. They have these sponsored product placements that are supposed to be relevant to my search. In practice, they hardly ever are. And if they're somewhat relevant, they're still not relevant enough for me to consider purchase.

Online ads do an incredibly bad job of providing useful knowledge about the mere existence of a product.

In practice, I always need to turn to reviews, forums, word-of-mouth, etc. etc. etc., and finding useful information in the infinite sea of ad-spam is quite frustrating.

Re:Google Issuing Refunds to Advertisers Over Fake Traffic, ... by amelius on Sunday August 27, 2017 @05:13AM (#15109873)
If ads were the only type of information, we were already doomed.

For example, why do you think reviews are so important?

Also, you are reading articles through HN, not by watching ads for them first.

Then there is the age-old word-of-mouth.

Or seeing products in action with friends.

I could go on and on.

Re:Google Issuing Refunds to Advertisers Over Fake Traffic, ... by srean on Sunday August 27, 2017 @05:33AM (#15109939)
I see that you have a very practical and scalable solution out there.

We will gush about a movie/product/service launch on television and call it news. One might even consider incentivising people to write positive reviews, we will just not call them ads. Why havent we seen any of these yet ? I have my review-blocker, post-blocker, word-of-mouth blocker startups still in waiting.

Re:Google Issuing Refunds to Advertisers Over Fake Traffic, ... by zaptheimpaler on Sunday August 27, 2017 @10:21AM (#15110894)
There are farms of blogs with junk content and reviews that exist purely for ad revenue and referral marketing. Online communities have sockpuppets doing the same shit. Respected news papers have "submarine" PR pieces promoting one product or another. The fake positive reviews you mention already exist - both on blogs and sites like Amazon, App Store etc.

In this vast sea of noise, it is very hard to find good information. These massive industries keep churning out ads in a million different forms & keep blurring the lines between ad/content with a motive to sell and trustworthy content from a real person without ulterior motives.

Its a constant never-ending war on trustworthy content and erodes the webs utility as a whole. In the past 10 years the web has become more and more of an artificially curated garden to sell you shit and keep you clicking.. and despite many protests about ads, they remain invasive and pervasive.

They ignore all these concerns and keep ramping it up. So I don't think twice about using AdNaseaum.

Re:Google Issuing Refunds to Advertisers Over Fake Traffic, ... by srean on Sunday August 27, 2017 @12:52PM (#15111529)
I agree with everything you said, but carpet-bombing the crap out of all ads does not seem to be an improvement. Ads satisfy a real need, stamp it out artificially and it will come up with some other name, some other form.

This

     war against *
 
is too hackneyed an approach, admittedly, very popular in the US. It has not done much good anywhere.
Re:Google Issuing Refunds to Advertisers Over Fake Traffic, ... by zaptheimpaler on Monday August 28, 2017 @12:16AM (#15114378)
Well using ad nauseaum is not carpet bombing or waging a war - all depends on how you define war. Its just sending a message, if enough people send the message things will change. If not, they will continue to get worse.
Re:Google Issuing Refunds to Advertisers Over Fake Traffic, ... by srean on Monday August 28, 2017 @03:56AM (#15115082)
It depends on how it is used, but I would have no qualms about going after the egregiously annoying and inherently dishonest ads. Those are the ones where even the advertiser knows that a click indicates absolutely no intent to explore or to buy, the reader was just tricked into triggering a booby trap. Some pages are so bad that it feels like navigating a veritable minefield, you dont know where to position your mouse to read the damn article. To all who wants to go after these guys, godspeed. I dont use adblock, but I do use flashblock and nuke javascript on all except a few whitelisted sites that I keep expanding as needed.

But seriously, I am genuinely tickled that my sarcastic comments on this post was mistaken for genuine lack of knowledge regarding paid reviews and submarine articles.

My goal was to point out that if one kills one specific form-factor it will reappear in some other form-factor and it already has; to point out that the notion that reviews, articles, word of mouth can be a substitute for ads is a silly idea [0]. Paid reviews and submarine articles being some of the other form factors. Those reviews and articles are just as dishonest if not more so and ignoring them to target others rather indiscriminately is not going to result in a better web. Thats closer to a baby throwing a tantrum than anything else.

An indiscriminate war against all ads is just childish and silly. Silly is the sweeping notion that _all_ ads are essentially motivated by malice [1] and only does harm to the reader.

[0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15109873

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15110059

Re:Google Issuing Refunds to Advertisers Over Fake Traffic, ... by amelius on Sunday August 27, 2017 @06:17AM (#15110075)
Incentivized reviews == ads == bad

Are you saying that ads are okay simply because we have no means to eradicate them?

Re:Google Issuing Refunds to Advertisers Over Fake Traffic, ... by yjftsjthsd-h on Sunday August 27, 2017 @12:37PM (#15111470)
> One might even consider incentivising people to write positive reviews, we will just not call them ads.

Are you being sarcastic, or are you unaware that this is a real thing that happens?

Re:Google Issuing Refunds to Advertisers Over Fake Traffic, ... by Noos on Sunday August 27, 2017 @08:11AM (#15110419)
How do you get reviews when people have no idea the product exists in the first place? The amount of ignorance these comments have about why marketing in general is a necessary part of business is disheartening.
Re:Google Issuing Refunds to Advertisers Over Fake Traffic, ... by legopelle on Sunday August 27, 2017 @05:02AM (#15109832)
I imagine a single state-owned database where merchants enter detailed product information. The consumers may then query the database at their leisure.
Re:Google Issuing Refunds to Advertisers Over Fake Traffic, ... by KGIII on Sunday August 27, 2017 @05:22AM (#15109907)
Which government would you trust to do that?
Re:Google Issuing Refunds to Advertisers Over Fake Traffic, ... by pbhjpbhj on Sunday August 27, 2017 @05:33AM (#15109941)
I'd trust the UK civil service to do that. The hardest but would probably be verification -- does that lasagne really only have beef in, was the cocoa for that chocolate actually grown in a Fairtrade farm, in Ivory Coast, etc..
Re:Google Issuing Refunds to Advertisers Over Fake Traffic, ... by KGIII on Sunday August 27, 2017 @05:45AM (#15109993)
I'm American. I don't even trust my government to do math properly.
Re:Google Issuing Refunds to Advertisers Over Fake Traffic, ... by gaius on Sunday August 27, 2017 @05:42AM (#15109981)
The French, bring back Le Minitel!
Re:Google Issuing Refunds to Advertisers Over Fake Traffic, ... by KGIII on Sunday August 27, 2017 @05:49AM (#15110003)
And if there is a change in the political spectrum, will you still trust them? My government lost my security clearance application to who knows who. In return, I got some credit monitoring and a form letter.
Re:Google Issuing Refunds to Advertisers Over Fake Traffic, ... by hesarenu on Sunday August 27, 2017 @12:19PM (#15111367)
India has something similar. Datakart app from gs1 has product related information. You can scan using barcodes.
Re:Google Issuing Refunds to Advertisers Over Fake Traffic, ... by shubhamjain on Sunday August 27, 2017 @04:42AM (#15109773)
I disagree. A large advertising budget will win more eyeballs but that doesn't meant a shitty product will have a free reign. A product has to work hard to justify its value. Yes, marketing and advertising is misused to make people pay more for the same thing, but that doesn't mean that chief benefit of advertising, which is discovery, is lost in the process.
Re:Google Issuing Refunds to Advertisers Over Fake Traffic, ... by srean on Sunday August 27, 2017 @05:28AM (#15109928)
I would keep ads. But I would prefer if advertisers are not allowed to lie or make unverified claims on ads. I would perefer to be able to take an advertiser to court for the claims made. That still leaves a lot of room for word play and weaseling ..."upto 80% improvement in blah", but better than nothing.
Re:Google Issuing Refunds to Advertisers Over Fake Traffic, ... by CM30 on Monday August 28, 2017 @07:11AM (#15115766)
Isn't that what the Advertising Standards Authority does in various regions?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Advertising_Standards_Authorit...

There are laws and guidelines stating that claims made in ads have to be backed up, or at least not misleading and there are companies who've been fined or forced to take down ads because of it.

Whether it works well is another question though.

Re:Google Issuing Refunds to Advertisers Over Fake Traffic, ... by srean on Monday August 28, 2017 @02:29PM (#15118903)
> Whether it works well ?

You must be kidding, right ? I would be happy if it works at all.

Re:Google Issuing Refunds to Advertisers Over Fake Traffic, ... by raverbashing on Sunday August 27, 2017 @05:44AM (#15109990)
> It's hard to understand the level of _schadenfreude_ that warrants use of AdNauseam

MacKeeper ads

Re:Google Issuing Refunds to Advertisers Over Fake Traffic, ... by gasof on Sunday August 27, 2017 @12:06PM (#15111310)
Demonizing the anti-advertisement camp doesn't help your case. There are legitimate reasons people dislike the deep penetration of advertisements in every area of life. I personally consider ads unethical, and I don't care if I decrease the effectiveness of what I consider to an unethical practice, in fact it's a joyous thing to me.

Your tone convinced me to go to the distance of moving to AdNauseam, and I'll be changing my recommendations to friends on unmetered connections as well.

Re:Google Issuing Refunds to Advertisers Over Fake Traffic, ... by tomjen3 on Sunday August 27, 2017 @07:31AM (#15110291)
It is not Schadenfreude, it is war and arguably a defensive one. And if you believe ads are wrong then it really doesn't matter whether it is a big or a small company that does it.
Re:Google Issuing Refunds to Advertisers Over Fake Traffic, ... by convery on Sunday August 27, 2017 @04:31AM (#15109741)
Or for the contentcreators, think Youtube, their CPM going from 2$ to 0.5$ just because people dislike Google seems a little cruel.
Re:Google Issuing Refunds to Advertisers Over Fake Traffic, ... by cyphar on Sunday August 27, 2017 @05:12AM (#15109866)
YouTube already ruined the CPM of creators several months ago, through a bunch of hair-brained schemes to try to appeal to advertisers that were scared by flat-out lies by WSJ.

AdNauseum was created long after the "adpocalypse". I would not be surprised if some people are using it in protest of YouTube's attempts to ruin the ability for independent media to fund themselves.

Re:Google Issuing Refunds to Advertisers Over Fake Traffic, ... by wyager on Sunday August 27, 2017 @09:41AM (#15110735)
I would feel bad about this if YouTube wasn't already ramping up targeted demonetization via "YouTube Heroes".
Re:Google Issuing Refunds to Advertisers Over Fake Traffic, ... by ko27 on Sunday August 27, 2017 @04:53AM (#15109799)
If you are talking about the obfuscation, and not the ad-block part, then they never had those 2$ to begin with.
Re:Google Issuing Refunds to Advertisers Over Fake Traffic, ... by _pmf_ on Sunday August 27, 2017 @05:00AM (#15109825)
The cynic in me: Oh, no, my daughter will have less 2h videos of people unwrapping Kinder surprise eggs to watch; a cultural loss.
Re:Google Issuing Refunds to Advertisers Over Fake Traffic, ... by radicalbyte on Sunday August 27, 2017 @05:10AM (#15109854)
Killer feature! Does Adnauseum work on iPad? :)
Re:Google Issuing Refunds to Advertisers Over Fake Traffic, ... by wyager on Sunday August 27, 2017 @09:31AM (#15110699)
I can imagine several reasonable belief systems that would justify attacking advertisers; for example, if you view advertising as a form of psychological pollution.

However, given that one generally chooses to go on websites that serve ads, I think it's harder to justify messing with web ads as opposed to, say, billboards.

Re:Google Issuing Refunds to Advertisers Over Fake Traffic, ... by micheljones on Sunday August 27, 2017 @08:49AM (#15110562)
It's not schadenfreude, and this latest uptick in AdNauseam installation&use is not caused by anti-ad attitudes, but as backlash against what is perceived as thought policing by google, mostly in form of demonetizing and silencing popular YouTube users who lean right in their political expression.
Re:Google Issuing Refunds to Advertisers Over Fake Traffic, ... by shimon_e on Sunday August 27, 2017 @09:02AM (#15110623)
Yeah its a politic war. I believe it all started when some people on the left got some companies to pull their ads from some right wing Fox anchor. Unless someone knows of events older than this?
Re:Google Issuing Refunds to Advertisers Over Fake Traffic, ... by pjc50 on Sunday August 27, 2017 @10:10AM (#15110860)
This has been going on for decades - I can remember it being used as a tactic against apartheit in South Africa.
Re:Google Issuing Refunds to Advertisers Over Fake Traffic, ... by zo1 on Sunday August 27, 2017 @09:12AM (#15110646)
The earliest notable one I can think of is the whole Kellogs and Breitbart incident. However, specifically relating to Google, I'd say it's the James Damore political silencing by Google. And even more recently, Youtube has started censoring controversial videos and putting them inside a "gimped" version of Youtube. I.e. no likes/shares/related videos. It really is turning into a 1984 scenario.
Re:Google Issuing Refunds to Advertisers Over Fake Traffic, ... by UncleMeat on Sunday August 27, 2017 @11:50AM (#15111238)
1984, where the government literally rewrites books, changes the language to be incapable of expressing dissent, and murders its citizens.

Comparable to firing a guy who upset a huge portion of the company and false positives on hate detection algorithms. Sure.

Re:Google Issuing Refunds to Advertisers Over Fake Traffic, ... by micheljones on Sunday August 27, 2017 @09:21AM (#15110670)
Yes, no likes/shares/related, but on top of that, the videos are demonetized + no longer embeddable.
Re:Google Issuing Refunds to Advertisers Over Fake Traffic, ... by whipoodle on Sunday August 27, 2017 @09:22AM (#15110674)
Somehow, I think Google just might pull through this dire situation.
Re:Google Issuing Refunds to Advertisers Over Fake Traffic, ... by oh_sigh on Sunday August 27, 2017 @05:13AM (#15109872)
I think the intent is to screw Google over. The advertisers are an unfortunate casualty
Re:Google Issuing Refunds to Advertisers Over Fake Traffic, ... by birken on Sunday August 27, 2017 @01:22AM (#15109264)
You think Google can't detect this? Enough advertisers have conversion tracking that Google can detect if a person is clicking a zillion ads and never actually converting, in addition to the other multitude of ways they detect fraud. I'm sure in the battle between fake traffic producers and Google there are probably tricky ways you can fool Google, but a person clicking every ad is not one of them.

Also... this doesn't actually hurt Google. If the percentage of fake traffic goes up, the cost per click will just go down over the long term. And what, advertisers are going to lose faith? Give me a break. It doesn't matter if the traffic is 0% fake or 90% fake, all that matters is if the traffic is making you a profit or not.

Re:Google Issuing Refunds to Advertisers Over Fake Traffic, ... by runeks on Sunday August 27, 2017 @02:05AM (#15109368)
> It doesn't matter if the traffic is 0% fake or 90% fake, all that matters is if the traffic is making you a profit or not.

Only under the assumption that no competing, superior technologies exists. The worse the efficiency of the ad-model, the more attractive the alternatives will be.

Criticizing Microsoft over delivering an inferior user experience twenty years ago is in the same category as the critique against Google: as long as they have complete control over the market, it doesn’t matter at all. But when competing, superior technologies start appearing, it becomes their downfall. And the worse the user (advertisers, in case of Google) experience, the greater the incentive for competing technologies to appear.

Re:Google Issuing Refunds to Advertisers Over Fake Traffic, ... by birken on Sunday August 27, 2017 @02:52AM (#15109496)
What alternatives? The key product here is Google search which is what attracts the consumers. The advertisers are dealing with Adwords not because Adwords is the greatest platform in history, but because Adwords is the platform where the consumers are. Ad fraud, no matter how massive, has no effect on the consumer side of Google search.

Google has a strong incentive to fix this because any money going to scammers is theoretically coming out of their own pockets as advertisers lower their CPCs to adjust for lower conversion rates, but it isn't an existential threat to the marketplace. Cut out the scammers and the CPCs adjust back upwards as conversion rates increase.

And again, Google has the tools to find the scammers. It's a game of whack-a-mole for sure, but at the end of the day the higher the level of fraud on the marketplace the easier it is to catch, so the scammers are somewhat limited in how much damage they do.

Re:Google Issuing Refunds to Advertisers Over Fake Traffic, ... by runeks on Sunday August 27, 2017 @04:18AM (#15109703)
> What alternatives?

I’m not claiming any alternative exists right now. I’m saying that the less efficient Google is at converting dollars paid by advertisers into visitors, the greater the pressure from future (unknown) technologies that eradicate the inherent inefficiency in Google’s model.

If I knew exactly how to capture Google’s ad revenue, I would be starting a company rather than writing comments on HN.

Re:Google Issuing Refunds to Advertisers Over Fake Traffic, ... by Drdrdrq on Sunday August 27, 2017 @04:13AM (#15109688)
> It's a game of whack-a-mole for sure, but at the end of the day the higher the level of fraud on the marketplace the easier it is to catch, so the scammers are somewhat limited in how much damage they do.

This is a perfect summary of what is going on.

In this case I trust Google because their incentives are aligned with advertisers', and they certainly have both data (from Google Analytics and other sites) and means to distinguish between a human and a bot.

Re:Google Issuing Refunds to Advertisers Over Fake Traffic, ... by cat199 on Sunday August 27, 2017 @08:36AM (#15110509)
> In this case I trust Google because their incentives are aligned with advertisers

Is it?

The better the overall search algorithm, the less the need to hack around it by paying for placement..

Some level of 'bad results' helps ensure that ads are needed in the first place, and junk sites provide a ready source of bad results..

Now, when junk sites cause you to lose revenue, the equation gets unbalanced, but that is not to say having the variable equate to 0 is good either, because the revenue would lessen..

Obviously it can't simply allow the fraud because that would make google fraudulent itself, but at the same time they cant just outright ban crappy sites, since there are so many that are only marginally crappy but otherwise legitimate, and could only be unwilling participants in someone else's dishonest scheme..

I would argue that google is attempting to maximize a set of equations here, and since at some point there is a grey area between 'crappy scammish sites' and 'full on fraud', google has some leeway to what extent it polices the grey area, and, further, to some extent can do this at advertisers expense so long as 'the house wins' to borrow gamboling terminology..

Re:Google Issuing Refunds to Advertisers Over Fake Traffic, ... by runeks on Sunday August 27, 2017 @09:43AM (#15110741)
> The better the overall search algorithm, the less the need to hack around it by paying for placement..

All the things you need are not necessarily known to you in advance. It’s entirely possible that someone has created a new product that no one knows about, and allowing these companies to pay for visibility allows you to discover these ideas that you might end up finding useful. The idea is that when advertisers pay for placement, they better have a useful product (that can recoup the cost), or else they’ll be throwing money out the window.

Re:Google Issuing Refunds to Advertisers Over Fake Traffic, ... by cat199 on Friday September 01, 2017 @08:58AM (#15147967)
true, but which likely-related things are shown is also a decision for the algorithm to make, and one which can be skewed in a variety of positive or negative ways
Re:Google Issuing Refunds to Advertisers Over Fake Traffic, ... by 47 on Sunday August 27, 2017 @04:40AM (#15109763)
Actually Google do not have a complete market control. I managed a 100M+ ecommerce startup and our largest traffic source is Facebook and Instagram.
Re:Google Issuing Refunds to Advertisers Over Fake Traffic, ... by denzil_correa on Sunday August 27, 2017 @05:38AM (#15109965)
> You think Google can't detect this?

If they randomize it, no.

Re:Google Issuing Refunds to Advertisers Over Fake Traffic, ... by bitJericho on Sunday August 27, 2017 @01:35AM (#15109288)
looks like they just need to start clicking a lower random percentage.
Re:Google Issuing Refunds to Advertisers Over Fake Traffic, ... by cyphar on Sunday August 27, 2017 @04:56AM (#15109814)
4chan has been shilling it quite heavily as well, and (of course) they've been championing articles like TFA as proof that their technique is working. I personally think that there is a fair point to make that Google has already been sabotaging people who were trying to make a living off advertising (see the YouTube "adpocalypse"), so I can see where the anger might be coming from.
Re:Google Issuing Refunds to Advertisers Over Fake Traffic, ... by paulgb on Sunday August 27, 2017 @06:13AM (#15110068)
I used to work in ad fraud detection (eg. publishers buying fake clicks) about five years ago and fake clicks were a bigger problem than people talk about. I would be surprised if 4chan is more than a drop in the bucket.
Re:Google Issuing Refunds to Advertisers Over Fake Traffic, ... by user5994461 on Sunday August 27, 2017 @05:20AM (#15109900)
Warning: Don't use that plugin if you have web sites and use any of google adsense/adword/analytics. Your account would get banned for fake clicks.
Re:Google Issuing Refunds to Advertisers Over Fake Traffic, ... by cft on Sunday August 27, 2017 @12:53AM (#15109192)
This could be a coordinated 4chan attack https://files.catbox.moe/6ueduv.png
Re:Google Issuing Refunds to Advertisers Over Fake Traffic, ... by tanilama on Sunday August 27, 2017 @02:49AM (#15109487)
There is no proof it does. Even before it Google has estimated the fraud traffic compositing of 20% to 30% of all its inventory. I think 4chan bros are too caught up with themselves to think that a bunch of ideologists can cause tens of billions of damage.

http://www.businessinsider.com/thepartnership-msix-and-adloo...

Re:Google Issuing Refunds to Advertisers Over Fake Traffic, ... by MichaelGG on Sunday August 27, 2017 @01:22AM (#15109262)
Yes, it's seen as, probably correctly, the only way to do anything that'll affect Google. Outside of getting laws changed, that is. It probably won't be effective - the people handling ad fraud are probably not the ones pushing their censorious politics. But hey, unlike most slacktivism, this causes them real damage. I imagine the response will be to ban people's Google accounts, for those dumb enough to sign in while using AdNauseum. (Anything more forensic might be a target for trolls.) We'll see if Firefox caves to pressure like Pale Moon did.
Re:Google Issuing Refunds to Advertisers Over Fake Traffic, ... by cat199 on Sunday August 27, 2017 @08:38AM (#15110521)
which, aside from being ironic, could create network effects to move people out of gapps and back towards more federated solutions..

things could get interesting.. or, more likely, they could not.

Re:Google Issuing Refunds to Advertisers Over Fake Traffic, ... by Drdrdrq on Sunday August 27, 2017 @04:16AM (#15109700)
Give me a break. It is laughably easy, even trivial for Google to filter out such traffic.
Re:Google Issuing Refunds to Advertisers Over Fake Traffic, ... by ManlyBread on Sunday August 27, 2017 @09:03AM (#15110628)
How? If the clicks are random, how does one filter them out and separate them from actual traffic?
Re:Google Issuing Refunds to Advertisers Over Fake Traffic, ... by lugg on Sunday August 27, 2017 @09:25AM (#15110682)
People don't click random ads at random times.

Google has more than enough training data to pick up on this traffic with a high degree of accuracy using rudimentary machine learning.

Re:Google Issuing Refunds to Advertisers Over Fake Traffic, ... by ThePhysicist on Sunday August 27, 2017 @05:37AM (#15109957)
This might be quite dangerous if used without a solution to anonymize your IP and block all third party cookies, as it will expose your browsing habits and could even let advertisers de-anonymize you. Knowing that you regularly visit e.g. 5-10 specific domains can be enough to uniquely identify you in a dataset containing millions of people depending on the relative popularity rank of these domains. I would therefore be very cautious with this as it might do serious harm to your privacy. Not interacting with ads and not sending any data about you to the ad provider is still the best option for that. Also, most fake clicks can be easily detected (because you e.g. do not interact with the ad content after clicking on the ad), so it might not even do much harm to the ad providers (if that's the reason why you use the system, which I do not endorse personally).
Re:Google Issuing Refunds to Advertisers Over Fake Traffic, ... by ThePhysicist on Sunday August 27, 2017 @05:44AM (#15109991)
From their website:

> As the collected data gathered shows an omnivorous click-stream, user tracking, targeting and surveillance become futile.

This is (IMHO) a flawed and dangerous view, as by clicking on the ad you provide valuable information to the provider (I.e. that you visited the website on which the ad was embedded) and this information can be used to build a pretty detailed view of your browsing habits. As the largest ad networks have very high coverage on many domains (Google e.g is present on more than 80 % of the top 100k most popular domains) you will give them a wealth of data about you, which IMHO is a privacy nightmare.

Re:Google Issuing Refunds to Advertisers Over Fake Traffic, ... by jakobdabo on Sunday August 27, 2017 @05:55AM (#15110028)
If you are not running an ad blocker they already know you are visiting those sites from the trackers accompanying the ads, now they will also see a click from you which will make their database about your interests become less accurate.
Re:Google Issuing Refunds to Advertisers Over Fake Traffic, ... by ThePhysicist on Sunday August 27, 2017 @10:08AM (#15110856)
Yes, but one of the points of running an ad blocker is to avoid sending any information about you to third-party trackers, clicking on every ad nullifies this, even when blocking the third-party cookies. And as I said I don't think that it will make their databases less accurate, as it's often easy to separate false clicks from real ones (due to different engagement rates and requests).
Re:Google Issuing Refunds to Advertisers Over Fake Traffic, ... by swills on Sunday August 27, 2017 @09:56AM (#15110802)
I'm not sure this actually IS related. I think bot traffic is a bigger problem. Are you saying there's as much fake ad click traffic from AdNauseam as there is from bot traffic?
Re:Google Issuing Refunds to Advertisers Over Fake Traffic, ... by tonyedgecombe on Sunday August 27, 2017 @02:41AM (#15109469)
If that worked then advertisers would just switch to cost per acquisition.
Re:Google Issuing Refunds to Advertisers Over Fake Traffic, ... by cat199 on Sunday August 27, 2017 @08:40AM (#15110526)
quantified by? measured by?

"oh hey google, trust us, noone converted, we promise"

Re:Google Issuing Refunds to Advertisers Over Fake Traffic, ... by tonyedgecombe on Monday August 28, 2017 @06:04AM (#15115542)
Re:Google Issuing Refunds to Advertisers Over Fake Traffic, ... by cat199 on Friday September 01, 2017 @08:56AM (#15147951)
my understanding was this (sub)thread pertained to actual conversion - e.g. someone bought something.