News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google Issuing Refunds to Advertisers Over Fake Traffic, ... by amelius on Sunday August 27, 2017 @04:32AM (#15109742)
The problem with ads is much bigger than most people realize.

To put it simply: ads work against the free market; instead of the "best" product, the one with the largest advertisement budget wins.

Re:Google Issuing Refunds to Advertisers Over Fake Traffic, ... by srean on Sunday August 27, 2017 @04:37AM (#15109756)
Free market cannot work without propagation of information. Curious what kind of mechanism you envision to solve that problem: public service anouncements in place of ads ?
Re:Google Issuing Refunds to Advertisers Over Fake Traffic, ... by psyc on Sunday August 27, 2017 @09:02AM (#15110620)
I can't recall a time when ads ever provided useful information about products, as opposed to psychologically conditioned brand awareness.
Re:Google Issuing Refunds to Advertisers Over Fake Traffic, ... by neotek on Sunday August 27, 2017 @10:57AM (#15111035)
How about providing knowledge of the mere existence of the product? How is that not useful?
Re:Google Issuing Refunds to Advertisers Over Fake Traffic, ... by clarry on Sunday August 27, 2017 @11:15AM (#15111108)
If it really did that. In practice, it doesn't. Not for me anyway. It's like firing an assault rifle at the sky and hoping there's someone to catch the bullet, where ever it might land. It's just spam about products I'm never going to buy and don't need to know about.

By all means, give me all the ads when I'm actually looking for a product to buy. The sad thing is that when I do that, all the ads tend to be irrelevant. Even on sites like amazon, which should know what I'm looking for. They have these sponsored product placements that are supposed to be relevant to my search. In practice, they hardly ever are. And if they're somewhat relevant, they're still not relevant enough for me to consider purchase.

Online ads do an incredibly bad job of providing useful knowledge about the mere existence of a product.

In practice, I always need to turn to reviews, forums, word-of-mouth, etc. etc. etc., and finding useful information in the infinite sea of ad-spam is quite frustrating.

Re:Google Issuing Refunds to Advertisers Over Fake Traffic, ... by amelius on Sunday August 27, 2017 @05:13AM (#15109873)
If ads were the only type of information, we were already doomed.

For example, why do you think reviews are so important?

Also, you are reading articles through HN, not by watching ads for them first.

Then there is the age-old word-of-mouth.

Or seeing products in action with friends.

I could go on and on.

Re:Google Issuing Refunds to Advertisers Over Fake Traffic, ... by srean on Sunday August 27, 2017 @05:33AM (#15109939)
I see that you have a very practical and scalable solution out there.

We will gush about a movie/product/service launch on television and call it news. One might even consider incentivising people to write positive reviews, we will just not call them ads. Why havent we seen any of these yet ? I have my review-blocker, post-blocker, word-of-mouth blocker startups still in waiting.

Re:Google Issuing Refunds to Advertisers Over Fake Traffic, ... by zaptheimpaler on Sunday August 27, 2017 @10:21AM (#15110894)
There are farms of blogs with junk content and reviews that exist purely for ad revenue and referral marketing. Online communities have sockpuppets doing the same shit. Respected news papers have "submarine" PR pieces promoting one product or another. The fake positive reviews you mention already exist - both on blogs and sites like Amazon, App Store etc.

In this vast sea of noise, it is very hard to find good information. These massive industries keep churning out ads in a million different forms & keep blurring the lines between ad/content with a motive to sell and trustworthy content from a real person without ulterior motives.

Its a constant never-ending war on trustworthy content and erodes the webs utility as a whole. In the past 10 years the web has become more and more of an artificially curated garden to sell you shit and keep you clicking.. and despite many protests about ads, they remain invasive and pervasive.

They ignore all these concerns and keep ramping it up. So I don't think twice about using AdNaseaum.

Re:Google Issuing Refunds to Advertisers Over Fake Traffic, ... by srean on Sunday August 27, 2017 @12:52PM (#15111529)
I agree with everything you said, but carpet-bombing the crap out of all ads does not seem to be an improvement. Ads satisfy a real need, stamp it out artificially and it will come up with some other name, some other form.

This

     war against *
 
is too hackneyed an approach, admittedly, very popular in the US. It has not done much good anywhere.
Re:Google Issuing Refunds to Advertisers Over Fake Traffic, ... by zaptheimpaler on Monday August 28, 2017 @12:16AM (#15114378)
Well using ad nauseaum is not carpet bombing or waging a war - all depends on how you define war. Its just sending a message, if enough people send the message things will change. If not, they will continue to get worse.
Re:Google Issuing Refunds to Advertisers Over Fake Traffic, ... by srean on Monday August 28, 2017 @03:56AM (#15115082)
It depends on how it is used, but I would have no qualms about going after the egregiously annoying and inherently dishonest ads. Those are the ones where even the advertiser knows that a click indicates absolutely no intent to explore or to buy, the reader was just tricked into triggering a booby trap. Some pages are so bad that it feels like navigating a veritable minefield, you dont know where to position your mouse to read the damn article. To all who wants to go after these guys, godspeed. I dont use adblock, but I do use flashblock and nuke javascript on all except a few whitelisted sites that I keep expanding as needed.

But seriously, I am genuinely tickled that my sarcastic comments on this post was mistaken for genuine lack of knowledge regarding paid reviews and submarine articles.

My goal was to point out that if one kills one specific form-factor it will reappear in some other form-factor and it already has; to point out that the notion that reviews, articles, word of mouth can be a substitute for ads is a silly idea [0]. Paid reviews and submarine articles being some of the other form factors. Those reviews and articles are just as dishonest if not more so and ignoring them to target others rather indiscriminately is not going to result in a better web. Thats closer to a baby throwing a tantrum than anything else.

An indiscriminate war against all ads is just childish and silly. Silly is the sweeping notion that _all_ ads are essentially motivated by malice [1] and only does harm to the reader.

[0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15109873

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15110059

Re:Google Issuing Refunds to Advertisers Over Fake Traffic, ... by amelius on Sunday August 27, 2017 @06:17AM (#15110075)
Incentivized reviews == ads == bad

Are you saying that ads are okay simply because we have no means to eradicate them?

Re:Google Issuing Refunds to Advertisers Over Fake Traffic, ... by yjftsjthsd-h on Sunday August 27, 2017 @12:37PM (#15111470)
> One might even consider incentivising people to write positive reviews, we will just not call them ads.

Are you being sarcastic, or are you unaware that this is a real thing that happens?

Re:Google Issuing Refunds to Advertisers Over Fake Traffic, ... by Noos on Sunday August 27, 2017 @08:11AM (#15110419)
How do you get reviews when people have no idea the product exists in the first place? The amount of ignorance these comments have about why marketing in general is a necessary part of business is disheartening.
Re:Google Issuing Refunds to Advertisers Over Fake Traffic, ... by legopelle on Sunday August 27, 2017 @05:02AM (#15109832)
I imagine a single state-owned database where merchants enter detailed product information. The consumers may then query the database at their leisure.
Re:Google Issuing Refunds to Advertisers Over Fake Traffic, ... by KGIII on Sunday August 27, 2017 @05:22AM (#15109907)
Which government would you trust to do that?
Re:Google Issuing Refunds to Advertisers Over Fake Traffic, ... by pbhjpbhj on Sunday August 27, 2017 @05:33AM (#15109941)
I'd trust the UK civil service to do that. The hardest but would probably be verification -- does that lasagne really only have beef in, was the cocoa for that chocolate actually grown in a Fairtrade farm, in Ivory Coast, etc..
Re:Google Issuing Refunds to Advertisers Over Fake Traffic, ... by KGIII on Sunday August 27, 2017 @05:45AM (#15109993)
I'm American. I don't even trust my government to do math properly.
Re:Google Issuing Refunds to Advertisers Over Fake Traffic, ... by gaius on Sunday August 27, 2017 @05:42AM (#15109981)
The French, bring back Le Minitel!
Re:Google Issuing Refunds to Advertisers Over Fake Traffic, ... by KGIII on Sunday August 27, 2017 @05:49AM (#15110003)
And if there is a change in the political spectrum, will you still trust them? My government lost my security clearance application to who knows who. In return, I got some credit monitoring and a form letter.
Re:Google Issuing Refunds to Advertisers Over Fake Traffic, ... by hesarenu on Sunday August 27, 2017 @12:19PM (#15111367)
India has something similar. Datakart app from gs1 has product related information. You can scan using barcodes.
Re:Google Issuing Refunds to Advertisers Over Fake Traffic, ... by shubhamjain on Sunday August 27, 2017 @04:42AM (#15109773)
I disagree. A large advertising budget will win more eyeballs but that doesn't meant a shitty product will have a free reign. A product has to work hard to justify its value. Yes, marketing and advertising is misused to make people pay more for the same thing, but that doesn't mean that chief benefit of advertising, which is discovery, is lost in the process.
Re:Google Issuing Refunds to Advertisers Over Fake Traffic, ... by srean on Sunday August 27, 2017 @05:28AM (#15109928)
I would keep ads. But I would prefer if advertisers are not allowed to lie or make unverified claims on ads. I would perefer to be able to take an advertiser to court for the claims made. That still leaves a lot of room for word play and weaseling ..."upto 80% improvement in blah", but better than nothing.
Re:Google Issuing Refunds to Advertisers Over Fake Traffic, ... by CM30 on Monday August 28, 2017 @07:11AM (#15115766)
Isn't that what the Advertising Standards Authority does in various regions?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Advertising_Standards_Authorit...

There are laws and guidelines stating that claims made in ads have to be backed up, or at least not misleading and there are companies who've been fined or forced to take down ads because of it.

Whether it works well is another question though.

Re:Google Issuing Refunds to Advertisers Over Fake Traffic, ... by srean on Monday August 28, 2017 @02:29PM (#15118903)
> Whether it works well ?

You must be kidding, right ? I would be happy if it works at all.