Re:Domain Names
by jazzychad on Monday July 12, 2010 @11:29PM
(#1510276)
Funny, I would have picked the "Baking for Dummies" book. Perhaps it's because I am a novice at cooking and don't necessarily want the best book on baking at the moment, just an introductory one; and I can be pretty sure the Dummies book will be decent since it is part of a well-known series.
Likewise with these StackExchange sites; some of them I had no idea they were stackexchange sites until I actually visited them. It took quite a while to click on their links after seeing them around the net in some cases. Had it been superuser.stackexchange.com I would have immediately known it would probably be a high-caliber Q&A site.
Re:Domain Names
by JadeNB on Tuesday July 13, 2010 @12:25AM
(#1510358)
I think the general premise that ‘series are bad’ is flawed. When I am looking for programming books, I look for O'Reilly (maybe that doesn't count as a series, in the sense that one can refer to “O'Reilly volume 47” or whatever, but neither can one do that with a “for Dummies” book); when I am looking for math books, I look for Springer Lecture Notes, London Math Notes, or any of a number of other series. (In fact, I was just marvelling the other day at the universality of the Springer brand—even in domains about which I don't know anything, when I see that logo, I immediately think that I'm seeing a book that's worth reading.)
Re:Domain Names
by hartror on Tuesday July 13, 2010 @01:35AM
(#1510464)
Brands are aimed at demographics, which is why Unilever has the Dove brand and the Lynx brand for basically the same product for example. People identify with a brand, have a perception and make purchasing decisions based on it.
What Joel's point is, I believe, is that generic umbrella series/brands are bad for user/customer perception (such as his "For Dummies" example). And as the entire Stack Exchange ecosystem is going to cover a massive range of topics it makes more sense to separate them as the good perception of a Stack Exchange cooking site isn't going to help the perception of a Stack Exchange mechanics site.
Re:Domain Names
by fragmede on Tuesday July 13, 2010 @01:54AM
(#1510498)
I can kinda see Joel's point, but it runs counter to the whole notion of branding. Cooking may seem to have little to do with mechanics, but a QA website about cooking vs. a QA website about mechanics has, well, the QA website part in common.
That's not to say I'd put up with crap on a mechanic's QA site even if the cooking QA site was good, but previous experience with Google search absolutely helped sell the Gmail switch.
Re:Domain Names
by JadeNB on Tuesday July 13, 2010 @04:21AM
(#1510756)
> What Joel's point is, I believe, is that generic umbrella series/brands are bad for user/customer perception (such as his "For Dummies" example).
I'm not saying that there is no such thing as a bad umbrella brand, just that there is such a thing as a good umbrella brand (at least for me). Springer (which also covers a massive range of topics!), and possibly also O'Reilly, are examples of umbrella brands that I perceive as good. In fact, I can think of far more good umbrella brands than bad ones for books; as a bibliophile, I rely on my knowledge that I can trust certain publishers for quality, format, content, &c. to help me make my buying decisions quickly.
I can't think of many examples of good or bad brands for websites—except CPAN and its derivatives, which are (again, to me) a very good umbrella brand indeed. (I can think of CTAN and JSAN right off the top of my head; I'm sure that there are others.)
Re:Domain Names
by robryan on Tuesday July 13, 2010 @12:00AM
(#1510327)
It works both ways I guess, I generally avoid the for Dummies series I think mainly because I've gone through a few a long time ago and didn't find them to useful. So yes, the brand can carry over, but also in a negative as well as a positive way.
Although with stack exchange it doesn't matter to much, because the sites all have the same look. So that works the same way the domain name would.
Re:Domain Names
by thenbrent on Monday July 12, 2010 @11:38PM
(#1510289)
I was trying to support reasonable use of editorial. I was not supporting "linkbait" editorial. There is a big difference.
The poster referenced a piece of the article. He/she did no use gratuitous link bait like "* * * TOP 5 DOMAIN CHOOSING TIPS [vid] * * * ". It's unfair to treat them like they did just because they changed the title.
Re:Domain Names
by teebes on Monday July 12, 2010 @10:56PM
(#1510209)
Completely agree. And about the actual article... isn't debating the merits of the domain names publicly going to attract domain sitters to buy those names as they are discussed? Especially given the emphasis on .coms, they are cheap to own and sit on.
Re:Domain Names
by robryan on Monday July 12, 2010 @11:58PM
(#1510323)
It mentioned contacting someone, so not exactly in the open. I guess they could register everything that seems decent and then discuss the choices in the open.
Re:Domain Names
by thunk on Tuesday July 13, 2010 @01:42AM
(#1510476)
Say, hypothetically, you discover a long, well-written, insightful and generally intellectual-curiosity-gratifying essay on the craft of programming, titled "10 Ways to Grow Your Penis". Would it be reasonable to editorialize?
If you're wondering about the reference to being "Influenced by Ries and Trout", it's a reference to the book Positioning: The Battle for your Mind, which I've recommended on HN before and will continue to do so - http://www.amazon.com/Positioning-Battle-Your-Al-Ries/dp/007...
It talks about the importance of standing out in your marketplace, because consumers want simple purchasing decisions so will only, at best, compare the top few.
Re:Domain Names
by kes on Monday July 12, 2010 @10:29PM
(#1510162)
I wonder how this relates to Reddit. Both sites (SO and Reddit) have unique, community driven and created sections.
Would a site like Reddit benefit from turning some of these sections into top-level domains? I know that they are having financial issues right now, and could this be a possible step to move away from their problems into something that would be profitable?
Re:Domain Names
by metellus on Monday July 12, 2010 @11:18PM
(#1510253)
I think the communities are fundamentally different. On Reddit, you think of yourself as a Redditor. You may only go to certain subreddits, but it's all supposed to be a part of something large. For SO, one of the main points was to give quality search engine results. You search for some problem you have and SO shows up instead of experts-exchange! ServerFault and other spinoffs are supposed to stand on their own in a way that I think Reddits are not.
Re:Domain Names
by sgallant on Monday July 12, 2010 @11:14PM
(#1510250)
He's definitely referring to experts-exchange.
I listened a great interview with Jeff Atwood on Herding code today (http://herdingcode.com/?p=263). It's funny how their QnA model seems so obvious in retrospect.
Re:Domain Names
by ErrantX on Tuesday July 13, 2010 @04:58AM
(#1510814)
I think Joel misses the point about brands; whilst still getting the decision right :)
Stack Overflow is a brand - in it's visuals and how it works.
The name is where it gets interesting; because often products are "branded" using their name - but not always. And this is one case where there is absolutely no need to brand the sites using the Stack Overflow name - doing so would be like branding it the same way as the supermarket own brand of a top class store. i.e. the store is quality, the goods are quality, but the brand name makes it look cheap :)
Re:Domain Names
by qjz on Monday July 12, 2010 @11:53PM
(#1510312)
The most important and valuable aspect of a top level domain is that it can be treated as an individual asset if there is an opportunity to sell it (or if it needs to be split away from the parent organization for some other reason).
To support this, it's ideal if all of its resources (images, stylesheets, scripts, etc.) are also served from within the domain, without being dependent on other domains owned by the parent organization (code can still be shared by using symlinks or multiple virtual hosts pointing to the same resources). This should help simplify any transfer.
Re:Domain Names
by netcan on Tuesday July 13, 2010 @03:12AM
(#1510614)
Exchange sites are part of a series.
The real question is not about some abstract branding truth: people trust/don't trust series.
They should be asking whether they want to accentuate or deaccentuate the grouping. Do they want good brand equity to flow between them. Do they want to avoid bad brand equity (brand liability?) to flowing? Do they want the sites to feel more independent?
Relying on 'series are bad' as justification is like when clients tell me that blue makes their clients feel like buying.
Re:Domain Names
by dirtyaura on Tuesday July 13, 2010 @03:28AM
(#1510655)
But StackExchange sites will work only if they inspire a community of domain experts around each site. And the whole Stack Exchange idea is about separate communities, not about community around Stack Exchange brand.
I bet that garden aficionados around the world would enjoy more to be part of the LiliesAndRoses.com community than StackExchange.com/Flowers community.
Re:Domain Names
by netcan on Tuesday July 13, 2010 @05:03AM
(#1510826)
One the other hand, they are looking for members of one community to seed the next. They are looking for people to understand some of the concepts by recognising it as an exchange site. They are looking for communities to learn from eachother.
I'm not saying it's the wrong choice. I don't know much about it.
Just saying that as an argument 'Americans don't trust series,' doesn't cut it. I also think it isn't true. I absolutely do pic 'Lonely Planet.'
Re:Domain Names
by prawn on Tuesday July 13, 2010 @02:50AM
(#1510595)
And to me also (as someone who buys domains, does some SEO, etc), but I wonder if it's also true for the general public? Have they come to make that same association or is it just another domain to them?
Re:Domain Names
by rlpb on Tuesday July 13, 2010 @07:48AM
(#1511037)
Years ago, I used to prefer them because I thought they were more readable. Then I realised how much of a pain it is to give your email address out over the phone if you have punctuation in it.
Re:Domain Names
by mkramlich on Tuesday July 13, 2010 @01:49AM
(#1510494)
I think their argument about series domains vs standalone names is actually backward. If people like the StackOverflow format you want to easily attract those people to the other sites that use the same engine. You want cross-polination of visitors, and you probably want to get some PageRank momentum of the established base domain name.
Re:Domain Names
by sjm on Tuesday July 13, 2010 @02:47AM
(#1510587)
If the quality is excellent and the name isn't tacky (e.g. for Dummes), then I think a series is much more beneficial. There's no way I'd compare '..for Dummies!' books and StackExchange on anywhere near equal footing.
If you have to use dashes in your URL, then you must be desperate for that name. A business would only register shirlaws-coaching.com if shirlawscoaching.com were already taken, and the business was desperate for those words.
The OP's opinion seems to be 'if you need dashes to make it work, it ain't gonna work, move on'.
Re:Domain Names
by jasonrr on Tuesday July 13, 2010 @09:07AM
(#1511190)
Maybe easier to read on screen, but not easier to type or say to someone else. There was a previous comment about reading punctuation over the phone, which I've found true. In addition, there are lots of folks who are generally confused by which punctuation mark is which. My wife recently had a 5 minute conversation with someone who simply didn't know what a dash was (it's in her company's domain). As the SO brand spreads beyond the hacker community memorable word-based URLS without punctuation will be even more important.
My biggest problem with the series vs. individual sites thing is that I already have to remember so many URLs and information about my identity on each site. Where do I log in to see all of my notifications from the various sites? How do I find my friends when I move from one site to another? How do I see that a bunch of my friends are now answering questions on a cool topic on a totally new SE site? A series approach would have provided a much more straight forward approach to answering these questions. I think the unique sites make leveraging the asset of users who participate in many communities harder.
Likewise with these StackExchange sites; some of them I had no idea they were stackexchange sites until I actually visited them. It took quite a while to click on their links after seeing them around the net in some cases. Had it been superuser.stackexchange.com I would have immediately known it would probably be a high-caliber Q&A site.
I guess I'm an outlier on both points?
What Joel's point is, I believe, is that generic umbrella series/brands are bad for user/customer perception (such as his "For Dummies" example). And as the entire Stack Exchange ecosystem is going to cover a massive range of topics it makes more sense to separate them as the good perception of a Stack Exchange cooking site isn't going to help the perception of a Stack Exchange mechanics site.
That's not to say I'd put up with crap on a mechanic's QA site even if the cooking QA site was good, but previous experience with Google search absolutely helped sell the Gmail switch.
I'm not saying that there is no such thing as a bad umbrella brand, just that there is such a thing as a good umbrella brand (at least for me). Springer (which also covers a massive range of topics!), and possibly also O'Reilly, are examples of umbrella brands that I perceive as good. In fact, I can think of far more good umbrella brands than bad ones for books; as a bibliophile, I rely on my knowledge that I can trust certain publishers for quality, format, content, &c. to help me make my buying decisions quickly.
I can't think of many examples of good or bad brands for websites—except CPAN and its derivatives, which are (again, to me) a very good umbrella brand indeed. (I can think of CTAN and JSAN right off the top of my head; I'm sure that there are others.)
Although with stack exchange it doesn't matter to much, because the sites all have the same look. So that works the same way the domain name would.
I think it's reasonable to use one of the more interesting points of the article when the original title is so vague.
The poster referenced a piece of the article. He/she did no use gratuitous link bait like "* * * TOP 5 DOMAIN CHOOSING TIPS [vid] * * * ". It's unfair to treat them like they did just because they changed the title.
It talks about the importance of standing out in your marketplace, because consumers want simple purchasing decisions so will only, at best, compare the top few.
Would a site like Reddit benefit from turning some of these sections into top-level domains? I know that they are having financial issues right now, and could this be a possible step to move away from their problems into something that would be profitable?
I listened a great interview with Jeff Atwood on Herding code today (http://herdingcode.com/?p=263). It's funny how their QnA model seems so obvious in retrospect.
Stack Overflow is a brand - in it's visuals and how it works.
The name is where it gets interesting; because often products are "branded" using their name - but not always. And this is one case where there is absolutely no need to brand the sites using the Stack Overflow name - doing so would be like branding it the same way as the supermarket own brand of a top class store. i.e. the store is quality, the goods are quality, but the brand name makes it look cheap :)
Doesn't Craigslist fly in the face of this theory?
To support this, it's ideal if all of its resources (images, stylesheets, scripts, etc.) are also served from within the domain, without being dependent on other domains owned by the parent organization (code can still be shared by using symlinks or multiple virtual hosts pointing to the same resources). This should help simplify any transfer.
The real question is not about some abstract branding truth: people trust/don't trust series.
They should be asking whether they want to accentuate or deaccentuate the grouping. Do they want good brand equity to flow between them. Do they want to avoid bad brand equity (brand liability?) to flowing? Do they want the sites to feel more independent?
Relying on 'series are bad' as justification is like when clients tell me that blue makes their clients feel like buying.
I bet that garden aficionados around the world would enjoy more to be part of the LiliesAndRoses.com community than StackExchange.com/Flowers community.
I'm not saying it's the wrong choice. I don't know much about it.
Just saying that as an argument 'Americans don't trust series,' doesn't cut it. I also think it isn't true. I absolutely do pic 'Lonely Planet.'
To me, dashes reek of desperate SEO.
Dashed domains are to SEO as bogosort is to scalability.
The OP's opinion seems to be 'if you need dashes to make it work, it ain't gonna work, move on'.
www.salesexchange.com - "sales exchange" or "sale sex change" www.sales-exchange.com makes the meaning clear.
But I agree with you about spammy domain names like http://www.black-and-white-digital-photography.com.
My biggest problem with the series vs. individual sites thing is that I already have to remember so many URLs and information about my identity on each site. Where do I log in to see all of my notifications from the various sites? How do I find my friends when I move from one site to another? How do I see that a bunch of my friends are now answering questions on a cool topic on a totally new SE site? A series approach would have provided a much more straight forward approach to answering these questions. I think the unique sites make leveraging the asset of users who participate in many communities harder.