News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:83 percent of Bay Area renters plan to leave, says survey by schnevets on Wednesday August 16, 2017 @11:20AM (#15028153)
I'm noticing similar sentiments among friends in New York City. Everyone came here for jobs/culture/friends after graduating, but the mad-rush of millennials is making the city more and more unlivable. Nobody wants to spend their thirties in a cramped, overpriced studio, but nobody is ready to leave their hip, startup lofts for the drudgery of a Westchester office complex (let alone endure an hour commute into the city every day).

Smaller cities (the Portlands, New Havens, and Columbuses of the country) will continue to inherit the overflow, with those cities that have the lowest cultural cachet taking the lowliest remnants. Given the demand for urban environments by businesses and consumers, it seems like the only thing holding back any city from heavy growth is incompetence or negative reputations.

Re:83 percent of Bay Area renters plan to leave, says survey by tmh79 on Wednesday August 16, 2017 @11:23AM (#15028192)
> but the mad-rush of millennials is making the city more and more unlivable

IMO, the problem is the policies of the city that are unfriendly to growth and make housing a zero sum game, the problem isn't than people expressing their preferences.

Re:83 percent of Bay Area renters plan to leave, says survey by hinkley on Wednesday August 16, 2017 @12:34PM (#15028862)
About 8 years ago I went to OSCon in Portland and someone told me it was currently employing some ridiculous percentage of all of the construction cranes available.

And about this time three years ago I was standing in an office in downtown Seattle and we could count fourteen cranes. There's still a lot of space for midrise buildings. I'm just not sure transportation is keeping up.

Re:83 percent of Bay Area renters plan to leave, says survey by irrational on Wednesday August 16, 2017 @01:30PM (#15029387)
One of the main reasons we moved to Portland 17 years ago was there was almost no traffic, whereas Seattle, where my wife is from, had a ton of traffic. Now Portland has a ton of traffic. I recently read an article in the local newspaper that there used to be certain hours in the morning and afternoon when traffic would be heavy, but other others would have no traffic. But, that is no longer the case. All hours now have heavy traffic. It sucks ;-)

Of course, everytime we go back to Seattle to visit the family we are reminded of what real heavy traffic looks like (though that still isn't anything like what LAs traffic look like where I once got into bumper to bumper traffic at midnight on a Sunday from Anaheim to Santa Clarita - now that is real traffic).

Re:83 percent of Bay Area renters plan to leave, says survey by mmmpop on Wednesday August 16, 2017 @12:52PM (#15029020)
Denver's skyline is littered with somewhere around a dozen too. The west-side of downtown has grown a tremendous amount in just about 3 years. Seems like mostly shoddily-constructed apartment buildings (source: a guy who helped design 4 of them).
Re:83 percent of Bay Area renters plan to leave, says survey by eunoia on Wednesday August 16, 2017 @01:08PM (#15029166)
We've got way more than a dozen... Anecdotally they do seem to be mostly sub-par, overpriced apartment buildings by and large.

https://www.bizjournals.com/denver/maps/crane-watch

I keep wondering when the supply of 2k+/month shoddily constructed one bedroom rental apartments will catch up with the demand for them. That may not seem like a lot for the Bay types, but Denver has traditionally been a lot cheaper. The last 5-10 years have seen crazy population and rent growth.

Re:83 percent of Bay Area renters plan to leave, says survey by tmh79 on Wednesday August 16, 2017 @01:05PM (#15029146)
a "shoddily constructed" building is still a place for people to live.
Re:83 percent of Bay Area renters plan to leave, says survey by mmmpop on Wednesday August 16, 2017 @02:00PM (#15029628)
But it doesn't inspire much faith in those investing in living in Denver (by say, purchasing a very expensive home) when big capital doesn't see it fit to finance a building meant to last a century. Do they not have confidence that people will still be wanting to pay these same exorbitant rents in 2040?
Re:83 percent of Bay Area renters plan to leave, says survey by scarmig on Wednesday August 16, 2017 @12:40PM (#15028920)
NYC is not SF. It's not perfect, but it's not anti-growth.
Re:83 percent of Bay Area renters plan to leave, says survey by irq11 on Wednesday August 16, 2017 @12:47PM (#15028978)
Careful. You're getting perilously close to the hackernews shibboleth on development policy.

Remember: if housing is expensive, it must be because there aren't enough skyscrapers. There can be no other logical explanation.

Re:83 percent of Bay Area renters plan to leave, says survey by xienze on Wednesday August 16, 2017 @01:01PM (#15029099)
The downvotes mean you're on to something ;).

I share the sentiment. I find it likewise amusing that the same crowd that argues that building additional highway capacity won't accomplish anything because it'll just get filled with more cars seems to think that additional housing capacity won't similarly be filled up immediately.

Re:83 percent of Bay Area renters plan to leave, says survey by deathanatos on Wednesday August 16, 2017 @01:14PM (#15029233)
There are two, closely related paradoxes:

There's the Downs-Thomson paradox[1], which is usually quoted as adding capacity to highways to the road network will not reduce congestion, and the one I believe you mean. What the paradox actually states is that "the equilibrium speed of car traffic on a road network is determined by the average door-to-door speed of equivalent journeys taken by public transport." That is, as you add capacity to road networks, you disincentivize people from taking public transport, because the roads are quicker, until the two level out in terms of cost/benefit.

I'm not certain how directly applicable it is to the housing market. Essentially, what is the housing market's "public transport"? I suppose you could argue it's still public transit, since there is a trade-off between the more expensive, but closer housing and the cheaper but farther away public housing. But I'm also in favor (and I think most of the people in the HN SF crowd are) of better public transit in the Bay Area and better housing/zoning policy. (Either would help me and many others: a better public transit network would reduce the need for housing in cities closer & further up the Bay.)

There's also Jevons paradox[2], which says that when "technological progress increases the efficiency with which a resource is used (reducing the amount necessary for any one use), but the rate of consumption of that resource rises because of increasing demand." This is mostly concerned with reducing use of the resource though, and I fully expect that better zoning policy would result in more and cheaper housing, more use of said housing, and more demand — all in line with Jevons paradox, but none of which seems detrimental when compared to the current situation.

[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Downs%E2%80%93Thomson_paradox

[2]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jevons_paradox

Re:83 percent of Bay Area renters plan to leave, says survey by dredmorbius on Wednesday August 16, 2017 @01:48PM (#15029534)
Housing's "more roads" is simply density.

In transport, more roads means more capacity to carry traffic, and hence, more induced traffic. The death-spiral effect comes from the fact that each additional car on the road produces far more congestion than its operator alone experiences (negative externalities). True costs aren't born by the operator, so gridlock ensues.

For housing, or rather, urban development generally, the challenge is that denser cities with more inhabitants (generally) give rise to greater opportunity. This is where the action is, for whatever definition of action you have.

I'm not entirely sure what produces the death-spiral of cities pricing themselves out of their own housing markets, as SF is doing, but I'm inclined to think that the general trend of holders of investment assets to seek inflation of those assets' values is a key element. That is, you have a house, you've sunk a lot of money into it, you want its value to increase (hey! free money, right?). This turns into collaterisable assets for loans or other opportunities as well.

There's also the fact that high-value urban real-estate markets make for good options to bank wealth appropriated elsewhere, or for money-laundering. Values are high, tend to remain high, the market is liquid, and urban cores are far more stable for real estate prices than outlying areas. Hence, the housing stock value is bid up further.

Land value tax might help address that. Something I'm looking at. Originally suggested by Adam Smith and David Ricardo, though championed by Henry George.

Re:83 percent of Bay Area renters plan to leave, says survey by milesvp on Thursday August 17, 2017 @01:50AM (#15034086)
If you're interested in 'real world' emperical and experimental data on under utilized resources due to low rents the economist for eve online has some pretty convincing data based on actual game changes they made.

Basically they had a problem of high value 'factories' being undeveloped since there was only opportunity costs associated with their not producing goods. Government rents were increased such that factories were only profitable for people utilizing them, and they saw a huge increase in total gdp.

Re:83 percent of Bay Area renters plan to leave, says survey by dredmorbius on Friday August 18, 2017 @12:05PM (#15047365)
Thanks, that's a wonderful example.

I keep hearing that gaming comes up with interesting case studies, but rarely specifics such as this.

Re:83 percent of Bay Area renters plan to leave, says survey by afarrell on Wednesday August 16, 2017 @02:31PM (#15029931)
I wish there was an investment vehicle where you could sell a portion of the equity of your own home for a share of equity in construction projects in your area.
Re:83 percent of Bay Area renters plan to leave, says survey by astrange on Wednesday August 16, 2017 @02:38PM (#15029983)
You could get a second mortgage and use it to buy REITs. (In CA funding YIMBYs would be more productive.)
Re:83 percent of Bay Area renters plan to leave, says survey by dredmorbius on Thursday August 17, 2017 @12:08AM (#15033743)
Land value tax.
Re:83 percent of Bay Area renters plan to leave, says survey by jtmcmc on Wednesday August 16, 2017 @02:03PM (#15029649)
yes prop 13 is an active problem with housing in the bay area as well.
Re:83 percent of Bay Area renters plan to leave, says survey by dredmorbius on Saturday August 19, 2017 @09:32AM (#15053244)
Definitely an element, yes.
Re:83 percent of Bay Area renters plan to leave, says survey by abalashov on Wednesday August 16, 2017 @01:38PM (#15029464)
That's not quite right. The argument about widening highways leading to more traffic is called "induced demand" and is an accepted concept in traffic engineering and city planning; when you make driving easier or cheaper, people will do more of it because they can. The same person with the same car will use it more of the time, because why not?

That's not quite how housing works. Yes, I suppose there's a broad supply-demand dynamic inasmuch as areas with more affordable house prices tend to see bigger houses and land parcels bought, but still, people don't just use more units of housing stock in response to a slightly less onerous housing crunch. If housing in the SF Bay area suddenly became more attainable, I wouldn't buy 3 apartments just 'cause.

Re:83 percent of Bay Area renters plan to leave, says survey by maxsilver on Wednesday August 16, 2017 @02:44PM (#15030021)
> If housing in the SF Bay area suddenly became more attainable, I wouldn't buy 3 apartments just 'cause.

But that's equally true of the highways too. If you widen a freeway, I'm not going suddenly commute to and from work an extra 3 times each day just 'cause.

> when you make driving easier or cheaper, people will do more of it because they can.

Not really, not anywhere near the amount people claim. This is a common misconception made by miscounting traffic on freeways past capacity. They mistake failed trips as non-existent ones, and then mistakingly claim "new traffic" was created when failed trips stop failing.

It's like saying "if you make hospitals easier or cheaper, people will get more sick because they can". You could even support that false claim, by measuring patients in hospitals. "We had a 100 bed hospital last year, and it was full. We built a second 100 bed hospital this year, and now it's full too. Clearly building hospitals is a bad idea, because it just makes more sick people".

This obviously isn't true, people were still sick before, they were miscounted because they weren't in the hospital (it was full). Just like how new freeways don't create new traffic, they serve existing traffic that was miscounted before because it wasn't on the freeway (it was full).

Re:83 percent of Bay Area renters plan to leave, says survey by xienze on Wednesday August 16, 2017 @02:26PM (#15029885)
> If housing in the SF Bay area suddenly became more attainable, I wouldn't buy 3 apartments just 'cause.

No, but you'd have all those people waiting on the sidelines jumping in immediately. Net result, housing is still expensive (sorta like the highway analogy, we still have tons of traffic after building these lanes).

Re:83 percent of Bay Area renters plan to leave, says survey by rm_-rf_slash on Wednesday August 16, 2017 @01:46PM (#15029522)
But to be fair, more housing stock in San Francisco could also lead to wealthier tech workers buying crash pads in the city for work during the week while they spend their weekends out at their houses in Silicon Valley, Berkeley, etc.
Re:83 percent of Bay Area renters plan to leave, says survey by abalashov on Wednesday August 16, 2017 @01:53PM (#15029577)
All of that is certainly true, but given the supply and the pricing, it seems very unlikely that the needle is going to move anywhere near that much? In what other major metropolis in the world do you see people doing that on a mass scale — the kind of mass scale at which it is meaningful to speak of induced demand?

The very wealthy will do it, of course, as they always have, and always will.

Re:83 percent of Bay Area renters plan to leave, says survey by randomstudent on Wednesday August 16, 2017 @01:10PM (#15029192)
> the same crowd that argues that building additional highway capacity won't accomplish anything because it'll just get filled with more cars

It will allow more people to commute into the city, which is the goal, right?

> seems to think that additional housing capacity won't similarly be filled up immediately.

And more people will be able to live there... Isn't that the goal?

Re:83 percent of Bay Area renters plan to leave, says survey by xienze on Wednesday August 16, 2017 @02:23PM (#15029865)
> And more people will be able to live there... Isn't that the goal?

The goal is "I want to be able to afford to live here." The only way to really affect prices is to absolutely flood the market with new housing. You can't just do it with a couple hundred units here, a couple hundred units there. Everyone in the world wants to live in SF, remember? They're just going to get snapped up and housing will still be expensive, the only real difference is that there's some more people living there now.

Re:83 percent of Bay Area renters plan to leave, says survey by astrange on Wednesday August 16, 2017 @02:47PM (#15030047)
I doubt everyone in the world wants to live in a city with bad transit, unusable public schools and feces everywhere, but if you want to reduce demand you could try and prop up some competitor cities instead.
Re:83 percent of Bay Area renters plan to leave, says survey by Spooky23 on Wednesday August 16, 2017 @01:25PM (#15029341)
In both cases there are tradeoffs and diminishing returns. We discovered in 1930s New York with the Triborough bridge that highways will always reach a level of equilibrium (i.e. Max peak capacity) and will drive sprawl -- the new trio generation doesn't necessarily improve efficiency. In the case of NYC, it created inefficiency as it pushed the metro area up 75 miles up the Hudson River and at least 50 into Long Island and Jersey.

Housing is boom/bust. Housing booms always attract dumb money and always bust.

Re:83 percent of Bay Area renters plan to leave, says survey by closeparen on Wednesday August 16, 2017 @06:32PM (#15031907)
>it pushed the metro area up 75 miles up the Hudson River and at least 50 into Long Island and Jersey.

So... it unlocked a whole bunch of housing supply? Sounds like a great policy!

Re:83 percent of Bay Area renters plan to leave, says survey by maxsilver on Wednesday August 16, 2017 @02:49PM (#15030065)
> I find it likewise amusing that the same crowd that argues that building additional highway capacity won't accomplish anything because it'll just get filled with more cars seems to think that additional housing capacity won't similarly be filled up immediately.

Yes, this! One thousand times this!

Either additional capacity helps service that need or it doesn't. You can't argue it both ways simultaneously. So many people want to pick and choose where they apply that logic, just to fit their political desires.

These two ideas are inherently contradictory, and it is an constant pet peeve of mine that most people refuse to recognize the contradiction.

Re:83 percent of Bay Area renters plan to leave, says survey by ewjordan on Wednesday August 16, 2017 @03:18PM (#15030317)
When a good is in limited supply, yes, it's trivially true that increasing supply will allow more people to use that good. That is not the same as saying that more supply will drive up demand or prices, merely that more of the existing demand will be met.

The difference between housing and cars-on-the-road is that housing is generally seen as a positive thing that people get real value out of, whereas cars-on-the-road are an unfortunate side effect of people not having housing near where they live. We explicitly want fewer people to drive into our cities; on the contrary we want more people living in housing near where they want to be.

To put it another way, if you really think that building more housing will make things worse, then why not argue for the destruction of existing housing stock to make things better?

Or do you think we're at a peak, where we have built just the right amount of housing and we should just leave it alone? I guess there probably is some amount that's just right for each city, though I have no idea what we'd have to look at to figure out that number.

Re:83 percent of Bay Area renters plan to leave, says survey by maxsilver on Wednesday August 16, 2017 @03:50PM (#15030648)
> To put it another way, if you really think that building more housing will make things worse, then why not argue for the destruction of existing housing stock to make things better?

I don't personally believe that. I think capacity solves shortage needs, consistently. But most don't.

Most people really believe your reasoning is valid, and they advocate for the exact destruction you've mentioned (see "Road Diets" / freeway removal / any article from CNU / etc).

> The difference between housing and cars-on-the-road is that housing is generally seen as a positive thing that people get real value out of, whereas cars-on-the-road are an unfortunate side effect of people not having housing near where they live

I think most people agree with you, but I personally believe this is a very dystopian view. Transportation is an inherently positive thing too, that real people get real value out of. Even if every single human lived right next to their work place, it's still a good thing that people have fast reliable easy freedom of movement in whatever method they prefer.

Even if you live right next to your workplace, your next job won't be. Your spouses job, or next job, won't be. Your parent's home won't be, your children's school won't be. Unless your constantly moving every 2 years, this idea of "transportation is just a bad side effect of not living inside your workplace" doesn't really hold up to regular life, in my opinion.

Re:83 percent of Bay Area renters plan to leave, says survey by closeparen on Wednesday August 16, 2017 @06:27PM (#15031889)
Building more freeways will deliver transportation to more people. HN thinks this is a bad thing because driving is inherently bad, so facilitating more driving is bad.

Fewer believe that people-living-in-homes is bad.

Re:83 percent of Bay Area renters plan to leave, says survey by stcredzero on Wednesday August 16, 2017 @01:11PM (#15029206)
If it is filled up immediately, then some potential unrealized economic growth of SF is then immediately realized.
Re:83 percent of Bay Area renters plan to leave, says survey by xienze on Wednesday August 16, 2017 @01:21PM (#15029293)
Sure, but it doesn't solve the problem of "I can't afford to live here".
Re:83 percent of Bay Area renters plan to leave, says survey by stcredzero on Friday August 18, 2017 @05:35PM (#15049929)
It would get us closer to the solution. It's just that getting closer to the solution doesn't result in an immediate rent drop.
Re:83 percent of Bay Area renters plan to leave, says survey by ameister14 on Wednesday August 16, 2017 @01:24PM (#15029324)
SF has a population that is 1/2 of Manhattan and covers 2x the area.
Re:83 percent of Bay Area renters plan to leave, says survey by irq11 on Wednesday August 16, 2017 @02:01PM (#15029635)
So? Your argument is that it's affordable? Or that they could build enough to make it affordable?

Both are laughably wrong.

Re:83 percent of Bay Area renters plan to leave, says survey by sliverstorm on Wednesday August 16, 2017 @12:27PM (#15028800)
It may not be a zero sum game, but it at least approximates/approaches zero sum. How exactly would you change downtown Manhattan such that anyone & everyone who wanted to live there could?
Re:83 percent of Bay Area renters plan to leave, says survey by twinkletwinkle on Wednesday August 16, 2017 @12:33PM (#15028854)
You've drawn a false dichotomy between the current situation and an unrealistic scenario. The truth is there could be more growth and room for more people without it being room for literally everyone.
Re:83 percent of Bay Area renters plan to leave, says survey by sliverstorm on Wednesday August 16, 2017 @12:37PM (#15028893)
Right, and that's what I mean by it approximates/approaches zero sum.

I'm not arguing against development, I just think a lot of the pro-development folks imagine that cities are making things zero sum with their policies, when real property will always have that element.

Re:83 percent of Bay Area renters plan to leave, says survey by Dylan16807 on Wednesday August 16, 2017 @12:59PM (#15029081)
Housing does not inherently have a major zero-sum factor until you're inside one of the densest downtowns in the country. In the general case it's all about policies and whether they allow demand to turn into construction.
Re:83 percent of Bay Area renters plan to leave, says survey by RealityNow on Wednesday August 16, 2017 @12:39PM (#15028909)
> How exactly would you change downtown Manhattan such that anyone & everyone who wanted to live there could?

That's not what we should be striving for. We should be striving to allow people to comfortably live and work outside of just downtown Manhattan. The biggest obstacles to that are zoning laws and a decrepit subway system that makes traveling between boroughs outside of Manhattan practically impossible.

Re:83 percent of Bay Area renters plan to leave, says survey by sliverstorm on Wednesday August 16, 2017 @12:43PM (#15028943)
Ok, maybe I was unfairly projecting, a few days ago I was talking to someone who was making basically that argument, that we have the housing technology to fit everyone in <downtown city>. Improved public transit in & out to neighboring nodes is a good goal that partially sidesteps the zero sum nature of property.
Re:83 percent of Bay Area renters plan to leave, says survey by crdoconnor on Wednesday August 16, 2017 @01:11PM (#15029202)
100% Land value tax. It would eliminate property hoarding and inefficient use of inner city land (e.g. low rises in high demand areas).

Better public transportation would also relieve pressure on the city center.

Re:83 percent of Bay Area renters plan to leave, says survey by cptskippy on Wednesday August 16, 2017 @01:34PM (#15029434)
> the problem is the policies of the city

That's more like a symptom.

Policies are shaped by people and people are motivated by forces. The motivating force in this case is probably money. There are lots of people who make money off real-estate and they're motivated to keep supply down to drive up costs. What better way than by influencing public policy to suit their agenda.

If you try to change city policy to make housing affordable then you're basically declaring war on a very influential portion of the population that has a lot to lose.

Re:83 percent of Bay Area renters plan to leave, says survey by overcast on Wednesday August 16, 2017 @11:26AM (#15028217)
I've seen quite a few New Yorkers moving Upstate to Western, NY. Rochester has been having quite a renaissance in the last 5-6 years. Especially in the food/cocktail scene. Outside of NYC, it's probably the best in the Northeast as far as I'm concerned. RIT, University of Rochester, and other top schools. Easy commutes, short rush hours, Fingerlakes, Great Lakes. There's multiple festivals nearly every week during the summer months. The Public Market is the second oldest in the entire country, and amazing. Far, and away the best grocery chain in the country (Wegmans). Also recently received $600 million in funds for photonics research.

Also cost of living is LOW, any decent wage here, especially in tech. You'll live like a king.

Re:83 percent of Bay Area renters plan to leave, says survey by dcole2929 on Wednesday August 16, 2017 @12:29PM (#15028816)
I went to RIT and Rochester is definitely a city trying to recreate itself, but it runs into the same problem that most every other north eastern city outside of NYC and Boston do. The weather sucks 6-8 months a year and there's not enough there to make up for that fact. I think it's a much more attractive option for families because it's so cheap and the schools are good. Still I think for a lot of personality types the lack of nightlife and comparatively small demo of post grad but pre middle aged people (what do we even call that age range) kills it.

Anecdotal obviously but after graduation everyone I know left, and those who couldn't still mostly want to. And to me that's the difference between say a city like Philly that's growing because people want to stay there after graduating.

Re:83 percent of Bay Area renters plan to leave, says survey by yardie on Wednesday August 16, 2017 @01:56PM (#15029599)
I live in the SE and from the opposite end it's not that great. A/C bill is high and only getting higher. And some days the trip outside leaves you drenched in sweat. Our "good" weather is really only from Nov-March and then it's a humid inferno.

I have a few friends that are looking to move north. Georgia seems to be absorbing a lot of Florida residents.

Re:83 percent of Bay Area renters plan to leave, says survey by overcast on Wednesday August 16, 2017 @01:07PM (#15029159)
Regarding the nightlife, that has done a total 180 in the last five years. Seriously, if you're into killer craft cocktails, seasonal farm to market type food. It's here, in droves. Yes, the weather sucks sometimes, but welcome to the Northeast. I'll take seasons over the same day over, and over.
Re:83 percent of Bay Area renters plan to leave, says survey by dcole2929 on Wednesday August 16, 2017 @01:37PM (#15029457)
I still wouldn't classify the nightlife as great. There is a lot for the college scene but Rochester is really missing that in between stage. I'd say even Buffalo's nightlife is better. And it helps that stuff is open til 4 there.

Side note Rochester is the same day over and over. And that day is cold, dreary and probably snowing. The 4-5 months of Spring/Summer/Fall though is amazing though.

Re:83 percent of Bay Area renters plan to leave, says survey by overcast on Wednesday August 16, 2017 @02:04PM (#15029665)
Venture out past East and Alexander then. There is TONS of nightlife for adults. Revelry, Nosh, Cure, Branca, Cub Room, Lento, Roux, Nox, Goodluck, Daily Refresher, Lux, and the general park ave area are all a good start. Buffalo's college scene is MUCH bigger.

4-5 months of amazing is fine with me, spend the rest working on projects, and making money.

Re:83 percent of Bay Area renters plan to leave, says survey by notadoc on Wednesday August 16, 2017 @03:10PM (#15030235)
Most of NY state is amazing, beautiful, great outdoors and scenery, lakes, rivers, tons of nice little towns and smaller cities. And aside from NYC, it's also dirt cheap.
Re:83 percent of Bay Area renters plan to leave, says survey by ende on Wednesday August 16, 2017 @12:39PM (#15028906)
We call it Western NY. Upstate NY is the Adirondacks.
Re:83 percent of Bay Area renters plan to leave, says survey by jrjarrett on Wednesday August 16, 2017 @12:25PM (#15028771)
I left Rochester in 2004, before the Kodak plane completely augered into the ground next to the Xerox, B&L, etc.

I'd moved there after college because it seemed to be the last Upstate place with any life in it but that all drained away.

What's changed in the intervening time? What's drawing people there, specifically for jobs?

Re:83 percent of Bay Area renters plan to leave, says survey by pcsanwald on Wednesday August 16, 2017 @01:08PM (#15029167)
Everyone I know who has moved upstate has done it because they can work remotely as a software engineer, and they are either from there, or just like the quality of life / cost of living balance. So, I would say the availability of remote work rather than industry.

There's obviously a significant sample bias in the above.

Re:83 percent of Bay Area renters plan to leave, says survey by overcast on Wednesday August 16, 2017 @01:17PM (#15029261)
A lot of research has come here, especially with University of Rochester, and RIT getting a research program. UofR is a HUGE employer, Paychex, Rochester General Health, Wegmans, and like I said previously the food, and drink scene has just exploded. There are quite a few restaurateurs, chefs , and bartenders that have moved upstate from downstate. I'm directly involved with that stuff, so I hear/eat/drink quite a bit.
Re:83 percent of Bay Area renters plan to leave, says survey by tomkinstinch on Wednesday August 16, 2017 @01:18PM (#15029266)
I'll second the endorsement of Rochester. The quality of life for the cost can't be beat. I have (affordable) gigabit fiber running to my house thanks to a local ISP. Rochester punches above its weight for culture, thanks to the philanthropic history of Eastman, Bausch & Lomb, etc. The orchestra is world-class and affordable, and the music scene in general is quite good, perhaps owing to the Eastman School of Music at UofR, which alternates with Juilliard as one of the best conservatories in the country. Geva, the local stage theater is enjoyable, and the independent movie theater, The Little is great ($3 student tickets, anyone?), and there are fun museums. It takes 20 minutes to drive anywhere. But you can bike if you don't want to drive, most of the year. Housing is actually affordable. Imagine beautiful Victorian homes for <$250k, or even <$150k. I rented a single room in the Boston area last year, and the cost for a month was 150% of my monthly mortgage in Rochester for 10% of the space. The UofR Medical Center is a heavyweight research hospital.

Rochester and Monroe County have an amazing system of public parks and green space, and they're always well-kept. If you golf, there are many nice public courses. Bike trails abound for transit, and you can hop on the Erie Canal towpath trail and ride from Buffalo to Albany. Irondequoit Bay has sailing, and people row on the Erie canal and Genesee river. Club sports take advantage of the parks. Parks nearby have hiking, though not tall mountains.

The Public Market is an amazing resource as you mention. Vendors at "farmers' markets" in big cities have realized they can charge inflated yuppie prices, while the Public Market has farmers from the local area selling directly at wholesale rates, as well as third-party vendors selling overstock/ugly produce from local supermarkets. Wegmans is the best, for consumers and their employees.

The Rochester city government is (mostly) functional and well-meaning, and citizens generally have a sense of civic pride and interest in their communities. The tax base is not what it once was, but the city makes the most of what it can, with new experimental initiatives and impeccable maintenance of public services. Rochester weathered the recession well.

A downside is of course the grey skys of winter, but that is counterbalanced by four distinct seasons with a beautiful summer. When I lived in California I missed having four seasons.

It's a fairly future-proof place to live; Western NY is not prone to natural disasters like earthquakes, droughts, wildfires, volcanos, tornados, or hurricanes. Most areas are high enough where flooding is not a concern. Climate change will have less of an impact than many other areas. Blizzards are likely the most probable "natural disaster", but you can wait them out: snow melts.

If VCs were willing to take more risk, they could bankroll startups in cheaper areas like Rochester and spread their resources across larger portfolios.

Buffalo is having a similar resurgence, or so I've heard. Western NY is cheap enough to take risks, and people are. New restaurants; cocktail joints; art, dance, meditation, and yoga studios are opening all the time. Startups could be next; take a look at Rochester for your next company and lower your burn rate.

Re:83 percent of Bay Area renters plan to leave, says survey by overcast on Wednesday August 16, 2017 @03:32PM (#15030452)
That's a good point about the VC money, and I wish there were more looking this way. There is a relatively decent sized tech culture, having regular meetups, sharing what we're all working on. With the cost of living, and access to RIT/UoR grads, it would encourage more people to make this a tech base in the Northeast. It wouldn't take more than a few higher profile companies, to get the ball really rolling. People are looking for excuses to get out of the overpriced city grind.
Re:83 percent of Bay Area renters plan to leave, says survey by schnevets on Wednesday August 16, 2017 @05:33PM (#15031564)
I could never understand why Poughkeepsie isn't thriving as a tech hub. You've got IBM hiring & firing employees in droves, good universities nearby, and NYC as a client/talent pool. I can only assume government incompetence or shortsightedness.

The growth in tech over the past decade had some clear winners, but any city that is just mobilizing now is entering a crowded pool. Anyone thinking ahead should consider how remote work will change businesses in 5 - 10 years, and start planning from there (schmooze freelancers instead of VCs and prepare legislation that would benefit the employee, rather than the business).

Re:83 percent of Bay Area renters plan to leave, says survey by ghaff on Wednesday August 16, 2017 @11:51AM (#15028459)
You're pretty much describing how Manhattan has been for many decades. New grads go into finance and they just have to live where the action is. Fast forward a few years and the vast majority of them take jobs elsewhere or move out to the burbs.
Re:83 percent of Bay Area renters plan to leave, says survey by Ologn on Wednesday August 16, 2017 @12:52PM (#15029021)
> Nobody wants to spend their thirties in a cramped, overpriced studio, but nobody is ready to leave their hip, startup lofts

Well I think this is it. I was born in New York City, and while it may be more expensive than some town in the Midwest, the housing problem is not like it is in San Francisco. On the other hand, if you insist on living in Greenwich Village or Williamsburg then you will have to pay. If you're OK with living in a slightly older, not super exciting, middle class neighborhood that has a half hour commute to the city, then you have plenty of affordable options. Another thing about New York affordability is rent in some towns in the Midwest is cheaper but you need a car, in New York City you can get around pretty well without a car.

Also a commute into Manhattan does not have to be an hour. You can make a map of the rent prices of apartments in boring but decent neighborhoods that are within 10 minutes commute of Manhattan, then 20 minutes, then 30. Plenty of options. For myself, I can walk out my door and in less than thirty minutes walk out of a train in Penn Station. I used to live in another part of the city and my apartment door to office desk commute was less than 30 minutes.

Re:83 percent of Bay Area renters plan to leave, says survey by RealityNow on Wednesday August 16, 2017 @01:54PM (#15029582)
NYC is a pretty terrible city to live in by first world standards unless you're wealthy. Crappy shoeboxes in tenement buildings that used to house servants go for outrageous prices, overcramped, awful subway (though Americans think it's amazing because they're not used to big cities that don't require a car). People put up with it because of the jobs, the people, the cosmopolitan nature of it, not needing a car, and because there aren't any comparable cities in the U.S. in terms of size, density, and significance. Millennials don't seem to be as fond as suburbs as the boomers (I personally hate suburbs).

NYC used to be a city where artists and writers could live, but it's become a city of trust fund kids, corporate shmucks, and tourists. Everybody works all the time - not because they're working on groundbreaking stuff - but to make a buck.

Personally my plan is to work remotely and go somewhere else, most likely outside the country because nothing in the car-obsessed suburban sprawl-infested U.S. compels me.

Re:83 percent of Bay Area renters plan to leave, says survey by cylinder on Wednesday August 16, 2017 @02:34PM (#15029957)
Mostly true, but they have built new highrise towers in Brooklyn. I am probably living in the most convenient building in the US right now, with lots of amenities in a very comfortable 1bdrm. The problem is it's still $3400/mo+ and all the buildings are rentals, no buying, and most of all this is not sustainable for us as a couple who plan to have kids so we have to jump ship.

It's also very true that so many Americans are willing to put up with NYC because there's not many other options for proper cities in the US. The public transportation sucks and there's now a divide where everyone I know seems to be grabbing Uber to work which is totally ridiculous and irresponsible.

Re:83 percent of Bay Area renters plan to leave, says survey by dpflan on Wednesday August 16, 2017 @11:59AM (#15028522)
It would be nice to see the visualization of the inflow-outflow: the people eagerly coming in to the city, then then gradual spreading out to adjacent metro areas as the city gets more crowded and unlivable. This style of growth would probably benefit from efficient, affordable, convenient transit options, like the high-speed rail teasers that pop-up every now and then in the news about connecting the east coast's major cities.

Taking hints from the likes of Japan to support this growth; and other examples and ideas would be cool for discussion here as a solution to this metro-area-growth.

> https://www.theguardian.com/cities/2014/sep/30/-sp-shinkanse...

> https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/T%C5%8Dkaid%C5%8D_Shinkansen

Re:83 percent of Bay Area renters plan to leave, says survey by Spooky23 on Wednesday August 16, 2017 @01:17PM (#15029263)
This is just the normal migration pattern. Once you have kids and get married, the advantages of living in a big city start to go away.

Those fun bars and restaurant become generators of noise and parking problems. The fun diverse neighborhood translates into a school district where the legacy of desegregations means your kid will be dragged across the city for school. The list goes on.

Re:83 percent of Bay Area renters plan to leave, says survey by Tokkemon on Wednesday August 16, 2017 @12:36PM (#15028879)
True facts, I just moved to Westchester after living in NYC for almost 20 years. An opportunity came to buy a lovely house overlooking the Hudson and I leapt at it. Brooklyn really had started to grate on me even though I was used to the "lifestyle" of living in New York.
Re:83 percent of Bay Area renters plan to leave, says survey by njarboe on Wednesday August 16, 2017 @01:58PM (#15029614)
I would guess that one of the big reasons that there are a "mad-rush of millennials" into select cities is that most of the ambitious, type-A personalities used to try and pick a mate in the high density environment of a selective university. That is not nearly as common now but un-paired people still want/need a high density of potential mates that meet their minimum standards. Choosing what happening city to move to after college is now much more important instead of getting a job(s) and moving directly to a home selected for raising the kids.
Re:83 percent of Bay Area renters plan to leave, says survey by winter_blue on Wednesday August 16, 2017 @11:54AM (#15028483)
> but nobody is ready to leave their hip, startup lofts for the drudgery of a Westchester office complex (let alone endure an hour commute into the city every day)

I live in New York City, and I can certainly empathize with the no one wanting to do endure a long daily commute in a crowed, cramped, subway full of people where you likely might not get a seat. (LIRR/MNR/NJT are great in comparison (but terrible in frequency).)

But I dissent on your comment on living and working in Westchester (or really any suburbia in general). I understand people think the city is hip and all, but I really like greenery, nature, having a lot of space, being able to get to places in the comfort of your car, reasonable/low cost to own a home, generally low cost of living, the lack of noise, clean air, etc, etc. What's so dull about it?

Re:83 percent of Bay Area renters plan to leave, says survey by MarchHare on Wednesday August 16, 2017 @12:27PM (#15028794)
Getting to use a car quickly becomes having to use a car in much of the U.S.

There is a lot of middle room between suburbia and NYC for build environments.

Re:83 percent of Bay Area renters plan to leave, says survey by Sleeep on Wednesday August 16, 2017 @12:35PM (#15028864)
I'm not familiar with Westchester specifically but, to me, suburbia isn't good for any of those things you mentioned. To me suburbia feels like a giant mass produced parking lot and is an incredibly depressing display of concrete! Nature is nowhere to be found in the suburbs. The real estate is very expensive in desirable suburbs and traffic is still bad in the suburbs, just bad in a different way than in a bigger city.

Right now I live in what I guess would be described as a town. Its ~100 miles from any major urban area and it's much more effective at providing the majority of the things you mentioned plus amazingly short commute times! It also has some sorts of benefits you would associate with the city as well - for example, I can walk to at least 10 establishments as well as 2 parks whereas when I lived in a suburb the street I lived off of was 4 lanes 45 MPH and didn't even have a sidewalk. Even if it did have a sidewalk the noise of a mass of neverending SUVs buzzing past is unpleasant.

You would also have no problem driving almost everywhere in a smaller city.

Re:83 percent of Bay Area renters plan to leave, says survey by smallnamespace on Wednesday August 16, 2017 @12:46PM (#15028973)
I think you're describing the difference between a suburban town vs. a suburban bedroom community. The latter usually lacks services and amenities [1] or a real sense of community, so on the weekends you're forced to commute just to get a good meal.

Luckily both exist -- often times the sweet spot is to live near downtown + transit of a smaller town. Then you get a faster commute, some walkability, and the option to do things in town as well.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Commuter_town

Re:83 percent of Bay Area renters plan to leave, says survey by Sleeep on Wednesday August 16, 2017 @01:43PM (#15029494)
IDK, I would not, personally, consider my town in any way suburban. It's European "founding" predates the American revolution and the vast majority of the construction in the town center is pre war and it's nowhere near any major or even minor urban area.

My opinion on suburbia that I stated was based on what would be "suburban town" moreso than a "suburban bedroom community." I've never lived in the latter.

I know it's just my opinion though, I know some people like suburbia but smallish towns like mine are better at providing greenery, nature, and a low cost of living plus a pleasant environment. To me suburbs are the opposite of that. (Getting to the airport is a giant pain in the ass though...)

Pretty much the first thing I did when I moved here was take a walk!

Re:83 percent of Bay Area renters plan to leave, says survey by cylinder on Wednesday August 16, 2017 @02:38PM (#15029988)
That is not how Westchester is. I would love to live in Westchester or Hudson Valley towns. The problem is due to shitty trains, the commutes are far too long.

Look at a town like Beacon NY. Beautiful place with ridiculously cheap real estate.

If we had high speed trains we could link these cities to NYC for daily commuting and it would pay for itself with increased property values.

There's so much value being lost and inconvenience beared by us because of shitty government.

Re:83 percent of Bay Area renters plan to leave, says survey by chris_7 on Wednesday August 16, 2017 @03:33PM (#15030463)
High speed trains only reach high speeds because they don't stop. They're not high acceleration and deceleration trains. MNR has too many stops (and curves, but setting that aside) for high speed to matter.

Of course, you can run them express, but then they probably wouldn't stop in small towns like Beacon or Cold Spring. Amtrak is basically this on the New Haven line, how many people actually take it to commute?

Re:83 percent of Bay Area renters plan to leave, says survey by Sleeep on Wednesday August 16, 2017 @11:05PM (#15033492)
Wow!! Screw trains, as a Hudson Valley native, Hudson valley is not Westchester.

I hope the trains pass you by. We don't want you.

Re:83 percent of Bay Area renters plan to leave, says survey by cylinder on Thursday August 17, 2017 @11:25AM (#15037571)
Yep, classic Hudson Valley asshole right here!

Go drive South a couple thousand miles if you want to be an insular hillbilly.

Re:83 percent of Bay Area renters plan to leave, says survey by chaosbutters314 on Wednesday August 16, 2017 @12:48PM (#15028997)
What is wrong with westchester? It doesn't smell as bad, you can get a place for the same price as nyc with 4x the space and you're only a 1 hr drive away if you don't try to go during rush hours.

A big problem I see with going to westchester to nyc is the parking costs in nyc. Like $50/day is wayyyyyyyy too high to be sustainable. And the trains are just too slow, it is faster to drive from where I am in westchester than take the train.

Re:83 percent of Bay Area renters plan to leave, says survey by schnevets on Wednesday August 16, 2017 @05:40PM (#15031608)
I meant the Westchester comment as a bit tongue-in-cheek. More of the stereotypical opinion among my generation, rather than my own opinion. I'm actually shopping around in the Hudson Valley with my fiance atm.

Regardless, the "corporate campus" will need to go through a reimagining if it wants to appeal to city-weary knowledge workers. This will require some more lateral thinking beyond replicating Facebook's Headquarters in White Plains, NY.

Re:83 percent of Bay Area renters plan to leave, says survey by sjg007 on Wednesday August 16, 2017 @12:57PM (#15029062)
It's probably in one's interest to be an early adopter in the tech migration (or wait for a collapse) unless you win the IPO lottery. You can get something nicer closer to work in a trendy area before prices go through the roof.
Re:83 percent of Bay Area renters plan to leave, says survey by nugget on Wednesday August 16, 2017 @11:26AM (#15028215)
Is there a way to measure which cities are benefiting, and by how much?
Re:83 percent of Bay Area renters plan to leave, says survey by rayiner on Wednesday August 16, 2017 @11:39AM (#15028351)
Not really, because yuppie employment doesn't move the needle in most places. Pittsburgh is having a real renaissance with a tech scene built around CMU. There are new restaurants where you can get a bone marrow whatever. [But the city is on pace to post another double-digit percentage population loss this decade.]

Edit: I can't read. Pittsburgh has only lost 0.7% since 2010: https://www.census.gov/quickfacts/fact/table/pittsburghcityp....

Re:83 percent of Bay Area renters plan to leave, says survey by ghaff on Wednesday August 16, 2017 @12:02PM (#15028567)
To this point, the urbanization trend is often overstated because, in the sense that people here use it, it's actually fairly limited. A lot of it is about college educated twenty-somethings moving to a handful of dense urban cores.

Broader urbanization is much less pronounced and, to the degree it's a trend, it's mostly to what a lot of people here would be more inclined to call suburbs than cities.

Re:83 percent of Bay Area renters plan to leave, says survey by rhapsodic on Wednesday August 16, 2017 @12:12PM (#15028644)
> But [Pittsburgh] is on pace to post another double-digit percentage population loss this decade.

Out of curiosity, where did you get that information?

Re:83 percent of Bay Area renters plan to leave, says survey by graphitezepp on Wednesday August 16, 2017 @12:22PM (#15028743)
I live in PGH and am to lazy to find a link, but can confirm that population is rapidly declining.
Re:83 percent of Bay Area renters plan to leave, says survey by rhapsodic on Wednesday August 16, 2017 @12:35PM (#15028871)
> I live in PGH and am to lazy to find a link, but can confirm that population is rapidly declining.

This article claims that the population of Pittsburgh is essentially static:

http://www.post-gazette.com/local/city/2017/05/25/2016-censu...

Re:83 percent of Bay Area renters plan to leave, says survey by YuriNiyazov on Wednesday August 16, 2017 @11:58AM (#15028512)
Did the renaissance start a decade ago? yuppie job growth takes a while to move the needle - first all the nonyuppies have to move out