News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why I Was Fired by Google by basseq on Friday August 11, 2017 @04:26PM (#14993845)
His take still seems a little tone deaf and defensive (e.g., repeated use of "echo chamber"). But he hits the nail on the head of why Google fired him:

  ... they really couldn't do otherwise.
No matter what you think about the memo, Google had absolutely no option but to fire Mr. Damore once this blew up into a firestorm (internally and externally).
Re:Why I Was Fired by Google by toomuchtodo on Friday August 11, 2017 @04:28PM (#14993872)
They could've had a spine and supported intelligent discourse. Seems like a leadership problem.

"At Google, just as we strive for a diverse workforce, we also encourage the free flow of ideas and along with that, support the vigorous discussion around those ideas. We don't comment on specific HR issues." (EDIT: Minor grammar edits for my faux PR statement)

And that would've been the end of it, had they had the fortitude to ignore the witch hunt.

Re:Why I Was Fired by Google by saidajigumi on Friday August 11, 2017 @04:50PM (#14994118)
Except, as has been pretty well documented elsewhere, it was not intelligent discourse. Whatever productive content may have been present, it was overwhelmed by the senseless repetition of long-debunked stereotypical nonsense.

Endlessly, emphatically parroting what is ultimately discriminatory nonsense is an aggressive action against others, not "just an opinion". E.g. [1], and numerous other examples. My favorite, which I'm having trouble digging up the citation for, is a recent-ish study that compared test performance of various minority/gender groups based on social anxiety measures (e.g. "girls aren't good at math")... and found that it was literally possible to turn this difference on and off like a switch based on triggering vs disarming these anxieties as part of the test setup. This literally flies the in face of the schoolyard "sticks and stones may break my bones, but words will never hurt me" mantra so ingrained in US culture. It turns out, we have increasingly good scientific evidence that humans just don't work that way.

Let's be clear about that: being a toxic jerk to {insert out-group here} actively harms those people, and can directly harm their performance orthogonally to their actual potential capabilities. "Yeah, I'm meritocratic in footraces, but only when I can stick thorns in my competitors' shoes."

[1] https://psychcentral.com/news/2010/03/19/negative-effects-of...

Re:Why I Was Fired by Google by glenra on Friday August 11, 2017 @05:52PM (#14994644)
> a recent-ish study that compared test performance of various minority/gender groups...

You are referring to the idea of "stereotype threat" which, alas, did not survive the replication crisis.

Quote "After correcting for publication bias, this literature shows very little evidence that stereotype threat has a notable and practically significant effect on women’s math performance (Flore & Wicherts, 2014)."

Some analysis: https://replicationindex.wordpress.com/2017/04/07/hidden-fig...

Direct study link: http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0022440514...

Re:Why I Was Fired by Google by submersiveblue on Friday August 11, 2017 @05:06PM (#14994275)
> it was overwhelmed by the senseless repetition of long-debunked stereotypical nonsense.

This is why what Damore did is important and why having the discussion is important. People like you either mistakenly believe this or are being deliberately manipulative and misleading by claiming the science is settled. In fact, the science is not settled, and if anything it is leaning in Damore's favor. That you and people like you want to believe one thing very much is not a substitute for the actual truth to the rest of us, and never will be.

Re:Why I Was Fired by Google by frgtpsswrdlame on Friday August 11, 2017 @05:09PM (#14994293)
>if anything it is leaning in Damore's favor.

This isn't true.

Re:Why I Was Fired by Google by submersiveblue on Friday August 11, 2017 @05:18PM (#14994383)
Sure it is, and a number of scientists in the relevant fields have spoken up and said so. Here's a start for you: https://www.theglobeandmail.com/opinion/no-the-google-manife...
Re:Why I Was Fired by Google by BinaryIdiot on Friday August 11, 2017 @05:33PM (#14994504)
You know, every single person on the internet that I've seen argue that the science is solid in the Google memo point to this article in The Globe and Mail. It's bizarre.

I've tried to toe the line and not get into the argument as much as I can because, as evidenced by the previous HN thread [1], it's just two sides yelling past each. Some are citing scientific papers stating they are correct (which a single paper does not make), others are arguing based on remembering other scientific papers and virtually no one seems to be an expert but are all commenting as such.

What I would like to point out is the article in question isn't very well sourced. It points to "four - academic studies" [2] [3] [4] [5] but none of those are actual studies; they're all replies to a single study (Sex beyond the genitalia: The human brain mosaic [6]) and none include a methodology to how they came to their reply conclusion as the full text barely contains anything additional to the extract. Now I'm not writing them off as wrong but those are being misrepresented as studies without having the proper information a study or research paper would require. Unless it's available elsewhere? It's unclear at least to me and appears, again to me, as very misleading.

Ultimately there is a boat load of research out there. Some of it is going to support the Google memo writing. Some of it will not. Some of it can be used to represent both sides of the argument. I think a better article, should one exist, should be used to defect your viewpoint should you side with the Google memo. Much of science requires a consensus and rock solid testing methodologies and I'm just not seeing that sourced in the article.

Again, I am not an expert but this is my impression from this article. Feel free to make any corrections to my statement :)

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14952787

[2] http://www.pnas.org/content/113/14/E1968.extract

[3] http://www.pnas.org/content/113/14/E1971.extract

[4] http://www.pnas.org/content/113/14/E1966.extract

[5] http://www.pnas.org/content/113/14/E1965.full.pdf

[6] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4687544/

Re:Why I Was Fired by Google by Spivak on Friday August 11, 2017 @05:50PM (#14994635)
That article is circulated because it showed up here and, unlike a lot of the blogspam, the author has the credentials to have an informed opinion about the current research. Here's another one, but from a Psychologist rather than a neurologist.

https://slatestarcodex.com/2017/08/07/contra-grant-on-exagge...

Re:Why I Was Fired by Google by BinaryIdiot on Sunday August 13, 2017 @01:13AM (#15001628)
> the author has the credentials to have an informed opinion about the current research

If you say so. I'm not an expert but as I wrote in my comment it appears either terribly sourced or the author equates replies to research as full blown studies.

> Here's another one, but from a Psychologist rather than a neurologist.

This one, as far as I can tell, mostly ignores much of the critical feedback that I've seen so far. Again, I'm not an expert but I'm surprised it doesn't call this out explicitly and in greater detail if the critics are wrong. Like, it has some small references to it but not a lot of direct discussion around it.

Not that all of the critical articles are better in terms of sources, etc I just haven't seen any of the articles in support of the memo be very well sourced or respond to much of the criticism directly.

Re:Why I Was Fired by Google by frgtpsswrdlame on Friday August 11, 2017 @05:32PM (#14994492)
Re:Why I Was Fired by Google by submersiveblue on Friday August 11, 2017 @05:38PM (#14994537)
What's funny about that link is that when she refers to the scientific claims she mostly seems to agree that they are well founded. Apart from that she seems to reading a lot of stuff into the memo that Damore probably wouldn't agree is there, and getting offended. I.e. he is a racist/sexist/alt-right bigot.
Re:Why I Was Fired by Google by frgtpsswrdlame on Friday August 11, 2017 @05:42PM (#14994572)
You mean she agrees that there are differences between men and women? Sure, most people do. But she doesn't agree that there is a basis for the idea that men would make better programmers than women because of something at the biological or genetic level, which is really the contention around Damore's memo.

>Apart from that she seems to reading a lot of stuff into the memo that Damore probably wouldn't agree is there, i.e. he is a racist/sexist/alt-right bigot.

Well his first interview was with Stefan Molyneux and he's done another with Jordan Peterson. I'm assuming Mike Cernovich and Lauren Southern are next? Come on. The thing about writing a dogwhistling document like his memo is you have to keep your true beliefs secret. By running straight to some of the darlings of the alt-right he's exposed himself a bit and his dogwhistles become clear as exactly that.

Re:Why I Was Fired by Google by submersiveblue on Friday August 11, 2017 @06:02PM (#14994718)
>men would make better programmers than women because of something at the biological or genetic level, which is really the contention around Damore's memo.

Where does he say this?

As for the interviewers, so what? Either the claims are supported by the facts or not, who's agenda is served by those facts is an entirely separate issue.

Re:Why I Was Fired by Google by frgtpsswrdlame on Friday August 11, 2017 @06:33PM (#14994907)
I’m simply stating that the distribution of preferences and abilities of men and women differ in part due to biological causes and that these differences may explain why we don’t see equal representation of women in tech and leadership. Many of these differences are small and there’s significant overlap between men and women, so you can’t say anything about an individual given these population level distributions.

The "and abilities" part is the important bit because it's where he makes a logical leap. So here's what I'm going to ask of you as someone who seems to like Damore's document and likes the scientific process behind it. Can you find me scientific evidence that men are biologically predisposed to have greater tech abilities?

Re:Why I Was Fired by Google by submersiveblue on Friday August 11, 2017 @08:20PM (#14995538)
I'm not sure what Damore is referring to in that specific quote, but there is evidence of relevant differences, especially if you're talking about recruitment numbers for a company like Google:

"A 2005 study by Ian Deary, Paul Irwing, Geoff Der, and Timothy Bates, focusing on the ASVAB showed a significantly higher variance in male scores, resulting in more than twice as many men as women scoring in the top 2%"

..."the study indicated that, while boys and girls performed similarly on average, boys were over-represented among the very best performers as well as among the very worst."

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sex_differences_in_intelligenc...

Re:Why I Was Fired by Google by frgtpsswrdlame on Saturday August 12, 2017 @02:35PM (#14999221)
Except that same wikipedia article has a whole huge section titled Researchers in favor of no sex differences or inconclusive consensus and also includes this sentence: "The current literature on sex differences produced inconsistent results depending on the type of testing used." It sorta seems like you read until you found a sentence you liked and then didn't go any further... It's not a settled issue at all AND the ASVAB study you're picking doesn't actually connect anything to a biological basis. This is why Damore's paper is bad and why I'm sad that the community is taking it seriously as a scientific source. Some of his statements are cited but plenty aren't and because a fair amount of the people reading it already agree with him, Damore's leaps of logic don't pop out to them. It's not a good paper and it's not very scientific.
Re:Why I Was Fired by Google by submersiveblue on Saturday August 12, 2017 @04:01PM (#14999674)
Admitting the science isn't settled is enough for me, I'm all for more open discussion on it, and I think that's what Damore was after too.
Re:Why I Was Fired by Google by DrScump on Friday August 11, 2017 @10:51PM (#14996159)
Has there ever been an independent study of how well ASVAB results correlate to later professional success in tech?

I took the ASVAB as a teen, and I was relentlessly pursued by military recruiters for years afterward.

Re:Why I Was Fired by Google by egonschiele on Friday August 11, 2017 @07:12PM (#14995152)
> when she refers to the scientific claims she mostly seems to agree that they are well founded.

What part of this answer makes you say that? She is quoting directly from the paper a bunch of times, offering refutations, and providing sources. I agree that she is reading into the memo. I don't agree that she is agreeing with the science -- she's spent thousands of words doing the exact opposite.

Re:Why I Was Fired by Google by fche on Sunday August 13, 2017 @09:05AM (#15002744)
Yes, yes yes, the science is settled (tm), after all 97% of scientists agree. And the case is closed. Yupper.
Re:Why I Was Fired by Google by sremani on Friday August 11, 2017 @05:07PM (#14994280)
The willful misrepresentation of the memo is one of the reasons he got more support than usual. Most people who argued on the scientific basis mostly concurred and a few disagreed. There is nothing "overly debunked".
Re:Why I Was Fired by Google by dvfjsdhgfv on Friday August 11, 2017 @04:56PM (#14994187)
> senseless repetition of long-debunked stereotypical nonsense

Could you provide some references for this claim? Because Damore did.

Re:Why I Was Fired by Google by yellowapple on Friday August 11, 2017 @09:13PM (#14995768)
Even if what Damore wrote was "long-debunked", it's the sort of thing that a pretty big chunk of the U.S. population believes to be more-or-less accurate. Lots of people are wrong about things and don't know it. Them being wrong does not justify an attempt to burn them at the stake; it justifies an attempt to calmly yet firmly explain the errors in the subjects' beliefs (and then maybe burn them at the stake - figuratively, plesse, not literally - if they choose to ignore the counterevidence).

Having read the memo, I rather strongly disagree with the "toxic jerk" characterization you've given. Yammering fool, sure, but not (deliberately) malicious.

Re:Why I Was Fired by Google by strgrd on Friday August 11, 2017 @04:57PM (#14994192)
You know what is not intelligent discourse? Equating what was said in the memo as harassment by citing this:

> They asked 114 undergraduate female students to watch a video and imagine themselves as bystanders to a situation where a man made either a sexist catcall remark (“Hey Kelly, your boobs look great in that shirt!”) at another woman or simply greeted her (“Hey Kelly, what’s up?”).

Maybe you could provide a citation instead for this?

> the senseless repetition of long-debunked stereotypical nonsense.

Re:Why I Was Fired by Google by TeMPOraL on Friday August 11, 2017 @05:02PM (#14994243)
Especially that few scientists are on record saying that the memo is solid on science, and the quoted research is not only not debunked, but also not even controversial in sociological circles.
Re:Why I Was Fired by Google by Chris2048 on Friday August 11, 2017 @05:55PM (#14994669)
> pretty well documented elsewhere

In a strange place no one can seem to name.. funny how the existence of this "documentation" is so often assumed, but not so often referenced..

Re:Why I Was Fired by Google by kbenson on Friday August 11, 2017 @04:38PM (#14993989)
> They could've had a spine and supported intelligent discourse. Seems like a leadership problem.

But that's not the job of the people involved, or if you believe it is their job, only tangentially and in a way that might help in the long run.

When you have a major PR problem on your hands and you're a public company, you make it go away before it can adversely affect the stock. That's the the job of the highest executives, and that's what will be delegated to those responsible for fixing it. Would we all be better off with reasoned discourse? Probably. Would Google benefit from being the company to push it? Possibly, but I give that slim odds. The responsible thing to do for your job is to fix the problem that is immediately threatening the company.

Google isn't the martyr you've been looking for.

Re:Why I Was Fired by Google by submersiveblue on Friday August 11, 2017 @05:09PM (#14994295)
>The responsible thing to do for your job is to fix the problem that is immediately threatening the company.

The problem is double talk. They pretend that they want open discussion and provide an internal forum for it, but when someone like Damore takes them up on it they see it as a problem. If you don't want controversy don't pretend that you do.

Re:Why I Was Fired by Google by wmf on Friday August 11, 2017 @04:40PM (#14994012)
Do you think firing him made the problem go away? It looks like it made things worse.
Re:Why I Was Fired by Google by anindha on Friday August 11, 2017 @05:30PM (#14994482)
They would have faced backlash either way, it is hard to say.
Re:Why I Was Fired by Google by toomuchtodo on Friday August 11, 2017 @04:39PM (#14993999)
I hope they're willing to fire LGBTQ workers (or workers who are pro choice, or any other political third rail) when the right rages just as hard, if they're not a martyr and simply a business with no moral compass. If they're not prepared to perform those actions, they're picking sides, and should be prepared for the consequences.
Re:Why I Was Fired by Google by kbenson on Friday August 11, 2017 @04:51PM (#14994133)
> I hope they're willing to fire LGBTQ workers

This isn't about firing people with specific attributes, it's about firing people that have become associated with a particular cause publicly and drawn the company into that same discussion, whether purposefully or on accident. If enough of their workforce and enough of the public shared the opinion that LGBTQ workers should not be hired, and the company policy followed that, and someone became prominent in that discussion, I expect they would do the same.

I'm not saying I think this is how the world should work and it's the best situation, I'm saying our current mix social, political and economic systems make this the likely (but not required) outcome. It often takes a martyr to change that. We venerate those who make that sacrifice, but let's not pretend it's easy for them, or that everyone should make that choice all the time (depending on how egregious the offense being protested is).

> if they're not a martyr and simply a business with no moral compass.

There's a difference between no moral compass and picking your battles. Winning a war doesn't always require rushing the enemy with whatever is in hand immediately when sighted. You can call a strategic retreat cowardly all you want, but if it's part of a larger strategy it may not be indicative of the competency of the people involved or the future (not that Google's actions necessarily should be viewed in that light, I'm just pointing out that this is but one action and should not define them entirely).

Re:Why I Was Fired by Google by Pils on Friday August 11, 2017 @04:50PM (#14994124)
Well, the government already said you can be fired for being queer: https://www.economist.com/blogs/democracyinamerica/2017/08/f.... I feel like outrage from the right for firing someone for something they can actually choose (political ideology) would be intensely hypocritical.
Re:Why I Was Fired by Google by woofyman on Friday August 11, 2017 @04:49PM (#14994111)
LGBTQ is a status, not a political stance. There are LGBTQ people of all political stripes
Re:Why I Was Fired by Google by toomuchtodo on Friday August 11, 2017 @04:51PM (#14994138)
> not a political stance

Let the identification and firing of radical progressives (or even moderate progressives!) begin. Things must get worse before they will get better; otherwise, everyone will continue to seek out ways to forward their agenda in legal yet immoral ways.

If proponents of the firing encourage the use of at-will employment for the firing, I'll support its use against other activists with opposite leanings. Otherwise, this silicon valley witch hunt routine will never end.

Re:Why I Was Fired by Google by gamblor956 on Friday August 11, 2017 @04:54PM (#14994163)
If an LGBTQ employee publishes a 10-page diatribe about how straights are biologically less suited to working at Google, they'd have been fired too.

He wasn't fired because he was a conservative, and he wasn't fired because of his opinions. He was fired because he made hostile remarks about the majority of his co-workers that legally resulted in a hostile work environment under US law.

Re:Why I Was Fired by Google by TeMPOraL on Friday August 11, 2017 @04:57PM (#14994198)
Except he didn't; what you describe is the media misrepresentation of the original memo.
Re:Why I Was Fired by Google by gamblor956 on Friday August 11, 2017 @06:44PM (#14994983)
No, it's how I and more than a dozen other people I talked to who read the memo, from front to back, in great detail, all interpreted it.

That's the thing about words: if you're not precise, they can be interpreted differently from how you intended them.

Re:Why I Was Fired by Google by fche on Sunday August 13, 2017 @09:10AM (#15002757)
> dozen other people I talked to

That's just like the Pauline Kael apprx-quote about how "no one she knew voted Nixon - how could he possibly win?". IOW, you are already in an echo chamber.

Re:Why I Was Fired by Google by HeroOfAges on Friday August 11, 2017 @05:11PM (#14994310)
What in your opinion, is a proper interpretation or representation of the original memo?
Re:Why I Was Fired by Google by aianus on Friday August 11, 2017 @05:27PM (#14994460)
That the ratio of women:men in tech may never reach 1:1 even if historical biases against women are resolved (he lists some possible reasons). Therefore efforts by Google and others to improve this ratio to 1:1 at all costs can be counterproductive and discriminatory in and of themselves and should be re-examined.

That was my interpretation at least.

Re:Why I Was Fired by Google by clarky07 on Friday August 11, 2017 @05:31PM (#14994485)
He didn't though. He didn't say that at all. He simply said that LESS women are interested in this field than men. He didn't say NO women were qualified, or anything close to it. He said aiming for 50/50 might not be the best idea, because there simply might not be that many women interested.
Re:Why I Was Fired by Google by egonschiele on Friday August 11, 2017 @07:16PM (#14995175)
What side is Google picking again?
Re:Why I Was Fired by Google by Brockenstein on Friday August 11, 2017 @04:43PM (#14994045)
Are you familiar with the phrase, "false equivalency"?
Re:Why I Was Fired by Google by toomuchtodo on Friday August 11, 2017 @04:44PM (#14994064)
I'm amiable enough to be polite and say "you're entitled to your opinion".
Re:Why I Was Fired by Google by patrickyan on Friday August 11, 2017 @04:55PM (#14994173)
As the other person said, that's a false equivalency. This memo directly affected the workplace environment by saying one group of people had less aptitude for working there. The examples you give are just groups who are seeking certain rights or equality in society have nothing to do with the workplace.
Re:Why I Was Fired by Google by TheAceOfHearts on Friday August 11, 2017 @05:03PM (#14994249)
AFAIK, he didn't claim one group of people had less aptitude for working there. Could you cite where exactly he said that?
Re:Why I Was Fired by Google by clarky07 on Friday August 11, 2017 @05:41PM (#14994558)
No he didn't. He said that one group of people had less desire to work there, and trying for 50/50 might not make sense. I went to a relatively small school, but there were 0 women who majored in computer science in the 4 years I was there. We certainly didn't reject anyone, there just wasn't 1 single person interested in making that their major. It's not unreasonable to suggest that computer science is a field that may not be exactly 50/50 in the type of people who want to do it.

Coal miners, fire(persons?), nurses, elementary school teachers and many many other fields are nowhere near 50/50. There are clear differences in genders and what they want out of life. He didn't in any way say the there are no women that can be good at this job. He simply pointed out that it's possible it might not be 50/50. maybe it's 60/40 or 70/30 and if you just try to hit a certain number you might not always be getting the best candidate for the position.

As a whole, if the tech industry was forced to be 50/50 tomorrow, we'd have to fire like 80% of the workforce. There simply aren't enough women interested in the field and qualified to do it right now. If you want to work towards having more women in tech, you have to start much sooner, at say the elementary and junior high age. Promote STEM more to them at those ages and maybe in 20-30 years we can be closer to 50/50. But it isn't happening tomorrow just because people want to change hiring practices. I hope that my daughter is interested in it when she grows up, and I certainly don't want her to be discriminated against, but saying it might not be 50/50 because different genders enjoy different things isn't in fact discrimination.

Re:Why I Was Fired by Google by egonschiele on Friday August 11, 2017 @08:14PM (#14995513)
Then I'd ask: why do women not enjoy tech? Why did your college have zero women? Do you think it's biological? Cultural?
Re:Why I Was Fired by Google by fche on Sunday August 13, 2017 @09:11AM (#15002759)
Ask average women - those not in tech.
Re:Why I Was Fired by Google by BinaryIdiot on Friday August 11, 2017 @04:44PM (#14994065)
> They could've had a spine and supported intelligent discourse. Seems like a leadership problem.

That's not really how things work in companies. In a University? Sure. In a company that doesn't really make sense and is far too idealistic.

Regardless of whether you support the contents of the memo or not, he created a disruption within the company. A disruption that made some feel alienated and others vindicated. This is not where you have any type of discourse. This is a simple "fire the person disrupting business".

Re:Why I Was Fired by Google by creaghpatr on Friday August 11, 2017 @05:09PM (#14994294)
isnt disruption the whole point of Silicon Valley?

Capitulating due to media pressure, if that is the reason, is extremely weak leadership and only made the problem worse.

Re:Why I Was Fired by Google by BinaryIdiot on Friday August 11, 2017 @05:16PM (#14994366)
> isnt disruption the whole point of Silicon Valley?

I could stand next to your desk and smash two pots together thus disrupting your work; surely you see how disruption of a market is different than disrupting co-workers...

Simply because the word "disruption" can be used in a positive context to describe aspects of Silicon Valley doesn't mean it's always positive regardless of context.

> Capitulating due to media pressure, if that is the reason, is extremely weak leadership and only made the problem worse.

This was never stated as the reason as far as I can tell.

Re:Why I Was Fired by Google by briholt on Friday August 11, 2017 @04:38PM (#14993984)
It would've been a week of impotent whiny tweets, then the outrage machine would've moved on to the next faux issue. What kind of insane world do we live in where leaders are too cowardly to withstand mean internet comments? Now they've got a lawsuit on their hands (which will surely open the floodgates) and an anti-science stigma that will stick with them for years.
Re:Why I Was Fired by Google by jmduke on Friday August 11, 2017 @04:42PM (#14994022)
To clarify: you are aware that, prior to the memo, Google already a lawsuit on their hands from the Department of Labor with regards to alleged gender discrimination?
Re:Why I Was Fired by Google by masonic on Friday August 11, 2017 @11:01PM (#14996196)
And let's not forget their participation in at least one de facto cartel to suppress salaries.

https://phys.org/news/2015-01-apple-google-settlement-high-t...

Re:Why I Was Fired by Google by toomuchtodo on Friday August 11, 2017 @04:42PM (#14994026)
Don't forget to mention Google wouldn't hand over the data the Department of Labor demanded.
Re:Why I Was Fired by Google by ue_ on Friday August 11, 2017 @06:35PM (#14994923)
This is what really gets me and confuses me.

Google is accused of a "left wing bias" by many defenders of the manifesto and the writer himself. And yet, they don't want to turn over information that they're fairly hiring, firing and paying wages fairly?

How is being sly and secretive about your hiring practices and wage information "left wing"? Hardly seems consistent with the idea of supporting worker rights.

So how does Google (not to mention, it is a capitalist organisation) have a "left wing bias", as they say?

I see no evidence for it.

Re:Why I Was Fired by Google by briholt on Friday August 11, 2017 @09:02PM (#14995720)
Are you serious? This is exactly the criticism leveled against the left. They've abandoned free speech, they judge people based on race, they've ignored working class voters in favor of coastal elites, yet they keep telling themselves they're "liberal."
Re:Why I Was Fired by Google by ue_ on Friday August 11, 2017 @09:31PM (#14995836)
I suppose I have a different idea of what 'left' means, then. For me, 'left' is at least strong social democracy and preferably [democratic] Socialism, Communism and anarchism. Not the US Democratic Party.
Re:Why I Was Fired by Google by toomuchtodo on Friday August 11, 2017 @07:29PM (#14995264)
> Google is accused of a "left wing bias" by many defenders of the manifesto and the writer himself. And yet, they don't want to turn over information that they're fairly hiring, firing and paying wages fairly?

Then Google should cough up the data. But they won't, because they're hiding malfeasance.

Re:Why I Was Fired by Google by dionidium on Friday August 11, 2017 @04:42PM (#14994033)
Setting this particular issue aside, this really is a weird phenomenon that I don't quite understand, yet. So, a lot of people are condemning you on Twitter? I understand that as humans we don't like that feeling, but if you don't react to it nothing happens.

Why don't more people take that path?

Re:Why I Was Fired by Google by BinaryIdiot on Friday August 11, 2017 @04:48PM (#14994102)
Pick a topic that's really, really important to you. Let's say it's fishing.

You're known as someone who fishes a lot in your small circle on Twitter. Suddenly someone steps in and says "Fishing is stupid. Screw you, fishing people!". Maybe one of your followers explicitly tags you in it to bring it to your attention.

Ignoring it is the right thing to do but could you? You probably could since my example is extremely contrived but in general I gotta admit sometimes it's difficult to ignore something that's right in front of me that I staunchly disagree with. I try but I'm human and I fail at it sometimes. Other times if I don't respond others feel like I'm letting them down.

I hate Twitter. I also enjoy it at times, too, which keeps me on it but I really do hate it the majority of the time.

Re:Why I Was Fired by Google by cxseven on Friday August 11, 2017 @04:50PM (#14994125)
I guess a boycott could happen, or employees might get emboldened to quit or sue. Google would get lumped in with Uber and others accused of being brogrammer haven.
Re:Why I Was Fired by Google by alexqgb on Friday August 11, 2017 @04:45PM (#14994068)
Dude, this is a massive, for-profit corporation, not some leafy liberal arts campus. Their cultures and priorities may align to a degree, but there are some fundamental differences between them in terms of whose interests they serve, how those interests are prioritized, and the way conflicts are resolved (something Damore discovered the hard way).
Re:Why I Was Fired by Google by fche on Sunday August 13, 2017 @09:12AM (#15002768)
In this case, google is -both- a for-profit corporation AND some leafy liberal arts campus.
Re:Why I Was Fired by Google by danso on Friday August 11, 2017 @05:30PM (#14994479)
What intelligent discourse could there be had? Damore's essay is heavily premised on Google's current policies being illogical, unethical, and even illegal, and other statements of apparently self evident fact. The memo is basically a giant prompt of, "Have you stopped beating your mother?" In which engaging in a dialog forces you to implicitly acknowledge something that is a total non sequitur.

I'll give an example: (sorry, unable to copy paste from tablet)

https://medium.com/@Cernovich/full-james-damore-memo-uncenso...

Under the subheading of Non-discriminatory ways to reduce the gender gap, his first example refers to how "Women on average show a higher interest in people and men in things". That's one of the biological facts he cited and I'll accept it as true for the sake of brevity.

Damore then points out that this has a silver lining, because if programming is made more collaborative, then women can naturally benefit. OK, nothing objectionable about that, I believe some companies incorporate pair programming in their recruiting and onboarding.

And then he drops the other shoe: "unfortunately there may be limits to how people-oriented certain roles a Google can be"

What the hell does that even mean? What exactly are these "certain roles" that Damore is referring to? How can this kind of assertion lead to intellectual and open debate when Damore's argument: there exists jobs are just not suited/optimal for women. I'm completely willing to meet him where he's at on biological gender differences, but Damore's memo just does not invite discussion because he makes self-evident assertions and avoids specific detail or proof that he had really looked into things.

Because after claiming that there Google jobs too technical for women's people-preferences, a Damore randomly shits on Google's female coding classes. Because there are jobs for which there's a ceiling to the effectiveness of women's people-skill..."we shouldn't deceive ourselves or students into thinking otherwise"

Does anyone have context for this? What is Google deceiving itself about? Why are students involoved? Darmore's phrasing is so sloppy and lacking in details that he leaves things open to the imagination. I'm imagining that there was an incident at Google in which a woman was diversity-promoted into a highly technical job that had been designated for men. This woman believed her people-skills would make up for her technical weakness but she ended up causing killing her entire department in a fiery explosion.

The cherry on top is Damore stating: "(some of our programs getting female students into coding might be doing this)"

Again, what the hell is he talking about? What are the Googl coding classes doing, tying girls to chairs until they master recursion? Is it an open secret that these coding programs are horrible, or has Damore actually observed classes. Can he describe an example of when a Google teacher forced coding lessons on a girl who was clearly not born to do it?

A charitable reading of what I quoted would argue that Damore believes: *as a population, women will fail to be the best they can be as programmers. Because only so much that work would benefit from women's people skills. Google has been in denial to the truth, to the point that Google's coding schools are deluding female students about learning to code.

There's a lot that bothers me about this paragraph on women's people-skills and how those skills do and don't apply to Googl's work. I'll just ask about this: why does a Damore think that Google is "deluding" itself with its female coding classes? Is the curriculum bad? Does the curriculum aspire (in vain) to teach the skills and work that Damore thinks aren't optimal for women?

Re:Why I Was Fired by Google by moduspol on Friday August 11, 2017 @06:17PM (#14994802)
> How can this kind of assertion lead to intellectual and open debate when Damore's argument: there exists jobs are just not suited/optimal for women.

Truly: Is there any valid way to say anything about women in general, at a macro level, that won't be twisted as explicitly meaning all women like has been done here?

Like, if one suggestion were to start serving salads at the company cafeteria because that is likely to appeal more to women, would this prompt claims that all women only like salads, or that women aren't suitable for eating burgers?

We can discuss how to make a restaurant appeal more to women, or an apartment building, or a car. And we can do it without jumping down each other's throats, because we all acknowledge we're not talking about all women--we're targeting general preferences to apply to a general audience. Why is it that the same can't be acknowledged for software engineering or leadership roles?

Re:Why I Was Fired by Google by danso on Saturday August 12, 2017 @12:32AM (#14996481)
First of all, I acknowledge that Damore premises his argument on populations and distributions. My example here was to point out that he jumps into assertions that make no specific reference to populations. In his criticism of Google's initiative to teach coding to females (students, employees), Damore says:

> "Unfortunately, there maybe limits to how people-oriented certain roles at Google can be and we shouldn't deceive ourselves or students into thinking otherwise (some of our programs to get female students into coding might be doing this)."

How does population distributions apply here? Is Google attempting to push coding (and at what sophistication) onto far more women than is statistically sound? I had heard that Google had such classes, but that their enrollment was self-selecting and seemingly not at a scale that included the majority of girls/women. So what is the delusionary practice that Damore refers to?

I'm genuinely interested in the answers to these specific (albeit) minor questions. But I brought this up as one aggravating example of how open, intellectually honest discussion is difficult when the claims are unspecific and unsupported.

Re:Why I Was Fired by Google by moduspol on Saturday August 12, 2017 @11:07AM (#14998120)
> How does population distributions apply here?

To apply my previous metaphor: We shouldn't be trying to get more women to like burgers. We should make the food we serve appeal more to women.

To step out of the metaphor: Perhaps we shouldn't be having software engineering roles that put so much emphasis on the parts that don't seem to appeal to women (generally) as much. We might have more success modifying the roles so that they appeal more to women (generally).

He's also acknowledging that some roles might inherently have facets that appeal more to men in a way that can't be easily changed. Just like a role that's inherently very social and perhaps deals heavily with small children might be difficult to make appeal more to men (generally). That in no way implies men aren't suited to be kindergarten teachers, or that the men who are kindergarten teachers aren't good at it. It just means trying to make it more competitive or take the focus off the interaction with the children isn't likely to work well.

> I'm genuinely interested in the answers to these specific (albeit) minor questions. But I brought this up as one aggravating example of how open, intellectually honest discussion is difficult when the claims are unspecific and unsupported.

Respectfully: It's difficult when any opposing claim is assumed to be sexist. Like I said, it's in fact very easy to have an intellectually honest discussion about how to make a restaurant, car, or apartment building appeal more to women--even without explicit scientific studies backing up every statement!

It is because people are choosing to infer meaning that wasn't there in order to be offended and virtue signal that it is difficult to have this discussion.

Re:Why I Was Fired by Google by tankenmate on Friday August 11, 2017 @04:50PM (#14994116)
Certainement qui est en droit de vous rendre absurde est en droit de vous rendre injuste.
Re:Why I Was Fired by Google by pow_pp_-1_v on Friday August 11, 2017 @04:42PM (#14994023)
> They could've had a spine and supported intelligent discourse. Seems like a leadership problem.

Why? What use is intelligent discourse to the work that Google does?

Re:Why I Was Fired by Google by crimsonalucard on Friday August 11, 2017 @04:46PM (#14994080)
Google had a choice here. Piss off people who support intelligent discourse, or piss off the other set of people.

Personally for me I would choose to piss off the group who tends not to escalate things irrationally and let emotion drive the entire agenda until the bloody end. Not sure which group Google chose.

Re:Why I Was Fired by Google by danso on Friday August 11, 2017 @05:38PM (#14994538)
Which group is which? What's the group that doesn't tend to escalate things irrationally?
Re:Why I Was Fired by Google by crimsonalucard on Saturday August 12, 2017 @01:46PM (#14998935)
I'm not sure. I feel I am unable to elaborate because there are people on HN who support political correctness over intelligent discourse.
Re:Why I Was Fired by Google by tylerst on Friday August 11, 2017 @04:45PM (#14994074)
I disagree with your first sentiment... His take, is just that, his take. He did his own research and came to his own conclusions. They might have been flawed, but they were his own. He very well could have changed his mind, had anyone presented more convincing evidence that would lead to a different conclusion. That didn't even appear to be an option, though, and I think that is the more threatening issue.
Re:Why I Was Fired by Google by throwaway23998 on Friday August 11, 2017 @04:52PM (#14994154)
It's remarkable how much of an uproar and distraction one fairly low level employee can cause.

Reminds me of an old Napoleon quote: "whoever is stupid and industrious must be got rid of, for he is too dangerous." This individual conducted cursory research while thinking he was conducting in-depth research.

I fear his "echo chamber" argument will be construed to damage the diversity in tech movement.

Re:Why I Was Fired by Google by egonschiele on Friday August 11, 2017 @07:27PM (#14995250)
Context is important. Maybe he can give his take on Hacker News and no one will care. But he can't say whatever he likes at work. Every company has some legal obligations. No sex discrimination is one of them.

Even if you think his take is not sex discrimination, that is a big topic in Silicon Valley right now. So to write something like this right now just says "hey everybody, I'm in my own world. I have no social intelligence, and I don't pay attention to what's going on out there."

Re:Why I Was Fired by Google by JKCalhoun on Friday August 11, 2017 @07:39PM (#14995317)
> Context is important. Maybe he can give his take on Hacker News and no one will care.

I wouldn't even go that far. I work for a tech company and am extra careful, even outside of work — on public forums, talking about my company or even controversial issues regarding tech in general because someone might mistakenly believe I am speaking as a representative of said company. It just wouldn't be professional.

Re:Why I Was Fired by Google by egonschiele on Friday August 11, 2017 @07:52PM (#14995397)
Yeah I agree, even posting on HN is fairly unprofessional. Afaik when you join certain corporations like Apple they limit what you can do online, because they don't want your comments associated with their company. Maybe Google is nice enough to not do that, but it is not uncommon.

So I'm surprised to see comments like this parent comment, saying "he should be free to say what he wants". No, that's just not how it works.

Re:Why I Was Fired by Google by reactor4 on Friday August 11, 2017 @04:28PM (#14993865)

  Upper management tried to placate this surge of outrage by 
  shaming me and misrepresenting my document, but they 
  couldn’t really do otherwise: The mob would have set upon 
  anyone who openly agreed with me or even tolerated my views.
Re:Why I Was Fired by Google by CalChris on Friday August 11, 2017 @04:33PM (#14993922)
Actually, companies mostly exist to get work done and CA is an at will state. If you get in the way of getting work done then you likely will get fired. The document was readable by anyone internally and eventually everyone externally. So there was no misrepresentation.
Re:Why I Was Fired by Google by leifaffles on Friday August 11, 2017 @04:41PM (#14994015)
Yes, there was misrepresentation.

Google's CEO said: “To suggest a group of our colleagues have traits that make them less biologically suited to that work is offensive and not O.K.”

He said no such thing. This is a cruel smear. Google, including its CEO and VP of Diversity & Newspeak, acted like thugs.

And no, this has nothing to do with at-will employment. It has to do with hypocrisy. Google claimed they be open and tolerant, and then they proceeded to directly contradict that ethos by firing Demore and viciously lying about him on the way out the door.

Re:Why I Was Fired by Google by egonschiele on Friday August 11, 2017 @07:31PM (#14995274)
From the paper:

At Google, we’re regularly told that implicit (unconscious) and explicit biases are holding women back in tech and leadership. Of course, men and women experience bias, tech, and the workplace differently and we should be cognizant of this, but it’s far from the whole story. On average, men and women biologically differ in many ways. These differences aren’t just socially constructed because: ● They’re universal across human cultures ● They often have clear biological causes and links to prenatal testosterone ● Biological males that were castrated at birth and raised as females often still identify and act like males ● The underlying traits are highly heritable ● They’re exactly what we would predict from an evolutionary psychology perspective Note, I’m not saying that all men differ from all women in the following ways or that these differences are “just.” I’m simply stating that the distribution of preferences and abilities of men and women differ in part due to biological causes and that these differences may explain why we don’t see equal representation of women in tech and leadership.

I agree that he doesn't use the term "biologically suited" anywhere. I would instead say that he suggested: "men and women have biological differences, and those differences partially explain why where are fewer women in tech". Do you agree with that?

Re:Why I Was Fired by Google by ribosometronome on Friday August 11, 2017 @04:51PM (#14994135)
>Women, on average, have more:

>Openness directed towards feelings and aesthetics rather than ideas. Women generally also have a stronger interest in people rather than things, relative to men (also interpreted as empathizing vs. systemizing).

>These two differences in part explain why women relatively prefer jobs in social or artistic areas. More men may like coding because it requires systemizing and even within SWEs, comparatively more women work on front end, which deals with both people and aesthetics.

...

>Women on average are more prone to anxiety. Make tech and leadership less stressful. Google already partly does this with its many stress reduction courses and benefits."

I don't know how you can come away from reading his memo and not arrive at the conclusion he thinks men and women are different and those differences make them less suited to the Google workplace. His solution is that diversity efforts need to focus not just on evolving recruiting/training but the way work is structured and you can absolutely argue that's not a super-evil-misogynistic thing to say. But that's very different than pretending he didn't say women, on average, aren't well suited to the current environment.

Re:Why I Was Fired by Google by leifaffles on Friday August 11, 2017 @04:59PM (#14994219)
The intentional blurring of the difference between "individuals" and "group averages" is out of control.

Here some quotes from the essay that underscore this distinction:

> Many of these differences are small and there’s significant overlap between men and women, so you can’t say anything about an individual given these population level distributions.

> I’m also not saying that we should restrict people to certain gender roles; I’m advocating for quite the opposite: treat people as individuals, not as just another member of their group (tribalism).

Re:Why I Was Fired by Google by CalChris on Friday August 11, 2017 @04:46PM (#14994081)
> Yes, there was misrepresentation. > Google's CEO said: “To suggest a group of our colleagues have traits that make them less biologically suited to that work is offensive and not O.K.”

Possible non bias causes of the gender gap in tech

...

On average, men and women biologically differ in many ways.

Work your rhetorical magic on that.

Re:Why I Was Fired by Google by engel on Friday August 11, 2017 @04:59PM (#14994218)
He says that if 10% of men and 8% of women are suitable for tech, and google hires unbiased from suitable people, then google should expect a 55:45 gender gap.

That doesn't mean that the female colleagues are unsuitable for tech, since they were exactly hired among people who were suitable.

He is also not saying that this explains the complete gender gap, just that there is no point in blindly aiming at 50:50 without considering research on the underlying distribution.

He may have the research wrong, but otherwise the point seems to stand?

EDIT: Of course, this argument only works for a binary 'suitable/not suitable' distinction. If 'tech talent' was said to be normal distributed, with men having a slightly higher expectation, it would follow that the average men above some cut was also better than the average woman above the same cut. So in that way he does attack his colleagues.

Re:Why I Was Fired by Google by ocdtrekkie on Friday August 11, 2017 @05:19PM (#14994392)
This is still misrepresenting. He said those gender-based tendencies lead men and women to prefer and be interested in different things. Preference and interest has nothing to do with "suitability".

To say that 100% of men and women are suitable to work in tech, but that maybe only 20-30% of the women would actually want to would be a more accurate representation of what he wrote.

It's hard to see what's sexist about suggesting women should work wherever they prefer to, rather than being told they should become software engineers.

Re:Why I Was Fired by Google by egonschiele on Friday August 11, 2017 @07:33PM (#14995292)
That makes sense. My next question would be:

> He says that if 10% of men and 8% of women are suitable for tech

Why would a higher % of men be more suitable for tech? In the paper he suggests it is partly due to biological differences. Do you agree with that?

Re:Why I Was Fired by Google by davidsong on Saturday August 12, 2017 @10:35PM (#15001186)
Depends on what you deem suitable. If you're aiming to get people who have a strong desire for exploring and creating systems then you'd likely end up with more people with Aspergic traits, a majority of which are male.
Re:Why I Was Fired by Google by Udik on Friday August 11, 2017 @05:00PM (#14994228)
Easy. Imagine a company that hires only people at least 6'1'' tall (1.85 for us Europeans). The employees genders ratio would be skewed towards males. You could argue that there are biological differences that make the number of suitable female hires smaller, and you would be right. Does that make your female colleagues shorter? Not at all. They are and remain, as all other employees, at least 6'1''.
Re:Why I Was Fired by Google by engel on Friday August 11, 2017 @05:17PM (#14994375)
Actually this argument only works for binary treats. Like "tall" vs "short". If hired random people above 6'1", we would still expect that most women hired were only slightly above the cut, while the men were a bit further up.
Re:Why I Was Fired by Google by Udik on Friday August 11, 2017 @05:30PM (#14994477)
Also most hired men would be only slightly above the cut, if I'm not wrong. In any case, I'd be happy enough of being above the cut, some people are never satisfied, really :).
Re:Why I Was Fired by Google by cxseven on Friday August 11, 2017 @04:57PM (#14994191)
Colleagues selected by Google already made the cut, so that's more predictive than gender?
Re:Why I Was Fired by Google by JSONwebtoken on Friday August 11, 2017 @04:42PM (#14994029)
No misrepresentation? Like Sundar Pichai and the media conveniently conflating neurosis with the completely unrelated theory of neuroticism? Search "Google memo neurosis" and see how many headlines contain "neurosis" when that word or concept was never referred to even once in the 10 pages.
Re:Why I Was Fired by Google by alexqgb on Friday August 11, 2017 @04:51PM (#14994142)
Here's a direct quote from the "Personality Differences" section of the screed:

"Neuroticism (higher anxiety, lower stress tolerance).This may contribute to the higher levels of anxiety women report on Googlegeist and to the lower number of women in high stress jobs."

So yeah, it was referenced, specifically, explicitly, and used in direct support of the central argument that the preponderance of men in Google's ranks was biologically determined, meaning a number of Google's D&I initiatives were misguided, at odds with scientific consensus, and should be discontinued.

Re:Why I Was Fired by Google by kinkrtyavimoodh on Friday August 11, 2017 @05:00PM (#14994223)
Neuroticism isn't a vague insult. It's a specific technical term in psychology and is one of the Big Five personality traits—https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Neuroticism

People want Damore to have written a PhD level thesis for an internally circulated document but most haven't themselves done even a basic Wikipedia level research before bringing out the pitchforks.

Re:Why I Was Fired by Google by shas3 on Friday August 11, 2017 @04:41PM (#14994017)
I think he clarifies this. Two things are germane:

1. Google is "more than just a company." It is more like an old style company-town by now.

2. They are the gatekeepers of all information ever. Perhaps we should hold them to different standards, especially when it comes to opinions and ideologies?

Re:Why I Was Fired by Google by toomuchtodo on Friday August 11, 2017 @04:37PM (#14993966)
I encourage folks to start surveilling Google employees in public who take part in civil disobedience for progressive issues, and demand they be fired. Companies exist to get work done, and CA is an at will state.

This won't get fixed ("its okay to fire someone if they don't align with my opinions") until everyone has had their proverbial nose bloodied.

Disclaimer: Progressive myself.

Re:Why I Was Fired by Google by sidlls on Friday August 11, 2017 @06:57PM (#14995065)
It sounds like you don't understand why he was fired. Hint: it wasn't because of his beliefs per se. It was more likely because of his repetition of gender stereotypes that impeded his ability to work effectively with his peers.
Re:Why I Was Fired by Google by toomuchtodo on Friday August 11, 2017 @07:23PM (#14995224)
> It was more likely because of his repetition of gender stereotypes

I keep hearing this line parroted, but that's not how the situation played out, and you either are inadvertently or maliciously being disingenuous.

You're entitled to your opinion, of course, but there are facts, and those facts aren't congruent with the narrative.

Re:Why I Was Fired by Google by sidlls on Friday August 11, 2017 @07:51PM (#14995388)
How are the facts incongruent with the narrative you object to?

Generally people who support this guy focus on only the bits of fact the memo author relied on: they ignore the context and his application of alleged facts. That's what you did, for example.

Re:Why I Was Fired by Google by toomuchtodo on Friday August 11, 2017 @08:11PM (#14995499)
> they ignore the context and his application of alleged facts.

You're projecting what isn't there. Again, part of the problem.

Re:Why I Was Fired by Google by sidlls on Friday August 11, 2017 @09:03PM (#14995729)
No, I'm not projecting anything.
Re:Why I Was Fired by Google by CalChris on Friday August 11, 2017 @04:41PM (#14994018)
It is ok to fire someone if they don't align with the company's opinions in CA. It really is.

Advertisement: Progressive myself.

Re:Why I Was Fired by Google by tajen on Friday August 11, 2017 @04:52PM (#14994152)
To check the full extent of CA's reasoning: Is it ok to fire someone who fights for LGBT, black or women's rights, because it doesn't align with a company's opinions?
Re:Why I Was Fired by Google by toomuchtodo on Friday August 11, 2017 @05:13PM (#14994332)
It is.
Re:Why I Was Fired by Google by evgen on Friday August 11, 2017 @04:39PM (#14993992)
If they do it on company time perhaps, otherwise you have no case at all.
Re:Why I Was Fired by Google by toomuchtodo on Friday August 11, 2017 @04:40PM (#14994004)
Your opinions and beliefs aren't just on company time, and that's what this gentleman was fired for; his beliefs after presenting research that accompanied his reasoning.

Gulag indeed!

Re:Why I Was Fired by Google by koolba on Friday August 11, 2017 @04:45PM (#14994075)
That's the best part! You don't need a case because all employment is at-will.

Just enough dirt, or supposed dirt, to frame a person in a negative enough light that the company considers them persona non grata.

Re:Why I Was Fired by Google by gamblor956 on Friday August 11, 2017 @04:44PM (#14994053)
It's a real problem that you can't tell the difference between what people do on their own time outside of work, and what they do at work, in a work forum.

If JD had posted his diatribe online on his own personal blog, there'd be a lot of discussion about it but he'd probably still be employed at Google.

The problem is that he posted his diatribe on a company forum. Legally, he forced the company to fire him and refute his words or else be treated as adopting his words as their own. (And yes, that is how workplace harassment laws work in the US. If you have a problem with that, take it up with Congress, not Google.)

Re:Why I Was Fired by Google by toomuchtodo on Friday August 11, 2017 @04:47PM (#14994092)
> The problem is that he posted his diatribe on a company forum. Legally, he forced the company to fire him and refute his words or else be treated as adopting his words as their own. (And yes, that is how workplace harassment laws work in the US. If you have a problem with that, take it up with Congress, not Google.)

So, correct me if I'm wrong: You're saying that any comments, writings, or ideas Google leaves up on their internal message boards is them providing implicit support or endorsement of said writings? Because it seems like if that's the case, obtaining the contents of those forums or message boards would provide ample work for a stable of employment lawyers for years.

Take note Google employees who are currently feeling fearful and "non-compliant" with Google's corporate stance. Maybe its time to sit down with an employment attorney who works on contingency while rolling through online forum posts.

Re:Why I Was Fired by Google by openmosix on Friday August 11, 2017 @04:54PM (#14994164)
Brendan Eich was fired for things he did outside of work. There are plenty of cases of request for retaliation on the professional environment for things done outside of the professional environment (for example, the OpalGate).
Re:Why I Was Fired by Google by dictum on Friday August 11, 2017 @08:01PM (#14995440)
> If JD had posted his diatribe online on his own personal blog, there'd be a lot of discussion about it but he'd probably still be employed at Google

Not so sure:

"In addition, violations of this code outside these spaces may affect a person's ability to participate within them."

https://duckduckgo.com/?q=%22violations+of+this+code+outside...

Re:Why I Was Fired by Google by exabrial on Friday August 11, 2017 @05:17PM (#14994379)
Definitely a sign of weak leadership.
Re:Why I Was Fired by Google by true_religion on Friday August 11, 2017 @04:29PM (#14993879)
> Upper management tried to placate this surge of outrage by shaming me and misrepresenting my document...

You are James Damore?

Re:Why I Was Fired by Google by gavanwoolery on Friday August 11, 2017 @04:40PM (#14994010)
I have seen this argument a lot, but there is no hard evidence there were not two options. IMHO firing him created worse PR for the company. They could have scolded him and it would have blown over within a month.
Re:Why I Was Fired by Google by alexqgb on Friday August 11, 2017 @04:47PM (#14994094)
Spoken like a dude who hasn't listened to a single response from women.
Re:Why I Was Fired by Google by gavanwoolery on Friday August 11, 2017 @05:27PM (#14994459)
Anecdotally (fwiw), my wife, whose profession requires a high level of expertise in biology, agrees with the memo writer
Re:Why I Was Fired by Google by egonschiele on Friday August 11, 2017 @06:52PM (#14995034)
Can you elaborate on this? What part does she agree with? What are her thoughts on this Quora answer? https://www.quora.com/What-do-scientists-think-about-the-bio...
Re:Why I Was Fired by Google by gavanwoolery on Friday August 11, 2017 @09:11PM (#14995764)
From her personal perspective and that of vicariously raising a daughter, she agrees that females tend to have certain seemingly innate preferences. However (like me) she does not believe that these preferences limit the potential of an individual, but they do provide insight into why the distribution of professions is skewed between the sexes for several fields (both in the favor of males or females depending on the field). Ill have to ask her opinion about the quora piece, but in my opinion there were a few red flags, and for a scientist the tone was not very objective and carried more than a hint of personal bias.

"That said, the argument in the document is, overall, despicable trash." < not scientific

"what appears to be a covert alt-right agenda" < this shows both a misunderstanding of the alt-right and the memo author, who hold two distinct systems of belief (in the author's memo IIRC he claims to be a classic liberal).

"based on extremely weak evidence" < prove it?

"completely fails to understand the current state of research" < prove it?

"makes repugnant attacks on compassion and empathy" < not scientific

"paradoxically insists that authoritarianism be treated as a valid moral dimension, whilst firmly rejecting any diversity-motivated strategy that might remotely approach it." < what?

etc

Re:Why I Was Fired by Google by egonschiele on Saturday August 12, 2017 @12:13AM (#14996424)
Makes sense, the answer was pretty hostile. I told my mom about the incident, and her first question was: "someone leaked the paper isn't that a privacy concern?" So I also have some anecdata about a woman not being concerned about the content. Overall though i think the paper is still pretty bad for a lot of reasons!
Re:Why I Was Fired by Google by johan_larson on Friday August 11, 2017 @05:14PM (#14994341)
> ... Google had absolutely no option but to fire Mr. Damore once this blew up into a firestorm ...

That's a bold statement. Care to explain? Why were all other options unacceptable?

Re:Why I Was Fired by Google by basseq on Friday August 11, 2017 @09:21PM (#14995797)
You're Google. In a tech environment where Uber is literally falling about because of anti-diversity issues, you have employees and the public beating down your doors because one guy wrote a memo.

Let's enumerate your options:

1. Support him and try to foster a dialog. Untenable: everyone's riled up, you can't be seen to support a sexist white male, and "let's talk about it" is naive.

2. Do nothing. Probably the worst option, as it makes you look spineless and wil piss both sides off.

3. Reprimand him. What does that buy you? You still piss off the alt-right, and the left thinks you're "forgiving" it by letting him off with a slap on the wrist.

4. Fire him. Literally all you can do. The left is happy. The right expects it. It optimizes happiness, shows decisive action, appeases the status quo.

There really isn't an option once it got this far.

Re:Why I Was Fired by Google by nunez on Friday August 11, 2017 @09:41PM (#14995869)
Meaning that they knew he would sue, they knew he had a case, they know they might lose and they're more than fine with paying him to make the problem go away because a few grand in his pocket is a lot less than a long-term depreession in your monthly average user rate (i.e. potentially less ad engagement)
Re:Why I Was Fired by Google by egonschiele on Friday August 11, 2017 @07:08PM (#14995122)
I've heard it was illegal for Google to keep him on. Here's what I've found online:

> Explicit protections against ... sexually hostile work environments, ... discrimination against unlawful sex stereotypes

From https://www.workplacefairness.org/sexual-gender-discriminati....

I would love to see a response from a lawyer. My understanding as a layperson is:

1. He is saying that biological differences explain why fewer women go into tech. That is not true, here is the best point-by-point analysis I've seen on it: https://www.quora.com/What-do-scientists-think-about-the-bio...

2. If you are a manager, and you ignore this analysis and agree that there is a biological difference, you can use that to explain why you aren't hiring/promoting women: it's not you, it's biology!

Re:Why I Was Fired by Google by fche on Sunday August 13, 2017 @09:34AM (#15002841)
> That is not true, here is the best point-by-point analysis

But that is pretty crappy analysis, throwing your conclusion into doubt.

> it's not you, it's biology!

What if that is literally true somewhere in the causal chain? Is it good to put managers into terror at having to justify hiring Top Men?

Re:Why I Was Fired by Google by pow_pp_-1_v on Friday August 11, 2017 @05:00PM (#14994231)
Exactly. People just fail to think in the shoes of Google, the company. They don't gain anything by keeping him there. Getting rid of him and preparing for a few weeks of unwanted scrutiny is the best thing they can do.
Re:Why I Was Fired by Google by mrisoli on Friday August 11, 2017 @04:30PM (#14993894)
I partially agree, had this been kept as an internal firestorm they could have some other solution(offer placement somewhere else within the company or another company), I have personally seen this happen elsewhere.