News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:“Rest and vest”: engineers who get paid and barely work by boulos on Sunday August 06, 2017 @04:46PM (#14943414)
There seems to be conflation in this article between two very different groups.

Group A is folks who are acquired and have outsized grants that say vest over N years (N between 2 and 4). It turns out the acquisition was probably a mistake, but the acquiring company made it (and won't own up to it). That's what's described in the Facebook and Microsoft examples. This is the classic "rest and vest" scenario (Note: an acquisition is not required, just any outsized grant).

Group B is "just" engineers at Google, Facebook, etc. getting paid really well for not doing much, while hanging out with the lavish perks. I've never heard of anyone refer to this as "rest and vest". In particular, I found this quote disturbing:

> There are a lot 'coasters' who reached a certain level and don't want to work any harder. They just do a 9-5 job, won’t work to get promoted, don’t want to get promoted.

At Google (and elsewhere), it's considered fine to reach a senior / terminal level and stay there. Is a VP or Director of Engineering lazy if they never move up? Of course not. The same is true of individual contributors.

Finally, the numbers mentioned for compensation are normal for very senior engineers at Google (and again, Facebook, Microsoft, etc.). This isn't "rest and vest", it's just business as usual. I don't particularly agree with the folks who spend their days in classes, taking long lunches, etc. but if they get their work done, what do I care?

Re:“Rest and vest”: engineers who get paid and barely work by scurvy on Sunday August 06, 2017 @06:11PM (#14943938)
At Microsoft, we called a lot of these people in Group B, "volunteers". They were with the company through the glory years and had great wealth. They just wanted to come to work every day because they liked saying that they worked at MS. The best response given when I asked one why they still worked, "Why would I spend time at home? Have you met my wife and kids?"
Re:“Rest and vest”: engineers who get paid and barely work by cpeterso on Sunday August 06, 2017 @07:18PM (#14944267)
When I worked at Microsoft, people joking called the Red West campus "Red Vest" because it was home to fun projects (like internet and Xbox) that attracted people who had vested enough MSFT options that they didn't need to work.
Re:“Rest and vest”: engineers who get paid and barely work by watwut on Monday August 07, 2017 @01:49AM (#14945576)
> The best response given when I asked one why they still worked, "Why would I spend time at home? Have you met my wife and kids?"

I am not sure whether I should fear sorry for the kids or for the father. Having father that jokes about not liking you must sux.

Re:“Rest and vest”: engineers who get paid and barely work by ltaaug8 on Monday August 07, 2017 @02:35AM (#14945731)
I once interviewed with a team leader and two of his engineers. When I asked "What qualities characterize a valuable member of your team?", one of the engineers described how hard they work: they work so hard that the team leader cancelled dinner with his wife on their 10th anniversary so he could work late that night. The team leader was beaming with pride. I felt sorry for all of them and especially for that guy's family.
Re:“Rest and vest”: engineers who get paid and barely work by imesh on Monday August 07, 2017 @05:28AM (#14946275)
Unless his kids are more like him than you and can take a bit of joking.
Re:“Rest and vest”: engineers who get paid and barely work by Kluny on Monday August 07, 2017 @03:55AM (#14945935)
I dunno, you could take it lightheartedly. It's good for a relationship for the partners to have their own interests and have some time apart.
Re:“Rest and vest”: engineers who get paid and barely work by kobeya on Monday August 07, 2017 @02:11AM (#14945647)
I've been in that position, and yes you are spot on.
Re:“Rest and vest”: engineers who get paid and barely work by yulaow on Sunday August 06, 2017 @06:30PM (#14944053)
Well that's a profoundly sad and depressing answer, hoping to never end with that kind of thoughts
Re:“Rest and vest”: engineers who get paid and barely work by dsacco on Sunday August 06, 2017 @06:32PM (#14944062)
It's a lighthearted joke.
Re:“Rest and vest”: engineers who get paid and barely work by scurvy on Sunday August 06, 2017 @06:34PM (#14944073)
Indeed, he said it jokingly.
Re:“Rest and vest”: engineers who get paid and barely work by pdimitar on Sunday August 06, 2017 @06:56PM (#14944172)
I ain't buying it. I don't know the concrete person, that's a fact.

I spent my younger years in much more social jobs compared to programming in cubicles (thank the gods I work remotely for 5+ years now) and out of probably 200+ men I've heard joking about horrible wife and kids, I can assure you no more than 5 were really joking. And I don't mean offhand conversations -- I am talking about people who I've chatted with between midnight and 4 AM. (It was a job with wildly varying schedules)

"Joke" in the marital context usually means "I am too scared to confront my wife so I'll pretend I am light-hearted and make-believe I am just joining the popular marital jokes club -- while secretly I am hating every second of my home life".

Sorry for cynicism. It's what I found during my whole life. Anecdotal evidence for sure but, my $0.02.

Re:“Rest and vest”: engineers who get paid and barely work by mattm on Sunday August 06, 2017 @07:49PM (#14944386)
I've also learned that a big reason why some people are workaholics is because they don't want to go home. Working late at the office gives them a good excuse.
Re:“Rest and vest”: engineers who get paid and barely work by jeffhuys on Monday August 07, 2017 @04:39AM (#14946064)
I'm one of those. I live with roommates who do nothing but party all night (it's school vacation right now here, and I've started working full time last year). It's excruciating. They don't know what I'm going through, act like it's not that hard waking up every morning at 7AM and coming home to a balcony full of people I've never met, having to have small-talk with them (or feel like I need to when I just want to go to my room). They act like they have it the worst because they need to go to school still and I mean, you're working! Ain't that the best?

I stay in the office until ~9PM. I go to the nearest coffeeshop to allow me to say "I've been working late, I'm tired, I'm gonna sleep. See you tomorrow". Well, that and I'm addicted to weed because it allows me to just not THINK about how sad I actually am. I'm not married, but I "have no home" basically.

That got way too personal. Contemplating on just not hitting reply. Still gonna do it. I mean, it's great for my professional life. It's not so great for my (mental) health.

Re:“Rest and vest”: engineers who get paid and barely work by corobo on Monday August 07, 2017 @05:59AM (#14946370)
Move house. I know, I know "It's not that easy I'd have to search for a place etc" but what if you were evicted tomorrow? What course of action would you take if you had to?

Do that.

Re:“Rest and vest”: engineers who get paid and barely work by denzil_correa on Monday August 07, 2017 @06:47AM (#14946546)
If mosquito bites are a problem, you eliminate the mosquitoes - you don't skin yourself.
Re:“Rest and vest”: engineers who get paid and barely work by pdimitar on Sunday August 06, 2017 @09:46PM (#14944752)
That's a sad and miserable existence. :(
Re:“Rest and vest”: engineers who get paid and barely work by WalterBright on Sunday August 06, 2017 @08:57PM (#14944594)
Back when I worked at Boeing, there was a story from a gate guard (checks badges of people coming in) that an engineer he knew drove up to the gate one day, stopped, shook his head, did a U-turn, and drove off.

He was never seen again (and abandoned his family).

Re:“Rest and vest”: engineers who get paid and barely work by madengr on Sunday August 06, 2017 @10:32PM (#14944910)
That sounds more like burnout.
Re:“Rest and vest”: engineers who get paid and barely work by hosh on Sunday August 06, 2017 @09:46PM (#14944756)
I buy it. Relationships are hard and marriages are harder, even for partners trying to make things work. It was shocking to me that my friends who are married also have their own struggles. In hindsight, it is normal. I used to think, "well, those guys should have a better marriage", and now I realize how difficult it actually is, and how widespread. The parents from Rick & Morty? Yeah.

My wife and I had tried a lot of things. What seems to be working is applying the practices laid out in "Crucial Conversations". That has been helping both at home and work. It isn't magic sauce, though it helps that even after all that, we still want to try. It feels like the eigenvector is pointing towards a better relationship.

(We both work from home).

Re:“Rest and vest”: engineers who get paid and barely work by pdimitar on Sunday August 06, 2017 @11:12PM (#14945042)
Not sure I follow. Your reply reads like "marriage is yet another job, you must invest the proper amount of hours in it". If so, I disagree.

If not, what were you trying to say? And apologies if I misread your comment.

In general, I agree with the notion that relationships need "work" -- but in my case the "work" is basically not allowing certain relationship entropy events to ever happen (or to never last more than a few days). Me and my wife are real and sometimes brutal with our honesty with one another, we're down-to-earth and [mostly] humble, and we never, EVER, go to sleep angry at each other. That "formula" has worked wonders so far.

Re:“Rest and vest”: engineers who get paid and barely work by hosh on Monday August 07, 2017 @01:34AM (#14945529)
Thanks for responding. Not sure why you got downvoted.

I don't equate work with a job. By "work", I mean that you have to put effort into the marriage. A marriage is not the same as a romance, and should also not be conflated with love.

That you and your wife are honest with each other and make an effort at not going to bed angry with each other is aligned with what I was expressing.

On the brutal honesty thing: it sounds like it works well for you and your wife, and that is great. It doesn't work so well with my wife and I becuase we suck at crucial conversations and we are now just learning how to have them. One key thing about the teachings in crucial conversations is to recognizing the false dichotomy of speaking truth and having a good relationship. It is possible to do both. It sounds like you and your wife are already doing both.

Re:“Rest and vest”: engineers who get paid and barely work by pdimitar on Monday August 07, 2017 @08:59AM (#14947159)
I love reaching out when a possible misunderstanding is in progress. Appreciate your reply.

You're very correct about the false dichotomy -- it's happening way too often and too much people fall into that trap. It's saddening for me to watch, especially having in mind that me and my wife are doing both.

But as she would say -- "yes, me and you are far ahead in that regard but it's very likely that the people who just discover this aspect are far ahead in other regards, and we're likely very behind in those".

Re:“Rest and vest”: engineers who get paid and barely work by patrickdavey on Sunday August 06, 2017 @10:31PM (#14944907)
Absolutely this. Crucial conversations should be mandatory reading for anyone entering into marriage. Fantastic book. And not just for marriage either, just good life skill on how to approach tricky subjects.

Go read it. Honestly :)

Re:“Rest and vest”: engineers who get paid and barely work by hosh on Monday August 07, 2017 @01:43AM (#14945559)
Agreed. A friend of mine's got married recently. That was the wedding gift I sent them.
Re:“Rest and vest”: engineers who get paid and barely work by duncan_bayne on Sunday August 06, 2017 @07:20PM (#14944277)
My experience - also anecdotal - supports this. Only a small minority of people who 'joke' about their home life are actually joking. See also:

http://catb.org/jargon/html/H/ha-ha-only-serious.html

Re:“Rest and vest”: engineers who get paid and barely work by pdimitar on Sunday August 06, 2017 @07:27PM (#14944311)
Yep. People use the joking form of expression to tell truths they wouldn't dare saying with a straight face while the other side knows they're fully serious.

Social stigma and dogma are to blame for this.

(Off-topic: one of the reasons that the love between me and my wife hasn't at all eroded -- it even got stronger -- after 3 years and a few months is that we're very honest with each other, even for the unpleasant truths. It's not about blinding your eyes; it's about being real plus being loving.)

Re:“Rest and vest”: engineers who get paid and barely work by StavrosK on Sunday August 06, 2017 @07:40PM (#14944351)
Also, it's only been three years. Give it a few decades.
Re:“Rest and vest”: engineers who get paid and barely work by pdimitar on Sunday August 06, 2017 @07:44PM (#14944367)
I had a failed relationship that lasted 8 years before. But I know what you are talking about. Time can kill love.

I do believe we're on the right track however. We are sensitive to the relationship killers and we are actively addressing them. Being inert is not our thing.

Re:“Rest and vest”: engineers who get paid and barely work by StavrosK on Monday August 07, 2017 @07:23AM (#14946676)
I think that's the actual reason for doing well, ie addressing problems. (Lack of) honesty is just one of those.
Re:“Rest and vest”: engineers who get paid and barely work by coldtea on Sunday August 06, 2017 @09:22PM (#14944682)
>after 3 years and a few months

That's not long at all.

Re:“Rest and vest”: engineers who get paid and barely work by pdimitar on Sunday August 06, 2017 @09:45PM (#14944750)
From my subjective experience, most relationships' future is known no later than year two.
Re:“Rest and vest”: engineers who get paid and barely work by coldtea on Monday August 07, 2017 @03:56AM (#14945941)
Of most relationships maybe, but not of most marriage type relations though. People marry and divorse after the 5th and 10th and 15th etc. year all the time...
Re:“Rest and vest”: engineers who get paid and barely work by pdimitar on Monday August 07, 2017 @09:02AM (#14947173)
That's a sad reality. If my father hadn't died 16 years ago, my mother would have divorced him.

People change. Sometimes a lot. You've fallen in love with a certain person and one morning, decades later, you suddenly realize this person is no longer with you.

Re:“Rest and vest”: engineers who get paid and barely work by robertcorey on Sunday August 06, 2017 @09:56PM (#14944782)
that's really sad. it's like they've been domesticated.
Re:“Rest and vest”: engineers who get paid and barely work by Nokinside on Monday August 07, 2017 @06:40AM (#14946517)
Groub B was part of the reason for Nokia's fall in mobile phones.

Nokia decided to develop incentive system package for key employees and it totally screwed up work atmosphere at the senior level.

Once Nokia stock skyrocketed, Nokia workforce was divided into two with system that was not all clear. Sudden multimillionaires and those who didn't get anything extra often working side by side. One group started to take it easy, or leaving the company. Others were bitter because they had to work with millionaire coasters who were suddenly more opinionated because getting fired was not an issue.

The most ironic thing was that MIT economist Bengt Holmström was a member of Nokia's board of directors when it happened. He received Nobel memorial price for economics last year for developing contract theory and researching incentive systems within companies. He knew it was overly complex and inefficient system, but nobody was interested to know what the number 1 guy in the field was thinking. http://mitsloan.mit.edu/newsroom/articles/in-nobel-prize-lec...

Re:“Rest and vest”: engineers who get paid and barely work by PhasmaFelis on Monday August 07, 2017 @02:30AM (#14945712)
> In particular, I found this quote disturbing: "There are a lot 'coasters' who reached a certain level and don't want to work any harder. They just do a 9-5 job, won’t work to get promoted, don’t want to get promoted."

Jesus, yes. What kind of sociopath thinks that someone who works normal hours and gets the job done is a problem? I work to live, I don't live to work.

Re:“Rest and vest”: engineers who get paid and barely work by richardknop on Monday August 07, 2017 @05:14AM (#14946203)
> They just do a 9-5

I agree. How is working hours defined in your contract (9-5) nowadays considered coasting? And why couldn't I get promoted by not working overtime?

That sounds unfair. When you sign a contract it doesn't say you need to work overtime and burn yourself out to get promoted.

There has been a worrying trend in our industry I have observed when working normal hours is not considered enough anymore and unless you put in hours of overtime every week you are considered a slacker.

Re:“Rest and vest”: engineers who get paid and barely work by muzz on Sunday August 06, 2017 @04:50PM (#14943451)
Yes and moreover, engineers are expected to have an upward trajectory until they reach senior level. Edit: I'm not sure what happens these days if someone doesn't get promoted in a timely manner.
Re:“Rest and vest”: engineers who get paid and barely work by johan_larson on Sunday August 06, 2017 @04:54PM (#14943472)
Clarification: "Senior SWE", the formal rank, at Google is indeed a plausible terminal level. If you get there, they'll let you stay indefinitely. But it isn't particularly senior. If you start at Google straight out of college, it's two promotions up, and you may not have supervised anyone higher than an intern.
Re:“Rest and vest”: engineers who get paid and barely work by boulos on Sunday August 06, 2017 @05:02PM (#14943517)
Thanks for that (as you surmised, I meant "senior" in the broad sense). For those following along, new college grads usually start at Level 3 ("SWE II"), and "Senior SWE" (Level 5) is considered "high enough". Explicitly the guidance for L5 is that: "All Google engineers are expected to reach this level".
Re:“Rest and vest”: engineers who get paid and barely work by throwaway7230 on Sunday August 06, 2017 @11:00PM (#14945002)
Apple has a similar system: I've never met a level 1. Level 2 SWE is kind of entry level, level 3 is mid-career, level 4 is senior. It's pretty achievable to get promoted quickly up to level 4. Some people even come in at level 4 if they come in with experience. Unfortunately level 4 where most people's careers and raises (and stock, from what I hear) come to a screeching halt.

I understand there's a level 5 that takes about 10x the effort of going from 2 to 4. You need to be pretty much a world renowned wizard to get there. I think a SVP needs to approve 5's. The vast, vast majority of SWEs will never make level 5, and managers are discouraged from promoting people to 5 unless they are super ultra mega stars.

Re:“Rest and vest”: engineers who get paid and barely work by thaumasiotes on Sunday August 06, 2017 @05:36PM (#14943711)
What are levels 1 and 2?
Re:“Rest and vest”: engineers who get paid and barely work by klodolph on Sunday August 06, 2017 @05:50PM (#14943811)
From what I understand, the levels exist across all job ladders, but the SWE ladder starts at level 3, except in rare cases involving acquisitions. Facebook is the same way, and Amazon starts at level 4.
Re:“Rest and vest”: engineers who get paid and barely work by ianbicking on Sunday August 06, 2017 @08:56PM (#14944588)
Usually companies try to make it so that levels mean roughly the same thing across all professions, so 1 and 2 or 3 mean "almost no experience". So while there might be people at level 1 and 2 in the HR department, or receptionist, or other professions where there is extremely close supervision, they don't hire anyone at that level for engineering. Often management also has a similar level system, but starts at a yet higher level (in the likely case that they never hire engineering managers straight out of college).
Re:“Rest and vest”: engineers who get paid and barely work by thaumasiotes on Sunday August 06, 2017 @11:51PM (#14945206)
That doesn't explain why the bottom rung of software engineers has the profession-specific label "SWE II", though. Entry level at eBay is also "Software Engineer 2".
Re:“Rest and vest”: engineers who get paid and barely work by wastedhours on Monday August 07, 2017 @05:41AM (#14946313)
I've seen it like that before because it gives hiring managers scope to create different types of job. They might have to hunt for talent at a certain price/responsibility point, but having extra steps on the scale downward allows them to open up a position at a lower price point if needs must. If that rung didn't exist, it's be a much harder ask to get a JD approved in a large co.

Also, a number of places need a few spine points below someone's normal band for probationary periods (I once started a role at a lower salary and they bumped me up to my real one on probation pass), or other reasons.

Most of it comes down to internal processes for job creation and sign off.

Re:“Rest and vest”: engineers who get paid and barely work by sn9 on Sunday August 06, 2017 @10:27PM (#14944890)
That's so confusing for students and new graduates. I would imagine a large number of students aren't applying for those jobs because they think the jobs require more experience than they do, shrinking the talent pool from which companies draw.
Re:“Rest and vest”: engineers who get paid and barely work by mattnewton on Monday August 07, 2017 @12:52AM (#14945382)
The numbers aren't advertised that way, and also Google is inverted in that you apply to Google and then after meeting a hiring bar for a level they match you with a specific role.
Re:“Rest and vest”: engineers who get paid and barely work by sn9 on Monday August 07, 2017 @01:12AM (#14945450)
Right they aren't advertised that way, but they can certainly be interpreted that way.

There's rarely any sort of explanation of the numbering system in job posts. I don't think it's unreasonable to assume that a III requires more experience than a I or II.

Re:“Rest and vest”: engineers who get paid and barely work by mattnewton on Monday August 07, 2017 @11:14AM (#14948083)
By not advertised I mean it simply isn't in the job posting. You apply to google and they talk to you during be process about the level.

https://careers.google.com/jobs#!t=jo&jid=/google/software-e...

https://careers.google.com/how-we-hire/?&src=Online/House%20...

Re:“Rest and vest”: engineers who get paid and barely work by sn9 on Monday August 07, 2017 @10:42PM (#14953442)
Yes but I haven't been talking about just Google, and I have been talking about applying in the first place. My point was that some people may not apply, thinking that those jobs require more experience than they do. Think entry-level vs. junior.
Re:“Rest and vest”: engineers who get paid and barely work by chronid on Sunday August 06, 2017 @05:51PM (#14943821)
Data center engineers, IIRC.
Re:“Rest and vest”: engineers who get paid and barely work by johan_larson on Sunday August 06, 2017 @09:11PM (#14944644)
Engineering interns might be level 2.
Re:“Rest and vest”: engineers who get paid and barely work by muzz on Monday August 07, 2017 @12:54PM (#14948990)
I think so. Also engineers in Google India used to start at level 2
Re:“Rest and vest”: engineers who get paid and barely work by muzz on Sunday August 06, 2017 @05:55PM (#14943845)
Yes, but: 1) promotions are not particularly easy. they are approved by committee, ie not because a manager happens to favor an employee 2) Senior SWE itself is an Individual Contributor role (some say the optimal level if one wants to remain an IC). Only at the next level is leadership required 3) There is a HUGE jump in compensation between Senior SWE and the next level (Staff). Senior SWEs are not pulling anywhere near the $1M/yr referred to in the title
Re:“Rest and vest”: engineers who get paid and barely work by iandanforth on Sunday August 06, 2017 @10:53PM (#14944975)
Perspective for those outside of CA, to be in the top 1% you need to be making in excess of $450k / year.

Source: http://www.businessinsider.com/top-one-percent-every-us-stat...

Re:“Rest and vest”: engineers who get paid and barely work by boulos on Sunday August 06, 2017 @09:34PM (#14944716)
Right. The article instead repeatedly referred to the Group B candidates as making upwards of $600,000:

> "Engineers get paid $250,00 to $600,000 range, but there's no sense of urgency."

> "estimating that very senior engineering positions can command up to $400,000- $600,000 in total compensation at X, including bonus and stock options.

(though now that I quote it, those are all data from the same anonymous engineer working at X)

Re:“Rest and vest”: engineers who get paid and barely work by oh_sigh on Sunday August 06, 2017 @08:23PM (#14944489)
Even staff probably isn't 1m...maybe 800 total
Re:“Rest and vest”: engineers who get paid and barely work by muzz on Sunday August 06, 2017 @06:00PM (#14943877)
Also by "they'll let you stay indefinitely" you mean there is no expectation of any further promotion. If someone starts slacking, that would theoretically show up in perf
Re:“Rest and vest”: engineers who get paid and barely work by mcv on Monday August 07, 2017 @03:59AM (#14945946)
Also, the first engineer mentioned in the article is in no way coasting, but sounds like she's recovering from a burn out. It is incredibly important to let burnt out employees rest and recover.
Re:“Rest and vest”: engineers who get paid and barely work by gaius on Monday August 07, 2017 @08:08AM (#14946888)
I didn't understand why she was "livid" that her manager told her to take some time off, on full pay, to recover.
Re:“Rest and vest”: engineers who get paid and barely work by mcv on Monday August 07, 2017 @09:12AM (#14947217)
That's how workaholics work and why they burn out. Work above everything.
Re:“Rest and vest”: engineers who get paid and barely work by acchow on Sunday August 06, 2017 @07:50PM (#14944389)
"Rest and vest" also happens for startups early employees who stay through IPO and are still vesting their initial grants. Generally, they've built up enough domain knowledge about the mostly-hacky systems that they are valuable enough for that knowledge alone and don't have to work very hard.
Re:“Rest and vest”: engineers who get paid and barely work by rodgerd on Sunday August 06, 2017 @07:42PM (#14944355)
> In particular, I found this quote disturbing

Indeed. But this is the world we're in, where coming to work and doing the job you're paid for because you have a life outside of work is considered toxic.

Re:“Rest and vest”: engineers who get paid and barely work by taway_1212 on Monday August 07, 2017 @06:59AM (#14946581)
Very senior engineers make seven figures at Google?