News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Buying time promotes happiness by neilwilson on Tuesday July 25, 2017 @02:15AM (#14845516)
Call me old fashioned, but rather than working yourself silly to then spend your money buying time back, why don't we set society up so that you have to work less in the first place to earn a living?

Are we not back to the parable of the fisherman and the banker? http://www.garywu.net/fisherman-and-banker/

Re:Buying time promotes happiness by dalbasal on Tuesday July 25, 2017 @04:37AM (#14846155)
Well... I suppose it's because we don't set up societies. In some sense the technology has done its job. When Keynes predicted the 15 hour workweek he (ironically) got the technology predictions right, but the economics/sociology wrong.

Individuals don't make the choices to optimize for less work. As few individuals make those choices, it is more socially and/or economically difficult to make those choices.

For the middle classes, major aspects of the modern economy are also competitive "races." Good neighborhoods, good schools, good colleges... These things are effectively competitive, not absolute. Costs rise with earnings. T

The social context isn't limited to pure economics. Generally speaking, people don't tend to choose lifestyles at all. We like to fantasize it, but don't do it that much. I think this comes down the the "we" problem. Lifestyle invention is something people do as groups (if at all) not individuals. We're more individualistic in modern culture, so there's less room for it even though it is more possible than ever. A religious group could more easily decide on a 15-hr-workweek, or some other major lifestyle engineering choice. There are stranger choices that endure longer than that.

Re:Buying time promotes happiness by UK-AL on Tuesday July 25, 2017 @03:30AM (#14845834)
Because it's more efficient. If your a software developer, 1 hour of your time could probably buy many hours of time from someone else.
Re:Buying time promotes happiness by grecy on Tuesday July 25, 2017 @05:56AM (#14846470)
If you sit down and run the numbers, it's not even close. Going to work to pay other people to do things for you to "free up time" simply does not work. You will work a lot more than you would if you just did things for yourself. Money is an extremely inefficient middle-man, given taxes and everyone wanting their cut.

Keep in mind you have to deduct taxes from your income, and the expenses it costs you to earn your income (clothes, transport, bought food, parking, car & maintenance, expensive housing, etc.).

Also keep in mind you must pay others with after-tax dollars. So when you pay that mechanic or plumber $85 per hour, that's a LOT of money, not even similar to you EARNING $85/hr.

I wrote a book about it, and in all my research and calculations, it roughly works out that most people earn only around 30-50% as much as they think they do.. so even if your salary is $120k, you're only earning something like $30/hr at absolute best, which is much lower than you pay a plumber or mechanic.

Re:Buying time promotes happiness by UK-AL on Tuesday July 25, 2017 @06:28AM (#14846587)
This is demonstrably false, because otherwise the logical conclusion is to do everything yourself. Including growing your own food.

The entire premise of market economies is that people are better at different things and by working together you get a higher aggregate amount of value. I.e Get more stuff with less resources spent(which includes time)

If it didn't work. Market economies wouldn't work.

Are your perhaps not including the efficiency of the worker in your calculations? Mechanic could probably change the brakes on a car without even thinking about it, you would probably take a hour of research and work grabbing the right replacement before you even start. Most farmers have a large of agricultural knowledge which allows them produce food cheaply in large quantities.

Re:Buying time promotes happiness by grecy on Tuesday July 25, 2017 @06:39AM (#14846648)
> because otherwise the logical conclusion is to do everything yourself

The logical conclusion is to do as much as you can yourself, and only get others to do things you are unable to do yourself. Where possible, don't use the work/income/tax/payment cycle to do it, try to use bartering or something more efficient where there are not so many middle-men taking a cut.

> The entire premise of market economies is that people are better at different things and by working together you get a higher aggregate amount of value

Ah-ha, you're right - but it doesn't create "higher value" for the individual worker.. it's higher value for those at the top of the pyramid.

> If it didn't work. Market economies wouldn't work.

Again, you are right, they don't work! The rich are getting vastly richer while the workers are getting vastly poorer. Look around you.

You might not have noticed, but the reason everyone goes to work every day for their entire lives is NOT because it's the most efficient or smartest thing for them to do. It's because they have been convinced that it is, and they are chasing the carrot dangling on a stick in front of them (house, car, new iPhone, etc.)

>Mechanic could probably change the brakes on a car without even thinking about it, you would probably take a few hours research before you even start.

I can tell you have never tried. Even the first time I did it I took less than an hour (inc research), and actually it would still have been "cheaper" even if it took 8+ hours (I was earning ~$70k as salary, mechanics where I live start at $145/hr)

Re:Buying time promotes happiness by jasode on Tuesday July 25, 2017 @09:37AM (#14847587)
>don't use the work/income/tax/payment cycle to do it, try to use bartering

Fyi, bartering is taxable in the USA.[1]

Yes, lots of people barter without reporting "fair market value" of bartered services to the IRS and yes, there isn't a large scale manhunt or crackdown for the tax evaders.

So it's very possible that people think bartering is cheaper because of ignorance of IRS laws. It's still technically "tax evasion". (Similar to how driving across state lines to buy things for 0% sales tax is also technically tax evasion when you don't declare the purchases in your home state's tax forms.)

E.g. A homeowner's lawn service costs $3000 a year. The homeowner could barter his web developer skills to make a "lawn care website" in exchange for 1 year of lawn care. The homeowner is supposed to declare the $3000-fair-market-value as income. If the homeowner is in 30% tax bracket, he owes ~$900 extra taxes PLUS he still has to expend the extra hours writing HTML/javascript to fulfill his side of the trade.

Is bartering that much cheaper if it's not "under the table" and you add in the the extra work+time to satisfy your end of the deal? (Especially if that extra work could be expended on other projects that are worth more than $3000 -or- working on websites more interesting to the homeowner than a lawn care service.)

[1] https://www.irs.gov/publications/p525/ar02.html#en_US_2016_p...

Re:Buying time promotes happiness by TheSpiceIsLife on Tuesday July 25, 2017 @07:36AM (#14846913)
It is extraordinarily unlikely any of my ancestors were ever rich.

And even if some of my ancestors were rich, my life today as a worker is economically better of by, oh I don't know, a factor of 1000.

If we also take in to account things like decrease in child mortality, clean running water, modern medicine, the internet, Wikipedia, Khan Academy, disposable computers, my life today as a worker is better off by a factor of at least 10,000.[1]

Additionally, despite what Jubal Harshaw might have us believe[2], it is infeasible that any given person should hope to be proficient at a wide variety of tasks.

While I certainly can do most automotive servicing myself, I lack a few specialist tools that would make the tasks efficient and enjoyable, so I outsource some / most if it as I choose.

1. Deirde McCloskey bangs on endlessly about this in her book Bourgeois Dignity: Why Economics Can’t Explain the Modern World https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bourgeois_Dignity

2. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Competent_man

Re:Buying time promotes happiness by RugnirViking on Tuesday July 25, 2017 @12:33PM (#14849144)
'my life today as a worker is better off by a factor of at least 10,000.'

Is it? I see this kind of argument in many places: "I don't have to wash clothes by hand" or "You wouldn't be saying this if you tried picking wheat for 14 hours"

But I think the issue with the argument is they are comparing against the wrong metric. We should be optimizing for human happiness. Innovation is a terrible proxy for this, as we are only marginally more happy than our predecessors in some areas. The main problem with happiness is that it is relatively indifferent to things that are unpleasant (such as picking wheat every day for 14 hours), as our brain quickly adapts and this becomes a new baseline. The things that make us unhappy in the long term (lack of exercise, lack of space, less predictable life, lack of control) are still around for almost everyone, regardless of them being saved menial chores.

Re:Buying time promotes happiness by TheSpiceIsLife on Tuesday July 25, 2017 @02:45PM (#14850680)
You raise some good points with regard to happiness, although I don't think I said anything about happiness. I simply said better off.

As a Registered Armchair Psychologist, I'm not entirely convinced that our brains quickly adapt to unpleasantness. I've heard quite a few soldiers come back from tours of duty with quite the mental health issues, ditto victims of abuse, etc etc.

My argument, and I side with Deirdre McCloskey here, is that we, we in the modern liberal west, and some other developing countries, are better off by far than our peasant ancestors because we have more predictability in and more control over our lives precisely because we have the ability to start our own businesses, to innovate and bring new products to market, to be economically upwardly mobile, to buy better health insurance... shall I go on? Rather than half half our siblings die early from disease and war.

With regard to happiness, well I'll defer to the experts here and side with David Steindl-Rast who claims that in order to be happy on a more frequent / long term basis we ought to cultivate gratefulness[1]. And in that sense I'll agree with you in that, despite adverse conditions, some people do still manage to be happy for what they do have.

The trajectory of the income gap, the rising price of housing, and the erosion of purchasing power, I treat as a separate issue. Moving forward this certainly does look like it's going to rapidly become a problem. Perhaps.

1. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UtBsl3j0YRQ

Re:Buying time promotes happiness by urethrafranklin on Tuesday July 25, 2017 @12:18PM (#14848962)
Love it. The self-defeatist rationalization of the utterly housebroken. "At least I have plumbing", he mews as he faithfully gives half of his profits to his master.
Re:Buying time promotes happiness by UK-AL on Tuesday July 25, 2017 @06:44AM (#14846666)
I defiantly earn more than say the pay for my cleaner even after a tax. I could prepare all my meals, but I've done the work I've worked that it defiantly pays more just to buy them.

I've done the calculations, and for me its defiantly more time efficient. I think your picking a particular inefficient example. Mechanics where I live don't earn that much at all.

I could service my car which for me would take me most of my day. My daily pay rate could defiantly pay for a full service after tax.

What i'm seeing here is that you just need to figure out what per hour rate is after tax, and use that to make quick calculations based on your local market.

"they are chasing the carrot dangling on a stick in front of them (house, car, new iPhone, etc.)" - Not everyone is like that. I have a cheap small car, a cheap smartphone, house that requires low maintenance I then plough the savings into services which I means I have more time and less stress. Then the rest goes into retirement funds and cheap vanguard funds.

If anything however its made my life a bit boring but very comfortable and laidback.

Re:Buying time promotes happiness by grecy on Tuesday July 25, 2017 @07:12AM (#14846776)
> What i'm seeing here is that you just need to figure out what per hour rate is after tax, and use that to make quick calculations based on your local market.

Yep, it's a whole chapter in the book I wrote on the topic of working less to live your dreams.

The other thing to realize is that when you are spending money, you are spending the time you have left in your life. You can never, ever get that time back, so spending should be very precious.

It's quite a mind-shift, but once you make it you'll never be able to go back.

Re:Buying time promotes happiness by wruza on Tuesday July 25, 2017 @08:16AM (#14847128)
All that seems to be a philosophy, not a fact. Obviously, when I'm spending my hour equivalent on full featured dinner, I'm saving myself around five hours, not even comparing quality and extra time to achieve it. That's how competence and production lines basically work.
Re:Buying time promotes happiness by atomashpolskiy on Tuesday July 25, 2017 @07:08AM (#14846760)
> The logical conclusion is to do as much as you can yourself, and only get others to do things you are unable to do yourself.

I think there's also a social/psychological aspect to this. When people pay for something that they are unable to do/produce by themselves, they feel (or at least should feel, from the society's point of view) some respect for the person doing the job, because he is a specialist with some non-trivial skills. In contrast, when people pay for something that they can do (or at least think that they can) but don't like to, they feel sympathy at best, or superiority and disdain at worst, because the job doer is now perceived more as a servant.

Re:Buying time promotes happiness by davidcbc on Tuesday July 25, 2017 @03:38PM (#14851179)
This works great if you measure value in terms of dollars spent per hour, but most people don't. I don't pay the mechanic to fix my car because it is cheaper than doing it myself, I pay the mechanic to do it because I don't want to do it myself. I have the means to avoid doing many things I don't enjoy by paying others to do it. If someone has a job they don't enjoy AND they have the ability to choose how many hours they work then your system would probably work, but most jobs have requirements for hours per week anyway so those hours are spent either way. After that you have to maximize the enjoyment value of the time you have free.
Re:Buying time promotes happiness by bdushabfjjsh on Tuesday July 25, 2017 @09:52AM (#14847681)
Why would the answer be so absolute? Shouldn't this calculation just shift the break even point where it makes sense to do things yourself to somewhere where you do more things yourself?
Re:Buying time promotes happiness by cloop_floop on Tuesday July 25, 2017 @07:31AM (#14846887)
Even if I accepted these calculations, I still have to work a 40 hour week. I can't optimize time spent on my profession, time spent on life maintenance, and leisure time. So I just work with what I have left over, and given these constraints I choose not to change my own oil, sure as I am I could do it.
Re:Buying time promotes happiness by smcdow on Tuesday July 25, 2017 @12:16PM (#14848944)
> You will work a lot more than you would if you just did things for yourself.

Nonsense. I would work no more nor no fewer hours in a given year regardless of whether I hired a plumber or mechanic. In fact, given that I won't adjust my work hours either way, then hiring people gives me more free time.

I may (or not) have a smaller bank balance, but that appears to be beside the point you're trying to make.

Re:Buying time promotes happiness by TheCoelacanth on Wednesday July 26, 2017 @12:33AM (#14853658)
But, a professional plumber or mechanic is probably many times more efficient than I am. I recently fixed the air conditioner in my car by replacing a bad relay. It took me about 5 hours to figure out what was wrong, figure out how to fix it, find the right replacement part and then replace it. A professional mechanic probably could have done it in 15 minutes which they probably would have rounded up to an hour which would still cost me much less than my after tax earnings for the 5 hours it took me. If it had been something more complicated that actually took specialized tools and more specialized skills, I probably would have come out even worse trying to fix it for myself.

Even with something relatively unskilled like cleaning someone who does it every day is still probably at least twice as fast as I am which makes up for the entire cost of taxes even if my hourly rate is the same as theirs.

Re:Buying time promotes happiness by sideshowb on Tuesday July 25, 2017 @06:13AM (#14846536)
What would your alternative suggestion be though? Toil on a farm growing your own vegetables? (nb for me this is in the "don't like doing" and "I'm bad at it" quadrant).

And if the implied alternative is to be workable for everyone, we have to magic roads, healthcare etc out of nowhere with no tax dollars.

Re:Buying time promotes happiness by grecy on Tuesday July 25, 2017 @06:31AM (#14846608)
> What would your alternative suggestion be though?

My alternative is only go to work as much as you need to. Food, shelter and some basic enjoyment, not more. That's something like $10-20k per year, at most. Which means you really only need to work 2ish days a week.

> And if the implied alternative is to be workable for everyone, we have to magic roads, healthcare etc out of nowhere with no tax dollars.

Not no tax dollars, but certainly less. It's clear that if everyone only went to work half as much we'd only need to build half the roads and trains and airports.

If every single person went to work only 4/5ths of what they do now. (i.e. 4 days per week instead of 5), The economy would only grow at 4/5ths of what it does now, but otherwise, everything would continue to function more-or-less like it does today. Once you see that, you realize it's also true for 3/5ths or even 2/5ths.

Re:Buying time promotes happiness by dragonwriter on Tuesday July 25, 2017 @09:10AM (#14847409)
> It's clear that if everyone only went to work half as much we'd only need to build half the roads and trains and airports.

Er, no. First, not all existing road/rail/air trips are for work, and, second, more time out of work would quite likely not merely preserve, but increase, non-work trips.

> If every single person went to work only 4/5ths of what they do now. (i.e. 4 days per week instead of 5), The economy would only grow at 4/5ths of what it does now

That's not at all obvious. The natural naive assumption is that there would be a one-time 20% contraction but after that growth rate would be unaffected; less naively, there's some reason to suspect that the one-time hit would be less, because productiob isn't linear, and the highest value work would be the last displaced.

But, more to the point, the general idea that utility is reduced ybbworkong for trade vs. working for one self is not well supported by evidence.

Re:Buying time promotes happiness by CJefferson on Tuesday July 25, 2017 @07:33AM (#14846899)
No, that maths is way off. If everyone went to work 4/5 of what they did now, the economy would contract by 20%, one of the biggest crashes in history.
Re:Buying time promotes happiness by smcdow on Tuesday July 25, 2017 @03:03PM (#14850850)
> That's something like $10-20k per year, at most.

You are obviously not married.

> Which means you really only need to work 2ish days a week.

And where do you find these unicorn jobs where you work only two days per week?

Re:Buying time promotes happiness by TheSpiceIsLife on Tuesday July 25, 2017 @07:45AM (#14846954)
It could be argued that societies that found themselves with the sorts of lifestyles you espouse (Australian Aboriginals; pre-Columbian indigenous of North America; etc) have all been decimated by societies that toiled.
Re:Buying time promotes happiness by adwn on Tuesday July 25, 2017 @07:44AM (#14846947)
> It's clear that if everyone only went to work half as much we'd only need to build half the roads and trains and airports.

Not only is this not "clear", it's also false. To connect two towns, you need 1 road. If everyone only went to work half as often, you still need 1 road – you can't have 0.5 roads. And if people work half as much, but only 4 hours per day, you wouldn't save anything.

Sure, with less utilization comes less need for maintainance, but not all wear and tear results from direct use.

Re:Buying time promotes happiness by majewsky on Tuesday July 25, 2017 @08:56AM (#14847314)
> you can't have 0.5 roads

Of course you can. Half a four-lane road is a two-lane road.

Re:Buying time promotes happiness by lodi on Tuesday July 25, 2017 @02:17PM (#14850394)
His point is fair though; just replace "road" with "railroad".
Re:Buying time promotes happiness by kerryfalk on Tuesday July 25, 2017 @12:11PM (#14848893)
Canada's rural roads (read: most of Canada's roads) are already mostly two-lane.
Re:Buying time promotes happiness by adwn on Tuesday July 25, 2017 @11:48AM (#14848650)
Most roads are not four-lane ones. Think residential roads, for example.
Re:Buying time promotes happiness by dragonwriter on Tuesday July 25, 2017 @11:55AM (#14848719)
Over time, most cost of a road is maintenance cost, not initial construction. While this probably isn't linear with use, it does scale with use, so that lower use means lower maintenance cost. The cost of a single lane road supporting current usage levels is not an individual less quantum unit of road cost.
Re:Buying time promotes happiness by brightball on Tuesday July 25, 2017 @09:12AM (#14847423)
There's some areas where the trade off works. I hire a yard company that comes out to take care of my yard every single week, brings equipment, hauls of trimmings and otherwise does maintenance that would take a couple of hours a week for me to do myself. They show up with a team of 3-4 people for about $180 / month.

We do something similar by hiring a house cleaning service that comes in every 2 weeks to do a heavy and thorough cleaning of our house for about $200 / month. That job would use an entire day of the weekend to do ourselves.

It's not every little task, but if there's a market for it there are certainly some areas where you can buy your time back relatively efficiently.

For $380 / month I buy back about 30 hours of my non-working time every month with those two services.

Re:Buying time promotes happiness by dnh44 on Tuesday July 25, 2017 @08:47AM (#14847259)
If you're self employed or have your own business you can use pre-tax dollars for a lot of those expenses.

Out of curiosity why would you include food, housing, and transport, etc in your calculation. Those are sunk costs so if the premise is "I'll work 2 extra hours a week" in order to pay someone to 6 hours of cleaning, cooking, etc, then those sunk costs don't really enter into it.

It's seems like what you're really calculating is profit per hour.

Do you have a link to your book?

Re:Buying time promotes happiness by grecy on Tuesday July 25, 2017 @07:19PM (#14852676)
> Out of curiosity why would you include food, housing, and transport, etc in your calculation.

Because they are all higher as a result of going to work. i.e. if you buy lunch at work everyday for $15, you would only spend $5 if you were at home and ate a sandwich you made yourself.. so the $10 per day difference is a "cost" of going to work. Same for transport (would be $0 without work). Housing is often greatly inflated because of work. i.e. I want to earn the big bucks in Silicon Valley, so I pay $4000/mo rent. Or I just move way out someplace and only spend $1000/mo.. therefore the $3000 difference per month is a "cost" of going to work.

> It's seems like what you're really calculating is profit per hour.

That's an interesting way to say it.... I guess I would say "how much are you really getting ahead for every hour of your life you are selling. (hint: it's massively less than most people think)

> Do you have a link to your book?

"Work Less to Live Your Dreams" http://amzn.to/2vVzpbG

Re:Buying time promotes happiness by anotheryou on Tuesday July 25, 2017 @09:07AM (#14847386)
Numbers are not the only thing though:

- to re-do a roof would take me ages, while professionals are pretty quick at it

- I might not even be able to do the roof

- Cleaning personal might mean untinterrupted and fully free time at home on the weekend.

- most employees (at least here in the EU) do their 40h and it is not easy to find other deals.

(disclaimer: I own no roof and have no cleaning personal either)

Re:Buying time promotes happiness by grecy on Tuesday July 25, 2017 @07:20PM (#14852682)
> it is not easy to find other deals.

I didn't say any of this would be easy. Nothing rewarding ever is, in my experience.

Re:Buying time promotes happiness by dalbasal on Tuesday July 25, 2017 @04:34AM (#14846142)
Efficient by what standard? IE what are we optimizing for?
Re:Buying time promotes happiness by IshKebab on Tuesday July 25, 2017 @04:57AM (#14846255)
Free time in that case. If I work for one hour to pay a cleaner to work for two I end up with more free time.
Re:Buying time promotes happiness by UK-AL on Tuesday July 25, 2017 @04:55AM (#14846244)
Time
Re:Buying time promotes happiness by jstanley on Tuesday July 25, 2017 @04:35AM (#14846146)
> why don't we set society up so that you have to work less in the first place to earn a living?

The good news is you don't need to "set society up" to do this. You can just work less and live cheaply, and then you're done.

It's especially easy if you're a highly-paid software developer or similar, which you most likely are if you're on HN.

Re:Buying time promotes happiness by grecy on Tuesday July 25, 2017 @05:51AM (#14846447)
I agree with this wholeheartedly, and have used my ample time to drive around the world.

I'm so passionate about it I wrote an e-book called "Work Less to Live Your Dreams". [1]

[1] http://amzn.to/2vVzpbG

Re:Buying time promotes happiness by jventura on Wednesday July 26, 2017 @09:52AM (#14856164)
I like the way you reason on your other posts about the "externalised" costs of not doing your own things at times, as I usually think on similar lines. That is why I usually try to fix my own things, buy second hand, and only buy when truly needed. For instance, I always assume that it will be I that will have to do all the maintenance of whatever I buy.

Is this something you talk about on your book? Do you recommend some store where I can get an epub copy of your book (or pdf, but would prefer epub)? I don't have a Kindle, only a Sony PRS-T1. If you have a referal to yourself (outside amazon), it's perfectly fine!

Re:Buying time promotes happiness by grecy on Wednesday July 26, 2017 @08:29PM (#14861651)
Actually I don't have much in the book about doing your own maintennce, other that working on your car, painting your house, etc.

Thanks for the input, maybe it will make it into the revised edition.

My book is also on Apple iBook store and kobo. You can buy it off amazon and just read on your computer too.

Re:Buying time promotes happiness by andruby on Tuesday July 25, 2017 @03:09AM (#14845740)
When we work more and spend money to outsource household stuff, that increases GDP and allows the government to tax more of the economic output.

If you do your own household work, that's not counted in the GDP and is non-taxable. I guess that's why some countries have been subsidising day care, etc.

Re:Buying time promotes happiness by ajdlinux on Tuesday July 25, 2017 @03:20AM (#14845782)
Intuitively, I'd expect that a day care provider has a higher ratio of children to staff than families have of children to primary caregivers, and that the difference is such that subsidising day care can increase GDP just by freeing up more parents to work
Re:Buying time promotes happiness by blowski on Tuesday July 25, 2017 @03:36AM (#14845877)
A relevant observation (not my own):

> If I marry my housekeeper, national GDP goes down

Re:Buying time promotes happiness by tonyedgecombe on Tuesday July 25, 2017 @03:49AM (#14845930)
But personal well-being goes up.
Re:Buying time promotes happiness by pizza234 on Tuesday July 25, 2017 @05:34AM (#14846377)
Are we not back to the parable of the fisherman and the banker? http://www.garywu.net/fisherman-and-banker/ -

It depends on who "we" is.

In some cultures, "being the banker" is the ultimate goal in life. I remember talking to a person coming from one of such cultures, telling that "we are taught ambition since we are children". Ambition for the sake of ambition is the root of "being the banker".

So certain cultures are not "back to the parable" - they never moved; they likely, never will, and that's fine, it's their choice, and I don't assume that's negative just because I disagree with it.

This relates to the previous statement:

Call me old fashioned, but rather than working yourself silly to then spend your money buying time back

"Bankers" (or "banking cultures", to follow up with the metaphor) won't do this - they will actually see it as opportunity to produce more with the same time.

Re:Buying time promotes happiness by manmal on Tuesday July 25, 2017 @03:27AM (#14845813)
Update: Sorry this comment does not quite fit with parent, I actually wanted to post it as a root comment.

My big hope for reducing time spent on current society's tasks is robotics. There already are robots for a lot of tedious tasks, in theory - vacuum cleaners, lawn mowers, even window and BBQ grill cleaners. Alas, except for maybe vacuums and mowers, those tend not to buy time but just shift your work from the basic activity to maintaining the robot.

But I think a universal, affordable household robot is absolutely within reach, and it would not require general intelligence, but just well implemented capabilities. From sorting dishes to vacuuming, stairclimbing, taking out the trash to a predefined location, sorting in groceries, to maybe cooking with the help of standardized storage and equipment - I don't care if it's all highly specialized tasks, it just has to do enough of them.

Re:Buying time promotes happiness by tonyedgecombe on Tuesday July 25, 2017 @03:48AM (#14845923)
A lot of those time sinks are self-inflicted, when vacuum cleaners came along we didn't use it as an opportunity to save time but rather to keep our carpets cleaner. The same pattern occurs with lawn mowers, washing machines, BBQ grill cleaners, etc.

I know it's a hackneyed quote but our possessions really do own us.

Re:Buying time promotes happiness by mattferderer on Tuesday July 25, 2017 @09:43AM (#14847633)
I wish I would have read this before buying a Roomba. I thought it would save me so much time because my wife wanted to clean the floors nightly due to having an infant crawling around. Instead of the time saved resulting in relaxation, it ended up "allowing us" to clean other parts instead.
Re:Buying time promotes happiness by atomashpolskiy on Tuesday July 25, 2017 @02:29AM (#14845576)
More work produces more goods/services to sell, why would capitalists cut back on their profits?
Re:Buying time promotes happiness by beaconstudios on Tuesday July 25, 2017 @04:17AM (#14846066)
because not all capitalists work for publicly traded companies where they are legally bound to maximise profits. There are plenty of businesspeople out there who aren't constantly seeking out new ways to increase profits. Usually small business owners.
Re:Buying time promotes happiness by atomashpolskiy on Tuesday July 25, 2017 @07:19AM (#14846818)
What kind of impact do these lifestyle businesspeople have on an average person's life? Or do you mean that they are a good example of giving up on pursuing wealth in exchange for spare time and unquantifiable humanly joys?
Re:Buying time promotes happiness by beaconstudios on Thursday July 27, 2017 @06:08AM (#14863934)
I mean they're a good model of what healthy capitalism can look like. Provide valuable services, don't work your employees to death to maximise profits for the mob-rule of shareholders, stay small and focus on well-roundedness. I'm very pro-capitalism and I can't stand the enterprise model of business, it's very dehumanising.
Re:Buying time promotes happiness by shusson on Tuesday July 25, 2017 @02:36AM (#14845602)
> why don't we set society up so that you have to work less in the first place to earn a living

I think in practice this is very hard and would require modification of economic fundamentals e.g at a very broad level capitalism vs socialism.

Re:Buying time promotes happiness by tonyedgecombe on Tuesday July 25, 2017 @03:52AM (#14845945)
We did end slavery, we did introduce a 40 hour week, we did stop children working.

If you take Europe as an example the country with the strongest economy is among the shortest working hours.

Re:Buying time promotes happiness by terminalcommand on Tuesday July 25, 2017 @08:35AM (#14847209)
The problem is 40 hour week does not apply to high-earning professionals such as brokers, lawyers, doctors etc. I do not think corporate lawyers in Europe stick to a 40 hour week schedule.

I'm currently interning at a law firm, and everyone around here works 10 or more hours a day on average. (official office hours are 09:30-19:30, but only on rare occasions you can leave at 19:30 sharp. )

Re:Buying time promotes happiness by atomashpolskiy on Tuesday July 25, 2017 @04:05AM (#14846018)
Tell this to the people in "developing" countries, who make your clothes and gadgets.
Re:Buying time promotes happiness by beaconstudios on Tuesday July 25, 2017 @04:18AM (#14846075)
many of those things are made in south-east Asia, in countries that aren't really "developing" in the sense you're implying. China is a modern country, Taiwan is a modern country.
Re:Buying time promotes happiness by tonyedgecombe on Tuesday July 25, 2017 @04:28AM (#14846117)
Actually, all those things happened before we started outsourcing to Asia.
Re:Buying time promotes happiness by atomashpolskiy on Tuesday July 25, 2017 @04:42AM (#14846173)
True. The problem is that these things magically "unhappened" at some point in the last few decades.
Re:Buying time promotes happiness by wvh on Tuesday July 25, 2017 @07:47AM (#14846963)
Because the American (referring to the story in link) would push through his own grand visions, create an empire and crush the little man, either as a struggling independent or as a underpaid cog in a large machine.

If not enough people (majority?) agree on this philosophy, those that do are going to find themselves on the outside of productive society without the means to live in it.

Think small grocery stores, book shops, bakeries, really anything that has been disappearing the last half century. And think how many people can't any more afford to live in the city they were born in.

Re:Buying time promotes happiness by pascalxus on Tuesday July 25, 2017 @12:19PM (#14848985)
It's a good idea, but too many people are against it. And, ultimately, the reason we can't do it, is because we're too desperate for money. Modern day society only allows you to reduce your expenses so much - in CA, the latest generation must pay 50%+ of their salary for basic shelter. This doesn't leave much room to trade significant amounts of money for time.

As long, 99% of the population is still shelter insecure (the lowest level of maslow's hierarchy of needs), we won't be able to trade money for time.

Re:Buying time promotes happiness by z3t4 on Tuesday July 25, 2017 @02:42AM (#14845625)
Some people actually love what they do for "work".
Re:Buying time promotes happiness by pasquinelli on Tuesday July 25, 2017 @03:10AM (#14845743)
I don't understand those people. I went out and got a job doing what I love, but it only turned the thing I love into a fucking job.
Re:Buying time promotes happiness by octygen on Tuesday July 25, 2017 @03:19AM (#14845780)
This happened to me too. I find the quality of the boss/leadership mitigates this for me. A good leader can make a job into something you love if it can be aligned to what you want to do. I try to attain this utopia with everyone on my teams.
Re:Buying time promotes happiness by z3t4 on Tuesday July 25, 2017 @07:56AM (#14847012)
If it feels like work, it's work, otherwise you would do it for free right !? smile Most people enjoy the reward, and that's ok, but there's also people that enjoy the work. But you can't expect it to be fun all the time. But for those of you who hates your work, I think extrinsic motivation (a salary) works just as well as intrinsic motivation for both "success" and happiness.
Re:Buying time promotes happiness by TeMPOraL on Tuesday July 25, 2017 @02:56AM (#14845693)
Good for them. That would be a what, a pretty small fraction of the global population? And that's before asking whether it's true love or just Stockholm syndrome.
Re:Buying time promotes happiness by Rainymood on Tuesday July 25, 2017 @03:27AM (#14845819)
Maybe work satisfaction is like a bell-curve? There are a small amount of people who absolutely LOVE what they do and also a very small amount of epople who absolutely HATE what they do with a large majority in the middle.
Re:Buying time promotes happiness by tonyedgecombe on Tuesday July 25, 2017 @03:57AM (#14845964)
Actually, I think the statistics show most people hate their jobs.
Re:Buying time promotes happiness by JetSpiegel on Tuesday July 25, 2017 @03:32AM (#14845847)
That's just the Protestant Work Ethic.
Re:Buying time promotes happiness by aplummer on Tuesday July 25, 2017 @03:52AM (#14845941)
I don't think so, i get to work early because I want to.
Re:Buying time promotes happiness by LouisSayers on Tuesday July 25, 2017 @04:03AM (#14846001)
There's a certain level of comfort that people will still want to have.

I like the idea of doing both - earn high, spend low, and reap the rewards in-between.

Re:Buying time promotes happiness by kazagistar on Tuesday July 25, 2017 @11:07AM (#14848251)
I'm not sure which rewards you are thinking of. The reward of having a big bank account?
Re:Buying time promotes happiness by lkbm on Tuesday July 25, 2017 @03:38PM (#14851172)
Basic financial security if you can pull this off better than the average American. Early retirement if you do much better.

Most people are stressed about money. Then they get a raise, their expenses grow with it, and are just as stressed about money. If you can skip grow half of one raise-grow step, you now have some breathing room. If you can skip several, you can get a lot of breathing room, and still have a comfortable life.