Re:The Tyranny of Other People’s Vacation Photos (2016)
by jasode on Saturday July 22, 2017 @06:23AM
(#14826389)
The NYT article about over-sharing vacation photos can be generalized to the widespread human nature of narcissism: people share too many personal highlights that most others don't care about.
E.g. new mother shares endless stream of baby photos while most of her 20-something ex-college friends/coworkers are oversaturated with it. (E.g. the sentiment that if you've seen one blob of an undifferentiated poop machine in diapers, you've seen them all.) Yes, the infant is The Most Interesting Person In The World to that mother so it seems logical to her that others would find her posted photos to be interesting too.
On a large scale, we simply have no self-awareness about our narcissism and its banality to others.
Long before the existence of the internet and Facebook in the days of film photography, hosts would torture their dinner guests by having them gather in the living room and flip through slides[1] of the hosts' vacation. The guests silently suffer through the boring presentation but of course, etiquette means nobody would dare say, "Joe, this is boring and we're going home now." Polite society on a large-scale, self-censors the expression of boredom which perversely continues the large-scale unawareness that sharing too many personal highlights is subjecting friends to cruel & unusual punishment.
Re:The Tyranny of Other People’s Vacation Photos (2016)
by jaclaz on Saturday July 22, 2017 @09:17AM
(#14827037)
>Long before the existence of the internet and Facebook in the days of film photography, hosts would torture their dinner guests by having them gather in the living room and flip through slides[1] of the hosts' vacation.
Yep, I do remember some of the most fierce fights against falling asleep in those occasions.
But - to give some sociological insight - those terrible after dinners came out because of sheer convenience.
Till then there were "pictures" (not slides) that costed a lot of money to print in a decently large format, so typically you took less shots, then had them printed in a very small format, and only reprinted a handful out of each roll.
With slides the costs were a fraction, even considering the cost (rather high for today's standards) of the projector and of the carousels.
Now what if someone (not the government as it would be anti-democratic, not google as it would be a dominant position abuse, etc.) would put a minimal cost for publishing on the net these images (let's say 0.50 US$/apiece, of course devolved entirely to a non-profit/humanitariaon association)?
I would bet that in no time we would have the amount of those photos reduced to 1/20th or less.
Re:The Tyranny of Other People’s Vacation Photos (2016)
by teddyh on Saturday July 22, 2017 @11:07AM
(#14827548)
Yes. And when someone dares to suggest that maybe you shouldn’t have used a dinner-planning group to announce the birth of your baby, you get flamed to a crisp:
Re:The Tyranny of Other People’s Vacation Photos (2016)
by Retric on Saturday July 22, 2017 @08:50AM
(#14826931)
I actually rather enjoyed siting through some of those slide shows. It's largely a question if they try and take and show interesting photos, or if they just take pictures of themselves.
Re:The Tyranny of Other People’s Vacation Photos (2016)
by rayiner on Saturday July 22, 2017 @09:05AM
(#14826986)
As someone in the cohort that was in college when Facebook was first invented, who are now all having kids, I don't really see that phenomenon at play. Nobody responds when I post, e.g. a rebuttal to the recent Atlantic article that discusses US versus Canadian public spending. Putting up a picture of my kid, in contrast, will result in dozens of likes. (I of course feel reciprocally.)
I'd turn this around and say, if you're annoyed by pictures of other peoples' kids or their vacations or what they ate, maybe you're the narcissistic one. In a modern world where people often move far away from friends and family to pursue careers, Facebook fills in for a lot of the shared experience that people would otherwise have. I want to see pictures of my friends baby, because I can't visit her often on the opposite coast. I want to see the latest food my father in law put in the smoker, because I can't drop in to steal a sample. I'm interested in the lives of my friends and family and Facebook let's me at least keep a bit in touch with what's happening.
Re:The Tyranny of Other People’s Vacation Photos (2016)
by jasode on Saturday July 22, 2017 @09:21AM
(#14827056)
>when Facebook was first invented, who are now all having kids, I don't really see that phenomenon at play.
I don't doubt that there are people that genuinely enjoy others' baby photos. However, I wouldn't be able to tell which comments left on each others' pages were expressions of authentic sincerity instead of mindless reflexes of etiquette.
That said, this Reddit thread[1] highlights a collective exasperation that clearly comes from somewhere.
Likewise, there are surely some who enjoy others vacation slideshows (e.g. Retric in this thread) but again, there's a widespread rejection of them[2] that comes from somewhere. People won't complaint directly to the posters face -- e.g. they won't write on the posters wall to "stop flooding the feed with your stupid vacation photos". People are generally too polite to do that.
>, maybe you're the narcissistic one.
It's not about me. It's about observing social dynamics:
1) People overestimate the parts of their personal lives that are interesting to others
2) People are silent or insincerely praise the over-sharing of others' personal highlights
Those 2 factors create a weird/interesting feedback cycle that transcends Facebook/Instagram/Snapchat. It's been happening long before that.
Re:The Tyranny of Other People’s Vacation Photos (2016)
by rayiner on Saturday July 22, 2017 @09:51AM
(#14827193)
Without knowledge of the minds of others, I can only assume they understand how Facebook works. For my part, if I consistently like pictures of your kid it means I want to see them on my feed.
Clearly there are people who don't like pictures of peoples' vacations or kids enough to bitch on Reddit about it. I'd call those people narcissists. Facebook is inherently about sharing things about yourself: your kid, your vacation, your new job, your walk by the river, even your political opinions. Almost nothing posted on Facebook is not self centered in some way. That's not inherently narcissistic. What narcissistic is when you post that stuff yourself, but can't empathize with others enough not to be annoyed when they do it.
Re:The Tyranny of Other People’s Vacation Photos (2016)
by jasode on Saturday July 22, 2017 @10:41AM
(#14827448)
>For my part,
Yes, I've already acknowledge that people like you exist but it's not relevant to what I was discussing. But let's continue on that example you gave...
>if I consistently like pictures of your kid it means I want to see them on my feed.
Right... but when a person complains to her friends that "nobody 'likes' her posts", it then causes some of them to start "liking" the posts just to get her to shut up. This type of dynamic contributes to the phenomenon I'm talking about.
>Facebook is inherently about sharing things about yourself: [...] Almost nothing posted on Facebook is not self centered in some way. That's not inherently narcissistic.
You're reducing the topic to an absolutism which is not what I'm talking about even though I took great care in the first post to properly qualify the social phenomenon: over-sharing instead of just sharing and "too many personal highlights" instead of just "personal highlights". The NYT author did the same when he wrote, "_excessive_ posting of these pictures".
Yes, Facebook is inherently about sharing... just as an old slide carousel is about sharing film photos. The respective technologies' purpose is not the point.
To restate... There is a widespread social phenomenon: many of us share more than the audience wants to see. It has a perverse feedback mechanism (social grooming, white lies, polite self-censorship, self-ignorance, etc) that perpetuates the phenomenon across different media (e.g. film slides to Facebook). (This disconnect between posters' (non)curation vs audience receptiveness is also mentioned at the end of the NYT article when the author wrote, "I am trying to calibrate my photographic output. As we all should.")
I think that's interesting observation to talk about. Maybe your issue is the word "narcissism"? I used that term because that seems to have the most currency.[1] If there's a better word, make a suggestion. If bringing up the topic itself is toxic and shouldn't be discussed, please explain why.
Re:The Tyranny of Other People’s Vacation Photos (2016)
by Sleeep on Saturday July 22, 2017 @10:30AM
(#14827387)
You don't seem to understand there is difference between sharing and over sharing. I really like sharing but I absolutely loathe over sharing. It's like the difference between a conversation and listening to someone rant.
Re:The Tyranny of Other People’s Vacation Photos (2016)
by wvh on Saturday July 22, 2017 @10:37AM
(#14827435)
Some things are just easier to reply to. On my way from work I see tonnes of people, all with their phones out, just flicking up, like, up, like, up, like, without even checking what's in the pictures. I'm not sure I understand the value of receiving "x likes".
I'm too old and a(media)social to know the platforms people use these days, but I guess those platforms don't lend themselves to the writing of large insightful essays. On a bus. With a phone. And I think most people won't, anyway.
I think you really need to be a certain kind of person to want to see and reply something trite to every picture of your "inner circle"; as I'm really on the other side of that spectrum, I can't really understand the motivation of the replier or happiness of the content poster. If you want to kill yourself, please come and talk to me, but please don't bore/harass me with pictures of your breakfast. I have a baby girl; I don't understand why I'd post pictures and check how many people like them. I don't see the value; (to me) it's nothing more but a social charade.
Maybe I'm too far on the autistic spectrum to be certain types of social.
Luckily, when you don't crave the attention yourself, you don't have to be part of the game.
Re:The Tyranny of Other People’s Vacation Photos (2016)
by rayiner on Saturday July 22, 2017 @11:47AM
(#14827740)
> I'm too old and a(media)social to know the platforms people use these days, but I guess those platforms don't lend themselves to the writing of large insightful essays. On a bus. With a phone. And I think most people won't, anyway.
I'd much rather look at pictures of your kids than read your "insightful essays." Most essays, even ones appearing in respectable publications, are little more than a patchwork of spin, guessing, and questionable assumptions connected with questionable reasoning.[1]
I'm probably on the other side of the spectrum, but I don't really want to hear your ideas. I want to share your human experiences. That feeling when you watch your toddler develop enough motor skills to pick up food, but not enough to put it in her mouth. The happiness at your wedding. Your pride at cooking a meal for your family. Those are the things that are real, genuine, and true.
[1] Think about how inaccurate every article you read in the press is about any scientific topic you come across. They are no more accurate about the topics you know less about. For example, this article has been making the rounds on my Facebook: https://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2017/07/canada-.... It's based entirely on a false premise: that because U.S. tax rates are lower than in Canada, U.S. public spending is lower. In reality, per-capita non-military public spending in the U.S. is quite significantly higher than in Canada. And this is a "respectable" author appearing in a "respectable" publication! This is the trash clogging up the Internet; not baby pictures.
Re:The Tyranny of Other People’s Vacation Photos (2016)
by wvh on Sunday July 23, 2017 @10:38AM
(#14832434)
Well, I'd say both articles and pictures can be good or bad...
I guess it's about your mind. I want to decipher the world, in scientific terms, and I don't care about personal angles. Yes, you have to filter a lot of opinion and filler, but I want real information. I probably could live easier without personal information at all than without interesting stuff to study.
Mind you, I'm somewhat on the autistic scale, and I am well aware that most people have a greater need for personal connection and social inclusion. I can't look at pictures of a social event and not see the mechanics behind the behaviours, like it's hard to enjoy a movie if you can't suspend disbelief. To me, a baby trying to eat is mostly just an image of neurons trying to organise. I don't understand wedding pictures because I don't understand marriage, why people have to go through a weird social routine/tradition to declare that they want to be together. I have feelings and emotions of course, but stuff gets very boring very quickly if there's no "actual" information to go with it.
Re:The Tyranny of Other People’s Vacation Photos (2016)
by Kluny on Saturday July 22, 2017 @09:24AM
(#14827066)
Exactly. There are lots of babies on my facebook feed that I don't care about, but it's pretty easy to hit the mute button (and I do). But when it's my brother or my cousin's kid, I'm definitely interested.
Re:The Tyranny of Other People’s Vacation Photos (2016)
by jasonkester on Saturday July 22, 2017 @05:56AM
(#14826305)
It's a shame in a way that mobile internet has become so ubiquitous, and that people tend to therefore spend so much of their time on the beach looking at their phone.
One of the nice things about being away is that you're away. That you're forced out of your routine, unable to keep up with the same day-to-day stuff as usual, and cut off from your friends. It forces you to make new friends.
Travel for me used to be a good hack to overcome a natural tendency toward introversion. At some point, after not speaking to a human for a few days, I would go in to Emergency Survival Social Mode, where I had to strike up a conversation with the person at the next table right that minute just to preserve my sanity. And nearly every time I'd find that that person was going through the same thing and was thus happy to chat about whatever for a while.
That's a lot harder to do now, when everybody sitting alone at a table has their phone out, facebooking away with their friends at home as per normal.
I don't know what the solution will be. Hopefully the pendulum will swing back and people will realize that it's nice to disconnect for real from time to time. Especially when there is real sand between their toes and a real sunset going on in front of them (and a real girl sitting at the next table).
Re:The Tyranny of Other People’s Vacation Photos (2016)
by barrkel on Saturday July 22, 2017 @08:44AM
(#14826910)
I've gone for months at a time not talking to anyone and have never found myself needing to strike up conversation; normally, I would be busy thinking and any conversation would be mundane and irrelevant. I've toured alone by motorcycle a few times, and similarly, in the evening, I just want to get my food.
Re:The Tyranny of Other People’s Vacation Photos (2016)
by rimliu on Saturday July 22, 2017 @06:53AM
(#14826495)
Are you sure you have a tendency for introversion? I am introvert and I have no need for "Emergency Survival Social Mode". On the contrary, now and then I want to get away from and by with just myself for a few days.
Re:The Tyranny of Other People’s Vacation Photos (2016)
by jasonkester on Saturday July 22, 2017 @08:11AM
(#14826785)
Have you tried the thing I'm talking about? As in, traveling through Southeast Asia for several months by yourself and hitting spells of over a week at a time where you honestly haven't spoken to another human being except to order food?
It takes a pretty dedicated introvert to not need even a little human company after a while.
Re:The Tyranny of Other People’s Vacation Photos (2016)
by psyc on Saturday July 22, 2017 @09:01AM
(#14826975)
I'm very introverted, and I haven't had an in-person conversation in almost 2 years. It does eventually become the only priority, like when you're starving, or badly craving a cigarette.
Re:The Tyranny of Other People’s Vacation Photos (2016)
by frik on Saturday July 22, 2017 @06:09AM
(#14826345)
How about taking photos on scene, and post some pics later (taxi, hotel, etc). When your family is several time zones away it time doesn't matter that much anyway.
Re:The Tyranny of Other People’s Vacation Photos (2016)
by frik on Saturday July 22, 2017 @06:49AM
(#14826474)
you missed the point, when you are several time zones away, your family and friends probably sleep while you are awake and active. sure, when you are near by you might be interested in instant chit-chat
Re:The Tyranny of Other People’s Vacation Photos (2016)
by aaron695 on Saturday July 22, 2017 @09:24AM
(#14827070)
Point is family and friends don't care (Or even subliminally dislike you for it)
But the person has no idea, hence they post oblivious to whether there are real people who actually want to see it.
They post instantly, assume everyone likes it, instant hit achieved. Due to politeness (And the subliminal voting circle) people like back at some stage.
The arguable point is whether the superficial voting circle of Facebook works and makes people happy or it's a drug we get dependent on and just need.
Re:The Tyranny of Other People’s Vacation Photos (2016)
by owebmaster on Saturday July 22, 2017 @09:14AM
(#14827022)
Yeah what I mean is not that you will receive instant feedback (and thus instant happiness) but is that what people are looking for. Likes from strange people seems even more common than from family and friends anyway.
Re:The Tyranny of Other People’s Vacation Photos (2016)
by eludwig on Saturday July 22, 2017 @06:55AM
(#14826512)
Great article. I laughed. I wonder if this is mostly a matter of indiscriminate visibility and a lack of friction?
In the old days, there was that moment when visiting someone's house (friend, relative maybe) and the topic of family vacations came up. Then someone suggests the slide projector. You could almost feel the silent "uggh" from the people who were not on the vacation. The worst part would be the unknown length of the slide show. (ten minutes? two hours?) But setting up the slide projector was a fair effort, so it could easily be put off "until next time you come over" (phew! Dodged a bullet!)
Now you just pop them up on FB and they are there for all to see. Compound that with the fact that FB's sharing controls are so complicated that actually just sharing with a particular subset (immediate family, grandparents, etc) is nigh impossible for ordinary mortals and there you are! Bazillions of terrible family photos a click away, or worse: a scroll away, no click needed.
Physical photos did have some advantages: at least they could be avoided! ;D
Re:The Tyranny of Other People’s Vacation Photos (2016)
by watwut on Saturday July 22, 2017 @10:21AM
(#14827342)
I don't understand how facebook picture posting is worst then physical if this is your attitude towards them.
If they would set up projector, you would have to either watch it or say openly you dont want to watch them. Meanwhile, on facebook you just scroll past all that. Eventually you can click on something other people post and facebook will show you more of that in the future. Moreover people typically post them in albums. If you dont click album. You dont spend time watching pictures.
Unless of course, mere remainder of existence of such thing annoys you.
Re:The Tyranny of Other People’s Vacation Photos (2016)
by losteverything on Saturday July 22, 2017 @08:05AM
(#14826759)
<Then someone suggests the slide projector. You could almost feel the silent "uggh" from the people who were not on the vacation.
Still have our old carousel with "ten best" and latest trip.
But what that also did was drastically reduce family shared memories and stories to those precious slides. Reliving again for each generation.
Now, ubiquity of photos equalize all events to the same stature and,imo, lose group family memories of those few great events (whether or not they were indeed great)
Re:The Tyranny of Other People’s Vacation Photos (2016)
by TuringNYC on Saturday July 22, 2017 @07:22AM
(#14826613)
I've heard this sentiment from many people. I probably depends on how one uses Facebook. For me, I have a busy career, grad school at night, kids, and I barely get time to go to the gym. Sadly, my extended family gets left behind, we don't speak as much as we'd wish. Months go by and photos aren't shared. Being able to post to a limited audience and have them subscribe to these photos has lead to a much closer bond amongst our extended family. Same with childhood friends I love dearly but dont have time to keep up with.
Re:The Tyranny of Other People’s Vacation Photos (2016)
by _tulpa on Saturday July 22, 2017 @07:03AM
(#14826542)
How about a happy compromise: Ditch everything except mbasic.facebook.com (I have a hosts entry that does that) and messenger lite.
Both are perfectly usable and I can still have a social life, but it's not as effortless as just scrolling down so you tend to do it less and stop when you stop caring (well I do anyway). Definitely dialed back the background anxiety levels when I did that.
Re:The Tyranny of Other People’s Vacation Photos (2016)
by rimliu on Saturday July 22, 2017 @07:16AM
(#14826590)
I have deleted facebook app from my phone long ago because of the very shady things it was allegedly trying to do (and to save my battery). Only use FB mobile site on the phone.
I'll give mbasic a try, thanks for mentioning it :)
Re:The Tyranny of Other People’s Vacation Photos (2016)
by platetone on Saturday July 22, 2017 @08:42AM
(#14826903)
What is this magic?? I feel like I'm sane again reading Facebook like that. Just replaced my bookmark. If it could display in reverse chronological order, then Facebook would be totally fixed.
Re:The Tyranny of Other People’s Vacation Photos (2016)
by redial on Saturday July 22, 2017 @07:15AM
(#14826585)
At the beginning is just a splinter, but if an infection starts, and the flesh around it slowly begins to die you might have no choice but to amputate.
To some people is just a splinter, to others, well, you get the idea.
Re:The Tyranny of Other People’s Vacation Photos (2016)
by roadbeats on Saturday July 22, 2017 @09:39AM
(#14827141)
A month ago I went to a story telling event. There was one woman who came in the middle of the event, and went on the stage to tell her story as soon as she joined the group, without waiting or listening anyone else. She told a story about how she went to a beach, how she enjoyed, etc. Her personal experience of enjoying life. She talked about it like 10 minutes, then left the place without listening anyone else. She just wanted to tell 50 people how she enjoys the beach near her home, and also, asked the organizer of the event to record her 10 minutes speech with her phone, so she could put that video on Facebook. Narcissism in these days is in a level that people acts worse than celebrities, thanks to social media.
Re:The Tyranny of Other People’s Vacation Photos (2016)
by darrmit on Saturday July 22, 2017 @09:39AM
(#14827143)
I take tons of pictures of my son. I don't feel the need to share them on Facebook, nor does my wife. If we want a group of people to see pictures, we send them the pictures directly.
People ARE way too addicted to that red notification symbol.
Re:The Tyranny of Other People’s Vacation Photos (2016)
by Artlav on Saturday July 22, 2017 @10:03AM
(#14827261)
Hm, am i broken? I see travel photos as something private, only shown if and when the relative bicker me for them.
I take a lot of photos usually, and they act as something like an extension of my memory, a journal. To show them to someone else is an intimate thing.
Re:The Tyranny of Other People’s Vacation Photos (2016)
by mercurysmessage on Saturday July 22, 2017 @09:15AM
(#14827029)
I don't travel a ton, but I do some for personal vacations. Honestly myself, and I'm sure many others don't care about the money spent. I'd rather have a nice trip, I'm not that greedy.
Re:The Tyranny of Other People’s Vacation Photos (2016)
by cortesoft on Saturday July 22, 2017 @11:12AM
(#14827572)
I don't get why seeing people having fun makes you sad; when I see pictures of my friends and family having fun doing stuff, it makes me feel really happy knowing that people I care about are enjoying themselves. Sure, I sometimes laugh at the silliness of it all, but it still makes me happy.
If someone else's joy makes you feel bad, you need to take a look at yourself.
Re:The Tyranny of Other People’s Vacation Photos (2016)
by rocqua on Saturday July 22, 2017 @11:19AM
(#14827612)
Taking a look at yourself is the issue. Self-introspection ought to include some variant of the question "Am I having enough fun". In answering this question, people take an empirical approach, looking at other results.
If what you see of other is biased, that biases your answer to that question, and thus biases your introspection towards "I should be doing better".
Re:The Tyranny of Other People’s Vacation Photos (2016)
by kodis on Saturday July 22, 2017 @11:16AM
(#14827590)
I feel the same way -- I enjoy seeing my friends having a good time. More pragmatically, I'll frequently (like, just yesterday) see someone's vacation photos and think, "hey, that looks like fun! Maybe I should plan a trip there myself."
Re:The Tyranny of Other People’s Vacation Photos (2016)
by overcast on Saturday July 22, 2017 @10:23AM
(#14827348)
We've discussed a similar topic quite a few times on HN. All of these "social" sites, are giving only the best slices of everyones life, constantly. To the point that is makes you feel as an individual, that your life is almost meaningless, and deprived. Everyone else looks like they are having the most amazing time, constantly. While you're sitting there at work, refreshing the feed on your phone. I removed myself from Facebooks/Reddits/Twitters years ago. They are plague to this generation.
Re:The Tyranny of Other People’s Vacation Photos (2016)
by dustin999 on Saturday July 22, 2017 @10:39AM
(#14827440)
The fact that so many people are posting updates an hour after starting their vacation really speaks volumes. It just goes to show, people are making decisions about vacations, events, etc. based on how well it will post on Facebook.
I think that's part of the reason ticket prices have gone through the roof for sporting events. Before, you were only motivated to go to a game based on 1) your desire to see the event live, and 2) your immediate circle of friends and family who you could tell.
Now, all of your outer circle of friends, including the people you went to school with, ex's, etc get to see how well you're living life, how successful you are, etc.
It's really quite annoying and obnoxious.
Having taken a break from social media for about 3 months now, I'm realizing just how evil it is.
E.g. new mother shares endless stream of baby photos while most of her 20-something ex-college friends/coworkers are oversaturated with it. (E.g. the sentiment that if you've seen one blob of an undifferentiated poop machine in diapers, you've seen them all.) Yes, the infant is The Most Interesting Person In The World to that mother so it seems logical to her that others would find her posted photos to be interesting too.
On a large scale, we simply have no self-awareness about our narcissism and its banality to others.
Long before the existence of the internet and Facebook in the days of film photography, hosts would torture their dinner guests by having them gather in the living room and flip through slides[1] of the hosts' vacation. The guests silently suffer through the boring presentation but of course, etiquette means nobody would dare say, "Joe, this is boring and we're going home now." Polite society on a large-scale, self-censors the expression of boredom which perversely continues the large-scale unawareness that sharing too many personal highlights is subjecting friends to cruel & unusual punishment.
[1] https://www.google.com/search?q=kodak+slide+carousel+slide+p...
Yep, I do remember some of the most fierce fights against falling asleep in those occasions.
But - to give some sociological insight - those terrible after dinners came out because of sheer convenience.
Till then there were "pictures" (not slides) that costed a lot of money to print in a decently large format, so typically you took less shots, then had them printed in a very small format, and only reprinted a handful out of each roll.
With slides the costs were a fraction, even considering the cost (rather high for today's standards) of the projector and of the carousels.
Now what if someone (not the government as it would be anti-democratic, not google as it would be a dominant position abuse, etc.) would put a minimal cost for publishing on the net these images (let's say 0.50 US$/apiece, of course devolved entirely to a non-profit/humanitariaon association)?
I would bet that in no time we would have the amount of those photos reduced to 1/20th or less.
http://www.art.net/Studios/Hackers/Hopkins/Don/text/rms-vs-d...
I'd turn this around and say, if you're annoyed by pictures of other peoples' kids or their vacations or what they ate, maybe you're the narcissistic one. In a modern world where people often move far away from friends and family to pursue careers, Facebook fills in for a lot of the shared experience that people would otherwise have. I want to see pictures of my friends baby, because I can't visit her often on the opposite coast. I want to see the latest food my father in law put in the smoker, because I can't drop in to steal a sample. I'm interested in the lives of my friends and family and Facebook let's me at least keep a bit in touch with what's happening.
I don't doubt that there are people that genuinely enjoy others' baby photos. However, I wouldn't be able to tell which comments left on each others' pages were expressions of authentic sincerity instead of mindless reflexes of etiquette.
That said, this Reddit thread[1] highlights a collective exasperation that clearly comes from somewhere.
Likewise, there are surely some who enjoy others vacation slideshows (e.g. Retric in this thread) but again, there's a widespread rejection of them[2] that comes from somewhere. People won't complaint directly to the posters face -- e.g. they won't write on the posters wall to "stop flooding the feed with your stupid vacation photos". People are generally too polite to do that.
>, maybe you're the narcissistic one.
It's not about me. It's about observing social dynamics:
1) People overestimate the parts of their personal lives that are interesting to others
2) People are silent or insincerely praise the over-sharing of others' personal highlights
Those 2 factors create a weird/interesting feedback cycle that transcends Facebook/Instagram/Snapchat. It's been happening long before that.
[1] https://www.reddit.com/r/funny/comments/rtapw/my_facebook_ne...
[2] http://www.foxnews.com/travel/2017/06/29/no-one-wants-to-see...
Clearly there are people who don't like pictures of peoples' vacations or kids enough to bitch on Reddit about it. I'd call those people narcissists. Facebook is inherently about sharing things about yourself: your kid, your vacation, your new job, your walk by the river, even your political opinions. Almost nothing posted on Facebook is not self centered in some way. That's not inherently narcissistic. What narcissistic is when you post that stuff yourself, but can't empathize with others enough not to be annoyed when they do it.
Yes, I've already acknowledge that people like you exist but it's not relevant to what I was discussing. But let's continue on that example you gave...
>if I consistently like pictures of your kid it means I want to see them on my feed.
Right... but when a person complains to her friends that "nobody 'likes' her posts", it then causes some of them to start "liking" the posts just to get her to shut up. This type of dynamic contributes to the phenomenon I'm talking about.
>Facebook is inherently about sharing things about yourself: [...] Almost nothing posted on Facebook is not self centered in some way. That's not inherently narcissistic.
You're reducing the topic to an absolutism which is not what I'm talking about even though I took great care in the first post to properly qualify the social phenomenon: over-sharing instead of just sharing and "too many personal highlights" instead of just "personal highlights". The NYT author did the same when he wrote, "_excessive_ posting of these pictures".
Yes, Facebook is inherently about sharing... just as an old slide carousel is about sharing film photos. The respective technologies' purpose is not the point.
To restate... There is a widespread social phenomenon: many of us share more than the audience wants to see. It has a perverse feedback mechanism (social grooming, white lies, polite self-censorship, self-ignorance, etc) that perpetuates the phenomenon across different media (e.g. film slides to Facebook). (This disconnect between posters' (non)curation vs audience receptiveness is also mentioned at the end of the NYT article when the author wrote, "I am trying to calibrate my photographic output. As we all should.")
I think that's interesting observation to talk about. Maybe your issue is the word "narcissism"? I used that term because that seems to have the most currency.[1] If there's a better word, make a suggestion. If bringing up the topic itself is toxic and shouldn't be discussed, please explain why.
[1] examples: https://www.google.com/search?q=digital+narcissism
I'm too old and a(media)social to know the platforms people use these days, but I guess those platforms don't lend themselves to the writing of large insightful essays. On a bus. With a phone. And I think most people won't, anyway.
I think you really need to be a certain kind of person to want to see and reply something trite to every picture of your "inner circle"; as I'm really on the other side of that spectrum, I can't really understand the motivation of the replier or happiness of the content poster. If you want to kill yourself, please come and talk to me, but please don't bore/harass me with pictures of your breakfast. I have a baby girl; I don't understand why I'd post pictures and check how many people like them. I don't see the value; (to me) it's nothing more but a social charade.
Maybe I'm too far on the autistic spectrum to be certain types of social.
Luckily, when you don't crave the attention yourself, you don't have to be part of the game.
I'd much rather look at pictures of your kids than read your "insightful essays." Most essays, even ones appearing in respectable publications, are little more than a patchwork of spin, guessing, and questionable assumptions connected with questionable reasoning.[1]
I'm probably on the other side of the spectrum, but I don't really want to hear your ideas. I want to share your human experiences. That feeling when you watch your toddler develop enough motor skills to pick up food, but not enough to put it in her mouth. The happiness at your wedding. Your pride at cooking a meal for your family. Those are the things that are real, genuine, and true.
[1] Think about how inaccurate every article you read in the press is about any scientific topic you come across. They are no more accurate about the topics you know less about. For example, this article has been making the rounds on my Facebook: https://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2017/07/canada-.... It's based entirely on a false premise: that because U.S. tax rates are lower than in Canada, U.S. public spending is lower. In reality, per-capita non-military public spending in the U.S. is quite significantly higher than in Canada. And this is a "respectable" author appearing in a "respectable" publication! This is the trash clogging up the Internet; not baby pictures.
I guess it's about your mind. I want to decipher the world, in scientific terms, and I don't care about personal angles. Yes, you have to filter a lot of opinion and filler, but I want real information. I probably could live easier without personal information at all than without interesting stuff to study.
Mind you, I'm somewhat on the autistic scale, and I am well aware that most people have a greater need for personal connection and social inclusion. I can't look at pictures of a social event and not see the mechanics behind the behaviours, like it's hard to enjoy a movie if you can't suspend disbelief. To me, a baby trying to eat is mostly just an image of neurons trying to organise. I don't understand wedding pictures because I don't understand marriage, why people have to go through a weird social routine/tradition to declare that they want to be together. I have feelings and emotions of course, but stuff gets very boring very quickly if there's no "actual" information to go with it.
One of the nice things about being away is that you're away. That you're forced out of your routine, unable to keep up with the same day-to-day stuff as usual, and cut off from your friends. It forces you to make new friends.
Travel for me used to be a good hack to overcome a natural tendency toward introversion. At some point, after not speaking to a human for a few days, I would go in to Emergency Survival Social Mode, where I had to strike up a conversation with the person at the next table right that minute just to preserve my sanity. And nearly every time I'd find that that person was going through the same thing and was thus happy to chat about whatever for a while.
That's a lot harder to do now, when everybody sitting alone at a table has their phone out, facebooking away with their friends at home as per normal.
I don't know what the solution will be. Hopefully the pendulum will swing back and people will realize that it's nice to disconnect for real from time to time. Especially when there is real sand between their toes and a real sunset going on in front of them (and a real girl sitting at the next table).
It takes a pretty dedicated introvert to not need even a little human company after a while.
But the person has no idea, hence they post oblivious to whether there are real people who actually want to see it.
They post instantly, assume everyone likes it, instant hit achieved. Due to politeness (And the subliminal voting circle) people like back at some stage.
The arguable point is whether the superficial voting circle of Facebook works and makes people happy or it's a drug we get dependent on and just need.
In the old days, there was that moment when visiting someone's house (friend, relative maybe) and the topic of family vacations came up. Then someone suggests the slide projector. You could almost feel the silent "uggh" from the people who were not on the vacation. The worst part would be the unknown length of the slide show. (ten minutes? two hours?) But setting up the slide projector was a fair effort, so it could easily be put off "until next time you come over" (phew! Dodged a bullet!)
Now you just pop them up on FB and they are there for all to see. Compound that with the fact that FB's sharing controls are so complicated that actually just sharing with a particular subset (immediate family, grandparents, etc) is nigh impossible for ordinary mortals and there you are! Bazillions of terrible family photos a click away, or worse: a scroll away, no click needed.
Physical photos did have some advantages: at least they could be avoided! ;D
If they would set up projector, you would have to either watch it or say openly you dont want to watch them. Meanwhile, on facebook you just scroll past all that. Eventually you can click on something other people post and facebook will show you more of that in the future. Moreover people typically post them in albums. If you dont click album. You dont spend time watching pictures.
Unless of course, mere remainder of existence of such thing annoys you.
Still have our old carousel with "ten best" and latest trip.
But what that also did was drastically reduce family shared memories and stories to those precious slides. Reliving again for each generation.
Now, ubiquity of photos equalize all events to the same stature and,imo, lose group family memories of those few great events (whether or not they were indeed great)
Both are perfectly usable and I can still have a social life, but it's not as effortless as just scrolling down so you tend to do it less and stop when you stop caring (well I do anyway). Definitely dialed back the background anxiety levels when I did that.
To some people is just a splinter, to others, well, you get the idea.
This is okay.
I liked her method until I realized she recorded it to put on Facebook. Almost thought it was some sort of way to cope without being on Facebook.
People ARE way too addicted to that red notification symbol.
I take a lot of photos usually, and they act as something like an extension of my memory, a journal. To show them to someone else is an intimate thing.
If someone else's joy makes you feel bad, you need to take a look at yourself.
If what you see of other is biased, that biases your answer to that question, and thus biases your introspection towards "I should be doing better".
Travel is one of a handful of subjects/topics you can start with the range from total stranger to yourself.
People love to talk travel and it often allows them to be brought out. In this day and age of sides, travel has none
The others are weather and genealogy
I think that's part of the reason ticket prices have gone through the roof for sporting events. Before, you were only motivated to go to a game based on 1) your desire to see the event live, and 2) your immediate circle of friends and family who you could tell.
Now, all of your outer circle of friends, including the people you went to school with, ex's, etc get to see how well you're living life, how successful you are, etc.
It's really quite annoying and obnoxious.
Having taken a break from social media for about 3 months now, I'm realizing just how evil it is.