Ask HN: Stay or Leave? SoundCloud has deferred salary reviews
Over the last few years, travel between offices has been restricted to business critical travel only. More expensive food items have started disappearing from our kitchen.
Employees used to get a small bottle of champagne on their birthdays & employment anniversaries. This doesn't happen anymore.
All of the above feels reasonable.
However, they recently announced that the July 1 salary review that everyone was promised will be deferred. There is no information about back pay or a date about when the next salary review will happen.
Salary increases are predicated on the next round of funding. They anticipate that the round will close over the next couple of months, if not weeks.
I'm sure that everyone here will have been in similar situations before.
What did you do? And, how did you decide whether to continue working or start looking for other opportunities.
Also, what other arrangements, we, as employees should consider putting forward.
Example: I'd be okay working 4 days weeks, until the salary review is complete.
What questions should we ask our founders that'll help us build confidence that the company's financials are in a reasonable shape?
The company is obviously facing a cash crunch, but to me this is the key bit and why I would start shopping my resume if I were in your shoes. Management will have known about the cash crunch or should at least have anticipated it was a possibility for a while now, and should not have set expectations that they were unlikely to meet. The rest of the actions look like prudent cost-cutting measures, but if you can't trust that management will honor their promises today what guarantees do you have that they will do so in the future?
As a non-founder (i.e. very low equity upside), it's not for you to make compromises to keep their high-upside baby alive. Put your own interests first and find an employer that doesn't require you to subsidize their growth.
Also, if I had a dollar for every time a founder has told me that funding is coming in "months, if not weeks" .... well, you can guess the rest.
Maybe communicate earlier hmmm?
That would be better management rather than hold my beer I'll probably close this round while I risk the livelihoods and futures of my rank and file.
(I'm only speaking in general, not specific to this situation.)
Here's a tweaked version. If you can't get a raise, you have a problem. If a company can't pay its employees market rate, the company has a problem.
I pretty firmly believe that if money is tight at a company, paying fewer people more money (and setting higher expectations around performance) is the way to go. Otherwise you end up with top talent leaving and those left feel entitled to not give 100% (because they aren't being paid 100%).
If it was my company and I was having a bump in the road with funding I would hope for it not to immediately hit the front page of HN for the sake of a few weeks.
Soundcloud actually have a good reputation as an employer so maybe they deserve a small benefit of the doubt? I get the mercenary attitude but it's only potentially a few weeks or months for an incremental pay rise, not as if they are going under....
I suspect this won't be a popular point of view but I like to think company and employee owe each other at least a modicum of loyalty.
The company will not think twice if the have to fire an employee - why should the employee feel guilty about doing the same.
You can easily send an application a week or two to places you find really interesting without the "need money for food" feeling.
Also make this a yearly habit, so you stay on the ball, know where the market is at, and become comfortable leaving at a moment's notice to avoid this life changing anxiety you might be feeling.
Once you do it regularly, it's no big deal. Companies hire and fire dozens of people a year, it shouldn't be that different for you.
I assume you have a valid contract that says you work X hours for Y amount, what makes you think you're not bound to that just because you don't get to talk about a possible (!) raise?
It's up to you if you interpret the company's behaviour as a red flag and leave, but reducing your working hours because you don't get your regular fix of more money seems like a sense of entitlement to me.
As a side note, your post would have worked just as well without publicly shaming your employer.
(I am not affiliated with SoundCloud, except for the coincidence that one of my previous companies used to share an office with them.)
He can try to negotiate whatever he wants, for example working only 4 hours per day, or 3 days a week, or ... but the employer is not forced to agree.
However there is no reason to panic yet. It is likely they will raise again.
Meanwhile you can use your energy to prepare yourself. Get your resume and LinkedIn put together. Make sure your personal finances are secure and can handle 3-6 months with no income (standard advice for everyone). Start inquiring about what other companies would be worth working for.
If you have a plan to handle the downside risk, this will be less terrifying and more of a business like decision of the merits of staying or going.
Once you can feel safe walking away then you can negotiate a better structure if you want the extra time. It is important to have the walk away plan as your BATNA when negotiating.
http://dealwhisperers.blogspot.com/2015/07/a-million-dollar-...
In this case, find a friend at Google/Apple/whatever and ask them if you can have some employee-only branded stuff.
I'd certainly start the usual job-hunting process: updating my CV, mentioning to friends that I may be open to a new position, breaking out the ol' whiteboard for algorithm interview practice, going to meetups etc.
Also, prepare yourself for being laid-off, financially and mentally. It sucks, but it's the reality of startup life.
Don't worry about questioning the founders - it's their job to be upbeat and optimistic to get the best result for their startup, but it's your responsibility to look after your career. But that doesn't necessarily mean giving up the day job - hope for the best, prepare for the worst.
Also, nothing in your contract or offer letter would have said that the company would do a salary review every year.
When such a decision is made, companies are aware that what could happen, the way salary review is important for an employee, in equal measure it is important for the company too.
So if such a decision is made, they weighed in every thing, may be the fact also that, people might leave or they would look for another option.
And the company also knows that people who would have options are the good people, and no one wants to let go the good people and being left with average or above average people later, when the finances are sorted.
If you love what you do, stick with SoundCloud, it's just part of life and could happen anywhere.
PS: I have been through this once.
> What questions should we ask our founders that'll help us build confidence that the company's financials are in a reasonable shape?
... there is no question you can ask anyone that will help SoundCloud from burning money. Building confidence is just an act of faith, but this won't solve the underlying issue that SoundCloud does not have a viable business model, at least, with it's current corporate structure and business model. Don't get fooled by cheerleading VCs and CEOs, it's the oldest trick in the book. Always at the expense of employees and other stakeholders.
Many people join startup-land with the impression that these multi-(b)million, VC-funded companies are as safe as joining other old-school corporate companies which apparently are going to be disrupted by those very startups. Some other people joining startup-land are aware of this issue, and they will be the first to jump ship. All I can suggest is that you start looking for other opportunities, just in case. Do not get fixated on the back pay date, etc... just move on.
There's no way I'd make the same mistake today. No pay, no work. If I want to do work without being paid for it I'll get a hobby. While I might enjoy what I'm working on for you, YOUR dream is not my hobby. If I was a founder and the company went through tough times, I'd gladly work it for free because of the upside potential, but not as employee number 5 with 0.1% equity. No way, no how.
Of the things you mention, there seem to be two primary concerns.
One is that you definitely won't get a raise until a new round of funding comes in, and even if that funding does arrive I assume a raise is not a guarantee. We obviously aren't aware of your status or current and past performance. We also aren't aware of how much you are making now, and whether that amount is perhaps at the higher end or lower end of market rate already.
Two is that the company seems to be having at least some financial concerns.
You've also told us "they anticipate that the round will close over the next couple of months, if not weeks". That sounds optimistic. Being that the next salary review isn't for a couple weeks, it sounds as if this entire thing could be about nothing.
If you like your job enough where not getting a raise is OK for at least a few months, you should stay.
Beyond liking your job, are you still learning? Are you becoming better at what you do year after year by staying there? If the answer is "no" to either of those questions, you should probably leave regardless of salary raises and free champagne.
You should always be prepared for the worst, of course, so if an event (layoff, closure) were to happen you should always want to be in a position to start looking for work quickly.
I don't think suggesting a 4 day work week due to an incomplete salary review is a good option. That suggests that you may have anticipated a 20% raise, which isn't all that realistic. Making unrealistic demands of a cash-strapped company could be a quick way to a layoff.
I'm not sure at this point it's even relevant to ask the founders any questions. They seem to be forthcoming about things - it's not like they told you there will be no salary reviews the day before they were scheduled to happen, and if they have been trustworthy in the past you should have no reason to doubt their honesty now about their expected timeline for the next round to close.
When should one start looking for jobs? There are lots of reasons. If you are not fairly compensated for what you do and there are no other 'upsides' to your employment that make staying a good option. When you aren't learning or challenged by what you do. When you feel work is having a consistent negative impact on other parts of your life. When your company clearly makes decisions that do not consider the best interests of their employees.
Good luck to you.
If you're financially stable, enjoying your time and continuing to learn, stick around. It may be an informative experience for the future. Plus, you may have opportunities to take on new projects if other employees leave.
In the background, it can't hurt to sharpen your resume and start talking to friends about their companies in the event that you do have to depart SoundCloud.
Came here to say this. Missing a 3-5% raise and cutting your work hours by 20% is a petty over-reaction, both practically and mathematically.
(Mathematically, that would be the even-money proposition if you expected a 25% raise.)
As user bspn has said before, this is a bad sign. If the company has good financial management, they have seen this coming and chose to inform its employees very late (which is bad). If the company did not see it coming, they have bad financial management (which is also bad).
So yes, from an objective point of view it surely cannot hurt to start looking somewhere else.
No, because I've only worked for businesses that make money.
Your reply was intentionally snarky at best; obnoxiously insulting, demeaning and entirely non-useful at worst.
Yes -- I think it's worth pointing out the upsides of this option to counter the breathless startup optimism I routinely see on this site.
It won't hurt to get a sense about the current job market, what interesting companies are hiring and what are salaries for positions with your level of experience.
You will find out whether you are underpaid or not (working for a startup you very likely are) and then decide based on that.
all startups have risks. i think that's something people overlook and they tend to think about the non-corporate atmosphere. anyways, that being said, i think it boils down to if you believe in the future of the company.
if you believe in the company's plan and you're willing to stick it out, great! imo, you should expect to hear an explanation of a company/product strategy _you_ believe has a chance.
if you don't believe it has a chance, well, i imagine you are sticking around for other personal or professional reasons. that could be because the opportunity you are getting (with specific tech, roles, etc) that you believe will help get you to where you want to be. it doesn't have to be about money.
if genuine promises were broken, that makes it tough to trust the folks that you are likely looking to for said strategy and plan.
They aren't profitable and trying to get another round of funding. Only in the world of tech would that even be a question.
so understand they have to be mindful/careful on frivolities.
If you gave a 100 million to the company, would you be annoyed if you found out about people getting small champagne bottles on their birthday? Would you be worried about your investment?
The days of these companies building floor to floor slides, and pampering adult children was never going to last. Whats there to worry about?
Saying all this of course, if the Mgmt are still getting these perks (wasting money), while the employees are not, id leave.
That ship will hit the rocks very soon, and hard. And of course, it wont be the first company to get done under with high budget pay/perks for low budget mgmt.
Before my entrepreneurial journey I was working for a startup as a developer , I sticked there around for 5 years. For the last 3 years of the company existence I voluntarily gave up 20% of my salary and worked my ass off, simply because of being loyal and caring for the organization.
I work hard to create a sense of commitment and loyalty in my current start up, and during the recruiting process we pay a super attention to don't hire people who are looking for just money and are easy to abandon a ship during a crisis.
I work hard to feed my family. I can't give my baby a bottle of loyalty before she goes to bed.
How loyal are you to your employees? If they come to you and say, "sorry, I can only work four days a week from now on, but I want you to keep paying me the same" - would you willingly give up 20% of your employees' time simply because of being loyal and caring for the organization?
If loyalty during a crisis is valuable to your business but you do not intend to compensate people for that loyalty, do you know what that's called? Exploitation.
If you really don't feel like loyalty is something to be bought or sold, then you'd better make sure that whatever voluntary loyalty you expect from your employees is reciprocated by you, the employer. Like, assurances that layoffs are off the table, etc. But even that's not ideal, because it could put you in a position where you have to sacrifice the business rather than go back on your word.
But I don't really understand it. There are so many good places to work, being paid what I'm worth at a different place seems like a better deal.
I'll take a pay cut for more equity if I want it, not for nothing.
If I take risk, I get rewarded with ownership, but if I'm paid cash, why do I honestly care what happens to a company.
This isn't some fairytale, we're all here to get paid, and employees aren't your buffer for bad cash flow management, that's the responsibility of owners and management.
When cash is getting low two choices. Paycuts or firings. Pros and cons to both.
In the OP sounds like they arent that drastic yet. Just no raises. Seems not that dire all things considered.
Let me spell out the compact that undergirds capitalism: employees don't take risks and are paid a constant stream of cash, owner's do take risk, and it is up to them to ensure there is enough capital buffer to meet their constant stream obligations. Employees do the work, management/owners ensure they get paid.
Got it. Sounds like good decision making.
While there are certainly things to worry about, this is not a case of employees not being paid.
It's just when you've got neither of these perks that you should start searching - because if you don't have that side either, you could as well go to a high paying corporate job. And then I'm on the side of the employees: Loyalty is important, but it's not a one-way street.
Loyalty always seems to flow upwards in companies like you describe, where employees are expected to sacrifice during the hard times, but the company doesn't reciprocate during the good times.
I work hard in my job to fulfill the requirements I agreed to during the negotiation, but if the company can't or won't hold up it's end of the bargain, expecting me to continue to do so without compensation is just predatory behavior.
This is the business world, and the employer-employee relationship is a business relationship. Anyone who tells you otherwise is usually trying to take advantage of you.
However, understanding the mindset of startup CEOs is interesting. Particularly the mindset of the minority of CEOs who are able to raise money (again, not saying I agree, but VCs select for particular personality types).
But, I doubt the majority of the workforce (even the really good motivated people) out there agree with you. The level of commitment you're talking about isn't what I'd expect form an employee. It's more what I'd expect from a cofounder.