Personally, I think the poster suggesting that Amazon may start lobbying for basically welfare, is onto something. What if they lobbied for a massive redistribution scheme where half the excess/arbitrageous profits made by the 0.001% are redistributed to the 99.999% in the form of Amazon store credit and only Amazon store credit?
Since that is either already, or will inevitably be, the single most efficient distribution network by which you could get goods and resources to the populace in a market system?
What? Granted an overnight transition could cause disruption, but in a few months, what couldn't be replaced? Gmail? GMaps? Android? Youtube? Search+Adwords+GAnalytics? GCE? their CDN could be the worst, maybe? they all already have big competitors, and since Google's quality is minimal, it wouldn't be that hard to switch over. But you need a motivated company, i.e. just a little more effort than OpenStreetMaps or FastMail.
IBM, Sears (far more dominant in retail in its day than Amazon is today), General Motors (hi Toyota), US Steel (hi foreign steel), Pan-Am (hyper powerful at its peak), Alcoa (anti-trust + foreign competition), and a dozen others that were every bit as powerful as Amazon at their peak.
Oh and Walmart is slowly being replaced by Amazon. Walmart is/was the most dominant retailer in world history.
I think it's difficult to find any single X that makes "if a company is bad at X, it will be replaced by competitors" a consistently true statement, without X being essentially synonymous with "succeeding".
Kodak
Polaroid
Blockbuster
Research in Motion / Blackberry
Motorola
Nokia
Sun Microsystems
Yahoo
Is this really true though? Over the past few decades we've seen that if a company is big enough, and it fails, the government will step in and prop it up with a bailout.
IIRC most of the companies in the S&P 500 didn't exist 30 years ago. I think the DJIA is mostly companies that are younger than I am. The US has an unusually dynamic economy. Bailing out companies is reserved for politically important ones (GM, Ford) or politically and financially important ones.
However, if we achieve the momentum necessary to reform voting in the United States, it would be a shame to squander that momentum to receive IRV rather than an easier and better model such as Score voting or Approval voting.
More on the matter: http://electology.org/approval-voting-versus-irv
The best answer is Star voting (Score Then Auto-Runoff), which just does one instant runoff between top scoring candidates, thus counting everyone's scores equally. See http://www.equal.vote for details
This problem (the inconsistency in general, not the cultural variation though that underlined the problem) makes STAR and other score-based methods utterly unsuitable for most public elections.
If you want to fix the problems caused by loser elimination in IRV, just drop loser elimination and accept as winner the candidate who gets past the bare-majority threshold first as you check first all first preference votes, then total of first and second preference votes, and so on.
No, you completely misunderstand. There's no universal reference for what scores "mean". You can give candidates from, say 0-5 stars in terms of how much support you want to give them in the race. That's it. 5 = most support, 0 = no support. It's ONLY relative to the actual pool of candidates in the election. People can just learn to understand this clear fact, and ballots can be marked as such as "least support" to "full support". And educating people about this is easier than educating them about IRV and all it's weirdness (and more honest than making false claims about IRV). There are NO cultural issues or biases or problems here in terms of what a score "means".
> If you want to fix the problems caused by loser elimination in IRV…
I don't know what you mean here, but it isn't IRV, it's some other rank system. Tons have been proposed, none are perfect, all are far harder to calculate and understand than Star voting. Ranked Pairs is actually pretty good, probably the best way to handle ranked ballots. I'm not sure what you're proposing.
Now, democracy is supposed to fix this, by allowing you to vote for a different supplier of government every few years. But because of the voting system in some countries (like the US and the UK) it's actually really hard to do this, because everything gets turned into a black/white struggle between opposing forces, rather than lots of options being available for you make a choice between.