News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Swiss leaks and Panama papers open a window on the ta... by ChuckMcM on Thursday June 01, 2017 @03:36PM (#14463713)
It is an interesting data point. If it is consistent then increasing tax compliance on the 1% would be sufficent to boost overall tax revenues by close to 4%. (caveat they just decide to become Canadians :-)
Re:The Swiss leaks and Panama papers open a window on the ta... by tdeck on Thursday June 01, 2017 @06:55PM (#14465683)
This is exactly where we're at. The CBO has estimated that every additional dollar spent on IRS enforcement would yield an average $2 of additional revenue, increasing to over $6 by 2018 [1]. But certain political factions (can you guess which ones?) have, as a matter of policy, intentionally starved the IRS of funding to prevent them from enforcing compliance and collecting taxes.

[1]: Page 32, https://www.cbo.gov/sites/default/files/114th-congress-2015-...

Re:The Swiss leaks and Panama papers open a window on the ta... by antognini on Friday June 02, 2017 @12:06AM (#14467380)
I guess the thing that worries me is how would I know that the increased enforcement budget would actually go towards the ultra-rich? I make a middle-class income, not enough that it really makes sense to hire an accountant. The tax code is complicated enough that I'm sure I screwed up somewhere doing my taxes --- I just try to muddle my way through it as best I can year after year. I'm sure the IRS could get more money harassing thousands of people like me instead of a single ultra-wealthy individual since we don't have the resources to fight the IRS but the ultra-wealthy do.
Re:The Swiss leaks and Panama papers open a window on the ta... by croon on Friday June 02, 2017 @07:11AM (#14469034)
I really understand your frustration and uncertainty, and to be frank; you don't know for sure that the IRS would chase after rich people.

But let me float this: Guess which parties/party wanted the tax code that complicated to begin with? The first step to fixing it would be to not align yourself with the ones who caused the issue.

Simpler tax code would make it less worrysome for regular plebs (us) to fill out our taxes, meaning the lower/middle class that pays their taxes would ensure they weren't in danger, and IRS would have an easier time chasing down tax avoiders.

The people who complicated the tax codes and also wants to uninsure tens of millions of people to save a few bucks for rich people won't help you.

Re:The Swiss leaks and Panama papers open a window on the ta... by ethbro on Friday June 02, 2017 @08:32AM (#14469358)
The problem I have with the tax simplification folks is that they're generally disingenuous about the fact that they're proposing moving from a progressive to a much flatter tax code. Or at least ignorant about the differences.

I'm sure a lot of the language and ideas they're parroting are coming from conservative talk radio, hence the blind spots. But it really soured me on the US tax simplification debate.

Re:The Swiss leaks and Panama papers open a window on the ta... by croon on Friday June 02, 2017 @08:39AM (#14469389)
> The problem I have with the tax simplification folks is that they're generally disingenuous about the fact that they're proposing moving from a progressive to a much flatter tax code. Or at least ignorant about the differences.

Whole heartedly agree. Simplification and flatter tax code should be separate discussions, with separate conclusions.

Re:The Swiss leaks and Panama papers open a window on the ta... by logfromblammo on Friday June 02, 2017 @01:19PM (#14471659)
Here's a simple, progressive income tax:

1. IRS determines the median for personal income (total household income divided by household size), and publishes it no later than January 1.

2. Your taxable income is your household income minus the published median from #1 times the number of people in your household. If this is less than or equal to zero, pay no tax.

3. Those with positive taxable income pay x% of that amount as tax, with x set according to the requirements of the previous year's budget, but not to exceed a statutory limit of y%.

If you take the median income as a proxy for spending, this tax thus approximates a flat tax on the annual increase in household wealth.

Re:The Swiss leaks and Panama papers open a window on the ta... by brewdad on Saturday June 03, 2017 @12:44AM (#14475048)
The thing is, you can greatly simplify the tax code and still have progressive tax brackets. Looking up the total amount due in the back of the tax booklet (or more realistically having software calculate the total due) is the easy part of doing one's taxes.

Cut out the various deductions and credits and additions to income etc. to make things simple. Then calculating tax due becomes a simple table lookup or addition of amounts from multiple tables. 3rd grade math. We don't need to set a single universal x% tax rate to make things easy.

Re:The Swiss leaks and Panama papers open a window on the ta... by logfromblammo on Monday June 05, 2017 @10:25AM (#14487796)
Consider that the only reason we have "tax brackets" is because many people apparently cannot be relied upon to calculate the results of an intractably complex polynomial function such as f(x) = 0.40x - c or a choice function like MAX( f(x), 0 ).
Re:The Swiss leaks and Panama papers open a window on the ta... by Frondo on Friday June 02, 2017 @11:58AM (#14470846)
Perfect, yes, excellent distinction.

I'm all in favor of a vastly simpler tax code, but I'm also in favor of a vastly more progressive tax code. These two things aren't in opposition to one another.

Re:The Swiss leaks and Panama papers open a window on the ta... by njarboe on Friday June 02, 2017 @12:16PM (#14471022)
At this point a flat income tax rate would be more progressive at the top end than the current system, especially if you wrap in medicare and social security taxes. Maybe start with a flat tax and move from there.
Re:The Swiss leaks and Panama papers open a window on the ta... by BatFastard on Friday June 02, 2017 @12:56PM (#14471402)
A flat tax by its vary nature and NOT be progressive. And even with how broken the tax code is, a flat tax still places a totally unfair burden on the poor.

If you take 20% of 20,000 bucks your tax on me is 4k which only leaves me 16k to live on (You would be extremely poor in US). 20% of 200k is 40k, which leaves me 160k to live on.

Re:The Swiss leaks and Panama papers open a window on the ta... by lern_too_spel on Friday June 02, 2017 @07:29PM (#14473974)
Return free filing, the ultimate in tax simplification, is also opposed by the politicians who claim to be for tax simplification. You could set up a progressive tax code in a way that requires computing non-trivial integrals, but as long as the math is done by the IRS, it would still be simpler than what we have today.
Re:The Swiss leaks and Panama papers open a window on the ta... by EliRivers on Friday June 02, 2017 @11:02AM (#14470382)
I suppose the market driven way would be to put IRS tax inspectors on commission. Perhaps above a certain amount per target; maybe for every extra dollar above six figures they bring in from "one" [1] individual, they can keep half.

[1] Where "one" is a bit of a fuzzy concept when you're dealing with multi-millionaires hiding their wealth through various shenanigans.

Re:The Swiss leaks and Panama papers open a window on the ta... by tdeck on Friday June 02, 2017 @01:00AM (#14467569)
Agreed, I know the feeling well. It's a crazy mess of a system where people with very straightforward sources of income and deductions end up unsure every year whether they've done their tax returns right. This is why other countries just fill them out for you.
Re:The Swiss leaks and Panama papers open a window on the ta... by 24gttghh on Thursday June 01, 2017 @08:59PM (#14466581)
And also from that presentation:

>CBO projected a drop in the ROI after 2018 as taxpayers found new ways to evade taxes.

I mean, damn.

Re:The Swiss leaks and Panama papers open a window on the ta... by zeveb on Friday June 02, 2017 @06:40PM (#14473803)
Do you have any faith that an IRS with more funding wouldn't just target foes of the party currently in power?
Re:The Swiss leaks and Panama papers open a window on the ta... by microcolonel on Thursday June 01, 2017 @07:49PM (#14466116)
I mean, AFAIK technically taxes are voluntary. Is the IRS really under mandate to "enforce" taxation?
Re:The Swiss leaks and Panama papers open a window on the ta... by dpark on Thursday June 01, 2017 @07:51PM (#14466139)
> AFAIK technically taxes are voluntary.

You are incorrect as a large number of would-be tax avoiders can attest.

e.g. Mr. Snipes

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wesley_Snipes

Re:The Swiss leaks and Panama papers open a window on the ta... by tdeck on Thursday June 01, 2017 @09:15PM (#14466672)
Or my personal favorite, Kent Hovind, who actually maintains those taxes were voluntary:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kent_Hovind

Re:The Swiss leaks and Panama papers open a window on the ta... by seanp2k2 on Thursday June 01, 2017 @10:13PM (#14466920)
Wow, what a read. There are two certainties in this life: death and taxes. Some people try to unsuccessfully avoid one or both :)
Re:The Swiss leaks and Panama papers open a window on the ta... by devoply on Thursday June 01, 2017 @10:44PM (#14467044)
Well income tax was magically mandated without any sort of discussion so there's that. In the end the question is a question of hard power. If you have none, you are in no position to bargain. IMO giving government taxes that are used for purposes that may not agree with your personal sense of responsibility and morality may itself be immoral, for instance if the government uses your taxes to start wars you want nothing to do with. For infrastructure and education though they are fine regardless. They are always tooting the horns of voting with your dollars, in this case where is the voice of voting with your dollars as to what gets done with your money. /rant.
Re:The Swiss leaks and Panama papers open a window on the ta... by dpark on Friday June 02, 2017 @12:13AM (#14467411)
> Well income tax was magically mandated without any sort of discussion so there's that.

The nation literally passed a constitutional amendment specifically to allow direct, unapportioned income tax.

Re:The Swiss leaks and Panama papers open a window on the ta... by Ntrails on Friday June 02, 2017 @05:59AM (#14468756)
There's a wonderful old sitcom called "The Goode Life" where one of the characters walks in to the council offices to pay her council tax and proceeds to itemize and declare which services she is unwilling to pay for as they were unsatisfactory...
Re:The Swiss leaks and Panama papers open a window on the ta... by caf on Thursday June 01, 2017 @11:54PM (#14467311)
That seems redundant when you can vote with your... vote.

(Also: the sixteenth amendment?)

Re:The Swiss leaks and Panama papers open a window on the ta... by devoply on Friday June 02, 2017 @12:09AM (#14467396)
When you vote, you are not voting for anything or anyone substantial. Party A and Party B have the exact same policies with simply different political tones and groups of elites that they support.

The 16th amendment was adopted on February 3, 1913. Good to read its history: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sixteenth_Amendment_to_the_Uni... and how controversy still stands despite a century of litigation.

Re:The Swiss leaks and Panama papers open a window on the ta... by dpark on Friday June 02, 2017 @12:17AM (#14467430)
> The 16th amendment was adopted on February 3, 1913.

Yes. 4 years after congress passed the amendment, it was ratified by the 36th state and adopted. In no way was this "magically mandated without any sort of discussion".

Re:The Swiss leaks and Panama papers open a window on the ta... by wmil on Friday June 02, 2017 @01:04PM (#14471490)
But you can also vote in primaries where there's a wider array of candidates. Plus many elections have ballot measures enabling you to vote for or against specific items.

You're just unwilling to admit that your views aren't broadly popular.

Re:The Swiss leaks and Panama papers open a window on the ta... by enraged_camel on Friday June 02, 2017 @11:23AM (#14470542)
>>Party A and Party B have the exact same policies

No they don't.

Re:The Swiss leaks and Panama papers open a window on the ta... by microcolonel on Thursday June 01, 2017 @08:13PM (#14466299)
Wasn't it the falsified returns which generated the charges though?
Re:The Swiss leaks and Panama papers open a window on the ta... by dpark on Thursday June 01, 2017 @11:52PM (#14467306)
No. He was convicted of failing to file returns.
Re:The Swiss leaks and Panama papers open a window on the ta... by tdeck on Friday June 02, 2017 @12:57AM (#14467552)
Furthermore, he produced videos instructing the viewer on how he avoided paying income tax [1], then sold those videos. For income. That he didn't report.

[1]: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jL-F4-RDNz4

Re:The Swiss leaks and Panama papers open a window on the ta... by dahoraTSUNAMI on Thursday June 01, 2017 @10:35PM (#14467008)
You are confusing practice, or customary, with technical (constitutional law), which I would include political philosphy and the unalienable rights of man as identified by Rosseu.

If I cannot choose to not pay taxes, then I have been denied the right to choose, then it is a forced subjugation of my free will. Correct would be to give my taxes voluntarily, according to my disposition and agreement with the government.

If you are profoundly 'contra' what the government is doing, then how can you be forced to help with activities that you believe to be deeply detrimental to the well-being of yourself, others, and all life on earth and beyond?

Tolstoy argues this point very well in his book "The Kingdom of God is Within You." He essentially says that if we pay taxes to a government that kills innocents or tortures Arabs their blood is on our (the taxpayers') hands.

If the government is doing something that I find to be deplorable then I have the moral obligation to find a way to avoid contributing to such array of horrors.

Re:The Swiss leaks and Panama papers open a window on the ta... by croon on Friday June 02, 2017 @07:22AM (#14469079)
> If you are profoundly 'contra' what the government is doing, then how can you be forced to help with activities that you believe to be deeply detrimental to the well-being of yourself, others, and all life on earth and beyond?

Because you participate in society and its infrastructure and services, paid for by taxes.

I'm sure there are uninhabited tundras where no one will bother you.

Re:The Swiss leaks and Panama papers open a window on the ta... by jrochkind1 on Friday June 02, 2017 @12:42AM (#14467501)
No, you are confusing philosophy with law.
Re:The Swiss leaks and Panama papers open a window on the ta... by clock_tower on Thursday June 01, 2017 @08:05PM (#14466249)
"Voluntary" is an old-fashioned term of art; it means "you volunteer your version of events to the information to the IRS" rather than "the IRS sends you what they know".
Re:The Swiss leaks and Panama papers open a window on the ta... by notyourwork on Thursday June 01, 2017 @07:59PM (#14466202)
I guess you can say lots of things are technically voluntary. I suppose you can say if you choose not to volunteer there may be consequences.
Re:The Swiss leaks and Panama papers open a window on the ta... by pm90 on Thursday June 01, 2017 @04:10PM (#14464061)
I'm not even joking when I say: I really hope they do. These are the kinds of people who buy into Koch's philosophy (as opposed to Gates' philosophy). Once this country is rid of Dark money, the political system might finally start serving its citizens, and not just its wealthy citizens.
Re:The Swiss leaks and Panama papers open a window on the ta... by ChuckMcM on Thursday June 01, 2017 @04:28PM (#14464266)
Interestingly enough, if there really is a 30% gap in compliance, then I expect that there is enough money in increased tax collections to take a 1% management fee off the top and fund an accounting & legal organization that would be required to "do the taxes" of the .1%.
Re:The Swiss leaks and Panama papers open a window on the ta... by emodendroket on Thursday June 01, 2017 @04:31PM (#14464306)
It has been known for quite a while now that cutting the budget of the IRS is actually a money loser.
Re:The Swiss leaks and Panama papers open a window on the ta... by Sharlin on Thursday June 01, 2017 @04:40PM (#14464437)
Has someone actually proposed that it's a net money gain to cut the budget of the entity that's supposed to enforce taxation?! Sounds like an idea only slightly less stupid than reducing the budget of the police so as to reduce crime...
Re:The Swiss leaks and Panama papers open a window on the ta... by logfromblammo on Thursday June 01, 2017 @05:27PM (#14464961)
...which has actually been tried successfully.

The usual story is that the incorporated municipality dissolves its police department and then contracts with the county sheriff for less money. Then reported crime goes down. This is in large part because there was not a crime problem in the first place, and the local police were simply issuing citations all day, to collect the fines that paid for the police to issue citations. A more minor component is that smaller crimes may go unreported because it is less convenient to report them.

It only makes sense to cut the budget of the tax enforcement agency if it costs more than one unit to collect an additional one unit of taxes, which is currently not the case for the IRS.

Re:The Swiss leaks and Panama papers open a window on the ta... by RobertoG on Friday June 02, 2017 @03:44AM (#14468200)
"It only makes sense to cut the budget of the tax enforcement agency if it costs more than one unit to collect an additional one unit of taxes, which is currently not the case for the IRS."

You are assuming that the only function of enforcing taxes is to get money (1).

We can presume that honest taxpayers would feel like fools if taxes were not enforced in a assertive way. That would be a thread to social cohesion.

(1)- In fact, I dispute that the function of taxes is to get money, but I will leave that polemic discussion for other day.

Re:The Swiss leaks and Panama papers open a window on the ta... by logfromblammo on Friday June 02, 2017 @11:13AM (#14470463)
I would naturally assume that if it cost the IRS more than $1 to collect a marginal $1 in revenue, that the purpose of the agency would be to intimidate and terrorize taxpayers, and would therefore call for the agency to be abolished, rather than just have its budget reduced. Additionally, I question the utility of taxes that cost more to enforce than the revenues they bring in. Those are things that the public should not acquiesce to, anyway.

My tinfoil-hat self adamantly asserts that the purpose of the income tax is not to collect revenue, but to control the side-effects to the inflationary monetary policy that is the real source of revenue for the federal government. That self somehow sees a significant difference between spending money after it was collected via taxation and spending debt that is later discharged via taxation. Whenever that self starts ranting about the great Keynesian confidence game, my other selves generally cram it back into the penalty box for a while.

Re:The Swiss leaks and Panama papers open a window on the ta... by emodendroket on Friday June 02, 2017 @09:52PM (#14474520)
You think that any attempts to prevent tax evasion are tyrannical? Why even have laws if you're not going to bother enforcing any of them?

The idea that the government's primary means of paying for things is printing currency is perhaps true if you just stepped out of a time machine from the early 19th Century, but it has little to do with how the government works today. If that were actually how the government ran inflation would be well into the double digits (if not higher), as you could see by referring to any historical examples of governments trying to do this.

Re:The Swiss leaks and Panama papers open a window on the ta... by logfromblammo on Monday June 05, 2017 @12:43PM (#14489037)
Sometimes, taxes are imposed as a substitute for a law, especially when such a law would not be possible.

For instance, poll taxes were routinely used as a substitute for laws banning black Americans from voting.

Attempts to punish tax evasion that are more costly to pursue than the revenues generated from the tax being evaded are tyrannical. The cost-benefit analysis makes it clear that the tax in question is a lever to control people rather than a means of raising revenue for some particular purpose.

Please don't try to argue with my foil-hatted self. I have tried it on occasion, and it just never works. Better for me to just cram it into a locked compartment of my brain, and only let it out for entertainment purposes. But even my more rational personality components can detect the odor of trimethylamine in the Federal Reserve-Treasury relationship.

Perhaps it is because I can still hear foil-hat tapping on the pipes when it is locked up, but the manner in which the government measures inflation and publishes inflation statistics is not entirely honest. Look into price indices [0], and in particular, the price indices that US policymakers use [1] [2]. It is clear that they choose to use measures that understate real inflation. Furthermore, they occasionally change the method of calculation, without putting hard breaks in all the time series graphs. That can cause the index to further understate inflation. That isn't to say that you should believe the favorite sites of fearmongers and gold-hawkers (i.e. ShadowStats) either. Be skeptical of anyone trying to tell you what your money is worth.

Trying to track money through the government is more than a full-time job, and would be a boring and infuriating hobby for an amateur. As such, few people can perceive how their taxes become... well, anything. In that environment, tax evasion frequently becomes rationalized as a victimless crime, and political corruption grows in the spaces where no one ever looks.

Transparency and open records would go further to prevent tax evasion than any number of law enforcers hunting down those people that attempt it, as would simply dropping those taxes that cost more to collect than they bring in.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Price_index

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_Consumer_Price_I...

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Personal_consumption_expenditu...

Re:The Swiss leaks and Panama papers open a window on the ta... by emodendroket on Thursday June 01, 2017 @09:28PM (#14466743)
Not only have they argued that but they have repeatedly carried it out. Do they really believe what they're saying? That I'm more skeptical of. http://www.cbpp.org/research/federal-budget/trump-budget-con...
Re:The Swiss leaks and Panama papers open a window on the ta... by wyager on Friday June 02, 2017 @12:02AM (#14467364)
Money loser for the government, money gain for society. Money spent on bureaucracy is money not spent towards more productive ends.
Re:The Swiss leaks and Panama papers open a window on the ta... by mfringel on Friday June 02, 2017 @10:26AM (#14470113)
Please explain how society is completely disjoint from government, such that a zero-sum assertion is possible.
Re:The Swiss leaks and Panama papers open a window on the ta... by wyager on Saturday June 03, 2017 @01:58AM (#14475214)
If the money were spend by market forces rather than government dictate, the funds that go to hire IRS bureaucrats would instead go towards more productive ends, like the production of food or snowmobiles. In other words, instead of wasting human productive capacity on bureaucracy, the people currently employed by the IRS would instead have to find jobs useful to society.

It's not zero-sum at all. The amount of money is zero-sum (obviously), but net social utility isn't zero-sum. That's the point.

Re:The Swiss leaks and Panama papers open a window on the ta... by emodendroket on Friday June 02, 2017 @10:04AM (#14469939)
Taxes evaded mean programs not funded.
Re:The Swiss leaks and Panama papers open a window on the ta... by jacquesm on Thursday June 01, 2017 @05:12PM (#14464791)
You'll find quite a bit of support for that viewpoint in Greece.
Re:The Swiss leaks and Panama papers open a window on the ta... by arethuza on Friday June 02, 2017 @07:34AM (#14469124)
Apparently there is at least one company that chases down artworks stolen by the Nazis and returns works with the rightful owners to recover their items for a fee.

It's mentioned in "The Panama Papers" book:

https://www.amazon.com/Panama-Papers-Breaking-Story-Powerful...

It also mentioned that some governments (I think it was Iceland) paid to get hacked data covering offshore company ownership.

So there might actually be a business model where you investigate tax evasion and sell the relevant data to tax authorities.

I suspect that might be a rather high risk activity though!

Re:The Swiss leaks and Panama papers open a window on the ta... by infogulch on Friday June 02, 2017 @11:37AM (#14470665)
Tax evader bounty hunters sounds like the plot of a movie I'd watch.
Re:The Swiss leaks and Panama papers open a window on the ta... by cookiecaper on Thursday June 01, 2017 @04:50PM (#14464553)
Say "wealth tax" near Buffet and Gates and watch them have quite a different reaction. Income tax rates have little effect on the already-wealthy because most of their money is not distributed in the form of a wage or salary; rather, it is stored in various types of financial vehicles that are already tax privileged. To the extent that this wealth is not held in stock, accountants set up other types of tax-privileged holdings.

Whenever a prominent wealthy person is talking, be aware of the PR necessity to not appear as if they are hoarding their wealth, or as if they are uninterested in sharing. Buffet and Gates are no doubt keenly aware of this necessity.

From the perspective of a Buffet or Gates, it is wise to publicly advocate for a tax increase that has little or no effect on your personal wealth, potentially targets up-and-comers who are currently making good money through their small-to-medium business ventures and may some day pose a threat to your interests (weakening them by confiscating more money from them), and keeps the public on your good side because they can point at you and say "There is $FAMOUS_RICH_GUY, and he knows that being greedy is bad."

Re:The Swiss leaks and Panama papers open a window on the ta... by rsync on Thursday June 01, 2017 @05:37PM (#14465054)
"Income tax rates have little effect on the already-wealthy because most of their money is not distributed in the form of a wage or salary; rather, it is stored in various types of financial vehicles that are already tax privileged."

The problem with this line of thought in it's current implemenation is that the top marginal income tax rates are very, very, very low in comparison to the "truly wealthy" people that you are referring to.

You only have to make (roughly) $400k[1] in the US to hit the very top federal bracket of 39%. That's hardly scrooge mcduck swimming in his bank vault. It's more like middle sized contractors, and (lower echelon) doctors and dentists.

So if you are a proponent of substituting income taxes with wealth taxes I would hope you are also a proponent of drastically raising the income brackets for very, very high tax rates to avoid hitting people that aren't "actually wealthy" (your definition).

[1] https://taxfoundation.org/2017-tax-brackets/

Re:The Swiss leaks and Panama papers open a window on the ta... by milcron on Thursday June 01, 2017 @06:52PM (#14465660)
Income tax is the wrong way to tax the extremely wealthy. They make most of their income from capital gains, which is taxed at a different, low rate.
Re:The Swiss leaks and Panama papers open a window on the ta... by dragonwriter on Friday June 02, 2017 @01:10AM (#14467609)
> Income tax is the wrong way to tax the extremely wealthy.

No, it's the right way.

> They make most of their income from capital gains, which is taxed at a different, low rate.

Capital gains taxes are income taxes, they just are at a lower rate to deliberately favor holders of capital. But there's a simple and obvious way to correct that; apply regular income tax rates to capital gains [0].

[0] there is actually a good reason for special treatment of income earned over a period of greater than one year in a progressive annual income tax system, as doing otherwise penalizes punctuated, non-repeatable income; but you can address that by either (or both) of allowing income to be recognized in advance for tax purposes and allowing income to be deferred for tax purposes for a period after it is earned (neither of which, managed properly, provides any avoidance opportunity for regularly-recurring income.)

Re:The Swiss leaks and Panama papers open a window on the ta... by milcron on Friday June 02, 2017 @06:35PM (#14473794)
In that case I agree.

I ought to have said, "labor income tax is the wrong way to tax the extremely wealthy."

Re:The Swiss leaks and Panama papers open a window on the ta... by rsync on Friday June 02, 2017 @12:19AM (#14467442)
"Income tax is the wrong way to tax the extremely wealthy."

That's my point.

The top income tax brackets are designed for, and sold to voters as, appropriate rates for the "super rich".

So to whatever degree you feel this is a bad tool for that job, I would hope you'd recognize that, therefore, the income ranges for those very high rates are not appropriate.

As I pointed out, those top rates aren't for millions or tens of millions of dollars of income - they are for (roughly) $400k.

Re:The Swiss leaks and Panama papers open a window on the ta... by refurb on Thursday June 01, 2017 @08:14PM (#14466315)
Income tax includes capital gains. At least in the US it's included when you file your "income taxes".
Re:The Swiss leaks and Panama papers open a window on the ta... by cookiecaper on Thursday June 01, 2017 @08:35PM (#14466447)
Short-term capital gains are taxed as regular income. Long-term capital gains are taxed at a significantly reduced rate (highest income tax bracket (39.6%) pays 20% on long-term capital gains).

See http://www.investopedia.com/articles/personal-finance/101515...

Re:The Swiss leaks and Panama papers open a window on the ta... by raarts on Thursday June 01, 2017 @06:52PM (#14465657)
Does a dentist really make $400k in the US? Wow, just wow..
Re:The Swiss leaks and Panama papers open a window on the ta... by cmurf on Thursday June 01, 2017 @07:24PM (#14465900)
Quick google search: The median annual Dentist salary is $146,434, as of April 27, 2017, with a range usually between $130,761-$171,212...

If the dentist owns a particularly successful office of dentists, they're not just a dentist, but a small business owner, so they could be making more money (paid by dividends rather than salary).

Re:The Swiss leaks and Panama papers open a window on the ta... by lern_too_spel on Friday June 02, 2017 @08:22PM (#14474185)
An established single dentist practice will take in over a million dollars per year. After paying secretary and dental hygienist salaries, rent, and other business costs, that comes to more than $400k net.

http://www.dentaleconomics.com/articles/print/volume-102/iss...

https://forums.studentdoctor.net/threads/how-much-can-a-priv...

Re:The Swiss leaks and Panama papers open a window on the ta... by cookiecaper on Thursday June 01, 2017 @08:19PM (#14466336)
I'm not a proponent of a wealth tax.
Re:The Swiss leaks and Panama papers open a window on the ta... by ChuckMcM on Thursday June 01, 2017 @05:21PM (#14464894)
I appreciate the point of view, but in this conversation specifically, and the Economist article specifically, the discussion is around evaded taxes of the wealthiest individuals. By definition an 'evaded' tax is one that is legally owed, but has been not paid illegally[1]. So without a tax increase, simply increasing compliance, you increase the actual tax revenue collected.

[1] Not to be confused with 'sheltered' where the tax was not paid but through a legal loophole.

Re:The Swiss leaks and Panama papers open a window on the ta... by refurb on Thursday June 01, 2017 @05:46PM (#14465147)
Another thing to keep in mind is that the top 1% in the US (>$428 AGI) earn 19% of all AGI and pay 38% of all income taxes. The top 1% pay more in taxes than the bottom 90%.[1]

[1]https://taxfoundation.org/summary-latest-federal-income-tax-...

Re:The Swiss leaks and Panama papers open a window on the ta... by vkou on Thursday June 01, 2017 @06:11PM (#14465357)
The top 1% also own more then the bottom 90%. 35% of all the wealth, compared to 28%. (Going by reported numbers - the reality may be worse.)

Their wealth also tends to stay with them. Bill Gates isn't planning on taking out a reverse mortgage for his house anytime soon.

In our debt-based society, wealth flows up. The average person spends most of their life paying interest to someone, in exchange for the ability to work, a place to live, and a vehicle for getting them from where they live to where they work.

People who don't need to go into debt for those three expenses get to grow their wealth, and pass it on to their children. People who do have to go into debt to do so tend to die, and pass on little to nothing.

Re:The Swiss leaks and Panama papers open a window on the ta... by skookumchuck on Thursday June 01, 2017 @09:10PM (#14466648)
> 35% of all the wealth

This neglects to account for all the wealth owned by the government.

Re:The Swiss leaks and Panama papers open a window on the ta... by refurb on Thursday June 01, 2017 @08:15PM (#14466320)
The top 1% also own more then the bottom 90%. 35% of all the wealth, compared to 28%

Hmmm... so it sounds like the rich are paying their fair share then?

Re:The Swiss leaks and Panama papers open a window on the ta... by ethbro on Friday June 02, 2017 @08:50AM (#14469449)
Yes. That's the definition and social contract of a progressive tax code.

E.g. "You probably screwed over a lot of people to get where you are, or at least leveraged their work while reaping most of the gains. As well as being able to afford to pay more (given that basic necessity costs don't scale with income). So you should pay a larger share."

Re:The Swiss leaks and Panama papers open a window on the ta... by soundwave106 on Friday June 02, 2017 @10:48AM (#14470281)
Actually, Bill Gates has directly called for a capital gains tax increase (http://www.cnbc.com/2016/05/02/bill-gates-calls-for-higher-c...) -- I assume capital gains would be most of his current taxable income at this point. Capital gains taxes are of far more concern to mega-rich people and big businesses, compared to small and medium businesses (which can take advantage of some capital gains exemptions specifically designed for them). So in his case at least I don't think this is reflecting some nefarious hidden agenda.
Re:The Swiss leaks and Panama papers open a window on the ta... by edanm on Thursday June 01, 2017 @05:21PM (#14464892)
Just out of curiosity, is there anything Gates/Buffet could do that you wouldn't approach cynically, i.e. that you would assume they're really doing it for other peoples' benefits rather than their own?
Re:The Swiss leaks and Panama papers open a window on the ta... by cookiecaper on Thursday June 01, 2017 @07:17PM (#14465847)
I think it's always valuable to analyze the cynical angle and potential game. As a sibling commenter stated, you don't get to Gates or Buffet level without good awareness of the game. In most cases, you can hardly get up more than one or two rungs on the corporate ladder without it.

I don't necessarily impute any of these motives upon Gates or Buffet per se. I just think it's important to be aware of how such actions align with their interests. The subjective judgment of each man's true motives is left to the reader.

I will say that if Gates and Buffet truly believed that 40% of the wealth they accrue each year could be put to better use by the USG than themselves, they could put their money where their mouth is and donate that portion of their assets to the U.S. Treasury. [0] Instead, they seem to keep that wealth within vehicles that they can control.

[0] https://www.fiscal.treasury.gov/fsfaq/faq_gifts_to_govt.htm

Re:The Swiss leaks and Panama papers open a window on the ta... by ethbro on Friday June 02, 2017 @08:46AM (#14469429)
How do you square your comments with Buffett being on the record (repeatedly) in griping about his effective tax rates vs those who earn less?

One example: http://money.cnn.com/2013/03/04/news/economy/buffett-secreta...

I don't have any quotes in memory from Gates, but your position of "Buffett is just trying to get good PR by advocating tax changes that wouldn't effect him" doesn't mesh with his quotes to the effect of "It's unfair I pay less effective tax than my secretary."

What exactly do you seem him advocating that has an ulterior motive?

Re:The Swiss leaks and Panama papers open a window on the ta... by cookiecaper on Friday June 02, 2017 @10:47AM (#14470264)
I think it's a calculated illustration. Power is all about making calculated gambles like that. If everyone was bare with their intentions all the time, it'd be easy for their enemies to bring them down.

The fact of the matter is that any type of change to the tax status of a significant asset is going to have far-reaching implications and plenty of people sticking their hands in the pot to try to make the outcome favorable to themselves.

A puff piece that features one of the most-conspicuous richest men in the world suggesting a tax hike against himself is just throwing a bone to the dogs; it's fodder that keeps Berkshire Hathaway and Buffett in the news and it makes the Buffett/BH brand more recognizable, likable, and personable, which are very important qualities.

It also gives him an anchor to point to if he ever needs to negate bad press. He can say "Look, I have a track record of advocating for selfless causes. What kind of greedy billionaire would get on TV and ask for a tax hike? You wouldn't see Donald Trump do that! The things that are causing my bad publicity are not actually bad, they're just misunderstood."

When people hear "tax hike" they think about it in relation to themselves, i.e., a hike on wage taxes. Beyond PR interest, the ulterior motives would be a) increasing the tax rate on people who are having good years in their small businesses, so that the growth of their nascent empire is stymied, lest it someday pose a challenge to BH's interests; and b) many of BH's major holdings are closely linked to government activity, things like railroads and utility companies. More money to the government = more money to BH, and this good PR makes government employees more favorable to Buffett/BH since he is not demonizing the thing that pays their salaries (taxes).

It's convenient to assume that people are honest and straightforward as long as one remains naive enough to believe that. But with something as complex and interconnected as BH and Buffett, nothing occurs in a vacuum. Buffett's private thoughts remain private. He knows when he is on the public stage and he certainly knows to calculate the consequences of his actions there. To deny that this is significant is to deny the purpose and value of Public Relations completely.

Re:The Swiss leaks and Panama papers open a window on the ta... by ethbro on Friday June 02, 2017 @11:28AM (#14470591)
I'm not denying your points. It just seems like you're torturing the facts so that Buffett is an exemplar vs looking at things more objectively.

> most-conspicuous richest men in the world

You mean the guy who still lives in a $600k house in Omaha [1] and briefly owned a $5.5M vacation house in California?

The guy who donates ~$2.8B [2] in Berkshire stock to charity annually? Who has said he does not plan to pass down an inordinate amount of wealth to his children?

These are facts. And they don't jive with a narrative of "He's doing all these things just to make more money."

A valid point becomes lesser when you have to perform gymnastics to make it fit to the person you've chosen. There's plenty of people who are better fits for your narrative: Larry Ellison, the Koch brothers, the Waltons, the Mars's, Soros, etc.

[1] http://www.today.com/slideshow/homes-warren-buffett-48385413

[2] https://www.forbes.com/sites/chasewithorn/2016/07/14/warren-...

Re:The Swiss leaks and Panama papers open a window on the ta... by cookiecaper on Friday June 02, 2017 @12:47PM (#14471312)
You're proving my point. Buffett is conspicuous due to his legend, not due to his ostentation. His legend would be harmed by making unpopular statements about tax policy, or by adopting a visibly-ostentatious lifestyle, or by a variety of other things that don't play well in the media. Buffett's legend is a valuable asset that he does not want to damage.

Call it "mental gymnastics" if you want; I just call it analysis. Every approach has pros and cons and I make no assertion about the true status of Buffett's motives. I just believe it is important to understand how these moves can work.

In competitive endeavors like business, it is wise to visualize the exercise as a game of chess. If I move to A5, that opens B4-C4 for my opponent, and opens to me D6-F6. My experience is that often, those who try to discourage such perspectives are merely trying to maintain the edge they get by having opponents that aren't aware a game is being played at all.

Enshrining placidity and complacency as social values only allows the sharks to operate more freely.

Re:The Swiss leaks and Panama papers open a window on the ta... by ethbro on Friday June 02, 2017 @06:05PM (#14473651)
> I make no assertion about the true status of Buffett's motives

That's the "I'm not saying he's a rapist, I'm just asking the question" defense, and it's bullshit. Every single one of your posts in this thread is along the lines of "If Gates and Buffett were profiteering assholes, they would do {thing they do} for {evil reason you ascribe to it}."

So by duck typing, you're absolutely saying they're profiteering assholes.

And then you throw out strawmen like this to support your point:

> I will say that if Gates and Buffet truly believed that 40% of the wealth they accrue each year could be put to better use by the USG than themselves, they could put their money where their mouth is and donate that portion of their assets to the U.S. Treasury. [0] Instead, they seem to keep that wealth within vehicles that they can control.

Re:The Swiss leaks and Panama papers open a window on the ta... by cookiecaper on Monday June 12, 2017 @11:37AM (#14538098)
I understand your point and I don't really disagree that passive accusations are irritating. It seems like the speaker is trying to weasel out of responsibility for what he's saying. All I can say is that it's not my intention to do that in this case.

IMO people are too quick to accept something at face value if it's politically or rhetorically convenient to do so, and I wanted to get more people thinking about the potential subtexts of statements made by the world's most conspicuously wealthy men, especially when these statements are oriented toward political matters.

Re:The Swiss leaks and Panama papers open a window on the ta... by dahoraTSUNAMI on Thursday June 01, 2017 @10:44PM (#14467043)
Just to clarify, Buffet and Gates didn't climb a corporate ladder. You are right, though, that the thinking is different and theirs is most likely atypically well-refined.
Re:The Swiss leaks and Panama papers open a window on the ta... by roenxi on Thursday June 01, 2017 @06:03PM (#14465296)
Cynicism comes into its own when that sort of money is involved. Practically it isn't possible to become build that sort of wealth without being super-aware of the financial outcomes of your decisions.

It isn't safe to take someone at face value once they can buy a PR firm without blinking.

Re:The Swiss leaks and Panama papers open a window on the ta... by edanm on Saturday June 03, 2017 @01:08PM (#14477292)
"It isn't safe to take someone at face value once they can buy a PR firm without blinking."

Well I agree with that. But it seems like you're saying that there's literally no evidence in the world that can convince you that your cynical view of them is wrong, which is a pretty hard position to hold IMO.

Re:The Swiss leaks and Panama papers open a window on the ta... by astrodev on Thursday June 01, 2017 @08:55PM (#14466549)
Not naming their foundations after themselves would be a good start.
Re:The Swiss leaks and Panama papers open a window on the ta... by croon on Friday June 02, 2017 @07:41AM (#14469149)
I would argue the opposite. They're not hiding behind other names, and you could instead argue that they're doing it for legacy, not for capital gain.
Re:The Swiss leaks and Panama papers open a window on the ta... by cmurf on Thursday June 01, 2017 @07:21PM (#14465881)
>Income tax rates have little effect on the already-wealthy because most of their money is not distributed in the form of a wage or salary

No, the fact is we differentiate between salaried "earned" income and tax it much, much higher, than investment "unearned" income. It's a very explicitly designed system that encourages stuffing the left overs into real estate, stocks, bonds rather than take the risk of starting or growing a business.

This is not a John Rawl's country, where we believe in "the veil of ignorance" thought game. If it were, there would be no such thing as tax free gifts, and low or non-existence inheritance tax.

Re:The Swiss leaks and Panama papers open a window on the ta... by skookumchuck on Thursday June 01, 2017 @09:15PM (#14466674)
Stocks & bonds are investing in growing a business.
Re:The Swiss leaks and Panama papers open a window on the ta... by cmurf on Friday June 02, 2017 @12:04AM (#14467374)
Only IPOs transfers cash directly to a growing business, all other stock trades are shareholder trades, the company sees none of that money.

Corporate bonds do help grow businesses, but these are dwarfed by government bonds, which are just another way of transferring money from the vast majority of living and future generations, to a tiny number of current living people.

Re:The Swiss leaks and Panama papers open a window on the ta... by 1123581321 on Friday June 02, 2017 @01:06AM (#14467593)
The part about trading not mattering to companies isn't true. One, companies issue additional shares after IPO. Two, the fluidity and likely future viability of the market affects IPO feasibility and price. Three, stock price affects employee compensation. Four, companies that own shares in other companies benefit from liquid markets just like retail investors.

Corporate bonds also trade on the secondary market and that has similar consequences.

Re:The Swiss leaks and Panama papers open a window on the ta... by skookumchuck on Friday June 02, 2017 @01:45AM (#14467741)
Also, if trading didn't matter, corporations wouldn't be so concerned about the stock price.
Re:The Swiss leaks and Panama papers open a window on the ta... by 1123581321 on Friday June 02, 2017 @08:01AM (#14469235)
They might actually be more concerned. Look at startup valuation for an example of how they might behave.
Re:The Swiss leaks and Panama papers open a window on the ta... by tomcam on Thursday June 01, 2017 @05:34PM (#14465023)
What Koch's philosophy (as opposed to Gates' philosophy)? Which party's money is "Dark" and why?
Re:The Swiss leaks and Panama papers open a window on the ta... by dredmorbius on Thursday June 01, 2017 @08:22PM (#14466358)
Warlord feudalism vs. Liberal democracy.
Re:The Swiss leaks and Panama papers open a window on the ta... by arethuza on Friday June 02, 2017 @07:31AM (#14469109)
"I want my fair share - and that's all of it."
Re:The Swiss leaks and Panama papers open a window on the ta... by tomcam on Friday June 02, 2017 @05:14PM (#14473354)
Citations?
Re:The Swiss leaks and Panama papers open a window on the ta... by dredmorbius on Friday June 02, 2017 @05:43PM (#14473534)
Mark Ames, or Philip Mirowski, on the Libertarian / MPS cabal are pretty good:

http://www.alternet.org/visions/true-history-libertarianism-...

http://www.worldcat.org/title/road-from-mont-plerin-the-maki...

Gates is quieter on his political views, but a general outline of his philosophy, in his own words, is in this piece:

https://www.wired.com/2013/11/bill-gates-wired-essay/

My assessment is also very strongly based on the actions and financial support both elements have provided. The Kochs, and most other major Libertarian supporters, ultimately back projects which favour a return to feudalism, though they rarely state it this baldly. Gates has tended to support instutions aligned with general liberal democratic principles.

Re:The Swiss leaks and Panama papers open a window on the ta... by cmurf on Thursday June 01, 2017 @07:12PM (#14465807)
That is inconsistent with the country's founding: the political system, as founded, is supposed to serve wealthy citizens first. It's a country founded on class, founded on making profit. You are white, you have land, you're a man, then you have a political voice. If you lack one of those, you cannot participate. And it was that way for a longer period of time, than it has been since womens' suffrage and the civil rights act of 1965.

Despite being more democratic today than its founding, there's still present a substantial minority who appear to believe in the proper existence of aristocracy. Family name, bloodline, class, are real things, they define who is better and who is inferior. Better people have more money, and they can buy things inferior people can't, or they can buy better versions: privacy, education, health care, justice, political representation, police protection, tax avoidance. Those things are products.

What most people are trying to do is find a civil way of playing reasonably fair. But aristocrats think money buys everything, so when catastrophe comes along to equalize things, they never see it coming. https://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2017/02/scheide...

Re:The Swiss leaks and Panama papers open a window on the ta... by guest on Thursday June 01, 2017 @10:01PM (#14466879)
Grassroots - socialdemocracy that sprung froms scandinavia but has major partial similarities to alot of European countries pre EU when the public sector was larger (around 10%). Through grassroots people achieved greater impact for the state (as represented by the people for the people) through law, regulation and public ownership ("the greater good"). That change was not brought on catastrophically but incrimentally by the poor working class also even partially by what today would be called entrepreneurs (the liberals of those days) that realised that local companies could gain more by increasing the wealth for the local populace who could then produce more efficiently (win/win).

Anyway, when people impact through the national state they have power, when wealth is shifted from nation to private hands is when the public should start to move. I'm still surprised the reality that could be had by the big short (2015) where moody's et al with rubberstamping actively helps in making that shift happen. It seems like hidden plutocrats have greenlit to jump ship more or less...

What people need to do is to organise, activate and put real pressure on those working for as few as possible instead of as many as possible. Once real democratic rule has been established through law and oversight (transparency - means disabling some shadow groups in the gov and right outside it) a more egalitarian and utilitarian (efficient) society will spring forth.

Re:The Swiss leaks and Panama papers open a window on the ta... by cmurf on Friday June 02, 2017 @12:12AM (#14467409)
Well when you have a substantial amount of the population voting against their economic interest, do not trust the political system to the degree they like hearing autocratic rhetoric like "so called judges" and "do nothing congress" and "rigged elections" and "fake news media" - that sort of denigration of checks and balances in favor of unity executive is totally the opposite of anything grassroots, or democracy.

It's people who have no trust in those things, and just want to go back to a simple life of one deity, one leader, a small bunch of benevolent aristocrats, and everyone else gets a basic job and they just suck it up and like it.

A significant minority is convinced crony capitalism is real capitalism, and the only reason why it doesn't work perfectly is because of government, gays, and libtards. That's the political reality of ~80% of Republicans who still approve of everything this U.S. administration is doing. That may only be 25% of the eligible voting population, but then a bit over 50% of those eligible voters could not be bothered to participate at all. So you have a sizable minority of anti-democratic people who want a weak autocrat to just fix things and de-Obamafy the country. And a bunch of disinterested people. Ergo 3/4 of the voting eligible population.

It's a problem.

Re:The Swiss leaks and Panama papers open a window on the ta... by wyager on Friday June 02, 2017 @12:07AM (#14467383)
Perhaps the fact that catastrophe is the only thing leads to increased equality (in dollar terms) is a sign that equality (in dollar terms) is a bad heuristic for net social utility.
Re:The Swiss leaks and Panama papers open a window on the ta... by laythea on Thursday June 01, 2017 @04:50PM (#14464550)
Yes but dark money will never be gotten rid off!
Re:The Swiss leaks and Panama papers open a window on the ta... by pasquinelli on Thursday June 01, 2017 @09:35PM (#14466775)
Right, it needs to be fought perpetually.
Re:The Swiss leaks and Panama papers open a window on the ta... by wyager on Friday June 02, 2017 @12:01AM (#14467358)
> Once this country is rid of Dark money, the political system might finally start serving its citizens

Oh boy, is this idiotic red herring from Indian politics going to get ported almost verbatim to US politics? Yes, I'm sure a max ~4% revenue boost will make the government start behaving properly.