I'm sure a lot of the language and ideas they're parroting are coming from conservative talk radio, hence the blind spots. But it really soured me on the US tax simplification debate.
Whole heartedly agree. Simplification and flatter tax code should be separate discussions, with separate conclusions.
1. IRS determines the median for personal income (total household income divided by household size), and publishes it no later than January 1.
2. Your taxable income is your household income minus the published median from #1 times the number of people in your household. If this is less than or equal to zero, pay no tax.
3. Those with positive taxable income pay x% of that amount as tax, with x set according to the requirements of the previous year's budget, but not to exceed a statutory limit of y%.
If you take the median income as a proxy for spending, this tax thus approximates a flat tax on the annual increase in household wealth.
Cut out the various deductions and credits and additions to income etc. to make things simple. Then calculating tax due becomes a simple table lookup or addition of amounts from multiple tables. 3rd grade math. We don't need to set a single universal x% tax rate to make things easy.
I'm all in favor of a vastly simpler tax code, but I'm also in favor of a vastly more progressive tax code. These two things aren't in opposition to one another.
If you take 20% of 20,000 bucks your tax on me is 4k which only leaves me 16k to live on (You would be extremely poor in US). 20% of 200k is 40k, which leaves me 160k to live on.
[1] Where "one" is a bit of a fuzzy concept when you're dealing with multi-millionaires hiding their wealth through various shenanigans.
But let me float this: Guess which parties/party wanted the tax code that complicated to begin with? The first step to fixing it would be to not align yourself with the ones who caused the issue.
Simpler tax code would make it less worrysome for regular plebs (us) to fill out our taxes, meaning the lower/middle class that pays their taxes would ensure they weren't in danger, and IRS would have an easier time chasing down tax avoiders.
The people who complicated the tax codes and also wants to uninsure tens of millions of people to save a few bucks for rich people won't help you.