Four days ago: I really want to work at this building
https://twitter.com/HarshilShah1910/status/86445977790400102...
Eight days ago: Apparently you can drive around in California as long as you have a valid license from anywhere. Really wish I’d planned for a longer stay.
https://twitter.com/HarshilShah1910/status/86300061707719475...
Twelve days ago: Wild to think that Jared Kushner’s brother being a VC might save H1B.
https://twitter.com/HarshilShah1910/status/86160090342970982...
May 2nd: I’m thinking of applying for 2 jobs. One is almost literally a stone’s throw away. The other is on a continent I’ve never stepped foot on.
https://twitter.com/HarshilShah1910/status/85958214083233382...
[Edit: This post is the result of my genuine curiosity. Again, I think it kind of sucks and the lost opportunity is unfortunate. I'm not trying to blame a victim or justify US immigration policy or trying to dig up dirt. I'm more interested in something approaching a root cause analysis that might help someone else avoid similar problems in the future. Getting a scholarship to WWDC is a big deal in a young person's life and getting refused a visa to attend is also a big deal.]
[Edit: If the source had not been Twitter, I certainly would not have scrolled through the tweets. I pretty much hate Twitter as a news source because it favors sound bites over analysis.]
It’s not like he can get a job working as a software engineer for Apple as an undocumented immigrant.
Edit for anyone confused: this is a comment about the policy, not about the parent poster.
I suspect that the US State Department has more sophisticated tools for analysis than my hand scrolling through the last three weeks of the 46,000 tweets. For example, I'd not be surprised if it had tools for looking at social graphs and demographic data that correlates applicants marital status,socio-economic status, educational status, and country of origin for temporary visas with visa compliance.
None of which is to take a stance on whether the process is fair or right or just or moral. The only stance I am taking is that it is the process and given that it is the process the result is understandable and that there is actionable intelligence based upon what happened.
Or am I misunderstanding something?
The Australian one is extra awesome because they have very tight import restrictions on food/plant products for biosecurity reasons and their proximity to Asia means there are tons of people trying to bring in very interesting (but illegal) items from those countries. Plus they have a whole series of really cute dogs that sniff out the food.
I am guessing in certain countries they are stricter than others. I think there is an issue with Indians overstaying their Visa in the US, so maybe that's why they are so strict over there.
Some examples: Close family back home, a job or school back home, money/property/investments/bank accounts back home, lack of strife/conflict back home, lack of family in the US, solid plans in the US that indicate a temporary stay, ticket for a return flight (this actual ranks pretty low I think).
But it turned out he just got rejected like any other normal person could get rejected. That is what I meant. Like his position to be a Conference Scholarship Recipient does not have anything to do with this. He is just a normal guy like you and me who got denied for a normal reason.
I mean, you can quote "security", "not enough paperwork", "he didn't smell right and a suit decided to reject him"... but in software we usually call that a bug - someone should be able to visit a conference but couldn't due to broken process. And there's A LOT wrong with making people miserable over paperwork. It has to serve people not enslave them.
This is "presumed guilty".
> The presumption in the law is that every nonimmigrant visa applicant (except certain employment-related applicants, who are exempt) is an intending immigrant unless otherwise proven. Therefore, applicants for most nonimmigrant visas must overcome this presumption by demonstrating that:
* The purpose of their trip is to enter the U.S. for a specific, intended purpose;
* They plan to remain for a specific, limited period; and
* They have a residence outside the U.S. as well as other binding ties which will ensure their return at the end of their stay.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Visa_policy_of_the_United_Stat...
But maybe some sort of bond procedure would be handy for this kind of thing where you really want someone to visit and are willing to stake a lot that they'll return. OTOH I'm sure if Apple wanted to get involved they could easily help him out on his application.
It's easy to debate from your position of power, but remember that it's easy that you can easily be the one rotting in an slump UK/EU/African or even your own bureaucracy.
All the kid wanted to do is visit a tech conference. Why on earth are you defending the shitty process that tried to prevent that?
That's so "American exceptionalism" way to think. People from some backwater developing countries maybe...
And usually it was just a matter of paying some money and getting the visa (sometimes even on the spot at the airport at arrival). Other times the travel agent just handled it all, with just your name and passport number.
No third degree examination I can recall of...
My brother showed up with a folder full of documents, but was dismissed without showing any of it. Profile based, I think.
P.S. Thanks for reminding me why I stopped commenting on HN, saves me a bunch of time.
Just to be clear: I'm not defending that law, but saying that this case might well have been in accordance with the law. There are tons of similar cases that don't make HN. If you think this is crazy, you should work to change the law, not decry this particular case.
He got rejected because he didn't provide enough evidence that his intent is purely non-immigrant.
https://twitter.com/HarshilShah1910/status/86578769858118451...