News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Emil Cioran: Anti-philosopher of Life and Death by coldtea on Sunday April 16, 2017 @04:40PM (#14127387)
An unbearable philosopher-wannabe writing the same platitudes and whining for decades on end while living a cushy literary/academic life.

Pass, and go directly to someone like Schopenhauer...

Re:Emil Cioran: Anti-philosopher of Life and Death by dang on Monday April 17, 2017 @12:14AM (#14129183)
Would you please not post snarky dismissals and especially not start off threads with them? It degrades discussion and we're hoping for better.

If an article (or philosopher) is so not to your taste that you can't think of anything else to say, please just don't comment. Nothing is to everyone's taste, and there's usually something else that's interesting.

Re:Emil Cioran: Anti-philosopher of Life and Death by soufron on Sunday April 16, 2017 @04:49PM (#14127432)
"cushy"? He quitted the Academy and stayed poor for most of his life. He refused every literary awards that he received. He was a solitary living in the same small apartment in Paris until his death.
Re:Emil Cioran: Anti-philosopher of Life and Death by coldtea on Sunday April 16, 2017 @06:02PM (#14127792)
None of those point to any kind of troubled life (except his sickness at the end). He got all kinds of scholarships and awards early on, he had continued recognition throughout his life, had an income from his books and never had trouble to find a publisher, he went through the most troubled period of Europe and didn't lift a finger to fight (on the contrary: he was partial to the Nazis and the Romanian Iron Guard), and could get a job at any time but refused.
Re:Emil Cioran: Anti-philosopher of Life and Death by nnq on Monday April 17, 2017 @07:19AM (#14130259)
I'm really curious why are you so wound up against him to mount such a strong an "ad hominem" attack against him?

Yeah, his work had mostly only aesthetic value imho (aka "worthless", I agree), bu one doesn't judges philosophers based on their life and character, one judges their ideas. And even so, I'd have no problems of with a philosopher who was lazy and sympathized with horrible people. Heck, if Hitler wrote good philosophy himself I'd praise his philosophy despite the person (note: he did not, I agree, Mein Khampf is 100% crap).

Re:Emil Cioran: Anti-philosopher of Life and Death by theoh on Monday April 17, 2017 @09:01AM (#14130594)
In the case of an artist, I'm sure you'd consider their life experience and artistic production to be deeply inter-related.

It's the same with philosophy and literature. Only mathematical logic and similar formal philosophy is immune from an analysis that takes the author into account...

The "New Criticism" of the mid-20th century which rules out considerations of biography is just one possible stance. The censorious tone of dang concerning a personal reaction to Cioran feels like part of a HN ethos of denying the value of subjectivity. A deadly caricature of life as lived by engineers.

Re:Emil Cioran: Anti-philosopher of Life and Death by petre on Tuesday April 18, 2017 @12:17AM (#14136436)
The pen is mightier than the sword.
Re:Emil Cioran: Anti-philosopher of Life and Death by RodericDay on Monday April 17, 2017 @10:59AM (#14131311)
You're a pretty great poster and I hope you know that the frequency with which your posts are greyed out is a good indicator that you often push the right buttons.

A bunch of tech-nerds who routinely act skeptical of women testimony about harassment, waxing poetic about the nuances of the thought of a Nazi sympathizer.

Re:Emil Cioran: Anti-philosopher of Life and Death by sctb on Tuesday April 18, 2017 @11:51AM (#14139837)
Please stop violating the guidelines by sparking sub-flamewars. We've asked you already to stop, and we ban accounts that won't.
Re:Emil Cioran: Anti-philosopher of Life and Death by RodericDay on Monday April 17, 2017 @11:02AM (#14131350)
> "there is no present-day politician that I see as more sympathetic and admirable than Hitler",[1] while expressing his approval for the Night of the Long Knives—"what has humanity lost if the lives of a few imbeciles were taken"

HN: "wow; beautiful, thoughtful stuff. really makes me think."

Re:Emil Cioran: Anti-philosopher of Life and Death by mariusmg on Sunday April 16, 2017 @04:54PM (#14127452)
You have no idea what are you talking about...
Re:Emil Cioran: Anti-philosopher of Life and Death by vixen99 on Sunday April 16, 2017 @05:04PM (#14127499)
Are you by chance a graduate of the Colin Wilson school of literary criticism?
Re:Emil Cioran: Anti-philosopher of Life and Death by coldtea on Sunday April 16, 2017 @06:03PM (#14127798)
No, just one for good philosophy.
Re:Emil Cioran: Anti-philosopher of Life and Death by Mediterraneo10 on Sunday April 16, 2017 @07:00PM (#14128034)
I daresay “good philosophy” is based on the rigor of the ideas themselves, not the lives of philosophers themselves. The canon of philosophy is replete with men who did distasteful or abhorrent things, but their ideas are studied nonetheless.
Re:Emil Cioran: Anti-philosopher of Life and Death by coldtea on Sunday April 16, 2017 @07:54PM (#14128313)
>I daresay “good philosophy” is based on the rigor of the ideas themselves, not the lives of philosophers themselves. The canon of philosophy is replete with men who did distasteful or abhorrent things, but their ideas are studied nonetheless.

That only drives the point further: there are no ideas in Cioran, just (or in any case, mostly) whining.

My mentioning of his life wasn't to diminish his ideas (or rather, the lack thereof), just to show how unjustified the whining.

Re:Emil Cioran: Anti-philosopher of Life and Death by simion314 on Monday April 17, 2017 @07:02AM (#14130214)
If you have a happy life won't you be pissed/scared at the idea of death? Is there a philosophy that can give you comfort regarding the idea of death that is not a religious thing, the only idea that gives me a extremely small comfort is the idea that time is relative so in theory a dead person is stil young and living somewhere in the past just we can't get there.
Re:Emil Cioran: Anti-philosopher of Life and Death by miloshadzic on Monday April 17, 2017 @09:38AM (#14130756)
Maybe look into Epicureanism. In particular, before you read wikipedia or stanford's encyclopedia, I'd recommend this letter[1] written by Epicurus himself.

[1]: http://www.epicurus.net/en/menoeceus.html

Re:Emil Cioran: Anti-philosopher of Life and Death by stagbeetle on Monday April 17, 2017 @10:01AM (#14130897)
> If you have a happy life won't you be pissed/scared at the idea of death?

Why? Because it is the normal thing to do? Is it expected of you to be afraid of death? Is the natural inclination to be afraid of just thinking about dying?

I am "fearful" of death in the sense that if something is likely to cause my death in the present moment, I will act towards self-preservation.

But the idea of death, that just thinking of one's demise would cause one anguish is a sign one hasn't calibrated his priorities correctly. Pragmatically speaking, there are so many things to think about (and even moreso to do), so why would anyone focus on something that they cannot ever change? Besides their own self-imposed torture in the name "philosophy."

This will come off as snarky, but I recommend you find some more things to fill your time.

Re:Emil Cioran: Anti-philosopher of Life and Death by dEnigma on Monday April 17, 2017 @10:46AM (#14131211)
I think it is only natural to want good experiences to last for as long as possible and to be at least a little "pissed", as the parent comment put it, when you think about the inevitable end. It's similar to your instinct of self-preservation, only on a longer timescale. Of course it would probably be most enjoyable if one could just permanently forget about death and live life to the fullest, but that kind of oblivion seems almost impossible for such an important concept. Also without the prospect of death one might not be as inclined to make the most of what little time one has available. I guess you describe a kind of stoic philosophy where one shouldn't be concerned by things one cannot change at all, but that requires a lot of conscious effort, at least that's my personal experience, and the untrained human reaction to the fact that the good days are numbered is to be "pissed".
Re:Emil Cioran: Anti-philosopher of Life and Death by stagbeetle on Monday April 17, 2017 @11:02AM (#14131348)
> It's similar to your instinct of self-preservation, only on a longer timescale.

I haven't thought of it like that. But it would seem one is an unconscious reaction, spurred on by the autonomous nervous system, while the other is a (seemingly) conscious choice (if we don't get into determinism).

Then we get back to the beginning. You can influence the outcome of a sudden event, but not your own destined death down the line. Taking your "natural to want good experiences to last for as long as possible and to be at least a little 'pissed'," into account, doesn't that align with my parent comment? By consciously obsessing about how your days are numbered and that you have relatively little time alive, are you not contributing to your own state of being "pissed?"

Are you not being self-sabotaging?

> I guess you describe a kind of stoic philosophy where one shouldn't be concerned by things one cannot change at all, but that requires a lot of conscious effort, at least that's my personal experience, and the untrained human reaction to the fact that the good days are numbered is to be "pissed".

My response to this will sound aggressive, but once we identify a lapse in our untrained thinking, the practical thing to do would be to fix this.

In other words, as you mentioned, we can override such thoughts with sustained conscious effort. It may be difficult, but it would be a better use of time to make ours as good as it can be.

Re:Emil Cioran: Anti-philosopher of Life and Death by dEnigma on Tuesday April 18, 2017 @08:03AM (#14138110)
>I haven't thought of it like that. But it would seem one is an unconscious reaction, spurred on by the autonomous nervous system, while the other is a (seemingly) conscious choice (if we don't get into determinism).

OK, I thought you weren't only talking about unconscious processes but also short-term decision-making like "I'm not going to try this unknown berry because it might kill me". I don't know why I used the word "instinct", since that implies unconscious processes indeed.

As for the rest, I completely agree with everything you said, my point was mainly what I expressed in my last sentence, regarding the reaction an "untrained" human mind would have, which of course can be overcome with some effort.

Re:Emil Cioran: Anti-philosopher of Life and Death by nsxwolf on Monday April 17, 2017 @10:44AM (#14131204)
Your post reeks of a lack of empathy. The same kind that inspires the thin person to tell the fat person to just not eat so much. It's perfectly fine to not understand someone else, but it's another thing to assume they can snap their fingers and instantly reform themselves in your image.
Re:Emil Cioran: Anti-philosopher of Life and Death by stagbeetle on Monday April 17, 2017 @11:12AM (#14131447)
On the contrary, I empathize with the plights of humanity. I know first-hand how difficult it is to be alive, what it's like to be downtrodden, and even how difficult it is for some of us to lose weight.

But, going through the extremely terrible has given me a better perspective on: the true severity of problems, whereas one who suffers will be stuck in such a negative and hopeless mindset, even if such is not true at all; the problems that are strictly self-imposed, as opposed to those one has no control over; and the extent to which one's problems can be fixed by putting in conscious effort.

As there are few who truly are unable to lose weight, without extra effort and accommodations, there are few that are truly stuck with unmanageable and crippling thanatophobia.

Have you heard of former drug addicts being harder on addicts than those who've never faced the problem themselves? This is relevant to our discussion.

While people need support and understanding, the victims themselves must take personal responsibility for their issues as well.

Re:Emil Cioran: Anti-philosopher of Life and Death by simion314 on Monday April 17, 2017 @11:12AM (#14131450)
I was also thinking on the case when others you are about die and you are thinking if they are lost forever, I am not sure if you had this feelings, maybe if you are religious you can find much easier some comfort,
Re:Emil Cioran: Anti-philosopher of Life and Death by stagbeetle on Monday April 17, 2017 @11:29AM (#14131624)
Yes, I've had these thoughts.

The first time, I cried when the realization hit me. All of the things we couldn't do anymore and the hole that he would leave was terrible to think about.

I changed my mindset into something very cliche, but it works for me:

We can no longer create memories together, but I can still cherish the ones we had and pass on the same good he brought into my life, to others. Sort of like remembering one's legacy and passing on the torch.

I don't believe there is an intrinsically correct answer for these human situations, so picking the most efficient one is best.

Re:Emil Cioran: Anti-philosopher of Life and Death by voidhorse on Monday April 17, 2017 @01:00PM (#14132491)
This is correct to an extent--good modern philosophizing does, in the end, deal with the clarity of concept. But your conception points to a fascinating development in the history of philosophy.

If you return to the ancients, living philosophically was more important than the conceptual edifice or system building we conceive of as philosophical today--that's why we run into somewhat blatant contradictions in the systems of the neo-platonists and others--it is not that they were necessarily poor systematizers and let their concepts run away from them--that man didn't quite have the same intellectual power for reasoning cleanly yet--but that systemic clarity was not their goal--they had only an effect in mind.

The ancients were almost therapists in a sense--their whole goal was to get one living in the right way--thus few of them actually bothered to write as the philosophical schools were centered on practices, rituals, meditations etc.--progressions--and not just explication--exegesis of a master's thought was important--but only to the extent it had a direct impact on one's life and the way one lived. A philosopher, to the ancients was simply anyone who lived in a certain way--and by certain principles, whether or not they had conceived of those principles or learned them--the designation came with the living and the way not with intellectual output, but with intellectual activity(living with a love of wisdom). There's a reason Epictetus's text is called Enchiridion, which means manual or handbook--the same can be said of the use of the word Sutra

Then the middle ages hit and philosophy became far more theoretic as it was subordinated to theology--it became the so called handmaiden of theology--now its whole purpose was conceptual clarification, system building, logic--in order that one might know God, might develop a theological framework, put all the cosmological ducks in order.

I scarcely have to describe how the analytic tradition in the 20th century drove this notion of philosophy primarily as systematizing, abstract, and having little connection with one's actual practice and way of living further, and indeed to an extreme. As someone once enmeshed in the analytic tradition myself, I find nothing more distasteful than stuffy academic philosophy--it is necessary sure, but we must recall that philosophy was foremost supposed to teach one how to live (or how to die ;) ).

Wittgenstein is perhaps the only "analytic" that offers a philosophy similar to those of the ancients--You'll find that even the Tractatus, which helped birth the most arid and abstract form of philosophizing, logical positivism, if you read it carefully, is actually a text meant to directly influence the way you live and resolve some problem of living more than it is the presentation of some metaphysical, logical framework--indeed, the propositional structure of that text is more or less a smokescreen--W., like Socrates, like Nietzsche, presents a mask--remove the numbers, re-title it "Aphorisms"--has anything changed?

Hadot's book, Philosophy as a Way of Life is a great study on this shift from philosophy as lived, therapeutic practice to philosophy as a primarily textual, abstract, academic profession--and like all professions, limited by exterior considerations.

Re:Emil Cioran: Anti-philosopher of Life and Death by miloshadzic on Monday April 17, 2017 @01:40PM (#14132856)
I like your views on philosophy, and I recently read and liked that Hadot book. I'm guessing that you studied philosophy formally, but I'm curious, what do you do now? (My email is in my bio if you want to continue off HN)