News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Emil Cioran: Anti-philosopher of Life and Death by nnq on Monday April 17, 2017 @07:19AM (#14130259)
I'm really curious why are you so wound up against him to mount such a strong an "ad hominem" attack against him?

Yeah, his work had mostly only aesthetic value imho (aka "worthless", I agree), bu one doesn't judges philosophers based on their life and character, one judges their ideas. And even so, I'd have no problems of with a philosopher who was lazy and sympathized with horrible people. Heck, if Hitler wrote good philosophy himself I'd praise his philosophy despite the person (note: he did not, I agree, Mein Khampf is 100% crap).

Re:Emil Cioran: Anti-philosopher of Life and Death by theoh on Monday April 17, 2017 @09:01AM (#14130594)
In the case of an artist, I'm sure you'd consider their life experience and artistic production to be deeply inter-related.

It's the same with philosophy and literature. Only mathematical logic and similar formal philosophy is immune from an analysis that takes the author into account...

The "New Criticism" of the mid-20th century which rules out considerations of biography is just one possible stance. The censorious tone of dang concerning a personal reaction to Cioran feels like part of a HN ethos of denying the value of subjectivity. A deadly caricature of life as lived by engineers.