News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by zeteo on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @02:00PM (#14100097)
The subtext here is that customers don't have any actual rights when dealing with a large corporation. The terms of service have become so lengthy and obscure that it's virtually certain for a corporate lawyer to find some justification somewhere for almost anything. The corporate employees and the police both operate on this assumption. As a customer, your only recourse is to meekly accept whatever treatment is coming your way.
Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by Animats on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @02:12PM (#14100233)
The subtext here is that customers don't have any actual rights when dealing with a large corporation.

The problem is that people now believe that. In fact, lawsuits against big companies often are settled on very favorable terms for the customer. As the article points out, United violated their own contract of carriage and FAA regulations. This is going to cost them.

Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by zeteo on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @03:01PM (#14100718)
How many people have a) many thousands of dollars sitting around to pay for lawyers b) the requisite leisure to attend arbitrary court dates and locations c) the ability to deal with the loss of the above if the company wins the case based on some technicality? The company will happily take the proceeds from illegally squeezing the 99% who don't press charges to pay for the 1% who do.

Technically the blacks in the South had the right to vote after the Civil War. It took another hundred years of struggle to also secure the practical right. Theoretical rights don't matter much for those who can't exert them.

Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by cmurf on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @02:30PM (#14100429)
Only because the passenger peacefully resisted, and did not comply with the airline's request he depart the plane on his own volition. He didn't give into threats, and risked and received an assault, in order to arrive at the point where this is going to cost the airline.
Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by devoply on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @02:51PM (#14100635)
He should totally bring a multi-million dollar lawsuit, it's a total cake walk as it'd be hard to find a jury that wouldn't sympathize and he and his grandkids would be millions of dollars richer. Not to mention all the dirt you can drag United through during the lawsuit in the media. Love to see some testimony from the dick CEO as well who tried even character assignation of the poor doctor they needlessly assaulted.
Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by ThrowawayR2 on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @03:33PM (#14100983)
> He should totally bring a multi-million dollar lawsuit, it's a total cake walk as it'd be hard to find a jury that wouldn't sympathize and he and his grandkids would be millions of dollars richer. Not to mention all the dirt you can drag United through during the lawsuit in the media. Love to see some testimony from the dick CEO as well who tried even character assignation of the poor doctor they needlessly assaulted.

It'd be a cake walk alright ... for the airline.

Pilots have similar powers to the captain of a civilian naval vessel, and can legally refuse to carry passengers or order them off the aircraft: https://www.quora.com/What-are-the-extra-ordinary-powers-tha...

Moreover, refusing to leave the premises when requested or to comply with the police when they arrived, is unquestionably against the law.

Even a jury has to operates within the constraints of the law or be overturned on appeal. Remember, the airline would be the defendant and has the right to appeal.

Sure, being bumped is lousy behavior by the airline but the doctor doesn't have a legal leg to stand on for his tantrum. If anything, the airline could probably sue him for delaying the flight and win.

Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by jack9 on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @03:59PM (#14101181)
> requested or to comply with the police when they arrived, is unquestionably against the law.

Except that's not who dragged him off. Representatives of a customer safety federal aviation department physically dragged him. I don't think everyone fully understands the sequence or "players" involved (I had to look it up too). - http://www.chicagotribune.com/news/opinion/zorn/ct-united-pa...

Otherwise, you're absolutely correct about voluntary vs compulsory.

A police officer would still be liable for not properly restraining and ensuring the safety of the "victim".

Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by ThrowawayR2 on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @04:12PM (#14101297)
The article you linked says the individual was from the City of Chicago's Department of Aviation. While you do bring up an important clarifying point, I'd be surprised if the individual in question didn't have most or all of the same authority/powers as a police officer within his jurisdiction.

Some additional information from the Wikipedia article on airport police that seems to be relevant: "The City of Chicago Department of Aviation Police perform safety, security and law enforcement functions at O'Hare International Airport & Midway Airport. The department was formerly called the Department of Aviation Special Police. The Chicago Police Department Airport Unit also performs many of the law enforcement duties in and around Chicago area airports." (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Airport_police) However, that information may or may not be current.

Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by mturmon on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @03:44PM (#14101063)
"Moreover, refusing to leave the premises when requested or to comply with the police when they arrived, is unquestionably against the law."

One might think that, but TFA points out that there are regulations covering when a passenger can be bumped. The demand that the passenger leave may have violated these rules. The police order in that case was mistaken, a point also raised in TFA.

Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by ThrowawayR2 on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @04:02PM (#14101201)
> One might think that, but TFA points out that there are regulations covering when a passenger can be bumped. The demand that the passenger leave may have violated these rules. The police order in that case was mistaken, a point also raised in TFA.

Those regulations do not trump the pilot's authority to directly order a passenger removed for disrupting a flight, even for trivial reasons. See this article that discusses various airlines' history of expelling passengers (warning: autoplaying video with sound), http://fortune.com/2016/05/11/airlines-kicked-off-passengers..., or the FAA regulation directly, https://www.gpo.gov/fdsys/pkg/CFR-2011-title14-vol2/pdf/CFR-...

Moreover, the police order may have been mistaken but that in no way absolves the individual from complying with said order. He should have resolved the issue with litigation afterwards.

(Again, to make my position clear, the airline behaved quite badly but so did the passenger.)

Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by cmurf on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @05:58PM (#14102136)
FAR 91.3 and 91.11 exist for operational safety of the flight. The purpose of the FAR is the PIC can ignore company, customer, and even Air Traffic Control orders that compromise the safety of the flight. Company says you must land at this airport tonight, and the pilot says well it's socked in, it's not safe to land, so no. That's the purpose. It's to make him accountable to flight safety, not the company or anybody else.

By making him an agent of his company's customer service to remove a passenger who is in compliance with the law, regulations, and the company's own contract of carriage, and then use FAR 91.3(a) as an excuse to say the pilot must be obeyed is poor logic. And I am a pilot (and a former CFII). I think it makes flights less safe to inject the company's demands into the cockpit. They do not matter, what matters is safety. That's what his FAR is about, not to enable the pilot to be an ass to passengers on behalf of his moronic company.

And claiming otherwise damages the necessary trust that we're supposed to have, and should have, with pilots and crew. Their primary purpose is to save your life. It is not to pour sodas, or appease the company CEOs profit needs by being jerks to passengers, and throwing them off for business reasons.

As for the police, I think that was an illegal assault on the part of the officer, and given the available information the passenger wasn't breaking any laws, so the police being there was inappropriate in the first place, they shouldn't have intervened and should know that.

Edited a few times to remove foul language :-D

Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by ubernostrum on Thursday April 13, 2017 @01:45AM (#14104435)
I appreciate you making this comment.

Too many places I frequent have had crews, and especially airline pilots, basically pulling the "my word is law, there is no appeal and no review and nobody above me but God and even He only has an advisory role" crap.

Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by cmurf on Thursday April 13, 2017 @02:50PM (#14109836)
God complex in pilots. It's archaic, but still comes up from time to time. Before crew resource management it was absolute authority, and one of the most famous consequences of this thinking is the Tenerife accident in 1977. The PIC was basically all, no goddamnit we're cleared for takeoff and we're going now - 5 minutes later nearly 600 people are melting and burning.

More recently, examples of pilots refusing to fly with Muslims on board. It's more of this "what I say goes" logic, and the gate agents were not able to tell the pilot to take the corn cob out, and take these passengers to their destination.

Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by devoply on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @04:10PM (#14101279)
> order a passenger removed for disrupting a flight

Passenger was not disrupting the flight in any way. Passenger was behaving properly and then was forced to leave for the convenience of the airlines at great inconvenience to himself, despite the fact that he was as entitled to remain on the flight as any other passenger -- as in this was unfair to him and him alone. It was also made clear to him that he was not responsible for being forced to leave as well as the fact that all the other passengers felt the exact same way as the passenger who was being forced to leave.

Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by ThrowawayR2 on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @04:17PM (#14101334)
I think linked article and regulation adequately address that. If the pilot asks an individual to debark, s/he is not, in fact, entitled to remain on the flight, other regulations notwithstanding.
Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by devoply on Friday April 14, 2017 @06:29AM (#14113625)
Regardless of your opinions, United is now getting sued by the doctor. So it doesn't seem like reality actually agrees with your sentiments.
Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by ThrowawayR2 on Monday April 24, 2017 @12:46PM (#14185778)
Doesn't mean a thing. One can initiate a lawsuit for the most frivolous of causes but it doesn't mean that they will win.
Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by thedudemabry on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @04:05PM (#14101240)
Even a pilot has to operate within the constraints of the law or be sanctioned. They have operational authority to do pretty much anything while a plane is in flight, but that doesn't shield their airline from the legal consequences of forcefully pulling a man from a seat in order to shuttle airline employees to their next destination.
Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by consciouskernel on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @07:06PM (#14102575)
You are wrong. Pilot in command[1] only qualifies when the plane is in flight, which is even mentioned in the quora question you linked. In flight definition requires plane to be moving under its own power. Additionally, the pilot did not tell the passenger anything. An on the ground manager did.

You have no idea what you're talking about. Please throw away your throwaway account.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pilot_in_command

Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by dang on Thursday April 13, 2017 @01:47AM (#14104444)
You've been posting uncivilly to HN. We ban accounts that do that, so would you please (re-)read the site rules and comment civilly and substantively from now on?

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

https://news.ycombinator.com/newswelcome.html

Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by consciouskernel on Thursday April 13, 2017 @03:18AM (#14104828)
> read the site rules and comment civilly and substantively

Civilly I can give you, but substantively?

> The test for substance is a lot like it is for links. Does your comment teach us anything?

I don't understand how you can claim I'm not commenting "substantively" when I'm correcting blatantly wrong info with citations.

Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by dang on Thursday April 13, 2017 @04:32AM (#14105172)
If you edit the uncivil parts out of your comments and leave only the substantive parts, that would be just fine.
Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by theandrewbailey on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @03:07PM (#14100772)
And like all corporate dick moves, it will probably be topped off with United not admitting that they did anything wrong.
Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by criddell on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @03:19PM (#14100877)
I thought it was pretty awful when some news sites started publishing information on the passenger that was dragged off.
Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by tanderson92 on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @04:23PM (#14101382)
It was worse than that; they even published information on the wrong doctor (with the same name). One was from Louisiana, the other Louisville. Shameful.
Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by kafkaesq on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @02:13PM (#14100236)
The subtext here is that customers don't have any actual rights when dealing with a large corporation.

Well, no -- they just don't have much bargaining power. Which is different.

Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by Analemma_ on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @02:26PM (#14100386)
No, the GP has it right: for all practical purposes, customers have no rights, especially when their contracts include binding arbitration clauses, since arbitration rules against the company essentially never.
Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by thanksgiving on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @02:47PM (#14100607)
> No, the GP has it right: for all practical purposes, customers have no rights, especially when their contracts include binding arbitration clauses, since arbitration rules against the company essentially never.

I don't want to make it partisan but with all due respect TOS is not the law (oh btw, please keep pushing to repeal the CFAA in the US). We don't live in a libertarian "paradise".

I've heard of anecdotes where a judge throws a pre-nuptial agreement because it was too one-sided? I think the same should apply to terms of service and arbitration clauses. They cannot supersede the law or become the law.

Something people are not talking about is why isn't there a lawsuit against the police department? They're the ones who did the actual assaulting?

Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by kevin_b_er on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @03:21PM (#14100904)
They replace the law. Supreme court decided can and does permit a total severance of your connection to courts of law against a corporation.

Your rights are replaced with a contract you didn't quite realize you agreed to. As such, you have no rights against a corporation. The arbitration kangaroo court is not required to observe the law. A meeting of the minds is not required where a contract with a corporation is concerned, as a human doesn't have to realize their rights were stripped by the contract.

When everything is privatized, you will have no rights remaining.

Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by techsupporter on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @03:13PM (#14100819)
It doesn't matter what you think because the Supreme Court has ruled that the Federal Arbitration Act, and the arbitration clauses enabled by it, is sacrosanct and denies all but the most egregious (and that bar is very high) of court challenges. Virtually all actions in court are barred by those clauses.

See, for just one example, AT&T v Concepcion.

Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by dwyerm on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @02:21PM (#14100330)
This is exactly why I'm fighting against Mandatory Binding Arbitration and Class Action Waivers. The system is slow, creaky, and arguably broken, but that's a _feature_ if it means that companies are afraid of it. I'm not having a whole lot of success in my fight, it seems.
Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by techsupporter on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @03:16PM (#14100852)
What hurts even more is that the supposedly enlightened companies that come out of Y Combinator also put in these clauses. When I asked one why, the reasoning was "our lawyers made us." Yet there seems to be no consideration that the business owner hates to be on the other side of that kind of clause all the while imposing it on his or her own customers.
Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by dwyerm on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @03:53PM (#14101129)
I empathize with them, though. It is completely rational to limit the impact of lawsuits on your organization. If someone hands you a Get Out Of Jail Free card, you take it, no matter how good of a person you think you are.
Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by techsupporter on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @04:10PM (#14101272)
I don't. I consider it to be morally objectionable to say "man, I really hate arbitration clauses as a customer" and to then turn around and say "well, I should impose arbitration clauses on my customers." Besides, limitation of risk is already possible in a variety of ways: insurance, company formation structure, and being reasonable with your customers. It is atrocious that a core feature of our constitution is so quick to be contracted away by people who are in the position to effect change.

This goes double for Y Combinator-enabled companies because they operate under the guise of being better for their people, their customers, and their industry than others.

Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by logicallee on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @02:44PM (#14100566)
>The terms of service have become so lengthy and obscure

I don't think it's fair of you to criticize either the length or the obscurity of terms of service. After all, you could replace nearly all of them with:

" 1. We have every right of every kind and can do anything, without being liable for anything.

2. you have no rights of any kind and may do nothing, except those afforded by law, which you hereby waive as far as legally possible. "

More forward-thinking startups might add something to the effect of "Of course this does not mean we are Satan! We will naturally make an effort to provide roughly the service you have paid for. However, nothing in this section should be construed as a statement that we shall not act like Satan in any particular instance. We reserve the right to be Satan at any time and our sole discretion without providing any prior written warning. You've been warned."

Did I miss anything?

Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by notacoward on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @10:23PM (#14103624)
Two important points raised by a lawyer about how to interpret the Contract of Carriage (or any other).

(1) When the meaning of a term (e.g. "boarding") is ambiguous or undefined, courts are required to interpret it in the way less favorable to the drafter of the contract.

(2) If the conditions under which one party may do something are enumerated, they may not do it for reasons other than those on the list.

Both principles of legal interpretation go against United in this case. Remember, this is civil law - not criminal. The burden of proof is very different. While many such contracts are too one-sided, rules such as these exist to ensure that they can't be entirely so. A completely one-sided contract might even violate the requirement that it involve mutual consideration, making it a legal non-entity.

Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by t0mbstone on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @04:16PM (#14101331)
An interesting comment I ran across... not sure if it's valid or not, though:

"Lawyer here. This myth that passengers don't have rights needs to go away, ASAP. Here is how United illegally kicked him off the plane:

1. First of all, it's airline spin to call this an overbooking. The statutory provision granting them the ability to deny boarding is about "OVERSALES", specifically defines as booking more reserved confirmed seats than there are available. This is not what happened. They did not overbook the flight; they had a fully booked flight, and not only did everyone already have a reserved confirmed seat, they were all sitting in them. The law allowing them to denying boarding in the event of an oversale does not apply.

2. Even if it did apply, the law is unambiguously clear that airlines have to give preference to everyone with reserved confirmed seats when choosing to involuntarily deny boarding. They have to always choose the solution that will affect the least amount of reserved confirmed seats. This rule is straightforward, and United makes very clear in their own contract of carriage that employees of their own or of other carriers may be denied boarding without compensation because they do not have reserved confirmed seats. On its face, it's clear that what they did was illegal-- they gave preference to their employees over people who had reserved confirmed seats, in violation of 14 CFR 250.2a.

3. Furthermore, even if you try and twist this into a legal application of 250.2a and say that United had the right to deny him boarding in the event of an overbooking; they did NOT have the right to kick him off the plane. Their contract of carriage highlights there is a complete difference in rights after you've boarded and sat on the plane, and Rule 21 goes over the specific scenarios where you could get kicked off. NONE of them apply here. He did absolutely nothing wrong and shouldn't have been targeted. He's going to leave with a hefty settlement after this fiasco."

Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by tanderson92 on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @04:27PM (#14101420)
That comment is quoted in TFA, no?
Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by heisenbit on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @02:12PM (#14100227)
Yes, passengers don't know their rights but pilots and other administrators should. So United personal should have known they are in a legal grey area when removing a passenger who had boarded.

I found the argument interesting that United should have lied and just invented a plane swap with a smaller body. Would have left the affected passengers is a weak position.

There is so much wrong on all levels including the reaction of the CEO. This will be a case study for long time.

Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by eridius on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @02:28PM (#14100406)
> So United personal should have known they are in a legal grey area when removing a passenger who had boarded.

From what I've read, they weren't in a grey area, they were doing something that was specifically illegal. A grey area is when it may or may not be illegal. This wasn't grey.

Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by maxerickson on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @02:35PM (#14100479)
Any of those explain why force majeure would not apply?

(I'm not implying it would, I'm curious to read an analysis that covers it)

Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by eridius on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @02:41PM (#14100532)
I am not even remotely a lawyer or qualified to actually answer this, but my guess is the situation here didn't actually prevent United from fulfilling their contracts. They just chose to ignore their contracts because they thought they could get away with it.
Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by The_Magistrate on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @02:44PM (#14100568)
Force majeure doesn't apply in this circumstance because it requires an external force or event that is unforeseeable. In this case, United didn't plan correctly for the transport of its 4 employees, something well within its capability to predict.
Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by notacoward on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @10:06PM (#14103539)
It's possible that United did plan correctly for the transport of those employees, but the employees themselves failed to follow the plan. How was it that the 3411 crew didn't even know the other crew was coming, until the very last minute? That's extremely unlikely if the other crew had been scheduled for 3411. It's more likely that they had originally been scheduled for another flight, missed it, and got to 3411 before word did (possibly because of poor communication between United and Republic). At the very best, they were later than they should have been. Why? And did they (or someone else) pressure the 3411 crew into doing what they did?

United still screwed up in a lot of ways. So did Republic. So most of all did the aviation "police" - an organization that seems to consist largely of people thrown out of CPD for exactly the kind of misconduct visible on the video. But somewhere in there I think there's a fourth group that screwed up - the people whose sudden appearance triggered the whole mess.

Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by maxerickson on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @02:48PM (#14100615)
There were massive storms in the few days prior to the incident. That could disrupt their planning.
Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by kevin_b_er on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @03:24PM (#14100922)
Their "rights" were replaced by a contract. You have no rights not enumerated in the contract of carriage. Rights are for government actions against you. In the United States, "rights" are discarded in favor of profit.
Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by revelation on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @02:39PM (#14100512)
Hence why in the EU, most terms of service are essentially meaningless. If a judge finds your clauses surprising or an undue burden on the customer, they are null and void.
Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by sjg007 on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @02:44PM (#14100562)
It's the same in the US if you go to court. There are expected warranties and consumer laws. Corporations try to take it away and use many levels of policy and obfuscation to wear you down but once you get to court you have the ball.
Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by techsupporter on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @03:18PM (#14100871)
Very often you can't get to court because of mandatory arbitration clauses that the Supreme Court has ruled are all but inviolable.
Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by helthanatos on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @02:42PM (#14100542)
But what will happen is exactly what happens with overbroad patents. It is not possible to make an agreement with someone that requires soul-bonds. This could count as unlawful eviction and assault.
Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by jpollock on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @01:29PM (#14099788)
Even if it wasn't a passenger overbooking, it was overbooking in that they failed to properly account for the likelihood of having to ship crews around their network.

If their occupancy ratio was lower, then there wouldn't have been a problem, they could have fit the crew in. If they reserved 4 seats for crew on every flight, again there wouldn't have been a problem.

If they had even reserved 2 seats and run sufficient flights such that the crew got to the target airport in time there wouldn't have been a problem.

If they had brought crew in from two different starting points - it would have been fine.

It's still overbooking, just not oversold tickets.

The airline played the game, ran too lean and paid the price.

Much like an ISP having all their IP traffic going down one pipe, and not having enough room to send out the customer invoices because everyone is watching Netflix.

Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by LeifCarrotson on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @02:04PM (#14100136)
If they had recognized that they needed 4 seats for crew before the passengers scanned their tickets and walked down the jetway as is usually done they wouldn't have had a problem.

They could have started the process before the flight booked, asking for volunteers before they got seated and attached to the idea of being on that flight. If they had no volunteers, they could probably have randomly selected passengers to deny boarding, and rejected them at the gate. While I am offended by them violently dragging the man out of his seat and off the plane, if the ticket scanner doesn't blink green the passenger likely won't force his way onto the plane, and if he was injured by security while doing so, public opinion would not be so united against the airline.

Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by differentView on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @02:22PM (#14100334)
Exactly! This wasn't the last chopper out of Saigon. Someone would have given up their seat in exchange for more money.
Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by qubex on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @02:22PM (#14100336)
...so united against United. ;)
Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by hueving on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @02:10PM (#14100197)
>The airline played the game, ran too lean and paid the price.

There's absolutely nothing wrong with this, they just didn't follow through with the correct way to free up seats, which is increasing the bid.

Some family cleared something like $13,000 in amex gift cards during the delta debacle last week by volunteering their seats multiple times. If you keep increasing the bid, you will find a price at which someone will give up their seat.

Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by lostlogin on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @02:25PM (#14100363)
Compared to the 1.6 billion that came off the stock price, anything looks cheap.
Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by cmurf on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @02:33PM (#14100454)
The current price is the same as it was 5 days ago. There's no meaningful impact to the stock price, it was a temporary retreat.
Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by ProAm on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @02:50PM (#14100624)
We dont know that yet. Lets see how this quarter and next quarter and the lawsuit turn out.
Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by huebnerob on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @01:36PM (#14099849)
In this case, semantics matter. Overbooking is a legally protected practice, but what you're trying to wedge into the definition of 'overbooking' is not.
Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by churn1 on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @01:42PM (#14099914)
If terms and definitions matter, the legal term you are looking for is actually "oversales", not overbooking which is a colloquial term
Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by eridius on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @02:29PM (#14100416)
Overbooking is generally used as a synonym of oversales. Trying to redefine overbooking right now to mean something else is just going to cause confusion.
Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by rhizome on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @02:58PM (#14100689)
There's a rhetorical difference where "overbooking" puts the onus on the customer, and "oversales" puts it where it should be: on the airline who sold the extra tickets.

And at any rate, the flight was not oversold anyway. It was merely the 4 extra United employees who put the plane over capacity.

Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by eridius on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @03:03PM (#14100731)
How can "overbooking" possibly put the onus on the customer? Overbooking is entirely within the control of the airline, and the customer doesn't have the capacity to overbook, or even the knowledge as to whether overbooking could possibly occur.

> And at any rate, the flight was not oversold anyway. It was merely the 4 extra United employees who put the plane over capacity.

Well yes, that's the whole point of this discussion, that calling it "overbooking" or "oversales" is wrong.

Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by manigandham on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @04:45PM (#14101574)
Yes, overbooking/oversales are effectively synonyms, but that's not the issue at all here. Overbooking is purchased and reserved seating over capacity.

The plane was fully booked and boarded at capacity, and then 4 more seats were cleared by physically removing passengers. Collapsing these events by saying it's an overbooking issue overlooks the very important timeline in between the plane being booked/boarded and then initiating a removal of said passengers, instead of denying them in the first place.

The request for 4 seats should've arrived before the boarding process (or at least before it ended), that's the problem.

Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by eridius on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @09:19PM (#14103300)
I don't know why you're trying to make this argument with me, since it's unrelated to the actual discussion taking place in this subthread.
Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by rhizome on Thursday April 13, 2017 @01:47PM (#14109248)
Overbooking: People bought too many tickets

Oversales: The airline sold too many tickets

It's a thin distinction to be sure, but it reads with rhetorical significance to me.

Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by eridius on Thursday April 13, 2017 @04:57PM (#14110859)
No, there is literally no distinction at all. The customer cannot possibly buy too many tickets, they can only buy as many tickets as the airline sells. So the only way to overbook is by the airline selling too many tickets.
Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by LeoNatan25 on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @01:36PM (#14099851)
Even if that is the case, there are much better methods of dealing with a situation like this than calling a police officer. It seems, like usual for American police, officers are insensitive to anything but violence; no logic, just apply force. The man is lucky they didn't taze him. The crew should have known that. It's good that this policy is about to change, but it is too little too late.
Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by LeifCarrotson on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @01:55PM (#14100030)
I assume you meant "taze", as in incapacitated him with a Taser electroshock weapon. It's an unfortunate typo, because he seemed quite thorougly distressed, disheveled and without composure - fazed.
Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by LeoNatan25 on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @02:04PM (#14100134)
Yes, thank you for the correction!
Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by LordKano on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @03:10PM (#14100794)
It seems, like usual for American police, officers are insensitive to anything but violence; no logic, just apply force.

This is correct and I believe it's by design.

Law enforcement officers are selected for high aggression and high intelligence is often/usually penalized in the screening process. In a lawsuit against New London CT, the courts found it legal to disqualify a candidate for being too smart.

Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by LeoNatan25 on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @03:23PM (#14100918)
I don't doubt it. It's not for nothing that the USA police is by large mocked around the world. Land of the free and home of the brave is quite ironic when it comes to USA police.
Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by jjtheblunt on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @02:04PM (#14100138)
Those weren't even police officers. I wonder why this can't be considered "assault", accordinly.
Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by refurb on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @02:22PM (#14100343)
My understanding is that they were police officers. Not Chicago city police officers, but rather the airport authority police officers.
Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by maxerickson on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @02:23PM (#14100344)
They seem to hire people with law enforcement qualifications:

https://chicago.taleo.net/careersection/100/jobdetail.ftl?jo...

And I imagine they must have some sort of law enforcement authority.

Doesn't mean it wasn't illegal to do what they did though.

Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by Vivtek on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @02:07PM (#14100167)
It will be.
Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by dionidium on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @01:58PM (#14100068)
It seems, like usual for American police, officers are insensitive to anything but violence; no logic, just apply force

My understanding is that there was a lengthy conversation that took place before the outrage-inducing video starts. They did attempt to resolve the situation peacefully. At some point there is an impasse. Police are making a request and he's ignoring it. There are two ways that can go: 1) Police shrug their shoulders, leave, and let the man have his way; 2) He's going to be forcefully removed.

That is, as far as I can tell, the actual reality of the situation. And anybody advocating for outcome #1 probably has some thinking to do about what it actually means to have a police force at all.

Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by LeoNatan25 on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @02:09PM (#14100188)
I expect the police to police, as in, maintain law and order. As I understand it, neither were broken at said impasse.

Again, I have come to expect very little of American police. The crew should have known better than calling the police. I blame more the crew and probably their textbook for unleashing the dogs, rather than the dogs biting.

Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by hsod on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @02:24PM (#14100360)
Edit: seems this doesn't apply because the doors hadn't been closed yet. See below

I found this law which, from a layman's perspective and based on my understanding of the sequence of events, the passenger violated: https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/49/46504

"An individual on an aircraft in the special aircraft jurisdiction of the United States who, by assaulting or intimidating a flight crew member or flight attendant of the aircraft, interferes with the performance of the duties of the member or attendant or lessens the ability of the member or attendant to perform those duties, or attempts or conspires to do such an act, shall be fined under title 18, imprisoned for not more than 20 years, or both. However, if a dangerous weapon is used in assaulting or intimidating the member or attendant, the individual shall be imprisoned for any term of years or for life."

If a flight attendant asked him to get off the plane and he belligerently refused, that would seem to be a violation of this law.

Note that I'm not arguing that the original request was justified OR that the police response was justified.

Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by cmurf on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @02:58PM (#14100691)
Your reading is flawed.

49 U.S. Code § 46501 - Definitions (1) “aircraft in flight” means an aircraft from the moment all external doors are closed following boarding— (2) “special aircraft jurisdiction of the United States” includes any of the following aircraft in flight:

And to preempt more of this nonsense, FAR 91.3 and 91.11 don't apply either, those are for operational safety purposes. This is a contract of carriage issue, and what the airline tried to do is not in that contract.

The passenger was within his right to peacefully refuse to cooperate, in this instance, as reported.

Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by hsod on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @03:05PM (#14100747)
Thanks for the clarification.
Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by andmarios on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @02:13PM (#14100239)
The article suggests that the airline was the one breaking the law and not the passenger. So in this case the police helped the airline commit a crime. Is this nowadays what means to have a police force?
Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by narrowrail on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @02:16PM (#14100274)
There are currently 18 mentions of 'police' on this page, but they were security, not police. That's a crucial detail.
Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by maxerickson on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @02:40PM (#14100525)
They were sworn law enforcement officers working for the city of Chicago.

There's room for them to have different authority than other Chicago police, I haven't found anything in a couple minutes of looking, but they aren't private security or anything like that.

Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by dionidium on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @02:18PM (#14100300)
The central thesis of my argument is that the ins and outs of each side's claims can be litigated later on. At that moment, the cops probably don't (and likely in principle can't) know exactly who is right and who is wrong and in fact this isn't at all the role we expect the police to fill.
Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by ambulancechaser on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @02:51PM (#14100631)
I believe this is correct. If there is a civil argument, it can be heard in an appropriate venue. But once the owner/operator of an FAA regulated aircraft has asked you to leave you no longer have any recourse and the word of the airplane crew carries quite a bit of weight.

I'm seeing the suggestion that United broke the law which doesn't quite seem to be what this article is saying. The article is saying they breached their own contract of carriage. This would allow for damages afterwards in civil procedures but i can't imagine how it gives the man the right to ignore the order of crew and airport police to get off the plane.

Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by notacoward on Friday April 14, 2017 @11:45AM (#14115099)
> i can't imagine how it gives the man the right to ignore the order of crew and airport police to get off the plane.

Neither 49USC§46501 nor 14CFR§91 applied at the time in question, according to applicable definitions (e.g. "crewmember" and "flight time") which anyone who presumes to interpret law can and should look up near the rules themselves. Absent either of those, the passenger had all the rights he would have in any other time and place. He had a contract establishing his right to be where he was. United/Republic had already recognized that right by allowing him to board in the first place. He had done nothing since to waive or nullify his rights under that contract. Thus, at that moment and under those circumstances, he was under no obligation to comply with the order that was given.

If they'd closed the doors, 49USC§46501 would apply. If they had left the gate, 14CFR§91 would. Those would have been different cases, but we're not here to discuss different cases. Anybody who wants to treat rules as sacrosanct should do so based on a full and accurate understanding of those rules.

Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by dionidium on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @03:01PM (#14100714)
I wouldn't even get too hung up on the "FAA regulated aircraft" portion of this, just in a general sense. You and I may have a contract that says you can use my property for a day, but then I might prevent you from doing so. This could be wildly inconvenient for you for various reasons. If I told you to leave, I wouldn't expect the cops to figure out who was right. I would expect the cops to err on the side of the property owner and make the obvious and expedient decision to evict you from my property.

The contract wouldn't even enter into it. If there's a grievance, then it should be handled later. The police aren't there to litigate that issue. They're there to resolve the immediate conflict.

Crucially, it doesn't matter that the contract is 100% in your favor. That's not what the police are there to discern.

Everybody is trying to play amateur aviation attorney, but this is really about understanding the role of police in resolving disputes like this one.

Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by notacoward on Friday April 14, 2017 @11:55AM (#14115171)
> Everybody is trying to play amateur ... attorney

Including you.

You're right that it's not the responsibility of police to determine all details of who's right and who's wrong, especially considering contracts that can take days for a trained contract lawyer to understand. They do have a responsibility to ensure that the person requesting removal is the owner of the property, and the person being removed is not a co-owner, but that's about as far as it goes.

However, that's not the only issue being discussed here. Just as we should get too hung up on the "FAA regulated aircraft" portion, we shouldn't get hung up on the "police role" portion either. The more important question is United/Republic's role. Were they in a position to require this passenger's removal, or was that breach of contract? What about the issues of crew logistics and voluntary-deboarding incentives? If you want to broaden the focus, let's broaden it all the way.

Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by cmurf on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @02:43PM (#14100556)
This is deeply naive. They are civil servants, an arm of the executive branch of government, and we expect they will do lawful things, not unlawful things to be figured out later, and only if you can afford a good attorney to do this litigation you seem to think is the appropriate default scenario.

Your position strikes me as compatible with an authoritarian police state. And that is not the system of government we have in the U.S.

It is part of the job description for police to, at all times evaluate the legality of what they're doing. Otherwise, they are just hired thugs, might makes right, let a judge sort it out. And if they are merely hired thugs, that makes them untrustworthy by default as civil servants, and will even be viewed as capricious. What's the standard of the moment?

And in fact, that's why Black Lives Matter is even a thing. The police aren't trusted in some communities, because they have so often simply reacted with force. That's what the politics requires, and is a betrayal in those communities. Use force now, sort out the injustices later (maybe). That's a recipe for loss of trust, other than, do what they say or they will beat your ass. That's not justice in any possible sense of a civil society.

Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by andmarios on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @02:43PM (#14100554)
If the police didn't know who was wrong then maybe instead of using force, they could asked the airline to cancel the flight and seek damages in a court. Then, and only then, they could remove anyone from the plane as it wasn't part of a contract anymore but just the airline's property.

Instead they chose a side to favor by force.

Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by ambulancechaser on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @02:54PM (#14100650)
> If the police didn't know who was wrong

The police won't arbitrate a civil matter.

> they could asked the airline to cancel the flight and seek damages in a court. Then, and only then, they could remove anyone from the plane as it wasn't part of a contract anymore but just the airline's property.

If they asked the airplane to cancel the flight they could then remove the man from the plane? You're arguing that if United cancelled the flight for everyone that would render the contract of carriage moot for all and then the person would no longer have a claim to a seat?

Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by andmarios on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @03:01PM (#14100721)
Yes. If they removed the passenger and the flight went on, then they would favor one party. If the flight was canceled, they would favor neither party, a much more just approach if you can't know which party is in the wrong.

If the flight was canceled, the contract wouldn't be moot but the case would need to be resolved outside the plane anyway. As the plane wouldn't be anymore part of the problem, the airline could ask for the passenger to be removed on the ground that he was trespassing. The passenger could also ask the police make sure that the plane stays grounded.

Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by EliRivers on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @03:13PM (#14100818)
Well then you worded it really badly. It reads as if you're a cheerleader for the police being corporate bully boys.
Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by daenney on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @02:01PM (#14100109)
> 2) He's going to be forcefully removed.

Yet why does the forceful removal of that passenger justify knocking him down and dragging him off the plane? There's plenty of ways to forcefully remove someone from something without doing what they did.

Police is allowed to apply force, but that doesn't immediately give them the right to go loco.

Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by dionidium on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @02:13PM (#14100237)
This, like the notion that police should aim for the knees when shooting at suspects, is one of those perennial concerns that doesn't survive contact with reality. Once force is applied, you shouldn't be surprised when things go wrong. Force is messy. Which is why, yes, it should be viewed as a last resort.

Maybe there are better ways to resolve this situation wrt to the police and the airline. But I think basic common sense says that there are much better ways this passenger could have handled it, too. At some point it must have been obvious to any reasonable person that 1) the cops weren't going to change their minds; and that 2) force would eventually and inevitably be applied to resolve the situation in their favor.

Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by LeoNatan25 on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @02:17PM (#14100286)
Once the police were there, he resolved it the best possible way for him; he stood his ground, got a little banged up, and will not be quite rich for the idiocy of everyone involved.
Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by grasshopperpurp on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @02:45PM (#14100581)
Exactly this. It's not hard to understand. If you know you're right, and you're not afraid of being assaulted, stand up for yourself; or in his case, stay seated (for the wise guys). If someone told you that you'd be entitled to millions for going through what this guy did, you'd take it 100 times out of 100.

That's not to downplay how horrendously the situation was handled. The airline deserves to pay damages, and he deserves the money. But, to suggest that he didn't help by not cooperating is one of the silliest ideas swirling around.

Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by FireBeyond on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @02:58PM (#14100692)
Given that the man was not handcuffed and indeed made his way back on to the plane, there are perhaps assumptions that can be made about how happy the officers were with the situation in general too (without resorting to any Nuremberg analogy).
Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by ahoy on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @01:38PM (#14099866)
> The airline played the game, ran too lean and paid the price.

I would argue that the unconscious paying customer with a bloody head paid the price.

Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by AnimalMuppet on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @01:43PM (#14099919)
Well, United stock went down, IIRC, $830 million dollars. That's paying a bit of a price. They may pay for it in lost sales and lawsuits, as well.

The cop got suspended. That's paying a price, too. And it may not be the end of the price he pays.

Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by seanmcdirmid on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @01:45PM (#14099943)
UAL is still up for the week. This is a normal fluctuation in the grand scheme of things, it isn't "payback" by any means.
Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by jldugger on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @02:55PM (#14100668)
Well yea, man. If UAL is so popular they have to drag people off the plane, they must be selling crazy tickets, right? And they probably have more room to raise prices than anticipated.
Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by seanmcdirmid on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @03:45PM (#14101072)
No. I only mean UAL hasn't been hit yet in pocket book about this. I agree that they should be.
Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by lostlogin on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @02:28PM (#14100409)
The article says 1.6 billion. I suppose it matters when you take the measurement.
Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by droithomme on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @01:41PM (#14099904)
You make good points. Airplanes used to have jump seats, fold down seats, specifically for accommodating these sorts of crew transfers, so that they wouldn't interfere with normal passenger seating. I wonder if the jump seats were removed at some point in order to increase normal seating.
Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by seanmcdirmid on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @01:46PM (#14099946)
They still have those, but jump seat travel isn't considered safe by FAA regulations.
Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by ubernostrum on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @01:48PM (#14099972)
If you look in the /r/aviation threads you'll see various people who are airline crew claiming they can fly jumpseat but it's beneath them and they want their regular-seat privileges enforced at basically any cost.
Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by ItsDeathball on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @03:26PM (#14100933)
This sounds plausible, and fits with the incident if basically no one trusts the airline to negotiate in good faith. Employees assume that if they don't make a fuss about getting a seat, then they'll have to fly jump-seat or standing-room-only from then on out. Likewise, passengers don't trust the airline offer of $800 and the next flight out for giving up their seat. I would have taken that offer if I could be assured it was legit, but I'd have a strong suspicion they'd deduct the cost of the flight and the hotel and give me what's left in the form of Chili's gift cards or something.

With trust that low it was probably only a matter of time before a dispute escalated into unnecessary use of force.

Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by ubernostrum on Thursday April 13, 2017 @01:48AM (#14104450)
It's worse than that, really. I've got people on reddit telling me that policy -- which they say I can only read if I FOIA it, maybe -- is that all disputes with passengers are supposed to immediately escalate to police as a first and only resort. Because "9/11", apparently.
Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by ashark on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @02:37PM (#14100496)
Don't the jumpseats have more legroom? I thought the ones I'd seen did, just by not being part of the ordinary aisles and being smaller (slimmer back especially). I'd take a milking stool over the regular seats if it meant not having my knees jammed most of an inch into the seat in front of me (and I'm not even that tall).
Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by seanmcdirmid on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @03:44PM (#14101065)
Where is the cabin crew supposed to sit during take off and landing if the jump seats are occupied by others? Also, this wasn't a 737, but a smaller plane.
Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by yincrash on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @01:55PM (#14100032)
I have definitely been on Delta flights in the last year where crew in transit used the jumpseats.
Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by mason55 on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @01:46PM (#14099950)
> run sufficient flights such that the crew got to the target airport in time

Many (some? most? warning, weasel words) airports operate at capacity so just adding more flights might not have been possible even if they wanted to

See, for example, the fights going on at Love Field over gate space

Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by xenadu02 on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @08:21PM (#14102961)
Federal law governs contract of carriage. United was legally prohibited from removing anyone from that flight to make room for crew. Period.

They broke federal law by breaking their contract of carriage. I don't know what is so difficult to understand about that.

Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by jazzyk on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @02:06PM (#14100159)
No, the real failure (and the source of this and many other issues in the airline industry) is the lack of competition in the US domestic market.

Pure and simple.

The huge, 350-million US domestic market is served by 4-5 major airlines, while the EU with 500 million people is served by tens of airlines. I recently flew from Barcelona to Nice for 30 euros, round-trip (with seat assignment).

Where are the (potentially Mexican or Canadian-based) low cost airlines? That's right, none to be seen.

Let's hope this bust-up brings some legislative measures to introduce more competitive practices in the airline industry.

Otherwise we will soon be paying for the right to pee in-flight really soon.

Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by martinald on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @02:55PM (#14100660)
I don't know if it's just airlines that have competition problems in the US. I actually think it's the airports that the problem.

In the EU, many (most?) airports are privately owned. In the US, they're almost always state owned. Furthermore, the Port Authority generally owns all the airports in the area.

In many EU areas, that's not the case. There's 6 airports in the London area and they all compete to offer the lowest landing fees to win airlines.

Ryanair capitalised on this and really injected all the competition in the market by only flying from 'secondary' airports.

I'm not sure the same thing could happen in the US. There isn't the same level of competition for airports, and without that I think it's hard for any airline to really make any difference.

Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by strictnein on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @02:23PM (#14100350)
> "Where are the (potentially Mexican or Canadian-based) low cost airlines? That's right, none to be seen."

I'm in the upper midwest and we have two or three low cost airlines. Sun Country is the biggest (and based in MN). Spirit Airlines also has a decent presence. Sun Country flies to lots of places. First class ticket to Anchorage cost me ~$700 last time I flew with them, less than an economy seat on Delta.

Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by mark-r on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @05:31PM (#14101958)
I'm taking a flight this weekend with Sun Country, MN to DC round trip for $180. Booked two weeks ago.
Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by slantedview on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @02:19PM (#14100310)
Who are you saying no to? From the article:

> the lousy economics of airlines combined with their oligopoly status in the US says they will be extremely reluctant to make anything beyond bare minimum changes

It sounds like you agree with the author.

Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by jazzyk on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @02:25PM (#14100362)
I was really commenting on the part of the title "...a reporting and management problem", and on the comments in this thread splitting hairs over whether it was overbooking or over-selling - and completely missing the bigger point.

Which is understanding the cause, not looking at the symptoms.

Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by rconti on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @03:04PM (#14100737)
Foreign carriers are not allowed to operate domestic flights within the US.
Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by yladiz on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @02:13PM (#14100234)
Why would what happened to United being more competitive practices? I don't see the connection.
Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by jazzyk on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @02:21PM (#14100323)
The airlines can set up any rules they wish (with the FAA being complicit), because they know consumers (passengers) don't have much choice - they need to fly, driving is usually not an option in the US.
Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by yladiz on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @02:31PM (#14100437)
> driving is usually not an option in the US

If you mean by distance, sure, but you can drive anywhere in the US, and there are a lot of people that do choose to drive semi-long distances (10-12 hours) over flying when fuel is cheap because they enjoy driving. It's less of an option when the distance is something like 30-40 hours, i.e. from LA to NYC.

Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by jph on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @01:51PM (#14099991)
This is a new kind of UI/UX dark pattern. The United app lets customers pay for seats, and any reasonable person thinks that's the whole of it. But the fine print says that's not true, and says you can be forcibly removed if the flight is oversold.

https://darkpatterns.org/

"When you use the web, you don’t read every word on every page - you skim read and make assumptions. If a company wants to trick you into doing something, they can take advantage of this by making a page look like it is saying one thing when it is in fact saying another."

Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by Vivtek on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @02:09PM (#14100193)
No. The fine print does not say that. The fine print says they can deny you boarding, not remove you once already boarded. Your point about the dark pattern is all too true, but United still behaved entirely illegally here.
Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by scrumper on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @04:27PM (#14101419)
It's still denied boarding, and would be so until the doors were closed, so he wasn't technically boarded at the time he was removed. (And they can remove you for all sorts of reasons even after you've boarded.)

United behaved despicably, but not illegally.

Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by CyberDildonics on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @05:06PM (#14101747)
So someone with their luggage checked, their carry on stowed, and already in their seat is not boarded? Do you have a source that says this?
Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by tunesmith on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @02:11PM (#14100221)
But that is explicitly not true, that is what the article is about. You cannot be forcibly removed if the flight is oversold. That's the whole point.
Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by drfuchs on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @02:06PM (#14100163)
Why didn't they just keep doubling the offer for volunteers? Surely by $1600 or $3200 someone would bite. Then everyone is happy, it all gets finished quickly, and there's no chance of this sort of PR disaster (even docile removees can end up in the news if they then, say, miss the death of a hospitalized family member due to the delay).
Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by LeoNatan25 on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @02:15PM (#14100258)
Because handbook says a certain amount is the maximum they can offer, and likely the crew offering more would risk their job. Following this fiasco, Munoz said they will expand the handbook. We'll see.
Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by drfuchs on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @02:49PM (#14100621)
Right; the question is "Why is it not the policy of United to keep doubling until they get enough takers?"
Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by strictnein on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @02:24PM (#14100357)
Also, I think there's actually a government regulation which caps it at $1300 or so.
Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by differentView on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @02:30PM (#14100426)
The cap is the maximum of what passengers are legally entitled to. The airlines can offer more if they want.
Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by menssen on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @02:53PM (#14100640)
I've been wondering: does this mean that a valid response to this situation would be "I will leave the plane if given my legally entitled $1350"?

As in, among other reasons, is United in the wrong here because the maximum they offered for volunteers was $800, not the regulated $1350?

Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by differentView on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @03:10PM (#14100799)
The way I understand it is that they can offer any amount they want to get volunteers. But if they want to involuntarily bump someone, they have to pay at least four times the one-way fare that passenger paid, up to $1,350.

So bumping the person that paid the least for their ticket would mean they have to pay them the least.

Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by wflynny on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @03:27PM (#14100937)
See the Involuntary Bumping subsection under Overbooking in [1]. The airline is obligated to give you either:

    `min(2 * your ticket price, $675)`; or 
    `min(4 * your ticket price, $1350)`
depending on how quickly they can reroute you to your destination. You also have legal standing to demand they pay you with a cashier's cheque instead of a voucher.

Judging by personal anecdotes I've read around the web, airlines may be willing to pay more if they are in a bind. But note that this whole voluntary/involuntary bumping procedure happens before you scan your ticket and board the airplane.

[1]: https://www.transportation.gov/airconsumer/fly-rights

Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by MichaelGG on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @02:35PM (#14100476)
How could that possibly be true? The USG isn't going to limit what a company can voluntarily give to a customer.
Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by strictnein on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @02:53PM (#14100644)
There's a lot of nonsense regulations that different industries lobby to be put in place. I mistook the fact that there's a cap with what the airline is obligated to pay with what they are allowed to pay.
Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by colmvp on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @02:58PM (#14100693)
> This seems to reflect the deep internalization in America of deference to authority in the post 9/11 world, as well as reporters who appear to be insufficiently inquisitive. And there also seems to be a widespread perception that because it’s United’s plane, it can do what it sees fit. In fact, airlines are regulated and United is also bound to honor its own agreements.

I'm extremely pro-journalism (donate to various organizations, listen to podcasts hosted by journalists) but I'm completely baffled by how very few if any journalists dived into the details on what happened here in the very video, specifically the legalities and technicalities, compared to Redditors (who happen to be laywers) and bloggers. Going forward, readers who happen to be consumers and passengers could easily be adopting misinformation spread by trusted media sources and have the wrong frame of reference to view what happened.

Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by cmurf on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @02:26PM (#14100377)
I definitely agree with the criticism that the media has focused on the video, as "shockertainment" rather than educating their viewers. The awareness of the law and skepticism in media is lacking, they pretty much disseminated incorrect relevant details. Many would decry a 46 page contract of carriage, but then also not aid the viewer in navigating that complex document.

At the very least, a journalist should ask the airline and the police: -has a crime been committed? -has a civil contract been committed? -what breach of law or contract has been committed and can you cite this exactly? -do you often threaten passengers with removal? -how often are you asked to do non-criminal passenger extractions on behalf of the airline? which airlines?

Either the passenger committed a crime to cause forced removal, and it seems clear he didn't commit a crime (nor was in breach of the contract of carriage); or the police committed the crime of assault, an unlawful use of force. There's a crime here either way, and that outcome I think is interesting.

But no less interesting is that United appears to have a track record of using threats of violence to get passengers to do things that are not at all required by law, regulations, or their own contract of carriage. http://www.latimes.com/business/lazarus/la-fi-lazarus-united...

That passenger decided to acquiesce to the threats, and ended up having no real meaningful recourse, i.e. even for this reasonably affluent person, it wasn't worth it to sue.

Basically the contract is next to meaningless. This is might makes right. And if you won't stand your ground, aren't willing to get wrongfully arrested, and then sue at your own expense, the airline's threats will work and they'll get what they want.

Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by ryanmarsh on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @01:59PM (#14100080)
I've been saying for years that the only thing holding back massive disruption in the airline industry is the FAA.

American and United are two of the most poorly run mega-corps in the US. Customers hate them, but need to fly. Warren Buffet thinks they're notoriously bad investments. Why?

Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by yladiz on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @02:08PM (#14100176)
There are a lot of regulations for airlines like American, but considering, for example, that there's nothing you can do at 35,000 feet in a giant metal machine if there's a mechanical failure, I'm much happier that there are a lot of regulations than not enough, in this case. There are a lot of things that suck about air travel in the states, but the FAA isn't one of them.

As far as the companies being bad investments, it's most likely due to their extremely low margins and ROI.

Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by ryanmarsh on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @04:01PM (#14101196)
Safety and Regulation are two partially overlapping sets.

The FAA regulates an immense amount of things that are trivial and those regulations are very hard to update. The FAA issues the vast majority of regulations[0].

[0]: https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/search?conditions%...

Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by jameskilton on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @02:36PM (#14100484)
Flying is the safest form of transport because of the FAA. Yes there are a ton of rules and regulations, but the vast majority exist for a very good reason and the FAA is very good at cracking down on offenders. Why? Because the consequence of failure is so high that we can't afford not to.

Get rid of the FAA and it's only a matter of time before what was illegal ends up taking down a full airliner, killing hundreds or even thousands of people and ruins flying for everyone.

Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by ryanmarsh on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @04:03PM (#14101216)
> but the vast majority exist for a very good reason

I don't know how you can back that up. Who has done an analysis on the percent of them that have made a material impact on safety.

> Get rid of the FAA

I didn't say that. I just said they're in the way of innovation and customer satisfaction. Maybe we don't have to be extreme. Maybe we could just modernize them?

Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by TerminalJunkie on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @02:02PM (#14100122)
Isn't Berkshire Hathaway UAL's largest shareholder?

http://www.marketwatch.com/story/warren-buffetts-big-bet-on-...

Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by ryanmarsh on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @04:03PM (#14101222)
You managed to google for Warren Buffet's investment in UAL but didn't manage to find any of his statements of how bad the airlines are?

This still doesn't refute my primary argument.

Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by chrisper on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @02:28PM (#14100412)
I don't think the FAA is bad. It's the companies that are. What disruptions do you need? Other airliners can provide service just fine even though they have to follow FAA rules when flying to and from the US.
Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by ryanmarsh on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @04:07PM (#14101255)
The FAA stands in the way of innovation and sees it's job as supporting a healthy industry. Which can only mean one thing...

https://www.gpo.gov/fdsys/pkg/CHRG-113hhrg86618/html/CHRG-11...

Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by untog on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @02:27PM (#14100390)
Apparently Warren Buffet has changed his mind in recent years and invested in airlines. Largely because of what you describe: consolidation means people have no choice but to use them.
Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by ryanmarsh on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @04:05PM (#14101232)
That kind of proves my point.
Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by tanderson92 on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @04:36PM (#14101496)
He's smart so he bought other airlines as well. As Matt Levine pointed out today, while Buffett lost money on UAL yesterday, he more than made up for it with gains in other airlines which were up on the news. He said: "Boycotting United to fly another airline is just what United's index-fund owners want you to do"
Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by hysan on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @02:45PM (#14100587)
If the information in this article is true, which seems to be the case after reading most of the linked sources, then a lot of the news articles that were cited are reporting false information. Now that immediately made me curious to see if Google Fact Check would flag these news articles as false or possibly false. Doing a quick search shows no Fact Check under any of the search results, so seems like the answer is no.

If Fact Check really becomes a thing, I hope that Google will be able to use current events like this as a bar for how fast Fact Check needs to respond to an event to make it useful. If they could find and source well researched information and immediately flag misreported news articles while a topic is at the forefront of the news, then it would immensely help educate people. For example:

My parents have not stopped talking about this since it happened and are still looking at and reading news about it. There was some misreported information that I had to clear up for them. If Fact Check worked, then it definitely would have prevented misinformation spreading to them and probably many others.

Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by throw7 on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @04:09PM (#14101268)
There really isn't clarity here. The article argues that the flight wasn't overbooked, therefore UA couldn't kick anyone off. I agree if it wasn't overbooked, but it's not clear that that's evidently true. It's certainly gonna be contentious and probably up to a judge or jury to decide if it actually gets that far. I doubt it.

The more pressing matter is what do you do as a passenger when YOU are involuntarily denied boarding due to overbooking? Are you gonna sit in place, say, "I don't believe you." and wait for the stasi to take you away for a beating?

Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by gspetr on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @07:03PM (#14102563)
I believe this is exactly the kind of thing that will be resolved by the tools the market provides.

If they wanted volunteers to fly the next flight instead of this, they should have offered more than $400. Kind of like an auction: $500, $600, etc. and eventually enough people would have been incentivized to take the deal.

The company failed at that and now their competitors will get their business and increase their market shares at United's expense.

IANAL, but they might even be facing a very expensive lawsuit and will have to settle.

The market will ultimately work things out, I don't think the FAA should intervene much.

Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by ikeboy on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @01:48PM (#14099974)
So how many people will get fired over this?
Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by AlexandrB on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @02:59PM (#14100699)
My guess is it will be like the Wells Fargo fiasco. Some low-level employees - probably the staff that worked that flight - will lose their jobs while those that actually created the policies that led to this will be just fine.
Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by rconti on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @03:06PM (#14100761)
Just announced yesterday: Wells Fargo clawing back $75M in comp from the 2 execs.

https://www.nytimes.com/2017/04/11/business/dealbook/wells-f...

Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by dguo on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @03:05PM (#14100759)
In the Wells Fargo case, the CEO actually did resign (http://www.npr.org/sections/thetwo-way/2016/10/12/497729371/...). Though he was replaced by the COO.
Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by rargulati on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @02:15PM (#14100263)
On overbooking, this is a solved problem: hold an auction where the max payoff is the risk in dollars X, distributed amongst Y passengers (the number of seats you need to free up). Start at some low anchor point ("$300 to get off the plane") and increment up until you have takers. If the total value exceeds X, write it off - you messed up.

I believe other airlines implement this in some capacity.

Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by robbiemitchell on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @02:19PM (#14100312)
Yes, but to be clear: it wasn't overbooked.
Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by strictnein on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @02:19PM (#14100302)
United does too. They just stopped at $800 and then went the random route. They could have gone higher.
Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by FireBeyond on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @03:09PM (#14100789)
Yeah, there's also video from just prior to this incident where multiple people say "We'll get off for $1500" and the purser literally laughs and says "Yeah, that's not going to happen. People are going to need to leave the plane or it won't take off."
Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by jksmith on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @03:05PM (#14100750)
Seems to me that what is most unfortunate is that surrounding passengers didn't support the passenger dragged off the plane. 4 or 5 people standing up and threatening something along the lines of "Why don't you take my seat too jackass; I don't want it anymore" would have been far more effective at righting this situation than proper media reporting or crying about passenger contracts.
Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by Ductapemaster on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @03:12PM (#14100813)
While that sounds like a nice thing to do on a personal level, it distracts from the real issue at hand - poor service and handling of a situation that was bad from the start. I strongly disagree that the passengers should have stepped up and taken the fall for poor practices from United. People don't need to be better humans - companies need to be held accountable for their actions and act better towards their customers.
Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by jksmith on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @03:36PM (#14101007)
>>companies need to be held accountable for their actions and act better towards their customers.

Exactly.

Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by CharlesW on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @03:08PM (#14100780)
Maybe in those few minutes, but in the long run a high-publicized international incident will be a million times more effective in creating conditions for improvements.
Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by speby on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @06:03PM (#14102175)
Has everyone watched the video? There is a point in the video where "things went wrong" and it happens right before the officer makes the decision to physically touch the passenger and begin to assault him in order to remove him.

Immediately before that point, there are a multitude of things that could have been done or done differently. The choice was made by that one individual to physically take hold of the passenger who was ultimately, peacefully, declining to deplane.

For example ... the officers could have:

1. Explained to the passenger and everyone around him about how he is single-handedly delaying everyone else's arrival home right now.

2. Gave several warnings, spaced out appropriately over time, that increased levels of escalation will be involved, up to and including the point of physical removal. In other words, telling him he will be forcefully removed against his will for not obeying the law.

... and so on with certainly more creative approaches that I wouldn't necessarily expect a typical police officer to think of and/or employ.

Re:United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Fa... by Mithaldu on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @06:17PM (#14102253)
The officers should've told the flight staff they're outside their legal rights.