Re:When People Ate People, a Strange Disease Emerged
by Bjorkbat on Monday April 10, 2017 @05:16PM
(#14082635)
True, but one might argue that it's at least a step in the right direction if you're really worried about transmissible prions.
Re:When People Ate People, a Strange Disease Emerged
by adrianN on Monday April 10, 2017 @03:39PM
(#14081867)
Prions are nature's grey goo.
Re:When People Ate People, a Strange Disease Emerged
by maxerickson on Monday April 10, 2017 @03:44PM
(#14081904)
I would put bacteria in that role and call them green goo.
One thing I find interesting is that gray goo would have to compete with bacteria for resources. I'm not sure that it would necessarily be easy.
Re:When People Ate People, a Strange Disease Emerged
by jcoffland on Monday April 10, 2017 @04:10PM
(#14082098)
Prions are not alive and therefore do not need to compete for resources to further their existence.
Re:When People Ate People, a Strange Disease Emerged
by computerphage on Monday April 10, 2017 @04:59PM
(#14082496)
If "not alive" => "doesn't need resources", then "needs resources" => "alive". That doesn't seem right to me.
Re:When People Ate People, a Strange Disease Emerged
by DiThi on Monday April 10, 2017 @05:23PM
(#14082690)
That's a deductive fallacy. Alive things need resources, but things that need resources are not necessarily alive.
Re:When People Ate People, a Strange Disease Emerged
by computerphage on Tuesday April 11, 2017 @03:44AM
(#14085636)
It's not a fallacy. The truth table for implication and its contrapositive are the same.
A | B | A => B | ¬B => ¬A
T | T | T | T
T | F | F | F
F | T | T | T
F | F | T | T
My original point was that my parent was implicitly claiming that only living things need resources. That seemed absurd to me because of things like viruses, companies, governments, etc.
Re:When People Ate People, a Strange Disease Emerged
by irisli on Monday April 10, 2017 @05:55PM
(#14082902)
computerphage wasn't using deduction but rather contraposition. (A -> B) => (!B -> !A). The absurdity of (!B -> !A) shows that (A -> B) is not true for all cases.
Re:When People Ate People, a Strange Disease Emerged
by pvg on Monday April 10, 2017 @05:20PM
(#14082662)
"All cats die. Socrates is dead. Therefore Socrates is a cat."
Re:When People Ate People, a Strange Disease Emerged
by ajnin on Monday April 10, 2017 @07:06PM
(#14083349)
No. Mirroring the parent would be : "All cats die. Socrates is immortal. Therefore Socrates is not a cat." Which is perfectly valid logic.
Re:When People Ate People, a Strange Disease Emerged
by uzoodoo on Monday April 10, 2017 @09:30PM
(#14084153)
More like: "Non-living things don't move. The bus moves. Therefore, the bus is alive."
This is false because there exist things that are non-living but move.
Similarly, the original "not alive" => "doesn't need resources" argument is false because there exist things that are not alive that do need resources (such as buses), and so needing resources does not imply being alive.
Re:When People Ate People, a Strange Disease Emerged
by pvg on Monday April 10, 2017 @09:11PM
(#14084066)
I'll let Eugène Ionesco know.
Re:When People Ate People, a Strange Disease Emerged
by Sophistifunk on Monday April 10, 2017 @05:14PM
(#14082617)
That's... not how logic works.
Re:When People Ate People, a Strange Disease Emerged
by ianterrellwt on Monday April 10, 2017 @05:41PM
(#14082807)
I think that might be how logic works. The fallacy seems to be with its parent.
Re:When People Ate People, a Strange Disease Emerged
by andrewflnr on Monday April 10, 2017 @07:57PM
(#14083647)
You don't need to hedge. That's exactly how logic works.
Re:When People Ate People, a Strange Disease Emerged
by Sophistifunk on Monday April 10, 2017 @07:21PM
(#14083440)
"Alive implies needs-resources" is not the same as "needs-resources implies alive"
Re:When People Ate People, a Strange Disease Emerged
by dpark on Monday April 10, 2017 @07:39PM
(#14083547)
Of course not. And if he'd said "alive implies needs resources", the argument would not be valid.
ianterrelwt posted the article explaining this.
Re:When People Ate People, a Strange Disease Emerged
by computerphage on Tuesday April 11, 2017 @03:46AM
(#14085646)
Yes... it is.
Re:When People Ate People, a Strange Disease Emerged
by ssambros on Monday April 10, 2017 @06:21PM
(#14083057)
That's exactly how logic works.
Re:When People Ate People, a Strange Disease Emerged
by jcoffland on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @02:28PM
(#14100410)
I said, "do not need to compete for resources to further their existence." This is not the same as "do not need resources."
Re:When People Ate People, a Strange Disease Emerged
by xkcd-sucks on Monday April 10, 2017 @05:59PM
(#14082921)
They absolutely compete for resources, in the form of peptides that can fold into more prion aggregates or other proteins
Re:When People Ate People, a Strange Disease Emerged
by maxerickson on Tuesday April 11, 2017 @08:01AM
(#14086852)
Now that the giant logic thread has played out below I feel I have to point out that I was saying that technological gray goo would have to compete with green goo, I wasn't talking about prions competing for resources.
Re:When People Ate People, a Strange Disease Emerged
by webkike on Monday April 10, 2017 @05:47PM
(#14082857)
I have read on Wikipedia that lichens degrade prions, so I disagree with that analogy
Re:When People Ate People, a Strange Disease Emerged
by dnautics on Monday April 10, 2017 @03:37PM
(#14081851)
of course, you can still get CJD/kuru genetically, sporadically, from bone marrow transplants, etc.
Also: fatal familial insomnia, but that is a dramatically different pathology and we don't know why it's different from CJD.
> When researchers fed hamsters grass that grew on ground where a deer that died with chronic wasting disease (CWD) was buried, the hamsters became ill with CWD, suggesting that prions can bind to plants, which then take them up into the leaf and stem structure, where they can be eaten by herbivores, thus completing the cycle. It is thus possible that there is a progressively accumulating number of prions in the environment.
Source: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prion