Re:When People Ate People, a Strange Disease Emerged
by ajnin on Monday April 10, 2017 @07:06PM
(#14083349)
No. Mirroring the parent would be : "All cats die. Socrates is immortal. Therefore Socrates is not a cat." Which is perfectly valid logic.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:When People Ate People, a Strange Disease Emerged
by uzoodoo on Monday April 10, 2017 @09:30PM
(#14084153)
More like: "Non-living things don't move. The bus moves. Therefore, the bus is alive."
This is false because there exist things that are non-living but move.
Similarly, the original "not alive" => "doesn't need resources" argument is false because there exist things that are not alive that do need resources (such as buses), and so needing resources does not imply being alive.