Re:When People Ate People, a Strange Disease Emerged
by computerphage on Monday April 10, 2017 @04:59PM
(#14082496)
If "not alive" => "doesn't need resources", then "needs resources" => "alive". That doesn't seem right to me.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:When People Ate People, a Strange Disease Emerged
by DiThi on Monday April 10, 2017 @05:23PM
(#14082690)
That's a deductive fallacy. Alive things need resources, but things that need resources are not necessarily alive.
Re:When People Ate People, a Strange Disease Emerged
by computerphage on Tuesday April 11, 2017 @03:44AM
(#14085636)
It's not a fallacy. The truth table for implication and its contrapositive are the same.
A | B | A => B | ¬B => ¬A
T | T | T | T
T | F | F | F
F | T | T | T
F | F | T | T
My original point was that my parent was implicitly claiming that only living things need resources. That seemed absurd to me because of things like viruses, companies, governments, etc.
Re:When People Ate People, a Strange Disease Emerged
by irisli on Monday April 10, 2017 @05:55PM
(#14082902)
computerphage wasn't using deduction but rather contraposition. (A -> B) => (!B -> !A). The absurdity of (!B -> !A) shows that (A -> B) is not true for all cases.
Re:When People Ate People, a Strange Disease Emerged
by pvg on Monday April 10, 2017 @05:20PM
(#14082662)
"All cats die. Socrates is dead. Therefore Socrates is a cat."
Re:When People Ate People, a Strange Disease Emerged
by ajnin on Monday April 10, 2017 @07:06PM
(#14083349)
No. Mirroring the parent would be : "All cats die. Socrates is immortal. Therefore Socrates is not a cat." Which is perfectly valid logic.
Re:When People Ate People, a Strange Disease Emerged
by uzoodoo on Monday April 10, 2017 @09:30PM
(#14084153)
More like: "Non-living things don't move. The bus moves. Therefore, the bus is alive."
This is false because there exist things that are non-living but move.
Similarly, the original "not alive" => "doesn't need resources" argument is false because there exist things that are not alive that do need resources (such as buses), and so needing resources does not imply being alive.
Re:When People Ate People, a Strange Disease Emerged
by pvg on Monday April 10, 2017 @09:11PM
(#14084066)
I'll let Eugène Ionesco know.
Re:When People Ate People, a Strange Disease Emerged
by Sophistifunk on Monday April 10, 2017 @05:14PM
(#14082617)
That's... not how logic works.
Re:When People Ate People, a Strange Disease Emerged
by ianterrellwt on Monday April 10, 2017 @05:41PM
(#14082807)
I think that might be how logic works. The fallacy seems to be with its parent.
Re:When People Ate People, a Strange Disease Emerged
by andrewflnr on Monday April 10, 2017 @07:57PM
(#14083647)
You don't need to hedge. That's exactly how logic works.
Re:When People Ate People, a Strange Disease Emerged
by Sophistifunk on Monday April 10, 2017 @07:21PM
(#14083440)
"Alive implies needs-resources" is not the same as "needs-resources implies alive"
Re:When People Ate People, a Strange Disease Emerged
by dpark on Monday April 10, 2017 @07:39PM
(#14083547)
Of course not. And if he'd said "alive implies needs resources", the argument would not be valid.
ianterrelwt posted the article explaining this.
Re:When People Ate People, a Strange Disease Emerged
by computerphage on Tuesday April 11, 2017 @03:46AM
(#14085646)
Yes... it is.