Sounds like someone scripted an Ajax-Json-API-Call to Google Servers.. today's equivalent of writing a small shell script.. "wow, I piped grep, had I done this by hand in C this would have taken me days" would have been the tweet in the 80s.. what did they call it back then, Gopher?
And actually it was even simpler than that. No coding involved - I did this with nothing more than a handful of IFTTT recipes. Hook it up to Google, listen for "Home" commands, and send them to a Google Spreadsheet. I have one for each type of entry I wanted to log - meals, symptoms, medications. Planning to add activities and some general exercise capturing when I have another 20 minutes (ha).
And I'll add some biometric logging, although my ultimate goal would be to actually script that to get data directly in from my BP monitor and a scale automatically. Same with sleep data from the app I use to track that. Both would be easier if I were using one of the devices or apps for tracking those that IFTTT supports.
The idea is to set up and collect as much as I can with as little manual entry (i.e., typing) as possible, with as little coding as possible.
Exacly. Pipes and grep functionality are great abstractions that have saved people countless hours.
The fact that there are a lot more easy to use tools today means things are easier to do today, and are going to keep getting easier.
There's no such thing as "real" tools; there are only different models of risk. If you're building a system that needs speech recognition, what you should care about is the risk that the next recognition won't be correctly interpreted, and the odds of that are probably greater for a local installation of PocketSphinx than for a Google service, even including the possibility of it "going away".
I don't think that programming is a good opportunity for automation, because I think programming is something that humans are actually very good at. In order to write a program, you have to figure out what functionality would be useful to a person, both to elicit latent specifications and to intuit what would be acceptable for things that are not precisely specified. Anticipating what a person would want requires having a theory of mind and understanding the experience of being human. That's about the hardest task in all of computer science. It's also the thing that people are probably best at. On top of just making it work, it has to work well enough be cost-competitive with employing a person.
If we ever get to that point, there will be so few jobs left for humans that almost everyone on earth will be a programmer. So it won't cost very much to employ one.
Right now, is there any natural language system that can appropriately correct the punctuation on these sentences (not meant rhetorically)?
SPLINTERS WEAR SHOES
PANDA EATS, SHOOTS AND LEAVES
Are you setting up for a joke about a gun-toting panda at diner, who left the scene of a crime? Are you paraphrasing an informational sign at a zoo about a black and white animal?
Assuming you're not trying to go for a bit of clever wordplay, however, plug the panda sentence in Google Translate and it'll correctly translate "leaves" to be the plant, and not the verb tense of "to leave", in the chosen destination language.
TechCrunch discussed Google's internal representation of language[1] which implies that while the computer doesn't have a concept of the animal and its food sources, it recognizes that "panda" has something to do with "leaves" as being related to plants rather than "to leave".
Google Translate's far from perfect, but as poor as it is, it was once considered impossible to advance to where it is now.
[1]https://techcrunch.com/2016/11/22/googles-ai-translation-too...
You can't parse conversations effectively without a social context, because a lot of the meaning is implied by the context. The words themselves are more like pointers into the context, and are never a full description of the meaning. (See also: "Make me a sandwich".)
So when someone on HN says "Time flies like an arrow, fruit flies like a banana" the context tells a human reader that the real meaning is "This is a meta-sentence illustrating a point about grammar, context, ambiguity, and NLP. It does not mean I am saying anything specific about flies, time, arrows, fruit, or bananas."
The contextually correct response would be to continue with a different comment about AI. Or maybe to make a context-bending joke. (But not on HN, where the context doesn't allow that.)
Every so often someone in AI rediscovers this idea and tries to model it, but for some reason it keeps being forgotten. It's been around since at least the 1970s, but so far as I can tell modern statistical ML largely fails to be interested in it.
With respect to creativity becoming more important relative to technical ability-- I think that both will be important.
In fact the price for most art is very low, below the cost of materials, or free. This implies that demand for art is very, very finite.
Andy Warhol's whole point was that the art that sells for real money has nothing to do with art. It's a sale of association with social status, and the physical art itself is superfluous.
Demand has multiple dimensions. There is only demand for so much quantity of art, but competition can drive the quality up indefinitely.
This has been happening for a long time. Back in the 80's and 90's, most of the major tech companies had their own derivative of UNIX because it made sense (sort of) to have their own in-house OS. Now almost everything is Windows, Linux, or MacOS. It would seem very strange for any company to go off and do their own thing rather than use one of those three.
As it is now, we - as humans with programming skills, not professional programmers employed by few select corporations and their subsidiaries - might never hit that point because we'll be prevented from doing so. Trusted computing, DRM, SaaS model and various other things together conspire to take away the ability to run Turing-complete programs on our own machines. It's something we need to keep in mind too.
Now we're in a situation where we produce most goods that society needs (and a lot that we don't need) yet there are fewer jobs. This is absolutely going to get worse, but we shouldn't be thinking of robots as any different to the market forces that have been going on for years. Something has to give.
Before, automation only impacted the jobs of blue collar workers so nobody cared. Now it impacts the jobs of white collar workers so everybody is starting to whine.
Karl Marx, etc already wrote about a kind of devastating "singularity" that is here and now at the roots of many social, physical and spiritual ills.
As per Josef Pieper – it's all about leisure.
School especially so:
"The Greek word for leisure (σχολή) is the origin of Latin scola, German Schule, English school. The names for the institutions of education and learning mean leisure."
In this potential world of abundant leisure we just need to get back to good old sharing – because sharing means caring!
For everyone else, Leisure the basis of culture is worth reading and relevant here.
But finding a realistic economic system where the benefits of automation don't just benefit the top x% and lead to a morlocks and Eloi society is HARD!
There are all kind of possible ideas. Just the other day I read about, instead of taxing corporations, make that a minority percentage is owned by the society. Not without its problems, but sounds like it would line up some bad incentives that we see now in action.
At the end of the day, we always go back to who owns the means of production.
As is always the case with humans, change it's not going to happen until we are in real trouble. Maybe not even then.
I thought sharing meant copyright infringement! ;-)
I think not.
It is not very different than the political handling of man-made global warming. The solution is for affluent nations like the US to reduce its standard of living and cede more control to international bodies. We can debate the merits of the science all we want, but the solution put forward promotes a pre-determined political agenda.
We're seeing the same type of thing starting now with the talk of the automation crunch. Ideas like UBI are declared the solution and a shift to greater reliance on government because we will all soon be unable to have good enough jobs to look after ourselves.
Where is this solution put forward? By what politicians is this "political handling" being done? What legislation has been proposed, let alone passed?
It's not that they're so different as such; it's the scale and speed of change that's different.
Every new level of abstraction leads to new capabilities and new demands. You may have to learn new technology or move in a different direction, but I'm pretty sure software development as an industry is pretty safe unless we develop strong AI.
Higher levels of abstraction allow people to build virtual goods that are more complex and there is no foreseeable limit to the desire for more complex goods virtual goods, and no real physical limit.
Programmers ended up getting more work. Whatever the computers displaced is where the jobs diminished.
In this case, I actually did create it that quick while lying in bed, and used nothing more than IFTTT and a Google Spreadsheet. I probably should have mentioned "without coding" in the original tweet to be clear about that, cause I think it's a pretty big factor.
Literally anyone with the least bit of tech savvy and a recent Android phone could do this, and it's actually more effective than the original web app I used.
Edit: clarified the time it took
How many programmers were knocked out by C?
Are you assuming it's a small number? It seems reasonable to assume that without WordPress we might have another 10,000 web designers. Or 100,000. Or 0. Or -10,000 if WP theme design increased the size of the web industry. We don't know.
These sorts of notionally statistical questions breakdown when you try to use "common sense" or logic-but-without-data to answer them. We have no way of knowing what might have happened without WordPress.
Remember those "website for $100” ads? All gone.
How many code-monkeys (who are real humans with real needs) can't find a job now because modern high level languages take out so much of the monotony of programming in the 50s?
How big would MS have to be if all code was written in Assembly?
I think the increase in prevalence of software since C was created provides some empirical evidence that this dynamic was occurring (and perhaps still is).
WordPress is a bit trickier as it allows non-technical people to implement working software. However, isn't there a booming market of WordPress devs who do more complex customizations? Such work is different than being a full stack engineer at Google, but it is still a technical role that produces software.
In fact, you can be a business owner, set aside a Sunday, and you're done. You don't need to hire anyone
That was essentially my point.
Just wait until things go wrong (for whatever reason).
We're looking at a similar situation in the programming, ops, and IT support areas.
A friend of mine Tweeted this the other night: "I'm sleepless so I just created a voice-based health tracker using Google Assistant in about 20 minutes that took me wks to write 3 yrs ago." [2]
I've heard numerous anecdotes of "A Zapier account and 20 minutes of fiddling with things just replaced a SAAS app/consultant, etc. we were paying for."
This is what automation looks like: the top 10% in a profession doing 100x the work previously done. To date the appetite for more and more software development (eating the world) has sufficed, but there is no guarantee that will always be the case.
1 - http://www.bbc.com/news/business-38747485
2 - https://twitter.com/Raelshark/status/843776684407111680