News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Programming won’t be automated, or it already has been by jordwest on Wednesday March 22, 2017 @05:27PM (#13935143)
I don't understand the constant focus on the upcoming automation crunch. Efficiency improvements (through automation and otherwise) have been happening over the past several decades - more output with less jobs - where the majority of the benefits go to the owners of the clockwork.

Now we're in a situation where we produce most goods that society needs (and a lot that we don't need) yet there are fewer jobs. This is absolutely going to get worse, but we shouldn't be thinking of robots as any different to the market forces that have been going on for years. Something has to give.

Re:Programming won’t be automated, or it already has been by bsder on Wednesday March 22, 2017 @10:02PM (#13936890)
> I don't understand the constant focus on the upcoming automation crunch. Efficiency improvements (through automation and otherwise) have been happening over the past several decades - more output with less jobs - where the majority of the benefits go to the owners of the clockwork.

Before, automation only impacted the jobs of blue collar workers so nobody cared. Now it impacts the jobs of white collar workers so everybody is starting to whine.

Re:Programming won’t be automated, or it already has been by vacri on Thursday March 23, 2017 @12:38AM (#13937410)
To be fair, I think a modern day professional carpenter would much rather work with modern power tools than what carpenters had to use at the dawn of the Industrial Revolution. Modern-day miners much prefer using their heavy machinery than swinging a pickaxe and pushing a trolley. I can't see many modern-day blue-collar workers volunteering to go back to the old ways in order to increase employment counts.
Re:Programming won’t be automated, or it already has been by gremlinsinc on Thursday March 23, 2017 @01:26AM (#13937571)
Pretty sure the carpenter will complain when anything made w/ wood can just be put through a 3d 'wood' printer and come out flawless, or a device that basically can take a block of wood, or 4x4s and construct just about anything without any human intervention. Won't be long before mining operations are all manned by drones and not a single human. This isn't sci-fi, it's near-future tech.
Re:Programming won’t be automated, or it already has been by flukus on Thursday March 23, 2017 @02:23AM (#13937742)
Mining is already there, bringing a mine online is human intensive, but when that's done most of the mining is automated.
Re:Programming won’t be automated, or it already has been by candiodari on Thursday March 23, 2017 @03:22AM (#13937918)
But when AIs start to program we as programmers have a simple solution : we simply bring them into a meeting with marketing and product management and let the result natural suicidal impulse take care of those suckers.
Re:Programming won’t be automated, or it already has been by return0 on Thursday March 23, 2017 @03:42AM (#13937978)
But programming is blue collar work!
Re:Programming won’t be automated, or it already has been by TheOtherHobbes on Thursday March 23, 2017 @05:04AM (#13938258)
Maybe more accurately, it's blue collar work that is sometimes encouraged to think it's white collar work.
Re:Programming won’t be automated, or it already has been by macawfish on Wednesday March 22, 2017 @06:02PM (#13935413)
People like Ray Kurzweil prophecy about a time when human "intelligence" is replaced in value. But what about human work? It is something deeper and at least as precious, our freedom to be physically integrated with one another and and with the physical environment we are embedded in.

Karl Marx, etc already wrote about a kind of devastating "singularity" that is here and now at the roots of many social, physical and spiritual ills.

Re:Programming won’t be automated, or it already has been by musha68k on Wednesday March 22, 2017 @07:18PM (#13935984)
Aristotle would have been OK with that. Work simply is "non-leisure" and therefore shouldn't be aspired to per-se.

As per Josef Pieper – it's all about leisure.

School especially so:

"The Greek word for leisure (σχολή) is the origin of Latin scola, German Schule, English school. The names for the institutions of education and learning mean leisure."

In this potential world of abundant leisure we just need to get back to good old sharing – because sharing means caring!

Re:Programming won’t be automated, or it already has been by rubidium on Wednesday March 22, 2017 @08:16PM (#13936399)
Never thought I'd see Pieper referenced on HN. Great point and reference.

For everyone else, Leisure the basis of culture is worth reading and relevant here.

But finding a realistic economic system where the benefits of automation don't just benefit the top x% and lead to a morlocks and Eloi society is HARD!

Re:Programming won’t be automated, or it already has been by RobertoG on Thursday March 23, 2017 @05:41AM (#13938404)
It's not so hard to find it, it just it sounds too much as socialism.

There are all kind of possible ideas. Just the other day I read about, instead of taxing corporations, make that a minority percentage is owned by the society. Not without its problems, but sounds like it would line up some bad incentives that we see now in action.

At the end of the day, we always go back to who owns the means of production.

As is always the case with humans, change it's not going to happen until we are in real trouble. Maybe not even then.

Re:Programming won’t be automated, or it already has been by throwaway2048 on Wednesday March 22, 2017 @07:43PM (#13936161)
I doubt the multi billionares are going to be open to the idea of sharing.
Re:Programming won’t be automated, or it already has been by dkersten on Thursday March 23, 2017 @05:29AM (#13938354)
because sharing means caring!

I thought sharing meant copyright infringement! ;-)

Re:Programming won’t be automated, or it already has been by TeMPOraL on Thursday March 23, 2017 @06:23AM (#13938578)
I'd say both, and that's why I think we need to loosen up on the copyrights a bit :). Too much "intellectual property" protection is harmful to society.
Re:Programming won’t be automated, or it already has been by flukus on Thursday March 23, 2017 @02:26AM (#13937755)
I'm not sure if we should be taking lessons from people who's leisure time was created from slavery. Arisotle was the ancient equialent of billionaires who's family can live forever off of interest/investments
Re:Programming won’t be automated, or it already has been by mfukar on Thursday March 23, 2017 @04:54AM (#13938230)
Aristotle's contemporaries who claimed "nature has made nobody a slave" also held similar, if not the same, views on leisure. Of course, you could argue all Athenians really took others into slavery by virtue of war, or their unquestioned military superiority of the time. The question is, is hypocrisy actually contradictory to Aristotle's views?

I think not.

Re:Programming won’t be automated, or it already has been by Kaizyn on Thursday March 23, 2017 @06:09AM (#13938522)
The new focus on the 'automation push' is for political reasons and not for any other real concerns. Ask yourself what changes in society are being agitated for the most? What is being put forward for the solution to the automation push?

It is not very different than the political handling of man-made global warming. The solution is for affluent nations like the US to reduce its standard of living and cede more control to international bodies. We can debate the merits of the science all we want, but the solution put forward promotes a pre-determined political agenda.

We're seeing the same type of thing starting now with the talk of the automation crunch. Ideas like UBI are declared the solution and a shift to greater reliance on government because we will all soon be unable to have good enough jobs to look after ourselves.

Re:Programming won’t be automated, or it already has been by coolgeek on Thursday March 23, 2017 @10:17PM (#13946059)
> The solution is for affluent nations like the US to reduce its standard of living and cede more control to international bodies. We can debate the merits of the science all we want, but the solution put forward promotes a pre-determined political agenda

Where is this solution put forward? By what politicians is this "political handling" being done? What legislation has been proposed, let alone passed?

Re:Programming won’t be automated, or it already has been by pilsetnieks on Thursday March 23, 2017 @06:39AM (#13938641)
> we shouldn't be thinking of robots as any different to the market forces that have been going on for years

It's not that they're so different as such; it's the scale and speed of change that's different.

[dead]
Re:Programming won’t be automated, or it already has been by ianai on Wednesday March 22, 2017 @10:58PM (#13937111)
Maybe people don't react rationally? Maybe we wind up in a world where you don't want to be in anything remotely seeming part of the government. Think French Revolution.