News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:'My life was ruined by a typo' by yeukhon on Tuesday March 21, 2017 @07:17PM (#13927160)
I was recently hospitlized. The EMT took my id card and entered my name incorrectly (YUEK as opposed to YEUK). I told the nurse and she said there is nothing she can do about it until I check out the hospital.

I waited until I checked out the hospital, and the nurse took my information down. For my situation, I have to follow up with specialist. The clinic received my medical information and the referral from the hospital. The clinic also got the typo from the hospital, plus the wrong insurance information, as well as the wrong cell phone number. I was amazed at the wrong insurance (hospital gave them my dental insurance, but I received a notice from my health insurance regarding my hospital admission before I visited the clinic). How funny. When I went back to confirm my appointment a few days later, the clinic said no one correct my name (wtf?).

What a joke. While I was getting admitted into the hospital for a few nights, the nurses had to pair up in order to figure out how to enter data into the system. The program looks like Excel except it isn't. In some cases you have to enter the data in a different column, in some cases you have to enter 0, in some cases you leave it out. The nurses kept saying "oh I remember you have to do this to get around this issue, oh I think you can ignore this option."

When I met with the nurse practitioner the next day, he couldn't log into his system. I told him I work as a DevOps and he was curious about my role. Then he said he has to call the IT support (managed solution) somewhere in Tennessee and all the vendor would say is try again later). Yeah, after meeting 30 minutes he was able to login.

Here is the thing - typo can ruin life, typo can take away money and time for fixing error, can cause divorce and all sorts of other bad things. Insurance, Social Security, government IDs, Diploma, etc.

There is no reason, in my funny but pretty frustrating anecdote, for hospital to run so inefficient, relying on systems built by incompetent people, product dedicated by policy makers or administrators who really are out of touch with real life (they don't use the system).

You know, I am angry, I want to reform hospital software system.

Re:'My life was ruined by a typo' by cyberferret on Tuesday March 21, 2017 @07:26PM (#13927226)
I am amazed that a lot of systems don't allow changing of information once entered. I signed up with a new ISP a couple of years ago - one of the biggest ISPs in Australia, and during the phone conversation to set up my plan, the operator heard my first name wrong, substituting a 'v' with a 'b'. I didn't realise during the call (because, well, it IS hard to pick up that nuance audibly) until they sent me my sign on links which of course had the typo in my username. Billing information is also all wrong.

When I told them about it, their response was pretty much "Oh, too bad - once that username is created, it is there for life. You will have to shut down that account and create a new one", meaning I lose all the benefits I got from the promotional transfer.

So I just put up with a wrong first name whenever I sign on or ask for support from them. I still think it is strange that some second or third level support engineer can't just change that info in the database for me, after the proper authentication. I can't believe that something so easy to create over the phone can be so hard to change over the phone.

Re:'My life was ruined by a typo' by traviscj on Tuesday March 21, 2017 @11:02PM (#13928188)
If this is the type of error you want to minimize, NATO phonetic alphabet [1] is worth learning. (Amateur radio is a good place to practice, though I'll admit I'm a bit rusty.)

I actually kinda enjoy these minor discrepancies, because it exposes who has sold my customer data and to whom -- though I've never gone as far as giving anyone intentionally incorrect data with this purpose in mind. I remember my parents also being amused with these copied mistakes, and with greater frequency. Seems plausible that the error rate goes down when most of my utilities/accounts were self-created online instead of typed in from a handwritten form or during an onboarding phonecall.

[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NATO_phonetic_alphabet

Re:'My life was ruined by a typo' by cyberferret on Tuesday March 21, 2017 @11:27PM (#13928266)
Ironically (being a former pilot), I DID use radio phonetics when spelling out my name - I just wish ALL call centre staff used the same baseline too.. :)

Me: That's ABCD as in Alpha, Bravo, Charlie, Delta. Them: So, that's Alpha, Burger, er, Charles, Diamond??

Re:'My life was ruined by a typo' by ajford on Wednesday March 22, 2017 @12:37PM (#13932349)
That's one of my pet peeves... There's an official phonetic letter system, why don't they train these people in call centers to use them?

My last job used radios for site communication, and everyone had to use the NATO phonetics, and was provided with a cheat sheet for learning. You'd think that would be something they could tape up in every cube in a call center...

Re:'My life was ruined by a typo' by unscaled on Wednesday March 22, 2017 @06:38PM (#13935693)
Or better yet, upgrade our phone system to bleeding-edge high-fidelity CD quality with 44.1khz and 16 bits.

It's not a natural law that phone audio quality has to suck.

Re:'My life was ruined by a typo' by viraptor on Wednesday March 22, 2017 @03:02AM (#13928973)
Even with a phonetic alphabet, you can still run into issues. Some people are just surprised when they hear it. "P for Papa" / "was that P as in Patrick?" Sigh... I'm seriously considering changing my surname to something that's trivial to understand in English.
Re:'My life was ruined by a typo' by kaishiro on Wednesday March 22, 2017 @07:41AM (#13930109)
Man, my surname is a basic color and people still get it wrong sometimes.
Re:'My life was ruined by a typo' by mrSugar on Wednesday March 22, 2017 @08:35AM (#13930361)
Well, #00ff00 could be difficult to dictate over the phone... :-)
Re:'My life was ruined by a typo' by cafard on Wednesday March 22, 2017 @09:30AM (#13930708)
Sorry, Gray with an "a" or Grey with an "e"?

(Teachers knew in high school for three or four years never quite figured out whether my surname was the Danish or the German variation of a common patronymic. I feel your pain.)

Re:'My life was ruined by a typo' by talmand on Wednesday March 22, 2017 @04:29PM (#13934580)
Try living with almand instead of almond.
Re:'My life was ruined by a typo' by kayfox on Wednesday March 22, 2017 @08:56AM (#13930482)
My surname is Fox.

Its very hard for CS agents to spell correctly.

Re:'My life was ruined by a typo' by bryondowd on Wednesday March 22, 2017 @10:10AM (#13931001)
Hello Mr. Focks.
Re:'My life was ruined by a typo' by billpg on Wednesday March 22, 2017 @06:19AM (#13929747)
I once gave a phone number over the phone using Nine-er for 9. Operator thought I said "Nine Oh" (or 90).
Re:'My life was ruined by a typo' by methou on Thursday March 23, 2017 @10:26PM (#13946107)
I once used NATO phonetics over the phone with a Blizzard representative, there's a Z in my name, so they guy called me Mr. Zulu since then.
Re:'My life was ruined by a typo' by pluma on Wednesday March 22, 2017 @09:12AM (#13930587)
"B for bacon and eggies. E for the egg in bacon and eggies. A..."
Re:'My life was ruined by a typo' by Karlozkiller on Wednesday March 22, 2017 @03:44AM (#13929121)
My friend was trying to get an account with his ISP to his apartment. The ISP got data from the landlord, my friend noticed that he was in fact getting internet for another apartment completely.

He first told them to cancel the deal, then tried again, same wrong apartment number registered, he called the ISP and the response was, "yes we know it's the wrong one, but we've mapped that apartment to your apartment on our side, so all is good."

How would it play out legally if I sign a contract where delivery is to be made to X but I want it to Y, but they tell me to sign it anyways because they can fix it in their end. I mean, what I signed would not be what I wanted, how so I prove this if my wish is not fulfilled?

Re:'My life was ruined by a typo' by komali2 on Tuesday March 21, 2017 @07:53PM (#13927394)
>lose all the benefits from promotional transfer

Were you not able to direct the person on the phone to recreate the account for you, and to include all benefits, and then some for the inconvenience?

I've always gotten what I wanted from US ISPs. Say what you want about their evil business practices, but it sure is easy to get whatever weird shit you're asking for with simple "ok, you can't give me this? Please escalate to your manager / please transfer me to retention."

Re:'My life was ruined by a typo' by philovivero on Wednesday March 22, 2017 @01:17AM (#13928636)
I am curious your life experience that makes you assume fixing the errors is doable with a phone operator. I'm from California, and my assumption is no, the person on the phone wouldn't be able to recreate the account with benefits/promotion.

In my experience with phone staff in any large org, once an error is committed, it's generally a one-way street. Attempts to get the person to fix things lead to worse and worse problems, more damage, more problems.

My experience with T-Mobile seems typical: simply wanted to take monthly plans of myself and wife (both with TMbl) and combine into a single family plan. By the time the ordeal was done, I'd forfeit the remainder of my month's payment into the plan, had no functional phone, was being bounced between two different departments neither of whom could fix it, and both of whom insisted the other was the one to fix it.

In the end I just let the money go and moved my phone number onto a competitor. I have no faith the competitor will fare better if some error is made.

Re:'My life was ruined by a typo' by btschaegg on Wednesday March 22, 2017 @03:22AM (#13929044)
Funny story:

My ISP actually closed my contract earlier this year. Out of the blue, I got a phone call from someone about "my cancellation". After some puzzled minutes the operator figured out that someone else with the same name cancelled their account but didn't state a customer ID or his address, so they went on to cancel mine. The operator told me he'd correct this, but a month later my internet access went down all the same.

After some back and forth to get it back up, the next supporter I had on the line said that they actually tried to cancel the cancellation, "but it was already too late for that" and the system didn't let them. That was surely one of the bigger WTF moments I had with support so far.

Re:'My life was ruined by a typo' by chris_wot on Wednesday March 22, 2017 @06:37AM (#13929826)
If the typo was in the name and you cancel because of it, then you should just tell them this isn't your name and thus the contract is invalid. If they claim it is, then tell them if that's the case, why do you refuse to correct an obvious error? And until they do, the contract is null and void.
Re:'My life was ruined by a typo' by komali2 on Wednesday March 22, 2017 @03:30PM (#13933985)
> In the end I just let the money go

So, I've had pretty much your exact experience with T-Mobile, but I never did this. I just called and called and called. I'd stay on hold while I lifted or was driving around, it was no skin off my bones. When I had a person, I'd always repeat "this is exactly I want in no uncertain terms. Do you understand? Can you get me this? No? Please transfer me to your supervisor / retention." For some reason, they'd always transfer me up. I've almost never heard "no" to a transfer request. I've never not gotten what I wanted.

So maybe I'm just waaaaay more annoyingly persistent? :P I probably have notes raging at my dickishness on every account I hold.

Re:'My life was ruined by a typo' by got2surf on Wednesday March 22, 2017 @03:15AM (#13929021)
Anecdotally, I've had bad experiences with T-Mobile (similar issues with customer service reps messing up a plan transfer, and being unable to fix it), but I've found Verizon reps to be more able/willing to fix things.
Re:'My life was ruined by a typo' by chrisper on Tuesday March 21, 2017 @08:47PM (#13927672)
That reminds me of American Express. My firstname is Christopher, but it seems parts of their system have a very short length limit. So when they send letters and emails, they call me "Christophe". It is spelled correctly on my card, though
Re:'My life was ruined by a typo' by cardamomo on Tuesday March 21, 2017 @11:34PM (#13928290)
I'm also a Christopher. For the longest time, in the upper right corner of Amazon.com, there was a sign-out link that said, "Not Christ...?"
Re:'My life was ruined by a typo' by SmellyGeekBoy on Wednesday March 22, 2017 @08:45AM (#13930413)
Heh, mine has always just been my first initial. "Welcome, R!". Also when I buy Kindle ebooks the default option is "Send to R's Kindle".

I have no idea where this info is stored as the details on my billing / shipping addresses have my correct (full) name.

Re:'My life was ruined by a typo' by kagamine on Wednesday March 22, 2017 @04:15AM (#13929247)
I've seen that too, "Welcome Christ..."
Re:'My life was ruined by a typo' by abrowne on Tuesday March 21, 2017 @09:24PM (#13927844)
A high school classmate's name was Joseph Longname, which the attendance system displayed as "LONGNAME, Jose".
Re:'My life was ruined by a typo' by kagamine on Wednesday March 22, 2017 @04:15AM (#13929242)
Windows had this length limit all the up to and including Win8, my work login which included a 3 letter domain and backslash was too long for Windows, so they cut the last 3 letters of my name off so that I could be logged in. It's made logging in to to some work services difficult, I'm not always sure they are asking for full ID like email address, or the truncated version.
Re:'My life was ruined by a typo' by in_the_sticks on Wednesday March 22, 2017 @08:17AM (#13930273)
10 isn't much better if you're using a Microsoft account. My email follows the format "[email protected]" (and is coincidentally the exact same character count). My user directory gets shortened to "fmlas".
Re:'My life was ruined by a typo' by Angostura on Wednesday March 22, 2017 @05:26AM (#13929534)
I also have a truncated first name thanks to Virgin Media in the UK. Mind you, the same bozos also limit password length to 8 or 10 characters, so they are generally hopeless.
Re:'My life was ruined by a typo' by raverbashing on Wednesday March 22, 2017 @06:10AM (#13929699)
I think that for letters it is to avoid names that overflow name tags

So it's better for them to send a mail to LongName LastName than to LongNameSomethingHere where the last name fell outside of the tag

And as your card shows, the full name is on the DB

Re:'My life was ruined by a typo' by pluma on Wednesday March 22, 2017 @09:21AM (#13930646)
Except you would expect that it's basic design to account for both very short names ("Li Pho") and reasonably long names ("Christopher Tannenbaum-Greenspan").

If your name tags don't work with slightly longer names, your name tags are broken, not the names.

OTOH these days I'm happy when receiving mail from the US if the address wasn't mutilated by converting Unicode to ASCII or using HTML escapes. Especially when ordering things to my company address, which has an ampersand in the company name and an umlaut in the city.

Re:'My life was ruined by a typo' by raverbashing on Wednesday March 22, 2017 @09:43AM (#13930794)
Your name tags are a function of the space allocated for the address on a letter (which is printed in bulk)

They're doing exactly what you mentioned in the first line, so big names are identifiable on letters with size limits for the address

Re:'My life was ruined by a typo' by joering2 on Tuesday March 21, 2017 @08:36PM (#13927614)
Might be as simple as some genius designed database using usernames instead of ids for relations in tables.

Trust me - I seen things like this before (with huge companies where dev soft costed millions of USD). Probably same story here.

Re:'My life was ruined by a typo' by mjevans on Wednesday March 22, 2017 @01:17AM (#13928635)
Or worse, someone designed the database correctly, but then added a (hidden to the user) unique identifier that's normalized in some way to make it short, unique, and limited on allowed characters.

Often /that/ doesn't get updated when they update the username, leading to mass confusing since external tooling will use that as the subject identifier instead of actually being given a proper internal identifier. (Offhand I can't recall if any particular standard happens to require that such an identifier start with a letter; at least one probably does.)

Re:'My life was ruined by a typo' by chris_wot on Wednesday March 22, 2017 @06:38AM (#13929837)
And this is why you should always use synthetic keys.
Re:'My life was ruined by a typo' by eganist on Wednesday March 22, 2017 @09:16AM (#13930619)
> I am amazed that a lot of systems don't allow changing of information once entered.

For systems where cell-level change logging on the order of years is a requirement, this doesn't surprise me. Many providers would rather prohibit edits rather than risk having to greatly expand logging requirements.

Re:'My life was ruined by a typo' by luca_ing on Wednesday March 22, 2017 @06:43AM (#13929850)
> Oh, too bad - once that username is created, it is there for life.

So what happens if you change your name, e.g. because of marriage?

Twitch.

Re:'My life was ruined by a typo' by brokenmachine on Wednesday March 22, 2017 @01:10AM (#13928608)
I had a similar experience with an Australian ISP, although not with a typo.

When I moved house I had to make up a new username/email. They couldn't just change my address, they had to create a whole new account.

I'm looking at you, TPG. Truth be told, they have been a fine ISP, other than that WTF.

Re:'My life was ruined by a typo' by kagamine on Wednesday March 22, 2017 @04:23AM (#13929282)
Similarly, my job lets me claim a part of the monthly internet bill as a work-from-home expense, but my ISP cost me 6 months expenses because they couldn't transfer the account to my name from my SO's. Same last name, same address. To start a new account they wanted a sign up fee equal to about 3 months of said expenses. Employer would not accept a copy of the bill in my SO's name (same surname, same address) citing tax fraud, which surely would have been our own breach of law if we both had been making the same claim on the same bill.

Bureaucracy won again. Until we got a different operator at the ISP who worked out that they could add my name as if the account was landlord & renter scenario, so there could be an owner and another who was responsible for payment.

Re:'My life was ruined by a typo' by tim333 on Tuesday March 21, 2017 @09:28PM (#13927859)
Same thing for Hacker News - you can't change your username and keep your karma. I guess the designers just don't design for that. https://www.quora.com/Why-cant-I-change-my-username-on-Hacke...
Re:'My life was ruined by a typo' by Dylan16807 on Tuesday March 21, 2017 @11:00PM (#13928180)
A brand new HN account is worthless, so typos don't matter because you can make a new account and redo your single post.

Changing a name that was correct is a totally different problem from a typo at ingest.

Re:'My life was ruined by a typo' by mayoff on Tuesday March 21, 2017 @09:55PM (#13927964)
I wouldn't want an HN user to be able to ditch her reputation while keeping her karma.
Re:'My life was ruined by a typo' by CM30 on Wednesday March 22, 2017 @06:18AM (#13929743)
Given your profile shows all your comments and submissions (and would likely still show them if only the name was changed), I'm not sure what the big deal is here.
Re:'My life was ruined by a typo' by mayoff on Wednesday March 22, 2017 @11:02PM (#13937124)
You learn to recognize the names of active users that post in threads you're interested in. I shouldn't be able to ditch that recognition but keep my karma, and you shouldn't have to look through my history to see if I'm someone you previously recognized.
Re:'My life was ruined by a typo' by CM30 on Thursday March 23, 2017 @07:53AM (#13938958)
Eh, maybe I don't see it. I mean, I use a lot of internet forums running scripts like XenForo and IPB, and those let you change your 'display name' whenever the hell you like. Yet I still recognise everyone perfectly fine. There are people on my forums that change their display name, avatar and signature on a weekly basis. I still recognise them just fine.

Same works on Discord too. There you can change your name whenever the hell you feel like it. Again, doesn't stop most people recognising you.

Re:'My life was ruined by a typo' by axlprose on Tuesday March 21, 2017 @10:27PM (#13928065)
Perhaps not in that case, but regardless, this is the kind of thing should be designed in deliberately as a feature (with an option to bypass it under special circumstances), rather than some accidental/arbitrary technical limitation just because the dev team didn't bother to implement the ability to update the field for whatever reason.
Re:'My life was ruined by a typo' by cookiecaper on Tuesday March 21, 2017 @10:29PM (#13928068)
The difference is that changing your username creates a completely new identity. It's not just correcting a typo.
Re:'My life was ruined by a typo' by kevingadd on Tuesday March 21, 2017 @10:49PM (#13928135)
HN encourages people to pick their real names as usernames (or a variant of such) for 'real identities', but ignores the reality that people change their names when they get married. Is getting married a completely new identity? Now the username doesn't actually identify the poster by the name people might recognize, if they gained their rep after getting married.
Re:'My life was ruined by a typo' by grzm on Tuesday March 21, 2017 @10:57PM (#13928169)
HN encourages people to pick their real names as usernames

From what I've observed, HN encourages people to use consistent identities, not necessarily real names. 'dang has mentioned a number of times that pseudonymity is fine.

Re:'My life was ruined by a typo' by labster on Wednesday March 22, 2017 @05:00AM (#13929425)
Workaround: Don't change your name when you get married. Less work, it makes genealogy research for your descendants easier. And the only downside is people guess the wrong name because of all the patriarchy.

There are always exceptions. I have a friend who had a bad history with her family, so she really wanted to take her husband's name. But I still believe that keeping your pre-married name is usually the best choice if you don't want your identity to be lost or subsumed.

Re:'My life was ruined by a typo' by pluma on Wednesday March 22, 2017 @09:27AM (#13930678)
That's incredibly dismissive of couples who decide to pick a shared family name. There are more downsides than people guessing wrong, but that's beside the point. You're basically arguing that the only reason people do it is patriarchy and giving up your native name is giving up your identity as if it were a form of oppression.
Re:'My life was ruined by a typo' by labster on Wednesday March 22, 2017 @03:11PM (#13933790)
Eh, people choose oppression for themselves all the time. We have a right to determine our own identity, for sure. It's just unfortunate that people just happen to make the choice that supports patriarchy the most often, that you wonder what forces are really in play.
Re:'My life was ruined by a typo' by cookiecaper on Tuesday March 21, 2017 @10:55PM (#13928160)
I don't know their policy, but I would guess that if someone has a reasonable explanation like this (or some other small change that doesn't materially affect the ability of readers to recognize the user), the HN team will try to be accommodating. They have always been responsive and gracious to me on the handful of occasions that I've contacted them, although I'm sure my questions were annoying.
Re:'My life was ruined by a typo' by kevingadd on Wednesday March 22, 2017 @01:00AM (#13928580)
I've asked before, they said no.
Re:'My life was ruined by a typo' by pluma on Wednesday March 22, 2017 @09:30AM (#13930701)
My guess: the underlying database uses usernames as a primary key and they don't want to update all the comments and submissions just to make a specific user happy. Especially because doing it once would set a precedent for others.
Re:'My life was ruined by a typo' by cookiecaper on Wednesday March 22, 2017 @12:33PM (#13932308)
I doubt they'd use the username as the primary key, but either way, I agree the precedent is the biggest concern. They'd get inundated with name change requests if they started making exceptions for people.
Re:'My life was ruined by a typo' by brokenmachine on Tuesday March 21, 2017 @10:44PM (#13928113)
The point is that it doesn't need to be that way. Why can't username be an editable field?
Re:'My life was ruined by a typo' by cookiecaper on Tuesday March 21, 2017 @10:52PM (#13928147)
Because it creates a new identity. The only way anyone on HN can recognize you is your username. Changing it at will would allow anyone to shed their identity on HN at any time while keeping the karma and account privileges they've accumulated.

Perhaps that is something that's worth allowing, and iirc dang et al have made some vague statements that they may be interested in allowing that at some point, but the ramifications would be substantial. This isn't something that should be taken lightly, nor should it be expected/implicit that a social site will accommodate new identities on-demand.

Re:'My life was ruined by a typo' by brokenmachine on Wednesday March 22, 2017 @01:16AM (#13928626)
> Because it creates a new identity.

And?

My anonymous (to everyone but the NSA) username will be a different anonymous username. The karma/privileges are entirely dependent on the quality of my posts, not some inherent value of the username. Also the posts that generated that karma would still be there under the new username.

I'm not too concerned either way , but I don't see why that would be a big deal.

Re:'My life was ruined by a typo' by TeMPOraL on Wednesday March 22, 2017 @06:12AM (#13929709)
Again, identity. You're not anonymous here, you're pseudonymous. Believe it or not, but I do actually recognize a lot of people here by their HN usernames, and I would mind if those were to randomly change all the time.

Anyway, I suspect that if you e-mail HN mods, they could be able to correct your username in no time. But making it any easier than that would, IMO, be harmful to community.

Re:'My life was ruined by a typo' by raverbashing on Wednesday March 22, 2017 @06:13AM (#13929720)
> but I don't see why that would be a big deal.

Yes, you don't. But forum managers have been aware of the issue for years

It's a feature that's very easily abused.

Re:'My life was ruined by a typo' by brokenmachine on Wednesday March 22, 2017 @09:07PM (#13936634)
What is the abuse? Changing your meaningless identifier?

Despite your explanation, I still don't see any actual damage. I made up the identifier in the first place. Why should anyone care if I change it? All my posts will remain my posts.

The only thing is that maybe some people who remember my posts with the old username won't recognize the new name as the same poster, which I don't see as a significant issue. Is that a problem for forum managers? I would have thought they would have problems with people creating multiple new accounts and spamming, not changing the username of existing accounts.

Please explain, I'm honestly curious. Maybe I'm missing something?

Re:'My life was ruined by a typo' by raverbashing on Thursday March 23, 2017 @04:03AM (#13938052)
> who remember my posts with the old username won't recognize the new name as the same poster, which I don't see as a significant issue. Is that a problem for forum managers?

Yes, because people will abuse it. If you keep track of violations (especially in moderated forums) it's important to know who did what. And while your primary key on the DB might still be the same, people don't know it, they know your nickname.

Some people would change it every time they comment just for the sake of it

New account creations have some kind of gatekeeping/email verification so it's not as efficient, and admins have ways of checking if this was done with the purpose of evading a ban for example

But if you want to change it because you made a typo or for a similar reason admins usually let you do it (they have to change it for you though)

Re:'My life was ruined by a typo' by Firadeoclus on Wednesday March 22, 2017 @06:15AM (#13929727)
That can be addressed within the UI. E.g. display the old name next to the new name for a few weeks. After that, just leave a symbol indicating that this username has a change history, which could be presented on click or hover.
Re:'My life was ruined by a typo' by Mtinie on Tuesday March 21, 2017 @07:31PM (#13927265)
Immutability of names may be a perceived benefit and a feature, vs. simply poor UX.

Regulatory, perhaps?

Re:'My life was ruined by a typo' by yeukhon on Tuesday March 21, 2017 @07:42PM (#13927323)
Regulatory is a process, so if there's a process... we can correct name on a typo on our passport, why not in this case? Either the regulatory is really really stupid (we never thought of it!), or the company bought a bad system.
Re:'My life was ruined by a typo' by okket on Tuesday March 21, 2017 @08:18PM (#13927520)
Amazing that in the age of git and Merkle trees it is still hard to change something plus keeping an immutable history of the changes for documentation/accountability purposes. This should be a basic requirement for any sane system nowadays.
Re:'My life was ruined by a typo' by sly010 on Tuesday March 21, 2017 @08:49PM (#13927680)
It is how most databases, filesystems and distributed systems work, so we know how to build those things, we don't even need merkle trees.

And despite the fact that many real world problems can be better modeled with an append only log and a derived state, somehow 99% of software systems opt to store the derived state only.

Re:'My life was ruined by a typo' by emodendroket on Tuesday March 21, 2017 @08:42PM (#13927648)
Hard to imagine any situation whatever where someone's name would change so that definitely makes a lot of sense.
Re:'My life was ruined by a typo' by titanix2 on Tuesday March 21, 2017 @08:58PM (#13927719)
That may be right in your culture but it is not universally true. For example in Taiwan the law allow one to change name twice[1]. I met someone whose mother was actively searching for a more lucky name before graduation (thus reducing expected paperwork).

In France too where there is some provisions to change its name. Someone in my town who was running a business did it. His family name was Hittler, which has you guess was quite heavy to handle, and change it for Hittier.

[1] http://www.taipeitimes.com/News/taiwan/archives/2010/05/30/2...

Re:'My life was ruined by a typo' by emodendroket on Tuesday March 21, 2017 @09:09PM (#13927773)
It's actually not right in my culture at all; it's blindingly obviously wrong.
Re:'My life was ruined by a typo' by brokenmachine on Tuesday March 21, 2017 @10:48PM (#13928130)
What are you talking about?

Women usually take the surname of their husbands in western countries.

Edit: oh, sorry I thought you were being serious.

Re:'My life was ruined by a typo' by Mtinie on Tuesday March 21, 2017 @09:47PM (#13927933)
Of course there are a huge number of reasons why you would want to have the ability. I don't agree with the system requirements, I was trying to figure out why it may be that way.
Re:'My life was ruined by a typo' by okket on Tuesday March 21, 2017 @08:47PM (#13927674)
Marriage.
Re:'My life was ruined by a typo' by emodendroket on Tuesday March 21, 2017 @08:52PM (#13927693)
Yeah, that's what I was getting at.
Re:'My life was ruined by a typo' by thomasfoster96 on Tuesday March 21, 2017 @09:08PM (#13927765)
Friendly suggestion: The italics didn’t help the sarcasm come across any easier.
Re:'My life was ruined by a typo' by emodendroket on Tuesday March 21, 2017 @09:10PM (#13927778)
So what do you suggest?
Re:'My life was ruined by a typo' by dkersten on Wednesday March 22, 2017 @10:23AM (#13931104)
Don't use sarcasm on the internet (or at least not on HN), it usually ends with a bunch of responses which didn't pick up on the fact that it was sarcasm which lowers the quality of the conversation. Remember also that many HN readers are not native english speakers and are unlikely to pick up on the true meaning of a comment if you're not really clear. Even suffixes like /s are not clear IMHO (at least, I didn't know what it meant until I saw the other comment here suggesting it and I AM a native english speaker).

Jokes and such are frowned upon on HN and many people probably see sarcasm the same way, so you risk getting downvoted too.

In order to avoid adding noise (in the form of responses from people who didn't realise you weren't serious), I would suggest to refrain from sarcastic comments.

Re:'My life was ruined by a typo' by emodendroket on Wednesday March 22, 2017 @12:18PM (#13932156)
I will definitely cease using a useful rhetorical device in case a handful of people might misunderstand me.
Re:'My life was ruined by a typo' by throwanem on Tuesday March 21, 2017 @10:02PM (#13927978)
A trailing /s is the convention. Failing that, perhaps less subtlety? Text is poor at conveying tone.
Re:'My life was ruined by a typo' by emodendroket on Tuesday March 21, 2017 @10:57PM (#13928168)
Why don't I put a flashing red sign that says I am joking while I'm at it?
Re:'My life was ruined by a typo' by TeMPOraL on Wednesday March 22, 2017 @06:16AM (#13929730)
It's up to you; you're the one controlling the chances people will get the joke in your comment :P.
Re:'My life was ruined by a typo' by emodendroket on Wednesday March 22, 2017 @09:20AM (#13930642)
At this point I'm resigned to people taking even the most improbable interpretation of whatever I say if it gives them an opportunity to call me an idiot.
Re:'My life was ruined by a typo' by throwanem on Wednesday March 22, 2017 @10:11AM (#13931005)
Much to my occasional regret, the principle of charity is far more often invoked here than adhered to.
Re:'My life was ruined by a typo' by NoGravitas on Wednesday March 22, 2017 @09:41AM (#13930774)
Unfortunately, HN doesn't support blink tags.
Re:'My life was ruined by a typo' by emodendroket on Wednesday March 22, 2017 @10:17AM (#13931055)
Where can I make a feature request?
Re:'My life was ruined by a typo' by dpark on Tuesday March 21, 2017 @10:12PM (#13928011)
I thought it was pretty obvious and the italics made it more so.
Re:'My life was ruined by a typo' by brokenmachine on Tuesday March 21, 2017 @10:56PM (#13928166)
People can be very wrong on the internet so it's hard to tell sometimes.

Also, Poe's Law. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Poe%27s_law

Re:'My life was ruined by a typo' by RcouF1uZ4gsC on Tuesday March 21, 2017 @08:57PM (#13927714)
This is surprising to me. At the hospital where I worked, everybody was assigned a medical record number. It was possible (in fact, I saw it done several times) to change the name of the patient, and even combine multiple patients into one (useful for drug seeking patients who claim to be multiple people on different visits). A common case was with newborn/pediatric patients. A newborn was listed with a system name of <Mother's last name>/Baby <Boy|Girl> with an optional A/B/C for twins/triplets/etc. If that patient was later admitted in follow-up (for example heart defects which required multiple surgeries over time to fix) their actual name was then used.

I guess the issue is that the future is not evenly distributed.

Re:'My life was ruined by a typo' by zxexz on Tuesday March 21, 2017 @09:45PM (#13927922)
Out of curiousity, do you remember the vendor of the software at the hospital you worked?
Re:'My life was ruined by a typo' by Spooky23 on Tuesday March 21, 2017 @08:33PM (#13927596)
I got sued by a hospital because their systems couldn't distinguish between the dependent version of me (from my Parents health insurance 3 years prior) and the current version of me. (I share a name with my dad and had the same insurance plan)

They kept billing my defunct account, despite dozens of attempts to correct.

Re:'My life was ruined by a typo' by chris_wot on Wednesday March 22, 2017 @06:46AM (#13929858)
Counter sue for fraud.
Re:'My life was ruined by a typo' by Spooky23 on Wednesday March 22, 2017 @08:36AM (#13930363)
They ultimately settled it and fixed it when I got my State Senator involved.

My small claims suit for my expenses was dismissed due to a binding arbritration clause. As a then 22 year old, that was about all I had the time to do.

Re:'My life was ruined by a typo' by pragone on Tuesday March 21, 2017 @07:22PM (#13927190)
I've seen all of these situations thousands of times, and I don't even work in a hospital (yet). There has not existed a single EMR I've ever seen that makes any sense whatsoever to the individuals using it. I understand it from the bigger picture, but when things are directly impacting patient care, something needs to be done.

I've likewise been extremely interested in reforming EMRs. It's a precarious field to get into, but I am definitely very interested in pursuing it (perhaps after medical school, though).

Re:'My life was ruined by a typo' by tyingq on Tuesday March 21, 2017 @07:55PM (#13927412)
Part of the issue in healthcare is the "who gets to decide what software to buy".

The culture seems to be that individual departments get to decide their own software, based only on their needs. Interoperability is not on their list.

So radiology buys what they want, admissions buys what they want, and so forth.

Then, the department that has the least clout and direct funding (IT) has to tie it all together.

There are some actual standards like HL7, and some generally accepted non-standards like Orsos, but they are all too loose to solve the problem completely.

Changing a name is hard partially because it is one of the identifiers that tie the mess together.

Re:'My life was ruined by a typo' by flukus on Tuesday March 21, 2017 @08:56PM (#13927709)
> The culture seems to be that individual departments get to decide their own software, based only on their needs.

I think that's a good thing by itself, various parts of a hospital are incredibly specialized and a one size fits all solution will never work. The alternative is some much higher level of management deciding what everyone buys.

HL7 needs to be scrapped though, it does nothing to achieve inter-operability, it's just there to make hospital managers think that it exists and keep smaller players out of the market.

Re:'My life was ruined by a typo' by tyingq on Tuesday March 21, 2017 @09:22PM (#13927832)
I probably should have expanded on that a bit. In many cases the individual departments don't even communicate purchase intent to IT.

So things like "optional" integration modules go unpurchased. Contract terms don't address basic integration needs, etc.

Or, a specialized department has a software bake off, finds 3 solutions of equal value to them, and picks one at random. Not knowing it's the one least likely to fit in the larger picture.

Or, crossover software that serves more than one department is purchased by only one, with no discussion.

Basically, for whatever reason, healthcare is just more territorial and segregated than most other companies I've worked in.

Re:'My life was ruined by a typo' by pragone on Tuesday March 21, 2017 @08:01PM (#13927441)
You 100% hit the nail on the head. It's really, really amazing to see how absolutely disconnected the buyers and the users are.

I was doing training at one hospital where, when they admitted a patient to the floor from the ED, had to print out the entire EMR, because the EMR in the ED and the floor was not compatible. Insanity.

Re:'My life was ruined by a typo' by tim333 on Wednesday March 22, 2017 @04:23AM (#13929281)
That kind of thing's not so rare though. Hospitals have lots of systems and paper works quite well.
Re:'My life was ruined by a typo' by mjevans on Wednesday March 22, 2017 @01:25AM (#13928659)
The solution, obviously, is for everyone to be a stakeholder and everyone to get a formal veto on the matter.

By all stakeholders I mean:

  * The department needing the software.
  * The department integrating the software (usually IT).
  * The department(s) consuming the data.
  * Any other departments that interact with the above dataflow (IE does it contradict things they are/plan to do?).
  * Whoever signs off on the check.
The formal veto would include written problems with the proposal "this is not a good idea as proposed because Z" and/or "for this to work we need X as a requirement, but it isn't in the proposed spec".
Re:'My life was ruined by a typo' by tyingq on Wednesday March 22, 2017 @01:42AM (#13928704)
I don't know that there's any particular formula that works. Other environments I've been around are also territorial, just less so.
Re:'My life was ruined by a typo' by tim333 on Tuesday March 21, 2017 @10:03PM (#13927981)
>There has not existed a single EMR I've ever seen that makes any sense whatsoever to the individuals using it.

There are some with good user feedback for GPs and individual doctors like Elation EMR http://www.softwareadvice.com/medical/elation-emr-profile/

but I haven't seen any people really like for hospitals. Epic is often the best reviewed and a lot of people hate it.

I went to a hackathon for nurses three months ago where they were complaining the hospital systems are crap and asking for fixes and thought oh I'll knock something up and have not got very far - in three months you can't even read what other people have tried really - there are over 300 emr systems listed on softwareadvice.com and I read elsewhere the average hospital uses about 80 separate systems. It's a complicated mess.

I've been working on an idea for something like Dropbox with a viewer to display the different formats, HL7&v2, FHIR etc with basic search as a step up from people having to print stuff out and fax it. Not really an EMR but a tool to view record which could maybe be extended. Dunno if that has legs or if anyone had done it already?

Re:'My life was ruined by a typo' by brokenmachine on Wednesday March 22, 2017 @01:45AM (#13928720)
> I've been working on an idea for something like Dropbox with a viewer to display the different formats, HL7&v2, FHIR etc with basic search as a step up from people having to print stuff out and fax it. Not really an EMR but a tool to view record which could maybe be extended. Dunno if that has legs or if anyone had done it already?

Not sure what your intended market is, assuming internal for a hospital, but that doesn't sound like a usable idea to me. How does a typical enduser get the HL7 out to put in your dropbox? Most health systems won't let you just export a HL7 without paying the vendor through the nose for an interface.

There are so many inefficiencies in the typical hospital that there has to be ideas there, unfortunately there's usually some silly political issue or crazy Catch-22 type situation that stops common sense stuff from being able to be implemented.

Re:'My life was ruined by a typo' by tim333 on Wednesday March 22, 2017 @03:06AM (#13928996)
Yeah I'm not quite sure of those details. I think there is something in HIPAA along the lines "If your practice maintains EHR, you must provide a copy of the medical record in at least one readable electronic format." Also some may want to cooperate - dunno.

There must be some way better than this stuff: https://www.quora.com/How-do-Medical-Records-go-from-institu...

Re:'My life was ruined by a typo' by yeukhon on Tuesday March 21, 2017 @07:45PM (#13927344)
I have some ideas, hit me up on my email if you want. Most of the information repeat every time you visit a doctor or a hospital, it doesn't need to be that me.
Re:'My life was ruined by a typo' by brokenmachine on Tuesday March 21, 2017 @10:43PM (#13928106)
I am acutely familiar with hospital systems and in every one I have seen so far, you can modify demographic information.

Maybe the nurses didn't know how to do it, but it can definitely be done.

Not saying there aren't other glaring inefficiencies (outsourced useless IT helpdesk especially), but changing patient demographic info is not one of them.

Re:'My life was ruined by a typo' by kagamine on Wednesday March 22, 2017 @04:28AM (#13929303)
As a UX guy "Maybe the nurses didn't know how to do it, but it can definitely be done." is absolutely no excuse.

It still screams 'poor design' and 'couldn't be bothered to test'.

Re:'My life was ruined by a typo' by brokenmachine on Wednesday March 22, 2017 @10:34PM (#13937005)
As a UX guy, you would surely vomit or run away if you saw most of the health programs I've seen.

Please help fix them, there are so many examples of shocking UI in health. So many of them look like first year uni projects by middling level programmers.

Also, sometimes only particular people (probably Admissions Dept) would have the permissions/knowledge necessary to edit that info. So maybe the nurses couldn't fix it but surely there would have been people in that hospital that could have fixed an incorrect name, had they been notified. They were probably who made the error in the first place!

Re:'My life was ruined by a typo' by frik on Wednesday March 22, 2017 @01:58AM (#13928767)
The program looks like Excel except it isn't. In some cases you have to enter the data in a different column, in some cases you have to enter 0, in some cases you leave it out.

It could be SAP or some other old fashion ERP system. Or some old Java/C# application built for the hospital. These have usually in common a very crude old fashion UI and things like changing a record is overly complex.

Often also the workers don't know the program good enough. So they only know the standard use case. If you fall out of the 95% use case, you get into a lot of trouble because of their inexperience with the application. If they try new things put to mitigate the issue, it's better to ask for their boss or things can go worse.

Re:'My life was ruined by a typo' by rows on Wednesday March 22, 2017 @02:14AM (#13928832)
Yes this sounds like SAP with insufficient training.

Clients have been asking for years to get browser-like functionalities, getting a form with only the fields they really need and nothing that can be determined automatically. But SAP has been improving for years, and now they are offering jQuery in disguise https://sapui5.hana.ondemand.com/

It's hard to blame bad UI on SAP when they are pushing for the opposite.

Re:'My life was ruined by a typo' by Udik on Tuesday March 21, 2017 @07:29PM (#13927247)
Typos in ID codes are usually prevented by appending a checksum. But what about reforming names? We could append a checksum to them also :)
Re:'My life was ruined by a typo' by icebraining on Tuesday March 21, 2017 @08:22PM (#13927541)
In some European countries, you could already just ask the user to insert his national ID smartcard into a reader and get a digital file with basic info (essentially what's printed on the front).
Re:'My life was ruined by a typo' by emodendroket on Tuesday March 21, 2017 @08:43PM (#13927653)
No reason you couldn't do something similar with licenses.
Re:'My life was ruined by a typo' by amorphid on Tuesday March 21, 2017 @10:53PM (#13928148)
It is interesting to me that we don't have a national ID card in the USA. I don't appreciate strong arguments against them. Like on this list by the ACLU...

https://www.aclu.org/other/5-problems-national-id-cards

>> Reason #2: An ID card system will lead to a slippery slope of surveillance and monitoring of citizens.

I think "they" are already monitoring everything I do. Maybe this would have mattered more to me before I had a smartphone, passport, bank account, social media accounts, etc. If I wanted to live off the grid with no electricity & only using trained ninja squirrels to buy things with unmarked bills on my behalf, I would certainly not want to be forced to into having a national ID card. I'm not advocating monitoring. I just feel a national ID card wouldn't be much different than my current situation.

Re:'My life was ruined by a typo' by emodendroket on Tuesday March 21, 2017 @10:58PM (#13928174)
Especially when the SSN is used as a stand-in but has no security whatever.
Re:'My life was ruined by a typo' by realusername on Wednesday March 22, 2017 @06:14AM (#13929722)
I don't see most of these issues in European countries with ID cards. Anyway, you need to have a way to identify citizen for practical purpose anyway, if it's not an ID card, it's going to be something less reliable and prone to errors.
Re:'My life was ruined by a typo' by mino on Wednesday March 22, 2017 @07:12AM (#13929987)
Yes, this cyclically comes up on HN and it's 100% American culture dependent.

There's no reason why ID cards would lead to more or less secure data collection than today.

Re:'My life was ruined by a typo' by traviscj on Tuesday March 21, 2017 @10:54PM (#13928155)
Names need check digits, then?

"Hi I'm Travis Johnson42"

Re:'My life was ruined by a typo' by sobkas on Wednesday March 22, 2017 @02:17AM (#13928841)
>There is no reason, in my funny but pretty frustrating anecdote, for hospital to run so inefficient,

There is one reason why it is so. When they make such error, you must take effort, time and money to fix it. So if hospital can spend "their" money on system that can fix and/or catch such errors (+staff that can efficiently​ use it), but on the other hand they can just "outscore" it to you, guess what choice they will make?

Re:'My life was ruined by a typo' by kevin_thibedeau on Tuesday March 21, 2017 @10:47PM (#13928125)
I had to stop handwriting the letter "u" in my name with a tail because it was being entered as an "n" too often.
Re:'My life was ruined by a typo' by mjevans on Wednesday March 22, 2017 @01:27AM (#13928664)
Fancy is for the places they don't ask you to print for clarity... (which is everywhere except the 'signature' area).
Re:'My life was ruined by a typo' by Benjammer on Tuesday March 21, 2017 @10:34PM (#13928073)
Re:'My life was ruined by a typo' by MaysonL on Tuesday March 21, 2017 @10:16PM (#13928023)
35 years ago my name was entered incorrectly into a data base. I'm still getting mail with the incorrect spelling.
Re:'My life was ruined by a typo' by marme on Wednesday March 22, 2017 @02:05PM (#13933213)
just realize that the type or wrong cell phone number could have been an extra 0 in you medicine dosage that have killed patients before. The leading cause of death in hospitals is error not any actual disease. Doctors amputate the wrong limb, give the wrong medication, all sort of stupid mistakes that should be easily preventable
Re:'My life was ruined by a typo' by leni536 on Wednesday March 22, 2017 @06:38AM (#13929833)