FB might be a bigger fish than we might be aware of.
Thoughts?
I think we're aware of the size of the Facebook fish, but you might not be aware of the size of Microsoft at its peak.
Something like 75% of adults in the United States have a Facebook account[1], but at the height of their dominance Microsoft operating systems ran on ~98% of computers [2]. 75% is a lot, but it's probably not a monopoly - especially because Facebook does not make the devices or the OS on the devices. Lots of people use Facebook, but nothing is keeping them using it.
Being popular is not illegal.
[1] http://www.usatoday.com/story/tech/2015/01/09/pew-survey-soc... [2] https://arstechnica.com/features/2005/12/total-share/8/
Of course, Bell also had a vertical monopoly in that they owned the physical wires in addition to being the service provider, and I think that was part of what brought them down in the end. Unless FB starts buying ISPs they won't be in the same position.
They tried (are trying?) becoming that in poor countries with their 'free' internet initiative.
So a company might have close to 75% market share in an industry that matters and they would be a lot easier to prosecute vs the company w/ 100% market (a fleshlight, or other trivial niche thing)
Those are the only ones.
It's a 400 billion dollar company and, as the GP noted, most people's default web experience.
More importantly, you could buy a computer and phone and live without Facebook (or Instagram. My life would be poorer without Whatsapp though).
However, looked at another way, Facebook is now too important to be a private company. It has access to so much data about so many people that the potential for abuse is huge. I wouldn't want to see them become a government owned entity, as the potential for abuse would be just as great (maybe greater) while innovation would inevitably slow down.
But I would like to see a regulator that sits on Facebook's board, can review its source code and order changes.
My dream would be for Facebook to be broken up and turned into a protocol. But it seems that ship has sailed.
E: Please don't upvote this, it doesn't help the discussion!
If I need to use FB messenger on mobile, which is rare for me, I'll load their page in desktop mode and use it that way.
You can also use Trillian.
The rarity is my use of instant messaging (outside of SMS/Google Hangouts and Slack)
It's more buried than maybe it needs to be (to be fair there are a lot of obscure settings in this monster of an app), but basically findable.
Rather than crashing the thing, it's probably more productive for web developers with serious compatibility issues just to detect it and tell users how to find the setting.
This is an assertion I see relatively regularly, is it based on a gut feeling or is their some evidence to back it up?
If so what does it really mean - surely all(?) users do some things outside of facebook (email, news websites and so on)? Are you saying that most users will not look anywhere beyond facebook for any service?
Couldn't find good statistics quickly, but https://qz.com/333313/milliions-of-facebook-users-have-no-id... is relevant.
One big question it brings up for me does this just reflect that people don't know what "the internet" is at all? Like would you get a similar result if you asked "did you use Google?" or even "did you use Chrome?".
Also I don't know about everyone else but a quick glance at my face book feed and the vast majority of stuff is people posting articles from various blogs and talking about them. Do those respondents really never click and visit anything outside the facebook eco-system?
This includes your friends and contacts - if you look at the people around you and observe that everyone does/has X, it's still quite likely that most people worldwide look to people around them and observe that everybody has/does not-X. For us, personal experience is not really representative of reality (coincidentally, this is a common problem for startups and their market understanding), we often have to intentionally go much beyond our normal circle of contacts to see how the majority of "normal" users actually behave. Blogs are a particular example - actually, for most of general public, there's such thing as independent blogs; and most content providers are available without leaving e.g. the facebook ecosystem, insomuch that a regular reader can be unaware that it's "not facebook".
It's kind of similar to sociology/psychology, where studies often inadvertently are WEIRD (Western, Educated, Industrialized, Rich and Democratic) but the global average/median is very different from that.
the vast majority of stuff is people posting
articles from various blogs and talking about them
If a user were to only discover those articles via Facebook, and only see them within the Facebook app's browser, would they be savvy enough to know that these blogs aren't part of Facebook?While you a right about "app store" kind of apps being forbidden (I've worked on one few years ago. We knew it was doomed, but higher-ups wanted to try anyway) what do you base your "OS system" comment on? I'd say WeChat is even more OS-like and still does fine.
For example, Messenger now has a "Share your Day" option which is nested at the very top blocking a huge chunk off.
What happened to just messaging users?
Snapchat happened.
A few years ago, Facebook wanted all posts to be completely public, in order to combat Twitter. Now they want to be Snapchat.
If they can't buy a rising competitor, they try to become it.
That was my assumption, and in that case I have no idea how it competes directly with Snapchat--Facebook basically invented that feature.
I remember of a time when Microsoft used to force you to use Internet Explorer on a default Windows OS install. They got sued for this which forced them to give user a choice to choose one browser from a selection of browsers (story: https://www.extremetech.com/computing/196170-microsoft-is-fi...)
The more I think of it, the more Facebook becomes the equivalent of an operating system for the average user. You can send/receive messages, do image editing, surf the web, but you have no choice of which software to use to do these tasks Once you're in FB ecosystem you're forced to use their array of services.
I see the same pattern happening again. I wonder if people will rise to the occasion and put a halt to this, just like it was done to Microsoft a decade (or so) ago.
I'd love to hear your thoughts?
On a different note: Apple app store has strict guidelines on any app that is trying to recreate an "app store" or OS system in their store and would reject/remove such an app. FB might be playing with fire here?