It's now at about 20% Chinese population as well.
I have no problem with immigration and foreigners buying houses, but they are making it basically impossible for the average Kiwi to consider purchasing in Auckland, and it is somewhat of a problem when a single group has been allowed to purchase in such intensity in a single area.
The wider New Zealand population is quite angry about it, but the government seems to be denying a problem. The problem was they were happy taking in foreign money, with complete disregard for the inevitable consequences.
They are now going to be implementing much increased tax on foreign buyers to try and stop the problem.
The thing is it's happening everywhere in NZ. The provinces are getting worse as well. For reference, a median multiple of 3 is considered affordable.
http://www.nzherald.co.nz/business/news/article.cfm?c_id=3&o...
Not a single region in NZ is affordable - and this is from 2012. It's only gotten worse.
Governments will do what's in their best interest. You literally pointed it out yourself in the next paragraph..
As someone who wrote code to forecast the demise of the housing bubble back in 2008, RENT vs BUY is still the strongest argument in my mind.
In 2005 I could choose to rent a 3bdr/2bth for $800 per month or I could buy it for $1200 per month.
Today, I feel like things are frothy but rent is actually more per month than "buying." I'd be curious to see when rental vacancies go up. That to me is a strong signal that a correction may take place in that local market.
Many of us chose to rent because rent was cheap, we were young, not wealthy, and most importantly didn't know if we would love in this or that city for much longer (perhaps we came to study and moved on to look for our first jobs).
By the time rent became unaffordable, or at least much more expensive than a (lengthy) mortgage, we had also been prices out of home ownership because we don't make enough even with our partner's wages combined. We just couldn't get a mortgage at the prices houses are going. It feels like been between a rock and a hard place.
The psychology of pain applies to both the individual, the city, and all the way to the state and federal government. Which is that in comfort, no one changes. The only one motivated to change in this scenario currently is the individual (household).
In planning, I generally try and first determine if a market is frothy and then predict where the pain could/should/will come from. If I can't determine a pain point, I assume that either a) I missed something or b) there is yet to be a point of inflection.
My plan for housing ended up by waiting 7 years (2005-2012) to purchase my home as a foreclosure. So it certainly took some patience and planning. With that said, if I hadn't seen some pain in the local RE market by around 2009, I would have moved to some place that afforded me a similar lifestyle but one that I could purchase a home, given my priorities.
Single data point as an example: Last month a friend, who between he and his partner make approx. $200k (before tax) combined household income, bought a semi-detached property on the east end (west of the DVP, south of Dundas). "$200k you say, that is a lot!", right, it isn't insignificant, but it's also just two skilled people who make $100k in a major city. There are a significant volume of $100k jobs out there (so if they lose them, I suspect they will find another fairly soon). It's just not as impossible to do as people say, but most of us are not willing to pack a lunch every day, stop drinking lattes make it possible.
When hunting for a house in Toronto there were 3 things that really bugged me that would be great to have addressed before we freak out over the possibility of foreign money:
1) "Second round of offers". It's a trick relators play. Basically they get all the offers together and then come back and say "uh, they're all super close, we're looking to get an outlier". Of course some people come back with bigger offers...and the highest is accepted, or the highest offer from the previous round is accepted.
2) Poorly done home-owner renovations. People doing shitty renovations and then later selling the place (often these are flips). Uneducated buyers see these 'improvements' as positive things when most of the work will be to be re-done due to the job not being done properly. It just keeps Home Depot humming and inflates the cost of the house by the cost of materials + repairs down the road. It's compounded by the fact all offers [in practice] need to be unconditional or they won't get considered. So no inspection, the buyer doesn't get the chance to really find out until later. Sellers often include inspections, but these are always terrible sources of info.
3) Illegal housing; So many listings say "Potential basement suite", and people do the math expecting to get $800-1500 / month extra income from it. They say "potential" in the listing because it's nearly impossible to create an actual legal basement apartment in your house in Toronto [and they know it], but people are willing to risk it or simply unaware of the exposure this places on them. Legal basement apartments need fire rated rooms, to include a parking spot (which is super hard to do in Toronto!), have a separate HVAC system and much much more. 99% of basement apartments do not comply, but due to either people not knowing, or not caring, they rent them out to increase their housing budget. Banks are partly to blame here, they enable this by increasing the lending amount accordingly based on an assumption that the second unit will be rented 10/12 months per year.
I think the thing we're truly seeing here is what access to cheap capital produces in established major (aka historically low risk) cities. Interest rates are sub 3% with no signs of increasing, people make decent money and are willing to sign up for 30 year commitments. There is risk, but when you look at the key factors, it's pretty low give the likely outcome over that time horizon. This isn't a small suburb hours away from a major city [i.e. Hamilton Ontario - where prices are going up despite the fact lots of the residents commute hours to Toronto every day] where one company going broke will send everyone into the poor house, it's a major city with a very good history of having available skilled work.
I'm personally more worried about robots taking skilled jobs than I am the possible housing market crashing. Those things will probably be related events, and housing will be one of the many industries not ready for that shift.
Finally, having said all this, a well timed quote from a conversation i had on Friday "If i lose half the value in my house, i won't be upset or surprised...I went into it assuming things might not go my way". Not everyone has that luxury or time horizon to not mind waiting around like I do, but I'd encourage more people to not see a house as an investment but more as a cost (as you would rent) and use that emotional response you get to help you justify your next decision in the house buying process.
3 years ago your friends might have needed only $100k income for that semi, and in 3 years it will require $400k. Will your friends be earning $400k in 3 years? I doubt it. It's Toronto, not San Francisco.
In 3 years the number of families that could afford that semi-detached home went down by a factor of 6. [1] That's a problem.
I agree with you that the Toronto situation isn't as bad as others because Toronto has the most robust economy in Canada. A lot of the demand is driven simply by the fact that the city is a magnet for people from all over the country. I don't think the market will ever "crash". But the city's growth will be limited if the income needed to live in its core continues to rise from top 20% (2005), to top 10% (2013), to top 2% (2017) to top 1% and beyond. How will business attract highly mobile tech workers when a home in Toronto comes the same as SF but salaries are 1/2 or less? Since you live in Toronto you know the city is doing a desperately bad job of building new mass transit to alleviate the shortage/cost of housing the central parts of the city.
[1] http://www.statcan.gc.ca/tables-tableaux/sum-som/l01/cst01/f...
We need to double down on education, support the creation of new businesses, make massive steps forward in terms of transit networks and reduce the future need for high "demand" side in Toronto. If we invest in other areas now (that is not to say we don't invest in TO any less), it's possible that a more sustainable growth curve for TO will come to exist.
Oh, and NOT let Kevin O'leary win the PC leadership.
So what's your theory about why Toronto has seen 20%+ YoY appreciation? Why now?
1. Historically low mortgage rates and weak rules on who can access government-insured high-leverage mortgages
2. Softness in the other, non-Toronto, engine of the Canadian economy - the Alberta oil industry. Lots of people who left the GTA to work out west are migrating back now
3. Redirection of foreign capital from Vancouver after growing public outrage and many disturbing investigative reports on fraud, money laundering and tax evasion in the Vancouver market - this probably accounts for a lot of the change from 2015 to 2016/2017
4. Positive feedback effect as boomers sitting on $1M+ houses sell them, downsize, but give much of the proceeds to their kids to buy back into the market at even higher prices
5. Weak CAD amplifying the effect of (3)
It seems clear than #3 and, less so, #1 and 5 are driving the majority of demand. I'm not sure how one can explain the decoupling of prices from incomes without either a massive influx of capital or lax lending from the banks. The latter doesn't seem to be an issue, which leaves the former.
If you're curious, read the PDF from the SFU prof that I linked to in the top comment in the thread. It's a summary of the data and is an excellent read if you're trying to unpack what's really going on (in Vancouver, but a lot is applicable to Toronto).
But to be clear, I didn't mean to say that the organic factors in Toronto justify the 20% YOY growth, just that in contrast with Vancouver there is more inherent strength in the market to cushion it from taking a big haircut if and when foreign investment tails off. In the Lower Mainland, real estate and associated construction industries account for around 1/3rd of total economic output - which means BC is more dependant on the Lower Mainland housing market than Alberta is on oil. Toronto at least doesn't have that potential double-whammy of having housing tank and losing its main economic driver at the same time. Housing is outpacing Toronto's economy, but housing IS Vancouver's economy. The latter scenario is a lot more dangerous, IMO.
Still don't totally understand "why now" wrt Toronto's market taking off if the answer doesn't include foreign money as a main driver.
I don't think foreign money can ever explain "why now". Even if we agree that there is foreign money being invested, there still has to be some underlying driver to make them stand up and take interest in that investment opportunity. We can assert that it is not simply foreign money wanting to own a piece of Canada, as many parts of the country are only keeping up with inflation, and sometimes not even that. I think there had to be some change in the makeup of, most notably, Toronto and Vancouver that made it appealing now, and I suggest it is down to these demographic shifts.
That single data point is in the top 3% of Canadian incomes.
Are you sure you're talking about Toronto? My wife who is is an Executive in a particular industry has told me that there are engineers from Waterloo making 55-60k a year. At her last assignment there were several folks with CS Degrees making 55k and a UoT Grad with a Masters in CS making 65k. Being from the US she was surprised at the level these Grads were being utilized and quite astonished that they would be working for such poor wages.
Anyway, the home we had in Bloor West Village was purchased in 2005 for 440k.That same house (nothing was done to it) sold for 1.4 million within the last year. 11 years and a 1 million appreciation. Quite the investment.....
If things continue at the current rate that home will be worth about 10 + million in the next 10-15 years.
I'd say the most common range I see new grads start at is between 65-80, sometimes 85-90 but that's rare, with the right experience and attitude later in life I regularly see people ranging from 100-150+ without any questions being raised.
It's complicated but at the end of the day you're worth what you can justify. To me this is a question of how much I expect you can realistically contribute, which will not be the same for every place you interview due to the factors I mentioned above.
1. On top of that, there is also the fact that 100K new ppl move into the GTA every year. A good chunk of the wants to live in DT Toronto, further reducing the small supply;
2. Toronto produces 30% of Canada's economic output;
3. By many metrics, Toronto is extremely underpriced for the job and quality of life you get compared to other countries' largest cities;
4. Toronto is the 3rd largest North American city;
5. It's possible part of the prices are just tracking the USD as the CAD dropped ;and
6. The truth is, the majority of the Canadian population won't know/accept that in this single city people make 5-10x the income they make, hence "bubble" being thrown around as the obvious answer.
Don't get me wrong, there are definitely organic factors that contribute to the price growth in Toronto. But those cannot account for >15% year-over-year growth.
[1] http://www.torontohomes-for-sale.com/4a_custpage_2578.html
I'd argue that at least 20% of the price increase we're dealing with today is related to inflation.
Quebec / Montreal: historical politics pushed investment to toronto when separation was on the table and pushed by certain political groups (again bumping toronto prices and not helping those areas at all!)
Winnipeg / Calgary: isolation from other large cities, colder climate, less immigration friendly.
Isn't Manitoba one of the easiest provinces to immigrate to?
Toronto's population grew by 10% between 2001 and 2016. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demographics_of_Toronto#Popula...
There is currently a vast supply of condos in the city, and considering the average number of children per household (1.1 in 2011), the supply should cover the housing demand in the city.
Things are a little different in the GTA, but this still doesn't explain the magnitude of the jump in prices in the last two months.
Out of interest, who tracks economic output? It seems Statscan does not. Although it is worth mentioning that Toronto CMA is home to around 18% of the population, and represents about the same percentage of the nation's GDP.
Not quite, that's only technically correct, due to the fact that major urban areas in the US don't 'incorporate' into major cities.
It's better to compare 'greater urban areas' with other regions. On that basis, it's not so big.
LA, Chicago, Dallas Ft/Worth, NYC all bigger, with Boston, Houston, Bay Area, DC, Seattle, (even Atlanta) about the same size. There's a few more on that list.
America is very populous and just outside many urban centres are vastly populated areas of slightly less density. Esp. in the North East.
1 $100K earner is in the top 20%. Having both is quite rare.
You've made the opposite argument: those people should easily be able to afford a relatively nice home.
Homes are completely out of range for normal Torontonians, and it's a problem.
Remember that next time you vote. And that isn't a jab at the current government, it's more a statement to remind people that tax cuts and other incentives we can expect to come up on offer come election time are not what we are complaining about here.
That does not have to happen for a speculative bubble.
So, something like that happened in Frankfurt in some areas.
Rent skyrocketed. Only offices.
Later in self interest the city changed some areas to living areas. With affordable living and rent.
Is this the same in Canada?
On other side note. I think why no city stops it. They are hoping to be the next new York. High rent, high income renter's. High income for the city.
Usually reality proves them wrong.
Watching Toronto's market explode is like watching a horror movie that I saw take place in Vancouver over the last two years. The politicians, press, and real estate industry are spinning the same stories their counterparts in Vancouver did without providing an even plausible explanation for the rocket ship growth.
The key issue with Vancouver's market is that prices have become decoupled from local incomes. The same thing is happening in Toronto.
In Vancouver, the main driver of decoupled home prices is foreign investment dollars, mainly from China. I suspect the same is true in Toronto because prices there started exploding after Vancouver instituted a 15% tax on foreign buyers in August 2016.
If you're interested in understanding the key drivers of the Vancouver real estate market, this paper by a SFU professor summarizes the data, provides a sensible solution, and convincingly refutes the tropes that are often provided as reasoning for the market's explosion:
http://www.sfu.ca/content/dam/sfu/mpp/pdfs/Vancouver's%20Hou...
1 - where unaffordable is defined as the ratio of median home price to median income.