I think a huge part of it will be when it becomes really really obvious that Uber will never be able to IPO, the employees there will have to leave. The gravitational pull of the sunk cost fallacy (with respect to any exercised options the employees have) will be overwhelmed by the need to 'find other options' faster than their colleagues and it becomes a race to not be the last one off the sinking ship.
1_2__3 - while I agree with your overall thesis, I think it's reasonable to bring up self driving cars since they are in the original article, after all.
> my car drives 95% of my commute.
In the context of the taxi market, "self driving" means 100%. If I call for a self-driving cab, it needs to reach me on its own.Getting to 100% looks like it's going to be pretty hard, despite the endless stream of articles insinuating otherwise. A car that drives into oncoming traffic 1% of the time isn't good enough.
It would be really interesting to see the early pitch decks for Uber - especially the series A and B slides. I would be inclined to bet that autonomous vehicles do not make an appearance until much later.
The third point tying them together is Uber's faith that (2) is false. That is yet another indicator that Uber won't make it - their optimism is not well founded.
No. Why?
>if Uber is planing to rely on self driving cars they're already dead.
There's no discussion to be had there.
There's tons of discussion to be had about whether Uber can tweak their current business model (i.e. drivers) to be profitable.
Let's take Singapore as an example Core business you need to compete against the home-grown champion Grab, costing money. Basic strategy question: Diversify or Focus since loss leader does not work. Solution: Diversify.
The problem is the moment you start UberEats you are competing with Foodpanda, Deliveroo, etc. Competition costs money. Groceries delivery? You are competing with RedMart et al Document delivery? GogoVan, Zap.
The problem with that strategy is that it takes the focus off the core business -> You lose China to Didi, you lose India to Ola.
Voila, just like this Uber is not dominating the main global growth markets. If they now slow their growth by focusing their investors bail out since the "storyline" is not working anymore.
Seems to me like a lose/lose situation for Uber
Its anecdotal but most of the people I've asked about it said the pay on Lyft is better and they get far fewer bad passengers. Is Lyft losing as much cash as Uber? That would be a pretty bad trend if they're losing drivers and making less off of the drivers they have.
1) Lyft is in the USA only. Uber is in 400+ cities. Lyft is not remotely close to Uber in terms of hurting them.
2) No. It is scalable. They burn to drown their competition. They've got more money, so once the oxygen runs out for their competitors, Uber will just put margins back to where they are, stop comping so many rides, etc...
3) Not sure how you get to this approach. Self-driving = Lower/zero driver costs. Consumer facing app mobile experience is not going to be the deciding factor of Uber's success.
I'm not sure if your statement is trolling, or if you were actually being serious... If it's a troll, very well done... If it's not, then I strongly disagree with you.
A cynic might say: Lyft is losing money in the USA only. Uber is losing money in 400+ cities.
Also, its not so difficult for uber to start it's own fleet of self driving cabs , they already have a brand name, so consumers who cannot afford to buy the car , might still go the uber way !
A brand which has been horribly damaged. I started using Uber back in 2011 before UberX was rolled out. It was a great service with professional drivers. It was more expensive then cabs, but worth it for the incredible service. I was encouraging friends to use the app and got our company on business service about a year ago.
A month ago, I deleted the app.
Their brand is crap and they hve become the public face of the worst excesses of Tech Bro Douche culture. Their current brand ain't going to save them.
They used to call these "taxi companies", before the dark times... This is a photo of one of the company's yards:
https://www.facebook.com/TaxiCabJesus/photos/a.5237100478204...
They had to consolidate to the other yard (after I retired). I've read that the old taxi company now leases unbranded cars for use with any service. "no mileage restrictions and maintenance is included." Arizona's laws don't allow regular rental cars to be used for 'ridesharing'.
(I recently figured out how to finish my site about the 'taxi wars', http://www.taxiwars.org/ - I was learning about the human condition the whole time. New posts are in progress...)
An example of a network effect is a chat app: if 1 person uses a chat app worldwide, that person can get literally 0 utility out of it.
If 2 people use it, they have a tiny amount of utility: there is a single other person who can use it.
If three billion people use it, they all have massive utility: they can talk with anyone.
So, without changing the product, the more people who use it,the more utility each person has.
By that standard, Uber has no network effect at all (0, not "weak"): I simply don't get more utility whatsoever from the number of other people using Uber in my city.
If there are 5 available Uber cars which can take me to my destination, it really, really doesn't matter whether another 1,500 Uber cars in that city are already in use or whether that is the total 5 Uber cars which are available.
This shows that there is 0 (not "weak") network effect.
You can't use precisely defined economic concepts willy-nilly. By that standard Amazon has network effects because the more products I can buy there the happier I am to shop there (Amazon side) and also the same goes for the other side, because the more customers it has the happier it is.
Only problem is that's not the definition of the word we're arguing about.
2 - Uber is not very scalable (this is why they have to burn so much money to grow)
3 - Self-driving cars will actually destroy Uber's business.
Uber = Driver -> Uber -> Passenger. Self-driving cars will remove the Driver from the equation. Uber becomes a consumer facing app. Very vulnerable to Apple and Google should they ever want to get into that business. I think Google maps and Siri will become the interface to care sharing eventually as Apple/Google will have far more access to mobile experience that Uber will ever get.
I had made the above points before and predicted Uber will probably go the ways of AOL. It seems like more and more people are beginning see that too.