I can only conclude that some people have a radically different idea of "freedom" and "smaller government" than I do.
Bringing it back to the original topic a bit, it's sad that people's reactions are so predictable. People in favor of same-sex marriage think this study is great. People who oppose it think it sucks. How boring! Show me someone in favor of same-sex marriage who thinks this study is terrible, or someone against who thinks the study is really good.
Small government conservative here. It's actually pretty simple:
Small government: the government should stop meddling in marriage altogether. It's a social and often religious institution.
Freedom: We take seriously the founders' belief that government should not infringe on religious liberty.
"Religious liberty," especially in the context of the American founders, is the freedom to practice your faith privately in whatever manner you wish, and to speak about that faith publicly without fear or persecution. It is not the freedom to impose your religious mores on other people who do not share your religion, or even those who do. To imply otherwise is to bastardize what this country was founded on and does a disservice to the founders.
If you want government to stop meddling in marriage, I hope you're fighting against tax breaks and other marriage incentives just as hard as you are against allowing two people you'll never meet to enjoy the same recognition straight people do.
You may be mistaking American secularism with laicism.
> It is not the freedom to impose your religious mores on other people who do not share your religion, or even those who do.
I agree. This is why the Christian concept of marriage should not be imposed on others, like Muslims and Mormons who are perfectly happy with polygamy.
That's a common viewpoint today, but there's nothing in the 1A about _private_ exercise of religion. The public exercise of religion is very much what is protected though there are limits when it affects others or infringes on other laws (e.g., bigamy, etc.)
Tax breaks and other marriage incentives have a legitimate function in domestic policy (e.g., it's very much in the state's interest to encourage two-parent families for raising the next generation of productive citizens). While those reasons are not always entirely uncontroversial, it's unfortunate that they are sometimes swept up into the debate around "getting government out of the marriage business."
Civil (ie. government sanctioned) marriage is a social construct that most people want to, and eventually will, enter into. People enter into marriages because they want the legal framework around it. If there were no legal framework around marriage people would have to run around filling out paperwork everywhere setting up their partner as their next-of-kin.
There's also currently no non-marriage way to create the same sort of civil partnership that marriage brings, stuff like spousal privilege and unlimited inheritance just to name two. And these are things people want. If all people were interested in was religious marriage or partnership/love/companionship they either wouldn't bother getting married or wouldn't bother registering their religious marriage with the state.
Its currently impossible to get government out of marriage without also fundamentally changing our concept of marriage.
There's arguments that the "family/marriage" concept is benefited too much in society, and I'd probably agree with that.
How on earth is allowing other people to get married infringing on your religious liberty??
The logic of this baffles me.
I disagree with you, but I will not downvote your comment.
Healthcare: The Little Sisters of the Poor, a Catholic charitable organization that also offers healthcare for women, were required by the Affordable Care Act to provide contraception as part of their services. This infringed on the religious liberty of practicing Catholics. Nonetheless, the federal government fined the Little Sisters of the Poor for not providing a service the Catholic Church considers immoral. Million of dollars in lawyer fees later, the Supreme Court finally reversed the decision [0].
Marriage: A gay couple asked a Jack Phillips, a Christian baker and owner of Masterpiece Cakeshop, to make the wedding cake for their upcoming gay marriage ceremony. The Jewish, Christian, and Muslim faiths all forbid homosexuality; Philips asked the couple to take their business elsewhere. But the couple took Phillips to court and the court ruled that Phillips and his staff were required to break their moral convictions and were ordered take re-education classes and file quarterly compliance reports for two years [1].
[0]: http://thelittlesistersofthepoor.com/#supreme-court-ruling
[1]: http://dailycaller.com/2016/04/26/christian-baker-forced-to-...
Imagine a world in which any healthcare provider could arbitrarily decline coverage for anything on the grounds of "religion". Have a genetic illness, sorry that's founded on the "theory" of evolution we're not going to cover you, etc. Allowing healthcare providers to pick and choose coverage is a nightmare for consumers .
Your second example is a similar issue. Allowing businesses to arbitrarily deny service to minorities (the case would have been different if the couple asked for a custom cake with a phrase the Phillips found objectionable) is not small gov or freedom of religion. It's just plain bigotry.
A citizen's freedom of religion ends when the next citizen's rights begin. If you take that away you might as well be living in a Theocracy.
What "right" are you talking about here? The gay couple's "right" to force a particular person to bake them a cake? There is no such right.
Likewise, there's no "right" to healthcare. You can't force a doctor to perform a medical procedure on you, for example. Forcing people to provide you with their services is called slavery.
It is someone's "opinion" that a private Catholic Christian charity should exercise a procedure or have a policy that is strictly against the values of that organization.
Strictly speaking, as intelligent adults here, we can rationalize that a Catholic charity does not believe in contraceptives or abortions and would not participate in these activities. They have a long held history of this practice and it wasn't made up on the spot because they felt like it, such as your example of belief in evolution leading to denial of a procedure, which very few if any people in this country hold and especially any organizations that practice in the field of medicine.
Frankly, if you have issue with private healthcare providers having a choice in their practice, you should be for a legal framework and consumer market that allows for more consumer choice instead of less so people can choose a provider that works with what they need. In a truly free market, this would be extremely easy to accomplish.
As to the baker example, it doesn't require any further explanation than this. No private individual or business has a solemn duty to respect and faithfully accommodate the practices and requests of another individual that they object too. Would a satanist be a protected individual with case to sue if they specifically wished for a Christian bakery to create a cake with Jesus impaled on a cross? Afterall, the satanist is a minority holding a minority belief.
As citizens in a free society, if we want to start rolling back division in this country, we need to dramatically improve our education, and we need to start allowing people to behave freely again, good and bad. Forcing people into associations they don't want to have causes further division ultimately.
You are merely changing the language to avoid admitting the reality of a government infringing on religious liberty.
The government forcing religious people to go against their religion is infringement of religious liberty. Forcing those religious people to undergo government re-education classes is Stalinesque.
The founders of the US saw this potential abuse; it's why religious liberty is protected as the first right in the Bill of Rights.
And on a broader point, this is why we fight for small government: a large, powerful government is a bastion for tyranny. And the religious are merely the canary in the coal mine.
Perhaps the left will recognize this wisdom after President Trump issues executive orders overturning all that the left holds dear.
Everything else in your comment is basically offtopic.
You dismissed it as pertaining to anti-discrimination laws, even though it specifically was caused by same-sex marriage laws and involved a dispute about religious freedoms in response to those laws.
That case might be an argument against laws which prohibit discrimination on the basis of sexuality, but it's not an argument against same-sex marriage.
Gay families can and do raise children. Being unable to naturally produce children doesn't preclude raising children.
My mother-in-law is gay. When she was a young adult, before she came out, she got married and had children because "that's what you did" and she didn't have the courage to go against what was expected of her.
She, however, was incredibly miserable. Her distress with being gay and married to a man was a huge contributor to her drug and alcohol addition at that time. As a result her children didn't have a good family life.
Finally she was distressed enough to divorce my father-in-law and come out.
She's now married to a woman, totally sober, much healthier (she dropped over 100 pounds), and very happy.
This article is US-centric, and the US does not have a problematic low reproductive rate (total fertility rate of 1.9), so I fail to see the relevance.
My comment was neutral about gay marriage. I was trying to tie the relationship between demographics and Nation-States and why hetero-sex is mostly overlook but important ingredient.
May be in the future each of us get to have clone armies and designer babies, I do not know. But to pretend Sexuality and its outcomes have no bearing in Life and Destiny of a Nation to me is laughable.
The only technology you fundamentally need is enough alcohol for the involved parties to have sex against their preference.
"Against their preference" does not mean "against their will." I'm referring to gay people consensually having heterosexual sex in order to procreate.
To be clear, I'm not sure it is an effective subsidy to begin with, but that's a moot point as far as this discussion goes.
If there's some perceived benefit in legal recognition of a romantic union, then there's no reason to exclude same-sex unions.
Basically, there are a few consistent positions:
1. Children are important. Outcome: either incentivize children, or incentivize fertile couples.
2. Romantic unions are important. Outcome: legally recognize all of them, including same-sex couples.
3. Freedom and small government is important. Outcome: stop recognizing marriage and let people handle it privately.
4. Religion is important. Outcome: legally recognize marriage under something like the rules of your religion.
We can argue for and against the merits of these individual possibilities, but what I can't understand is when someone uses an argument for #1 (as the other commenter here is) or #2 (as the site being discussed is) but somehow ends up with the outcome from #4.
Well, that is what the other commenter is arguing that we already do, at least in theory. The laws are from a different time, so there are many modern-day loopholes for sure, but when you look at the conditions at the time when the laws were enacted marriage would be essentially limited to those who could (to the best of their knowledge) and were willing to have children, intended to create an environment to make having children amiable.
Even divorce law is predicated on the idea that the spouse will stay home to take care of the children. Since that leaves one member of the household without an income for many years, in the event of a dissolution of the partnership one member will be left out in the cold, so to speak, so we created rules to share the proceeds gained in the process to ensure that each party is compensated for their efforts.
I think we can find all kinds of arguments as to why that is flawed in 2017, but if we just stick to the assumption that the subsidy provides exactly the expected outcome: Why does it need to change at all?
But, since nobody seems to be incorporating that data in the discussion, I'm not sure we can really fault the other commenter for believing that we are getting the desired results out of the existing subsidies. The results haven't shown up as a clear negative with respect to the intended outcome, so it is natural to assume, without better information, that it is working just fine. And, as you said, if it is working just fine there is no need for change.
Absolutely, more data is needed in this discussion to evaluate the effectiveness of what we have and to compare against alternatives. But to outright dismiss the unmeasured effectiveness of a subsidy because a handful of people have proven the willingness to do the same without that subsidy seems to be the only silly part of this discussion.
Funny ol' world, eh?
For example, we support the Bill of Rights' 1st amendment which states the government shall make no infringement on the free exercise of religion. That's a regulation that protects liberty, so we support it.
And we are generally pro-life for the same reason: the Declaration of Independence states that every person has the right to "life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness." Since abortion snuffs out all three, we seek regulation that restricts it.
The end goal is the same: smaller government, less powerful, with less impact on individual liberty.
So basically, bigger government. A smaller government would recuse itself and let the surrounding society punish infringement on protected liberties, which it already does quite well (example: do you, a San Francisco landlord, trust a racist renter over a non-racist one? And you know, because you looked them up on Facebook.)
Aren't you the least bit concerned with the other sectors of your society, that don't necessarily come to the same conclusions as you, taking notice and doing the same thing to yours? What happens when the definition of "every person" isn't universal ("group of cells" defined in an arbitrary way for the Left, from conception for the Right), or when different groups are split between which one is more important (parent for the Left, unborn child conceived the "right" way for the Right)?
Let's take another 1A example- freedom of speech. Both the Left and the Right have legitimate claims that exercise of certain kinds of speech damages the fabric of society. Their names and emphasis on certain parts are different, but the incidentals are otherwise identical (societies, like religions, are destabilized by blasphemy). But if we cave in and allow one subgroup's restriction, the other logically follows and every subgroup suffers- hard power is even more inflexible than an opposing subgroup's view of you/r group.
So subsocities agree to disarmament; one group gives up the authority to ban stuff culturally justifiable in areas held by a different group, and vice versa. This is the other purpose of the Bill of Rights- all groups, including yours, need protection from the society around them. The fact that there's an amendment ensuring that groups can defend themselves with force if things really go wrong should speak volumes about how important and valuable that treaty is.
Others are campaigning to make polygamy legal: http://www.huffingtonpost.com/entry/sister-wives-case-utah_u...
Some support pedophilic polygamy: http://www.cbsnews.com/news/warren-jeffs-trying-to-lead-poly...
I agree, the government should get out of marriage, but that also necessarily implies that it gets no special legal recognition, and would mean that gay people could also get married.
Governments may wish to encourage male-female marriage (moms & dads => children and healthy environment => productive families => civilization). If that means less taxation for families, and thus a smaller and less powerful government, all the better.
Would that be bad?
Or they are not acting in good faith.
Seems religiously motivated to me, as you'd expect. Nothing extraordinary.
Of course they also invent other reasons, and bend the facts to fit their views. But everybody does that, it's just human nature.
Please understand, I'm not attempting to make a general argument about every single person opposed to same-sex marriage. I'm specifically discussing the attitudes of stream.org, and by extension other people who hold a similar "freedom, small government, and no same-sex marriage" attitude.
"Free societies protect private property. They allow their citizens to participate in the political process, to make basic economic choices, to exercise virtue and charity and to freely exercise their religious faith."
"Evil is not just in our imaginations. We can’t eradicate it with the right amount of social engineering or positive thinking."
"The state does not determine what marriage and family are, but it must recognize them. We should oppose political attempts to redefine marriage, which are wars against the creation itself."
If they think official recognition of only "traditional" marriage is more important than the other stuff, then fine, but they should stop pretending that they're all about freedom.
They want the freedom to limit the freedom of others. They see no problem with that at all.
Liberty in this sense as used by the site you mention, includes certain responsibilities, while the libertine is unrestrained or free of responsibility.
Smaller government would be a government that does less stuff, grants status to fewer people, etc. Marriage is a legal construct that allows a couple to receive special status from the state. Same-sex marriage advocates are in favor of the government extending the benefits of that special status to an additional class of relationships. It's consistent with small government platforms to be suspicious of such expansions, regardless of one's feelings about the independent merits of the arrangement.
Hypothetically, one could be the largest advocate of permanent same-sex coupling while simultaneously believing that the government doesn't need to expand the definition of marriage to include them under its umbrella.
Not trying to drag this out, but no one has really said this yet. Opposing the expansion of marriage is consistent because expanding government is always met with suspicion by small government advocates.
No, consistency wouldn't demand that. Small government people are not automatically "no government" people. I'm saying it's natural for them to be skeptical of the expansion of services to cover new arrangements. That's government growth; small government people are likely to take a default dubious position for almost all forms of government growth/expansion, but that doesn't mean they have to oppose every function the government currently performs. That'd make them anarchists, not conservatives.
So when someone says "I want to expand a government-granted status to a new thing", the natural small government reaction is "You better have a very compelling case, because we hate the words 'expand a government-granted status'".
Going beyond this, we get into an argument on the details of same-sex marriage, and this is neither the time nor the place for that, but the point is that it is conventional for a small government proponent to view proposals to expand a longstanding legal tradition with suspicion, without necessarily requiring them to be hostile to that legal tradition as it stands. Pretending like this doesn't make sense is creating a false dichotomy. The choice doesn't have to be between "same-sex marriage" or "no marriage" to be internally consistent.
Your argument is basically that people tend to be more skeptical of change than of the status quo. Which is absolutely true, but it's not reason, it's just inertia.
"Small government" people are as prone to this mental shortcut as anyone, but that doesn't make it consistent or reasonable, it just makes it human.
We can't get into the details without this turning into a debate on same-sex marriage in general, but my point is that small government people are extra skeptical of changes that expand the government. More skeptical than the average person, because beyond simple inertia, there is an ideology that says the government should be limited and that growth should be opposed unless a compelling interest can be shown. That ideology must be satisfied to get small government people on board.
Any statistical study can be criticized as 'only being likely, not being certain.' Briggs does not provide contrary epidemiological evidence. His critique is based on the possibility of alternative explanation inherent in all statistical studies. At best there's a failure to understand the epistemological character of empirical knowledge.
Well, popular (or increasingly mainstream) results get more grants, peer acceptance and media coverage, so there's always that.
Up to the eighties those same journals would have no qualms "proving" that homosexuality is harmful, and in fact there were tons of studies to that effect.
(It works the same, but with an inverse sign, for those scientists going for the conservative audience and its, increasingly fewer, and more marginalised, grants).
So it could be more that the tide has turned, and a push to get a cute result to publish and get some publicity and good will, than an actual causation.
Better assign the same, high, probability in all fields where there are humans involved.
I assign a similarly low probability to the idea that the refuting author's self interest or fallibility caused him to publish an opinion that is at odds with the current mission of the organization that published it as I do to the probability that the original author is at odds with the purposes of the institution that published his research.
Statistical noise is always present, so of course suicide among GSM teens did not uniformly drop.
The JAMA study used different years for different states, as same-sex marriage became legal in different states at different times. His criticism about "any event in 2014 explains this drop in suicide" is malformed.
Take perspective of the modeller. What would be the first circle of influence in teen suicide? Probably direct social interactions (family, peers). Second circle? More abstract things like succes in school, relationships, the absence of bullying. For a regulatory change to have a meaningfull and measurable effect on suicides (literally the most drastic step available) is hard on first sight.
And then the step to research design. How would one expect to find a determinating factor by a DiD-design with only some regulatory measure as an explanatory factor?
For me, after looking into this study. First explain me the state by state differences in teen suicides over time adequately, before you start explaining the effect of gay marriage on teen suicides.
By the way, if you look at the accompanying figure 2 and figure 3 in the JAMA article, you will see just how noisy the data is for both Wave 1 and Wave 2 states, as well as the relative lack of post-2014 data points. Honestly, just looking at those two charts should be enough to give you a healthy skepticism about the conclusion, whatever your ideological views.
Along with 'gay marriage', 'gay acceptance' has been on the rise in general. Social interventions, heck, social media and the internet (i.e people can form like minded networks etc..).
Even a small change in policing and social policy could cause this. A bullying program.
There are so many things that could 'cause' a tiny drop in teen suicide.
So while the data is real, for whatever reason this study focused on seeking out a specific political conclusion from it that is tenuously linked at best. I would like to see who funded this research.
Pretty much none, I would expect. However, legalising same-sex marriage indicates a degree of acceptance by gay people.
I'm gay, and was born in 1985, in Ireland, which only formally legalised homosexuality in 1991. Employment discrimination against gay people only became illegal when I was 15 or so (thanks, EU), and we voted to legalise same-sex marriage when I was 29. As a kid, I felt that society was pretty bloody hostile to people like me, and I certainly did feel better when the employment discrimination law came in; I felt less like a second class citizen. Even though in practice it was rather rare for people to offend against this law, it signals certain societal attitudes.
The marriage referendum came late enough that it didn't really affect my self-image, but it's certainly plausible that it did for younger people.
We don't know, but probably "some". We can say that a state that forbids gay marriage might have schools that are less inclusive of LGBT teens, and that a state that allows gay marriage might have schools that are more inclusive of LGBT teens; and we sort of know that inclusive schools are important to reduce thoughts of suicide, suicide attempts, and deaths by suicide. (Although more research is needed.)
The CDC has some nice info, all sourced: https://www.cdc.gov/lgbthealth/youth.htm
You mentioned funding. That's described in the paper:
> Funding/Support: Ms Raifman is supported by training grants T32AI102623 and R25MH083620 from the National Institutes of Health. Dr Austin is supported by training grants T71-MC-00009 and T76-MC-00001 from the Maternal and Child Health Bureau, Health Resources and Services Administration, US Department of Health and Human Services.
> Role of the Funder/Sponsor: The funding sources played no role in the design and conduct of the study; collection, management, analysis, or interpretation of the data; preparation, review, or approval of the manuscript; and decision to submit the manuscript for publication.
Is that the conclusion the study comes to? Or is that an assumption you've made based on the headline here and not having read the study?
I hate studies that ignore missing data by saying it's not relevant.
This is why I always default to doubting "new study finds ..." until I can see the actual study.
Researchers get to choose the headlines about as much as programers get to choose the software features.
Perhaps. But we know there's a correlation between being gay and dying by suicide. We know that gay people are more likely to die by suicide than straight people.
Suicide is a complex phenomena and we should avoid simplistic reasoning, but anything that makes life easier for people to be gay is likely to reduce the numbers of death by suicide of gay people.
EDIT: I don't normally comment on downvotes, but this post is getting lots and I'm a it confused about why.
Here's the CDC: https://www.cdc.gov/lgbthealth/youth.htm
> Negative attitudes toward lesbian, gay, and bisexual (LGB) people put these youth at increased risk for experiences with violence, compared with other students.1 Violence can include behaviors such as bullying, teasing, harassment, physical assault, and suicide-related behaviors.
[...]
> LGBTQ youth are also at increased risk for suicidal thoughts and behaviors, suicide attempts, and suicide. A nationally representative study of adolescents in grades 7–12 found that lesbian, gay, and bisexual youth were more than twice as likely to have attempted suicide as their heterosexual peers.3 More studies are needed to better understand the risks for suicide among transgender youth. However, one study with 55 transgender youth found that about 25% reported suicide attempts.4
Wikipedia has a reasonable collection of references: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Suicide_among_LGBT_youth
So it would seem that the drop was more pronounced among gay people.
The truth of the conclusion seems irrelevant.
For example, I can say that hell is at the center of the Earth, and that's why it's hot.
It is indeed hot, but it is not due to hell at all.
In the context of this article, I don't think anyone is contesting that gay people are more likely to kill themselves, or that gay marriage is not an improvement.
However, the quality of this specific study apparently can be doubted, and the fact that one agree with the conclusion does not mean we should be lenient on the quality of the math behind it
Flawed study shows A implies B.
Hey! Study is flawed!
Flaws don't matter, because it got the expected result.
In this particular example the linked blog post is not saying "hey, this study is flawed", but is saying "I hate gay people and I don't want them to think that their sham marriage is in anyway equivalent to my real marriage". It's pretty clear that the linked post is only trying to find flaw with this study because they disagree with it; if you presented something with exactly the same flaws but showing A implies NotB they'd be praising it as good quality science that supports their point.
EDIT: a quote from the linked post:
>> Think about what the authors are implying: that the mere presence of gmarriage — government-defined marriage, as opposed to marriage defined by reality — stops teens from reporting suicide attempts.
>> This is among all teens, mind you, and not just the minority reporting same-sex attraction or other non-biologically oriented sexual desires. The authors claim the effect was greater in the sexual minority.
The author is clearly, unambiguously, a bigot looking to smear a study. He's not engaged in honest science.
Here's another example of his "science" writing, where he calls evolution a "theory in crisis": https://stream.org/darwins-finches-evidence-evolution-think/
And in your second paragraph, you're saying that the critique is not saying, "Hey, this study is flawed," but is saying, "I hate gay people and I don't want them to think that their sham marriage is in anyway equivalent to my real marriage." Briggs makes no secret of the fact that he rejects same-sex marriage, but the vast majority of his post is devoted to flaws in the study, not to his own personal objections to same-sex marraige, and although his ideological views probably are a motivating factor for his scrutiny of the study, that doesn't necessarily invalidate the points he makes.
Has he ever made similar points about studies that support his anti-gay marriage views? or his climate sceptic views? It should be really easy for him to find bad science among climate sceptics - has he ever written about that?
As far as I can tell, Briggs is Catholic, and he does mock Catholic officials -- including the Pope -- occasionally.
On conservative commentary website Stream.org, statistician William M. Briggs (who, take it for what it's worth, opposes same-sex marriage) offers a critique of the study's methodology and conclusion, as well as the conclusion that the study expressly does not make, but that the headlines have made:
https://stream.org/no-a-study-did-not-show-that-same-sex-mar...
A few interesting snippets from his critique:
> A weighted 8.6% to a weighted 8%, they say. This is a 7% reduction, all right, but a minor tweak in the actual weighted number. The numbers are weighted averages across several states and the result of a statistical model called a linear regression. The 0.6 drop is not observed, but is the output from a model.
> The numbers within states is anything but straightforward (the authors provide graphs). For instance, some states show reported suicide attempts increasing after gmarriage (New York, Maine, New Hampshire and Vermont, for example). The graphs also indicate a general decline in rates before gmarriage and continuing afterwards (see their Fig. 3).
> putting Ebola in the model works equally well with gmarriage to explain the data. So do the disasters of those crashing Malaysian airliners, or the fighting in Ukraine and Crimea. So does the 2014 Winter Olympics!
One other point that Briggs makes only indirectly, but bears mentioning, is that measuring the number of self-reported unsuccessful suicide attempts only provides us with part of the picture; we can't make any firm conclusions about what its rise or fall says about suicide prevention unless we also know the number of _successful_ suicide attempts. For instance, it might be the case that some suicide prevention factor reduces the likelihood that any given suicide attempt is successful. Maybe hospitals have gotten better at reducing the mortality rate of intentional overdoses. In such a case, the rate of suicide attempts might remain relatively flat, but the rate of unsuccessful suicide attempts would rise, and the rate of successful suicide attempts would fall.