News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Same-sex marriage linked to decline in teen suicides by sremani on Monday February 27, 2017 @01:03PM (#13746281)
What about modern medical technology? how many people of the 3,978,497 of people born in US in year 2015 were born out of this modern technology ? Now if we extend that to world, that is hundreds of millions of babies.

My comment was neutral about gay marriage. I was trying to tie the relationship between demographics and Nation-States and why hetero-sex is mostly overlook but important ingredient.

May be in the future each of us get to have clone armies and designer babies, I do not know. But to pretend Sexuality and its outcomes have no bearing in Life and Destiny of a Nation to me is laughable.

Re:Same-sex marriage linked to decline in teen suicides by mikeash on Monday February 27, 2017 @01:05PM (#13746301)
Did you miss the middle part of my reply?

The only technology you fundamentally need is enough alcohol for the involved parties to have sex against their preference.

Re:Same-sex marriage linked to decline in teen suicides by randomdata on Monday February 27, 2017 @02:06PM (#13746858)
How does raping someone – at least I take that to be what you mean by drugging someone into having sex against their preference – relate to a subsidy designed to incentivize couples to willingly have (and care for) children?
Re:Same-sex marriage linked to decline in teen suicides by mikeash on Monday February 27, 2017 @02:10PM (#13746909)
Uh....

"Against their preference" does not mean "against their will." I'm referring to gay people consensually having heterosexual sex in order to procreate.

Re:Same-sex marriage linked to decline in teen suicides by randomdata on Monday February 27, 2017 @02:12PM (#13746932)
Thanks for the clarification. Now, if they are already willing to do it without government incentive, what does expanding the subsidy to include them add?

To be clear, I'm not sure it is an effective subsidy to begin with, but that's a moot point as far as this discussion goes.

Re:Same-sex marriage linked to decline in teen suicides by mikeash on Monday February 27, 2017 @02:21PM (#13747062)
It seems to make them happy.
Re:Same-sex marriage linked to decline in teen suicides by randomdata on Monday February 27, 2017 @02:25PM (#13747094)
Well sure, who doesn't like getting subsidies? That doesn't mean it is effective for a government to invent subsidies for everyone. There has to be a desired outcome, even if in the real world it falls short or brings many unintended consequences. And I think there are lots of good reasons to eliminate this subsidy entirely, but that's a whole other discussion.
Re:Same-sex marriage linked to decline in teen suicides by mikeash on Monday February 27, 2017 @02:33PM (#13747167)
What's the goal? If it's to promote having children, then you should just subsidize having children. If for some reason you really want to subsidize children through marriage, then you should stop subsidizing marriages involving people who can't or won't have children.

If there's some perceived benefit in legal recognition of a romantic union, then there's no reason to exclude same-sex unions.

Basically, there are a few consistent positions:

1. Children are important. Outcome: either incentivize children, or incentivize fertile couples.

2. Romantic unions are important. Outcome: legally recognize all of them, including same-sex couples.

3. Freedom and small government is important. Outcome: stop recognizing marriage and let people handle it privately.

4. Religion is important. Outcome: legally recognize marriage under something like the rules of your religion.

We can argue for and against the merits of these individual possibilities, but what I can't understand is when someone uses an argument for #1 (as the other commenter here is) or #2 (as the site being discussed is) but somehow ends up with the outcome from #4.

Re:Same-sex marriage linked to decline in teen suicides by randomdata on Monday February 27, 2017 @03:07PM (#13747473)
> you should stop subsidizing marriages involving people who can't or won't have children.

Well, that is what the other commenter is arguing that we already do, at least in theory. The laws are from a different time, so there are many modern-day loopholes for sure, but when you look at the conditions at the time when the laws were enacted marriage would be essentially limited to those who could (to the best of their knowledge) and were willing to have children, intended to create an environment to make having children amiable.

Even divorce law is predicated on the idea that the spouse will stay home to take care of the children. Since that leaves one member of the household without an income for many years, in the event of a dissolution of the partnership one member will be left out in the cold, so to speak, so we created rules to share the proceeds gained in the process to ensure that each party is compensated for their efforts.

I think we can find all kinds of arguments as to why that is flawed in 2017, but if we just stick to the assumption that the subsidy provides exactly the expected outcome: Why does it need to change at all?

Re:Same-sex marriage linked to decline in teen suicides by mikeash on Monday February 27, 2017 @06:13PM (#13749449)
If you assume it's already perfect then of course it doesn't need to change. But that's a silly assumption.
Re:Same-sex marriage linked to decline in teen suicides by randomdata on Monday February 27, 2017 @06:36PM (#13749656)
You are absolutely right. We shouldn't make assumptions. We should be looking at the data to see what we value we really are getting for the subsidy.

But, since nobody seems to be incorporating that data in the discussion, I'm not sure we can really fault the other commenter for believing that we are getting the desired results out of the existing subsidies. The results haven't shown up as a clear negative with respect to the intended outcome, so it is natural to assume, without better information, that it is working just fine. And, as you said, if it is working just fine there is no need for change.

Absolutely, more data is needed in this discussion to evaluate the effectiveness of what we have and to compare against alternatives. But to outright dismiss the unmeasured effectiveness of a subsidy because a handful of people have proven the willingness to do the same without that subsidy seems to be the only silly part of this discussion.

Re:Same-sex marriage linked to decline in teen suicides by sremani on Monday February 27, 2017 @01:28PM (#13746514)
No, apparently you need to read and understand my first post, esp. taking off those "ideological" glasses.
Re:Same-sex marriage linked to decline in teen suicides by ionised on Tuesday February 28, 2017 @10:29AM (#13754389)
Why are you repeatedly capitalising those three words (Life, Destiny and Nation)?