News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Wall Street Is Giving Up On Twitter by the_economist on Friday February 10, 2017 @01:06PM (#13617469)
Twitter is so powerful. When Paul Graham wants to say something, he takes to Twitter to do it. Not Facebook. Not Hacker News. Not reddit.

The same goes for many of the most influential people in the world.

Twitter has incredible utility for powerful people but very limited utility for average people. Maybe the exact opposite of facebook. On Facebook, my friends interact with me. On twitter, I speak into the void.

Re:Wall Street Is Giving Up On Twitter by anigbrowl on Friday February 10, 2017 @01:43PM (#13617770)
I find the exact same thing; on every other social platform you get out more or less what you put in and it's reasonably easy to build persistent acquaintances and even intimate friendships over time.

I decided to make a concerted effort to participate more on Twitter a few months back, but if you have a low number of followers hardly anyone interacts with you, it's like being in a big crowd where a few people have megaphones and everyone else is whispering. I suppose I could buy a bunch of followers for $ in order to seem more worth talking to but that's a bullshit tactic and I don't respect platforms where bullshit is rewarded. Twitter seems to function best as an adjunct to other media than as a self-sustaining ecosystem.

Frankly I feel Twitter has made the internet (and by extension, society) worse in numerous ways - the dumb 140 character limit (notwithstanding this being inherited from SMS), its appalling user interface, and the overuse of simplistic metrics to score everyone and everything they say, promoting the crudest sort of lowest-common-denominator social proof.

As far as I can see the best way to be popular on Twitter (other than already being famous to start with) is to be an ass, which will get social approval from people who feel the same way but are inhibited from expressing that for whatever reason. The good things about Twitter (speed and flatness) persist despite the other factors rather than as a result of them. If it shut down tomorrow I think people would get over the loss within a week.

Re:Wall Street Is Giving Up On Twitter by dtornabene on Friday February 10, 2017 @04:30PM (#13619061)
I did the same a year ago, largely agree with this, though I would note that it has been extremely useful to follow journalists (and comedy people/funny users). Specifically in regard to journalists however, I feel, just barely, that its worth it. One is able to gain a sense of what these people actually feel, away from an editorial board. Which is both enlightening and highly useful, if you actually devote time to reading journalism. Its also been very useful for organizing, as in, "there is a rally ya'll, come to such and such, like, now". More than once I've missed emails or other communications that would have pulled me into an action, meeting or other event but saw references to it on twitter and was able to make it at the last minute.
Re:Wall Street Is Giving Up On Twitter by gwking on Friday February 10, 2017 @09:46PM (#13620652)
I went to this event two nights ago: http://www.nydailynews.com/new-york/experts-debate-solution-...

One interesting comment during the debate was that many (liberal) journalists use Twitter as a side platform on which they feel comfortable voicing more personal views. While it is an acceptable practice in their circles, conservative readers often point to those tweets as evidence of liberal bias in the industry. Regardless of the professional ethical consensus, it may be a cause of distrust, and suggests a general problem of liberal journalists preaching to the choir.

Re:Wall Street Is Giving Up On Twitter by dtornabene on Saturday February 11, 2017 @04:12AM (#13621853)
Eh, I'm kind of in the Colbert (although far more to the left) view of "reality has a well known liberal bias". It was a great joke, and I think got to the heart of the screeching about "bias" from "conservatives" (reactionaries). I find the idea that there is a neutral impartial view laughable, honestly. But then, I'm a commie, so shrug.

A final thought as well, I think, whatever your politics, that much of the liberal bias talk from the right, especially the now unmasked far right, was simply language policing. It was an attempt to set the terms of the debate and pull the frame as far right as possible, which seemed to have been largely successful in my opinion. Thanks for the link and the comment, I'll check it out!

Re:Wall Street Is Giving Up On Twitter by BaronSamedi on Saturday February 11, 2017 @08:30AM (#13622499)
I get the idea behind the "reality has a well known liberal bias" shibboleth. I think, however, that a more accurate and less self-serving formulation is that reality is non-partisan. Reality doesn't care about anyone's cherished political views.
Re:Wall Street Is Giving Up On Twitter by redthrowaway on Friday February 10, 2017 @10:58PM (#13620923)
It's certainly contributed to the irreparable ending of the relationship between conservatives and the MSM (to the detriment of both, and society itself). But conservative journalists and pundits are no less shy about spouting off, provided they work for a conservative outlet. I think what you don't see is journalists at mainstream (read: liberal) outlets who happen to be conservative, instead of token conservative pundits like @DouthatNYT, expressing their views publicly.
Re:Wall Street Is Giving Up On Twitter by rtpg on Saturday February 11, 2017 @03:15AM (#13621702)
I follow developers and journalists, and spend a decent amount of time replying to things I see. I usually get responses from people.

I've found that twitter has gotten close to replacing email for sending a message to a "stranger" (software dev, journo).

I post stuff more for myself. I get sad when my clever tweets don't get looked at, but just writing is fun too.

Re:Wall Street Is Giving Up On Twitter by martin-adams on Saturday February 11, 2017 @06:39AM (#13622199)
I'm like you. I would rather a tweet than email from a stranger. It just feels less intrusive and better for quick a back and forth with a bit of personality.
Re:Wall Street Is Giving Up On Twitter by pavel_lishin on Friday February 10, 2017 @03:21PM (#13618539)
> if you have a low number of followers hardly anyone interacts with you

I don't have this problem, but the only people that follow me are typically my friends who may be interested in the things I have to say.

Re:Wall Street Is Giving Up On Twitter by mtw on Friday February 10, 2017 @01:18PM (#13617550)
It's interesting to see how the power and reach of every word on Twitter by politicians or journalists, yet Twitter is unable to profit from it. On the other hand, nobody cares about the power of a Facebook posting or an instagram, yet Facebook makes so much money of the frivolity.
Re:Wall Street Is Giving Up On Twitter by danjoc on Friday February 10, 2017 @01:30PM (#13617670)
>yet Twitter is unable to profit from it.

Twitter could front run wall street on Donald Trump tweets.

Re:Wall Street Is Giving Up On Twitter by jessriedel on Friday February 10, 2017 @02:10PM (#13617977)
It does seem like having early access to all tweets would be immensely valuable, even if it was only a second of lead time. (Sure, Trump tweets are valuable on their own, but market info has to be encoded into coarse-grained info about individually useless tweets as well.) Unless they have an explicit policy against it, Twitter must be selling this, right?
Re:Wall Street Is Giving Up On Twitter by aetherson on Friday February 10, 2017 @02:55PM (#13618338)
New business model: For $1M per tweet, you can have a 50ms head-start on tweets from Trump. Just Trump, just one tier of headstart/pricing. You prepay for the next N tweets. You can set time-ranges (like, "when the markets are open") for when you want to pay for the headstart.

I bet they could get a few tens of millions of revenue there. Probably HFT firms would at least experiment with it, right?

Might get them into some serious regulatory crosshairs.

Re:Wall Street Is Giving Up On Twitter by jessriedel on Friday February 10, 2017 @03:10PM (#13618459)
What regulation? Insider trading requires actual insiders; non-insiders are generally allowed to trade on non-public information.
Re:Wall Street Is Giving Up On Twitter by wtvanhest on Friday February 10, 2017 @10:28PM (#13620799)
A non insider that posseses material, nonpublic info is not allowed to trade on it until it becomes public.
Re:Wall Street Is Giving Up On Twitter by jessriedel on Saturday February 11, 2017 @02:38PM (#13624321)
The sources I can find say there is only a violation when the person trading is an insider or is purposefully tipped off by an insider.

http://www.sandstormgold.com/_resources/policies/SSL_Stock_T...

https://www.sec.gov/answers/insider.htm

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Insider_trading#Definition_of_...

The most direct version is here:

> In 1983, Switzer was sued by the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) for an alleged civil violation of the laws prohibiting "insider trading" of securities. He defended himself as having innocently overheard the information while lounging on the bleacher behind some corporate insiders—at a stadium where Switzer was watching his elder son compete in a track meet. The case was tried in Oklahoma City United States District Court (before a special U.S. District Judge appointed from Kansas). The case was dismissed at the conclusion of the Government's case for its failure to demonstrate that there had been any purposeful disclosure to Switzer.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Barry_Switzer#After_coaching

https://www.sec.gov/news/speech/1986/062086grundfest.pdf#pag...

Do you have a source that says otherwise?

The situation is even more clear for Twitter. If I'm a marine biologist making the world's most detailed measurements of the ocean, I can clearly use this info to buy or sell stock in a fishing company, even if I don't release that info publicly. Likewise, I can sell that info to someone else who makes the trades.

Re:Wall Street Is Giving Up On Twitter by wtvanhest on Sunday February 12, 2017 @04:24PM (#13630950)
After reviewing the info you provided, I beleive you are mainly right. The only exception i can think of would be a situation where trump possesed inside information due to his position, then shared it via twitter early. That would be a violation, but it gets complex, and im having trouble formulating the exact line.
Re:Wall Street Is Giving Up On Twitter by jessriedel on Monday February 13, 2017 @04:43PM (#13639053)
Thanks for your response!
Re:Wall Street Is Giving Up On Twitter by mck- on Saturday February 11, 2017 @12:45AM (#13621245)
But this is already common practice with Bloomberg terminals -- banks paying big bucks get 15min earlier information than the public
Re:Wall Street Is Giving Up On Twitter by wtvanhest on Saturday February 11, 2017 @03:55AM (#13621805)
Prices are not nonpublic info. You can get them a number of ways without using bloomberg. Most people in finance believe in at least semi-efficient markets which means prices are not material anyway
Re:Wall Street Is Giving Up On Twitter by bryanrasmussen on Friday February 10, 2017 @04:37PM (#13619118)
I'm guessing there might some powerful family that would want a cut of the action.
Re:Wall Street Is Giving Up On Twitter by _yosefk on Friday February 10, 2017 @10:31PM (#13620814)
This is the funniest thing I read today. The problem of course is how to trade them.
Re:Wall Street Is Giving Up On Twitter by rhizome on Friday February 10, 2017 @10:47PM (#13620876)
Re:Wall Street Is Giving Up On Twitter by gdubs on Friday February 10, 2017 @01:36PM (#13617725)
It's reminiscent of the way that broadcast news was transformed as profit became a motive (basically the themes that are explored in the movie 'Network').

News orgs were never in themselves meant to be profitable, yet they were at the heart of the big three network's identities (and had enormous reach).

Re:Wall Street Is Giving Up On Twitter by linkregister on Friday February 10, 2017 @02:06PM (#13617957)
> News orgs were never in themselves meant to be profitable

Can you talk more about this? I was always under the impression that newspapers and newsrooms were always for-profit enterprises.

Re:Wall Street Is Giving Up On Twitter by genericpseudo on Friday February 10, 2017 @02:22PM (#13618067)
Local ad networks masquerading as news organizations. Record labels and newspapers have a lot in common; they were global logistics companies first (the core competence of Atlantic was shipping highly-processed petrochemical discs around the world) and media companies not really at all.

What newspapers had was a lock on the business now owned by Craigslist, with the transport and fulfillment network (newsagents and delivery vans!) being the key asset. Once that went away they were no longer businesses.

They didn't see it that way, but that's because their core business was so good they could afford to delude themselves - it didn't matter that they didn't know what they were really doing, the business model was that powerful. Google is remarkably similar in many ways.

Re:Wall Street Is Giving Up On Twitter by dilemma on Saturday February 11, 2017 @02:26AM (#13621585)
AAA+ comment.
Re:Wall Street Is Giving Up On Twitter by daffodil-11 on Friday February 10, 2017 @04:35PM (#13619102)
The networks were given broadcast spectrum in return for one hour a day of public service, which took the form of news broadcasts. This was taken quite seriously by the original owners of the networks as a solemn duty to inform the public. They built large, global news gathering organizations that were a source of pride to them personally. They practically competed to lose the most money on news. (IIRC, by the mid-80's losses were in the $300m/yr ballpark.)

By 1987, a number of factors - changes in ownership for the big 3 networks, upstart FOX network, the increasing importance of celebrity anchors on ratings, deregulation of media ownership laws and other factors - caused a mass shift towards looking at news as profit centers.

Ken Auletta's "Three Blind Mice" is excellent. (At least on recollection. It profoundly changed my understanding of the media when I read it 25 years ago.)

Newspapers have never had such constraints but there were laws limiting the concentration of ownership aimed at making sure people had diverse influences in any one market. For instance, TV channels could not be owned by the same company that owned a newspaper in the same market. I don't know enough off the top of my head to expand more usefully on that.

Re:Wall Street Is Giving Up On Twitter by gdubs on Friday February 10, 2017 @04:39PM (#13619129)
Also just got James Fallows' book "Breaking the News" – he's one of my favorite writers at the Atlantic, and so far it's a great book – don't know if it talks about this aspect of the news, but still worth checking out.
Re:Wall Street Is Giving Up On Twitter by cclements on Friday February 10, 2017 @03:00PM (#13618382)
You, know I remembered seeing something about this in the show 'newsroom':

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GXrOqjS9ZyA

But trying to do a little research on it, the best I could come up with for proof is:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prime_Time_Access_Rule

Still a good show though.

Re:Wall Street Is Giving Up On Twitter by rhizome on Friday February 10, 2017 @11:01PM (#13620937)
Re:Wall Street Is Giving Up On Twitter by gdubs on Friday February 10, 2017 @04:33PM (#13619086)
Re:Wall Street Is Giving Up On Twitter by gozur88 on Saturday February 11, 2017 @02:54AM (#13621651)
You can reach people on Twitter, but there's some question as to how much you can influence people. Periodically I see articles from people with hundreds of thousands of followers who admit to being unable to translate that into sales, or hits to their site, or votes, or whatever.

Twitter is a great platform to keep your name in the public consciousness. So... indispensable if you're a Kardashian. Other than that, though, it's not clear. A lot of people are wasting a lot of time building up a subscriber account that ends up being meaningless.

Facebook makes money because people give it a lot more information than they give twitter. Too much, IMO.

Re:Wall Street Is Giving Up On Twitter by schnevets on Friday February 10, 2017 @01:25PM (#13617621)
And a Snap is volatile and even more frivolous! Maybe they're even MORE valuable!
Re:Wall Street Is Giving Up On Twitter by sjg007 on Friday February 10, 2017 @04:51PM (#13619222)
Snapchat has a novel engagement mechanism. Short multimedia interactive ads in a captured setting. The format has potential. The Snapstream keeps people hooked. It's basically a next gen Facebook but more private.
Re:Wall Street Is Giving Up On Twitter by anigbrowl on Friday February 10, 2017 @01:44PM (#13617774)
Oh I care about the power of FB posting and indeed instagram. I think you're seriously underestimating the reach and popularity of those platforms.
Re:Wall Street Is Giving Up On Twitter by xyzzy4 on Friday February 10, 2017 @01:31PM (#13617688)
They're potentially able to profit from it, but they feel the need to have thousands of employees.
Re:Wall Street Is Giving Up On Twitter by swamp40 on Friday February 10, 2017 @01:31PM (#13617689)
They should charge you for each 'like' you get for a post. First 100 would be free.
Re:Wall Street Is Giving Up On Twitter by mirimir on Friday February 10, 2017 @01:36PM (#13617721)
They could at least charge by completed likes. That is, hold likes as prospective, and complete only after payment.
Re:Wall Street Is Giving Up On Twitter by AznHisoka on Saturday February 11, 2017 @02:23PM (#13624234)
thats untrue.

Look at all the articles written when Beyonce posts her pregnant body on Instagram as an example. we only think twitter has so much influence because thats where a lot of techies hang out.

Re:Wall Street Is Giving Up On Twitter by teej on Friday February 10, 2017 @01:29PM (#13617666)
Care to share which of pg's tweets you found powerful? I would say that when pg has something to say, he takes to his blog. I dont think his tweets are within an order of magnitude as valuable as his blog. And for that reason I don't agree with your assessment of Twitter.

I don't think you're giving the distribution mechanisms enough credit. The only reason that the POTUS's tweets hold so much weight is because every 24 hour news company reports on them endlessly. It gets power from magnification.

Re:Wall Street Is Giving Up On Twitter by sbarre on Friday February 10, 2017 @01:36PM (#13617720)
Twitter simplifies re-broadcasting and discovery..

Only people who know Paul Graham will know about his blog, but his tweets can be re-broadcast to a much wider audience through re-tweeting, who can be exposed to him without having sought him out or known about him in the first place.

I've discovered, and subsequently followed, probably half of my twitter feed through re-tweets from my existing feed.

I have to imagine that's the same for a lot of others.

Re:Wall Street Is Giving Up On Twitter by projektfu on Friday February 10, 2017 @02:30PM (#13618135)
That's funny. When I first started reading his blog, I had no idea who he was, and Twitter didn't exist yet. A friend emailed a link to me because he thought I should read it.
Re:Wall Street Is Giving Up On Twitter by sbarre on Friday February 10, 2017 @04:52PM (#13619228)
I definitely wasn't implying that there are no other ways for people to discover content, and email is of course still a very popular way for that to happen.

I still email links, and receive links by email, all the time ..

Re:Wall Street Is Giving Up On Twitter by wslh on Friday February 10, 2017 @01:09PM (#13617485)
Linus Torvalds uses Google+. Compare https://plus.google.com/+LinusTorvalds to https://twitter.com/Linus__Torvalds/with_replies?lang=en

Which means that different people in different communities choose different communication tools for reasons that are not obvious.

Re:Wall Street Is Giving Up On Twitter by pasbesoin on Friday February 10, 2017 @01:27PM (#13617640)
Torvalds. David Brin. Tim O'Reilly (although Tim uses or used to use multiple platforms in an ongoing fashion). Randall Schwartz. A few others I'm not thinking of right now.

Plus garnered a bit of a "tech"/thinker corner. I don't know whether it has any remaining vibrancy/growth, at this point, or whether its mostly a matter of inertia combined with the crapitude of other platforms for the particular communicating they are doing.

Too bad Plus was so thoroughly hosed from the start by political agendas.

OT: At Christmas, I stopped accessing Facebook. I thought it would be for a few days or a week. Coming up on two months, soon, and I haven't been able to make myself go back. Even with a relatively small set of FB friends whom I actually, personally know, and who are nice and not rabid and actually respond meaningfully to some of my own contributions, there.

In some ways, the impersonal, more technical content on Plus (and here, and etc.) is easier. There is no "missing aspect" as there is with FB engagement with friends.

Twitter? Gave up on that years ago. Tim O'Reilly had an interesting post or two about some of its positive, community aspects, in its early days. But now, it just mostly seems a megaphone for the loud and discontent.

And then, too, anywhere Trump et al. are and that seems to aid his lying megalomania. I'm not inclined to lend it the (incremental) support of my participation.

If he's a particular indication of their future, well, then, welcome to the gutter, Twitter.

Re:Wall Street Is Giving Up On Twitter by waynecolvin on Friday February 10, 2017 @03:43PM (#13618722)
Are you sure there weren't some sort of recruitment effort with at least some of those guys... Though you do see some tech pages out there, maybe because of Hangouts? shrug

I didn't know Tim O'Reilly was on G+ but ALL these recent posts are pop-politics and ugly at that! I thought you were referring to all Google services being tied in.

Re:Wall Street Is Giving Up On Twitter by pasbesoin on Friday February 10, 2017 @04:15PM (#13618965)
I don't know. Good point. I expect some, e.g. O'Reilly, were actively solicited.

I don't spend too much time in Plus. Brin has had a lot of political stuff, recently, although he's a bit mixed and individual in his opinions and they do tend to tie back to points modeled in his sci-fi writing.

O'Reilly I see less frequently. I suppose he's getting more "elder statesman", too.

Torvalds actually addresses some tech stuff. Though he has personal stuff, too -- he does not use it as a "tech blog".

Reminds me some of Tim Bray's "Ongoing" blog -- self-hosted -- that I haven't been to in a while. A personal take, on both tech and other stuff in his life. Whatever the topic, informed, intelligent, and thoughtful. Creative, too.

I don't think Plus is in any kind of a steady state. Even what I wrote about, may well be in decline. Maybe it was better a few years ago.

Regardless, this year's politics have really shocked a lot of people, and this is spilling over into erstwhile non-political venues.

Re:Wall Street Is Giving Up On Twitter by Navarr on Friday February 10, 2017 @01:12PM (#13617504)
Robert Scoble uses Facebook.

Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/RobertScoble Twitter: https://twitter.com/Scobleizer

Of note for Scoble is that there's much more room to talk on Facebook than twitter. I wonder if that's a similar reason that Torvalds uses G+

Re:Wall Street Is Giving Up On Twitter by problems on Friday February 10, 2017 @01:19PM (#13617559)
Quite probably, G+ also doesn't beg for login like Facebook does sometimes so it's easier to use without an account.
Re:Wall Street Is Giving Up On Twitter by oxryly1 on Friday February 10, 2017 @01:26PM (#13617634)
Oddly, when I clicked on Linus's G+ link it redirected me to a G+ advertising sequence, complete with web popups. I had to click a second time to actually get there.

I think that may be my biggest issue with G+ (despite so few people using it)... they keep changing it. Facebook evolves much more slowly, so it's much more predictable and comfortable to the distracted and comfort-seeking social media user like myself. G+ is constantly experimenting and I can't easily pin down exactly what it is...

Re:Wall Street Is Giving Up On Twitter by supergreg on Friday February 10, 2017 @01:39PM (#13617751)
Is there a service that can aggregate posts from people in Google+, Twitter, Facebook, blogs, patreon, etc?
Re:Wall Street Is Giving Up On Twitter by bjelkeman-again on Friday February 10, 2017 @09:55PM (#13620681)
The closest I get is the Flipboard app.
Re:Wall Street Is Giving Up On Twitter by bluedino on Friday February 10, 2017 @01:23PM (#13617603)
Carmack used to, didn't he? Until Facebook hired him?
Re:Wall Street Is Giving Up On Twitter by whatever_dude on Friday February 10, 2017 @01:39PM (#13617749)
Carmack uses Twitter a lot. But he uses Facebook for longer posts.
Re:Wall Street Is Giving Up On Twitter by jeron on Friday February 10, 2017 @01:13PM (#13617513)
I agree with this, Twitter is still the best place for celebrities to interact with their fans. Elon Musk for example has unveiled more than a few of his ideas and dropped details of his products on Twitter instead of anywhere else.
Re:Wall Street Is Giving Up On Twitter by ghaff on Friday February 10, 2017 @02:07PM (#13617965)
>for celebrities to interact with their fans.

More like broadcast to their fans.

Which is something of a strength and weakness of Twitter. It can be used for conversations but the 140 character limit makes it tough. As a result, Twitter is generally best used for people who are broadcasting things to a group of interested followers. If that doesn't describe you (either as a follower or a followee) then you're probably not going to find Twitter very useful.

Re:Wall Street Is Giving Up On Twitter by acchow on Friday February 10, 2017 @01:30PM (#13617671)
I follow musicians' pages on Facebook - they announce all kinds of things there.
Re:Wall Street Is Giving Up On Twitter by delecti on Friday February 10, 2017 @01:39PM (#13617746)
The problem with that is Facebook doesn't always show you everything from everyone you follow.
Re:Wall Street Is Giving Up On Twitter by tannerc on Friday February 10, 2017 @02:55PM (#13618337)
There's specifically a setting that you can select on any Page or Profile to "See First in News Feed." [https://www.facebook.com/help/1188278037864643]
Re:Wall Street Is Giving Up On Twitter by acchow on Friday February 10, 2017 @02:56PM (#13618348)
I like that.

I don't have the time or energy to consume the firehose that my Twitter feed has become - so I just don't use it anymore.

Re:Wall Street Is Giving Up On Twitter by delecti on Friday February 10, 2017 @09:02PM (#13620508)
I don't like that it forces me to go to a page to see everything they've posted. The whole reason I subscribe to things is to see all of those things. I can choose to hide things, they don't give me the choice to see everything. To me Facebook is fundamentally broken in that way.
Re:Wall Street Is Giving Up On Twitter by overcast on Friday February 10, 2017 @03:37PM (#13618671)
Which a mailing list would accomplish the same thing. In fact, I would prefer I just receive email directly from people I follow, rather than a separate stupid app.
Re:Wall Street Is Giving Up On Twitter by toomuchtodo on Friday February 10, 2017 @01:14PM (#13617524)
There's no reason he couldn't do the same with a mailing list.

Twitter might have value, but no route to profitability.

Edit: Y'all are super salty about Twitter falling apart. Sad!

Re:Wall Street Is Giving Up On Twitter by Ruphin on Friday February 10, 2017 @01:26PM (#13617631)
The reach of mailing lists is orders of magnitude smaller.

People have to sign up for a mailing list; and people who aren't signed up generally don't get your content. This is a stark contrast with Twitter, where content is shared at a significantly higher rate. I don't necessarily have to subscribe to a certain source to get content from them, if someone in my network decides to share that content. When was the last time you received a message that was sent over a mailing list that someone forwarded to your inbox?

I don't follow Elon Musk, but if he puts out an important tweet someone I follow will retweet him putting his content in my feed. An Elon tweet with some big announcement easily reaches an audience of millions. No mailing list has that kind of reach.

Re:Wall Street Is Giving Up On Twitter by rdiddly on Saturday February 11, 2017 @12:51PM (#13623734)
Yes but there's no reason it couldn't, I believe was somebody's point. Twitter doesn't do anything that's not possible by other means. Following is conceptually the same as subscribing. Sharing or retweeting is the same as forwarding. You're only describing differences in usage patterns, and network effects from popularity of the network. Not discounting those at all, just noticing nothing unique has been demonstrated.
Re:Wall Street Is Giving Up On Twitter by jkaunisv1 on Friday February 10, 2017 @01:20PM (#13617572)
The interaction is completely different. I can check on Elon's twitter whenever I want without having to subscribe. People can have conversations around his tweets without spamming strangers' inboxen. I can send you a link to one of his tweets and you can pass it on to whoever you want without exposing my address to your friends. I have no idea why you would compare the two.
Re:Wall Street Is Giving Up On Twitter by toomuchtodo on Friday February 10, 2017 @01:22PM (#13617592)
You just described a mailing list with a web frontend. Perfect example: NANOG (North American network ops group)

Massive mailing list. Web enabled. Trivial cost. Deep links possible to share. EDIT: And more than 160 characters! Hallelujah! A format an actual discussion can take place in.

I compare the two because I'm old, tech is cyclic, and everyone reinvents the wheel. Twitter is, clearly, not special, and can't justify its valuation.

Re:Wall Street Is Giving Up On Twitter by res0nat0r on Friday February 10, 2017 @01:50PM (#13617830)
I use twitter to get instant updates on current news from reporters sitting in WH briefing rooms and other breaking news unfiltered from the people on the ground. I like reading quotes from what is happening real time and being able to respond before it even hits the live NBC news feed.

You just aren't going to ever have that with a mailing list. If you could we would be doing it.

Re:Wall Street Is Giving Up On Twitter by coldtea on Friday February 10, 2017 @02:04PM (#13617942)
>I use twitter to get instant updates on current news

Because "current news" are so interesting/relevant/important to one's everyday life and/or politics?

It's mostly a bunch of noise -- with plenty of BS and lies on top.

If you want to know what's happening, better read a "not instant", more analysis/depth outlet.

Re:Wall Street Is Giving Up On Twitter by res0nat0r on Friday February 10, 2017 @04:48PM (#13619198)
>If you want to know what's happening, better read a "not instant", more analysis/depth outlet.

I read WaPo and the NYT for that, Twitter is for breaking news and info from reporters real-time when they are questioning folks.

Re:Wall Street Is Giving Up On Twitter by rhizome on Friday February 10, 2017 @11:09PM (#13620965)
"Mostly" is tunable.
Re:Wall Street Is Giving Up On Twitter by jkaunisv1 on Friday February 10, 2017 @02:44PM (#13618257)
Well, good point. I totally forgot about those.

That said, is this page representative of what you're talking about or am I missing a better UI? http://mailman.nanog.org/pipermail/nanog/2017-February/threa...

Obviously it could be styled differently/"better" for mass consumption, but that aside, it still exposes private emails and full names of the participants.

And I think the character limit is part of what makes it valuable...I don't really want to read an essay, the forced concision is great for a lot of the use cases. And getting back to Elon, he probably doesn't want to engage in deep discussion with all those randoms, he wants to drop a juicy tidbit, build excitement and let the discussion happen elsewhere. When he has something more to say, he writes a blog post and tweets a link.

I'm actually not defending Twitter's valuation or business prospects, just the value or uniqueness of the service relative to something like a mailing list. I'm still not convinced they're so similar.

Re:Wall Street Is Giving Up On Twitter by slg on Friday February 10, 2017 @01:27PM (#13617643)
The barrier for a follow is so much lower than a mailing list. I am not going to sign up for a mailing list from a random comedian to send me their tour dates that 98% of the time aren't relevant to me. But I will put up with them Tweeting those date if their other Tweets are funny.
Re:Wall Street Is Giving Up On Twitter by ghaff on Friday February 10, 2017 @02:14PM (#13618016)
Twitter also has this element of being like a river you can dip into whenever you're inclined and ignore the rest of the time. As you say, I do subscribe to some newsletters and mailing lists but it's very easy to get overloaded and/or end up filtering things to a folder that you never look at. Twitter seems to strike a reasonable balance of utility/effort/distraction/etc. for a lot of things that email-oriented methods really don't.
Re:Wall Street Is Giving Up On Twitter by tigershark on Friday February 10, 2017 @04:41PM (#13619148)
Ah right.. Like that story last week about the writer that got so addicted to twitter that she had to close her account? From my point of view it doesn't seem so easy and balanced.
Re:Wall Street Is Giving Up On Twitter by tigershark on Friday February 10, 2017 @04:38PM (#13619126)
I'm missing something.. You just said that you won't click a button to signup a newsletter that delivers you funny jokes and the tour dates of a random comedian, but you are more than happy to press a button to get exactly the same things but with the limitations that the funny jokes must be less than 140 chars. There must be a reason if I never used and understood twitter at all..
Re:Wall Street Is Giving Up On Twitter by slg on Friday February 10, 2017 @07:16PM (#13620110)
Emails require more of my attention and they arrive whenever they are sent. Tweets require zero attention, they are easy to ignore, and I never see them unless I specifically seek them out by opening Twitter. Basically Twitter is much more voluntary than email.
Re:Wall Street Is Giving Up On Twitter by rdiddly on Saturday February 11, 2017 @12:40PM (#13623667)
I get this, but it's kind of funny to hear someone say Twitter's unique value proposition is that you can ignore it. As a non-user I must be extracting tons of value from it then! It's the poor users I feel sorry for!

Just joking around. But, not completely. The value you speak of is really the ability to spend your time on something potentially more worthwhile. People forget social media has an opportunity cost.

Re:Wall Street Is Giving Up On Twitter by detaro on Friday February 10, 2017 @01:15PM (#13617529)
Twitter is way better for directly hype-building around those tweets. Although maybe a mailing list could be marketed in a similar way, of done cleverly.
Re:Wall Street Is Giving Up On Twitter by toomuchtodo on Friday February 10, 2017 @01:17PM (#13617542)
Twitter might be better, but it appears it can't make money from "being better" than a mailing list.

You can be the best platform in the world, and if you don't make money, you're going under.

Re:Wall Street Is Giving Up On Twitter by philwelch on Saturday February 11, 2017 @03:42AM (#13621769)
There's another side to Twitter:

> I know a lot of creators of nerd culture. Game designers, writers, comic artists. Old, gnarled, crabby, battle-hardened pros with decades of experience. You'd have heard of a bunch of them.

> They all have something in common. It never fails to amaze me, but a single mean email or bad review can send them into a spiral. Like, they'll still be obsessing over it days later. I think, "Wow. After all these years, they still won't let this stuff roll off of them?" And then it happens to me.

> So we filter our inputs.

> ...

> Some people are mean. Some people are crazy. Some people are both. I do not let people in these categories pour poison directly into my ear.

> ...

> Twitter was designed, from Day 1, to enable any random person to send messages directly to any public figure. In other words, from Day 1, it was designed to be an abuse and harassment engine. It's not a bug. It's a feature. All that abuse and controversy is how it gets clicks and money.

http://jeff-vogel.blogspot.com/2016/04/how-i-deal-with-haras...

Re:Wall Street Is Giving Up On Twitter by gottam on Saturday February 11, 2017 @10:16AM (#13622953)
To fix this "problem" they've been spending money on human moderators to filter content, tags, and ban people. They're spending money on employees to remove discussions and eyes from the site, which counter intuitive if their goal is to become profitable, nor does it solve the problem ultimately.
Re:Wall Street Is Giving Up On Twitter by Finnucane on Friday February 10, 2017 @01:23PM (#13617607)
I don't have a Twitter account, so the only way I see it is if something gets reposted on my FB feed or some other media outlet. Which generally means someone notable and/or famous for some reason. Personally, I'm okay with this level of filtering.
Re:Wall Street Is Giving Up On Twitter by puranjay on Saturday February 11, 2017 @01:46AM (#13621462)
A man became the most powerful person on the planet using Twitter, so yeah, it is very effective!

Trump doesn't do Snapchat videos. He does 3AM tweets.

Re:Wall Street Is Giving Up On Twitter by kisstheblade on Friday February 10, 2017 @03:49PM (#13618770)
Twitter is only useful because "normal" media makes news about notable tweets. I surely don't get my information from twitter. Would seem silly to get all my information (or "important" information from "powerful" people) from a hundred character sound bites.
Re:Wall Street Is Giving Up On Twitter by jdminhbg on Friday February 10, 2017 @04:03PM (#13618867)
When people talk about getting their news from Twitter, they don't literally mean they never leave Twitter for information. 140 characters is enough for a headline and a link; you click through to articles that interest you.
Re:Wall Street Is Giving Up On Twitter by genericpseudo on Friday February 10, 2017 @02:32PM (#13618149)
News is not monetizable because real, actual news is depressing and no-one wants to run ads for chocolate next to pictures of starving kids.

It's always been the fluff which drew the ads; the lifestyle and sports content.

Re:Wall Street Is Giving Up On Twitter by acveilleux on Friday February 10, 2017 @01:50PM (#13617831)
Instagram has notionally the same dynamic as twitter but somehow they do a lot better at convincing their eye balls that they are welcome on the platform and have a voice. Or at least it seems to me.
Re:Wall Street Is Giving Up On Twitter by boobsbr on Friday February 10, 2017 @02:14PM (#13618019)
> On twitter, I speak into the void.

My sentiment as well, why I never got into Twitter at all.

Re:Wall Street Is Giving Up On Twitter by creativityland on Friday February 10, 2017 @01:26PM (#13617629)
I share the same feeling when using Twitter with a following mainly consisting of friends. If the sole purpose was to communicate with friends, why do so publicly on Twitter?

There is a sense that you can connect with influential people on Twitter, but the truth is your voice just gets lost in a sea of noise.

Re:Wall Street Is Giving Up On Twitter by dhimes on Friday February 10, 2017 @01:29PM (#13617663)
When Paul Graham wants to say something, he takes to Twitter to do it.

Wow. I didn't even know he tweeted.

Re:Wall Street Is Giving Up On Twitter by WillyOnWheels on Friday February 10, 2017 @01:50PM (#13617835)
https://twitter.com/paulg/status/663456748494127104?lang=en is probably his most controversial tweet
Re:Wall Street Is Giving Up On Twitter by Grue3 on Friday February 10, 2017 @02:27PM (#13618119)
And within a few replies somebody threatens to violently assault him. Says a lot about the platform, really.
Re:Wall Street Is Giving Up On Twitter by angry-hacker on Saturday February 11, 2017 @03:36AM (#13621748)
What else can you say with 140 chars? It's heaven for snarky comments and trolls.
Re:Wall Street Is Giving Up On Twitter by dhimes on Friday February 10, 2017 @02:17PM (#13618038)
He definitely caught some shit for that one.
Re:Wall Street Is Giving Up On Twitter by brightball on Friday February 10, 2017 @02:53PM (#13618324)
It's basically a publishing system. On Twitter I generally put only professional broadcasting related items for 90% of the content. Blog posts, that kind've thing. I rarely even read it.

There's even an app in the Mac App store that a friend of mine wrote called Wren that is just a simple little "store and tweet" system. Doesn't attempt to read anything, just lets you keep it on your desktop to tweet stuff periodically. That sums up my usage of Twitter.

It's largely replaced press releases. While people used to send out releases to outlets, now they tweet it and outlets follow you and report if they think it's news worthy.

Re:Wall Street Is Giving Up On Twitter by camus2 on Friday February 10, 2017 @02:26PM (#13618109)
People use Twitter to broadcast something without wanting to have a real discussion about the thing they just said.

There is no discussion possible on Twitter, as the "threads" quickly devolve into an unintelligible mess.

You say something to the public, then you're done. It's purely a channel for viral marketing (also called "push", that word says it all).

Re:Wall Street Is Giving Up On Twitter by wodenokoto on Sunday February 12, 2017 @07:24AM (#13628036)
In Denmark, Twitter penetration has been fairly weak, while Facebook has been extraordinary.

Last I heard numbers, it was something like 80% of the population checked Facebook at least once a week.

Here most politicians and other "influential people" will take to Facebook when they want to be heard.

Re:Wall Street Is Giving Up On Twitter by Pxtl on Friday February 10, 2017 @01:41PM (#13617763)
I've found twitter works okay for discussing small scale events. Local journos tweet the goings on of city council and citizens and councillors and journos pile into the conversation. Muni politics is my hobby, but it does shine for this so I assume it extends to similar fields of small-scale news.
Re:Wall Street Is Giving Up On Twitter by iak8god on Friday February 10, 2017 @01:31PM (#13617683)
> The same goes for many of the most influential people in the world.

The President of the United States, for instance.

Re:Wall Street Is Giving Up On Twitter by joeblau on Friday February 10, 2017 @01:44PM (#13617777)
This type of statement reminds me of being in the music business (for the short period of time I was in it). Everyone would always hype their artist as the best thing since sliced bread. "You gotta hear this guy" "She's got an amazing voice" "They are so powerful". While I heard a lot of amazing talent — the fact of the matter was that they weren't "It". No matter how much marketing and promotion went behind them, they never grew beyond a decent sized market segment.

I do agree with you saying that Twitter has powerful impact. It's the primary social media network I use to get information from the development community I follow and I don't even use Facebook anymore. That being said, I'm starting to wonder if I'm in the same boat as the people promoting artists that were just never destined to be mega-stars.

Re:Wall Street Is Giving Up On Twitter by mfukar on Friday February 10, 2017 @01:47PM (#13617805)
Can't tell if you're serious or just have an aptitude at this.
Re:Wall Street Is Giving Up On Twitter by Spooky23 on Friday February 10, 2017 @10:19PM (#13620763)
Twitter is a tragedy of the commons type scenario.

It's an amazing way to connect, but ultimately it's a loudspeaker for loudmouths. It needs to die.

Re:Wall Street Is Giving Up On Twitter by martin-adams on Saturday February 11, 2017 @06:35AM (#13622190)
Yes, I've noticed the BBC quoting tweets as part of their news reporting on a regular basis. It really is an influential tool.
Re:Wall Street Is Giving Up On Twitter by EliRivers on Friday February 10, 2017 @03:22PM (#13618553)
I don't use twitter so if I'm wrong about this, I stand by to be corrected, but with twitter, I thought you can only reach people who have already chosen to listen to you.

It's powerful in that it's fast and can reach your followers quickly, and hope that they pass it on to non-followers, but it's fundamentally restricted in that you can't twitter to people who don't already follow you; the very people you need to reach most, given that followers are self-selectingly already on-message.

Re:Wall Street Is Giving Up On Twitter by psyc on Friday February 10, 2017 @03:37PM (#13618669)
Twitter lets you mention anybody. Unless they've blocked you, they will be notified that you mentioned them. It's like /u/username on Reddit, but on Twitter it's the standard way to address people.
Re:Wall Street Is Giving Up On Twitter by coldpie on Friday February 10, 2017 @01:36PM (#13617718)
Anyone have any thoughts on turning Twitter into a publicly funded utility? It's fraught with difficulties, and maybe unconstitutional, but as you say Twitter is an extremely powerful tool and it would be a tragedy to lose it just because it can't find a way to extract money from its users.
Re:Wall Street Is Giving Up On Twitter by tigershark on Friday February 10, 2017 @04:59PM (#13619283)
Are you really asking to get money from the taxes that everyone pays for a dubious utility service as twitter? If you really enjoy it finance it with your money. I already finance organisations that are much more worth my money than a glorified newsletter. It's a sad world in which we are living. If I had a twitter account probably I should have tweeted my really deep analysis in 140 chars. Wait for it.
Re:Wall Street Is Giving Up On Twitter by coldpie on Saturday February 11, 2017 @08:17AM (#13622460)
> Are you really asking to get money from the taxes that everyone pays for a dubious utility service as twitter?

No. I was proposing a thought experiment. Chill out, dude.

Re:Wall Street Is Giving Up On Twitter by anigbrowl on Friday February 10, 2017 @01:47PM (#13617804)
Public funding would be massively problematic (especially in this political climate), but I agree about wanting to conserve the utility even if it's not a good way to make money. I'm surprised that a distributed open alternative hasn't appeared by now.
Re:Wall Street Is Giving Up On Twitter by wott on Friday February 10, 2017 @10:16PM (#13620743)
GNU social, and others.
Re:Wall Street Is Giving Up On Twitter by Mikeb85 on Saturday February 11, 2017 @04:06AM (#13621833)
And if Twitter goes away, there will be another platform to take its place.
Re:Wall Street Is Giving Up On Twitter by tarr11 on Friday February 10, 2017 @01:52PM (#13617848)
It is interesting that PG doesnt participate here anymore, at all. Wonder why?
Re:Wall Street Is Giving Up On Twitter by positr0n on Friday February 10, 2017 @04:13PM (#13618952)
He used to. His comments and posts and slowed down over the years though.

https://news.ycombinator.com/user?id=pg

Re:Wall Street Is Giving Up On Twitter by dglass on Friday February 10, 2017 @01:21PM (#13617578)
powerful != profitable