I went to a bar, where a band was playing on stage... After a while I realized I know the drummer. I played with him before, in another band, years ago. We had a beer, chatted a bit and went home.
Now, we hadn't posted any pictures, nor statuses, we have no mutual friends on facebook, no connection at all... Heck, Facebook DIDN'T EVEN EXIST when I last saw him.
The second I got home the app suggested him as a friend
Gosh this was scary.
(OP here)
That's a whole other can of worms, of course.
All the other people that it suggests that I friend where I have no idea who they are, I wonder where the association came from...
I have her email address in my contacts which has been shared with WhatsApp.
Curiously, there should be no way to directly link my FB account with WhatsApp. I haven't shared my mobile number with FB, and I haven't shared my FB account email address with WhatsApp. Somehow they have tied the two together.
I've never installed any other FB app on my phone, and my FB account is only a month old.
I found that particularly chilling. The friend suggestion doesn't have my email address nor mobile number, and we live in different countries. I'd love to figure out how they did it. I even use a pseudonym on FB.
It's the same with facial recognition - to avoid it, it's not enough to never post your pictures, you'd also need to ensure that noone who knows you would ever tag you in some picture they have.
1. Location matching - both your apps detected you in the same place for an extended period of time. Maybe you guys had mutual friends in the music community?
2. Microphone[0]. They have since refuted that claim[1], but I've had way too many coincidences and I'm choosing to keep my tin-foil hat on... :/
[0] www.geek.com/apps/facebook-app-now-listens-and-records-audio-when-you-post-updates-from-your-phone-1595873/
[1]http://newsroom.fb.com/news/h/facebook-does-not-use-your-pho...
I presume you didn't post anything about the "event" to facebook (I've seen "Person is going to attend Blah" posts before) or "check in".
Advertising is such a racket.
Facebook: In the week we exposed the user to the add, the user posted a picture of your product. We made that sell for you!
Advertiser: Say no more, take my money!
Facebook: (smiles smugly)
It's like a conversation I saw last week, that video ads pay out to the provider/site even if the user only sees one second of it before pressing pause or the back-button.
The most uncomfortable angle is just how quickly Facebook tuned into what we were doing and then changed its ad-delivery algorithm to match. I have one friend who had his picture taken in front of a headshop - he now gets regular ads for bongs and smoke accessories, even though he's not a user. So, that's also quite discomfiting ..
This assumes that your and Facebook's intent and interests are aligned. Clearly they are not. Why you posted your picture onto someone else's database is relevant primarily to you, and perhaps also to some subset of your friends.
You're not obligated to turn that process into a money-making proposition.
As Eben Moglen warned us a long time ago [1] the arrangement between you and Facebook (et al) is neither complex nor confusing:
You get some PHP doodads and you get spying for free all the time.
[1] https://www.google.com.au/search?q=eben+moglen+doodads+and+s...
For example, I have a friend who has never been on any social media. If he wanted to opt out of the surveillance apparatus, he still would have to address: collection of phone metadata, browsing history, traffic cams, other CCTV, financial paper trail, probably more I'm missing.
I argued that the one thing we had some limited hope of shaping was cultural attitudes and public policy towards this information and how it is applied.
I must say that the current climate of everybody tearing each other apart on social media is so far not encouraging.
The rest of it was about the more concrete benefits, like improved traffic, logistics, labor and resource allocation.
When you're the advertiser, sure. When you're the target, not so much. Do you really want billboards speaking to you as you walk down the street? Making suggestions based on your recent purchase history or activities and personal associations?
Just because advertising technology can achieve greater powers of reaching people, doesn't mean we need or want advertising woven into the fabric of our existence more than it already is. You can opt in to that if you want, I'm staying well clear.
It's something to rationaly know it, it's totally different to experience it in real life !
I would like to come up with some powerful (frightening) examples of why the data collection going on is so dangerous, and why people should be worried and careful.
Depends on whether you're a fan other other people making your choices for you, I guess.
Within seconds of posting this picture of the machines, my friend was getting targeted ads from the manufacturers of those devices - within seconds!
This was a watershed moment for us. We won't be posting much to Facebook in the future .. far too scary for us!