News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:LG admits premium display fails near wi-fi by coldpie on Friday February 03, 2017 @12:44PM (#13561588)
How fucking hard is it to make a competent display? I feel like the A/V market is ripe for disruption. Sell a quality line of displays with no "smart" crap and a relatively low-cost receiver with no "smart" crap, a usable front-end with tons of A/V features and a dozen inputs of different types.

This must be harder than I think it is, because no one is doing it.

Re:LG admits premium display fails near wi-fi by delecti on Friday February 03, 2017 @12:53PM (#13561669)
My understanding is that you're overestimating the cost to manufacture the "smart" crap. The basic hardware is so inexpensive that they don't really lose much to just cram some extra crappy software (crappy software that is extra, or software which is extra crappy, your pick) onto the hardware that already has to go into the TV.
Re:LG admits premium display fails near wi-fi by coldpie on Friday February 03, 2017 @01:16PM (#13561876)
Leaving the "smart" crap out isn't for cost savings, it's to create a higher quality product. I will even pay more for a TV with fewer features to get in the way.
Re:LG admits premium display fails near wi-fi by cr0sh on Friday February 03, 2017 @01:56PM (#13562214)
> I will even pay more for a TV with fewer features to get in the way.

Look up "Retail Digital Signage" and "Retail Video Displays" (and similar terms) - for instance:

http://www.planar.com/products/large-format-displays/ultrare...

These are all essentially large LCD displays (monitors) with little to no extra features (many will have the ability to load via wifi or usb graphics and animations to be rotated on the screen - it's advertising after all).

Your only other option would be large computer monitors, but because these tend to be meant for the desktop, you won't easily find sizes beyond 40 inches diagonal.

Note that for digital signage - you are going to pay more - a lot more (it's one of those cases of pay more, get less - because niche and "you're a business, you have money"); also note that some of these kinds of displays can be found at Business Costco stores (though maybe not the 4K+ units).

Another interesting thing about these units is that they have very small width bezels at the edges, for those cases where you want to tile them to make a video wall (again, retail advertising and menus and such).

Re:LG admits premium display fails near wi-fi by untog on Friday February 03, 2017 @01:42PM (#13562078)
You're in a minority, though - that's the problem. Stuff like TVs have huge benefits to manufacturing at scale.

Counter-intuitive though it might seem, it'll be cheaper per-unit to produce a TV with smart TV crap with a market of one million than it will be to make a basic TV with a market of ten thousand.

Re:LG admits premium display fails near wi-fi by blacksmith_tb on Friday February 03, 2017 @01:46PM (#13562117)
But the manufacturer might stand to poach 10K incremental sales if they just added a small "disable (outdated) smart functions" switch to the back of the unit...
Re:LG admits premium display fails near wi-fi by ethbro on Friday February 03, 2017 @03:17PM (#13562926)
> it'll be cheaper per-unit to produce a TV with smart TV crap with a market of one million than it will be to make a basic TV with a market of ten thousand

I would go even farther and say that (in longer term accounting) it will be much cheaper to produce a smart TV with 10,000 sales than a basic TV with 10,000 sales.

Or haven't we learned that the first thing a processor + network connectivity is used for is extracting marketable analytics?

Re:LG admits premium display fails near wi-fi by swingbridge on Friday February 03, 2017 @01:34PM (#13562020)
This. I am endlessly frustrated with display manufacturers think that I want to do all sorts of "smart" stuff with my display. No. I want it to display a nice image for the stuff I want to plug into it, that's it!

Setup a new TV for a family member recently and the instructions basically wanted me to Bluetooth pair my phone to the TV so I could set it up. I was like you have to be $&@!ing kidding me. Power, volume, input select. Just give me 4 buttons and that's it and I'm happy.

Re:LG admits premium display fails near wi-fi by rb808 on Friday February 03, 2017 @12:55PM (#13561680)
I dont understand how you can get a 40 inch 4k TV for $350 but a 32 inch 4k display is $900.

Seems the 32 inch space prices are way too high.

Re:LG admits premium display fails near wi-fi by mikestew on Friday February 03, 2017 @01:16PM (#13561874)
You're looking at it from the point of view of "but the one over there is bigger". The manufacturer's point of view is "we sell a lot more 40" TVs than we do 32" monitors, so we're going to manufacture the shit out of 40" panels", something something economies of scale.

Same reason we suffered with 27" monitors at 1080 for so long: because LG and the like were selling literal boatloads of 1080 panels to put in TVs. If you wanted something out of band like a 1440 panel, well, get your checkbook out.

Oh, and does that 4K TV do 60fps at 4K? (Honest question, I have no idea if they do or not. Though I would assume so.)

Re:LG admits premium display fails near wi-fi by jdmichal on Friday February 03, 2017 @01:55PM (#13562194)
If you ever want a good place to answer your last question, I found rtings to be indespensible when I was shopping for a new TV last year. The "supported resolutions" section answers your question, and there's lots of other good information:

http://www.rtings.com/tv/reviews/sony/x850c#comparison_200

Re:LG admits premium display fails near wi-fi by ethbro on Friday February 03, 2017 @03:18PM (#13562940)
On the other monitor / panel side, if anyone isn't aware of it, TFT Central is amazing. http://www.tftcentral.co.uk/
Re:LG admits premium display fails near wi-fi by satysin on Friday February 03, 2017 @01:29PM (#13561970)
My Samsung TV does 2160p60+HDR and looks fucking incredible. I would use it as my main monitor if it were a little smaller.
Re:LG admits premium display fails near wi-fi by chris11 on Friday February 03, 2017 @01:16PM (#13561877)
Don't pc monitors usually have higher standards? And some 4k tvs can be bad. For instance, a few tv manufacturers are making rgbw 4k tvs, which are tvs where 25% of the pixels are white and don't produce color. And also I think that a 4k monitor is more of a premium item. I think the assumption is that if you are buying a 4k monitor you can usually afford to spend money than someone buying a 4k tv.
Re:LG admits premium display fails near wi-fi by ghostly_s on Friday February 03, 2017 @01:52PM (#13562170)
An RGBW panel has R,G,B and W subpixels. The white is there to increase overall brightness. You can't count your subpixels and call it 4k (although oddly you can count three-thousand...something and call that 4k.). Or are you criticizing the decreased color fidelity that accompanies those higher brightness levels?
Re:LG admits premium display fails near wi-fi by chris11 on Friday February 03, 2017 @02:40PM (#13562580)
Alright, I wasn't quite accurate on the specifics. But I'm criticizing the decreased color fidelity. I don't know how much a RGBW subpixel panel increases brightness, but I really don't think it's worth 25% of the panel losing the ability to display color.
Re:LG admits premium display fails near wi-fi by ghostly_s on Monday February 06, 2017 @06:26PM (#13585340)
I still think you're making a false equivalency between pixels and sub-pixels. If you look at a microscopic view of an LCD, it is not a seamless field of sub-pixels--substantial surface area is non-emitting black borders between them, but the eye merges the sub-pixels (and pixels, if sufficiently high density) into a unified light source. Adding white emitters does not inherently mean you are getting "less color" -- many factors influence the blending that you perceive. It does, presumably, mean that colors at the highest brightness levels are less saturated, but that may mean you are getting additional, less-accurate color space, without sacrificing the accuracy of the color space you already had. I have no idea if RGBW displays on the market actually have these characteristics, but your dismissal is based on a misunderstanding of the optical properties at play.
Re:LG admits premium display fails near wi-fi by rwmj on Friday February 03, 2017 @01:13PM (#13561849)
I'm using a 55" 4K TV as a monitor and it works fine at full resolution, so my advice is just buy a TV for this.
Re:LG admits premium display fails near wi-fi by vldx on Friday February 03, 2017 @02:18PM (#13562406)
Honest question, how do you work on 55" display?
Re:LG admits premium display fails near wi-fi by rwmj on Friday February 03, 2017 @03:49PM (#13563180)
By mainly having the work windows in the center, and email/chat in peripheral vision. See my setup here: https://rwmj.wordpress.com/2016/02/12/new-standing-desk-set-...
Re:LG admits premium display fails near wi-fi by bardworx on Friday February 03, 2017 @01:12PM (#13561843)
Manny different reasons, including: - monitors have better refresh rate and color accuracy - tvs don't have sleep functions and won't wake up with your computer. - tvs that cost $350 don't have have refresh rate, contract etc.

Monitors are more expensive because the have to be more detailed in color reproduction, accuracy, etc.

Re:LG admits premium display fails near wi-fi by ogsharkman on Friday February 03, 2017 @01:05PM (#13561776)
This has confused me too, maybe it has to do with the size of the relative markets?
Re:LG admits premium display fails near wi-fi by abhorrence on Friday February 03, 2017 @01:14PM (#13561850)
The pixel density on the 32 inch is mich higher, perhaps this leads to larger manufacturing cost? That seems unlikely to explain the entire gap however.
Re:LG admits premium display fails near wi-fi by glasz on Friday February 03, 2017 @01:20PM (#13561904)
ever tried a 40" 4k tv? anything below 1500 bucks is utter shit. you've gotta be lucky to get decent panel even for above 1500€.

the tv market is one giant shit show designed to sell you all the crap falling from production lines.

i spent weeks looking at and testing tv sets. reading reviews. watching videos. in the end i returned everything and gave up.

Re:LG admits premium display fails near wi-fi by matwood on Friday February 03, 2017 @01:35PM (#13562031)
Not only that, but then you have the panel lottery. Same TV model ends up using different panels. One version is amazing and the other version is crap, and it is is hard to know which until you get the TV out of the box.
Re:LG admits premium display fails near wi-fi by maxxxxx on Friday February 03, 2017 @12:50PM (#13561647)
I think "smart" stuff can be produced cheaply but sold expensively. It may be hard to make money on a basic display.
Re:LG admits premium display fails near wi-fi by digikata on Friday February 03, 2017 @01:07PM (#13561794)
I don't know about most consumers, but the "smart" stuff is a big product negative feature when I'm shopping. I'd much rather add an external device of my choosing, Roku or Apple TV or something else than use the TV internal "smart" apps/channels which may or may not get updated.

Now if some TV added a nice little shelf space, or mount point for an external box behind the TV - I would think that would be a selling feature.

You can just not activate/use the feature, but I find I keep tripping over the button on the remote.

Re:LG admits premium display fails near wi-fi by maxxxxx on Friday February 03, 2017 @01:23PM (#13561927)
Somehow this stuff seems to sell. Same for Android phones. I hate that every manufacturers feels they need to add some crappy custom UI on top of stock Android but they keep doing it.
Re:LG admits premium display fails near wi-fi by thwarted on Friday February 03, 2017 @01:42PM (#13562075)
For the same reason ISPs and telcos have traditionally included "value-adds" on their Internet connectivity, like email accounts, portals, news, business websites, etc, etc, etc, because they don't want to become commodity "dumb pipes".

The phone manufacturers need to create and push non-standard (and often broken) app launchers and branded skins in order to differentiate, otherwise they'd just be another Android phone maker, rather than, say, the manufacturer of the Samsung phone.

Re:LG admits premium display fails near wi-fi by coldpie on Friday February 03, 2017 @03:15PM (#13562905)
I feel like there's an easy Kickstarter grab here for some startup founded by someone with experience in display manufacturing......
Re:LG admits premium display fails near wi-fi by delecti on Friday February 03, 2017 @06:36PM (#13564349)
I would love a normally priced TV with no smart crap, but would absolutely not back a Kickstarter for one. It's really just not the right platform for that.
Re:LG admits premium display fails near wi-fi by scarface74 on Friday February 03, 2017 @02:12PM (#13562347)
I agree. With the exception of TVs with Roku built in. One remote that was intended to control the TV and the Roku functionality.
Re:LG admits premium display fails near wi-fi by gshulegaard on Friday February 03, 2017 @12:56PM (#13561688)
This is my suspicion as well. It's also why the "top of the line" TVs from a display specification perspective also have "SMART" baked in as well.

That said, is this LG issue because it has smart stuff or because it lacks appropriate shielding? The article kind of hints that it's a lack shielding.

Re:LG admits premium display fails near wi-fi by dan1234 on Friday February 03, 2017 @01:44PM (#13562098)
I think thin margins for a product not replaced too often, and a heavily patented technology makes it pretty unattractive market to new entrants.
Re:LG admits premium display fails near wi-fi by DavidPP on Friday February 03, 2017 @02:02PM (#13562262)
The Vizio P65-C1 might be what you are looking for. The "smart crap" is actually in the remote which is a 7" Android tablet.
Re:LG admits premium display fails near wi-fi by bitwize on Friday February 03, 2017 @01:28PM (#13561967)
Indeed.

If I wanted a smart TV I'd attach a brain to the VESA bracket on the back.

Re:LG admits premium display fails near wi-fi by chrisper on Friday February 03, 2017 @01:42PM (#13562079)
LG is just a bad company. Most of their products are faulty in some way. I had issues with their monitors and phones. I stopped buying anything LG since then.
Re:LG admits premium display fails near wi-fi by jobu on Friday February 03, 2017 @01:56PM (#13562211)
Their current OLED TVs are absolutely stunning, and I really like what they've done with WebOS. Unfortunately the price is not something I can justify right now.
Re:LG admits premium display fails near wi-fi by chrisper on Friday February 03, 2017 @02:20PM (#13562418)
Yeah, their TVs look nice. But I wonder what hidden issues it might have? I am just skeptical of everything LG now. Of course this is just anecdotal, so I am sure there are people who say everything LG is awesome.

On the upside, LG refunded me the whole purchase price of the Nexus 5x that broke. So props to that.