The disagreements with the travel ban are not partisan or political — this ban will have very serious consequences for millions of people, and maybe more in the future, given what the president has said during the campaign. So far, he has delivered on his campaign promises, and has demonstrated that he cannot be reasoned with.
Some of us gave us him a chance, but now it's clear he's not going to change. If we don't take action now and prevent him from being normalized soon, it will be too late.
Nobody likes comparisons with Hitler, but I think in 30 years we may very well view Trump in a similar light — if I were there, I would've said something, why didn't anybody stop him?
http://www.economist.com/news/united-states/21715732-scoldin...
Another thing is talking with Trump and Bannon and the like. It may not be possible.
Opposition and talking are mutually exclusive at times and then you have to choose. Trump is marching forward while people try to talk to him, using their credibility to bolster his attack. If he's ready to talk, he can always call a cease-fire and do so. These responses are very reminiscent to me of Chamberlain before WWII, who said the same about another madman, and ceded much ground and many lives of others, and then it was too late.
Talking with other Americans is an entirely different matter.
When was the last time there was a brute force against an US administration that worked?
I'm French, so historically brute force for me means using force. Brutally. Right now I only see people marching and yelling. When's the last time that worked in the us?
I'm a little lost to understand what would work in the US to be honest. Culturally, here, what is the best way to overthrow?
Based on his actions since Jan 20, he should be isolated, shunned, denounced and blocked by all available means until he either resigns or is impeached. It doesn't seem like "reason" is something that he will ever listen to, by this point.
That said, in principle it can be useful to have people capable of exerting the kinds of influence he seems to understand better (force, and threats of force). But not a hidebound accommodationist of dubious ethical principles like Kalanack.
(EDIT: apologies, didn't see the upvotes before revising the above substantially).
If the man is willing to talk to you about the things you care about, then why on earth wouldn't you?
What, in the last 18 months, gives you the impression he listens to anyone outside of his coterie of right-wing schmoozers anyway?
Nobody is expecting a radical shift in his policies, but even minor shifts on key issues are arguably worth the small time investment.
The man is self-interested, and self-interested people can generally be bargained with if you can find the places where their interests align with yours. In this case money and public opinion are good targets.
It all comes down to why he wants to talk to me. Is it because he's interested in listening to what to have to say and take my advice under consideration or does he just want to use my 'fame' and my name to add legitimacy to the the actions he would have taken anyway.
I think that the idea that Trump is completely uninfluencable is a bit hyperbolic. He's not an irrationality machine. He cares about things, just maybe not the things you or I care about, and so those things become avenues for influence and negotiation.
Well, I disagree with you there. Based on his actions, especially since assuming office, "irrationality machine" seems to be the perfect description of him.
That's an odd characterization. Regarding views, I'm sure each of them disagrees with him on something (because they're all different human beings) but several of them endorsed him. Regarding "tech", that's not how I would label Pepsi, JP Morgan, the Cleveland Clinic, Walmart, BlackRock... Tech is less represented on the forum than financial services.
That's more of a sign of him doing the best he can to scrape from the bottom of the barrel than of any real respect for diversity of viewpoints, let alone "reason."
I'd change "Jan 20" for "the 1980s" because he's always been a monstrous excuse of a human being willing to say anything and do anything to advance his personal interests.
If all he has a true believers then it makes it much more opaque for those of us on the outside.
Yes, but this is not just in the US, unfortunately. I have relatives in many places of the world, and things are escalating everywhere.
I blame social media for that.
People can't look at each other in the eye anymore, so they forget what it is like to feel empathy. They congregate around small online bubbles, and a lot of people is almost PTSD-anxious about talking to people of other bubbles. So they resort to humiliation and other tactics. When they try to talk the same way IRL, they get shunned, which makes them feel victimized and justified in their hate. Now we're seeing real politicians espousing the crazy ideas we'd only see in comment sections ten years ago.
It's a downward spiral, unfortunately.
I hear a line of reasoning like this quite often and I have yet to understand it.
I simply don't accept that empathy is a necessary precondition to productive conversation.
I can have a productive disagreement with someone that I don't empathize with. I can have a productive disagreement with someone I loathe and can barely force myself to maintain eye contact. It's called being an adult.
It is, however, pretty difficult to talk with people who are ever more convinced that the truth comes directly from Dear Leader via Twitter. Look at the whole inauguration photo thing - he's telling people to ignore what they see and believe him. That is very worrying. It's easy to have different ideas about the facts and what to do about them, but if you can't even agree on the facts, there's really not much to talk about.
The other issues are things people can certainly disagree on without calling one another 'goons'.
https://wikileaks.org/clinton-emails/emailid/23225
The "it's a big mess" excuse is just a fig leaf to cover the functional US policy in Syria, which has been to support Jihadists against Assad.
https://youtu.be/e4phB-_pXDM?t=1548
I have no patience for people who cry crocodile tears for a supposed loss of civility and use it as cover to push utterly cynical policies that will have massive real world impact. It's disgusting, actually, and not so different from the crybully Left.
“We’re on the verge of having someone take over the conservative movement who is a con artist,” Rubio said, accusing Trump of spending his career “sticking it to working Americans.”
"This man is a pathological liar.", Ted Cruz "Utterly amoral."
"You know how you make America great again? Tell Donald Trump to go to hell." Lindsey Graham.
I highly doubt he actually cares.
I also doubt it will mitigate the effect of the Uber hashtag. I don't think there's much general goodwill among most people because most people have had crappy jobs and see the sharing economy for what it is...surge pricing and no health care and no paid vacation and a job that might go away because some drunk complained of insufficient kowtow.
Uber didn't get out front of the hashtag and is playing PR catchup against a well constructed propaganda campaign and some group of investors is making money and money is always associated with White House politics and smart money plays both parties (and only having two parties keeps costs down).
Finally, in my opinion it is usually a political mistake to dismiss one's opponents actions as naive or lacking reason or absent of critical thought. Expressing political will is a naked form of reasoned thought and the hashtag is such an expression for many people.
I see the point, but this business council isn't going to meaningfully influence policy. The policymaking apparatus is huge and this is a tiny, tiny piece of it. However, it does send a signal to Republicans in Congress that the tech $ they want will not play along with Trump. That's a quite important signal.
What confuses me most is the notion that suddenly Kalanick has all this tremendous personal influence and respectability, from people who are plenty happy to jump on him in other contexts. Is there a single person who was saying, "Well, I wasn't sure about Trump, but that Uber guy supports him..."? It seems like many of the other names on the committee have much more favorable mind-share, and so in that dimension must be doing more harm, and yet are getting less criticism.
Bob Iger is the chairman of the Walt Disney Company. He hasn't resigned from the panel but after consumer pressure he's refusing to attend:
http://www.hollywoodreporter.com/news/bob-iger-wont-attend-t...
Returning to your main point, consumer pressure is being brought to bear. Even Musk has acknowledged this while saying he wants (for now) to engage.
BTW, Neiman Marcus and Nordstrom dumped Ivanka.
I'm not saying your statement of having smart people in Trump's ear being a good thing is wrong I just thought that the outrage mostly stemmed from the strike and not with his being on the team.
Granted maybe that doesn't matter; this is likely the only way to possibly reverse the #DeleteUber campaign. Though I'd be really curious as to how effective it has been (if at all though I'm assuming it has).
Furthermore, when the people protest his decisions or angrily criticize him, it actually fuels his ego and makes him more convinced that his decisions are correct.
We've seen this again and again and again.
Should my goal be to remain untainted by association or contact with Trump?
Or should it be to coax the confused monster away from his destructive path?
Generally, yes. However, I believe there is a line that can be crossed where this is no longer a good idea. The association will always lend some credibility to the administration, and when the administration commits an action like the immigration ban, you should stop assisting them in any way, period.
It wasn't necessarily Kalanick's choice. I think he there's a good chance he was made to leave.
It's Kalanick.
No, were I in that camp I would not.
First, because I don't see any evidence that I particularly want voices like Kalanick's in anybody's ear, particularly a mad man, and second because retaining the ear of a madman in a position of strength typically requires maintaining a degree of visible support for the madness to demonstrate loyalty, the harm from which often more than compensates for any benefit from whispering in his ear.
Reason and discussion is how you influence the rational, not the "mad man".
His point was we need to have conversations and real moderate intelligent people surrounding someone like Trump. You push those people away by calling them nazis and the only thing you're doing is leaving a gap for people who don't care if you call them nazis....you know...like actual nazis.
1. I will be called a member of a neo-fascist party
2. People will say that I am a racist, sexist, bigot.
3. I will be fired from my job because I no longer fit the "company culture".
4. People will see me at a public workspace, and move away from me, and refuse to partner with me. Eventually I will be asked to leave because I am making people uncomfortable with my mere presence.
5. My acquaintances will shun me, and speak about me in whispers of "I didn't know he/she was like that..."
This is why I do not speak. I simply cast my vote, and move on.
Why do you think you shouldn't be held accountable for your actions? If you're of voting age, you're not a child anymore. As an adult, you act, and are responsible and accountable for those actions.
Furthermore, if what you want the country to be like is something that others find distasteful, why do you believe that others shouldn't act on that? It's not like like we're talking about the difference between chocolate or vanilla ice cream. You were asked if you wanted a stable government or... whatever it is we have right now. Why don't you believe that would reflect upon who you are, and how others view you?
If you voted for Trump, yes, they will because you voted for someone who is all of those things - you were perfectly ok with his behaviour on those axes.
A third party vote isn't quite the same thing as not casting a vote.
Otherwise, I don't think we disagree?
The POTUS is decided by the electoral vote. If the process was by the popular vote, the candidates would have campaigned very differently and the voter turnout could be much higher.
If the popular vote decided the POTUS, then Trump voters in traditionally Democratic states (think Pacific NorthWest) might have turned out in droves and vice-versa for Hilary.
A hypothetical president who won only 30% of the popular vote, while winning the electoral college, will be enacting policies that 70% of the electorate explicitly voted against.
Even with these numbers, a more moderate (and reasonable) president might still be able to mend the fences put up during the campaign trail. But with such a polarising president, the dissatisfaction amongst the populace will be even more pronounced. This is exactly what we're seeing now.
Yet the administration itself keeps bringing it up. Making up stories to explain it away. As if it mattered quite a lot.
(EDIT: I said "and we aren't even certain about that number because states generally don't keep counting after the state outcome is certain" but I was mistaken).
Can you provide evidence that states stop counting votes after it looks there will be a winner in a specific race? Last time i checked, states take several weeks to provide official results because counting all the votes takes a while.
We have a first-past-the-post system in which only the top two candidates are viable, so 5.7% of the voters didn't prioritize keeping Trump out of office. If we set the bar at "I think this is the best qualified person on Earth for this office" every elected official has only had a small minority. If we set the bar at "of these two, this one is better" Hillary only won by 2% along with a lot of "don't care".
Seeing the US referred to in this way really makes you get a sense for how effective nationalistic propaganda is.
* leader of the free world
* greatest nation on earth
* freest nation in the world
None of which is quantifiable or accurate.I think he would have done a good job at picking up votes from the "disaffected" crowd that voted Trump over Clinton as a protest, but there's certainly the possibility that he would be lose votes for being too far left.
At this point, I certainly still wish Bernie won, seeing as Trump is president regardless, but I don't think there's necessarily a solid counterfactual that he would've beaten Trump. Either way, I think some of the blame can certainly be placed on Democrats pushing more of the same when people were clearly calling for a change.
[1] https://fivethirtyeight.com/features/trump-is-just-a-normal-...
The underlying problem in the US is we've stopped talking to each other. We only hurl partsisan-charged invectives at each other. Kalanack's choice here is a visible example demonstrating that "not talking" is the solution. I am saddened by his choice and I am ashamed of my fellow Americans, from all walks of the political spectrum for their choices to sling mud instead of speaking to each other and finding ways to cooperate with each other.
I also highly doubt this move will have the intended effect of mitigating the #deleteuber campaign. Even considering the facts about some of Lyft's key investors being Trump supporters. Mostly because people as a whole can't hear reason any more. Sure, #deleteuber is hurting Raisier LLC, but you know who it's really hurting? The immigrant Uber drivers who are renting/leasing their vehicle through one of Uber's partners, and are contractually obliged to drive only for Uber. There's no reasoning there. No critical thought. Just "fuck you #deleteuber".