News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Dropbox’s Smart Sync lets users open a file stored only i... by kilroy123 on Monday January 30, 2017 @02:43PM (#13524336)
So will this ever be available for paying customers that aren't on a business plan? If not, that is incredibly frustrating.

I pay for their service every month. I am not a business, so why should I pay more to have a feature that should be standard? Plus loads of features I don't want or need?

Re:Dropbox’s Smart Sync lets users open a file stored only i... by antoncohen on Monday January 30, 2017 @11:23PM (#13527589)
The FAQ[1] says:

> Smart Sync is available in early access for Dropbox Business users. It is not yet available for individual accounts.

Maybe they are rolling it out to Business customers first because they think they can provide better support to them?

I've had Smart Sync (Infinite) on my personal Dropbox account for a long time. It is awesome. When I recently added Dropbox to a new computer it started with all the files "in the cloud". It was so nice to have all my files available in the Finder and from command line, but not have to sync my whole Dropbox.

[1] https://www.dropbox.com/help/9293

Re:Dropbox’s Smart Sync lets users open a file stored only i... by jpalomaki on Tuesday January 31, 2017 @04:02AM (#13528916)
Could be also just a way to push people towards business edition. This is a pain point when you have lots of data in the Dropbox folder. Managing things with the current "selective sync" is painful and if you have lots of data, the full sync may take ages.

This is handy for example for the use case that you travel with clean laptop and sync needed stuff at the destination.

Re:Dropbox’s Smart Sync lets users open a file stored only i... by cridenour on Monday January 30, 2017 @03:03PM (#13524495)
Agreed. If anything, it should Pro first since individuals are more likely to accept the unpolished nature of new features.
Re:Dropbox’s Smart Sync lets users open a file stored only i... by gutnor on Monday January 30, 2017 @07:05PM (#13526236)
Another point - even if you want to consider yourself a business ( 10$ instead of $8.25 at this stage why not ), the business plan starts at minimum 5 users ( you can use less user, but you are still charged for 5 ) FYI if you are ever tempted to try this free 30 days upgrade of your pro account that is always 1 click away.
Re:Dropbox’s Smart Sync lets users open a file stored only i... by philfrasty on Monday January 30, 2017 @05:04PM (#13525475)
The same goes for their OCR full-text search which (I think) is only available to business customers (and not „regular“ paying customers).

EDIT: source (at the very bottom) https://www.dropbox.com/help/9244

Re:Dropbox’s Smart Sync lets users open a file stored only i... by gordon_freeman on Monday January 30, 2017 @02:45PM (#13524359)
i am a regular customer who just uses Dropbox free without paying to any individual or business plan and I could access Paper. So yes you should be able to access.
Re:Dropbox’s Smart Sync lets users open a file stored only i... by coldtea on Monday January 30, 2017 @04:09PM (#13525038)
This is not about Paper.
Re:Dropbox’s Smart Sync lets users open a file stored only i... by gordon_freeman on Monday January 30, 2017 @05:19PM (#13525595)
oops. looks like added to the wrong article.
Re:Dropbox’s Smart Sync lets users open a file stored only i... by brianbreslin on Monday January 30, 2017 @06:07PM (#13525945)
They have had Selective Sync on desktop for a while for Pro non business users. I've been using it for at least 6 months. Let's you pick folders to not load locally. BUT it isn't the same as this new feature, just close.
Re:Dropbox’s Smart Sync lets users open a file stored only i... by chias on Monday January 30, 2017 @05:28PM (#13525675)
Local filesystem interface to files which exist "only" on the cloud is basically the way Keybase FS operates. If this is a "killer feature" for you, consider giving it a try. The downsides at the moment are (a) alpha software, and (b) 10 gig limit. It is free though, very convenient, and does a lot of things "right" (by my way of thinking).

https://keybase.io/docs/kbfs

Re:Dropbox’s Smart Sync lets users open a file stored only i... by StavrosK on Monday January 30, 2017 @09:25PM (#13526997)
The major thing it does wrong is that it mounts the directory in the fs root, rather than my homedir. That means it was effectively invisible (if it's not in my homedir, I never see it), so I never used it. Dropbox, on the other hand, is always right in my face at ~/Dropbox.

It's too bad, because kbfs really gets many things right.

Re:Dropbox’s Smart Sync lets users open a file stored only i... by khc on Monday January 30, 2017 @10:15PM (#13527230)
it's just fuse, right? looks like you can control the mountpoint: https://github.com/keybase/kbfs/blob/master/kbfsfuse/main.go
Re:Dropbox’s Smart Sync lets users open a file stored only i... by morgante on Monday January 30, 2017 @10:49PM (#13527407)
You can fix that with a trivial symlink.
Re:Dropbox’s Smart Sync lets users open a file stored only i... by chias on Monday January 30, 2017 @10:15PM (#13527234)
can you not just mount --bind as needed?

    mkdir ~/keybase && sudo mount --bind /keybase ~/keybase
puts it in my homedirectory.
Re:Dropbox’s Smart Sync lets users open a file stored only i... by petters on Monday January 30, 2017 @02:18PM (#13524144)
> Smart Sync will be available for all Dropbox Business and enterprise customers today for early access.

I really hope us regular users will get it soon as well. This is great and how file syncing should work.

Re:Dropbox’s Smart Sync lets users open a file stored only i... by robocaptain on Tuesday January 31, 2017 @09:39AM (#13530862)
I've been a dropbox pro user for many years, but have lately gotten the impression that they (dropbox) are focused on Dropbox Business and not so much regular consumers. Curious if other people have had similar experiences?
Re:Dropbox’s Smart Sync lets users open a file stored only i... by petters on Tuesday January 31, 2017 @03:25PM (#13534860)
My impression as well. I am a long-time pro user. I don't mind that much, except that I really want this feature.
Re:Dropbox’s Smart Sync lets users open a file stored only i... by AlecSchueler on Monday January 30, 2017 @03:53PM (#13524894)
It's interesting how much this sounds like NFS. NFS works great, and serves a fairly obvious use case, but obviously requires some working knowledge of Unix and ssh technologies etc. Smart Sync gives a one-click install and forget solution. It makes me wonder why it took so long for this to be made, and what other things we Unix-heads take for granted that could easily be ported and marketed to a wider audience.
Re:Dropbox’s Smart Sync lets users open a file stored only i... by derefr on Monday January 30, 2017 @04:05PM (#13525007)
This particular class of "solution" has existed at the enterprise level forever: it's called Hierarchical Storage Management.

Windows even has a built-in overlay icon for an "offline file"--i.e., a file that exists within an HSM storage hierarchy, where the only copy of the data is currently in a lower part of the hierarchy (e.g. on a tape), and accessing it will trigger a delayed retrieval.

Of course, your own computer probably doesn't have any "HSM storage hierarchies", so even on an enterprise workstation, your local files will likely never show that overlay. Instead, it's more a thing you'll see if you have a home dir stored on a SAN, consumed by your workstation over SMB. In that sense, it's sort of a feature in the same group as "quota management."

Then again, it's not like you'd never run into it outside of an enterprise context; if you downloaded an AWS S3 filesystem driver for Windows, for example, the proper indicator for "this file exists only in Glacier" would be that same overlay, because S3's use of Glacier is also Hierarchical Storage Management.

Re:Dropbox’s Smart Sync lets users open a file stored only i... by geofft on Monday January 30, 2017 @04:19PM (#13525129)
So, like NFS - what happens if your internet connection is interrupted while you're reading the file? What happens if another computer saves to the same file while you're reading it?

Dropbox has smart people and I'm sure they would have wanted a feature like this from day 1, so if they're introducing it, I'm sure they have good answers. I'm just curious what they are!

Re:Dropbox’s Smart Sync lets users open a file stored only i... by pjc50 on Monday January 30, 2017 @04:48PM (#13525355)
NFS will, depending on mount options, block forever or start returning errors if the connection is lost. It's not really suitable for non-LAN use for a number of reasons.

It also will let you overwrite or interleave files unless both sides use advisory locking.

Re:Dropbox’s Smart Sync lets users open a file stored only i... by geofft on Monday January 30, 2017 @04:51PM (#13525374)
Yup. We use NFS at scale at $dayjob (including across continents, which is sometimes exciting) and I'm pretty sure everyone wishes we had something with the simplicity of Dropbox.

I'm curious how Dropbox has made this safe to use for people who don't want to think about things like "close-to-open consistency" or "stale file handle".

Re:Dropbox’s Smart Sync lets users open a file stored only i... by varenc on Monday January 30, 2017 @08:21PM (#13526669)
one cool thing I've seen "Smart Sync" do...on OS X it seems to fill out the thumbnail cache for images that are "online only". This means you can see the preview for what an image looks like without forcing the client to download it.

Also local files behave exactly like other local files so in that case (the typical case) all that pain you feel with NFS/FUSE goes away

Re:Dropbox’s Smart Sync lets users open a file stored only i... by AlexandrB on Monday January 30, 2017 @03:02PM (#13524494)
I think I'll pass on giving Dropbox a direct line into my computer's kernel.
Re:Dropbox’s Smart Sync lets users open a file stored only i... by LogicX on Monday January 30, 2017 @08:56PM (#13526835)
It's had that for a long time. one of the hallmarks of their OSX tight integration has been in memory patching of different OS versions to display dropbox files tightly integrated with finder.

be scared.

Re:Dropbox’s Smart Sync lets users open a file stored only i... by BadassFractal on Monday January 30, 2017 @03:55PM (#13524909)
Any chance they will let us store more than 1TB on the individual paid version of the product? I have a terabytes worth of RAW file format photographs that I currently have to store on S3, but I'd much rather keep everything on Dropbox if I can. https://www.dropbox.com/en/help/160
Re:Dropbox’s Smart Sync lets users open a file stored only i... by desireco42 on Monday January 30, 2017 @06:05PM (#13525932)
I gave up on Dropbox long time ago. Maybe I am wrong, but with data loss and other issues, especially limit on space, I found BTSync better suited for my needs. It's been working for years now.

I think Dropbox could've innovated much more then they did, to make their offering more compelling to guys like me. They didn't and that is unfortunate. I think they feel pressured now but it might be a little late and their solutions are kind of artificial and inspired by others... (paper for example)

Re:Dropbox’s Smart Sync lets users open a file stored only i... by rckclmbr on Tuesday January 31, 2017 @01:14AM (#13528176)
Fellow BTSync (now Resilio Sync) user. Lately, even its mobile clients feel superior to Dropbox. I have a "master" computer that has everything synced to it, then use backblaze to back up everything offsite (it stores historical files/edits as well). I'm 100% satisfied.
Re:Dropbox’s Smart Sync lets users open a file stored only i... by danieldk on Tuesday January 31, 2017 @01:50AM (#13528367)
I currently use both, but I am thinking of switching fully to Resilio Sync. Given Dropbox disregard for proper security, I don't want them to run in kernel space (via a kext).

The only downside of Resilio Sync is that the sharing story is not yet great.

Re:Dropbox’s Smart Sync lets users open a file stored only i... by desireco42 on Wednesday February 01, 2017 @12:56AM (#13538628)
I've been using it for at least 2 yrs if not more now. Zero issues.

Well, once I deleted files in misguided effort to move them. They were deleted from all machines :). It wasn't a big deal, it just shows it works.

Re:Dropbox’s Smart Sync lets users open a file stored only i... by odabaxok on Monday January 30, 2017 @02:13PM (#13524110)
Dropbox's first blog post about Smart Sync (aka Infinite) and discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11570888
Re:Dropbox’s Smart Sync lets users open a file stored only i... by jessriedel on Monday January 30, 2017 @03:03PM (#13524501)
What's happened since then? Is it that the project was announced back then and is now available to businesses, as predicted? Or is that it was available to businesses back then when announced, and will be available to individuals?
Re:Dropbox’s Smart Sync lets users open a file stored only i... by odabaxok on Tuesday January 31, 2017 @02:51AM (#13528598)
I haven't read both articles thoroughly, but two quotes from the articles will answer your questions:

Blog post: "Project Infinite will enable users to seamlessly and securely access all their Dropbox files from the desktop, regardless of how much space they have available on their hard drives."

This post: "Dropbox today released Smart Sync..."

So the blog post was a demo about feature in the future, while this article says it is already released.

Re:Dropbox’s Smart Sync lets users open a file stored only i... by nvr219 on Monday January 30, 2017 @03:24PM (#13524664)
I wish I could enforce this as dropbox administrator to my users... like when they install, have "smart sync" on specific folders instead of default to downloading everything.
Re:Dropbox’s Smart Sync lets users open a file stored only i... by abalone on Monday January 30, 2017 @05:07PM (#13525496)
How does this compare technically to iCloud[1] and (lesser known) Upthere[2]? And any other cloud storage providers that treat local files as purgeable / do selective syncing.

For example one major difference I've noticed is iCloud can sync while asleep (Power Nap). This has proven to be very useful with my iCloud Photo Library, which has tons of syncing to do every day and night over a slow connection.

Another distinction with Apple's approach, maybe not directly comparable to Dropbox Business, is how it is integrated with apps. I mentioned photos, but it also covers iTunes music and movies/TV. It lets it be smarter than a purely filesystem level sync, like downloading photo previews and purging movies only after you've watched them. In other words it has a direct Dropbox competitor in iCloud Drive, but also adds domain-specific syncing.

Are there any advantages to Dropbox's approach?

[1] https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT206996

[2] https://upthere.com/technology

Re:Dropbox’s Smart Sync lets users open a file stored only i... by reynoldsbd on Monday January 30, 2017 @06:22PM (#13526027)
OneDrive used to have "placeholder files" (online-only, downloaded on demand), but it was removed due to poor UX.

https://blogs.office.com/2015/01/07/taking-the-next-step-in-...

Sounds like the feature could be coming back to Win10 relatively soon:

http://www.pcworld.com/article/3124429/data-center-cloud/one...

Re:Dropbox’s Smart Sync lets users open a file stored only i... by Longhanks on Monday January 30, 2017 @05:37PM (#13525749)
Dropbox is cross-platform. I'd love iCloud features on my Linux Desktop, but I'm unable to consume it.
Re:Dropbox’s Smart Sync lets users open a file stored only i... by abalone on Monday January 30, 2017 @06:22PM (#13526026)
iCloud supports Windows, at least:

https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT204283

Re:Dropbox’s Smart Sync lets users open a file stored only i... by johnhattan on Monday January 30, 2017 @09:21PM (#13526970)
So how does this work with stuff like virus scanners or text-searches that read all the bytes of all the files in a hierarchy?

Does it load up all the files locally and then LRU-discard them only to load them all up again the next time the virus-scanner runs?

Re:Dropbox’s Smart Sync lets users open a file stored only i... by BadassFractal on Monday January 30, 2017 @09:23PM (#13526985)
Would also be curious to know how this would work with something like Lightroom that can operate on pre-computed downsampled versions of the RAW originals.
Re:Dropbox’s Smart Sync lets users open a file stored only i... by ChristianGeek on Monday January 30, 2017 @10:02PM (#13527178)
If this would allow me to keep the original image files in the cloud and only pull down the ones I want to work with, that would be awesome! I have the downsampled images on my laptop now and the originals on an external hard drive that's backed up to the cloud, but it would obviously be a lot more convenient to have the hard drive hold the backup.
Re:Dropbox’s Smart Sync lets users open a file stored only i... by dkonofalski on Monday January 30, 2017 @03:42PM (#13524820)
I'm really interested in the last part of the article where the file is store locally (with checks against space) for very large files and where only the diff is synced between the cloud and the local machine. That might work wonders for people that share large files constantly but it might also be a headache if you're trying to determine a diff for a binary file instead of something simple like ASCII text.
Re:Dropbox’s Smart Sync lets users open a file stored only i... by akeck on Monday January 30, 2017 @10:12PM (#13527209)
ExpanDrive on Mac and Win gives the same experience, but with almost any cloud storage backend. I combine it with unlimited Amazon Cloud Drive.
Re:Dropbox’s Smart Sync lets users open a file stored only i... by praveenperera on Monday January 30, 2017 @03:43PM (#13524825)
I've wanted this forever now, if they enable this on normal pro accounts I will finally pay for dropbox.
Re:Dropbox’s Smart Sync lets users open a file stored only i... by mixedCase on Monday January 30, 2017 @07:04PM (#13526233)
This has been available since forever in any of the Dropbox FUSE implementations.
Re:Dropbox’s Smart Sync lets users open a file stored only i... by zer0t3ch on Monday January 30, 2017 @08:18PM (#13526652)
But muh Windows
Re:Dropbox’s Smart Sync lets users open a file stored only i... by mixedCase on Monday January 30, 2017 @09:59PM (#13527165)
I've never used it, but Dokany seems to open a FUSE-shaped hole in a Windows kernel driver.
Re:Dropbox’s Smart Sync lets users open a file stored only i... by mankash666 on Monday January 30, 2017 @03:22PM (#13524638)
Wonder how this compares to NFS/pNFS.
Re:Dropbox’s Smart Sync lets users open a file stored only i... by coldtea on Monday January 30, 2017 @04:11PM (#13525055)
It doesn't. It's basically offering local proxies for remote files.

NFS was/is a networked filesystem protocol, where multiple clients access the same remote volumes.

Re:Dropbox’s Smart Sync lets users open a file stored only i... by Groxx on Monday January 30, 2017 @04:46PM (#13525341)
Is that substantially different somehow?
Re:Dropbox’s Smart Sync lets users open a file stored only i... by coldtea on Tuesday January 31, 2017 @04:09AM (#13528957)
Yes, in the same way that ssh to a server to get a file is not the same as a hard or soft link.
Re:Dropbox’s Smart Sync lets users open a file stored only i... by Groxx on Tuesday January 31, 2017 @04:24PM (#13535382)
If that hard / soft link hides an ssh connection behind it, and the ssh connection is presented as SSHFS[1] (since that's practically what NFS is), then I really don't see much of a difference. Protocol, implementation, sure. But it's the same end result.

[1]: https://github.com/libfuse/sshfs

Re:Dropbox’s Smart Sync lets users open a file stored only i... by giovannibajo1 on Tuesday January 31, 2017 @06:53PM (#13536653)
The main difference is that you are always one click away from switching between the "nfs mode" (so to speak) and the fully cached offline mode, which is the default for Dropbox and is unavailable with network filesystems. And I mean switch file-by-file or directory-by-directory.
Re:Dropbox’s Smart Sync lets users open a file stored only i... by niij on Monday January 30, 2017 @07:13PM (#13526281)
Is this available for Linux? I couldn't find information one way or the other on Dropbox's site.
Re:Dropbox’s Smart Sync lets users open a file stored only i... by nkkollaw on Monday January 30, 2017 @07:42PM (#13526462)
iCloud removed a 800MB Photoshop file while I was working on it today, and I had to download it again (luckily I had saved my work, but the file was still open).

I didn't expect that. I guess if it's open but not modified it isn't locked?

These things are not that intuitive, just yet.

Re:Dropbox’s Smart Sync lets users open a file stored only i... by tqkxzugoaupvwqr on Monday January 30, 2017 @08:04PM (#13526588)
Are you running out of local disk space by any chance? macOS has a feature where files stored in iCloud are removed from the local computer if disk space is getting low.

You can change the setting in System Preferences > iCloud > iCloud Drive Options. Uncheck “Optimize Mac Storage”.

Re:Dropbox’s Smart Sync lets users open a file stored only i... by nkkollaw on Wednesday February 01, 2017 @06:45AM (#13539937)
Yes. That's the featured that caused the file to be removed.

It's just that I didn't expect macOS to remove a file while it was open.

Re:Dropbox’s Smart Sync lets users open a file stored only i... by beached_whale on Monday January 30, 2017 @08:41PM (#13526767)
If the business package could upload photo's from phone devices I would consider it.
Re:Dropbox’s Smart Sync lets users open a file stored only i... by raverbashing on Monday January 30, 2017 @03:04PM (#13524503)
This sounds like NFS for the .js age

Slower, buggier and less reliable (and I mean, yes, compared to NFS)

Re:Dropbox’s Smart Sync lets users open a file stored only i... by matthewmacleod on Monday January 30, 2017 @04:06PM (#13525013)
You have literally no idea what the performance or UX of this service will be like, but you've decided to have a pop at it anyway. That's not a very endearing quality. You'll recall of course the similar short-sighted comments when Dropbox first debuted…

Have a look at some of the technology - there is some interesting stuff in there - before writing it off.

Re:Dropbox’s Smart Sync lets users open a file stored only i... by Spooky23 on Monday January 30, 2017 @04:27PM (#13525198)
Normally I'd agree, but there's a pretty substantial history of vendors trying to solve these problems in the filesystem context, and it's pretty clear that it's hard problem from many different perspectives. It's very reasonable to the skeptical.

Microsoft gave up in OneDrive (where they used stubbing for awhile), and moved to a model where they, in Windows 10 deliver a filesystem replacement that looks and smells like a traditional filesystem to end users, but is in fact a Dropbox-like mobile client.

I'm sure that when I get to use it (I'm merely a chump paying $100/year for Dropbox) it will be great for 90% of my needs. But there are many edge cases where things will break for users or applications that don't handle high latency file operations well.

If anyone has a chance to pull this off with a UX that people can grok, it will be Dropbox.

Re:Dropbox’s Smart Sync lets users open a file stored only i... by raverbashing on Monday January 30, 2017 @04:13PM (#13525077)
UX has to deal with real-life and technological limitations

That's the main problem in this case. And NFS. And CIFS. And in other similar things

Re:Dropbox’s Smart Sync lets users open a file stored only i... by dagw on Monday January 30, 2017 @05:22PM (#13525630)
NFS never did selective local and offline syncing. If you are going to compare it to anything, compare it to AFS.
Re:Dropbox’s Smart Sync lets users open a file stored only i... by ptman on Tuesday January 31, 2017 @05:02AM (#13529216)
what about AFS or Coda?
Re:Dropbox’s Smart Sync lets users open a file stored only i... by Animats on Monday January 30, 2017 @02:26PM (#13524203)
Haven't they had that for years, except with more local caching?
Re:Dropbox’s Smart Sync lets users open a file stored only i... by zuccs on Monday January 30, 2017 @05:37PM (#13525751)
No. You could turn off syncing a folder completely (Selective Sync).

This is a rebrand of their Project Infinite (https://blogs.dropbox.com/business/2016/04/announcing-projec...).

Re:Dropbox’s Smart Sync lets users open a file stored only i... by sikhote on Monday January 30, 2017 @06:55PM (#13526180)
Still no .ignore list :(
Re:Dropbox’s Smart Sync lets users open a file stored only i... by dpratt on Monday January 30, 2017 @10:53PM (#13527422)
I ditched Dropbox years ago - I have no tolerance for any platform that requires an invisible (and not terribly inspectable) patch to my kernel.

Plus, it ate batteries like nobody's business.