News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Dropbox’s Smart Sync lets users open a file stored only i... by raverbashing on Monday January 30, 2017 @03:04PM (#13524503)
This sounds like NFS for the .js age

Slower, buggier and less reliable (and I mean, yes, compared to NFS)

Re:Dropbox’s Smart Sync lets users open a file stored only i... by matthewmacleod on Monday January 30, 2017 @04:06PM (#13525013)
You have literally no idea what the performance or UX of this service will be like, but you've decided to have a pop at it anyway. That's not a very endearing quality. You'll recall of course the similar short-sighted comments when Dropbox first debuted…

Have a look at some of the technology - there is some interesting stuff in there - before writing it off.

Re:Dropbox’s Smart Sync lets users open a file stored only i... by Spooky23 on Monday January 30, 2017 @04:27PM (#13525198)
Normally I'd agree, but there's a pretty substantial history of vendors trying to solve these problems in the filesystem context, and it's pretty clear that it's hard problem from many different perspectives. It's very reasonable to the skeptical.

Microsoft gave up in OneDrive (where they used stubbing for awhile), and moved to a model where they, in Windows 10 deliver a filesystem replacement that looks and smells like a traditional filesystem to end users, but is in fact a Dropbox-like mobile client.

I'm sure that when I get to use it (I'm merely a chump paying $100/year for Dropbox) it will be great for 90% of my needs. But there are many edge cases where things will break for users or applications that don't handle high latency file operations well.

If anyone has a chance to pull this off with a UX that people can grok, it will be Dropbox.

Re:Dropbox’s Smart Sync lets users open a file stored only i... by raverbashing on Monday January 30, 2017 @04:13PM (#13525077)
UX has to deal with real-life and technological limitations

That's the main problem in this case. And NFS. And CIFS. And in other similar things

Re:Dropbox’s Smart Sync lets users open a file stored only i... by dagw on Monday January 30, 2017 @05:22PM (#13525630)
NFS never did selective local and offline syncing. If you are going to compare it to anything, compare it to AFS.
Re:Dropbox’s Smart Sync lets users open a file stored only i... by ptman on Tuesday January 31, 2017 @05:02AM (#13529216)
what about AFS or Coda?