News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Hawaiians call Mark Zuckerberg 'the face of neocolonialis... by tabeth on Tuesday January 24, 2017 @12:03PM (#13473144)
The idea of someone living in multiple places is just hilarious. The epitome of privilege.

That being said, didn't Z just buy the land from other people? How was he able to even "buy" the land without full agreement of all of the owners to begin with? Shouldn't the land not belong to him until the transaction is complete?

In any case, the regular people always get screwed in these cases and always will until things are completely communal. Land shouldn't be owned by anyone. Rather, it should be able to be used freely. There are obviously logistical issues, but perhaps that should be and place and we'll figure out the rest?

> Makaala Kaaumoana, the executive director of an environmental group in Hanalei, Kauai, said that the lawsuits would help identify and inform descendants of links to the land they may not know about, which is “a good thing”.

> “It is always a sad thing when families lose their land, for any reason, but at least this way they are compensated,” she said.

The rationalization afterwards is also interesting.

> And Matt Goodale, a neighbor whose 10 acres of breadfruit, banana, mango, lychee and longan trees lie about one and a half miles from Zuckerberg’s property, said that the CEO’s purchase of the land was much better than the alternative: an 80-home development.

Good to know the rich look after each other.

Re:Hawaiians call Mark Zuckerberg 'the face of neocolonialis... by LeifCarrotson on Tuesday January 24, 2017 @12:38PM (#13473519)
> Land shouldn't be owned by anyone. Rather, it should be able to be used freely.

How would this work? Honest question.

I agree that the concept of land ownership is a little weird - it's one of the most limited, exclusive resources we have.

Hypothetically, I would love to be able to use this land that Z is "buying" under the current land ownership paradigm. But that free use, to me, would look like pouring a concrete foundation and building a structure with a bunk room, kitchen, bathroom, common area, with storage for a Hobie Cat, some surfboards, and SCUBA gear, and a patio overlooking the ocean. I'd want the rest of the land to be nicely forested. I would come out for a week every couple months. Would I have freedom to do this in a non-land-ownership system? What would prevent others from building in front of me, or using my structure when I wanted to be there?

Re:Hawaiians call Mark Zuckerberg 'the face of neocolonialis... by ferbivore on Tuesday January 24, 2017 @12:53PM (#13473683)
The way it works is called communism: you put a small cabal of people in charge of deciding what you can and can't do. Everyone gets whatever amount of land the ruling cabal says they get, rather than being able to get an amount proportional to their wealth.

Unfortunately, we all know what happens when you put groups of self-interested humans in charge of a society, and I don't think any group of completely altruistic ones is going to take over the world any time soon.

Also, the only successful communist country currently in existence is actually a hardcore capitalist dystopia.

I'm not sure there is any other "common ownership of land" scheme that isn't just communism with window dressing or superintelligent AI thrown in. If there is, please do enlighten me.

Re:Hawaiians call Mark Zuckerberg 'the face of neocolonialis... by snerbles on Tuesday January 24, 2017 @01:09PM (#13473858)
The counter-argument would be that "real" communism involves everyone deciding for the collective good.

In practice it winds up as you describe, with strongmen at the top.

Re:Hawaiians call Mark Zuckerberg 'the face of neocolonialis... by wpietri on Tuesday January 24, 2017 @01:15PM (#13473924)
Community works pretty well at the small scale. I know plenty of people who jointly own and use land and it works out as fine as any other social thing. E.g., cohousing, shared vacation property, areas owned by extended families, condo buildings with common areas.

It has always failed scaling it up, but maybe that's just a sign we shouldn't try to scale it up.

Re:Hawaiians call Mark Zuckerberg 'the face of neocolonialis... by zardo on Tuesday January 24, 2017 @03:24PM (#13475116)
It seems obvious that it would fail. Community cohesion works by each person having a high level of connection with each other person. I'd say on the order of (n*n) connections.

Of course, this has implications for large democracies, as well as large communes.

Re:Hawaiians call Mark Zuckerberg 'the face of neocolonialis... by wpietri on Tuesday January 24, 2017 @01:12PM (#13473892)
Historical examples include the European commons system and the Mexican ejido system. I'm not an expert, but generally common resources are seen as owned by the community as a whole and there's some mechanism for jointly deciding how to use them.

As a familiar example, one could look at state and national parks. A state park is owned by the people and maintained by the government; use by individuals is controlled and negotiated. You want to camp? Great, book a spot. You want to do some logging? Maybe, but you'll need a permit. You want to clear cut and build a strip mall? Nope.

Your example of an exclusive vacation home doesn't fit well with that approach in that you're not part of the Hawaiian community. You want to control the land even when you're not there, which is ownership.

Giving up ownership for vacation property would be something more like Die Naturfreunde. My understanding is that they maintain a set of communally owned and operated guest houses around the world. There's one just north of San Francisco, a lovely hostel and beer garden in Muir Woods. If you want to be a member there, you have to consistently contribute labor to maintaining it.

Re:Hawaiians call Mark Zuckerberg 'the face of neocolonialis... by witty_username on Tuesday January 24, 2017 @01:30PM (#13474075)
Community ownership only works if humans are identical robots. We disagree very often so how would you decide usage of land based on communities?

Look at housing societies in India; they enforce rules like no single women or no Muslims.

It's convenient when you're in the majority but inconvenient when you're in the minority.

How would you decide between so many different wants? I can not decide between say whether this land should be used for a mall or a factory.

In fact, in the real world if I knew, I could earn good money by building whichever is better. Information is money.

This system is also poor as people who value land less end up with excess land and people who do value land more end up with a lack of land. How do you measure this "value"? Money.

> There's one just north of San Francisco, a lovely hostel and beer garden in Muir Woods. If you want to be a member there, you have to consistently contribute labor to maintaining it.

This ignores specialization, i.e. I could be doing something that I'm good at (like programming) and the labor can be done by someone else (who doesn't have any better option) with the money I earn.

EDIT: replaced LTV criticism with specialization argument

Re:Hawaiians call Mark Zuckerberg 'the face of neocolonialis... by wpietri on Tuesday January 24, 2017 @09:43PM (#13478003)
I'm just amazed at the number of people who are fundamentalist capitalists. Who have to see everything in dollar terms. Who can't even quietly consider other approaches that might work just fine in particular circumstances.

Personally, I'm a practicing capitalist, and somebody who approves of using market mechanisms for a wide variety of things. But nothing is perfect, and people legitimately have different values. So I think it's worth understanding those other approaches. I have no idea why people find that so threatening.

Re:Hawaiians call Mark Zuckerberg 'the face of neocolonialis... by witty_username on Wednesday January 25, 2017 @06:19AM (#13480493)
> people who are fundamentalist capitalists

Who?

> Who can't even quietly consider other approaches that might work just fine in particular circumstances.

I explained how it might not work.

You are attacking me but not my reasoning.

I am just criticizing communal ownership since it does not work.

> I have no idea why people find that so threatening.

Who?

Re:Hawaiians call Mark Zuckerberg 'the face of neocolonialis... by wpietri on Wednesday January 25, 2017 @10:44AM (#13482274)
Did somebody let an owl in? You, of course. Although it's a perennial problem on HN, which is why I was speaking more generally.

You haven't gotten to reasoning yet. I critiqued your style of argument: the outraged hot take, the instant defense of something that wasn't even attacked. It was a spew of semi-random points, not a coherent argument.

There's no point in discussing the details with you, because you aren't interested in learning anything. When called on your drama, you pretend to be purely rational. If you can't even admit your reaction or look at your own post honestly, why would I ever engage with the details of what you claim your point to be?

Re:Hawaiians call Mark Zuckerberg 'the face of neocolonialis... by witty_username on Wednesday January 25, 2017 @11:00AM (#13482445)
> the instant defense of something that wasn't even attacked

I just said how collective ownership fails and how capitalism is a better solution. Is there something I said that I shouldn't have?

> There's no point in discussing the details with you, because you aren't interested in learning anything.

I am. Go critique my points. Maybe show me some empirical examples to rebuke me. Send me research articles. Or write your own explanation of how collective ownership would be managed.

> When called on your drama, you pretend to be purely rational.

What drama? I was just a little bored and decided to poke a low hanging fruit (collective ownership).

> If you can't even admit your reaction or look at your own post honestly, why would I ever engage with the details of what you claim your point to be?

I'm pretty sure I wasn't angry or anything. Uncharitably, I was thinking "haha, commies are stupid", but I don't think I let that affect my comment.

To me, it seems like you're the more angry one. Perhaps it is just an effect of you being text on a screen as opposed to a person I can see and talk to.

Re:Hawaiians call Mark Zuckerberg 'the face of neocolonialis... by wpietri on Wednesday January 25, 2017 @06:56PM (#13487414)
> Maybe show me some empirical examples to rebuke me.

Like the three historical examples you ignored in the post you responded to? C'mon. Why would I waste more time?

> haha, commies are stupid

Yes, this is how you got to the "not even wrong" level of discourse and somehow thought it constituted reasoning. A random salting of pure-theory, Econ-101 points is the sort of lazy, free-market fundamentalism that I have no time for.

Communists weren't stupid. Communism didn't work, but people trying it had a reasonable intuition that it would work because they had a lot of experience with communal approaches working pretty well for them at smaller scales. And, just as important, working in ways and yielding outcomes that matched their values. Because they also had a lot of experience with unregulated capitalism fucking them over.

Laughing alternatives off like this is just a knee-jerk defense of the status quo. People here get endlessly mad when it happens to handwave away startups or new tech. But it's somehow common and acceptable whenever economics comes up.

> Or write your own explanation of how collective ownership would be managed.

It is not my job to force-feed you an education just because you saw fit to make a poorly considered reply to something I wrote. If you want to be taken seriously, it is your job to go get one. This is an entire field of literature.

Re:Hawaiians call Mark Zuckerberg 'the face of neocolonialis... by witty_username on Thursday January 26, 2017 @12:41AM (#13489031)
From https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ejido :

"Ejidatarios do not actually own the land, but are allowed to use their allotted parcels indefinitely as long as they do not fail to use the land for more than two years. They can pass their rights on to their children."

Taking land from landlords doesn't work because then no one will buy land in the future out of that risk, unless it is very clearly done as a one-time thing. See: one-time tax.

I'm not saying collective ownership does not exist but you haven't shown it works empirically or theoretically.

> A random salting of pure-theory, Econ-101 points is the sort of lazy, free-market fundamentalism that I have no time for.

What is wrong with pure-theory and Econ-101 points?

Mainstream economic theory is a refinement of Econ-101 with more complex modelling (imperfect competition, sticky wages).

Econ-101 can be used to rebuke many bad economic policies like what Venezuela is doing (capital control, etc).

> And, just as important, working in ways and yielding outcomes that matched their values.

Do famines and poverty reflect their values? Does food rationing reflect their values?

Does only the Politburo having access to the ZIL-111 reflect egalitarianism (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ZIL-111)? Does Chaikas only being available for purchase by the Soviet government reflect egalitarianism?

> Communists weren't stupid.

Most communism (such as LTV) is bad economics (that's why the Marxist school of economics is very much outside the mainstream). Communism forgets the Laffer curve at 100%. Complete equality does not work.

> communal approaches working pretty well for them at smaller scales

It works at smaller scales of family, neighbors, etc because then the people are roughly homogeneous. Even then it is not optimal. Have you heard of horrible stories involving housing societies?

> Laughing alternatives off like this is just a knee-jerk defense of the status quo.

It's not a knee-jerk defense because I gave some thinking.

> But it's somehow common and acceptable whenever economics comes up.

I have been downvoted at times for my "fundamentalist capitalist" views. The earliest post in this thread that I wrote is at 0 points (maybe you downvoted it).

Re:Hawaiians call Mark Zuckerberg 'the face of neocolonialis... by HillaryBriss on Tuesday January 24, 2017 @11:19PM (#13478469)
One concept to contrast with the American system of private property ownership and rights is the "freedom to roam" concept which exists in some Scandinavian countries:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Freedom_to_roam

In addition, I think, even in the US system as it exists currently, property ownership rights are not 100% absolute. I mean, even Zuckerberg couldn't declare his new 700 acre holding to be, say, a toxic waste dump, or a launch pad for outer space rockets. He'd need a whole lot of government approvals to use the land in those ways, and he most likely would never get the approvals.

Land rights and usages are not absolute, even for the title bearer.

Re:Hawaiians call Mark Zuckerberg 'the face of neocolonialis... by hydrogen18 on Wednesday January 25, 2017 @10:42AM (#13482249)
Additionally, he only owns it as long as he can pay whatever property taxes are levied upon it.
Re:Hawaiians call Mark Zuckerberg 'the face of neocolonialis... by tabeth on Tuesday January 24, 2017 @12:48PM (#13473621)
I won't pretend like I'm an expert. However, I will say that in our supposedly democratic land, a useful heuristic would be just to vote. If the land was not owned by anyone and this could be magically enforced, then the people would simply vote for its use, right?

As things come up people would just revote. Since no one owns the land there wouldn't be any conflict of interest. You may point out that those who originally voted may be conflicted, but I disagree: any proposition that would benefit the majority would clearly win. Any proposition that doesn't would necessarily be struck down.

This kind of system has its own problems, though. Long term sustainability is one, requisites for voting is another. But these problems I think are separate.

Re:Hawaiians call Mark Zuckerberg 'the face of neocolonialis... by madgar on Tuesday January 24, 2017 @01:17PM (#13473948)
You forgot about protecting minorities. What do you do when the majority of the people in a jurisdiction like (eg.) Mississippi consistently vote down land use by black people? Just accept that the people have spoken and that black people are unwelcome in that jurisdiction?

This is not a theoretical exercise. This happens everyday in America in co-op boards, HOAs, etc and it doesn't require anybody saying out loud why an individual is being rejected. The current US president got caught doing this in the 1960s. If you want to redesign land use rights wholesale I would hope you wouldn't make this kind of discrimination more common... maybe that's just me.

Re:Hawaiians call Mark Zuckerberg 'the face of neocolonialis... by Arizhel on Tuesday January 24, 2017 @02:23PM (#13474584)
>You forgot about protecting minorities. What do you do when the majority of the people in a jurisdiction like (eg.) Mississippi consistently vote down land use by black people? Just accept that the people have spoken and that black people are unwelcome in that jurisdiction?

Well, yes. That's how democracy works: there's a vote and the majority wins. Are you opposed to democracy?

Yeah, it sucks if you're a minority, but what can you do? This is a fundamental flaw in democracy. We attempt to mitigate it by having constitutions and laws and representatives who are voted on in multi-year cycles, which in engineering terms has the effect of creating a long feedback loop so that the populace's short term emotions don't create too much instability and chaos, but it only works to a point.

The alternative is a non-democratic system like what they do in China. And they don't seem to be too keen on protecting the rights of minorities either.

Re:Hawaiians call Mark Zuckerberg 'the face of neocolonialis... by RUG3Y on Tuesday January 24, 2017 @03:31PM (#13475181)
The alternative is a republic, which is supposed to protect the inalienable rights of the minority from the whims of the majority.
Re:Hawaiians call Mark Zuckerberg 'the face of neocolonialis... by Arizhel on Tuesday January 24, 2017 @03:55PM (#13475361)
Are you one of those people who thinks a modern democratic republic somehow isn't democratic? Did you miss my whole line about constitutions and laws? Those are fundamentals of a modern democratic republic. Why is it that every time someone mentions a democracy, someone like you pops up and claims that a modern democracy isn't a democracy?

Read this: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Democratic_republic

Line 1: "A democratic republic is both a republic and a democracy."

Furthermore, not all republics are democratic. North Korea and China are both republics, as is Iran. I already mentioned China in my previous post. Do you really think North Korea protects anyone's inalienable rights? Or Iran?

Re:Hawaiians call Mark Zuckerberg 'the face of neocolonialis... by RUG3Y on Tuesday January 24, 2017 @04:01PM (#13475402)
Maybe if someone always pops up to correct your vision of democracy, you're not communicating very well.
[dead]
Re:Hawaiians call Mark Zuckerberg 'the face of neocolonialis... by sctb on Tuesday January 24, 2017 @06:41PM (#13476908)
Please no personal attacks like this on Hacker News.
Re:Hawaiians call Mark Zuckerberg 'the face of neocolonialis... by madgar on Tuesday January 24, 2017 @04:57PM (#13476007)
Your first comment in this thread - in which you mention representatives in passing - suggests that you assume all "democracy" to come in the form of democratic republics. This might be true in a discussion of practical implementations of a scalable democratic governing system.

The thread you responded to, however, was about a theoretical directly democratic system of managing land use rights, without any grounding in a realized system with elements of republicanism. The disconnect between the discussion at hand and the assumptions you brought to it (IMHO) caused the confusion between yourself and Arizhel.

A more constructive comment from yourself might have instead politely pointed out that the scenario I described is a classic "tyranny of the majority" issue, a well understood failure mode of direct democracy that is indeed typically resolved practically through the features of republicanism you listed.

Re:Hawaiians call Mark Zuckerberg 'the face of neocolonialis... by PJDK on Tuesday January 24, 2017 @12:59PM (#13473749)
But how do you decide who gets a vote? Presumably there is some kind of rules based around locality, but then people are where they are due to the current land ownership rules!
Re:Hawaiians call Mark Zuckerberg 'the face of neocolonialis... by loafa on Tuesday January 24, 2017 @01:51PM (#13474279)
It seems to me that if a group of people did come across some new land and decide to vote on what to do with it, they'd immediately vote to subdivide it amongst themselves. Leave some bits as public land for roads and parks and other stuff, and subdivide the rest equally so that families can build their own houses and grow their own crops or whatever with confidence.

Of course within a few generations of inheritances and sales that equitable distribution of land will no longer look like that at all.

Re:Hawaiians call Mark Zuckerberg 'the face of neocolonialis... by tabeth on Tuesday January 24, 2017 @01:56PM (#13474338)
Hah. Obviously something like that wouldn't be allowed, since it would violate the rule of no land ownership to begin with.
Re:Hawaiians call Mark Zuckerberg 'the face of neocolonialis... by bufordsharkley on Tuesday January 24, 2017 @02:21PM (#13474571)
The way this works is a Land Value Tax (LVT)[0].

The land is still held by individuals, but they pay a use fee based upon the market value of the unimproved land. It's compatible with markets, capitalism, and in fact economists call it the most efficient tax possible.

It's also very environmentally friendly, insofar as it encourages efficient use of land, which would spur more infill instead of pushing the margin of land lower and lower, encouraging sprawl.

Why don't we use this tax, then? Mostly because it creates losers in the form of landowners, who tend to be extremely powerful, politically.

"This arouses furious opposition from landowners, in most countries a potent lobby, see it as highly unfair. They have got used to enjoying their rents and object to their sudden socialisation."[1]

If there's an upside, it's that it's been shown to be one of the only effective methods in implementing modern urban design and finance in a sustainable fashion. Just today, London expressed interest in seeing how LVT could remedy its housing crisis.[2]

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Land_value_tax

[1] http://www.economist.com/blogs/freeexchange/2015/04/land-val...

[2] https://www.london.gov.uk/press-releases/assembly/mayor-posi...

Re:Hawaiians call Mark Zuckerberg 'the face of neocolonialis... by pfarnsworth on Tuesday January 24, 2017 @12:25PM (#13473394)
Did you even bother reading the article? Zuckerberg is trying to do the right thing but identifying all the owners of the land first, and then trying to arrange to pay them. That's how it works in Hawaii, except he's being extremely proactive and in a manner that is friendly to the owners, if you RTFA.
Re:Hawaiians call Mark Zuckerberg 'the face of neocolonialis... by aaron-lebo on Tuesday January 24, 2017 @12:27PM (#13473409)
From TFA:

But for others, Zuckerberg’s lawsuits are unnecessary and unneighborly.

“Zuckerberg is saying he wants to respect the local culture and Hawaiian values but … I was always taught that if there was a dispute with somebody you go and knock on their door, sit down, and you kukakuka [discuss] and you hooponopono [make it right],” said Hawaii state representative Kaniela Ing of Maui. “You don’t initiate conversation by filing a lawsuit.”

Ing criticized Zuckerberg as “using the same legal loopholes sugar barons in Hawaii exploited centuries ago”, and said he planned to introduce state legislation to reform the quiet title process. One proposal would let kuleana owners group together and form a trust, in order to achieve a fairer price for their land.

and

“We have been waiting for contact,” said Hope Kallai, who lives on the same street as Zuckerberg, one property away. Kallai said she and other neighbors have attempted to reach out through Zuckerberg’s lawyers and ranch manager with no success. They did know that the billionaire was in town for Christmas, though, because they saw security guards parked on the road.

Very proactive.

Re:Hawaiians call Mark Zuckerberg 'the face of neocolonialis... by nubianwarrior on Tuesday January 24, 2017 @12:50PM (#13473646)
If he was trying to do the right thing he would be using his wealth to better the world, not buy parcels of land. What doublespeak.
Re:Hawaiians call Mark Zuckerberg 'the face of neocolonialis... by jdpedrie on Tuesday January 24, 2017 @12:58PM (#13473745)
I reject your premise, but just to play along for a minute...

https://chanzuckerberg.com/

Re:Hawaiians call Mark Zuckerberg 'the face of neocolonialis... by visakanv on Tuesday January 24, 2017 @01:04PM (#13473815)
A person who's convinced that Zuckerberg is a selfish agent will choose to cynically interpret this as some sort of tax evasion, PR stunt, etc
Re:Hawaiians call Mark Zuckerberg 'the face of neocolonialis... by caminante on Tuesday January 24, 2017 @01:29PM (#13474068)
Fair point. That said, even if a cynic interpreted a personal foundation as such, it doesn't preclude the philanthropist from harboring altruistic motives.

The issue here is that many of the comments have devolved into "gratuitous negativity."

Re:Hawaiians call Mark Zuckerberg 'the face of neocolonialis... by dave5104 on Tuesday January 24, 2017 @12:53PM (#13473682)
When did trying to legally buy land from people who are willing to sell it become the wrong thing?
Re:Hawaiians call Mark Zuckerberg 'the face of neocolonialis... by vkou on Tuesday January 24, 2017 @01:52PM (#13474299)
Me and my brother both own a horse. I have no immediate need for the horse, so I let my brother use it, but still maintain my stake in its ownership. My brother sells you the horse for $100, without asking me. You offer to buy me out for $50... And when I decline, threaten a lawsuit (On the grounds that you will put the horse to better economic use then I would have.)

This is a problem between you and my brother, not you and me. This is also a story as old as colonialism.

If you think this is all fine and dandy, and lives up to the greatest virtue of capitalism, please replace the horse in the analogy with shareholders having partial ownership of a company, and being forced to give up their stake, just because Zuckerburg paid off the biggest shareholder.

Nobody's putting a gun to his head, forcing him to buy 700 acres of land in Hawaii. If he can't come to an agreement with all the owners of the land, he should go back to California, instead of suing minority owners. That's generally how business works.

Re:Hawaiians call Mark Zuckerberg 'the face of neocolonialis... by logfromblammo on Tuesday January 24, 2017 @04:31PM (#13475712)
A company has 1000000 shares outstanding. Mr. Z buys 500001 of them at fair market price. He then votes himself onto the board and proposes a 500001-to-1 reverse split. The measure passes with 500001 votes in favor. Everyone having fewer than 500001 shares is paid cash for their shares, while Mr. Z turns in 500001 old shares for one new one. Mr. Z is now sole owner.

Large-scale reverse splits occasionally happen in real life, as a means of forcing smaller investors off the ownership rolls.

Re:Hawaiians call Mark Zuckerberg 'the face of neocolonialis... by pfarnsworth on Tuesday January 24, 2017 @06:22PM (#13476764)
If you read the article, the lawsuit isn't to force the owners to sell their land. They don't even know they own the land. Zuckerberg tracked down 300 heirs of a small piece of land that was never transferred properly decades previous. The lawsuit is a formality to first find all the owners, and to declare them owners of parts of the land, so that he can negotiate with them.

Again, RTFA.

Re:Hawaiians call Mark Zuckerberg 'the face of neocolonialis... by vkou on Wednesday January 25, 2017 @12:04AM (#13478692)
Some of them don't know that they own the land. Many of them most certainly do.

He isn't conducting the lawsuit out of some strange desire to figure out who is related to whom, or to clarify some papers. The purpose of a quiet title lawsuit is to steal a piece of land from its owners.

Discovering who the other claimants are is the first step in this process. The second step in this process is... To force them to put their land up for auction, where it will be sold to the highest bidder. The current landowners have no say in this. [1]

And, at the end of the process, Zuckerburg's investigation and attourney fees will be billed to... The owners of the land. For some of those parcels, they are quite likely to be higher then the cost of the parcels.

You couldn't come up with a less fair law if you tried - because it was specifically designed to benefit a wealthy party, that wants to take possession of a bunch of land, and the only thing in the way is a bunch of peasants who refuse to sell.

[1] http://www.staradvertiser.com/2017/01/18/business/facebooks-...

Re:Hawaiians call Mark Zuckerberg 'the face of neocolonialis... by pfarnsworth on Tuesday January 24, 2017 @06:23PM (#13476780)
He's donating his money at a scale of generosity that you will never achieve.
Re:Hawaiians call Mark Zuckerberg 'the face of neocolonialis... by tabeth on Wednesday January 25, 2017 @04:41AM (#13480045)
Poor people donate a greater percentage than Z:

http://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=1290682...

Re:Hawaiians call Mark Zuckerberg 'the face of neocolonialis... by falcolas on Tuesday January 24, 2017 @12:05PM (#13473163)
He's trying to, not everyone wants to sell (or more accurately, they don't want to sell for the amount Z is offering).

[EDIT]

Source: http://www.staradvertiser.com/2017/01/18/business/facebooks-...

"For someone to use the law to not only establish title, but to also force a sale requires that they have an ownership claim. For some of the Kauai land, Zuckerberg has done this by purchasing interests from several part-owners."

Re:Hawaiians call Mark Zuckerberg 'the face of neocolonialis... by iaw on Tuesday January 24, 2017 @12:11PM (#13473243)
> not everyone wants to sell (or more accurately, they don't want to sell for the amount Z is offering)

Could you provide a source for this? To my knowledge this was his first effort at acquiring the properties. Also, the structure of the law he's using requires the land to be sold at auction to the highest bidder making it, theoretically, fair market value.

Re:Hawaiians call Mark Zuckerberg 'the face of neocolonialis... by falcolas on Tuesday January 24, 2017 @12:17PM (#13473311)
The laws he's exploiting for the lawsuit require him to own a portion of the land - it's a law which is usually used with condos. So he has contacted at least some of the owners, and many of them said no, hence the lawsuit.

This was part of the article a few days back on HN which first introduced the issue.

Re:Hawaiians call Mark Zuckerberg 'the face of neocolonialis... by aaron-lebo on Tuesday January 24, 2017 @12:06PM (#13473180)
How is he trying to when he won't even talk to his neighbors and his lawyers won't respond to them or journalists?

That doesn't sound like caring about the community or acting in good faith.

Re:Hawaiians call Mark Zuckerberg 'the face of neocolonialis... by falcolas on Tuesday January 24, 2017 @12:08PM (#13473200)
He's bought some portions of the ownership, and is leveraging that via lawsuits to force the others sell.

Which tells me there are some who he's contacted and who have said "no".

Re:Hawaiians call Mark Zuckerberg 'the face of neocolonialis... by iaw on Tuesday January 24, 2017 @12:15PM (#13473285)
Rather than speculating, could you provide documentation for these statements?

I've been following this story fairly closely and the statement "He's bought some portions of the ownership, and is leveraging that via lawsuits to force the others sell." doesn't align with any of the documentation I've seen.

For one, he owns the land around the parcels, not portions of the parcels himself. For two, I don't think he's "leveraging" any sort of ownership to utilize the law as ownership does not seem to be needed for this process.

Re:Hawaiians call Mark Zuckerberg 'the face of neocolonialis... by falcolas on Tuesday January 24, 2017 @12:31PM (#13473462)
Edited into my OP:

http://www.staradvertiser.com/2017/01/18/business/facebooks-...

For someone to use the law to not only establish title, but to also force a sale requires that they have an ownership claim. For some of the Kauai land, Zuckerberg has done this by purchasing interests from several part-owners.

Re:Hawaiians call Mark Zuckerberg 'the face of neocolonialis... by dopamean on Tuesday January 24, 2017 @12:17PM (#13473305)
What do you mean by saying that it is hilarious? My come from a family that has multiple homes, mostly for vacationing purposes, and it's a nice thing. Sure you have to have some amount of privilege to afford it but I'm not sure what's funny about it.
Re:Hawaiians call Mark Zuckerberg 'the face of neocolonialis... by dsacco on Tuesday January 24, 2017 @12:26PM (#13473401)
The parent commenter finds it hilarious because, in their words, "land shouldn't be owned by anyone." Your family owning multiple plots of land is diametrically opposed to that world view. I foresee a very unproductive ideological argument about capitalism and property rights ensuing.
Re:Hawaiians call Mark Zuckerberg 'the face of neocolonialis... by caminante on Tuesday January 24, 2017 @01:13PM (#13473900)
Definitions matter too. "Privilege" has lost much of its meaning [0] if "living in multiple places" is acceptable criteria.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Privilege_(social_inequality)

Re:Hawaiians call Mark Zuckerberg 'the face of neocolonialis... by throwanem on Tuesday January 24, 2017 @10:31PM (#13478223)
That's not the definition of the word. It's a description of the word's use as a term of art in a very specific sociological and political theory which its adherents would like very much for everyone to assume is the only one which correctly describes reality.
Re:Hawaiians call Mark Zuckerberg 'the face of neocolonialis... by tabeth on Tuesday January 24, 2017 @01:38PM (#13474151)
Why link to the Wikipedia page and not to an actual definition?

https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/privilege

Re:Hawaiians call Mark Zuckerberg 'the face of neocolonialis... by caminante on Tuesday January 24, 2017 @02:16PM (#13474526)

  Why link to the Wikipedia page and not to an actual definition?
Your claim is provably false.

The Wikipedia entry offers "an actual definition." Also, the Wikipedia entry is based on numerous references and published literature supporting the definition.

Re:Hawaiians call Mark Zuckerberg 'the face of neocolonialis... by cmdrfred on Tuesday January 24, 2017 @12:24PM (#13473374)
You don't consider yourself privileged?
Re:Hawaiians call Mark Zuckerberg 'the face of neocolonialis... by eonw on Tuesday January 24, 2017 @12:27PM (#13473411)
many people with lots of privileges to not see themselves as privileged, simply because they know nothing else.
Re:Hawaiians call Mark Zuckerberg 'the face of neocolonialis... by 67726e on Tuesday January 24, 2017 @12:35PM (#13473492)
> simply because they know nothing else.

So lemme get this straight, if my ancestors worked hard to provide for their families and I, down the line, inherit some land or money I should feel bad about this? Why?

Re:Hawaiians call Mark Zuckerberg 'the face of neocolonialis... by umanwizard on Tuesday January 24, 2017 @12:40PM (#13473539)
That's a false dichotomy; you can recognize that you're privileged without simultaneously feeling bad about it.
Re:Hawaiians call Mark Zuckerberg 'the face of neocolonialis... by 67726e on Tuesday January 24, 2017 @01:10PM (#13473874)
Except all rhetoric I see involving privilege is ultimately about me having to keep my mouth shut about real issues or concede benefit to another, all because I'm a white guy. In fact I didn't inherit wealth or any "privilege", but I'm meant to feel as though I did something wrong by virtue of my skin color. You may not say "feel bad" but the type to use that word sure are.
Re:Hawaiians call Mark Zuckerberg 'the face of neocolonialis... by visakanv on Tuesday January 24, 2017 @12:55PM (#13473715)
> if my ancestors worked hard to provide for their families and I, down the line, inherit some land or money I should feel bad about this? Why?

You don't have to feel BAD about it; just recognize it. People inherit vastly different conditions by sheer accident of birth.

Re:Hawaiians call Mark Zuckerberg 'the face of neocolonialis... by 67726e on Tuesday January 24, 2017 @01:00PM (#13473764)
So what is the point? I have "privilege", now what?
Re:Hawaiians call Mark Zuckerberg 'the face of neocolonialis... by throwanem on Tuesday January 24, 2017 @01:06PM (#13473835)
Now you're supposed to feel bad about it, because the word connotes injustice by virtue of denoting a concept of "private law" - one rule for me, another for thee. But people who want you to feel bad about it don't want to be seen to be saying they want that, so they ignore the denotation and the connotation in their rhetoric, whose every deployment demonstrates further that it is enormously unhelpful toward its stated purpose, but which persists nonetheless. One wonders why.
Re:Hawaiians call Mark Zuckerberg 'the face of neocolonialis... by eonw on Wednesday January 25, 2017 @05:18PM (#13486781)
why so defensive about being privileged? it almost illustrates the concept for us... you claim to be privileged but also claim to not understand how it might make you different.
Re:Hawaiians call Mark Zuckerberg 'the face of neocolonialis... by dopamean on Tuesday January 24, 2017 @01:31PM (#13474081)
I am not one of those people. I said nothing to suggest that I might be either.
Re:Hawaiians call Mark Zuckerberg 'the face of neocolonialis... by ferbivore on Tuesday January 24, 2017 @12:27PM (#13473408)
Did you even read the comment you're replying to?
Re:Hawaiians call Mark Zuckerberg 'the face of neocolonialis... by kakarot on Tuesday January 24, 2017 @12:35PM (#13473486)
> "Sure you have to have some amount of privilege to afford it"
Re:Hawaiians call Mark Zuckerberg 'the face of neocolonialis... by hxegon on Tuesday January 24, 2017 @12:22PM (#13473363)
Uh, don't you know that money is evil and being rich is (like, uh, basically) a crime? REPENT CAPITALIST SCUM /s
Re:Hawaiians call Mark Zuckerberg 'the face of neocolonialis... by gnopgnip on Tuesday January 24, 2017 @01:29PM (#13474071)
The previous owner acquired it through adverse possession over a period of 10+ years. Due to a quirk in the local laws, compensation is still owed to all of those who descended from the original owners. In this case there are over 300 potential owners, some owning as little as one hundredth of a percent of the land. As long as there are unsettled claims no one will invest any time or money to improve the land. The quiet title action settles these claims allowing the land to either be sold or developed, and for all of the current owners to be compensated.
Re:Hawaiians call Mark Zuckerberg 'the face of neocolonialis... by Arizhel on Tuesday January 24, 2017 @02:27PM (#13474624)
This is Kauai, Hawaii. The land doesn't need to be "improved", it's already perfect as-is. It doesn't need investment, it just needs to be left alone for the locals to enjoy and for nature.

If you want to "improve" some land, go buy some ugly desert land in the LA area or something. Or better yet buy up some urban land filled with dilapidated buildings and bulldoze it and build something newer and better.

Re:Hawaiians call Mark Zuckerberg 'the face of neocolonialis... by Inconel on Tuesday January 24, 2017 @05:40PM (#13476449)
> go buy some ugly desert land in the LA area

I'm not sure if you've ever visited some of the desert areas around LA, but I wouldn't describe them as ugly or view their potential destruction so flippantly.

Re:Hawaiians call Mark Zuckerberg 'the face of neocolonialis... by Arizhel on Wednesday January 25, 2017 @04:42PM (#13486483)
I have. Some of it is quite interesting and beautiful (like that place where they filmed all the ST:TOS scenes with the slanted rocks), others are not so much.

Maybe I should have pointed to some other places. West Texas comes to mind: the area on I-40 going through the northwest part of the state (and Amarillo) is probably the ugliest natural (I guess) land I've ever seen. Just miles of flat, brown dirt.

Of course, there's plenty of land marred by humans that could certainly benefit from being bulldozed and rebuilt anew, if someone is looking for land to "improve". Parts of New Jersey around Newark come to mind here, plus Detroit and lots of other places in the Rust Belt. There's also a bunch of desert north of Las Vegas NV that could use "improvement": it's marked by tons of craters from nuclear bomb testing.

Re:Hawaiians call Mark Zuckerberg 'the face of neocolonialis... by local_kauai on Wednesday January 25, 2017 @04:54AM (#13480100)
In good faith, I am sure, however this is one of the most pristine tracks of land on Kauai. Lack of development is a good thing here.
Re:Hawaiians call Mark Zuckerberg 'the face of neocolonialis... by bebop on Tuesday January 24, 2017 @03:01PM (#13474930)
Not that long ago 10 acres on the north shore of Kauai was not particularly expensive. It has largely been developed in the last 20 years or so. My point is that the neighbor may not be particularly rich, especially if he is a farmer. It may be that he is more willing to accept a large estate, rather than a subdivision in what is a largely rural area. Note that I am in no way commenting on the situation Zuckerberg finds himself in, but there are people on the north shore who farm (own land/not rich).
Re:Hawaiians call Mark Zuckerberg 'the face of neocolonialis... by joyeuse6701 on Tuesday January 24, 2017 @01:24PM (#13474009)
Begin with your own residence.
Re:Hawaiians call Mark Zuckerberg 'the face of neocolonialis... by armenarmen on Tuesday January 24, 2017 @01:52PM (#13474306)
Because the tragedy of the commons isn't a trope already. Communally owned things always end up being run super efficiently. There are no negative externalities, that's why Central Asia under the soviets was so pristine and unpoluted.

Not to mention how well run recently liberated farms do under community mgmt once the evil (well trained in agriculture with skin in the game but inherently evil) landowners are chased out or strung up. so much better. and never, I repeat never, has transfering property rights to the people lead to the starvation of millions.