Re:Hawaiians call Mark Zuckerberg 'the face of neocolonialis...
by RUG3Y on Tuesday January 24, 2017 @04:01PM
(#13475402)
Maybe if someone always pops up to correct your vision of democracy, you're not communicating very well.
[dead]
Re:Hawaiians call Mark Zuckerberg 'the face of neocolonialis...
by sctb on Tuesday January 24, 2017 @06:41PM
(#13476908)
Please no personal attacks like this on Hacker News.
Re:Hawaiians call Mark Zuckerberg 'the face of neocolonialis...
by madgar on Tuesday January 24, 2017 @04:57PM
(#13476007)
Your first comment in this thread - in which you mention representatives in passing - suggests that you assume all "democracy" to come in the form of democratic republics. This might be true in a discussion of practical implementations of a scalable democratic governing system.
The thread you responded to, however, was about a theoretical directly democratic system of managing land use rights, without any grounding in a realized system with elements of republicanism. The disconnect between the discussion at hand and the assumptions you brought to it (IMHO) caused the confusion between yourself and Arizhel.
A more constructive comment from yourself might have instead politely pointed out that the scenario I described is a classic "tyranny of the majority" issue, a well understood failure mode of direct democracy that is indeed typically resolved practically through the features of republicanism you listed.
Read this: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Democratic_republic
Line 1: "A democratic republic is both a republic and a democracy."
Furthermore, not all republics are democratic. North Korea and China are both republics, as is Iran. I already mentioned China in my previous post. Do you really think North Korea protects anyone's inalienable rights? Or Iran?