Unfortunately, we all know what happens when you put groups of self-interested humans in charge of a society, and I don't think any group of completely altruistic ones is going to take over the world any time soon.
Also, the only successful communist country currently in existence is actually a hardcore capitalist dystopia.
I'm not sure there is any other "common ownership of land" scheme that isn't just communism with window dressing or superintelligent AI thrown in. If there is, please do enlighten me.
In practice it winds up as you describe, with strongmen at the top.
It has always failed scaling it up, but maybe that's just a sign we shouldn't try to scale it up.
Of course, this has implications for large democracies, as well as large communes.
As a familiar example, one could look at state and national parks. A state park is owned by the people and maintained by the government; use by individuals is controlled and negotiated. You want to camp? Great, book a spot. You want to do some logging? Maybe, but you'll need a permit. You want to clear cut and build a strip mall? Nope.
Your example of an exclusive vacation home doesn't fit well with that approach in that you're not part of the Hawaiian community. You want to control the land even when you're not there, which is ownership.
Giving up ownership for vacation property would be something more like Die Naturfreunde. My understanding is that they maintain a set of communally owned and operated guest houses around the world. There's one just north of San Francisco, a lovely hostel and beer garden in Muir Woods. If you want to be a member there, you have to consistently contribute labor to maintaining it.
Look at housing societies in India; they enforce rules like no single women or no Muslims.
It's convenient when you're in the majority but inconvenient when you're in the minority.
How would you decide between so many different wants? I can not decide between say whether this land should be used for a mall or a factory.
In fact, in the real world if I knew, I could earn good money by building whichever is better. Information is money.
This system is also poor as people who value land less end up with excess land and people who do value land more end up with a lack of land. How do you measure this "value"? Money.
> There's one just north of San Francisco, a lovely hostel and beer garden in Muir Woods. If you want to be a member there, you have to consistently contribute labor to maintaining it.
This ignores specialization, i.e. I could be doing something that I'm good at (like programming) and the labor can be done by someone else (who doesn't have any better option) with the money I earn.
EDIT: replaced LTV criticism with specialization argument
Personally, I'm a practicing capitalist, and somebody who approves of using market mechanisms for a wide variety of things. But nothing is perfect, and people legitimately have different values. So I think it's worth understanding those other approaches. I have no idea why people find that so threatening.
Who?
> Who can't even quietly consider other approaches that might work just fine in particular circumstances.
I explained how it might not work.
You are attacking me but not my reasoning.
I am just criticizing communal ownership since it does not work.
> I have no idea why people find that so threatening.
Who?
You haven't gotten to reasoning yet. I critiqued your style of argument: the outraged hot take, the instant defense of something that wasn't even attacked. It was a spew of semi-random points, not a coherent argument.
There's no point in discussing the details with you, because you aren't interested in learning anything. When called on your drama, you pretend to be purely rational. If you can't even admit your reaction or look at your own post honestly, why would I ever engage with the details of what you claim your point to be?
I just said how collective ownership fails and how capitalism is a better solution. Is there something I said that I shouldn't have?
> There's no point in discussing the details with you, because you aren't interested in learning anything.
I am. Go critique my points. Maybe show me some empirical examples to rebuke me. Send me research articles. Or write your own explanation of how collective ownership would be managed.
> When called on your drama, you pretend to be purely rational.
What drama? I was just a little bored and decided to poke a low hanging fruit (collective ownership).
> If you can't even admit your reaction or look at your own post honestly, why would I ever engage with the details of what you claim your point to be?
I'm pretty sure I wasn't angry or anything. Uncharitably, I was thinking "haha, commies are stupid", but I don't think I let that affect my comment.
To me, it seems like you're the more angry one. Perhaps it is just an effect of you being text on a screen as opposed to a person I can see and talk to.
Like the three historical examples you ignored in the post you responded to? C'mon. Why would I waste more time?
> haha, commies are stupid
Yes, this is how you got to the "not even wrong" level of discourse and somehow thought it constituted reasoning. A random salting of pure-theory, Econ-101 points is the sort of lazy, free-market fundamentalism that I have no time for.
Communists weren't stupid. Communism didn't work, but people trying it had a reasonable intuition that it would work because they had a lot of experience with communal approaches working pretty well for them at smaller scales. And, just as important, working in ways and yielding outcomes that matched their values. Because they also had a lot of experience with unregulated capitalism fucking them over.
Laughing alternatives off like this is just a knee-jerk defense of the status quo. People here get endlessly mad when it happens to handwave away startups or new tech. But it's somehow common and acceptable whenever economics comes up.
> Or write your own explanation of how collective ownership would be managed.
It is not my job to force-feed you an education just because you saw fit to make a poorly considered reply to something I wrote. If you want to be taken seriously, it is your job to go get one. This is an entire field of literature.
"Ejidatarios do not actually own the land, but are allowed to use their allotted parcels indefinitely as long as they do not fail to use the land for more than two years. They can pass their rights on to their children."
Taking land from landlords doesn't work because then no one will buy land in the future out of that risk, unless it is very clearly done as a one-time thing. See: one-time tax.
I'm not saying collective ownership does not exist but you haven't shown it works empirically or theoretically.
> A random salting of pure-theory, Econ-101 points is the sort of lazy, free-market fundamentalism that I have no time for.
What is wrong with pure-theory and Econ-101 points?
Mainstream economic theory is a refinement of Econ-101 with more complex modelling (imperfect competition, sticky wages).
Econ-101 can be used to rebuke many bad economic policies like what Venezuela is doing (capital control, etc).
> And, just as important, working in ways and yielding outcomes that matched their values.
Do famines and poverty reflect their values? Does food rationing reflect their values?
Does only the Politburo having access to the ZIL-111 reflect egalitarianism (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ZIL-111)? Does Chaikas only being available for purchase by the Soviet government reflect egalitarianism?
> Communists weren't stupid.
Most communism (such as LTV) is bad economics (that's why the Marxist school of economics is very much outside the mainstream). Communism forgets the Laffer curve at 100%. Complete equality does not work.
> communal approaches working pretty well for them at smaller scales
It works at smaller scales of family, neighbors, etc because then the people are roughly homogeneous. Even then it is not optimal. Have you heard of horrible stories involving housing societies?
> Laughing alternatives off like this is just a knee-jerk defense of the status quo.
It's not a knee-jerk defense because I gave some thinking.
> But it's somehow common and acceptable whenever economics comes up.
I have been downvoted at times for my "fundamentalist capitalist" views. The earliest post in this thread that I wrote is at 0 points (maybe you downvoted it).
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Freedom_to_roam
In addition, I think, even in the US system as it exists currently, property ownership rights are not 100% absolute. I mean, even Zuckerberg couldn't declare his new 700 acre holding to be, say, a toxic waste dump, or a launch pad for outer space rockets. He'd need a whole lot of government approvals to use the land in those ways, and he most likely would never get the approvals.
Land rights and usages are not absolute, even for the title bearer.
As things come up people would just revote. Since no one owns the land there wouldn't be any conflict of interest. You may point out that those who originally voted may be conflicted, but I disagree: any proposition that would benefit the majority would clearly win. Any proposition that doesn't would necessarily be struck down.
This kind of system has its own problems, though. Long term sustainability is one, requisites for voting is another. But these problems I think are separate.
This is not a theoretical exercise. This happens everyday in America in co-op boards, HOAs, etc and it doesn't require anybody saying out loud why an individual is being rejected. The current US president got caught doing this in the 1960s. If you want to redesign land use rights wholesale I would hope you wouldn't make this kind of discrimination more common... maybe that's just me.
Well, yes. That's how democracy works: there's a vote and the majority wins. Are you opposed to democracy?
Yeah, it sucks if you're a minority, but what can you do? This is a fundamental flaw in democracy. We attempt to mitigate it by having constitutions and laws and representatives who are voted on in multi-year cycles, which in engineering terms has the effect of creating a long feedback loop so that the populace's short term emotions don't create too much instability and chaos, but it only works to a point.
The alternative is a non-democratic system like what they do in China. And they don't seem to be too keen on protecting the rights of minorities either.
Read this: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Democratic_republic
Line 1: "A democratic republic is both a republic and a democracy."
Furthermore, not all republics are democratic. North Korea and China are both republics, as is Iran. I already mentioned China in my previous post. Do you really think North Korea protects anyone's inalienable rights? Or Iran?
The thread you responded to, however, was about a theoretical directly democratic system of managing land use rights, without any grounding in a realized system with elements of republicanism. The disconnect between the discussion at hand and the assumptions you brought to it (IMHO) caused the confusion between yourself and Arizhel.
A more constructive comment from yourself might have instead politely pointed out that the scenario I described is a classic "tyranny of the majority" issue, a well understood failure mode of direct democracy that is indeed typically resolved practically through the features of republicanism you listed.
Of course within a few generations of inheritances and sales that equitable distribution of land will no longer look like that at all.
The land is still held by individuals, but they pay a use fee based upon the market value of the unimproved land. It's compatible with markets, capitalism, and in fact economists call it the most efficient tax possible.
It's also very environmentally friendly, insofar as it encourages efficient use of land, which would spur more infill instead of pushing the margin of land lower and lower, encouraging sprawl.
Why don't we use this tax, then? Mostly because it creates losers in the form of landowners, who tend to be extremely powerful, politically.
"This arouses furious opposition from landowners, in most countries a potent lobby, see it as highly unfair. They have got used to enjoying their rents and object to their sudden socialisation."[1]
If there's an upside, it's that it's been shown to be one of the only effective methods in implementing modern urban design and finance in a sustainable fashion. Just today, London expressed interest in seeing how LVT could remedy its housing crisis.[2]
[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Land_value_tax
[1] http://www.economist.com/blogs/freeexchange/2015/04/land-val...
[2] https://www.london.gov.uk/press-releases/assembly/mayor-posi...
How would this work? Honest question.
I agree that the concept of land ownership is a little weird - it's one of the most limited, exclusive resources we have.
Hypothetically, I would love to be able to use this land that Z is "buying" under the current land ownership paradigm. But that free use, to me, would look like pouring a concrete foundation and building a structure with a bunk room, kitchen, bathroom, common area, with storage for a Hobie Cat, some surfboards, and SCUBA gear, and a patio overlooking the ocean. I'd want the rest of the land to be nicely forested. I would come out for a week every couple months. Would I have freedom to do this in a non-land-ownership system? What would prevent others from building in front of me, or using my structure when I wanted to be there?